Sa~Y
S
S
Sart Sa
r r
p p
1 1
J J
k k
'Y
h h
'Yi
Asa
'Yig 'Yig
Llsa
Asa
.4sa
Er Er
E E
cm
A
Ar Ar dA dA
em, em,
A.u A.u
cm
Aft Aft
cf cf
b b
a a
•
ar.aropfiurc ar.aropfiurc
a..eabott a..eabott
Ae
s s
g g
na na
Determination Determination
ws ws
y y
alop alop
abot
x x
r
10
to
ho
bo
ospace ospace
pdx pdx
pdy pdy
Gravity Gravity
udy udy
nr.lx nr.lx
ifiln
c c
and and
the the
position position location location
that that
positions, positions, due due Surface Surface
propellant propellant
= =
= =
= =
== ==
= =
Engineer
Many Many
surface surface
surface surface
surface surface
surface surface unit unit
fill fill
surface surface unit unit
density density
unit unit
liquid liquid
solid-gas solid-gas
total total
liquid-solid liquid-solid
liquid-gas liquid-gas
z-component z-component
differential differential
thus thus potential potential
y-component y-component
differential differential
differential differential
differential differential .x-component .x-component
differential differential
local local
upper upper
wet wet
total total
lower lower
Surface Surface
dry dry
to to
\surface \surface
fraction fraction
surface surface
vector vector
vector vector
vector vector
surface surface
Evolver, Evolver,
surface surface
of of
for for
energy energy
the the
surface surface
circumference circumference
contact contact
climb climb
, ,
integration integration
integration integration
for for
spacecraft, spacecraft,
management management
area area
are
area area
area area
area area
the the
of of
Propulsion Propulsion
a a
area area
center center
Evolver Evolver
energy energy
surface surface
propellant propellant
a a
complicated complicated
surface surface
in in
in in
in in
surface surface
propellant, propellant, surface surface
area area
surface surface
surface surface
surface surface
o
o
of of
of of
area area of of
area area
due due
height height
tension tension
of of
area area
f f
y
f f
z-direction z-direction
GPM GPM .x
if if
of of
of of
of of
an an
angles, angles,
-direction -direction wetted wetted
-direction -direction top top
wetted wetted NASA NASA
bottom bottom
revolved revolved
the the
liquid-gas liquid-gas
of of
propellant propellant
of of
propellant propellant
propellant propellant
to to
of of
due due
tension tension
American American energy energy
of of
limit limit
can can
limit limit
tension tension
half half
mass mass
surface surface
Branch
the the along
facet facet
area area
area area
area area
area area
tens
such such
propellant propellant
tank tank
of of
to to
Interface Interface Liquid/Gas
Goddard Goddard
and and
devices devices
s
section section
and and
half half
accurately accurately
ection ection
of of
the the
along along
gravity gravity
along along
i
tank tank
the the
equation equation s
equation equation
equation equation
equation equation on on
Tank Tank
of of
urface urface
minimization minimization
spher
as as
interface, interface,
propellant propellant
, ,
tension tension
circle circle
center center
of of
fill fill
center center
center center
the the
GSFC GSFC
Institute Institute
contact contact
tank tank
revolve revolve
and and
of of
of of
sphere sphere
(PMDs) (PMDs)
the the
revolve revolve
fractions fractions
Spa
fo
e e
propellant. propellant.
can can
top top
bottom bottom
which which
r r
in in
in in
in in
in in
of of
of of
of of
wall wall
PMD. PMD.
model model
the the
Mail Mail
Global Global
ce ce
with with
the the
the the
the the
the the Nomenclature Nomenclature
part part
also also
David David
mass mass
drastically drastically
mass mass
mass mass
of of
angle angle
axis axis
Flight Flight
propellant propellant
axis axis
center center
to to
from from
stop
Aeronautics Aeronautics
x-direction x-direction
y-direction y-direction
y-direction y-direction
is is
x-direction x-direction
part part
routine, routine,
for for
o
referred referred
the the control control
The The
perpendicular perpendicular
f f
1 1
J. J.
between between Precipitation Precipitation
the the
: :
Center, Center,
center center
the the
of of
597, 597,
Benson
PMD PMD
liquid-gas liquid-gas
of of
Surface Surface
sphe
the the
affect affect
GPM GPM
to to is is
Gr
liquid liquid
mass mass
sphere sphere
o
fo
for for
for for
for for
re re
used used
.
as as
and and
Greenbelt, Greenbelt,
f f
e
1 1
the the
r r
enbelt
tank tank
as as
the the
top top
top top
bottom bottom
bottom bottom
tank tank
Evolver Evolver
the the
locations locations
to to
Astronaut
propellant propellant
Using Using
interface interface
a a
propellant propellant
to to
as as
free free
of of
of of
func
(ori
the the Mission Mission
, ,
liquid-gas liquid-gas
fmd fmd
with with
MD, MD,
a a
sphere sphere
sphere sphere
g
o
of of
and and
z-axis z-axis
function function
surface surface
ti
MD
in) in)
f f
on on
results results
sphere sphere
sphere sphere
liquid-gas liquid-gas
a a
20
i
for for
and and
cs cs
, ,
of of
PMD
within within
20
77
(GPM) (GPM)
Surface Surface
and and
h h
Liquid Liquid
varying varying
7
interface interface
1, 1,
of of
liquid liquid
show show
71 71
and and
. .
solid solid
h h
This This
propellant propellant
interface interface
spacecraft, spacecraft,
AIAA AIAA
that that
center center
surfaces, surfaces,
initial initial
study study
in in
the the
Member Member
Evolver Evolver
the the
Center Center
of of
shapes shapes
shows shows
tanks. tanks.
initial initial
liquid liquid
mass mass
tank tank
and and
use use of of
the the
zero zero surface surface
between between
the the
is is
with with
solid. solid. Bond Bond
directions directions
this this
angle, angle,
acceleration
tank tank
liquid liquid blue blue
are are
lines lines
maneuvers. maneuvers. A. A.
used used
solid solid
propellant propellant
It It
the the the the
exist exist
and and
surface surface
interface interface
tank
especially especially
the the
moments moments V V
flight. flight.
y y
formed formed
z z
x x
~pacecra:ft ~pacecra:ft
e e
V V
is is
liquid liquid
The The
The The
The The
The The
Figure Figure
Geometry Geometry
This This
Surface Surface
Supercomputing Supercomputing Geometry
defined defined
degree degree
propellant propellant
large, large,
tank tank
axes
hence hence
. .
outline outline provided provided
for for
that that
surfaces, surfaces, wall wall
lines lines
angle angle
paper: paper:
When When
is is
free free
liquid liquid
initial initial
On On
number, number,
contact contact
tension tension following following
paper paper
. .
in in
this this free free
position position
NOWING NOWING
a a
will will
considered considered
and and
summarize summarize
on on
1 1
management management
when when
converges converges
"" ""
contact contact
earth, earth,
, ,
and and
surface surface
microgravity microgravity
the the
shows shows
Evolver
outline outline
liquid liquid
the the
as as
the the
paper. paper.
liquid liquid
this this
initial initial
associated associated
be be
and and
free free
volume volume coordinate coordinate
coordinate coordinate
will will
contact contact
coordinate coordinate
and and
in in
position, position,
PMD. PMD.
angle angle
energy energy
which which
used used
surface, surface,
the the
formed formed
a a
contact contact
spacecraft. spacecraft.
gravity gravity
wetted wetted
once once
the the
terms terms
angle angle
vane-type vane-type
angle angle
Terms Terms
the the
solid solid
body body
of of
present present
is is
the the
position position
center center
and and
and and
The The
1 1
the the
the the
to to red red
the the
the the
quickly quickly
charge, charge,
in in
is is
is is
Global Global
angle angle
PMD PMD
ofpropellant ofpropellant
have have
a a
liquid liquid
and and
be be
device device
spacecraft spacecraft
work work
center center
is is
causes causes
after after
an an
interface interface
in in
in in
in in
is is
non-wetting
of of
considered considered
methods methods
Figure Figure
potential potential
the the
the the
a a
the the
as as
Knowledge Knowledge
energy energy
is is
with with
propellant propellant
caused caused
mass mass
fill fill
with with
in in
large large
Precipitation Precipitation
done done
maneuvers maneuvers
measured measured
defined defined
American American
(PMD). (PMD).
