Vale of Glamorgan Council Buildings at Risk Survey 2011
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Vale of Glamorgan Council Buildings at Risk Survey 2011 2006 – 2011 Change Analysis Sample Comparison Analysis - Summary 1 Sample Definitions Survey Status/Cycle Community Grade Use Group Detailed Use Cond Occ Own Risk Score/Assessment CEF Score Range S 1 2006 Full Survey * * * * * * * * - * 0 to 100 S 2 CURRENT * * * * * * * * - * 0 to 100 Average Scores Risk Assessment - Broad Average Scores No. in Sample % in Sample Difference S1 to S2 Condition Occupancy Risk Cat CEF S1 S2 S1 S2 No. % Sample 1 (S1) 3.305 2.789 4.914 83.292 At Risk 78 71 10.67 9.62 -7 -1.05 Sample 2 (S2) 3.348 2.817 4.978 84.719 Vulnerable 134 117 18.33 15.85 -17 -2.48 Difference S1 to S2 0.043 0.027 0.065 1.426 Not at Risk 519 550 71.00 74.53 31 3.53 % Difference S1 to S2 1.31 0.976 1.31 1.712 General Assessment The average condition of buildings in SAMPLE 2 is BETTER than that of buildings in SAMPLE 1 The average occupancy level of SAMPLE 2 is HIGHER than that of buildings in SAMPLE 1 The average risk score of buildings in SAMPLE 2 is HIGHER (less risk) than that of buildings in SAMPLE 1 The average CEF score of buildings in SAMPLE 2 is HIGHER than that of buildings in SAMPLE 1 CEF Assessment (Broad Defect Type Grouping) CEF Assessment (Rate of Change Grouping) % in Sample Difference S1 to S2 % in Sample Difference S1 to S2 S1 S2 % S1 S2 % No significant work required 38.44 41.06 2.62 No significant decay 38.44 41.06 2.62 Reduced maintenance levels 16.01 15.04 -0.96 Very slow rate of decline 16.01 15.04 -0.96 Maintenance backlog building up 15.18 16.12 0.94 Slow rate of decline 15.18 16.12 0.94 Secondary item maintenance required 12.18 12.74 0.56 Little or no decline 12.18 12.74 0.56 Major repairs required to many items 4.38 3.66 -0.72 Short term action required 9.58 6.78 -2.80 Serious lack of maintenance 3.83 2.71 -1.12 Rapid decline likely 3.15 2.85 -0.30 Ongoing decline 3.56 2.03 -1.52 Medium term action required 2.74 2.71 -0.03 Very poor condition 1.78 1.63 -0.15 Complete loss possible 1.50 1.76 0.26 Structurally unsound 1.50 1.76 0.26 Rate of decline may increase 1.23 0.95 -0.28 Many items require replacement 1.37 1.22 -0.15 Some critical items require replacement 1.23 0.95 -0.28 Full refurbishment required 0.55 1.08 0.54 Report Prepared 16/03/2011 22:19:22 The Handley Partnership - www.buildingsatrisk.com Sample Comparison Analysis - Summary 2 Sample Definitions Survey Status/Cycle Community Grade Use Group Detailed Use Cond Occ Own Risk Score/Assessment CEF Score Range S 1 2006 Full Survey * * * * * * * * - * 0 to 100 S 2 CURRENT * * * * * * * * - * 0 to 100 Risk Assessment No. in Sample % in Sample Difference S1 to S2 6 1.97 S1 S2 S1 S2 No. % 5 1.55 6 - Not at Risk 254 271 34.75 36.72 17 1.97 -2.48 4 5 - Not at Risk 265 279 36.25 37.80 14 1.55 Risk Score -1.03 3 4 - Vulnerable 134 117 18.33 15.85 -17 -2.48 1 0.12 3 - At Risk 64 57 8.76 7.72 -7 -1.03 1 - At Risk (Extreme 13 14 1.78 1.90 1 0.12 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 % difference S1 to S2 Condition Assessment No. in Sample % in Sample Difference S1 to S2 4 3.23 S1 S2 S1 S2 No. % -2.17 3 4 - Good 327 354 44.73 47.97 27 3.23 -1.05 2 3 - Fair 314 301 