Talent Identification and Development in Male Rugby League

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Talent Identification and Development in Male Rugby League TALENT IDENTIFICATION AND DEVELOPMENT IN MALE RUGBY LEAGUE by David Rotheram A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment for the requirements for the degree of Professional Doctorate in Elite Performance at the University of Central Lancashire March 2020 AUTHOR’S DECLARATION STUDENT DECLARATION FORM Type of Award Professional Doctorate School Sport and Wellbeing 1. Concurrent registration for two or more academic awards *I declare that while registered as a candidate for the research degree, I have not been a registered candidate or enrolled student for another award of the University or other academic or professional institution. 2. Material submitted for another award *I declare that no material contained in the thesis has been used in any other submission for an academic award and is solely my own work. 3. Use of a Proof-reader *No proof-reading service was used in the compilation of this thesis. Signature of Candidate Print name: David Rotheram i ABSTRACT The purpose of this thesis is to investigate the effectiveness of the Talent and Performance Pathway in professional (male) English Rugby League, in order to meet the aims of both the Rugby Football League (RFL), the National Governing Body (NGB) of the sport in the UK, and Super League (Europe), the premier club competition in Europe. Specifically, the thesis has focused upon how optimum environments can be created in order to propel England to consistent World Cup wins and ensure that the Super League is supplied with high quality players providing ‘world class’ spectator and broadcast entertainment that drives increased commercial revenues. This work has been viewed through the complex social, financial and political backdrop in which the sport operates. The origins of the sport of Rugby League and the communities that it serves, through an engrained culture are initially investigated. These factors are shown to have a direct impact upon the Talent and Performance pathway since discrepancies were found between what current talent identification and development (TID) literature says and what is happening in practice. These discrepancies have been investigated using a mixed methods approach where a comparison with our major international competitor in Australia was conducted. Findings dispelled the myth that all England had to do was copy what the Australians did due to the social milieu in which the sport exists in both countries. Qualitative approaches were used to investigate challenges relating to the competition structure within the talent and performance pathway. Findings revealed that there is too much emphasis being placed upon short term results as opposed to long term development at the base of the pathway (i.e. community RL and first selective environments). In addition, an inappropriate development environment and competition offer was found to exist for athletes transitioning between age-group and elite performance environments resulting in players being ii ill-equipped to maximise their potential. Using the empirical evidence gathered, an alternative competition offer has been proposed. In an attempt to create better environments, behaviour change literature was explored and discrepancies between behaviours and desired outcomes from TID literature are discussed. To conclude, further areas of investigation arising from the thesis are suggested namely talent inclusion and people development. iii Table of Contents Author’s Declaration............................................................................................................ i Abstract ............................................................................................................................... ii List of Figures..................................................................................................................... ix List of Tables ....................................................................................................................... x Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................. xi Abbreviations .................................................................................................................... xii Publications Arisen from the Thesis ................................................................................ xiv Chapter 1 Introduction and Outline of this Thesis ............................................................ 1 1.1 Context of the work................................................................................................. 1 1.1.1 My position and interests ................................................................................. 1 1.1.2 A guide to the key ‘players’ ............................................................................. 2 1.2 My approach to this topic ........................................................................................ 5 1.3 Research Objectives ................................................................................................ 7 1.4 Guiding the reader through the thesis ...................................................................... 8 Chapter 2 General Considerations and Specific Design of Methodology – How did I want to do It? .................................................................................................................... 10 2.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................... 