Acceleration Tolerance: Effect of Exercise, Acceleration Training; Bed Rest and Weightlessness Deconditioning a Compendium of Research (1950-1996)

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Acceleration Tolerance: Effect of Exercise, Acceleration Training; Bed Rest and Weightlessness Deconditioning a Compendium of Research (1950-1996) NASA Technical Memorandum 112214 Acceleration Tolerance: Effect of Exercise, Acceleration Training; Bed Rest and Weightlessness Deconditioning A Compendium of Research (1950-1996) J. L. Chou, M. A. McKenzie, N. J. Stad, and P. R. Barnes, California State University at San Francisco C. G. R. Jackson, California State University at Fresno F. Ghiasvand and J. E. Greenleaf, Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, California October 1997 National Aeronautics and Space Administration Ames Research Center Moffett Field, California 94035-1000 Contents Page Summary ................................................................................................ iv Introduction ............................................................................................. v Abstracts and Annotations ............................................................................ 1 Additional Selected Bibliography .................................................................... 45 Author Index ............................................................................................ 47 Keyword Index ......................................................................................... 51 iii Summary This compendium includes abstracts and annotations of clinical observations and of more basic studies involving physiological mechanisms concerning interaction of acceleration, training and deconditioning. If the author's abstract or summary was appropriate, it was included. In other cases a more detailed annotation of the paper was prepared under the subheadings Purpose, Methods, Results, and Conclusions. Author and keyword indices are provided, plus an additional selected bibliography of related work and of those papers received after the volume was prepared for publication. This volume includes material published from 1950-1996. iv Introduction The purpose of this compendium is to present summaries of clinical observations and results from more basic studies that help to elucidate physiological mechanisms for control of acceleration tolerance as affected by exercise training and deconditioning. It the author's abstract or summary was appropriate, it was utilized. In some cases a more detailed annotation was provided under the subheadings Purpose, Methods, Results, and Conclusions. This volume includes studies published from 1950 through 1996. Author and keyword indices are provided. The material is listed in alphabetical order by first author and numbered consecutively by abstract number, not page number. We thank our many colleagues who sent us reprints, and apologize to those whose work we have inadvertently overlooked. The authors thank Esther Johnson for valuable technical assistance. J.E.G. 1. Antonutto G, D Linnarsson, CJ Authors' Abstract Sundberg, PE diPrampero. The goal of this study was to provide Artificial gravity in Space: vestibular information for developing means to protect tolerance assessed by human operators from +Gz acceleration. A total of centrifuge spinning on Earth. 36 subjects, aged 20 to 31, participated in the Acta Astronautica 27:71-73. 1992. study. All had been certified fit for Authors' Abstract centrifugation and hypokinesia with head- Artificial gravity created by the astronauts down tilt. Three conditions were run. In the themselves, without any external power first, 10 subjects s_nt 60 hours in supply, by pedalling on a couple of hypokinesia with -60 head-down tilt during counterrotating bicycles along the inner wall the night and -150 during the day. Before of the space module (Twin Bikes System, and after this treatment, subjects' endurance TBS), was previously suggested (Antonutto of +3Gz was assessed for 15 minutes with et al., 1991) to prevent musculo-skeletal and without antigravity device I (AGD-1). decay and cardiovascular deconditioning In the second condition, the effectiveness of during long term space flights. To AGD-1 was tested on 24 subjects before and investigate whether this unusual rotating after a 7-day period of hypokinesia with environment would determine abnormal head-down tilt (-10°). The following stimulations of the vestibular