DOCSLIB.ORG

Fifth Round Evaluation Report on Estonia

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Fifth Round Evaluation Report on Estonia Adoption | Publication Public 7 December 2018 GrecoEval5Rep(2018)3 FIFTH EVALUATION ROUND Preventing corruption and promoting integrity in central governments (top executive functions) and law enforcement agencies EVALUATION REPORT ESTONIA 7 Adopted by GRECO at its 81st Plenary Meeting (Strasbourg, 3-7 December 2018) TABLE OF CONTENTS I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................................................. 4 II. INTRODUCTION AND METHODOLOGY ..................................................................................................... 6 III. CONTEXT .................................................................................................................................................. 7 IV. CORRUPTION PREVENTION IN CENTRAL GOVERNMENTS (TOP EXECUTIVE FUNCTIONS) ......................... 9 SYSTEM OF GOVERNMENT AND TOP EXECUTIVE FUNCTIONS.............................................................................................. 9 Status and remuneration of persons with top executive functions ............................................................. 13 ANTICORRUPTION AND INTEGRITY POLICY, REGULATORY AND INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK .................................................. 14 Legal framework/ethical principles and rules of conduct ............................................................................ 15 Institutional framework ............................................................................................................................... 17 Awareness ................................................................................................................................................... 18 TRANSPARENCY AND OVERSIGHT OF EXECUTIVE ACTIVITIES OF CENTRAL GOVERNMENT ........................................................ 19 Access to information .................................................................................................................................. 19 Transparency of the law-making process .................................................................................................... 20 Third parties and lobbyists........................................................................................................................... 20 Control mechanisms .................................................................................................................................... 21 CONFLICTS OF INTEREST .......................................................................................................................................... 22 PROHIBITION OR RESTRICTION OF CERTAIN ACTIVITIES ................................................................................................... 24 Incompatibilities, outside activities and financial interests ......................................................................... 24 Contracts with state authorities .................................................................................................................. 24 Gifts ............................................................................................................................................................. 25 Misuse of public resources ........................................................................................................................... 25 Misuse of confidential information ............................................................................................................. 25 Post-employment restrictions ...................................................................................................................... 26 DECLARATION OF ASSETS, INCOME, LIABILITIES AND INTERESTS ....................................................................................... 27 Declaration requirements ............................................................................................................................ 27 Review mechanisms ..................................................................................................................................... 28 ACCOUNTABILITY AND ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS .................................................................................................... 30 Criminal proceedings and immunities ......................................................................................................... 30 Non-criminal enforcement mechanisms ...................................................................................................... 31 V. CORRUPTION PREVENTION IN LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES .............................................................. 32 ORGANISATION AND ACCOUNTABILITY LAW ENFORCEMENT/POLICE AUTHORITIES ............................................................... 32 Overview of various law enforcement authorities ....................................................................................... 32 Access to information .................................................................................................................................. 33 Public trust in law enforcement authorities ................................................................................................ 34 Trade unions and professional organisations .............................................................................................. 34 ANTI-CORRUPTION AND INTEGRITY POLICY .................................................................................................................. 34 Anti-corruption strategy .............................................................................................................................. 34 RISK MANAGEMENT MEASURES FOR CORRUPTION PRONE AREAS ..................................................................................... 35 Advice, training and awareness ................................................................................................................... 38 RECRUITMENT, CAREER AND CONDITIONS OF SERVICE ................................................................................................... 39 Appointment procedure............................................................................................................................... 39 Performance evaluation and promotion to a higher rank ........................................................................... 40 Rotation ....................................................................................................................................................... 42 Termination of service and dismissal from office ........................................................................................ 42 Salaries and benefits .................................................................................................................................... 43 CONFLICTS OF INTEREST .......................................................................................................................................... 43 PROHIBITION OR RESTRICTION OF CERTAIN ACTIVITIES ................................................................................................... 44 Incompatibilities and outside activities ....................................................................................................... 44 Gifts ............................................................................................................................................................. 