10 2.2 What information did I need? ................................................................................ 10 2.3 Research methods for consideration ...................................................................... 11 2.3.1 Qualitative Methods ....................................................................................... 11 2.3.2 Quantitative research methods........................................................................ 11 2.3.3 Mixed Methods research ................................................................................ 12 2.3.4 Determining the methods ............................................................................... 12 2.3.5 Collecting Data .............................................................................................. 12 2.3.5.1 Single versus multiple methodologies ..................................................... 15 2.4 Summary .............................................................................................................. 15 Chapter 3 The Context of RL in the UK – exploring our challenges .............................. 17 3.1 The Sporting Landscape of TID in RL .................................................................. 17 3.1.1 Birthplace Effect and Social Environment ...................................................... 17 3.1.2 Governmental influence – Funding and the wider national sporting agenda for talent and participation ................................................................................................ 19 3.1.3 Influence of Academic Research and Higher Education Institutions ............... 23 3.1.4 Influence of Key Internal Sporting Stakeholders ............................................ 29 3.1.5 The Academy System in Rugby League ......................................................... 32 3.2 ‘Prequel’ influences on TID .................................................................................. 34 3.3 The Role of Competition ....................................................................................... 38 iv 3.4 Summary .............................................................................................................. 39 Chapter 4 Myths, Mores and Half-truths of Talent Identification and Development Systems .............................................................................................................................. 40 4.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................... 40 4.2 Myths of Talent Identification and Development ................................................... 41 4.2.1 Early Specialisation ....................................................................................... 42 4.2.2 10,000 hours rule ........................................................................................... 43 4.2.3 Long Term Athlete Development (LTAD) ..................................................... 43 4.3 Mores of TID ........................................................................................................ 46 4.3.1 Long term aims and methods ......................................................................... 52 4.3.2 Wide ranging coherent messages and support................................................. 52 4.3.3 Emphasis upon appropriate development and not early success ...................... 53 4.3.4 Individualised and on-going development. ..................................................... 54 4.4 Half Truths............................................................................................................ 55 4.4.1 Function Movement Screen (FMS) ................................................................ 55 4.4.2 Over Training Syndrome ................................................................................ 57 4.5 Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 58 Chapter 5 Looking for Role Models – The Epidemilogy of Success
Recommended publications
  • 3 Day - Leeds Rhinos Multi Sport Activity Camp at Allerton C of E Primary £15 Only!
    3 Day - Leeds Rhinos Multi Sport Activity Camp at Allerton C of E Primary £15 only! Leeds Rhinos Foundation has joined forces with the Alwoodley Local Councillors to deliver multi-sport camps over the February half term for just £15: Monday 18th Feb – Wednesday 20th Feb – 9am – 3pm – Allerton Primary School Each camp is 3 full days of fun and engaging activities and includes a visit from Ronnie the Rhino. The camp is exclusively for those living in Alwoodley (LS17) Headed by highly qualified coaches, who carry a Level 2 National Governing Body coaching qualification and hold a valid DBS and safeguarding check, the camp will provide a safe and engaging environment for children to succeed. Our partnership with the Outer North West Community Committee allows us to offer this fantastic opportunity at a reduced cost to local school children and provide them with an experience over half term they won’t forget as well as the chance to get active and meet new people. Children will need to bring a packed lunch with them and suitable footwear and attire for the typical English weather!!! Children will be enrolled as a Leeds Breeze member on day 1 of the camp or alternatively if you can bring your Breeze card with you on the first day of camp. (free of charge) *Demand is likely to be extremely high and we will operate on a first come first served basis. To Book: Please contact the Leeds Rhinos Ticket Sales Hotline on 0371 4231315, come down to the Leeds Rugby Store @ Emerald Headingley Stadium.