42.95 40.79 -13 -2.17 -0.021 Condition Score Condition 2 - Poor 76 69 10.40 9.35 -7 -1.05 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 1 - Very Bad 14 14 1.92 1.90 0 -0.02 % difference S1 to S2 Occupancy Assessment No. in Sample % in Sample Difference S1 to S2 3 2.90 S1 S2 S1 S2 No. % -3.04 2 3 - Fully Occupied 450 469 83.96 86.85 19 2.90 2 - Partly Occupied 59 43 11.01 7.96 -16 -3.04 1 0.15 1 - Vacant 27 28 5.04 5.19 1 0.15 Occupancy Score -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 % difference S1 to S2 Report Prepared 16/03/2011 22:20:07 The Handley Partnership - www.buildingsatrisk.com Sample Comparison Analysis - Summary 3 Sample Definitions Survey Status/Cycle Community Grade Use Group Detailed Use Cond Occ Own Risk Score/Assessment CEF Score Range S 1 2006 Full Survey * * * * * * * * - * 0 to 100 S 2 CURRENT * * * * * * * * - * 0 to 100 CEF Assessment - Detailed % in Sample Difference S1 to S2 S1 S2 % No significant work required at present, regular maintenance will hold condition 38.44 41.06 2.62 In general, no work required to main elements, some repair of secondary items may be needed 12.18 12.74 0.56 Maintenance levels may be slipping, redecoration (if applicable) may be required 8.89 9.35 0.46 Maintenance levels may be slipping, redecoration (if applicable) may be required 7.11 5.69 -1.42 Maintenance backlog beginning to build up, redecoration and minor repairs required 9.58 9.35 -0.23 Maintenance backlog beginning to build up, redecoration and minor repairs required 3.28 4.74 1.46 Maintenance backlog building up, some items may be deteriorating 2.33 2.03 -0.29 Lack of maintenance is allowing defects to build up and become serious - action required soon 2.19 1.63 -0.56 Lack of maintenance is allowing defects to build up and become serious - action required now 1.64 1.08 -0.56 Condition deteriorating, action is now required to multiple defects to halt the decline 1.50 0.81 -0.69 Condition deteriorating, action is now required to a wide range of defects to halt the decline 2.05 1.22 -0.83 Condition gives cause for concern, overall refurbishment is needed 0.55 1.08 0.54 Condition may decline quickly if action is not taken, multiple items need attention 3.28 2.85 -0.44 Condition may decline quickly if action is not taken, many items need attention 1.09 0.81 -0.28 Speed of decay may be increasing, some items will now or soon need replacement 1.23 0.95 -0.28 Widespread replacement of defective items now needed, rapid action is required 1.37 1.22 -0.15 Condition is very poor, main structural elements serviceable but many items need replacing 1.78 1.63 -0.15 Widespread and serious defects, the loss of the building is possible in the short/medium term 1.23 1.36 0.12 Structurally unsound with multiple failures - loss may follow in short term 0.27 0.41 0.13 Report Prepared 16/03/2011 22:20:27 The Handley Partnership - www.buildingsatrisk.com Building Status - Sample 1 - AT RISK Sample 2 - AT RISK Survey Status/Cycle Community Grade Use Group Detailed Use Cond Occ Own Risk Score/Assessment CEF Score Range S 1 2006 Full Survey * * * * * * * * - * 0 to 100 S 2 CURRENT * * * * * * * * - * 0 to 100 CEF Score Use Group Community Rec No Name and Grade S1 S2 Diff S1 S2 Barry 26997 Grotto in Wenvoe Castle