8 City Worked: Occupation Colonial Stefan Biellins Callonsssalbany Social Project New York State Muse

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

8 City Worked: Occupation Colonial Stefan Biellins Callonsssalbany Social Project New York State Muse 8 City Worked: Occupation Colonial Stefan Biellins callonsssAlbany Social Project New York State Muse his essay addressesthe theme of how a city worked. mary, the Colonial Albany Project seeks to illuminate In this case, appreciating the play on words in the title and focus the life story of early Albany through the prism holds an important key toward understanding the of the lives of each early Albany person. developmentof an urban characterand urban identity for the city of Albany, New York during its colonial period No aspect of the lives of these people is more from 1686 to 1776. significant than their contributions to the pre-industrial community’s economy. That is, how they supported To date,most studiesof colonial cities and particularly themselves and their dependants-how they worked. the scholarship focused on early Albany either have This essaywill focus on the working people of colonial described community events, traced the evolution of Albany and will draw on the work profile data collected local institutions, or have offered the careersof the most so far by the Colonial Albany Social History Project to outstanding personages as the best ways of under- suggestan outline occupational framework for pre-urban standing the founding, growth, and developmentof what, workers in pre-industrial America. in the case of Albany, was a trading station, a military outpost, a commercial and communications center, and These laborers, artisans, craftspeople, transporters, then a seat of government and service on the west bank human services vendors, merchants and traders, and of the Hudson River, 150 miles north of Manhattan.’ professional people gave this colonial city its character, its identity, and its life. An appreciation of how the ‘This essay applies a functional framework and working people of colonial Albany earned a living is employs a humanistic approach toward the under- basic to understandingissues that led to the chartering of standing of life in an early American community. The the colonial city in 1686; how Albany grew over the next city of Albany was a home for as many as 10,000 hundred years; how its political economy functioned in different people during the century before the War for practice; and how its people related to their neighbors, a Independence.Each of these Albany residents played a large dependanthinterland, transient populations, and to part in the community’s socio-economic drama. other parts of the outside world.2 Appreciating the individual and collective contributions of each of the people of colonial Albany representsa Before submitting this outline, an appreciation of two comprehensively revealing approach to community basic concepts is essential. These definitions help history. To know intimately the lives of each of these provide a framework for understanding why the city of people of colonial Albany and to understand how Albany flourished and how the lives of its people differed individual life histories worked as parts of a larger story from those living in the Albany hinterland. First, this of family and community over a period of approximately essaydefines an “Albany person” as a resident of the city 114 years is the ambition of the Colonial Albany Social of Albany, the one mile by sixteen mile strip of land History Project, a model community history program running northwest away from the Hudson as specified in sponsoredby theNew York StateMuseum. The Colonial the city charter granted by Governor Thomas Dongan in Albany Social History Project has undertaken a broadly 1686. The center of this municipality was the land conceived program of historical research and has enclosedby the Albany stockade,a log fence which was developed several data base information centers on the enlarged several times during the seventeenth and people of colonial Albany and their world. The central eighteenth centuries. Most, but not all, Albany residents element of this data base is a detailed life course bio- lived inside the six gates.The distinction of city residents graphy for each of the people who lived in the city of from those living in the countryside is critical to Albany before 1800. These biographies are the essential appreciating the development of the regional economy building blocks of all project-related programs. In sum- on two levels. 119 120 SELECTED RENSSELAERSWIJCK SEMINAR PAPERS Fig. 26. Early Albany Street Sceneby Leonard F. Tantillo. By the date of the charter, these “city” people had city’s mayor and aldermen), was responsible for protect- formed an image of themselvesas members of an Albany ing the Albany fur trading monopoly. Somleenterprising community. Their special status confirmed in the individuals sought to maintain dual residenciesand thus Dongan Charter was tangibly important to them with qualify as traders.But the Albany city fathers (the mayor respectto their land titles in an areaotherwise surrounded and aldermen) were successful in almos%completely by Van RensselaerManor, their exclusive right to trade eliminating that practice by the end of the first decadeof for furs, and the other privileges connected to city the eighteenth century.3 residency. Albany people were distinguished from other regional residents by their occupations, which The Albany city charter also established.Albany as the unlike the others, did not revolve around farming. county market town and designatedregular market days when farmers could bring their