Project, Project,
y-direction y-direction
z-direction z-direction
x-direction x-direction
of of
a a
most most
fraction fraction
flat flat
its its
between between
communication communication
mass mass vanes vanes
adequate adequate
position position
maneuver maneuver
1. 1.
wet/dry wet/dry
Central Central
with with
and and
minimization minimization
various various
by by
energy energy
liquid/gas liquid/gas
cases
to to
GPM GPM
. .
as as
management management
The The
which which
When When
of of
tube tube
results results
Surface Surface
and and
surface surface
be be
from from
of of
Institute Institute
were were
the the
and and
the the
the the
. .
mass mass
within within
Mission Mission
perfectly perfectly
vanes vanes
liquid liquid
the the
documentation documentation
parts parts
Surface Surface
PMD PMD
(body (body
has has
location location
II. II.
the the
was was
when when
this this
liquid liquid
liquid/gas liquid/gas
varied varied
for for
I. I.
interface interface
liquid liquid
Evolver Evolver
ratio ratio
tension
ended ended
solid solid
called called
of of
routine routine
initial initial
propellant propellant
with with
funded funded
calculating calculating
Background Background
angle angle
accelerations). accelerations).
Introduction Introduction
device device
Evolver Evolver
using using
Aeronautics Aeronautics
(GPM) (GPM)
and and
wetting. wetting.
to to and/or and/or
of of
to to
propellant propellant
and and
2 2
different different
. .
out. out.
as as
the the
give give
position position
to to
gas gas
interface interface
is is
liquid liquid
This This
by by
that that
thermal thermal
applicable applicable
be be
small
(PMD) (PMD)
provided provided
all all
liquid liquid
Figure Figure
tank tank
in in
spacecraft spacecraft
tanks.
was was
different different
a a
the the
created created
sloshing sloshing
the the
can can
results results
complete complete
surfaces surfaces
, ,
and and
in in
developed developed
parts parts
with with
liquid-gas liquid-gas
the the
i
Surface Surface
is is
s s
2
when when
tank. tank.
capacitance capacitance
is is
2 2
'
be be
7 7 the the
important important
important important
by by
Astronautics Astronautics
used used
shows shows
The The
to to
solid solid
in in
academic, academic,
in in
that that
stopped stopped has
a a
used used
labeled. labeled.
tank, tank,
through through
propellant propellant
Ken Ken
a a
a a
view view
slightly slightly
energies energies
propellant propellant
Evolver Evolver
unintuitive unintuitive
to to
simulation simulation
surface surface
have have
the the
interface interface
by by
Brakke. Brakke.
to to
orient orient
contact contact
of of for for
models models
for for
Ken Ken
GPM GPM
model model
the the
government, government,
large large
how how
simplified simplified
identifying identifying
tank tank for for
only only
is is
(or (or
attitude attitude
the the
liquid liquid
Brakke, Brakke,
tank
angle angle
and and
is is
tank tank
to to considered
liquid/gas liquid/gas
propellant propellant
Several Several
thrusters thrusters
nearly nearly
the the
propellant propellant
to to
the the
and and
begun. begun.
models models
. .
liquid liquid
gauge gauge
volume volume
liquid liquid
and and
The The
be
vanes, vanes,
PMD PMD
steady-state steady-state
Bottom Bottom
control, control,
circa circa
version version
so). so).
t
and and
i
ween ween
good good
f f
PMD PMD
liquid/gas liquid/gas
that that
Physically, Physically,
the the
center center
the the
will will
tanks tanks
propellant propellant
interface interface
outlet outlet
design.
at at
private private
1991, 1991,
sump, sump,
be be
liquid liquid
can can
the the review review
outlet outlet
the the
reservo
especially especially
with with
of of
behave behave
of of
wetting. wetting.
can can
exert exert liquid liquid
exit exit
liquid-gas liquid-gas
the the
9
as as
"
mass mass
entities
the the
interface interface
and and
1
surface, surface,
areas areas
2 2
include include
this this shapes, shapes,
part part
papers papers
during during
i
of of
GPM GPM
r r
axes axes
after after
large large
and and
for for
the the
A A
for for
is is
of of
of of
. ' '
tensions tensions
dry dry
paper paper of of
how how
solid-gas solid-gas the the
brief brief
surface surface
modeled modeled
B. B.
z-direction, z-direction,
direction direction
forces forces
positive positive
back. back.
this this
or or
left, left, the the direction. direction.
the the
gravity, gravity,
force. force.
acceleration acceleration becomes becomes
body body
is is
is is
than than
number number
acceleration. acceleration.
force. force.
tension tension
relative relative
term term
(Bo) (Bo)
this this
The The
much much
Surface Surface
surface surface
Surface Surface
results results
The The
Low-Gravity Low-Gravity
The The
rotating rotating
acceleration acceleration
spacecraft spacecraft
energy energy
The The
the the
paper paper
review review
the the
right, right,
1, 1,
Up Up
used used
is is
relation relation
dominating dominating
If If
in in energy
tension tension
in in
directions directions
y-direction, y-direction,
absence absence
the the
a a
by by but but
term term
greater greater
along along
tension, tension, surface
the the
effect effect
is is
is is
presented presented
Eq. Eq.
dominant dominant
area, area,
non-dimensional non-dimensional
and and
tension tension
Bond Bond
tension tension
per per
are are
to to
the the
surface surface
right right
looking looking only
The The
in in
of of
forward, forward,
much much
in in
in in
Bond Bond
on on
surface surface
If If
(1) (1)
compare compare
the the accelerating accelerating
relate relate
acceleration acceleration
that that surface surface the the
the the
Aa., Aa.,
up, up,
space space
a a
than than
of of
caused caused
of of
a a
the the
dominant dominant
Fluid Fluid
is is
a a
by by
earth earth
used used
positive positive
propellant propellant
specific specific
same same
fluid fluid
is is
is is
equations equations
number number
number number
smaller smaller
tension tension
sometimes sometimes
significant significant
surface surface
wetted wetted
and and
in in
down, down,
in in
in in
the the
1, 1,
Bond Bond
measured measured an an
tension tension
body body
body body
fluid fluid
it it
this this
and and
area area
the the
for for a a
the the
Theory Theory
the the
by by
forward forward
axis. axis.
interaction interaction
is is
flow flow
surface surface
at at
physical physical is is
"'sp "'sp
paper. paper.
surface surface
Jlm
tension. tension. surface
tank tank
and and
will will
for for
this this (low (low
Figure Figure
American American
body body
the the
2 2
in in
is is is is
area area
calculating calculating
a a
451nchas 451nchas
be be
problem problem
system system
N
paper. paper.
equivalent equivalent
in in
area, area,
various various
liquid-gas liquid-gas
between between
Bond Bond
/
used. used.
m m accelerations accelerations
the the
with with
2. 2.
in in
Aw
GPM GPM
positive positive
Institute Institute
when when
number). number).
which which
SI SI
J
due due
surface surface
• •
Because Because
and and
the the
different different
units units
to to
Yso
surface surface
to to
the the
Tank Tank
Nlm Nlm
energy energy
free free
x-direction, x-direction,
each each
surface surface
-
of of
during during
contact contact
and and
tensions tensions
Yts Yts
surface surface
Aeronautics Aeronautics
where where
surface surface
The The
--
I I
tension, tension,
states states
and and
surface surface
/ /
can can
3 3
-
= =
associated associated
/ /
tension, tension,
·
- much much
lack lack
angle, angle,
Y111 Y111
PMD PMD
J J
be be
tension tension
of of
are are
area, area,
-· -·
is is
with with
"/t
tension tension
cos() cos()
considered considered
matter. matter.
