Modelling Religious Signalling

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Modelling Religious Signalling 1 MODELLING RELIGIOUS SIGNALLING A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the Australian National University Carl Joseph Brusse February 2019 © Copyright by Carl Joseph Brusse, 2019 All Rights Reserved 2 3 This thesis is solely the work of its author. No part of it has been submitted for any degree, or is currently being submitted for any other degree. To the best of my knowledge, any help received in preparing this thesis, and all sources used, have been duly acknowledged. 4 5 for Caroline, Alida, and Isobel 6 7 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I owe a great debt to my supervisory panel members past and present: Kim Sterelny, Justin Bruner, Rachael Brown, and Ben Fraser, for their deeply insightful commentary and gentle corrective during the various phases of this project. In particular, Kim very much provided both the inspiration for this project and the impetus for venturing to return to philosophy for this PhD candidature. I would not have entered into this without his encouragement, and I certainly would not have made it out the other side without his support and mentorship. Thank you, Kim, for your judgment and generosity, and for your astute, necessity-sensitive application of patience (or lack thereof) when required. Justin too deserves special mention for patiently schooling me in evolutionary game theory and signalling games (despite my sometimes bizarrely misguided intuitions), and in suggesting and contributing to my first simulation projects and our joint paper at the 2016 PSA, published in Philosophy of Science. Being at the School of Philosophy at the ANU, the number of faculty and grad students (local and visiting) who have taken the time to listen and offer valuable insights would be too long to record here. A few of the locals who deserve special mention are Ste Mann, Chris Lean, Ron Planer, Anton Killin, Heather Browning, David Kalkman, Alex Sandgren, Dominie Dessaix, Donald Nordblom, Ross Pain, and Ten-Herng Lai. I would especially like to acknowledge Matt Spike for the many hours he spent sitting next to me, helping me get my most recent simulations to work. Other philosophers from here and elsewhere whose insights I have mined include Paul Griffiths, Emily Parke, Brett Calcott, Toby Handfield, Russell Grey, Kevin Zollman, Pierrick Bourratt, Colin Klein, Seth Lazar, Geoffrey Brennan, and Alan Hájek. Given the interdisciplinary features of this project, I have also been lucky enough to benefit from the intellectual generosity of many expert scholars in the science of religion, especially Joseph Bulbulia, Aiyana Willard, Eleanor Power, Martin Lang, Quentin Atkinson, John Shaver, and two anonymous reviewers from Religion, Brain and Behavior. Regarding material support, I must thank my current employer, the University of Sydney, and Professor Paul Griffiths in particular for his generosity, support and understanding over the last months of write-up. Thank you, Paul. The ANU’s support to me as student has included travel scholarships, and too many free meals to count as part of the ‘thesis boot camp’ and veterans’ days program. These are the sessions where much of this thesis was written up, along with 8 funded ‘shut up and write’ sessions organised by PARSA, and informal sessions organised by myself and others, including Adam Bugeja and Hanh Nguyen. The comradery and productivity of the group writing environment was a revelation. Finally, but most importantly, I want to thank my wife – Caroline Margaret Brusse. Without her encouragement and support I would not have started, continued, or finished this thesis. Her firm conviction that I could get it done, and her shouldering of disproportionate burdens and responsibilities while I flailed my way towards submission is the single most important reason it is now completed (and we can get something of our lives back). This dissertation is dedicated to her, and to our children Alida and Isobel, both of whom were born while it was being written. 9 10 11 ABSTRACT The origins of human social cooperation confound simple evolutionary explanation. But from Darwin and Durkheim onwards, theorists (anthropologists and sociologists especially) have posited a potential link with another curious and distinctively human social trait that cries out for explanation: religion. This dissertation explores one contemporary theory of the co-evolution of religion and human social cooperation: the signalling theory of religion, or religious signalling theory (RST). According to the signalling theory, participation in social religion (and its associated rituals and sanctions) acts as an honest signal of one’s commitment to a religiously demarcated community and its way of doing things. This signal would allow prosocial individuals to positively assort with one another for mutual advantage, to the exclusion of more exploitative individuals. In effect, the theory offers a way that religion and cooperation might explain one another, but which that stays within an individualist adaptive paradigm. My approach is not to assess the empirical adequacy of the religious signalling explanation or contrast it with other explanations, but rather to deal with the theory in its own terms – isolating and fleshing out its core commitments, explanatory potential, and limitations. The key to this is acknowledging the internal complexities of signalling theory, with respect to the available models of honest signalling and the extent of their fit (or otherwise) with religion as a target system. The method is to take seriously the findings