produce ~toAlbany to Albany residents made, sold, and repaired things and barter for goods and services offered by those Albany also provided a range of personal services. Only residentsenjoying the “freedom of the city.” Only those qualified Albany city residents, called “burghers” or entitled by freemanship or licenced by the Albany “freemen,” were authorized to trade with the Indians. corporation (the mayor and councilmen) were permitted All others, and there were many, were liable to be to sell their waresat the Albany market. At the sametime, condemnedas illegal traders. In practice, this restriction internal carting and portering, and ferry accessto Albany seriously impeded non-resident, would-be traders, were controlled by appointment and license by the city whether they were from New York, New England, or corporation. Finally, the mayor was emlpowered as more immediately from Rensselaerswijck,Kinderhook, “clerk of the market” to set commercial standardsinclud- Catskill, or Schenectady,from openly purchasing Indian ing weights and measures, and, through the Mayor’s trade goods and from selling competitively the furs they Court, to arbitrate business disputes. This legislation might illegally receive from the Iroquois and Eastern meant that access to the market and the movement of Indians. This reservation also placed theseoutsiders at goods and supplies acrossthe Hudson and within the city risk of being arrestedby the Albany County sheriff who was reserved to those preferred by the Albany city with the Albany Commissioners of Indian Affairs (the fathers. WOW A CITY WORKED 124 Not surprisingly, both the fur trading monopoly and excepting infants and invalids. Wives took over manage- the rights and regulations of the Albany market were ment of theseenterprises during the absenceor death of violated and infringed on by non-residents. However, the head of the household, adding additional respon- unauthorized tradersand merchants(anyone who had not sibility to childbearing which lasted for up to two qualified for the “Freedom of Albany”) often were decades. Most widows of childbearing age remarried prosecuted and fined. Those who persisted were while those who had reachedmiddle age often managed compelled to carry on in some degreeof secrecy.Thus, the family trade or business themselves and did not they were at a seriousdisadvantage when competing with remarry. the legally established Albany traders and merchants, These Albany Handelaers, the Dutch word for Children generally outnumbered the adults in the merchants, who were prominently represented on the community as the typical Albany household included Albany Corporation and in the local courts, successfully four or more sonsand daughters.Childhood endedearly employed legal sanctions to curtail competition.4 as boys and girls had been introduced to crafts, trade, business,and above all, to labor, by the time they reached Second, by establishing the city of Albany as the their teens. Few children left their parents’ hearth until exclusive commercial center for the county that origi- they married during their early twenties. Thus, the family nally extended from Saugertiesto the St. Lawrence and work unit would retain its basic labor supply over all but from New England to the Indian country, commercial the first years of an Albany householder’s career. opportunities for the inhabitants of the rest of the region Virtually every Albany youth aged ten to twenty could were confined to agriculture and to extractive expect to passfive to fifteen years of work, training, and enterprises.These farmers were permitted to grow and seasoningin a family businessenterprise. In this city of harvest agricultural products and to cut, cure, and other- households characterized by a family-based economic wise prepareproduce and forest and mineral products for unit, wives, sons and daughters, a large number of or- sale on the Albany market in accordancewith the terms phans, and some adolescent apprentices formed the of their individual land titles. backboneof the community’s labor supply. Freedom to “mine” the
Recommended publications
  • 2016 Proposed Budget
    City of Albany 2016 Proposed Budget Kathy M. Sheehan, Mayor Ismat Alam, Budget Director CITY OF ALBANY OFFICE OF THE MAYOR 24 EAGLE STREET ALBANY, NEW YORK 12207 TELEPHONE (518) 434-5100 WWW.ALBANYNY.ORG KATHY SHEEHAN MAYOR Dear Common Council Members and Residents of the City of Albany: We are at a crossroads in our City where the future for private sector growth, new housing and public investment has never been brighter, but the fiscal sustainability of the very services that support this growth has never been at graver risk. Starting in 2007, consecutive City budgets included the use of Fund Balance (our “rainy day” fund) to balance the budget. This draining of our reserves occurred even with nearly $8 million in annual “spin up” revenue from the State. The most significant depletion of Fund Balance occurred in the prior administration’s 2014 budget, which did not include a “spin up” from the State. Primarily because of the resulting impact on the City’s reserves, the Office of the New York State Comptroller identified Albany as a City experiencing “Significant Fiscal Distress.” My administration’s first budget included significant cost savings measures and short-term relief from the State in the form of one-time revenue, but still required the use $2 million of Fund Balance to deliver a balanced budget. The State’s revenue relief resulted after the New York State Financial Restructuring Board (FRB) reviewed the City’s finances and recognized the gap between what it costs to provide city services and the revenue available to pay for those services.
