Legal Remedies for the Resource Curse

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Legal Remedies for the Resource Curse Legal Remedies for the Resource Curse A Digest of Experience in Using Law to Combat Natural Resource Corruption Legal Remedies for the Resource Curse A Digest of Experience in Using Law to Combat Natural Resource Corruption Open Society Justice Initiative OPEN SOCIETY INSTITUTE NEW YORK Copyright © 2005 by the Open Society Institute. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means without the prior permission of the publisher. ISBN: 1 891385 46 1 Published by Open Society Institute 400 West 59th Street New York, NY 10019 USA www.soros.org For more information contact: Open Society Justice Initiative 400 West 59th Street New York, NY 10019 USA www.justiceinitiative.org Cover designed by Jeanne Criscola/Criscola Design Text layout and printing by Createch Ltd. Cover photo by Associated Press, AP Contents Preface 5 Acknowledgments 7 I. Introduction 9 The Problem: “Spoliation” 9 The International Law Framework 12 Legal Remedies in “Home” Countries 14 Legal Remedies in “Host” Countries 17 II. Criminal Sanctions 19 A. Antibribery Laws in Home Countries 20 The United States 20 Other OECD Countries 22 Legal Strategies to Combat Bribery and Related Crimes 24 B. Antibribery Laws in Host Countries 28 C. Anti–Money Laundering Laws in Home Countries 30 Legal Strategies to Combat Money Laundering in Home Countries 34 D. Anti–Money Laundering Laws in Host Countries 37 E. Stolen Asset Recovery 38 Legal Strategies for the Recovery of Stolen Assets 39 1 III. Civil Causes of Action 41 Civil Actions in Home Countries 41 The U.S. Alien Tort Claims Act 41 Other Common Law Foreign Direct Liability 42 Unfair Business Practices in the State of California 43 Civil RICO Actions 43 The Council of Europe Civil Law Convention on Corruption 44 Secondary Civil Liability: Shareholder Actions 45 Civil Actions in Host Countries 46 The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights 48 Legal Strategies for Civil Causes of Action in Host Countries 49 IV. Access to Information and Transparency Mechanisms 51 Access to Information 51 Transparency Mechanisms 53 V. Conclusion 57 Notes 61 2 LEGAL REMEDIES FOR THE RESOURCE CURSE Case Studies Case Study 1: Oil, Bribery, and Money Laundering in Equatorial Guinea 11 Case Study 2: Elf Aquitaine and the Nigeria Construction Consortium Bribery Investigations 23 Case Study 3: Civil Party Initiation of Criminal Proceedings in France on Behalf of Cameroonians 26 Case Study 4: The Lesotho Highlands Water Project Prosecutions 29 Case Study 5: Riggs Bank and Money Laundering Controls 33 Case Study 6: Riggs Bank and Pinochet—Privately Initiated Action Against Money Laundering 35 Case Study 7: Equatorial Guinea: Bank Controls in Spain and Luxembourg 36 Case Study 8: Mutual Legal Assistance—Nigeria’s Stolen Assets Recovery 38 Case Study 9: Illegal Shipment of Iron Ore from Liberia 47 LEGAL REMEDIES FOR THE RESOURCE CURSE 3 Preface On February 17, 2005, the Open Society Justice Initiative held a colloquium with legal advo- cates and policy professionals to assess the status of legal remedies to curb large-scale cor- ruption arising from natural resource extraction, primarily in Africa. The meeting followed several months of research, consultation, and interviews, driven by three questions: What is the present state of efforts to pursue legal remedies for corruption arising from the exploitation of natural resources, especially in Africa? Why have there not been more—and more success- ful—efforts to secure legal remedies? Which legal strategies are particularly promising and, generally, what more could be done? The present report is a digest of the February colloquium, together with preceding and subsequent research and interviews with experts. When resource extraction companies can access oil, diamonds, gold, coltan, timber, and other natural resources through private and corrupt contacts with unaccountable government officials, the losers are those located in the very places where the wealth originates. The power of corrupt governments frequently derives from monopoly access to natural wealth and the support of private and governmental industry allies elsewhere in the world. Local populations suffer destruction of their immediate environment and official unaccountability, together with the social and economic devastation that follows: arbitrary eviction and dispossession, unlawful arrest or harassment, and neglect of healthcare, housing, and education. Natural resource corruption is often associated with a lack of transparency in