of formal modelling in animal signalling and other disciplines, and to apply these (and methods from the philosophy of biology more generally) to progressively build up a comprehensive picture of the theory, its inherent strengths and weaknesses. The first two chapters outline the dual explanatory problems that cooperation and religion present for evolutionary human science, and surveys contemporary approaches toward explaining them. Chapter three articulates an evolutionary conception of the signalling theory, and chapters four to six make the case for a series of requirements, limitations, and principles of application. Chapters seven and eight argue for the value of formal modelling to further flesh out the theory’s commitments and potential and describe some simple simulation results which make progress in this regard. Though the inquiry often problematizes the signalling theory, it also shows that it should not be dismissed outright, and that it makes predictions which are apt for empirical testing. 12 13 CONTENTS 1. Cooperation and Religion: evolutionary approaches ................................................................ 14 1.1. Explaining costly behaviour .................................................................................................................................... 17 1.2. The problem of religion: maladaptation and cultural evolution .................................................................... 33 1.3. Timelines of emergence .......................................................................................................................................... 50 1.4. Summary and context .............................................................................................................................................. 60 2. Big Gods ....................................................................................................................................... 63 2.1. Overview of the big gods model: theory and mechanisms ............................................................................ 63 2.2. Predictions and evidence ........................................................................................................................................ 66 2.3. Connecting the conceptual and the empirical ................................................................................................... 74 2.4. Conclusions ................................................................................................................................................................ 79 3. Rationale for a signalling theory of religion ............................................................................... 81 3.1. The Signalling theory as an explanation .............................................................................................................. 83 3.2. Mechanism, endogeny, and scalability .................................................................................................................. 86 3.3. Functionalism and the scope for explanation .................................................................................................... 89 3.4. Summary ..................................................................................................................................................................... 92 4. Signalling theory for religious signalling .................................................................................... 95 4.1. Signals and signalling systems ................................................................................................................................. 95 4.2. Honesty in fakeable and unfakeable signals ...................................................................................................... 104 4.3. The problem with ‘costly signalling’ ................................................................................................................... 108 4.4. Why signalling theory matters
Recommended publications
  • CONTENT2 2.Pages
    DRAFT PROPOSITIONAL CONTENT in SIGNALS (for Special Issue Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science C ) Brian Skyrms and Jeffrey A. Barrett Introduction We all think that humans are animals, that human language is a sophisticated form of animal signaling, and that it arises spontaneously due to natural processes. From a naturalistic perspective, what is fundamental is what is common to signaling throughout the biological world -- the transfer of information. As Fred Dretske put it in 1981, "In the beginning was information, the word came later." There is a practice of signaling with information transfer that settles into some sort of a pattern, and eventually what we call meaning or propositional content crystallizes out. The place to start is to study the evolution, biological or cultural, of information transfer in its most simple and tractable forms. But once this is done, naturalists need first to move to evolution of more complex forms of information transfer. And then to an account of the crystallization process that gives us meaning. There often two kinds of information in the same signal: (1) information about the state of the world that the signaler observes (2) information about the act that the receiver will perform on receiving the signal. [See Millikan (1984), Harms (2004), Skyrms (2010)]. The meaning that crystalizes out about the states, we will single out here as propositional meaning. The simplest account that comes to mind will not quite do, as a general account of this kind of meaning, although it may be close to the mark in especially favorable situations.