46 Misuse of public resources ........................................................................................................................... 47 Third party contacts, confidential information ............................................................................................ 47 Post-employment restrictions ...................................................................................................................... 48 DECLARATION OF ASSETS, INCOME, LIABILITIES AND INTERESTS ....................................................................................... 49 2 DECLARATION REQUIREMENTS ................................................................................................................................. 49 REVIEW MECHANISMS ............................................................................................................................................ 49 OVERSIGHT AND ENFORCEMENT ............................................................................................................................... 50 Internal oversight and control ..................................................................................................................... 50 External oversight and control..................................................................................................................... 51 Complaints system ....................................................................................................................................... 51 REPORTING OBLIGATIONS AND WHISTLEBLOWER PROTECTION ........................................................................................ 53 Reporting obligations .................................................................................................................................. 53 Whistleblower protection ............................................................................................................................ 54 ENFORCEMENT PROCEDURE AND SANCTIONS .............................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Trafficking in Human Beings
    TemaNord 2014:526 TemaNord Ved Stranden 18 DK-1061 Copenhagen K www.norden.org Trafficking in Human Beings Report from a conference on Identification of victims and criminals Trafficking in Human Beings – why we do not notice them In the Nordic countries, most of the reported cases of trafficking in human beings today concern women and girls trafficked for sexual exploitation, but experiences from Europe indicate that human trafficking has increased also in farming, household work, construction, and house building, as well as in begging, shoplifting and thefts. The conference Identification of victims and criminals – why we do not notice them on 30–31 May 2013 in Tallinn, Estonia formed the conclusion of a Nordic-Baltic-Northwest Russian cooperation project. Around 80 participants attended the two-day conference to discuss ways of identifying victims and criminals and to find answer to the question of why we do not notice victims or criminals, even though we now have available to us facts, figures, research and knowledge about human trafficking as a part of international organized crime. TemaNord 2014:526 ISBN 978-92-893-2767-1 ISBN 978-92-893-2768-8 (EPUB) ISSN 0908-6692 conference proceeding TN2014526 omslag.indd 1 09-04-2014 07:18:39 Trafficking in Human Beings Report from a conference on Identification of victims and criminals – why we do not notice them TemaNord 2014:526 Trafficking in Human Beings Report from a conference on Identification of victims and criminals - why we do not notice them ISBN 978-92-893-2767-1 ISBN 978-92-893-2768-8 (EPUB) http://dx.doi.org/10.6027/TN2014-526 TemaNord 2014:526 ISSN 0908-6692 © Nordic Council of Ministers 2014 Layout: Hanne Lebech Cover photo: Beate Nøsterud Photo: Reelika Riimand Print: Rosendahls-Schultz Grafisk Copies: 516 Printed in Denmark This publication has been published with financial support by the Nordic Council of Ministers.
    [Show full text]
  • International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial
    UNITED NATIONS CERD International Convention on Distr. the Elimination GENERAL of all Forms of CERD/C/329/Add.2 Racial Discrimination 5 July 1999 Original: ENGLISH COMMITTEE ON THE ELIMINATION OF RACIAL DISCRIMINATION REPORTS SUBMITTED BY STATES PARTIES UNDER ARTICLE 9 OF THE CONVENTION Fourth periodic report of States parties due in 1998 Addendum Estonia* [16 March 1999] _______________________ * This document contains the initial, second, third and fourth periodic reports of Estonia, submitted in one document, due on 20 November 1992, 1994, 1996 and 1998. GE.99-42697 (E) CERD/C/329/Add.2 page 2 CONTENTS Paragraphs Page Introduction .............................................................................................. 1 - 9 6 I. GENERAL INFORMATION ............................................................. 10 - 60 6 A. State structure................................................................. 19 - 28 8 B. The economy .................................................................. 29 - 35 9 C. Ethnic composition of the population.............................. 36 - 54 10 D. Estonia’s international obligations .................................. 55 - 60 14 II. INFORMATION ON THE ARTICLES OF THE CONVENTION ......................................................................... 61 - 417 16 A. Article 2 ......................................................................... 61 - 80 16 1. Prohibition of racial discrimination .......................... 62 - 63 16 2. Protection of national minorities..............................
    [Show full text]
  • Border Management Reform in Transition Democracies
    Border Management Reform in Transition Democracies Editors Aditya Batara G Beni Sukadis Contributors Pierre Aepli Colonel Rudito A.A. Banyu Perwita, PhD Zoltán Nagy Lieutenant-Colonel János Hegedűs First Edition, June 2007 Layout Front Cover Lebanese-Israeli Borders Downloaded from: www.michaelcotten.com Printed by Copyright DCAF & LESPERSSI, 2007 The Geneva Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces FOREWORD Suripto, SH Vice Chairman of 3rd Commission, Indonesian House of Representatives And Chariman of Lesperssi Founder Board Border issues have been one of the largest areas of concern for Indonesia. Since becoming a sovereign state 61 years ago, Indonesia is still facing a series of territorial border problems. Up until today, Indonesia has reached agreements with its neighbouring countries related to demarcation and state border delineation. However, the lack of an unequivocal authority for border management has left serious implications for the state’s sovereignty and its citizen’s security. The Indonesian border of today, is still having to deal with border crime, which includes the violation of the territorial border, smuggling and terrorist infiltration, illegal fishing, illegal logging and Human Rights violations. These kinds of violations have also made a serious impact on the state’s sovereignty and citizen’s security. As of today, Indonesia still has an ‘un-settled’ sea territory, with regard to the rights of sovereignty (Additional Zone, Economic Exclusive Zone, and continent plate). This frequently provokes conflict between the authorised sea-territory officer on patrol and foreign ships or fishermen from neighbouring countries. One of the principal border problems is the Sipadan-Ligitan dispute between Indonesia and Malaysia, which started in 1969.