the gen- eration, transfer, and investment of the resulting revenues. Recent efforts, including some sponsored by the Open Society Institute (OSI), have aimed to create preventive transparency 5 mechanisms—both voluntary and mandatory—aimed at corporations, banks, and governments in natural resource-rich countries. Legal remedies are here explored as a possible complement to these initiatives. This report reviews some of the main legal instruments used to date, and others as yet untested. Focusing on resource spoliation in Africa, it provides case studies to demonstrate what has and has not worked. The report treats the “home countries” of resource extraction companies separately from the “host countries” where they operate.1 It looks at both criminal and civil means of redress. Although the report finds that corruption in transnational resource extraction is gener- ally subject to weak or nonexistent safeguards, there are grounds for action. The international law framework has not yet addressed trans-jurisdictional spoliation in a coherent, enforce- able manner. Regional treaties have provided some basic legal tools to address spoliation, but national incorporation and enforcement are not robust in much of the world. The pursuit of corruption in foreign countries is a low priority for criminal prosecutors. Civil litigation, on the other hand, is obstructed by cross-jurisdictional complexity and extremely high costs. Nevertheless, there have been efforts in a number of countries to hold corrupt compa- nies and governments to account and find redress for spoliation, using the available legal tools. To date these efforts have had mixed results. Freedom of information laws offer another option for litigators in both home and host countries. Intergovernmental groups and others can also promote transparency through imposed or recommended measures on companies and governments alike, demanding that they “publish what they pay.” The present report is intended as a point of departure—it is not a legal treatise or comprehensive statement of available remedies. The focus is not on legal documents and collections of laws, but rather on the experience of legal experts and advocates on the ground. The hope is that this effort will spark further research, dialogue, and action on this important subject. There will likely be many postpublication developments in the cases discussed here. Nevertheless, by framing and assessing the critical—often seemingly intractable—problems in securing legal remedies, and by cataloging tentative strategies to address them, the report aims at helping law professionals and nongovernmental organizations combating natural resource corruption. 6 PREFACE Acknowledgments This report was co-authored by Ingrid Tamm, Christian Lucky, and Stephen Humphreys. It was edited by Stephen Humphreys with the assistance of James A. Goldston. The present report would not have been possible without the patience, generosity, and insight of a great number of individuals, in the form of interviews given, experience shared, and reviews and comments rendered on draft passages. For a variety of reasons, not everyone whose work and experience is reflected in the present pages can be cited by name. The authors and the Justice Initiative nevertheless wish to acknowledge the following: Kelly Askin, Nina Bang-Jensen, Károly Bard, Rachel Barnes, Joseph Bell, Jack Blum, William Bourdon, Bruce Broomhall, Judith Brown Chomsky, Andrew Clapham, Sandra Coliver, Carlos Cordero, Juanjo Cordero (and all at Sustentia), Andreea Craciun, Helen Darbishire, John Fawcett, J. ‘Kayode Fayemi, Patricia Feeney, Arvind Ganesan, Ian Gary, Jennifer Gleason, Tracey Gurd, Paul Hoff- mann, Bern Johnson, Anna Kirk, Ndiva Kofele-Kale, Ari Korpivaara, François Larocque, Kate Lauer, Susan Marks, Julie McCarthy, Purificación Montaña, Chidi Anselm Odinkalu, Kola- wole Olaniyan, Henry Parham, Jeremy Pope, Anita Ramasastry, Jose Luis Diez Ripolles, Peter Rosenblum, Nicholas Shaxson, Dinah Shelton, Sonja Starr, Simon Taylor, Robert C. Thomp- son, Svetlana Tsalik, Hennie van Vuuren, Robert Yarbrough, Alex Yearsley, and Kofi Woods. The Justice Initiative bears sole responsibility for any errors or misrepresentations. 7 I. Introduction The Problem: “Spoliation” Over the past decade, development economists have remarked that, in many cases, the richer a country is in natural resources, the slower its economic growth. This problem has been described as the “resource curse.”1 Africa presents a special challenge because exports from resource-rich African countries tend to be dominated by primary commodities, in contrast to those in Latin America and Southeast Asia, which have often succeeded in diversify- ing their export bases.2 Studies have linked primary commodity–dependent economies to higher rates of corruption.3 “Corruption” is a notoriously broad term with multiple meanings. The newly adopted United Nations Convention against Corruption, for example, avoids