    [Show full text]
  • Information Games and Robust Trading Mechanisms
    Information Games and Robust Trading Mechanisms Gabriel Carroll, Stanford University [email protected] October 3, 2017 Abstract Agents about to engage in economic transactions may take costly actions to influence their own or others’ information: costly signaling, information acquisition, hard evidence disclosure, and so forth. We study the problem of optimally designing a mechanism to be robust to all such activities, here termed information games. The designer cares about welfare, and explicitly takes the costs incurred in information games into account. We adopt a simple bilateral trade model as a case study. Any trading mechanism is evaluated by the expected welfare, net of information game costs, that it guarantees in the worst case across all possible games. Dominant- strategy mechanisms are natural candidates for the optimum, since there is never any incentive to manipulate information. We find that for some parameter values, a dominant-strategy mechanism is indeed optimal; for others, the optimum is a non- dominant-strategy mechanism, in which one party chooses which of two trading prices to offer. Thanks to (in random order) Parag Pathak, Daron Acemoglu, Rohit Lamba, Laura Doval, Mohammad Akbarpour, Alex Wolitzky, Fuhito Kojima, Philipp Strack, Iv´an Werning, Takuro Yamashita, Juuso Toikka, and Glenn Ellison, as well as seminar participants at Michigan, Yale, Northwestern, CUHK, and NUS, for helpful comments and discussions. Dan Walton provided valuable research assistance. 1 Introduction A large portion of theoretical work in mechanism design, especially in the world of market design applications, has focused on dominant-strategy (or strategyproof ) mechanisms — 1 those in which each agent is asked for her preferences, and it is always in her best interest to report them truthfully, no matter what other agents are doing.
    [Show full text]
  • The Cognitive Science of Religion
    Masarykova univerzita Filozofická fakulta Ústav religionistiky Martin Lang The Cognitive Science of Religion Connecting the Humanities and the Sciences in the Study of Ritual Practice, Prosociality, and Anxiety Dizertační práce Školitel: Mgr. Aleš Chalupa, Ph.D. Brno 2016 Prohlašuji, že jsem tuto dizertační práci vypracoval samostatně s využitím uvedených pramenů a literatury. ……………………………………… Mgr. Martin Lang V Brně dne 22. září 2016 TABLE OF CONTENTS CZECH ABSTRACT I ENGLISH ABSTRACT II ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS III PREFACE IV INTRODUCTION - 1 - THE COGNITIVE SCIENCE OF RELIGION - 4 - Two Cultures and the Divide between the Humanities and the Sciences - 4 - CSR and Consilience - 7 - CSR and the Mechanistic Approach - 12 - EFFECTS OF RELIGION AND RITUAL ON PROSOCIALITY - 18 - RELIGION AND PROSOCIALITY - 23 - Introduction - 23 - The Religious Congruence Fallacy - 25 - What Religious People Say They Do - 26 - What Religious People Actually Do - 28 - Religion as Prime - 31 - Belief and Practice - 35 - Future Directions - 37 - Summary - 38 - MUSIC AS A SACRED CUE? EFFECTS OF RELIGIOUS MUSIC ON MORAL BEHAVIOR - 40 - Abstract - 40 - Introduction - 40 - Materials and Methods - 44 - Results - 50 - Discussion - 62 - LOST IN THE RHYTHM: EFFECTS OF RHYTHM ON SUBSEQUENT INTERPERSONAL COORDINATION - 68 - Abstract - 68 - Introduction - 68 - Materials and Methods - 70 - Results - 74 - Discussion - 79 - Appendix - 83 - EFFECTS OF RITUAL BEHAVIOR ON ANXIETY - 84 - EFFECTS OF ANXIETY ON SPONTANEOUS RITUALIZED BEHAVIOR - 88 - Summary - 88 - Results - 89 - Discussion - 95 - Experimental Procedures - 98 - ANXIETY AND RITUALIZATION: CAN ATTENTION DISCRIMINATE COMPULSION FROM ROUTINE? - 100 - DISCUSSION - 103 - REFERENCES - 115 - SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL - 145 - CZECH ABSTRACT Náboženství je tradičním tématem mnohých humanitních a sociálních věd, jež při jeho studiu nabízí různorodé perspektivy a metodologické přístupy.