    [Show full text]
  • "Smackdown on the Hudson" the Patroon, the West India Company, and the Founding of Albany
    "Smackdown on the Hudson" The Patroon, the West India Company, and the Founding of Albany Lesson Procedures Essential question: How was the colony of New Netherland ruled by the Dutch West India Company and the patroons? Grade 7 Content Understandings, New York State Standards: Social Studies Standards This lesson covers European Exploration and Colonization of the Americas and Life in Colonial Communities, focusing on settlement patterns and political life in New Netherland. By studying the conflict between the Petrus Stuyvesant and the Brant van Slichtenhorst, students will consider the sources of historic documents and evaluate their reliability. Common Core Standards: Reading Standards By analyzing historic documents, students will develop essential reading, writing, and critical thinking skills. They will read and analyze informational texts and draw inferences from those texts. Students will explain what happened and why based on information from the readings. Additionally, as a class, students will discuss general academic and domain- specific words or phrases relevant to the unit. Speaking and Listening Standards Students will engage in group and teacher-led collaborative discussions, using textual evidence to pose hypotheses and respond to specific questions. They will also report to the class on their group’s assigned topic, explaining their ideas, analyses, and observations and citing reasons and evidence to support their claims. New Netherland Institute New Netherland Research Center "Smackdown on the Hudson" 2 Writing Standards To conclude this lesson, students write a letter to the editor of the Rensselaerwijck Times that draws evidence from informational texts and supports claims with clear reasons and relevant evidence. Historical Context: In 1614, soon after the founding of the New Netherland Company (predecessor to the West India Company, est.
    [Show full text]
  • A-Brief-History-Of-The-Mohican-Nation
    wig d r r ksc i i caln sr v a ar ; ny s' k , a u A Evict t:k A Mitfsorgo 4 oiwcan V 5to cLk rid;Mc-u n,5 3 ss l Y gew y » w a. 3 k lz x OWE u, 9g z ca , Z 1 9 A J i NEI x i c x Rat 44MMA Y t6 manY 1 YryS y Y s 4 INK S W6 a r sue`+ r1i 3 My personal thanks gc'lo thc, f'al ca ° iaag, t(")mcilal a r of the Stockbridge-IMtarasee historical C;orrunittee for their comments and suggestions to iatataraare tlac=laistcatic: aal aac c aracy of this brief' history of our people ta°a Raa la€' t "din as for her c<arefaal editing of this text to Jeff vcic.'of, the rlohican ?'yews, otar nation s newspaper 0 to Chad Miller c d tlac" Land Resource aM anaagenient Office for preparing the map Dorothy Davids, Chair Stockbridge -Munsee Historical Committee Tke Muk-con-oLke-ne- rfie People of the Waters that Are Never Still have a rich and illustrious history which has been retrained through oral tradition and the written word, Our many moves frorn the East to Wisconsin left Many Trails to retrace in search of our history. Maanv'rrails is air original design created and designed by Edwin Martin, a Mohican Indian, symbol- izing endurance, strength and hope. From a long suffering proud and deternuned people. e' aw rtaftv f h s is an aatathCutic basket painting by Stockbridge Mohican/ basket weavers.
