Midrange Array Buyer's Guide
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
NGE A RA RR D A I Y M BUYER’S GUIDE 2010 MIDRANGE ARRAY BUYER’S GUIDE The Insider’s Guide to Evaluating FC and iSCSI Midrange Arrays By Jerome M Wendt DCIG, LLC | 7511 Madison Street | Omaha NE 68127 | 402.884.9594 DCIG 2010 MIDRANGE ARRAY BUYER’S GUIDE The Insider’s Guide to Evaluating FC and iSCSI Midrange Arrays Table of Contents 1 Introduction 23 Midrange Array Models 3 Executive Summary 24 3PAR InServ F200 60 HDS AMS2100 25 3PAR InServ F400 61 HDS AMS2300 4 How to Use this 26 Celeros EzSANFiler XD34S 62 HDS AMS2500 Midrange Array Buyer’s Guide 27 Celeros EzSANFiler XF34S 63 HP EVA4400 28 Celeros EzSANFiler XD46S 64 HP EVA6400 5 Disclosures 29 Celeros EzSANFiler XF46S 65 HP EVA8400 5 Midrange Array Inclusion 30 Celeros EzSANFiler XD49S 66 HP MSA2000i and Exclusion Criteria 31 Celeros EzSANFiler XF49S 67 HP P2000 G3 32 Celeros EzSANFiler XD512 68 HP P4300 6 The 8-Step Process Used 33 Celeros EzSANFiler XF512 69 IBM DS5020 Express to Score and Rank Midrange Arrays 34 Celeros EzSANFiler XD810 70 Infortrend ESVA E20 35 Celeros EzSANFiler XF810 71 Infortrend ESVA F20 7 DCIG Comments and Thoughts on … 36 Compellent Storage Center 72 NEC D3 7 Midrange Array Performance and Pricing Series 20 73 NEC D3i 8 Power and Space Efficiency 37 Compellent Storage Center 74 NEC D4 9 Reliability and Functionality Series 30 75 NEC D8 38 Dell EqualLogic PS4000E 76 NetApp FAS2020 9 DCIG Observations and 39 Dell EqualLogic PS4000X 77 NetApp FAS2040 Recommendations Regarding 40 Dell EqualLogic PS4000XV 78 NetApp FAS2050 Each Midrange Arrays Ranking 41 Dell EqualLogic PS6000E 79 NetApp FAS3140 9 Recommended 42 Dell EqualLogic PS6000X 80 NetApp FAS3160 10 Excellent 43 Dell EqualLogic PS6000XV 81 NetApp FAS3170 10 Good 44 Dell EqualLogic PS6010E 82 Nexsan DataBeast 10 Entry Level 45 Dell EqualLogic PS6010X 83 Nexsan iSeries 400i 46 Dell EqualLogic PS6010XV 84 Nexsan SASBeast 12 Midrange Array Scores 47 Dell EqualLogic PS6500E 85 Nexsan SATABeast and Rankings 48 Dell EqualLogic PS6500X 86 Oracle Sun StorageTek 2540 13 Midrange Array FC/iSCSI SAN 49 Dell EqualLogic PS6510E 87 Oracle Sun StorageTek 6180 15 Midrange Array FC SAN 50 Dot Hill 2322 88 Oracle Sun StorageTek 6580 17 Midrange Array iSCSI SAN 51 Dot Hill 2332 89 Oracle Sun StorageTek 6780 19 Midrange Array Hardware 52 Dot Hill 3930 90 Oracle Sun StorageTek 7310 21 Midrange Array Software 53 Dot Hill 5730 91 Overland Storage SnapServer 54 EMC CLARiiON CX4 Model 120 SAN S2000 55 EMC CLARiiON CX4 Model 240 92 Pillar Axiom 300 56 EMC CLARiiON CX4 Model 480 93 Pillar Axiom 600 57 EMC CLARiiON CX4 Model 960 94 RELDATA 9240i 58 Fujitsu ETERNUS 4000 DX410 95 Xiotech Emprise 7000 59 Fujitsu ETERNUS 4000 DX440 Appendix A-1 Definition of Terms Used in Buyer’s Guide B-1 Storage Provider Contact Information C-1 Plans for Future Midrange Array Buyer’s Guides C-1 Establishing a Base Line C-1 Variables that Will Need to Be Re-Weighted C-1 New Variables © 2010 DCIG LLC. All rights reserved. p. i DCIG 2010 MIDRANGE ARRAY BUYER’S GUIDE The Insider’s Guide to Evaluating FC and iSCSI Midrange Arrays Introduction This Midrange Array Buyer’s Guide represents the next generation of technology reports that I produced for many years when I wrote for Storage magazine (now part of SearchStorage.com). But it is also different in one major way: it reflects the behind the scenes evaluations that myself and many other engineers regularly did when I worked as a storage engineer for First Data Corporation. During the six years that I wrote for Storage magazine and the three (3) years since then that I have run and operated my own data storage focused analyst firm and website, I have contemplated how the technology reports that I used to write for Storage magazine could be made more thorough. Further, I wanted to leverage my experiences at First Data so the Buyer’s Guide could alleviate one of the most time consuming components of the midrange array buying decision – the information gathering and evaluation stage. In writing for both Storage magazine and now for DCIGinc.com, my intent was and is to inform users so they could make objective buying decisions on a specific technology. In this respect, the feedback that I receive from readers indicates that I have achieved a level of success. However the influence that I have on user buying decisions weighs on me, espe- cially when I considered the breadth of some of the technologies that I attempt to authori- tatively cover. Midrange arrays are a perfect example. When I started writing this Buyer’s Guide, I identified nearly 30 providers of midrange arrays that offered over 130 different models that were considered for inclusion in this Buyer’s Guide. Just coming up with that exhaustive list of storage providers and the models took some time. Then I still had to sort through each model’s hardware and software features and