    [Show full text]
  • Why Do Nations Obey International Law?
    Review Essay Why Do Nations Obey International Law? The New Sovereignty: Compliance with InternationalRegulatory Agreements. By Abram Chayes" and Antonia Handler Chayes.*" Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1995. Pp. xii, 404. $49.95. Fairness in International Law and Institutions. By Thomas M. Franck.- Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1995. Pp. 500. $55.00. Harold Hongju Koh Why do nations obey international law? This remains among the most perplexing questions in international relations. Nearly three decades ago, Louis Henkin asserted that "almost all nations observe almost all principles of international law and almost all of their obligations almost all of the time."' Although empirical work since then seems largely to have confirmed this hedged but optimistic description,2 scholars Felix Frankfurter Professor of Law, Emeritus, Harvard Law School ** President, Consensus Building Institute. Murray and Ida Becker Professor of Law; Director. Center for International Studtcs. New York University School of Law. t Gerard C. and Bernice Latrobe Smith Professor of International Law; Director. Orville H, Schell, Jr., Center for International Human Rights, Yale University. Thts Essay sketches arguments to be fleshed out in a forthcoming book, tentatively entitled WHY NATIONS OBEY: A THEORY OF COMPLIANCE WITH INTERNATIONAL LAW. Parts of this Review Essay derive from the 1997 \Vaynflete Lectures. Magdalen College, Oxford University, and a brief book review of the Chayeses volume in 91 Am. J. INT'L L. (forthcoming 1997). 1 am grateful to Glenn Edwards, Jessica Schafer. and Douglas Wolfe for splendid research assistance, and to Bruce Ackerman, Peter Balsam, Geoffrey Brennan. Paul David, Noah Feldman. Roger Hood, Andrew Hurrell, Mark Janis, Paul Kahn, Benedict Kingsbury, Tony Kronran.
    [Show full text]
  • Measuring the Cultural Evolution of Music: with Case Studies of British-American and Japanese Folk, Art, and Popular Music
    Measuring the cultural evolution of music: With case studies of British-American and Japanese folk, art, and popular music Patrick Evan SAVAGE This is an English version of my Japanese Ph.D. dissertation (Ph.D. conferred on March 27, 2017). The final Japanese version of record was deposited in the Japanese National Diet Library in June 2017. #2314910 Ph.D. entrance year: 2014 2016 academic year Tokyo University of the Arts, Department of Musicology Ph.D. dissertation Supervisor: UEMURA Yukio Supervisory committee: TSUKAHARA Yasuko MARUI Atsushi Hugh DE FERRANTI i English abstract Student number: 2314910 Name: Patrick Evan SAVAGE Title: Measuring the cultural evolution of music: With case studies of British-American and Japanese folk, art, and popular music Darwin's theory of evolution provided striking explanatory power that has come to unify biology and has been successfully extended to various social sciences. In this dissertation, I demonstrate how cultural evolutionary theory may also hold promise for explaining diverse musical phenomena, using a series of quantitative case studies from a variety of cultures and genres to demonstrate general laws governing musical change. Chapter one describes previous research and debates regarding music and cultural evolution. Drawing on major advances in the scientific understanding of cultural evolution over the past three decades, I clarify persistent misconceptions about the roles of genes and progress in definitions of evolution, showing that neither is required or assumed. I go on to review older and recent literature relevant to musical evolution at a variety of levels, from Lomax's macroevolutionary interpretation of global patterns of song-style to microevolutionary mechanisms by which minute melodic variations give rise to large tune families.