    [Show full text]
  • 5 IMPLEMENTATION Implementation of the Hudson River Valley Greenway Trail Is an Ongoing Process
    5 IMPLEMENTATION Implementation of the Hudson River Valley Greenway Trail is an ongoing process. The existing hiking, biking and water trail routes can continue to be improved and promoted, while the multi-use path will require a significant level of new planning, design and capital investment. In the past 25 years, the Greenway has developed grass-roots and local government support for these efforts, providing an excellent foundation for the next generation of the trail system. The following actions are recommended for the ongoing success of the HRVG: 1. Continue promoting the Water Trail: this is the most direct connection to the river, and can be marketed without significant capital improvements to promote the whole Greenway. 2. Upgrade the existing Hiking Trails: The continuous hiking trail can be achieved with alignments closer to the river - and many of these key connections are already in progress. With the new TZ bridge path and the Walkway over the Hudson, a loop hiking trail can connect both sides of the river in the lower half of the valley. 3. Improve the on-road Bike Routes: the currently signed NYS Bike Route 9 is a challenging route and is limited to experienced cyclists. Improving signage, paved shoulders, bike lanes, bike parking and Amtrak access will all support increased use along the route. Both the PTNY and West Side routes are not currently designated, but they can be improved to create on-road routes on both sides of the river. 4. Develop the continuous Hudson River Valley Greenway Trail trunk line: the efforts of the past decades have led to significant new potential to create a continuous multi-use path the length of the Hudson River Valley from Manhattan to the Adirondacks.
    [Show full text]
  • NY Excluding Long Island 2017
    DISCONTINUED SURFACE-WATER DISCHARGE OR STAGE-ONLY STATIONS The following continuous-record surface-water discharge or stage-only stations (gaging stations) in eastern New York excluding Long Island have been discontinued. Daily streamflow or stage records were collected and published for the period of record, expressed in water years, shown for each station. Those stations with an asterisk (*) before the station number are currently operated as crest-stage partial-record station and those with a double asterisk (**) after the station name had revisions published after the site was discontinued. Those stations with a (‡) following the Period of Record have no winter record. [Letters after station name designate type of data collected: (d) discharge, (e) elevation, (g) gage height] Period of Station Drainage record Station name number area (mi2) (water years) HOUSATONIC RIVER BASIN Tenmile River near Wassaic, NY (d) 01199420 120 1959-61 Swamp River near Dover Plains, NY (d) 01199490 46.6 1961-68 Tenmile River at Dover Plains, NY (d) 01199500 189 1901-04 BLIND BROOK BASIN Blind Brook at Rye, NY (d) 01300000 8.86 1944-89 BEAVER SWAMP BROOK BASIN Beaver Swamp Brook at Mamaroneck, NY (d) 01300500 4.42 1944-89 MAMARONECK RIVER BASIN Mamaroneck River at Mamaroneck, NY (d) 01301000 23.1 1944-89 BRONX RIVER BASIN Bronx River at Bronxville, NY (d) 01302000 26.5 1944-89 HUDSON RIVER BASIN Opalescent River near Tahawus, NY (d) 01311900 9.02 1921-23 Fishing Brook (County Line Flow Outlet) near Newcomb, NY (d) 0131199050 25.2 2007-10 Arbutus Pond Outlet
    [Show full text]
  • The Legacy of Alida Livingston of New York
    Graduate Theses, Dissertations, and Problem Reports 2011 A Dutch Woman in an English World: The Legacy of Alida Livingston of New York Melinda M. Mohler West Virginia University Follow this and additional works at: https://researchrepository.wvu.edu/etd Recommended Citation Mohler, Melinda M., "A Dutch Woman in an English World: The Legacy of Alida Livingston of New York" (2011). Graduate Theses, Dissertations, and Problem Reports. 4755. https://researchrepository.wvu.edu/etd/4755 This Dissertation is protected by copyright and/or related rights. It has been brought to you by the The Research Repository @ WVU with permission from the rights-holder(s). You are free to use this Dissertation in any way that is permitted by the copyright and related rights legislation that applies to your use. For other uses you must obtain permission from the rights-holder(s) directly, unless additional rights are indicated by a Creative Commons license in the record and/ or on the work itself. This Dissertation has been accepted for inclusion in WVU Graduate Theses, Dissertations, and Problem Reports collection by an authorized administrator of The Research Repository @ WVU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. A Dutch Woman in an English World: The Legacy of Alida Livingston of New York Melinda M. Mohler Dissertation submitted to the College of Arts and Sciences at West Virginia University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History Jack Hammersmith, Ph.D., Chair Mary Lou Lustig, Ph.D. Elizabeth Fones-Wolf, Ph.D. Kenneth Fones-World, Ph.D. Martha Pallante, Ph.D.