system due to acceleration schedule was used: 2.5- and 3.0- Coriolis cross coupled accelerations, thus G for 5 minutes each, 3.5-, 4.0- and 4.5-G leading to acute motion sickness (AMS), the for 30 minutes each. In the third condition, conditions of a rotating environment were endurance of 6 subjects was measured before reproduced in a human centrifuge. A and after a 7-day period of hypokinesia using cycloergometer was fixed to the arm of the the AGD-2 device and the same acceleration centrifuge, the rotation speed of which was schedule as in condition 2. In all cases, equal to that yielding 1 g at the feet level in acceleration increased at a rate of 0. I-G per the TBS (i.e. ranging from 19 to 21 RPM). second. AGD-I consisted of closely fitting The ergometer position was such that the trousers made of stretch fabric with a high combination of the horizontal and elasticity modulus which could maintain the gravitational acceleration vectors was 1.414 perimeter and volume of the lower body at the inner ear level and was aligned along under exposure to longitudinal G-load. the head to feet axis. Three subjects, AGD-2 was a shortened modification of pedalling at 50 W on a cycloergometer during AGD-1 reaching to the knees. Operator centrifuge's spinning, were asked to move performance was evaluated in condition 3 the head following an AMS' provocation during exposure to acceleration with a control protocol. None of them developed any AMS task using a flight instrument providing symptoms. This supports the look of the information about flight parameters. TBS as tool for avoiding musculo-skeletal Physiological parameters were assessed by and cardiovascular deconditioning during an EKG with tetrapolar chest leads, long term space flights. photoplethysmography of the ear, and a myogram of the femur and abdominal muscles. Subjects were all trained to criterion on the control task before • Asyamolov BF, LI Voronin, VS Panchenko, NV Ulyatovsiy, centrifugation. RA Bondarenko, AV Kaliberdin, SYu Elizarov, VG 3. Balldin UI, K Myhre, PA Tesch, PIokhova, AS Yarov. U Wilheimsen, HT Andersen• Effectiveness of antigravity devices of Isometric abdominal muscle training the chamberless type after 7 days of and G tolerance. hypokinesia with head-down tilt. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Kosmicheskaya Biologiya i Medicine 56: 120-124, 1985. Aviakosmicheskaya Meditsina Authors' Abstract 22:37-40, 1988. Methodsto increaseG toleranceof pilots during submaximal G exposures may be used flying highperformanceaircraftareof vital as indicators of shifts in endurance G importance.Strainingmaneuversto increase tolerance. The procedure may reduce the G toleranceinvolveabdominalmuscles,and need for exhaustive G tolerance tests with highintra-abdominalpressures(IAP) are associated risks and discomfort. recordedduring G exposure. This study was carried out to examine the effects of an 11- 5. Beckman MC, KR Coburn, RM week abdominal muscle training program on Chambers, RE DeForest, WS maximal IAP, G tolerance and muscle Augerson, VG Benson. strength/endurance in 10 fighter pilots. G Physiological changes observed in tolerance was measured in a human human subjects during zero G centrifuge using simulated aerial combat stimulation by immersion in water up maneuvers (ACM). The pilots had a higher to neck level. maximal IAP before training than a control Aerospace Medicine 32:1031-1041, group. G tolerance, maximal lAP, and 1961. maximal peak torque of knee extensors were Authors' Abstract not changed by the training. In contrast, leg Knowledge relative to the effects of muscle endurance increased (p<0.01) and prolonged weightlessness is needed in ratings of local perceived exertion decreased preparing man for space flight. The buoyant (p<0.01). Static endurance of the knee force exerted upon immersed bodies extensors was positively correlated (p<0.05) effectively simulates the weightless state with with G tolerance. It is concluded that the respect to proprioceptive sensory responses present abdominal training program, and perhaps in other ways. An investigation employed in experienced fighter pilots, is not into the physiological effects of immersing sufficient to increase IAP or G tolerance. subjects in water up to neck level was undertaken. It was found that water 4. Balidin UI, P Kuronen, H Rusko, immersion produces an unnatural E. Svensson. physiological situation in that, during Perceived exertion during respiration, the inspired air inflates the lungs submaximal G exposures before and to atmospheric pressure while the external after physical training. pressure against the chest, abdomen, and Aviation, Space, and Environmental legs, due to the water, is greater than Medicine 65:199-203, 1994. atmospheric. This situation is equivalent to Authors' Abstract "negative pressure breathing." Ratings of perceived exertion (RPE) were A series of experiments involving seven registered at submaximal levels in G subjects immersed in water up to neck level endurance tests of a combined strength and for periods of 5 to 23 hours (five subjects for endurance training program in 17 pilots. 