Recommended publications
  • The Price Riggs Paid
    REPUTATION DAMAGE: The Price Riggs Paid A Case Study prepared by World-Check, the market pioneer and industry standard for PEP screening and customer due diligence — serving over 1,600 financial institutions and government agencies in more than 120 countries, including 45 of the world’s 50 largest financial institutions. © 2006 World-Check (Global Objectives Ltd) All Rights Reserved. For permission to re-publish in whole or part please email [email protected] World-Check is a registered trademark. Reputation Damage: ‘ The Price Riggs Paid’ CONTENT: Section Page FOREWORD: By David B. Caruso Former Executive Vice President of Compliance & Security at Riggs Bank INTRODUCTION: RIGGS: ‘Things fall apart’ 1 UNDERSTANDING THE ISSUES AT RIGGS: 2 TWO LEADERS, TOO MANY? 2 • RIGGS & PINOCHET 2 • RIGGS & OBIANG 3 PRIOR TO ITS ‘PRESIDENTIAL PROBLEMS’ 4 THE SAUDI ARABIAN DIPLOMATIC ACCOUNTS 4 THE RESULTS: 5 SHAREHOLDER SUITS AND FINES. 5 RENEGOTIATING THE MERGER. 8 UNDERSTANDING THE EFFECTS: 8 REPUTATION FALLOUT 8 TIMELINE 10 LESSONS TO BE LEARNT 11 WORLD-CHECK: AN OVERVIEW FOREWORD by David B. Caruso Former Executive Vice President of Compliance & Security at Riggs Bank Riggs is a story about the price paid when an Anti-Money Laundering ("AML") compliance program lacks proper oversight by management and the board of directors. As you will read in this paper the outcome of such failure in the case of Riggs was rather dramatic and as in any good drama there were lots of twists and turns in the various plots and sub-plots. Who could have imagined that one, relatively small bank in Washington DC, could have participated in the questionable financial activities of two of the more notorious dictators of the last quarter century? One of the many thing my staff and I learned over the two years we were at Riggs busy trying to build a compliance program and ultimately uncovering almost all of the facts you'll read about in this paper, is how harmless most poor business decisions seem at the time they are made.
    [Show full text]
  • the Territorial Jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court Certain Contested Issues
    The Territorial Jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court: Certain Contested Issues Vagias, M. Citation Vagias, M. (2011, May 25). The Territorial Jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court: Certain Contested Issues. Bynkers Hoek Publishing. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/17669 Version: Not Applicable (or Unknown) Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral License: thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden Downloaded from: https://hdl.handle.net/1887/17669 Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable). Michail Vagias / THE TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION OF THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT CERTAIN CONTESTED ISSUES Ph. D. Thesis THE TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION OF THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT CERTAIN CONTESTED ISSUES PROEFSCHRIFT ter verkrijging van de graad van Doctor aan de Universiteit Leiden, op gezag van Rector Magnificus prof. mr. P.F. van der Heijden, volgens besluit van het College voor Promoties te verdedigen op woensdag 25 mei 2011 klokke 16.15 uur door Michail Vagias geboren te Thessaloniki, Greece in 1980 Promotiecommissie: Promotor: prof. dr. C.J.R. Dugard Co-Promotor: dr. L.J. van den Herik Overige leden: prof. dr. L. Zegveld prof. dr. C. Stahn prof. dr. E. van Sliedregt (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) dr. C.M.J. Ryngaert (K. U. Leuven, Belgium en Universiteit Utrecht) Design cover: © Studio Meike Ziegler, Amsterdam This Ph.D. Thesis was financed by the State Scholarship Foundation of the Hellenic Republic (Greece) (Scholarship Program for International Law Studies Abroad, 2007-2010) Acknowledgments During the five years of this thesis (2005-2010), the Center of International and European Economic Law in Thessaloniki, the Peace Palace Library (especially Niels van Tol), the New Business School, Amsterdam, The Hague University of Applied Sciences and the Bynkershoek Institut, The Hague helped each in its own way in its production.