Joules, Joules, of of
go go
_.._.. _.._..
referred referred
of of
and and B, B,
Er. Er.
showing tank tank showing
the the
Aft. Aft.
X X
Equation Equation body body
with with
is is
the the
dominates dominates
Astronautics Astronautics ------!•y ------!•y
can can
....
......
known. known.
opposites opposites
is is
..; ..; Equation Equation
; ; I I
. .
There There
m m
_ _
spacecraft spacecraft
surface surface
. .
associated. associated.
accelerations accelerations
to to
be be
·
is is
-
-
an an
-
·
meters, meters,
as as
---
represented represented
(1)
is is
-· -·
energy energy
the the
surface surface
1
(3) (3)
,..,.-
a a
of of
3 3
tension tension
-
dimensions dimensions
liquid-solid liquid-solid
shows shows
-
these these
fluid fluid
flight flight
shows shows
and and
The The
· ·
-
./ ./ density. density.
I I
allows allows
energies; energies;
v v
N N
I I
behavior behavior
by by is is
terms terms
different different
how how
results results
the the
is is
beneficial beneficial
multiplying multiplying
newtons. newtons.
the the
final final
surface surface
the the
being being
and and
Equation Equation
in in
however
Tank Tank
in in
different different
surface surface
propellant propellant
the the
axes axes
surface surface
this this
in in
to to
tension, tension,
result. result.
It It
domes domes
the the
the the
understand understand
problem, problem,
is is
(2) (2)
used used
areas areas
, ,
types types
opposite opposite
because because
for for
surface surface
tension tension
shows shows
to to
Yu• Yu•
th
in in
(3) (3)
are are
(2) (2)
(1) (1)
of of
be be
i
s s
a a a a
calculation calculation
ex
to to
in in
s
angles
for for
cylinders
calculated calculated
area area
explicitly explicitly
the the
important important
contain contain
bubble bubble
Since Since
which which dry dry
bubble bubble calculates calculates
tank tank
bubble bubble
bubble bubble surface surface dry
there there as as
area area
contact contact
calculate calculate
C. C.
is is
As As
zero zero
imple imple
The The
ignored ignored
wc;tted wc;tted
sh•>wn sh•>wn
a
· ·
this this
calculate calculate
in in used
mple mple
The The
total total
the the
In In with with
Surface Surface
Method Method
By By
By By
By By
has has
surface surface
non-zero non-zero
degree degree
surface surface
is is
. .
needs needs
Eq. Eq.
paper paper
the the are are
The The
wall, wall,
shapes
touches
rearranging rearranging
free free
substituting substituting
noting noting
in in
facet, facet,
no no
surface surface
is is
energy. energy.
of of
, ,
are are
when when
this this
Eq. Eq.
wetted wetted
angle, angle,
the the
the the
within within
to to
for for
Eq
the the
and and (5) (5)
not not
for for
need need
a a
case case
modeled. modeled.
of of
wetted wetted
Evolver Evolver
the the
area. area.
contact contact
since since
sphere sphere for for
surface surface
find find
(5), (5),
same same
. .
wetted wetted
considered considered
tensions tensions
area. area.
the the
, ,
to to quantity quantity
the the
does does (4). (4).
surface surface
touched touched
and and
the the
that that
doing doing
, ,
Surface Surface
hemispheres, hemispheres,
such such
total total
area area
or or
to to
of of
Calculating Calculating
degree degree
the the
Surface Surface
the the
or or
the the
cases cases
Instead, Instead,
be be
Eq. Eq.
wetted wetted
surface surface
calculation calculation program program
energy energy
the the
"dries "dries
terms terms
therefore, therefore,
a a
Eq. Eq.
not not
can can
All All
angle. angle.
or or
automatically automatically
in in
surface surface
dry dry
an an
energy energy
area area
energy. energy.
dry dry
as as
zero zero
area area
and and
(6) (6)
total total
calculated calculated
dry dry
When When
by by
Eq
presented presented
be be
it it (1) (1)
explicitly explicitly
energy energy
spheres, spheres,
Evolver Evolver
surfaces surfaces
in in
Evolver Evolver
out" out"
contact contact
surface surface
wetted. wetted.
is is
. .
the the
area area
density density
surface surface
and and area area
is is
the the
This This
found found
degree degree
surface surface
total total
and and
(3) (3)
of of
surface surface
in in
Eq
minimum minimum
used used
tensions tensions
Surface Surface
For For
the the
not not
gas gas
the the
the the
the the
the the
the the
air air
. .
with with
of of
so so
is is
Eq. Eq.
minimization. minimization.
American American
through through
is is
(4), (4),
surface surface
in in
because because
calculates calculates
area. area.
area, area, (4) (4)
the the
a a
and and
about about
Figure Figure
and and
term term
Er Er Energies Energies
in in
into into
Surface Surface
then then
a a
Ar, Ar,
area area
Surface Surface
= =
which which
Axis Axis
rotated
total total
Polylines Polylines
Institute Institute
At~.r At~.r
line line
involving involving
Eq. Eq.
which which
-Aw
of of
3
the the
plugging plugging
of of
Equation Equation
. .
gives gives
area area
the the
about about
(3) (3)
Evolver Evolver
integral integral
Polylines Polylines
free free
the the
s
Evolver. Evolver.
the the
Aws Aws
Yia Yia
tank tank
. .
the the
of of
and and
are are
the the
tank tank
surface surface
are are
the the
Aeronautics Aeronautics
cos cos
= =
the the
polylines polylines
rearranging rearranging
constant constant
same same
(5) (5)
is is
manual.
along along
4 4
total total
Ar-
0 0
a a
are are
result result
that that
is is
constant, constant,
+ +
~
~""·=-=-=-=---
area, area,
~----~ ~----~
contribution contribution
the the
surface surface
constants, constants,
ArsYia ArsYia
the the
Ads Ads
make make
and and
1 1
into into
are are
equation equation
and and
and and
tenns, tenns,
three three
.
so so
· ·
Eq. Eq.
rotated rotated
we we
+ +
area
Astronautic
.
with with
=-~---...... , =-~---...... ,
up up
the the
. .
ArYsa ArYsa
can can
;1:(~
(3), (3),
phase phase
so so
Eq
as as
. .
used used
term, term,
the the
some some
The The
the the
replace replace
Aft Aft
. .
Eq. Eq.
to to
(5) (5)
GPM GPM
in in
create create
due due boundary boundary
between between relation
:
term
-~~·::
At}'$0> At}'$0>
(6}is (6}is
is is
~-
user user
s s
Surface Surface
,.~ ,.~
obtained. obtained.
:
. .
~ ~
to to
~}
either either
:' :'
, ,
. .
·
programming, programming,
AtY
tank tank
.
the the ~ ~
~
obtained. obtained.