12 hours) showed a significant weight loss After 12 months of physical training, the during the period of immersion, which was endurance G tolerance (time to exhaustion explained by the diuresis which occurred. during simulated aerial combat maneuver), Pulmonary volume measurements showed a increased by a mean of
Recommended publications
  • An Investigation of the Effects of Sustained G-Forces on the Human
    An Investigation of the Effects of Sustained G-Forces on the Human Body During Suborbital Spaceflight In Fulfilment of the Degree: Master of Science in Aerospace Engineering Eric Jackson KTH Royal Institute of Technology Stockholm, Sweden June 30, 2017 SAMMANFATTNING (SWEDISH) Inom en snar framtid ¨ardet troligt att privata, kommersiella rymdflygningar ¨arm¨ojliga,d¨arpassagerarna inte kommer att vara utbildade astronauter och, till majoriteten, troligtvis ¨aldre.Dessa personer kommer att uts¨attasf¨or h¨ogaG-krafter vilket utan avancerad tr¨aningmedf¨orrisker som inte beaktats i detalj tidigare. Accelerationsprofilerna f¨orde tv˚arymdfarkoster som just nu utvecklas kommersiellt var analyserade utifr˚anofficiellt tillg¨anglig data. Videoanalys utf¨ordesutifr˚anfilmer av testflygningar och m¨anskligacentrifugtester anv¨andes f¨oratt f˚afram individuell data. Dessa var sedan kombinerade f¨oratt f˚afram accelerationsprofiler f¨orb˚adafarkosterna. Baserat p˚adessa profiler och de maximala G-krafterna som uppn˚addesanalyserades de m¨ojligariskerna f¨or passagerarna utifr˚anett medicinsk perspektiv. 1 ABSTRACT With the advent of private commercial suborbital spaceflight, a new demo- graphic of untrained individuals will begin to travel to space. These individu- als are exposed to high levels of G-forces, resulting in medical considerations which are not a normal factor with high performance fighter pilots or astro- nauts. The acceleration profiles of the Virgin Galactic and Blue Origin spacecraft were obtained from publicly available data. Video analysis was performed on footage of spacecraft test launches and human centrifuge tests to obtain individual data sets. These data sets were used to develop the acceleration profiles for both spacecraft. Based on the spacecraft's acceleration profiles and peak G-forces, medical conditions were investigated and considered to identify potential risks that may affect the passengers, particularly the elderly.
    [Show full text]
  • G R a V I T Y a N D Ma N Part I . Studies on the Effect Of
    GRAVITY AND MAN PART I . STUDIES ON THE EFFECT OF INCREASED GRAVITATIONAL FORCE ON MAN. PART I I . THE EFFECTS OF OTHER PHYSIOLOGICAL STRESSES ON MAN'S TOLERANCE TO INCREASED GRAVITATIONAL FORCE. MATTHEW KENNEDY BROWNE THESIS PRESENTED FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF MEDICINE IN THE UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW. MARCH 1959. ProQuest Number: 13850369 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a com plete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. uest ProQuest 13850369 Published by ProQuest LLC(2019). Copyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States C ode Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. ProQuest LLC. 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106- 1346 CONTENTS. PAST I . Page CHAPTER I* INTRODUCTION. 1 " I I . METHODS AND MATERIALS. 10 " I I I . PHYSIOLOGY. PI " IV. HUMAN TOLERANCE TO ACCELERATION. 35 “ v. THE ELECTROCARDIOGRAM DURING POSITIVE 50 ACCELERATION. " VI. CHANGES IN THE ELECTRICAL AXIS AND THE VECTORCARDIOGRAM DURING 66 ACCELERATION. VII. THE ELECTRO-ENCEPHALOGRAM DURING 80 POSITIVE ACCELERATION. K V III. THE OCCURRENCE OP CONVULSIVE EPISODES 86 ON THE CENTRIFUGE. XI. A METHOD FOR THRESHOLD DETERMINATION 91 IN THE HUMAN CENTRIFUGE. PART I I . CHAPTER I . INTRODUCTION. 107 " I I . THE EFFECT OF HEAT ON TOLERANCE TO POSITIVE ACCELERATION. 136 " I I I .