    [Show full text]
  • Pan Macmillan September 2021 Highlights
    Pan Macmillan September 2021 Highlights They Got You Too Futhi Ntshingila Hans van Rooyen is a former police general raised by two women who survived the 1899 South African War. He finds himself being cared for in an old age home by the daughter of liberation struggle activists. At 80, he carries with him the memories of crimes he committed as an officer under the apartheid government. Having eluded the public confessions at the TRC for his time in the Border Wars, he retained his position in the democratic South Africa, serving as an institutional memory for a new generation of police recruits. Zoe Zondi is tasked to care for the old man. Her gentle and compassionate nature prompts Hans to review his decision to go to the grave with all his secrets. Zoe has her own life story to tell and, as their unlikely bond deepens, strengthened by the isolation that COVID-19 lockdown brings, they provide a safe space for each other to say the things that are often left unsaid. Futhi Ntshingila is a writer from Pietermaritzburg. The author of Shameless and Do Not Go Gentle, her work centres on women and marginalised communities. Futhi holds a Master’s Degree in Conflict Resolution and currently lives and works in Pretoria. • ISBN: 9781770107281 • Format: Trade Paperback • Genre: Fiction • Extent: TBC • Price: R290,00 IMMEDIATE RELEASE Shuggie Bain Winner of the Booker Prize 2020 July release Douglas Stuart It is 1981. Glasgow is dying and good families must grift to survive. Agnes Bain has always expected more from life.
    [Show full text]
  • Red Neighbours ...The LFC Newsletter for Residents of Anfield
    Red Neighbours ...the LFC newsletter for residents of Anfield Issue: June/July 2019 Dear Neighbour, Community News Welcome to our June/July Red Neighbours newsletter, which provides you with the latest news and updates about what’s Food poverty and education happening in your local community with our Red Neighbours team. LFC volunteers lend a hand at As we head towards the summer and another fantastic season draws to a close on the pitch, our Red Neighbours team have been working local community garden tirelessly off the pitch within our local community. Red Neighbours and Liverpool FC staff volunteers lent a hand at a local community allotment in May. In the last two months, numerous events and activities have taken place throughout L4, L5 and L6 including career speed networking sessions, The group spent the morning at Pinehurst Community Garden in Anfield - local school visits, Easter competitions, ticket giveaways, foodbank visits which grows food for local families in need - to help with weeding the beds in and volunteering at a local community garden. preparation for planting. You can read more about these activities below. As always, we’d like to Red Neighbours have already visited the allotment twice to date and will hear your views and feedback on the work we are doing in your local return next month to continue supporting the valued local initiative. community, so please get in touch with us using the contact details listed on the back of the newsletter. Thanks for taking the time to read and we hope to hear from you soon.
    [Show full text]
  • Leigh Centurions V ROCHDALE HORNETS
    Leigh Centurions SUvN DRAOY C17HTDH AMLAREC H O20R1N9 @ET 3S PM # LEYTHERS # OURTOWNOURCLUB# OURTOWNOURCLUB # LEYTHERS # OURTOWNOURCLUB# OURTOWNOURCLUB engage with the fans at games and to see the players acknowledged for their efforts at the Toronto game, despite the narrowness of the defeat, was something Welcome to Leigh Sports Village for day 48 years ago. With a new community that will linger long in the memory. this afternoon’s Betfred stadium in the offing for both the city’s Games are coming thick and fast at FChamRpionshOip gameM agains t oTur HfootbEall team s iTt could Oalso welPl also be present and the start of our involvement in friends from Rochdale Hornets. the last time Leigh play there. the Corals Challenge Cup and the newly- Carl Forster is to be commended for It’s great to see the Knights back on the instigated 1895 Cup and the prospect of taking on the dual role of player and coach up after years in the doldrums and to see playing at Wembley present great at such a young age and after cutting his interest in the professional game revived opportunities and goals for Duffs and his teeth in two years at Whitehaven, where under James Ford’s astute coaching. players. The immediate task though is to he built himself a good reputation, he now Watching York back at their much-loved carry on the good form in a tight and has the difficult task of preserving Wiggington Road ground was always one competitive Championship where every Hornets’ hard-won Championship status in of the best away days in the season and I win is hard-earned and valuable.