    [Show full text]
  • Vol. II: Anns. 1-29
    Note: This translation has been prepared by the Registry for internal purposes and has no official character 14579 Corr. INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE CASE CONCERNING IMMUNITIES AND CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS (EQUATORIAL GUINEA v. FRANCE) MEMORIAL OF THE REPUBLIC OF EQUATORIAL GUINEA VOLUME II (Annexes 1-29) 3 January 2017 [Translation by the Registry] LIST OF ANNEXES Annex Page 1. Basic Law of Equatorial Guinea (new text of the Constitution of Equatorial 1 Guinea, officially promulgated on 16 February 2012, with the texts of the Constitutional Reform approved by referendum on 13 November 2011) 2. Regulation No. 01/03-CEMAC-UMAC of the Central African Economic and 43 Monetary Community 3. Decree No. 64/2012, 21 May 2012 44 4. Decrees Nos. 67/2012, 66/2012, 65/2012 and 63/2012, 21 May 2012 46 5. Institutional Declaration by the President of the Republic of Equatorial Guinea, 47 21 October 2015 6. Presidential Decree No. 55/2016, 21 June 2016 49 7. Paris Tribunal de grande instance, Order for partial dismissal and partial 51 referral of proceedings to the Tribunal correctionnel, 5 September 2016 (regularized by order of 2 December 2016) 8. Paris Tribunal de grande instance, Public Prosecutor’s Office, Application for 88 characterization, 4 July 2011 9. Report of the Public Prosecutor of the Republic of Equatorial Guinea, 91 22 November 2010 10. Summons to attend a first appearance, 22 May 2012 93 11. French Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Note Verbale No. 2777/PRO/PID, 96 20 June 2012 12. Letter from the investigating judges to the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 98 25 June 2012 13.
    [Show full text]
  • 2015 Activity Report
    ACTIVITY REPORT 2015 Protecting and defending the victims of economic crime 1 CONTENTS History p3 Editorial p4 VISION & MISSION p5 Mission p5 Program p5 Means of action p6 The team p7 GLOBALIZATION AND HUMAN RIGHTS p10 CHANGING THE RULES Liability of parent companies towards their subsidiaries and subcontractors / Access to p12 justice for victims Transparency through reporting p18 The exemplarity of the state in its international obligations and investments p19 REFLECTION: Legal studies and research p21 FIGHTING IMPUNITY: judicial and extrajudicial actions Modern slavery p22 Death of workers, collapse of textile factories at Rana Plaza p24 Child labor, misleading advertising and the exploitation of children p26 Fueling conflict with blood timber p28 Denial of justice p30 Land seizure, environmental damage and the local impact on health p32 ILLICIT FINANCIAL FLOWS p34 CHANGING THE RULES Fighting illicit financial flows in the natural resources sector p36 Changing practices in matters of economic and financial crime p38 The recovery and restitution of assets to victim populations p41 FIGHTING IMPUNITY: judicial actions Corruption of foreign public officials p42 Misappropriation of public funds, corruption and money laundering p44 COMMUNICATION p46 FUNDING p50 PARTNERS p51 2 HISTORY herpa was founded in 2001 by William Bourdon, lawyer at the Paris Bar and President Sof the association. Long committed to human rights and the fight against corruption, William Bourdon was notably the advisor to Franco-Chilean families in the lawsuit filed against General Augusto Pinochet in October 1998, and also to the civil parties in the proceedings introduced in France against war criminals. He was committed to the International Federation for Human Rights for 15 years, serving as Secretary General for part of that time.