    [Show full text]
  • Implicit Cultures: Towards a Psychosocial Theory of 'Intuitive
    Implicit Cultures: Towards a Psychosocial Theory of ‘Intuitive Religious Beliefs’ By Timothy J. McVicar A Thesis Submitted to the Victoria University of Wellington In Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts In Religious Studies School of Art History, Classics and Religious Studies Victoria University of Wellington 2011 2 If we threw a handful of children on an island and they raised themselves I think they would believe in God (Barrett cited in Beckford, 2008). A child raised on a desert island…would come out as Geertz envisioned, something of a monster, something other than a fully human intentional and moral agent (Tomasello, 1999: 215). 3 Acknowledgements Many people helped ensure that this thesis reached fruition. The steady and always enthusiastic hand of my supervisor Joseph Bulbulia provided the necessary expertise, guidance, and inspiration needed to make the project achievable and enjoyable. I am grateful to him for this and for introducing me to the field in my undergrad years. His interest and enthusiasm directly stirred my own. My secondary supervisor, Michael Raddich, who came onboard in the final stages, offered timely expertise on writing style, structure, and content. My thesis would be poorer without the insight and precision he was able to bring. Thanks heaps. A thank you is also due to the Religious Studies programme administrator Aliki Kalliabetsos, who provided guidance and seemly endless tins of instant coffee. Thanks also to the academics in the Religious Studies Department: Rick Weiss, Paul Morris, and Art Buehler for informal discussions and direction. I would also like to thank my postgraduate colleges, Milan Magan, Lisa Eyre, Negar Patrow and Wil Hoverd, who ensured my time here has been an enjoyable, empathetic and intellectually enriching one.
    [Show full text]
  • The Cultural Evolution of Epistemic Practices: the Case of Divination Author: Ze Hong A1, Joseph Henricha
    Title: The cultural evolution of epistemic practices: the case of divination Author: Ze Hong a1, Joseph Henricha Author Affiliations: a Department of Human Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University, 11 Divinity Avenue, 02138, Cambridge, MA, United States Keywords: cultural Evolution; divination; information transmission; Bayesian reasoning 1 To whom correspondence should be addressed: [email protected] 1 ABSTRACT While a substantial literature in anthropology and comparative religion explores divination across diverse societies and back into history, little research has integrated the older ethnographic and historical work with recent insights on human learning, cultural transmission and cognitive science. Here we present evidence showing that divination practices are often best viewed as an epistemic technology, and formally model the scenarios under which individuals may over-estimate the efficacy of divination that contribute to its cultural omnipresence and historical persistence. We found that strong prior belief, under-reporting of negative evidence, and mis-inferring belief from behavior can all contribute to biased and inaccurate beliefs about the effectiveness of epistemic technologies. We finally suggest how scientific epistemology, as it emerged in the Western societies over the last few centuries, has influenced the importance and cultural centrality of divination practices. 2 1. INTRODUCTION The ethnographic and historical record suggests that most, and potentially all, human societies have developed techniques, processes or technologies that reveal otherwise hidden or obscure information, often about unknown causes or future events. In historical and contemporary small-scale societies around the globe, divination—"the foretelling of future events or discovery of what is hidden or obscure by supernatural or magical means” –has been extremely common, possibly even universal (Flad 2008; Boyer 2020).