    [Show full text]
  • P16 Layout 1
    TUESDAY, JUNE 20, 2017 SPORTS AUB announces participation in a Walk- A-Thon in support of autism stricken KUWAIT: Ahli United Bank (AUB) announced its par- eral and the facilities it accords to its clients from ticipation in a Walk-A-Thon in the Avenue Mall recent- this category. ly. The activity was organized by Autism Partnership Ahli United Bank added that it is keen to partici- Center - Kuwait, designated for individuals suffering pate in such events which aim at making a noticeable from autism. A large number of individuals participat- and serious change in the lives of affected children ed which had a great impact on creating awareness through promoting society awareness of the nature with the problem of autism. of Autism and the necessity of having early and accu- On this occasion, Ahli United Bank issued a state- rate diagnosis and how to provide timely assistance ment expressing its happiness with providing the nec- to affected individuals to enable their integration in essary support for the success of this Walk-A-Thon the society. which aims at educating the society about autism and Ahli United Bank expressed its gratitude to the reflects efforts of solidarity with Autism stricken indi- Autism Partnership Center - Kuwait, where their viduals and their families. efforts have contributed to the awareness with the Ahli United Bank’s support came in line with its problem of Autism. social responsibility towards the various categories For more information on Ahli United Bank’s prod- of the society especially the more needy ones who ucts and services, customers are invited to visit any of deserve support.
    [Show full text]
  • Pan Macmillan AUTUMN CATALOGUE 2021 PUBLICITY CONTACTS
    Pan Macmillan AUTUMN CATALOGUE 2021 PUBLICITY CONTACTS General enquiries [email protected] Alice Dewing FREELANCE [email protected] Anna Pallai Amy Canavan [email protected] [email protected] Caitlin Allen Camilla Elworthy [email protected] [email protected] Elinor Fewster Emma Bravo [email protected] [email protected] Emma Draude Gabriela Quattromini [email protected] [email protected] Emma Harrow Grace Harrison [email protected] [email protected] Jacqui Graham Hannah Corbett [email protected] [email protected] Jamie-Lee Nardone Hope Ndaba [email protected] [email protected] Laura Sherlock Jess Duffy [email protected] [email protected] Ruth Cairns Kate Green [email protected] [email protected] Philippa McEwan [email protected] Rosie Wilson [email protected] Siobhan Slattery [email protected] CONTENTS MACMILLAN PAN MANTLE TOR PICADOR MACMILLAN COLLECTOR’S LIBRARY BLUEBIRD ONE BOAT MACMILLAN Nine Lives Danielle Steel Nine Lives is a powerful love story by the world’s favourite storyteller, Danielle Steel. Nine Lives is a thought-provoking story of lost love and new beginnings, by the number one bestseller Danielle Steel. After a carefree childhood, Maggie Kelly came of age in the shadow of grief. Her father, a pilot, died when she was nine. Maggie saw her mother struggle to put their lives back together. As the family moved from one city to the next, her mother warned her about daredevil men and to avoid risk at all cost. Following her mother’s advice, and forgoing the magic of first love with a high-school boyfriend who she thought too wild, Maggie married a good, dependable man.
    [Show full text]
  • Toowoomba Grammar School Fidelis in Omnibus the School Welcomed Harry Hornery During His Recent Visit Back to Australia from California, USA
    Volume 28 No.2 August 2018 Toowoomba Grammar School Fidelis in Omnibus The School welcomed Harry Hornery during his recent visit back to Australia from California, USA. Harry left TGS a year ago to attend Mater Dei High School in Santa Ana to pursue a Basketball career. His team has just won the CIF State Championship. At 6ft8 Harry is one of the tallest on the team; year 7 student Owen Austin couldn't get close. From the Headmaster ...............................................................................................2 From the President ................................................................................................. 21 The New Queensland Certificate of Education .....................................4 Old Boy News ...................................................................................................... 22-30 ANZAC Day Service ....................................................................................................5 Centenary of the GPS ................................................................................................6 Volume 28 No.2 August 2018 Editor: Toowoomba Grammar School Publications Department Latin Club ...........................................................................................................................7 Photography: TGS Publications Contribution to Community Service.....................................................8-10 Department and various students and staff members & Mr Wes McRae New Glen McCracken Sports Centre ........................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Quantifying the Collision Dose in Rugby League: a Systematic Review, Meta