GPM GPM
is is
:
'•
:
~
~
j j
l l
< <
) )
ignored ignored
~s
is is
cosine cosine
Evolver Evolver
the the
, ,
outline outline
in in
tank tank s
traight traight
dry dry
this this
term term
the the
Polylines Polylines
when when
surface surface
surface. surface.
when when
problem problem
and and
can can
surface surface
forward. forward.
equaling equaling
Equation Equation
modeling modeling
be be
axis axis
area area
made made
areas areas
can can
or or
The The
one. one.
(6) (6)
(6) (6)
(5
the the
(4) (4)
be be
to to
is is
a a ) )
sphe
shown shown
1, 1,
respectively. respectively.
can can
sphere, sphere,
wall. wall.
coordinate coordinate
shown shown
in in
reasonably reasonably
down down
Sutface Sutface
4it, 4it,
Equations Equations
Step Step
the the
r
be be
To To
GPM GPM
e
Figure Figure
Note
is is
, ,
in in
respectively. respectively.
the the
revolved revolved
which which
Axis Axis
curve curve
done done
but but
GPM GPM
found. found.
a) a)
in in
illustrate illustrate
1 1
Evolver Evolver
Fig. Fig.
: :
the the
involves involves
center center
about about
uses uses
this this
for for
system system
Is Is
simple
4. 4.
the the
through through
tank tank
(8) (8)
4. 4.
Surface Surface
demonstration demonstration
Drawing Drawing
step step
a a
Sareabott Sareabott
of of
and and
by by
the the
cylindrical cylindrical
due due
, ,
at at
the the calculating calculating
the the
When When
can can
seven seven
the the
Eq. Eq.
(9) (9)
method method
Evolver Evolver
to to
tank. tank.
example example
be be
and and
showing showing
center center
the the
are are
(7)
the the
ignored ignored
curves curves
Sareat
1 1
simplicity simplicity
the the
The The
purposes purposes
tank tank
top top
manual, manual,
used used
American American
the the
where where
of of
of of
o
result result
polylines polylines
p p
and and
the the
the the
that that
with with
if if
a a
surface surface
are are
to to
sphere sphere
an an
tank. tank.
bottom bottom
a) a)
a a
it it
make make
we we calculate calculate
the the
when when
of of
equation equation
and and isotensoid isotensoid
curve curve
provides provides
Institute Institute
its its
will will
area area
surface surface
and and
is is
The The
b b
up up
areas areas
shape. shape.
used. used.
combining combining
are are
which which
show show
rotation rotation
of of
sphere sphere
a a
the the
already already
of of
a a
polyline. polyline.
the the
a a
domes. domes.
are are
areas areas
good good
Even Even
Aeronautics Aeronautics
wetted wetted
revolve revolve
the the
The The
is is
summed summed
lower lower
has has
5 5
axis axis
revolved revolved
exists exists
step step
for for
example example
Equation Equation
though though
sphere sphere
a a
The The
This This
are are
energy energy
the the
radius radius
of of
and and
here. here.
for for
b) b)
the the
shown shown
shape shape
the the
bottom bottom
and and polyline polyline
the the
is is
and and
of of
upper upper
the the
(7) (7)
known known
of of
Calculating Calculating
shown shown
polyline polyline
of of
the the
sphere's sphere's
Astronautics Astronautics
surface surface
1 1
the the
of of
in in
and and
~ ~
the the
method method half half
integration integration
Figure Figure
is is
the the
surface surface
b) b)
in in
the the
tank tank
then then
that that
of of
wetted wetted Figure Figure
isotensoid isotensoid
resulting resulting
area area
equation equation
the the
the the
3
used used
revolved revolved
wall
describes describes
. .
area area
of of
surface surface
sphere sphere
limits limits
4 4
surface surface
the the
, ,
to to
below below
of of
and and
sphere. sphere.
fmd fmd
tank tank
for for
domes domes
a a
around around
along along
and and
area, area,
sphere sphere
the the
to to
the the
area area
the the
shape, shape,
with with
keep keep
the the
outline outline
is is
outline outline
wetted wetted
Sana• Sana•
the the
can can
the the
with with
described described
the the
top top
such such
the the
revolve revolve
be be
axis axis
of of
origin origin
of of
half half
a a
surface surface
of of
obtained obtained
illustration illustration
a a
radius radius
as as
the the
revolve revolve that that
the the
of of
with with
within within
axis, axis,
of of
tank tank
(9) (9)
(8) (8)
the the
arc arc
(7) (7)
area area runs runs
of of
the the
a a as as
boundary. boundary.
part part
and and
sphere sphere bottom bottom
together. together.
Lief
differential differential
and and
information information
differential differential
what what
function function
can can
equations equations
previous previous
pool pool
top top
and and
top) top)
(top (top
currently currently
direction direction
when when
var along along
the the
distance distance
Surface Surface
Step Step
i
y y
Both Both
of of
· ·
top
integrate
height height
Step Step
able, able,
of of
Step Step
to to
Equations Equations
would would
would would
(16) (16)
directions. directions.
the the
the the
in in
has has the the
and and
the the
bottom) bottom)
. .
of of
These These
the the
3 3
equations equations
a
2 2
h. h.
4 4
It It liquid liquid
sphere sphere
three three
l
tank tank
measured measured
that that
Evolver Evolver
to to
ong ong
tank, tank,
arc arc differential
requires requires
surface surface
top top
requires requires
from from
show show
have have
Equations Equations
will will
been been
area, area,
need need
. .
x-direction, x-direction,
above above
involves involves
which which
Figure Figure
integrated integrated
equations equations
the the
wall
for for
(13), (13),
climb climb
then then
Surface Surface
Llsabo
steps steps in in
and and
a a
to to
.dsa, .dsa,
rotation rotation
area, area,
how how
which which
unique unique
the the are are
done done
the the
will will
the the
an an
. .
the the
will will
5 5
add add
be be
This This
hence
(bottom (bottom
n
height height
(11) (11)
(14), (15), (15), (14),
.Llsa
y-dlrection. y-dlrection.
.Lls~opdy .Lls~opdy
tb: tb:
valid valid
pool pool
combining combining equation equation
shows shows
liquid liquid
to to
defining defining
.dsa, .dsa,
solve solve
Llsa
switched switched
for for
give give
up up
is is
all all
Evolver Evolver
in in
be be
in in
to
bottom bottom
length, length,
step step
and and
axis. axis.
, ,
create create
for for
h h
the the
at at
bo
pdx pdx
.Llsabottdy .Llsabottdy
the the
at at
is is
each each
as as
Llsab
climbs climbs
11
put put
the the
the the
the the
the the
the the
American American
the the
the the
o
(12) (12)
below below h h
mdy mdy
involves involves
the the
to to
x x
results results
is is that that
a a
For For
= =
= =
of of
= =
o
equations equations
(xZ~y
is is
(
0. 0.
bottom bottom
ttdx ttdx
are are
an an
x
the the
up up
allows allows
Z+
Figure Figure
for for
-x -x
the the
It It
to to
equation equation
yZ)(1-
= =
the the
the the
purposes purposes
2) 2)
= =
is is
modifying modifying
the the
Institute Institute
z=O z=O
(xZ+y
give give
..j(1-
~ ~
( (
important important
resulting resulting
part part
X X
wall. wall.
the the
-x -x
2
bottom bottom
cf cf
5. 5.
for for
+y +y
Y Y
plane plane
the the
·······
2)
Figure Figure
2) 2)
calculation calculation
= =
of of
that that
~ ~
Equation Equation
each each
h)(1 h)(1
of of
· · of of
h)(1 h)(1
.J .J
final final
2Tr..j(1-
(1
the the
or or
(1 (1
Eq. Eq.