    [Show full text]
  • NAWC ASTC Cherry Point GTIP 95 American Osteopathic College of Occupational and Preventive Medicine 2014 Annual Meeting, Seattle, Washington
    American Osteopathic College of Occupational and Preventive Medicine 2014 Annual Meeting, Seattle, Washington 24.0 IDENTIFY Gz acceleration forces, the causes and symptoms of (G-LOC), and the methods to improve G-tolerance. disclosure information: “Nothing to Disclose!” • On 13 July 1977 British racing driver David Purley survived a 24.1 IDENTIFY effects of +/- Gs. deceleration from 173 km/h to zero in a distance of about 24.2 IDENTIFY different types of Loss of 0.66 m, enduring 180 G. Consciousness (LOC). • The beak of the red-headed woodpecker hits the bark of a 24.3 LIST physical and physiological factors that tree with an impact velocity of over 21 km/h, subjecting the may effect G-tolerance. bird’s brain to a deceleration of approximately 10 G when its head snaps back. 24.4 IDENTIFY physiological and mechanical mechanisms used to increase G-tolerance. The current capabilities of trained individuals to maintain clear vision during sustained exposures to 9 Gz is a result of: It’s fun • Use of a G suit It builds character • Very effective self-protective straining maneuvers such So you can kill the other guy as the M-1, L-1 So you don’t get killed • Pressure breathing Actually only pull Gs to change direction All of which are variants of the Valsalva maneuver developed in the 1940s S-1 NAWC ASTC Cherry Point GTIP 95 American Osteopathic College of Occupational and Preventive Medicine 2014 Annual Meeting, Seattle, Washington The most plausible causes are: Poor anti-G straining maneuver was cited in 1) Increased capability of jet-powered fighters to 70+% of the mishaps sustain, with minimal pilot effort, accelerations in the 7-10 gz range for periods longer than the Fatigue / G-suit malfunction is 20% symptom-free 3-8 second cerebral ischemic anoxic period which precedes GLOC.
    [Show full text]
  • N95- 16746 -67- •
    -65- -68- EVALUATION OF THREE METHODS FOR TESTING COLD WEATHER COMBAT BOOT SYSTEMS. D.A. DiRaimo t W. R. Santee, and R. R. Gonzalez*. U.S. Army Research PHYSIOLOGICAL RESPONSES DURING SHIPBOARD FIRE FIGHTING. Institute of Environmental Medicine, Natick, MA 01760-5007. B.L Bennett*. R.D. Hanan. G.R. Banta* and F.W. Williams. Naval Health INTRODUCTION. Studies were conducted on a static copper model of the foot, which is Research Center, San Diego, CA, 92186-5122 and Naval Research sectioned into twenty-nine heat transfer regions. This loot model is used to determine the Laboratory, Wash., 0 .C. 20375-5000 dry insulation properties of commercial and prototype cold weather combat boot systems INTRODUCTION. Fire fighters dressed in full protective ensemble and (CWCBS). Heat flux through the boot sole is an important criterion in selecting CWCBS. The combating shipboard fires are subjected to extreme heat strain. However, insulation of air (I,) between the foot and the boot sole is the key variable in the amount of physiological responses have not been well documented. Environmental heat flux through the sole. I,, which thcerporates both the radiative heat transfer (h,) and the chamber simulations to date have not been true representations. Therefore, convective heat transfer (he) coefficients, is reduced as the boot sole is compressed, thus the purpose for this study was to document the physiological responses of increasing the heat flux through the sole. The heat flux is further augmented with the addition U.S. Navy Damage Control personnel while combating fires aboard a fire of a cold substance, such as mud, water, or snow in an actual cold/wet field environment.