    [Show full text]
  • Chad: the Victims of Hissène Habré Still Awaiting Justice
    Human Rights Watch July 2005 Vol. 17, No. 10(A) Chad: The Victims of Hissène Habré Still Awaiting Justice Summary......................................................................................................................................... 1 Principal Recommendations to the Chadian Government..................................................... 2 Historical Background.................................................................................................................. 3 The War against Libya and Internal Conflicts in Chad....................................................... 3 The Regime of Hissène Habré................................................................................................ 4 The Documentation and Security Directorate (DDS) ........................................................ 5 The Crimes of Hissène Habré’s Regime ............................................................................... 8 The Fall of Hissène Habré and the Truth Commission’s Report ................................... 14 The Chadian Association of Victims of Political Repression and Crime....................... 16 Victim Rehabilitation.............................................................................................................. 17 The Prosecution of Hissène Habré...................................................................................... 18 The Victims of Hissène Habré Still Awaiting Justice in Chad .............................................22 Hissène Habré’s Accomplices Still in Positions
    [Show full text]
  • WRITTEN STATEMENT of RIGGS BANK N.A. to the PERMANENT SUBCOMMITTEE on INVESTIGATIONS of the COMMITTEE on GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS Of
    WRITTEN STATEMENT OF RIGGS BANK N.A. to the PERMANENT SUBCOMMITTEE ON INVESTIGATIONS of the COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS of the UNITED STATES SENATE July 15, 2004 I. Introduction. Riggs Bank has been privileged to serve the banking needs of our nation’s capital for nearly two centuries. During that time, Riggs has served such historical figures as President Abraham Lincoln and American Red Cross founder Clara Barton. Riggs also has assisted in some important historical transactions, such as supplying the gold for the purchase of the State of Alaska. Today, Riggs is the oldest independent bank headquartered in Washington, D.C., serving the District and the surrounding metropolitan area with more than 45 branch locations. Without a doubt, this past year has been among the most challenging in the Bank’s long and storied history. We will address today some of those challenges and how the Bank is moving to address them, and will address questions raised in the letter from Chairman Coleman and Senator Levin. Looking back, it is clear that Riggs did not accomplish all that it needed to. Specifically, with respect to the improvements that were outlined by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (“OCC”) in its examinations, Riggs deeply regrets that it did not more swiftly and more thoroughly complete the work necessary to meet fully the expectations of its regulators. For this, the Bank accepts full responsibility. Looking forward, Riggs is acting forcefully to comply with all federal rules and regulations and is cooperating as fully as possible with all appropriate agencies and congressional committees looking into these matters.
    [Show full text]
  • Pinochet US Bank Accounts Under Scrutiny LADB Staff
    University of New Mexico UNM Digital Repository NotiSur Latin America Digital Beat (LADB) 7-23-2004 Pinochet US Bank Accounts Under Scrutiny LADB Staff Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalrepository.unm.edu/notisur Recommended Citation LADB Staff. "Pinochet US Bank Accounts Under Scrutiny." (2004). https://digitalrepository.unm.edu/notisur/13279 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Latin America Digital Beat (LADB) at UNM Digital Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in NotiSur by an authorized administrator of UNM Digital Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. LADB Article Id: 52339 ISSN: 1089-1560 Pinochet US Bank Accounts Under Scrutiny by LADB Staff Category/Department: Chile Published: 2004-07-23 Money laundering and involvement in Operation Condor came up as potential points of prosecution against former Chilean dictator Gen. Augusto Pinochet (1973-1990) this month, as a scandal involving US-based Riggs Bank unfolded. Chilean President Ricardo Lagos received assurances from US President George W. Bush that there would be "a full investigation" of how the ex-dictator hid millions with the bank's help. The 88-year-old Pinochet has faced renewed legal fights since a Chilean appeals court stripped him of his immunity in May of this year (see NotiSur, 2004-06-18), though his defenders argue that his advanced age makes him unfit to stand trial. Riggs Banks accused of helping launder A US Senate committee report said the Washington-based Riggs Bank helped Pinochet hide his assets over an eight-year period, even after he was arrested in London in 1998 and a court froze his assets (see NotiSur, 1998-10-23).