this this
part part
Aeronautics Aeronautics
equations equations
gives gives
to to
-
above above
+h) +h)
edge edge
-
sphere sphere
+h) +h)
wetted wetted
showing showing
6 6
note note
h)(1 h)(1
(8) (8)
study study
of of
h)(1 h)(1
(10) (10)
the the
of of
the the
c~ c~
and and
that that
ct ct
z=O z=O
h)(1 h)(1
that that
1 1
+h) +h)
in in
+h) +h)
* *
the the
the the
where where
surface surface
(Sareatapfunc (Sareatapfunc
local local
shows shows
sphere sphere
(Sareatopfunc (Sareatopfunc
.Asa .Asa
(9) (9)
respectively. respectively. plane,
and and the the
makes makes
if if
+h) +h)
distance distance
surface surface
c
1 1
C C f f
there there
1
1 1
so so
circumference, circumference,
x-direction, x-direction,
and and
Astronautics Astronautics
(Sareabot
Sanabotrfim
the the
(Sareabottom) (Sareabottom)
area. area.
in in
that that
up up
they-direction, they-direction,
are are
.Acf .Acf
local local
area area
along along
the the
the the
In In
+ +
two two
for for
c c
t
+ +
fun
practice practice
circumference circumference
given given
and and
Sa
curve curve
definite definite
Sareabott) Sareabott)
Ll the the
the the
r
separate separate
c
s
eabatt) eabatt)
) )
Sa
a
cf, cf,
rotation rotation
,
0
sphere. sphere.
ro
different different
ptb: ptb:
that that
atopfimc atopfimc
the the
of of
integral integral
and and
is is
the the
pools pools
surface surface
marks marks
for for
are are
axis, axis,
Llsa
equation equation
tank tank
liquid liquid
the the
of of
the the
1
involves involves
0
the
pc~y pc~y
h, h,
area area
top top
as as
liquid, liquid,
equations equations
corresponds corresponds
. .
is is
climb climb
three three
a a
for for
is is
part part
for for
function function
a a
the the
a a
then then
the the
means means
phase phase
sphere. sphere.
of of
heights heights
X X
(16
(15) (15)
(14) (14)
(13) (13)
extra extra
used used
(12) (12)
top top
the the
(11) (11)
(10) (10)
the the
) )
to to of of
buboles
liquid liquid
design design
diff~rent diff~rent
A. A. a a
keeping keeping
value value
The The
and/or and/or
mass. mass.
user user
By By
propellant. propellant.
k, k,
simplified simplified
the the
mathematically mathematically
shows shows
it it
Surface Surface
D. D.
ccsine ccsine
of of
zero zero
can can
Figure Figure
Zero Zero
The The
For For
differential differential
obtaining obtaining The The
A A
dividing dividing
Starting Starting
correct correct
For For exception exception
Method Method
inputted inputted
.. ..
for for
propellant propellant
degree degree
The The
comparison comparison
be be
cm
. .
the the
the the
first first
of of
the the
process process
The The
regions regions
Degree Degree
spacecraft spacecraft
z
the the
shown shown
Evolver Evolver
6 6
, ,
the the resulting resulting
above above
equation equation
version version
number number
respectively
way way
set set shows shows
with with
liquid liquid
out out
contact contact
for for
the the
center center value value
contact contact
to to
of of
area, area,
shown shown
to to
of of
V V
rigorous rigorous Contact Contact
how how
is is
Calculating Calculating
surface surface
this this
the the
equations equations
results results
ofEq
from from
compute compute
propellant propellant
the the
can can
the the
varied varied
maneuvers, maneuvers,
of of
in in
of of
equations equations
of of
for for
angle angle
dA, dA,
equation equation
to to
rule rule
angle angle
Surface Surface
Eq. Eq.
faces faces
fmal fmal
tank. tank.
above above
mass
. .
easily easily
. . calculating calculating
the the
program program
In In
energy. energy.
(17) (17)
assumes assumes
derivation derivation
Angle Angle
gravity gravity
is is
to to
with with
17 17
in in
these these
integral integral
the the
to to
to to
for for solution
, ,
when when
The The
show show
is is
the the is is
however, however,
that that are are
and and
radians radians Evolver. Evolver.
used used
a a
work, work,
American American
compute compute
it it
center center
hydrazine. hydrazine.
wherever wherever
repeated repeated
minimum, minimum,
Results Results
To To
Surface Surface
initial initial
Eq. Eq.
acceleration, acceleration, Center Center
cases cases
is is
Eq. Eq.
design design
a a
includes includes
how how
to to
gravitational gravitational
in in
convert convert
essential essential
tank tank
of of
the the
(20) (20)
as as
calculate calculate
(18). (18).
of of
Eq. Eq.
Equation Equation
the the
the the
propellant propellant
the the
m. m.
the the
the the
explained explained
mass mass
to to the the
Evolver Evolver
entire entire
wall wall
conditions conditions
of of
the the
Institute Institute
and and
(17), (17),
The The
so so
method method
walls walls
obtain obtain
rest rest
the the
shows shows
Eq
Mass Mass
hydraziDe hydraziDe
zero zero
bubble bubble to to
center center
Results Results
keeping keeping
Eq. Eq.
is is
within within
E E
. .
G, G,
approximate approximate
the the
z-component z-component
liquid liquid
E E
an an
know know
(13), (14), (14), (13),
of of
potential potential
a a (19) (19)
= =
at at
degree degree
to to
of of
= =
(21) (21)
and and
the the
flat flat
positions positions that that
in in
expression expression
potential potential
the the
used, used,
G(p) G(p)
the the
find find
for for
is is
G(p)(V)(cmz) G(p)(V)(cmz)
Aeronautics Aeronautics
of of
Section Section
Surface Surface
is is
x-component, x-component,
surface surface
the the
as as
surface surface
not. not.
density, density,
prope11ant prope11ant
walls walls
an an
with with
the the
the the
zero zero
the the
7 7
mass mass
the the ff ff
contact contact
many many
but but
energy, energy,
center center
Discussion Discussion
(15), (15),
resulting resulting
propellant propellant
:!.z
2 2
GPM GPM
the the
assumed assumed
fill fill
energy energy
center center
plane plane
should should
will will
of of
B. B.
Evolver. Evolver.
must must
can can
2
the the at
walls walls
of of
p, p,
k k
unit unit
fraction fraction
and and
the the
angle angle
of of
· ·
and and
tank tank
present present would would
E
be be
are are
dA dA
the the
can can
of of
be be
, ,
due due
mass mass
center center
vectors vectors
(16) (16)
cmx, cmx,
x x
equation
be be
unfacetted unfacetted
over over
obtained obtained
that that
Astronautics Astronautics
mass mass
volume volume
included included
= =
facetted, facetted,
at at
cases. cases.
propellant. propellant.
remain remain
facetted. facetted.
to to
at at
behave behave
0, 0,
into into
launch. launch.
and and
the the
of of
the the
a a
gravity gravity
launch launch
of of
y y
location location
in in
facet. facet.
the the
. .
they-component, they-component,
= =
energy energy
author's author's
PMD PMD
mass, mass,
is is
the the
white white The
for for
unfacetted unfacetted
0; 0;
in in
the the including
as as
included included
propellant propellant
if if
GPM's GPM's
The The
is is
x-direction, x-direction,
within within
cmz. cmz. The The
and/or and/or
possible possible
Eq, Eq,
the the
This This
would would
of of
70%. 70%.
cmz, cmz,
equations, equations,
simulation simulation
methodology methodology
the the
It It unit unit
(17). (17).
launch launch
tank tank
Surface Surface
bu!>bles bu!>bles should should
paper
z z
and and
in in
The The
and and
propellant. propellant.