    [Show full text]
  • Mailonline - News, Sport, Celebrity, Science and Health Stories U.K
    MailOnline - news, sport, celebrity, science and health stories U.K. India U.S. News Sport TV&Showbiz Femail Health Science Money Video Coffee Break Travel Columnists Latest Headlines TV&Showbiz U.S. Showbiz Headlines Arts A-Z Star Search Pictures Showbiz Boards Login Saturday, Mar 21st 2015 11AM 32°C 2PM 35°C 5-Day Forecast Rita Ora nearly spills out of her VERY low cut silver crop top as she explains t o Alan Carr why she enjoys wearing such revealing clothes By Francesca Menato for MailOnline Published: 21:20 GMT, 20 March 2015 | Updated: 22:38 GMT, 20 March 2015 22 shares 174 View comments Another day; another revealing outfit for Rita Ora. The singer appeared on Alan Carr's Chatty Man, airing on Friday night on Channel 4, in a very low cut silver crop top and found herself more than a little expos ed. Even the host of the show had to comment to his guest: 'Even I'm looking at your breasts!' Scroll down for video Racy Rita! Rita Ora chose a typically revealing outfit for her appearance on Ala n Carr's Chatty Man +12 Racy Rita! Rita Ora chose a typically revealing outfit for her appearance on Ala n Carr's Chatty Man The singer was forced to readjust her assets as she sat with her fellow The Voic e mentors and told Alan, 'Every time I come on this show its something to do with my outfit. RELATED ARTICLES Previous 1 2 Next Sheer Right Now! Rita Ora looks sporty in a see-through..
    [Show full text]
  • UNIVERSITY of CALIFORNIA RIVERSIDE Integration Or Social
    UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA RIVERSIDE Integration or Social Control? The Evolution of Religious-Rituals A Thesis submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Sociology by John Manuel Aldecoa June 2016 Thesis Committee: Dr. Alexandra Maryanski, Chairperson Dr. Jonathan H. Turner Dr. Jan E. Stets Dr. Christopher Chase-Dunn Copyright by John Manuel Aldecoa 2016 The Thesis of John Manuel Aldecoa is approved: Committee Chairperson University of California, Riverside ABSTRACT OF THE THESIS Integration or Social Control? The Evolution of Religious-Rituals by John Manuel Aldecoa Master of Arts Graduate Program in Sociology University of California, Riverside, June 2016 Dr. Alexandra Maryanski, Chairperson Scholars generally agree that religion is a social construct, but polarize along the line of what consequences religious-rituals actually have in society. Durkheimian and neo-Darwinian scholars argue that the religious-ritual evolved to integrate societal members and promote prosocial behavior. Critical theorists contend religious-rituals may not operate so much to create shared beliefs but instead to legitimate a structure of dominance within society. I argue that a nexus between these theories can be found with an examination of the underlying neurology of religious-rituals. The mirror neuronal system (MNS) is the foundation for the humanistic ‘desire’ for mimesis. Religious-rituals stimulate the MNS to promote empathy, trust, and integration. As societies grew, increasing social distance and differentiation (i.e., stratification) weakened empathetic bonding between religious specialists and the religious group. Reduced empathy lead to increased selfishness and other antisocial behaviors that benefited the social elite. I conclude with a discussion of the primary link between the integration and social control hypotheses: mimesis, synchrony, and emotionality.
    [Show full text]
  • Arxiv:1612.07182V2 [Cs.CL] 5 Mar 2017 in a World Populated by Other Agents
    Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2017 MULTI-AGENT COOPERATION AND THE EMERGENCE OF (NATURAL)LANGUAGE Angeliki Lazaridou1∗, Alexander Peysakhovich2, Marco Baroni2;3 1Google DeepMind, 2Facebook AI Research, 3University of Trento [email protected], falexpeys,[email protected] ABSTRACT The current mainstream approach to train natural language systems is to expose them to large amounts of text. This passive learning is problematic if we are in- terested in developing interactive machines, such as conversational agents. We propose a framework for language learning that relies on multi-agent communi- cation. We study this learning in the context of referential games. In these games, a sender and a receiver see a pair of images. The sender is told one of them is the target and is allowed to send a message from a fixed, arbitary vocabulary to the receiver. The receiver must rely on this message to identify the target. Thus, the agents develop their own language interactively out of the need to communi- cate. We show that two networks with simple configurations are able to learn to coordinate in the referential game. We further explore how to make changes to the game environment to cause the “word meanings” induced in the game to better re- flect intuitive semantic properties of the images. In addition, we present a simple strategy for grounding the agents’ code into natural language. Both of these are necessary steps towards developing machines that are able to communicate with humans productively. 1 INTRODUCTION I tried to break it to him gently [...] the only way to learn an unknown language is to interact with a native speaker [...] asking questions, holding a conversation, that sort of thing [...] If you want to learn the aliens’ language, someone [...] will have to talk with an alien.