    [Show full text]
  • Episodes from a Hudson River Town Peak of the Catskills, Ulster County’S 4,200-Foot Slide Mountain, May Have Poked up out of the Frozen Terrain
    1 Prehistoric Times Our Landscape and First People The countryside along the Hudson River and throughout Greene County always has been a lure for settlers and speculators. Newcomers and longtime residents find the waterway, its tributaries, the Catskills, and our hills and valleys a primary reason for living and enjoying life here. New Baltimore and its surroundings were formed and massaged by the dynamic forces of nature, the result of ongoing geologic events over millions of years.1 The most prominent geographic features in the region came into being during what geologists called the Paleozoic era, nearly 550 million years ago. It was a time when continents collided and parted, causing upheavals that pushed vast land masses into hills and mountains and complementing lowlands. The Kalkberg, the spiny ridge running through New Baltimore, is named for one of the rock layers formed in ancient times. Immense seas covered much of New York and served as collect- ing pools for sediments that consolidated into today’s rock formations. The only animals around were simple forms of jellyfish, sponges, and arthropods with their characteristic jointed legs and exoskeletons, like grasshoppers and beetles. The next integral formation event happened 1.6 million years ago during the Pleistocene epoch when the Laurentide ice mass developed in Canada. This continental glacier grew unyieldingly, expanding south- ward and retreating several times, radically altering the landscape time and again as it traveled. Greene County was buried. Only the highest 5 © 2011 State University of New York Press, Albany 6 / Episodes from a Hudson River Town peak of the Catskills, Ulster County’s 4,200-foot Slide Mountain, may have poked up out of the frozen terrain.
    [Show full text]
  • Before Albany
    Before Albany THE UNIVERSITY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Regents of the University ROBERT M. BENNETT, Chancellor, B.A., M.S. ...................................................... Tonawanda MERRYL H. TISCH, Vice Chancellor, B.A., M.A. Ed.D. ........................................ New York SAUL B. COHEN, B.A., M.A., Ph.D. ................................................................... New Rochelle JAMES C. DAWSON, A.A., B.A., M.S., Ph.D. ....................................................... Peru ANTHONY S. BOTTAR, B.A., J.D. ......................................................................... Syracuse GERALDINE D. CHAPEY, B.A., M.A., Ed.D. ......................................................... Belle Harbor ARNOLD B. GARDNER, B.A., LL.B. ...................................................................... Buffalo HARRY PHILLIPS, 3rd, B.A., M.S.F.S. ................................................................... Hartsdale JOSEPH E. BOWMAN,JR., B.A., M.L.S., M.A., M.Ed., Ed.D. ................................ Albany JAMES R. TALLON,JR., B.A., M.A. ...................................................................... Binghamton MILTON L. COFIELD, B.S., M.B.A., Ph.D. ........................................................... Rochester ROGER B. TILLES, B.A., J.D. ............................................................................... Great Neck KAREN BROOKS HOPKINS, B.A., M.F.A. ............................................................... Brooklyn NATALIE M. GOMEZ-VELEZ, B.A., J.D. ...............................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 2018 Proposed Budget
    City of Albany 2018 Proposed Budget Kathy M. Sheehan, Mayor Michael W. Wheeler, Budget Director MISSION OF CITY GOVERNMENT The only reason we are here is to serve the City of Albany. It is our job to provide services and support that build a safe, healthy, and economically vibrant community. TABLE OF CONTENTS MAYOR’S letteR...........................................................................................................1 coMMonlY UseD PHRases ......................................................................................4 ORGanIZatIonal CHART .........................................................................................5 BUDGet SUMMARIes of REVenUes & EXPenDITURes .................................6 OPERatING BUDGet REVenUE .............................................................................10 OPERatING BUDGet EXPenDITURes BY DEPARTMent................................16 caPItal BUDGet .......................................................................................................89 WateR & WasteWateR seRVIces ......................................................................95 YOUTH & WORKfoRce seRVIces .......................................................................112 THE case foR caPItal CITY FUNDING .........................................................116 looKING AHeaD .....................................................................................................117 contRIBUtoRS .........................................................................................................118
    [Show full text]
  • Land Title Records in the New York State Archives New York State Archives Information Leaflet #11 [DRAFT] ______
    Land Title Records in the New York State Archives New York State Archives Information Leaflet #11 [DRAFT] __________________________________________________________________________________________________ Introduction NEW YORK STATE ARCHIVES Cultural Education Center Room 11A42 The New York State Archives holds numerous records Albany, NY 12230 documenting title to real property in New York. The records range in date from the early seventeenth century to Phone 518-474-8955 the near present. Practically all of the records dating after FAX 518-408-1940 the early nineteenth century concern real property E-mail [email protected] acquired or disposed by the state. However, many of the Website www.archives.nysed.gov earlier records document conveyances of real property ______________________________________________ between private persons. The Archives holds records of grants by the colony and state for lands above and under Contents: water; deeds issued by various state officers; some private deeds and mortgages; deeds to the state for public A. Indian Deeds and Treaties [p. 2] buildings and facilities; deeds and cessions to the United B. Dutch Land Grants and Deeds [p. 2] States; land appropriations for canals and other public purposes; and permits, easements, etc., to and from the C. New York Patents for Uplands state. The Archives also holds numerous records relating and Lands Under Water [p. 3] to the survey and sale of lands of the colony and state. D. Applications for Patents for Uplands and Lands Under Water [p. 6] This publication contains brief descriptions of land title records and related records in the Archives. Each record E. Deeds by Commissioners of Forfeitures [p. 9] series is identified by series number (five-character F.