have have
= =
is is
vector vector
within within
the the
Equation Equation
0 0
recommended. recommended.
liquid-solid liquid-solid
was was
t, t,
the the
initial initial
sti11 sti11
pushed pushed
. .
cmyo cmyo
planes planes
multiply multiply
filled filled
integral integral
and and
will will
be be
will will
Evolver, Evolver,
represent represent
volume
designed designed
in in
a a
give give
noted noted
of of
propellant propellant
position position
for for
y-direction, y-direction,
the the
not not
up, up,
run run
the the
for for Equation Equation
(18) (18)
the the
an an
determining determining
in in
them them
z-direction, z-direction,
, ,
that that
as as
interface. interface.
cmx, cmx,
liquid liquid faster faster
present present
Eq. Eq.
center center
Eq. Eq.
accurate accurate
V
to to the the
shows shows
, ,
per per
of of
of of
by by
have have
Vis Vis
(17i, (17i,
(17). (17).
cm
(21) (21)
tank. tank. (20) (20)
(19) (19)
gas gas
(18) (18)
(17) (17)
the the
(17) (17)
its its
by by
j. j.
to to
the the
the the
of of
y, y,
a a
a a a a
the the
the the
tank
and and
propellant. propellant.
fractions, fractions,
The The
B. B.
expected, expected, mass mass
we we
numerically numerically
center center
the the
because because
around around
so
flight
acceleration acceleration
total total
around around
where where
the the
where where
does does
and and
completely completely
cases cases
dried dried
l
ution ution
top top
The The
Figure Figure
Degree Degree Non-zero
darker darker
cases cases
nositions nositions
The The
bubble bubble
. .
wall, wall,
The The
dark dark
where where
the the
see see
a) a)
:omplataly :omplataly
not not
The The
energy energy
, ,
is is
g) g)
Cantered Cantered
where where
post. post.
the the
or or the the
Center Center
part part
Front Front
out. out.
offset offset
the the
results results
third third
position position
the the
initial initial
completely completely
area area
is is
bottom bottom in in
contact contact
any any
at at
fill fill
gives gives
areas areas
second second
bubble bubble
the the
Figure Figure
6. 6.
away away
the the
center center
of of
confirm confirm
more more
the the is is
a a
would would
(see (see
Fig. Fig.
center center fractions fractions
Fourth, Fourth,
more more
set set
Liquid-gas Liquid-gas
represents represents
the the
position position
gas gas
in in fill fill
similar similar
sigruficant sigruficant
center center
within within
a a
Half·Center Half·Center
h) h)
bubble bubble
b) b)
from from
liquid liquid
wrapped wrapped
angles, angles,
of of
of of
label label
solution solution
Table Table
7 7
post. post.
touches touches
type type
Right Right
bubble bubble
wall wall
6. 6.
fraction fraction
Centered Centered
likely, likely,
from from
shows shows
\·, \·,
results results
what what
the the
wrap wrap
pus
post, post,
Top Top
Contact Contact
the the
the the
are are
As As
the the
for for
of of
above above
results results
pools. pools.
of of
In In
is is
is is
h h
1 1
the the and and
propellant propellant
the the
interface interface
varied varied
the the
shaded shaded
i) i)
examines examines
center center Off-c:e Off-c:e
of of
Half..Rlsht Half..Rlsht
liquid liquid
initial initial
Table Table
angle angle
each each
c:) c:)
results results
Angle Angle
shown shown
' '
approximately approximately Bottom Bottom
American American
' '
between between
nter nter
. .
-· -·
area area
-$ -$
of of
.
position. position.
positions. positions.
subfillure subfillure
( (
changes. changes.
cases cases
results results
1. 1.
......
with with
with with
the the
in in
the the
show show
Fig. Fig.
Center Center
d) d)
j) j)
tank tank
Institute Institute
at at
3% 3%
the the
liquid liquid
PMD PMD
Half-Top Half-Top
Risht Risht
for for
Right Right
Top Top
The The
a a
6 6
where where
Throughout Throughout
The The
liquid liquid
if if
for for
and and
fill fill
give give
zero zero
70o/o 70o/o
the the
of of
propellant propellant
faces faces
the the
fraction fraction
70% 70%
contact contact
of of
the the
some some
bubble bubble
mass mass
initial initial
k
e) e)
degree degree
Aeron
) )
initial initial
with with
HalfBack HalfBack
that that
air air
-1
-0.03 -0.03
and and
-1.17 -1.17
Bottom Bottom -2.69 -2.69
0.01 0.01
3.64 3.64
3.63 3.63
016 016
2.48 2.48
& &
Back Back
interesting interesting
0 0
. 0 0
spacecraft spacecraft
56 56
(CM) (CM)
bubble bubble
position position
of of
angle angle
is is
; ;
varying varying
break break
a
the the
behavior behavior
nosition). nosition).
utics utics
contact contact
not not
approximately approximately
I) I) contact contact
wrapped wrapped
results results
changes changes
up up
and and
goes goes
f) f)
Canter Canter
Half· Half·
being being
operation, operation,
insight insight
initial initial
Left Left
Back Back
·3.58 ·3.58
-3 -3
.
-3 -3
-248 -248
the the
angle angle
0.05 0.05
1.01 1.01
0
2.63 2.63
in in
: :
Astronautics Astronautics
.
0 0
0 0
0 0
98 98
Top Top
below below
75 75
36 36
angle angle
the the
liquid-gas liquid-gas
in in
almost almost
around around
when when
into into
inches inches
GPM GPM
70o/o 70o/o
is is
the the
free free
total total
surface surface
shows shows
can can
surface surface
wetting wetting
the the This This
it it
combination combination
the the
bubble bubble
dry dry
surfaces. surfaces. initial initial resulting resulting
some some
initial initial b~bble b~bble
will will
center center
varied varied
the the
equal equal
will will
contamination contamination
top top
the the
fill fill
be be
with with
-0
-o.03 -o.03
-0.09 -0.09
out out
-0 -0
tank tank
interface interface -2.07 -2.07
not not
0.02 0.02
1.73 1.73
0
2
assumption assumption
fluid fluid
surface surface
(in) (in)
third third
energy energy
.
.
0 0
.
center center
dry dry
01 01
17 17
most most
of of
40 40
found found
09 09
fraction fraction
that that
position. position.
position position
touches touches
on on
between between
area, area,
of of
liquid liquid
automatically automatically
the the
tends tends
area
varying varying
and and
The The
bubble bubble
the the
for for
out out
behavior. behavior.
the the
observation observation
part part
the the
PMD PMD
it it
of of
post. post.
, ,
in in
that that
are are
area, area,
in in
PMD PMD
part part a
top top
zero zero
vane. vane.