    [Show full text]
  • The Fish That Got Away? Human Behavioral Ecology and the Study of Religion
    Religion, Brain & Behavior ISSN: 2153-599X (Print) 2153-5981 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/rrbb20 The fish that got away? Human behavioral ecology and the study of religion Richard Sosis, Joseph Bulbulia, Wesley J. Wildman & Uffe Schjoedt To cite this article: Richard Sosis, Joseph Bulbulia, Wesley J. Wildman & Uffe Schjoedt (2018) The fish that got away? Human behavioral ecology and the study of religion, Religion, Brain & Behavior, 8:4, 351-353, DOI: 10.1080/2153599X.2018.1523608 To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/2153599X.2018.1523608 Published online: 26 Sep 2018. Submit your article to this journal View Crossmark data Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=rrbb20 RELIGION, BRAIN & BEHAVIOR 2018, VOL. 8, NO. 4, 351–353 https://doi.org/10.1080/2153599X.2018.1523608 EDITORIAL The fish that got away? Human behavioral ecology and the study of religion During the growth phase of any academic field it is worthwhile to pause and consider the ways in which the field has developed. There are many reasons to attempt a stock-take: to gauge progress, diagnose problems, consider position relative to other disciplines, identify big challenges, spot opportunities, strategize, or simply to celebrate the field’s many achievements. Our previous edi- torials have variously attempted to address each of these tasks. Here, though, we would like to do something a little different. Instead of asking what actually happened to the field, we consider what might have happened: were there alternative, potentially more fruitful pathways in which our field, the biocultural study of religion, could have progressed? Were there missed opportunities during the field’s development? Rather than contemplating the fish in hand, how big was the fish that got away? By most accounts our field consists of at least two major subfields—the evolutionary study of reli- gion and the cognitive science of religion.
    [Show full text]
  • Game Theory and Scalar Implicatures
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by UCL Discovery Game Theory and Scalar Implicatures Daniel Rothschild∗ September 4, 2013 1 Introduction Much of philosophy of language and linguistics is concerned with showing what is special about language. One of Grice’s (1967/1989) contributions, against this tendency, was to treat speech as a form of rational activity, subject to the same sorts of norms and expectations that apply to all such activity. This gen- eral perspective has proved very fruitful in pragmatics. However, it is rarely explicitly asked whether a particular pragmatic phenomenon should be under- stood entirely in terms of rational agency or whether positing special linguistic principles is necessary. This paper is concerned with evaluating the degree to which a species of simple pragmatic inferences, scalar implicatures, should be viewed as a form of rational inference. A rigorous answer to this last ques- tion requires using the theoretical resources of game theory. I show that weak- dominance reasoning, a standard form of game-theoretic reasoning, allows us to cash out the derivation of simple scalar implicatures as a form of rational infer- ence. I argue that this account of the scalar implicatures is more principled and robust than other explanations in the game theory and pragmatics literature. However, we can still see that deriving Gricean implicatures on the basis of decision and game-theoretic tools is not nearly as straightforward as we might hope, and the ultimate tools needed are disquietingly powerful. ∗ This paper is a distant descendent of my first, tenative foray into these issues, “Grice, Ratio- nality, and Utterance Choice”.
    [Show full text]