Park II 14.802 14.802 0 GARDEN GARDEN Barry 16837 Operator's Cabin to Sliding Bridge II 24.368 24.368 0 OTHER OTHER Barry 13393 CHURCHYARD WALL OF CHURCH OF ST NICHOLAS, ST NICHOLAS' ROAD (W SIDE) II 40.779 30.576 -10.20 BOUNDARY BOUNDARY Barry 15886 FORMER FIRE STATION, COURT ROAD (W SIDE), BARRY II 46.127 41.462 -4.664 OTHER OTHER Dinas Powys 26510 Barn at Biglis Farm II 29.296 29.296 0 AGRICULTURAL AGRICULTURAL Dinas Powys 13624 Remains of Dinas Powis Castle II 17.486 17.486 0 FORTIFICATION FORTIFICATION Ewenny 19456 Barn on Ewenny Down II 24.37 19.279 -5.091 AGRICULTURAL AGRICULTURAL Llan Maes 81300 Cross in Churchyard of Church of St Cattwg II 27.854 22.911 -4.943 MONUMENT MONUMENT Llan Maes 81304 Railed Tomb to Nicholl family to east of Chancel of Church of St Cattwg II 24.504 24.504 0 MONUMENT MONUMENT Llancarfan 13594 RUINS OF LLANTRITHYD PLACE II 17.486 17.486 0 OTHER OTHER Llandow 16462 ST ANNE'S WELL, LLANMIHANGEL II 21.424 21.424 0 WATER BUILDIN WATER BUILDIN Llanfair 16416 FORMER HALL RANGE TO S OF OLD BEAUPRE CASTLE, OLD BEAUPRE II 60.392 62.965 2.5729 OUTBUILDING OUTBUILDING Llanfair 13487 BARN AT FISHWEIR, ST MARY CHURCH II 24.484 24.484 0 OUTBUILDING OUTBUILDING Llanfair 15763 LLANDOUGH CASTLE FLATS, LLANDOUGH II 54.99 42.955 -12.03 DOMESTIC DOMESTIC Llanfair 16417 OLD BEAUPRE BARN, OLD BEAUPRE II 29.564 21.424 -8.140 OTHER OTHER Llangan 81311 Chimney 100m north of Gelliaraul Farmhouse II 38.227 38.227 0 EXTRACTIVE EXTRACTIVE Llangan 81312 Chuchyard Wall of the Church of St Mary II 47.537 47.537 0 BOUNDARY BOUNDARY Llantwit Major 83401 Summerhouse Fort II 21.38 11.904 -9.476 FORTIFICATION FORTIFICATION Llantwit Major 13286 Old Place (or Llantwit Major Castle) II 20.191 16.654 -3.537 OTHER OTHER Llantwit Major 83402 Summerhouse Tower II 29.564 29.564 0 FORTIFICATION FORTIFICATION Page 1 of 3 Building Status - Sample 1 - AT RISK Sample 2 - AT RISK Survey Status/Cycle Community Grade Use Group Detailed Use Cond Occ Own Risk Score/Assessment CEF Score Range S 1 2006 Full Survey * * * * * * * * - * 0 to 100 S 2 CURRENT * * * * * * * * - * 0 to 100 CEF Score Use Group Community Rec No Name and Grade S1 S2 Diff S1 S2 Llantwit Major 13245 Boverton Place including attached bee-boles II* 29.564 27.006 -2.558 OTHER OTHER Llantwit Major 83385 Barn and Stable Range at Great Frampton Farm II 23.949 23.949 0 AGRICULTURAL AGRICULTURAL Llantwit Major 13250 Mid Well at West-End Town II 31.016 31.016 0 WATER BUILDIN WATER BUILDIN Llantwit Major 83404 Wall and Gateway opposite Boverton House II 72.809 72.809 0 BOUNDARY BOUNDARY Llantwit Major 13300 Great Frampton II 16.025 16.025 0 DOMESTIC DOMESTIC Michaelston 19575 Brynwell Farm including attached agricultural buildings II 21.979 20.534 -1.445 DOMESTIC DOMESTIC Penarth 13351 MARINE BUILDINGS,DOCK ROAD II 36.876 35.948 -0.927 OTHER OTHER Penllyn 13139 Penllyn Castle II 38.871 38.214 -0.657 DOMESTIC DOMESTIC Penllyn 13435 Gatepiers, Gates and Boundary Walls at entrance to Penllyn Castle Main Drive II 70.308 37.733 -32.57 BOUNDARY BOUNDARY Rhoose 83144 Aberthaw Lime and Cement Works II 29.678 29.678 0 OTHER OTHER Rhoose 83153 Fonmon Well II 38.251 38.251 0 WATER BUILDIN WATER BUILDIN Rhoose 83152 East Kilns at Aberthaw Lime and Cement Works II 21.424 21.424 0 OTHER