CM CM
will will
in in
is is
explanation explanation
to to
Eq. Eq.
dry dry
but but
the the
of of
l l
tank. tank.
has has enters enters
the the transparent transparent
Second, Second,
the the
0 0
position position
initial initial
and and
not not
contributes contributes
that that
Magn
vanes, vanes,
the the
remain remain
wet wet
(5). (5).
deg deg
surface surface
wall wall
degree degree
found found
of of First, First,
for for
also also
3 3
3
3
3.75 3.75
tank tank 3.n 3.n
3
3.07 3.07
2
2
0.01 0.01 2
2
problem. problem.
it it
bottom bottom
go go
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
only only
the the
Third, Third,
liquid liquid
79 79
n n
69 69
82 82
02 02
07 07
63 63
17 17
goes goes
Equation Equation
Instead, Instead,
i
the the
and and
all all
a a
varying varying
t\rr.le t\rr.le
positions; positions;
drying drying
of of
back back
even even
the the
decreases decreases
tank tank
the the
the the
perfectly perfectly
does does in in
the the
area area
near near
the the
tank tank
60 60
contact contact
for for
the the
and and
against against
within within
{in) {in)
bubble bubble
of of
to to
if if
to to cases cases
wall. wall.
solid solid
deg. deg.
if if
final final
tank tank
The The
free free
the the
this this
and and
dry dry
fill fill
the the
out out
not not
the the
the the
the the
(5) (5)
so so
or or
its its its its
microgravity microgravity
drop-towers, drop-towers,
face face
surfaces surfaces
liqu Evolver. Evolver.
fraction
as as
liquid liquid
propellant propellant
cemer cemer
tank. tank.
the the
initialized initialized
the the
PlviD PlviD tank, tank,
ability ability
the the
propellant propellant
more more
initializing initializing
center center
hence hence
location location
of of These These
interface interface
chmge chmge
three-phase three-phase
contact contact
occurs occurs
region region
wall wall
increases, increases,
fill fill
Second, Second,
vanes vanes
area area
wetted wetted
increases, increases,
trends
the the
interesting interesting
show show
GPM's GPM's
Physical Physical
F
i
Surface Surface
Understanding Understanding Figure Figure
the the
d d
initializing initializing
outlet outlet
By By
uture uture
top top
liquid liquid contact contact The The
Table Table
propellant propellant
propellant. propellant.
of of
on on
to to
, ,
of of
. .
liquid liquid
in in
of of
decreases
behaviors behaviors
position position
the the
The The
in in
and and
mass mass
of of
changes. changes.
of of liquid liquid
move move
First, First,
mass. mass.
both both
work work
PMD PMD
tanks
fraction fraction
at at the the
of of
8 8
as as
Evolver Evolver surface surface
2 2
the the
which which
experiments experiments
the the
with with
the the results results
shape shape
the the
shows shows
experiments experiments
the the
to to
angle angle
liquid-gas liquid-gas
at at
shows shows
the the
tank tank
tank, tank, and and
line line
gas gas
and and
the the
two two
the the
the the
techniques
the the
the the
. .
in in
and and
top top
as as
and and
of of
Surface Surface
sub-orbital sub-orbital
The The
tank tank
. .
this this
the the
how how
that that
fraction fraction
Table Table
but but
the the
can can
numerically numerically
of of
propellant propellant
the the
-
and and
1) 1)
varying varying
10 10
deg, deg,
distributed distributed
results results
interface interface
Figure Figure
liquid-gas liquid-gas
:
the the
can can
area area
'T''T' 'T''T'
~~~~~ ~~~~~
liquid liquid
may may m) m)
as as
be be
interface interface
a) a)
60 60
liquid liquid
solid solid
are are
deg, deg,
-
tension tension
that that
. .
2. 2.
varying varying
the the
tank, tank,
c) c)
used used
be be
deg, deg,
This This
will will
not not
of of
flights, flights,
essential essential
in in
60 60
7. 7.
h) h) when when
Center Center
could could
contact contact walls walls
·-
studied. studied.
contact contact
approximately approximately
h) h)
American American
~
propellant propellant
tank, tank,
,
n) n)
··. ··.
this this
and and to to
-
wet wet
b) b)
include include
these these
will will
GPM GPM deg, deg,
30 30
m) m)
interface interface
and and
forces forces
case case
model model
between between
fill fill
thrusters thrusters
deg, deg,
and and
the the or or
all all
report report
10 10
validate validate
can can
.
enable enable
. .
d) d)
hence hence
angle angle
-
differences differences
to to
of of
fractions fractions
' -
on-orbit on-orbit
·
·-
. .
Figure Figure
the the
·
x angles, angles,
1) 1)
deg, deg,
contact contact
-
o) o)
cause cause
: :
c) c) vanes. vanes. 10 10
modifYing modifYing
results results
tank tank
i) i)
be be
showing showing '' ''
T T
mass mass
the the
Institute Institute
shape. shape.
behaves behaves
60 60
solid solid
show show
deg, deg,
increases, increases,
the the
higher higher
modeled modeled
top top
n) n)
·
(or (or
'. '.
liquid-gas liquid-gas
-
Surface Surface
IV. IV.
deg
the the .
:
·: 8 8
. . 20% 20%
As As
· ·
flights. flights.
where where
angle angle
and and (CM) (CM)
.
30 30
d) d)
center center ~~T ~~T
j) j)
(see (see surface surface
other other
e) e)
that that
CJ20% CJ20%
shows shows c:J c:J
CJ CJ
and and
, ,
with with in in
liquid liquid
of of
that that
the the
j) j) fidelity fidelity
30 30
deg, deg,
Conclusions Conclusions
Surface Surface
in in
center center
with with
Aeronautics Aeronautics
legend). legend).
Fill Fill
10 10
a a
varied varied
fo
Evolver Evolver
PMD PMD
deg, deg,
the the
acceleration) acceleration)
contact contact
bottom bottom
results results
of of
a) a)
a a
the the
complicated complicated
r r
Fraction Fraction
interface interface
the the 9 9
even even
and and
deg, deg,
k) k) propellant propellant
e) e)
fluid fluid
low-gravity low-gravity
both both
10%CJ 10%CJ
39' 39'
mass mass
10 10
varying varying
air air
results results
Surface Surface
of of
f) f)
Evolver's Evolver's
results results
11
from from
deg, deg,
o) o)
c:J c:J
bubble bubble
at at
k) k)
60 60 liquid-gas liquid-gas
mass mass
non-zero non-zero
Lapnd Lapnd
include include
angle angle
for for
.
61 61
of of
of of
zero zero
60 60
30 30 equally equally
......
I) I)
deg, deg,
f) f)
shape shape
and and
1 1
and and
the the
b) b)
initial initial
tank, tank,
non-
0 0
location. location.
Evolver Evolver
deg, deg,
to to
at at
deg, deg,
is is
PMD PMD
decreases decreases
are are results
degree degree
deg deg
30 30
40f 40f
Astronautics Astronautics
70'J 70'J
g) g)
environment environment
turned turned
liquid liquid
more more
wetted wetted
orient orient
a a
experiments experiments
and and
zero zero and
fill fill
zero zero
to to
positions. positions.
and and
-18.00 -18.00 tank tank
initialized initialized
deg, deg,
60 60
hence hence contact contact
fill fill
liquid-gas liquid-gas
stable stable 1059 1059 Figure Figure
models models
contact contact
fraction fraction
propellant propellant
a) a)
in in
off
energy energy
degree degree
the the non-standard non-standard
deg
unintuitive unintuitive
less less
, ,
fraction fraction
c) c)
than than
and and
contact contact
the the
simulations. simulations.
. .
liquid liquid
60 60
done done
is is
angle
. .
are are
centered centered
8. 8.
angles angles
of of
models models
the the
center center
contact contact
at at
important important
deg deg
interface interface
is is
toward toward
giving giving
20%, 20%,
will will
GPM GPM
the the
. .
on on
contact contact
angle angle
affected affected
b) b)
of of
ways
with with
tank tank
parabolic parabolic of of
of of
bottom bottom
about about
and and 690 690
U
wet wet
20% 20%
with with
angle angle
mass mass
c
cases cases
.
a) a)
, , 61 61
Tank Tank
orrect orrect
more more
the the
angle angle
case case
shaped shaped for for
thus thus
developing developing
more more
by by
10 10
the the
more more
and and
location location
of of
the the
using using
cases cases
the the
top top
changing changing
results results
flights, flights,
deg, deg,
results. results.
o) o)
center center
between between
propellant propellant
and and
of of
the the
tank, tank,
liquid liquid
propellant propellant
design design
varying varying
the the
of of
Surface Surface
tank. tank.
at at
b) b)
PMD PMD
better better
of of
of of
at at solid solid
with with
such such
the the
The The
a a
30 30
the the
the the
fill fill
the the
the the
a a
of of fill fill
No. No.