    [Show full text]
  • The Washington Post Company 2003Annual Report
    The Washington Post Company 2003 Annual Report Contents Financial Highlights 01 To Our Shareholders 02 Corporate Directory 16 Form 10-K FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS (in thousands, except per share amounts) 2003 2002 % Change Operating revenue $ 2,838,911 $ 2,584,203 + 10% Income from operations $ 363,820 $ 377,590 – 4% Net income Before cumulative effect of change in accounting principle in 2002 $ 241,088 $ 216,368 + 11% After cumulative effect of change in accounting principle in 2002 $ 241,088 $ 204,268 + 18% Diluted earnings per common share Before cumulative effect of change in accounting principle in 2002 $ 25.12 $ 22.61 + 11% After cumulative effect of change in accounting principle in 2002 $ 25.12 $ 21.34 + 18% Dividends per common share $ 5.80 $ 5.60 + 4% Common shareholders’ equity per share $ 217.46 $ 193.18 + 13% Diluted average number of common shares outstanding 9,555 9,523 – Operating Revenue Income from Operations Net Income ($ in millions) ($ in millions) ($ in millions) 03 2,839 03 364 03 241 02 2,584 02 378 02 204 01 2,411 01 220 01 230 00 2,410 00 340 00 136 99 2,212 99 388 99 226 Diluted Earnings Return on Average Common per Common Share Shareholders’ Equity ($) 03 25.12 03 12.3% 02 21.34 02 11.5% 01 24.06 01 14.4% 00 14.32 00 9.5% 99 22.30 99 15.2% 01 The Washington Post Company The undramatic financial results of 2003—earnings per share a bit higher than last year’s—mask a year in which some important things happened at The Washington Post Company.
    [Show full text]
  • In the Matter of Riggs Bank, NA
    UNITED STATES OF AMERICA DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY FINANCIAL CRIMES ENFORCEMENT NETWORK IN THE MATTER OF No. 2004-01 RIGGS BANK, N.A. ASSESSMENT OF CIVIL MONEY PENALTY I. INTRODUCTION The Secretary of the United States Department of the Treasury has delegated to the Director of the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (“FinCEN”) the authority to determine whether a financial institution has violated the Bank Secrecy Act, 31 USC §§5311 et seq. and 31 CFR Part 103 thereunder (“BSA”), and what, if any, sanction is appropriate. In order to resolve this matter, and only for that purpose, Riggs Bank N.A. (“Riggs”) has entered into a CONSENT TO THE ASSESSMENT OF CIVIL MONEY PENALTY (“CONSENT”) dated May 13, 2004, without admitting or denying FinCEN’s determinations described in Sections III and IV below, except as to jurisdiction in Section II below, which is admitted. The CONSENT is incorporated into this ASSESSMENT OF CIVIL MONEY PENALTY (“ASSESSMENT”) by this reference. II. JURISDICTION Riggs is the principal subsidiary of Riggs National Corporation, a publicly traded bank holding company based in Washington, D.C. As of December 31, 2003, Riggs had assets of approximately $6 billion, deposits of $4.29 billion, and stockholders’ equity of $427.2 million. Riggs is a “financial institution” and a “bank” within the meaning of 31 USC §5312(a)(2) and 31 CFR §103.11. The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (the “OCC”) is Riggs’ primary federal supervisory agency and examines Riggs for BSA compliance. III. FINDINGS A. Summary of Violations FinCEN has determined that Riggs willfully violated the suspicious activity and currency transaction reporting requirements of the BSA and its implementing regulations, and that Riggs has willfully violated the anti-money laundering program (“AML program”) requirement of the BSA and its implementing regulations.