    [Show full text]
  • 2012 ABSTRACTS of the Asma SCIENTIFIC SESSIONS 83RD Annual Scientifi C Meeting Atlanta Hilton May 13-17, 2012 Atlanta, GA
    2012 ABSTRACTS OF THE AsMA SCIENTIFIC SESSIONS 83RD Annual Scientifi c Meeting Atlanta Hilton May 13-17, 2012 Atlanta, GA The following are the abstracts accepted for presentation after blind peer-review—in slide, poster, or panel sessions— at the 2012 Annual Scientifi c Meeting of the Aerospace Medical Association. The numbered abstracts are keyed to both the daily schedule and the author index. The order and numbering of some abstracts may have been changed. CONFLICT OF INTEREST: All meeting planners and presenters completed fi nancial disclosure forms for this educational activity. All potential confl icts of interest were resolved before planners and presenters were approved to participate in the educational activity. Any confl icts of interest that could not be resolved resulted in disqualifi - cation from any role involved in planning, management, presentation, or evaluation of the educational activity. Sunday, May 13 9:00 AM Sunday, May 13 12:00 PM Salon C Salon D WORKSHOP: AIRCREW FATIGUE: WORKSHOP: AEROSPACE MEDICINE CAUSES, CONSEQUENCES, AND FACULTY DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP COUNTERMEASURES [2] AEROSPACE MEDICINE FACULTY DEVELOPMENT [1] AIRCREW FATIGUE: CAUSES, CONSEQUENCES, AND WORKSHOP COUNTERMEASURES D. RHODES J.A. CALDWELL1 AND J. CALDWELL2 Aerospace Medicine, USAFSAM, Wright-Patterson AFB, OH 1 2 Fatigue Science, Honolulu, HI; 711 HPW, Wright-Patterson WORKSHOP OVERVIEW: The purpose of this workshop is to AFB, OH provide presentations on current topics of interest to faculty of Aerospace Medicine residencies and fellowships. These presentations WORKSHOP OVERVIEW: In modern aviation operations, may also be of interest to faculty of other Preventive Medicine aircrew fatigue has become a serious but often unrecognized problem.
    [Show full text]
  • 2012 ABSTRACTS of the Asma SCIENTIFIC SESSIONS 83RD Annual Scientifi C Meeting Atlanta Hilton May 13-17, 2012 Atlanta, GA
    2012 ABSTRACTS OF THE AsMA SCIENTIFIC SESSIONS 83RD Annual Scientifi c Meeting Atlanta Hilton May 13-17, 2012 Atlanta, GA The following are the abstracts accepted for presentation after blind peer-review—in slide, poster, or panel sessions— at the 2012 Annual Scientifi c Meeting of the Aerospace Medical Association. The numbered abstracts are keyed to both the daily schedule and the author index. The order and numbering of some abstracts may have been changed. CONFLICT OF INTEREST: All meeting planners and presenters completed fi nancial disclosure forms for this educational activity. All potential confl icts of interest were resolved before planners and presenters were approved to participate in the educational activity. Any confl icts of interest that could not be resolved resulted in disqualifi - cation from any role involved in planning, management, presentation, or evaluation of the educational activity. Sunday, May 13 9:00 AM Sunday, May 13 12:00 PM Salon C Salon D WORKSHOP: AIRCREW FATIGUE: WORKSHOP: AEROSPACE MEDICINE CAUSES, CONSEQUENCES, AND FACULTY DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP COUNTERMEASURES [2] AEROSPACE MEDICINE FACULTY DEVELOPMENT [1] AIRCREW FATIGUE: CAUSES, CONSEQUENCES, AND WORKSHOP COUNTERMEASURES D. RHODES J.A. CALDWELL1 AND J. CALDWELL2 Aerospace Medicine, USAFSAM, Wright-Patterson AFB, OH 1 2 Fatigue Science, Honolulu, HI; 711 HPW, Wright-Patterson WORKSHOP OVERVIEW: The purpose of this workshop is to AFB, OH provide presentations on current topics of interest to faculty of Aerospace Medicine residencies and fellowships. These presentations WORKSHOP OVERVIEW: In modern aviation operations, may also be of interest to faculty of other Preventive Medicine aircrew fatigue has become a serious but often unrecognized problem.
    [Show full text]
  • Evaluation of a Prototype System for Generating Conditions of Orthostatic Hypotension and Blood Pooling in the Lower Body
    Military Institute of Aviation Medicine Research Protocol Evaluation of a prototype system for generating conditions of orthostatic hypotension and blood pooling in the lower body Project DOBR/0052/R/ID1/2012/03 November 10, 2017 Dziuda et al. Research Protocol: Table of Contents ORTHO-LBNP Table of Contents Project summary ........................................................................................................................ 3 General information ................................................................................................................... 4 Protocol Title ......................................................................................................................... 4 Short title ................................................................................................................................ 4 Acronym ................................................................................................................................. 4 Sponsor .................................................................................................................................. 4 Primary Investigator .............................................................................................................. 4 Other medical and/or technical institutions involved in the research ................................... 4 Rationale & background information ........................................................................................ 5 Study goals and objectives ........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]