    [Show full text]
  • Bgb 487 Van Rensselaer Bowier Manuscripts.Pdf
    BGB 487 Van Rensselaer Bowier Manuscripts The complete title is, Van Rensselaer Bowier Manuscripts, Being the Letters of Kiliaen van Rensselaer, 1630-1643, and Other Documents Relating to the Colony of Rensselaerswyck. This work was translated and edited by Arnold J. F. van Laer. It was published in 1908 by the University of the State of New York, Albany. A brief description of the Van Rensselaer Bowier Manuscripts can be found on the New Netherland Institute's website. The link labeled, "Translation" will take you to a digital copy of the book in PDF format. It is over 900 pages and may take a few minutes to completely upload to your screen. Once it has, I have found that the best way to utilize the book is to download it to my computer and open it offline. Here is a direct link to the PDF: Van Rensselaer Bowier Manuscripts Digital copies in PDF and with options for other formats can be found elsewhere online, for example at the Internet Archives, and at Google Books. Since the book was published prior to 1927, it is in the public domain. For those who wish to have a physical book, used copies and reprints can be found for sale online at the websites of various booksellers. Just do a search. There is one person named Brouwer found in this volume, and a second person referred to as de Brouwer (the brewer), an appellation that should not be confused for a surname. Beginning at page 166 is a "Certificate of purchase from the Indians of land on the west side of the Hudson River from Smacks Island to Moenemin's Castle and of tract of land on the east side opposite Castle Island and Fort Orange." The date is given as August 13, 1630.
    [Show full text]
  • An Assessment of Immigration Federalism in the Nineteenth Century”
    “An Assessment of Immigration Federalism in the Nineteenth Century” Anna O. Law Herbert Kurz Associate Professor of Constitutional Law and Civil Liberties CUNY Brooklyn College [email protected] Abstract: In a federal system of government, why did the U.S. national government wait until 1882 to take over control of immigration policy from the states and localities? This phenomenon is especially curious since the control of entry/exit into and across a nation’s borders is so fundamental to the very definition of a state. Is it because the American state was too weak to do so, or specifically that the national government lacked administrative capacity to handle immigration until the late twentieth century? I argue that the delay of the national government taking over immigration was not due to a lack of administrative capacity. Instead, there were regionally specific reasons that the states preferred to retain control of migration policy. In the northern seaboard states, the priority was excluding the poor, sick, and criminal, who, if admitted, would pose social and economic burdens on those states. In the South, the motivation was preserving slavery and guarding against slave insurrections. The national government could not take over migration policy until a series of political events uncoupled slavery and migration policy in the South, and the federal government assumed financial responsibility for screening poor, sick, and criminal immigrants in the North. 1 ”There can be no concurrent power respecting such a subject-matter [policies regarding freedom of movement]. Such a power is necessarily discretionary. Massachusetts fears foreign paupers; Mississippi, free negroes.” —Frederich Kapp, New York City Commissioner of Emigration1 Introduction In a federal system, who, the national government or the states and localities, regulates immigration policy? The fact that there was a tough political and legal fight over Arizona’s controversial S.B.
    [Show full text]