    Naughton et al. Sports Medicine - Open (2020)6:50 https://doi.org/10.1186/s40798-020-00263-w CORRECTION Open Access Correction to: Quantifying the Collision Dose in Rugby League: A Systematic Review, Meta-analysis, and Critical Analysis Mitchell Naughton1*, Ben Jones1,2,3,4,5, Sharief Hendricks5,2,6, Doug King1,7,8, Aron Murphy1 and Cloe Cummins1,2,9 Correction to: Sports Med - Open 6:6 (2020) https://doi.org/10.1186/s40798-019-0233-9 An incompletely revised version of the above article was inadvertently submitted for publication before all Reference authors had the opportunity to approve the manuscript. 1. Naughton M, et al. Quantifying the Collision Dose in Rugby League: A As a result, multiple errors were present in the published Systematic Review, Meta-analysis, and Critical Analysis. Sports Med - Open. 2020;6:6. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40798-019-0233-9. article [1]. These relate to: – The number of articles assessed. – Reference citation details. – Data errors. – Figs 1, 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5, 6a, 6b and 6c. – Tables 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6. The full article with all corrections is re-published ahead. Author details 1School of Science and Technology, University of New England, Armidale, NSW, Australia. 2Carnegie Applied Rugby Research (CARR) centre, Institute for Sport Physical Activity and Leisure, Leeds Beckett University, Leeds, UK. 3Leeds Rhinos Rugby League club, Leeds, UK. 4England Performance Unit, The Rugby Football League, Leeds, UK. 5Division of Exercise Science and Sports Medicine, Department of Human Biology, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • Bulletin December 2019
    MESSAGE FROM THE PRINCIPAL Welcome to the fi nal edition of the bulletin for 2019 and a celebration of another fabulous year of outstanding achievements at Erindale College. There have been many successes accomplished by our students and staff this year, and we have an opportunity to refl ect and celebrate the extraordinary talents of those in our incredible community. It is also an important time to recognise and value the contribution of those ‘behind the scenes’ without whom, these talents can not be realised. We know that behind every high achiever is a crew of invaluable supporters and believers – you too deserve recognition. Thank you. I would also like to thank each and every one of you for welcoming me so warmly into the college this year. It has been an absolute privilege to work with such a talented and inspiring cohort of young people, and the staff that continue to off er their unwavering support to assist in the achievement of the goals and dreams of the students they educate. As we close out the academic year with a series of celebrations and ceremonies, I bid farewell to our 2019 graduates and extend a warm welcome to our incoming students and their families that will be joining us for the fi rst time in 2020, and welcome back to those families who have been with us before. We are currently experiencing a period of enrolment growth at EC and have some very exciting initiatives commencing next year. We can’t wait to share these with you once students return.
    [Show full text]
  • RL GUIDE 2006 FRIDAY PM 17/1/12 14:40 Page 1
    rfl official guide 2012 working.e$S:RL GUIDE 2006 FRIDAY PM 17/1/12 14:40 Page 1 RFL Official Guide 201 2 rfl official guide 2012 working.e$S:RL GUIDE 2006 FRIDAY PM 17/1/12 14:40 Page 2 The text of this publication is printed on 100gsm Cyclus 100% recycled paper rfl official guide 2012 working.e$S:RL GUIDE 2006 FRIDAY PM 17/1/12 14:40 Page 1 CONTENTS Contents RFL B COMPETITIONS Index ........................................................... 02 B1 General Competition Rules .................. 154 RFL Directors & Presidents ........................... 10 B2 Match Day Rules ................................ 163 RFL Offices .................................................. 10 B3 League Competition Rules .................. 166 RFL Executive Management Team ................. 11 B4 Challenge Cup Competition Rules ........ 173 RFL Council Members .................................. 12 B5 Championship Cup Competition Rules .. 182 Directors of Super League (Europe) Ltd, B6 International/Representative Community Board & RFL Charities ................ 13 Matches ............................................. 183 Past Life Vice Presidents .............................. 15 B7 Reserve & Academy Rules .................. 186 Past Chairmen of the Council ........................ 15 Past Presidents of the RFL ............................ 16 C PERSONNEL Life Members, Roll of Honour, The Mike Gregory C1 Players .............................................. 194 Spirit of Rugby League Award, Operational Rules C2 Club Officials .....................................