    [Show full text]
  • The Saudi Money Trail Rent Payments for 9-11 Hijackers and Mysterious Checks from a Princess's Account
    MSNBC.com Mobile Advertisement The Saudi Money Trail Rent payments for 9-11 hijackers and mysterious checks from a princess's account. Is there a Saudi tie to terror? Inside the probe the Bush administration doesn't want you to know about Dec. 2 issue — When the two Qaeda operatives arrived at Los Angeles International Airport around New Year's 2000, they were warmly welcomed. Nawaf Alhazmi and Khalid Almihdhar would help hijack American Airlines Flight 77 and crash it into the Pentagon a year and a half later, but that January in Los Angeles, they were just a couple of young Saudi men who barely spoke English and needed a place to stay. AT THE AIRPORT, THEY were swept up by a gregarious fellow Saudi, Omar al-Bayoumi, who had been living in the United States for several years. Al-Bayoumi drove the two men to San Diego, threw a welcoming party and arranged for the visitors to get an apartment next to his. He guaranteed the lease, and plunked down $1,550 in cash to cover the first two months' rent. His hospitality did not end there. Al-Bayoumi also aided Alhazmi and Almihdhar as they opened a bank account, and recruited a friend to help them obtain Social Security cards and call flight schools in Florida to arrange flying lessons, according to law-enforcement officials. Two months before 9-11, al-Bayoumi moved to England; several months later, he disappeared. He is believed to be somewhere in Saudi Arabia. MYSTERY MAN Who is al-Bayoumi? At various times, the affable father of four told people that he was getting his doctorate at San Diego State, though the school has no record he ever attended.
    [Show full text]
  • Undue Diligence: How Banks Do Business with Corrupt Regimes
    UNDUE DILIGENCE How banks do business with corrupt regimes A report by Global Witness, March 2009 CONTENTS Summary 03 1 Introduction: 07 Breaking the links between banks, corruption and poverty 2 Who is your customer? 17 3 Riggs and Equatorial Guinea: 26 Doing business with heads of state (Plus: Where did Equatorial Guinea’s oil money go after the demise of Riggs?) 4 Barclays and Equatorial Guinea: 40 Doing business with the sons of heads of state, Part I (Plus: Who banks for President Bongo of Gabon since Citibank closed its doors to him?) 5 Bank of East Asia and Republic of Congo: 50 Doing business with the sons of heads of state, Part II 6 Citibank, Fortis and Liberia’s logs of war: 68 Doing business with natural resources that are fuelling conflict 7 Deutsche Bank and Turkmenistan: 82 Doing business with a human rights abuser 8 Oil-backed loans to Angola: 90 Doing business with an opaque national oil company 9 The problem with the Financial Action Task Force 105 10 Conclusions and recommendations 112 Glossary 124 SUMMARY Economic crisis: banks have damaged the world’s richest economies, but by facilitating corruption they help perpetuate poverty in the world’s poorest countries. What is the problem? which deny these countries the chance to lift The world has learnt during 2008 and 2009 themselves out of poverty and leave them that failures by banks and the governments dependent on aid. that regulate them have been responsible for pitching the global economy into its This is happening despite a raft of anti-money worst crisis in decades.
    [Show full text]
  • Financial Accountability for Torture and Other Human Rights Abuses
    FINANCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY FOR TORTURE AND OTHER HUMAN RIGHTS ABUSES A Framework for Developing Case Strategies REDRESS is an international human rights organ- isation that represents victims of torture to obtain justice and reparations. We bring legal cases on be- half of individual survivors, and advocate for better laws to provide effective reparations. Our cases re- spond to torture as an individual crime in domestic and international law, as a civil wrong with individual responsibility, and as a human rights violation with state responsibility. REDRESS wishes to acknowledge the valuable input and feedback we received relating to promoting fi- nancial accountability for perpetrators of torture and other serious human rights abuses, including from the participants of the Roundtable convened in De- cember 2019 to consider financial accountability for perpetrators of torture, as well as participants in the side meeting of NGOs to the EU Genocide Network in June 2020. Particular thanks are made to Stuart Alford QC and Alex Cox of Latham Watkins LLP, Nich- olas Bortman and Louisa Barnett of Raedas/Find, and Kelsey Froehlich and Ekaterina Tomashchuk of Mintz Group, for their extensive pro bono support to this programme of work. REDRESS is grateful to the Knowledge Platform for Security & Rule of Law for their financial support for this project. Design by Marc Rechdane. Cover image: Jeroen Oerlemans/PANOS Pictures. Iraqi, Iranian and American currency depicting Sadd- am Hussein being changed on a street stall in Iraq. First published July 2020, updated March 2021. © REDRESS and Knowledge Platform for Security & Rule of Law. CONTENTS I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 5 II.
    [Show full text]