Shabbat-B'shabbato – Parshat Korach No 1579: 3 Tammuz 5775 (20 June 2015)
Shabbat-B'Shabbato – Parshat Korach No 1579: 3 Tammuz 5775 (20 June 2015) AS SHABBAT APPROACHES Is it Good to Have a King or Not? - by Rabbi Oury Cherki, Machon Meir, Rabbi of Beit Yehuda Congregation, Jerusalem In the Haftorah for this week, Shmuel tries to strengthen the status of the King. "And Shmuel said to the people, Let us go to Gilgal, where we will renew the kingdom." [Shmuel I 11:14]. It seems that Shmuel has resigned himself to accept the will of the nation to appoint a king as their head, in spite of his objections when the people first turned to him (ibid, 8:6). It is therefore surprising to see that Shmuel still rebukes the people at this point, even at an event where he seems to support Shaul and gives him the title, "anointed by G-d" [12:3]. The rebuke, which is accompanied by a sign of thunder and rain in the season of the harvest, leads the people to cry out, "we have added on to our sins, by asking for a king for ourselves" [12:19]. Evidently Shmuel's intention is to create the proper awareness with respect to the government institutions. Anybody who prays for the appearance of the Kingdom of G-d has doubts about any other government authority. The Rebbe of Satmar, Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum, expressed this doubt very well when he said that to establish any government, even a religious one, before the coming of the Mashiach, would be a revolt against the Kingdom of Heaven. While it is true that his words are not halachically valid with respect to the government of the State of Israel for the simple reason that we were commanded in the Torah to establish this government (see Ramban, commenting on the Sefer Hamitzvot, positive mitzva 4), such that in this case it is a mitzva and not a sin, there is a grain of truth in his approach – we must make sure that the government will not block the way to the Kingdom of Heaven but rather that it will be a reflection of this kingdom.
[Show full text]