Vo
AIAA AIAA
Washington
41st 41st
A1AA A1AA
AIAA!ASMEISAFIASEE AIAA!ASMEISAFIASEE
Aerospace Aerospace
Conforence, Conforence, AIAAIASMEISAEIASEEJoint AIAAIASMEISAEIASEEJoint
AIAAIASMEISAEIASEEJoint AIAAIASMEISAEIASEEJoint
http:
the the
Program, Program,
l
. .
14 14
13
12 12
11
9
1
18, 18,
8
7
6
sWeislogel, sWeislogel,
°Chato, °Chato,
4
31,2012, 31,2012, Aerospace Aerospace
3
2 Brakke, Brakke,
Collicott, Collicott,
Rodriguez, Rodriguez,
1
research research
Collicott, Collicott,
Tadmor, Tadmor,
This This
// Aparicio, Aparicio,
Dominick, Dominick,
Collicott, Collicott,
Jaekle, Jaekle,
Stewart, Stewart, Surface Surface
Aerospace Aerospace
Li Aerospace Aerospace
www.susqu.edu/brakke/evolver/evolver.htm
2004, 2004,
, ,
J., J.,
Sciences Sciences
research research
, ,
as as
Chen, Chen,
D
DC, DC,
AIAA, AIAA,
K. K.
pp. pp.
D. D.
R, R,
J., J.,
pp
. .
S. S.
and and
well well
S. S.
A., A.,
S. S. Sciences Sciences
J
A., A.,
Sciences Sciences
E., E.,
M
. .
Sciences Sciences
., .,
Ca/culs: Ca/culs:
7659-7664. 7659-7664.
H., H.,
2011, 2011,
"
S
E., E.,
331-336. 331-336.
H
H., H.,
Line Line
Evolver, Evolver,
Marchetta, Marchetta,
. .
. .
X., X.,
writing writing
and and
"The "The
. .
as as
and and
Meeting Meeting
Washington, Washington,
M., M.,
and and
and and
M.
was was
Jr., Jr.,
"Capillary "Capillary
and and
the the
pp Energy Energy
Joint Joint
Yend1er
, ,
Meeting Meeting
Collicott, Collicott,
Surface Surface
We
and and
Meeting Meeting
Meeting Meeting
Early Early Weislogel, Weislogel,
. .
"Propellant "Propellant
and and
1-12. 1-12.
Huang, Huang,
GPM GPM
made made
process. process.
i
& &
slogel. slogel.
Propulsion Propulsion
Collicott, Collicott,
Propulsion Propulsion
J., J.,
Propulsion Propulsion
and and
Exhibit, Exhibit,
, ,
Transcedenta/s, Transcedenta/s,
Tegart, Tegart,
Software Software
Evolver." Evolver."
DC, DC,
Hochstein, Hochstein,
and and
Fluid Fluid American American
B
Project. Project.
and and
and and
possible possible
S
Y.
the the ., .,
. .
M. M.
M. M.
Exhibit, Exhibit,
, ,
H "Thermal "Thermal
2008, 2008,
Exhibit
Exhibit
Relation Relation
"The "The
., ., Management Management
Physics Physics
AIAA, AIAA,
M., M.,
S. S.
M., M.,
Conference Conference
J. J.
Conforence, Conforence,
"Mass "Mass Conference Conference
Experimental Experimental
H., H.,
Special Special
"Review "Review
pp. pp.
J. J.
Review Review Institute Institute
R., R.,
by by
"Modeling "Modeling
, ,
AIAA, AIAA,
, ,
AIAA, AIAA, Package Package
L L
Washington, Washington,
AIAA, AIAA,
"Analysis "Analysis
1-7. 1-7.
Propellant Propellant
between between in in
5th 5th
Center Center
"Approaches "Approaches
funding funding
"Orbital "Orbital
l, l,
Zero-Gravity," Zero-Gravity,"
ed, ed,
1992. 1992.
thanks thanks
of of
Acknowledgments Acknowledgments
of of
Washington, Washington,
& &
and and
Device Device
AIAA, AIAA,
Washington, Washington,
of of
Washington, Washington,
Brooks/Cole-Thomas Brooks/Cole-Thomas
Exhibit, Exhibit,
Surface Surface
Interior Interior
Anomalies Anomalies
Advancing, Advancing,
of of
Mathematics, Mathematics,
Aeronautics Aeronautics
References References
Exhibit
of of
Gauging Gauging
from from
Test Test
the the
DC
go go
10 10
and and
Tank Tank
Washington, Washington,
Conceptual Conceptual
to to
, ,
to to
Evolver Evolver
Operatoin Operatoin
AIAA, AIAA, Comer Comer
2002, 2002,
, ,
Validation Validation
Results Results
NASA's NASA's
AIAA, AIAA,
DC, DC,
41st 41st
Catilin Catilin
DC
PMD PMD
DC, DC,
from from
at at
Receding
Manu
, ,
2003 pp. pp.
Vol. Vol.
AlAA AlAA
and and
Washington, Washington,
EOL, EOL,
Flow Flow
2004, 2004,
Validation Validation 2006, 2006,
Asymmetric Asymmetric
Washington, Washington,
Rewetting Rewetting
Bacha Bacha
DC, DC,
1-11. 1-11. of of
of of
Design Design
al, al,
, ,
1, 1,
Astronautics Astronautics
Learning
of of
pp Internal Internal
Research Research
the the
Fluid Fluid
EuroStar EuroStar , ,
pp
No.2, No.2,
pp
A A
1994, 1994,
and and
Models Models . .
. .
1-11. 1-11. . .
VTRE VTRE
1-15. 1-15.
for for
1-10. 1-10.
Vaned Vaned
Young Young
Tests Tests
Ver. Ver.
and and
Dynamics Dynamics
DC, DC,
1992
pp. pp.
Following Following , ,
providing providing
Propellant Propellant
Belmont, Belmont,
DC, DC,
Research Research
in in
for for
2000 2000
Propellant Propellant
2002, 2002,
Analysis: Analysis:
for for 1-12. 1-12.
, ,
Microgravity
Contact Contact
pp pp
Liquid Liquid
Low Low
1995
Zero-Gravity Zero-Gravity
2
Implementation," Implementation,"
141-165. 141-165.
.
Conference Conference
pp. pp.
5
, ,
CA, CA,
Thrust Thrust
, ,
Gravity Gravity
helpful helpful
pp. pp.
Positions Positions
and and
Angles
1-11. 1-11.
Acquisition Acquisition
Management Management
Traps Traps
2003
1-13. 1-13.
Ken Ken
,
"Procedia "Procedia
Development Development
Resettling," Resettling,"
Fluid Fluid
feedback feedback
, , ,
Fluids Fluids
" "
and and
Chap. Chap.
and and
in in
Langmuir, Langmuir,
Spacecraft," Spacecraft,"
Behavior," Behavior,"
Exhibit
SpaceOps SpaceOps
A. A.
Troughs,
Device," Device,"
Applications
8. 8.
Device," Device,"
Engineering
throughout throughout
40th 40th
, ,
Vol. Vol.
(IRAD) (IRAD)
AIAA, AIAA,
Brakke
" "
AIAA AIAA
42nd 42nd
2008 2008
44th 44th
38th 38th
30th 30th
20, 20,
31st 31st
," ,"
, , , ,