    [Show full text]
  • Covid 19 (Coronavirus) Ticketing FAQ’S
    Covid 19 (Coronavirus) Ticketing FAQ’s Public health considerations – for everyone - and particularly the most vulnerable in all our communities - are everyone’s priority. The Rugby Football League and Super League are following and have always followed Government’s advice and will continue to do so. We are in constant contact with the relevant Government Departments who are informed by the national scientific and medical experts. All tickets purchased with RFL ticketing are subject to the standard terms and conditions of sale which can be found on our ticketing website https://www.rugby- league.com/tickets/terms__conditions Please understand that due to the high volume of enquiries, our ticketing team is experiencing higher numbers of calls and emails at the current time and it may therefore take a little longer than normal for us to respond. We will endeavour to respond to all our customers within 72 hours at this time. We are working remotely in line with the government restrictions and we appreciate your patience. Dacia Magic Weekend Dacia Magic Weekend at St James’ Park is postponed. The event was due to make its return to Newcastle on May 23-24. Betfred Super League intends to keep Dacia Magic Weekend in the 2020 schedule and all options are being considered as part of extensive and ongoing fixtures remodelling. More information will be provided once there is a clearer picture regarding the resumption of the season. Tickets already bought for Dacia Magic Weekend in Newcastle will be transferable to a later date at St James’ Park, or an alternative venue depending on when the season restarts.
    [Show full text]
  • Councillor John Lawson
    Fixture Date Councillor Councillor C Burke x 2 (24.10.2016) / Thursday 16th Feb 2017 Salford Red Devils Councillor John Lawson (03.11.2016) th Cllr C Burke x 2 (20.02.17) Wakefield Trinity Wildcats Friday 24 Feb 2017 Councillor C Burke x 2 (24.10.2016) / Thursday 2 March 2017 Hull FC Councillor John Lawson (03.11.2016) Councillor C Burke x 2 (24.10.2016) / Friday 24th March 2017 Leeds Rhinos Councillor John Lawson (03.11.2016) th Councillor Cathy Scott x 2 (27.03.17) Castleford Tigers Thursday 4 May 2017 Warrington Wolves Sunday 4th June 2017 Councillor Cahal Burke x 2 (02.06.17) Widnes Vikings Friday 7th July 2017 Councillor Cahal Burke x 2 (06.07.17) Councillor Cahal Burke x 2 (11.7.17) Leigh Centurions Friday 14th July 2017 Councillor John Lawson x 2 (11.7.17) Councillor C Burke x 2 (24.08.17) Super 8s - Giants V Castleford Tigers 1st September 2017 Councillor J Lawson x 2 (24.08.17) Super 8s - Giants V Leeds Rhinos 22nd September 2017 Councillor C Scott x 2 (26.07.2017) Councillor C Burke x 2 (7.11.17) Warrington Wolves Thursday 8th February 2018 Councillor J Lawson x 2 (7.11.17) Councillor C Burke x 2 (7.11.17) St Helens Friday 23rd February 2018 Councillor J Lawson x 2 (7.11.17) Councillor C Burke x 2 (7.11.17) Leeds Rhinos Friday 30th March 2018 Councillor J Lawson x 2 (7.11.17) Cllr C Burke x 2 (23.07.18) Widnes Vikings Friday 4th May 2018 Cllr J Lawson x 2 (23.07.18) Hull FC Thursday 5th July 2018 Councillor C Scott x 2 (04.01.2018) Fixture Date Kick off Councillor Salford Red Devils Thursday 16th Feb 2017 8:00pm Councillor C
    [Show full text]