Woman in British Novels, 1790-1801
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE “IMPROPERLY EDUCATED” WOMAN IN BRITISH NOVELS, 1790-1801 A Dissertation by LACIE ADELL OSBOURNE Submitted to the Office of Graduate Studies of Texas A&M University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY August 2012 Major Subject: English “The ‘Improperly Educated’ Woman in British Novels, 1790-1801.” Copyright 2012 Lacie Adell Osbourne THE “IMPROPERLY EDUCATED” WOMAN IN BRITISH NOVELS, 1790-1801 A Dissertation by LACIE ADELL OSBOURNE Submitted to the Office of Graduate Studies of Texas A&M University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Approved by: Chair of Committee, Robert Griffin Committee Members, Margaret J.M. Ezell Laura Mandell James Rosenheim Head of Department, Nancy Warren August 2012 Major Subject: English iii ABSTRACT The ‘Improperly Educated’ Woman in British Novels, 1790-1801. (August 2012) Lacie Adell Osbourne, B.A., M.A., West Texas A&M University Chair of Advisory Committee: Dr. Robert Griffin This dissertation identifies the character type of the “improperly educated” woman, who is both rationally educated and passionately outspoken, and examines the delineation of this recurring figure, in relation to the female education continuum, within the evolving discourse on female learning during the period of 1790-1801. British women writers, who opposed the deficient education offered to females, contributed their voices to collectively challenging the notion that education deprived the female sex of their femininity. Consequently, women novelists exploited the “improperly educated” female character as a means to explore alternatives to the existing curriculum, specifically rational and classical knowledge and to consider the negative effects of restrictive gender identities on female education. I employ feminist literary history and criticism to evaluate the participation of Elizabeth Inchbald, Mary Hays, and Maria Edgeworth in this continuing educational debate through their advocation for restructuring of the educational system and their effective use of versions of the “improperly educated” woman to portray women as intellectually capable. Challenging the conception of “feminine” as a natural state, Inchbald, Hays, and Edgeworth used fictional narratives to show the difficulties of strict adherence to proper iv femininity and to portray the irony of an education that does not enlighten but rather restricts and censors. Inchbald’s A Simple Story, Hays’ Memoirs of Emma Courtney, and Edgeworth’s Belinda respectively demonstrate the important role played by this character type in regards to eighteenth and early nineteenth-century women writers’ efforts to promote improvements in female instruction, encourage female autonomy, and demonstrate women’s capabilities for self-improvement. Undeterred by traditional custom, women novelists renewed literary efforts to display similarities between women of diverse social classes and levels of learning, thus exposing the adverse consequences of the conventionally transitory and inferior education, which the majority of the female sex experienced. This character makes a significant impact in promoting improvement in the educational system and revising the definition of proper feminine behavior within British society. v DEDICATION I dedicate this dissertation to my parents, Donnie and Tammie Osbourne, who instilled into me the desire for learning and encouraged me to pursue my dreams. vi ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank my committee chair, Dr. Griffin, and my committee members, Dr. Ezell, Dr. Mandell, Dr. Rosenheim as well as Dr. Susan Egenolf for their guidance and support throughout the course of this research. I would also like to extend my sincerest gratitude to Dr. Griffin for his encouragement and direction throughout the duration of this project. My appreciation goes to the faculty and staff of the department of English and to my office mates and colleagues Amy Larsen and Claire Cothren as well as to Marina Trninic for all of their help and advice. Furthermore, I want to thank my parents for their love, prayers, unwavering emotional support, and willingness to listen. Also, I would like to recognize my grandmother and my late Aunt Becky for their love and kindness, and to express my thanks to my close friend Nikki Hart for lending a sympathetic ear. Finally, I want to show my immense gratitude and appreciation to my fiancé Victor Luciano for his endless love, patience, and encouragement. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT .............................................................................................................. iii DEDICATION .......................................................................................................... v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...................................................................................... vi TABLE OF CONTENTS .......................................................................................... vii CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION ................................................................................ 1 Feminist Literary History of Eighteenth-Century Texts, the Novel, and Education………………………………………………………. 11 Combating Inferior Feminine Education: Inchbald, Hays, and Edgeworth………………………………………………………….. 18 Conclusion………………………………………………………….. 21 II THE TRAGIC RESULT OF IM(PROPER) EDUCATION IN A SIMPLE STORY ...................................................................................... 22 The Nature of Education ................................................................... 32 Proper Female Education Undefined ................................................ 42 Conclusion ......................................................................................... 53 III EMPOWERMENT OF THE “IMPROPERLY EDUCATED” WOMAN IN MEMOIRS OF EMMA COURTNEY .............................. 55 (Mis)Reading: Improper Education................................................ 63 Engaging “Improper” Education .................................................... 77 Conclusion ...................................................................................... 89 IV FEMALE EDUCATION REEXAMINED: TRANSFORMATION OF THE “IMPROPERLY EDUCATED” WOMAN IN BELINDA .......... 91 “Masculine Femininity”: Female Rationality and Gender Construction……………………………………………………….. 101 The Paradox of Lady Delacour: The Properness of Impropriety….. 117 viii CHAPTER Page Conclusion………………………………………………………... 128 V CONCLUSION ..................................................................................... 130 WORKS CITED ........................................................................................................ 135 1 CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION If WOMAN is not permitted to assert a majesty of mind, why fatigue her faculties with the labours of any species of education? why [sic] give her books, if she is not to profit by the wisdom they inculcate? [. .] Man says you may read, and you will think; but you shall not evince your knowledge, or employ your thoughts, beyond the boundaries which we have set up around you. Then wherefore burthen the young mind with a gaudy outline which man darkens with shades indelible? why [sic] expand the female heart, merely to render it more conscious that it is, by the tyranny of custom, rendered vulnerable?1 At the end of the eighteenth century, Mary Robinson’s text delineates the restrictive nature of female education determined by established boundaries of gender roles. Robinson’s expressed frustration raises an important point regarding the inherent contradiction in the contemporary system of female education: the inhibition of female mental development due to the projection of eighteenth-century social values on female corporeality and gendered behavior. Female education appeared as a subject of interest in the late seventeenth century and remained an important issue in treatises, pamphlets, and novels alike throughout the eighteenth century. This heated debate primarily focused on women’s struggle for improved, if not equal, education for young girls and women who had previously been denied in-depth scholarly studies. Robinson’s passionate This dissertation follows the style of Modern Language Association (MLA) Handbook. 1 Robinson, Mary. A Letter to the Women of England, on the Injustice of Mental Subordination. 1799. Ed. Sharon M. Setzer. Ontario: Broadview, 2003. Print. 78. 2 appeal for educational and social reform reflects the general exasperation felt by women writers regarding the conflicts between the social understanding of female mental capabilities and their conventional gender roles within the domestic and public spheres. In light of this concern, this dissertation concerns the efforts of British women writers, during the period of the 1790s to the early 1800s, who advocated that “education cannot unsex a woman”2 through the ironical representation of the “improperly educated” female character within their novels. I define the “improperly educated” woman as one who is rationally educated, a process which has taught her to rely on her own mental capabilities, and is subsequently both passionately outspoken and inwardly reflective. Employing the methods of feminist literary criticism and history, I explore the novelistic development of the “improperly educated” female character, portraying both autonomy and rationalism, in various degrees of sexuality, intellectualism, and outspokenness. There has been extensive scholarship published on female education in this period, particularly in relation