differentiate between them. While the differences between individual models were in many cases slight, differences do exist between each and every midrange array. So if I or anyone attempted to write a 5 – 7 page technology report that attempted to provide users with any meaningful guidance at all in regards to purchasing a midrange array, it would be incomplete. Just by the brevity of the report it would fail to take into account many of the criteria that are important when trying to develop a short list of products to consider for inclusion when making such an important buying decision. So this is what the first DCIG Midrange Array Buyer’s Guide does: It provides a much more comprehensive and in-depth look into as many midrange array models and their hardware and software features as possible. In preparing this Buyer’s Guide, I looked at these midrange array models and their features in much the same way as I did while writing for Storage magazine and working as a storage engineer at First Data Corporation: Through the eyes of an end user. During my stint at First Data, the storage team would create extensive lists of evaluation criteria for midrange arrays that included each model’s hardware and software features as well as the support offered by the storage provider. © 2010 DCIG LLC. All rights reserved. p. 1 DCIG 2010 MIDRANGE ARRAY BUYER’S GUIDE The Insider’s Guide to Evaluating FC and iSCSI Midrange Arrays Introduction continued Once these criteria were established, the team would go through and do a technical evalu- ation of each midrange array. At that time, we would try to clear up any ambiguities that existed (eg. a feature that was referred to by a different name by each storage provider), put heavier weightings on features that were more important to us and then score and rank each midrange array. Based upon these scores, First Data would then come up with 3 – 5 possible contenders for purchase and then submit that list to our procurement department to get competitive bids on each of those models. This Midrange Array Buyer’s Guide does this heavy lifting for end users. This Buyer’s Guide: • Lists each individual midrange array models by storage provider • Lists different midrange array features, whether or not they are supported and (where appropriate) how they are implemented • Weights these features according to what end users consider most important • Scores these features • Ranks each midrange array model The end result is that this Midrange Array Buyer’s Guide gives users the opportunity to do “at-a-glance” comparisons between many different midrange array models. Using these results, they can quickly come up with a short list of products that meet their specific needs and either go directly to a product evaluation stage with select midranges or even opt to get competitive bids on these products. Note that this Buyer’s Guide is not intended to be a substitute for bringing individual midrange arrays models in-house and testing them with specific applications. That function should still be done since every midrange array will perform differently under different appli- cation workloads. But it should help users get to that short list of products that they want to test much more quickly. I hope you find that this Buyer’s Guide meets this intended purpose in your environment. Jerome © 2010 DCIG LLC. All rights reserved. p. 2 DCIG 2010 MIDRANGE ARRAY BUYER’S GUIDE The Insider’s Guide to Evaluating FC and iSCSI Midrange Arrays Executive Summary According to IDC, revenue from external disk storage systems totaled over $18 billion in 2009.i Included in that total was storage of every possible type including enterprise, midrange and consumer storage arrays. But what that IDC number does not fully reflect is the growing impact that midrange arrays are having on organizations of all sizes and how much more money they are poised to spend on this particular category of external storage. The declining costs of storage capacity and network bandwidth coupled with their constantly improving performance are contributing to making external storage systems affordable and practical in all of these environments. However the introduction and rapid adoption of server virtualization is now making external storage almost a necessity in all size organizations. Among the types of external storage systems available, midrange arrays are the ones that are best positioned to benefit from this forthcoming wave of server virtualization. Today’s midrange arrays are affordable, easy to deploy, reliable, and offer high levels of performance. The only problem is that there are so many storage providers and midrange array models from which to choose that there is no way to make an objective buying decision since no analyst report or buyer’s guide has previously existed that could guide organizations through this maze to help them make a quick and informed buying decision.