    [Show full text]
  • Women in Police Services Eu 2012
    WOMEN IN POLICE SERVICES IN THE EU FACTS AND FIGURES - 2012 © 2013 Institut for Public Security of Catalonia Ctra. C-17 Barcelona-Ripoll, km 13,5 08100 - Mollet del Vallès www.gencat.cat/interior/ispc Editor: Lola Vallès [email protected] Design: Conxita Gandia February 2013 Women in police services in the EU 2012 Summary Introduction.......................................................................................................................... 5 The researchers................................................................................................................. 7 Acknowledgements............................................................................................................ 7 The questionnaire .............................................................................................................. 9 Austria ................................................................................................................................ 11 Belgium .............................................................................................................................. 13 Cyprus ................................................................................................................................ 15 Denmark ............................................................................................................................. 17 England and Wales............................................................................................................ 19 Estonia...............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Practical Aspects of Cooperation Between the State Border Guard of Latvia and Federal Security Service Border Guard Service of Russian Federation
    PRACTICAL ASPECTS OF COOPERATION BETWEEN THE STATE BORDER GUARD OF LATVIA AND FEDERAL SECURITY SERVICE BORDER GUARD SERVICE OF RUSSIAN FEDERATION Jekaterina Kuprijanova1, Juris Livdāns2 Iluta Arbidāne3 1 State Border Guard, Latvia, e-mail: [email protected] 2State Border Guard, Latvia, e-mail: [email protected] 3 Rezekne Academy of Technologies, Latvia, e-mail: [email protected] Abstract. One of the main State Border Guard priorities is to maintain and develop the state border guarding system, according to the European Union external borders requirements, by fulfilling the conditions of the Schengen acquis. Schengen acquis provides that international cooperation in the field of border security can have multilateral, bilateral and local dimensions. In this context, an agreements concluded with bordering countries on cooperation in the field of border management is an effective tool to strengthen border security (EU Schengen Catalogue, 2002). In research as methodology are used scientific literature in the field of international law, treaties and agreements, the law of the Republic of Latvia, the State border guard of the internal regulations and the State border guard of unpublished materials. The Republic of Latvia and the Russian Federation cooperate in the field of development and implementation of coherent measures for the border control. Cooperation with RF is executed based on treaties and agreements concluded, as well, maintaining contacts between competent representatives of both countries at various management levels. The extensive cooperation between neighbouring countries on maintenance of security at the border results in the elucidation of the incidents occurring at the state border and other relevant issues, at the same time providing stability and security at the common border.
    [Show full text]
  • The Res Publica Party in Estonia
    Meteoric Trajectory: The Res Publica Party in Estonia REIN TAAGEPERA Formed in 2001, Res Publica won the Estonian parliamentary elections in 2003, and its leader became prime minister. It failed to win a single seat in the European Parliament in 2004 and was down to 5 per cent in opinion polls in 2005 when it dropped out of the cabinet. The founding chairperson of the party analyses here the causes for Res Publica’s rapid rise and fall, reviewing the socio-political background and drawing comparisons with other new parties in Europe. Res Publica was a genuinely new party that involved no previous major players. It might be charac- terized as a ‘purifying bridge party’ that filled an empty niche at centre right. Its rise was among the fastest in Europe. For success of a new party, each of three factors must be present to an appreciable degree: Prospect of success ¼ Members  Money  Visibility. Res Publica had all three, but rapid success spoiled the party leadership. Their governing style became arrogant and they veered to the right, alienating their centrist core constituency. It no longer mattered for the quality of Estonian politics whether Res Publica faded or survived. Key words: new parties; Estonia; Res Publica; rightist politics Democratization includes developing a workable party system. Around 2000, I would have told anyone who cared to listen that Estonia had too many parties. A study by Grofman, Mikkel and Taagepera1 also noted that no major new player had entered the field since 1995. We characterized the party constellation in the early 1990s as kaleidoscopic, but gave figures to show that the party system in Estonia seemed to stabilize.
    [Show full text]
  • EDU Letter Template
    Europol Public Information Management Board Membership September 2017 Chairperson Mr Priit Pärkna Intelligence Management and Investigation Estonian Police and Border Guard Board Member State MB member Department/Agency/Ministry Alternate MB member Department/Agency/Ministry Austria Ms Regine International Police Cooperation - Mr Christian Wandl International Police Cooperation Wieselthaler- Federal Police Ministry of Interior Buchmann Ministry of Interior Belgium Mr Peter De International Police Cooperation - Mr Frederik Van Oost International Police Cooperation - Buysscher Federal Police Federal Police Ministry of Interior Ministry of Interior Bulgaria Mr Valentin International Operational Cooperation Ms Kremena Peneva Head of LB Bulgaria Vasilev Kostov Directorate Platikanova-Nenova Ministry of Interior Croatia Mr Ante Orlović Criminal Police Directorate Mr Dalibor Jurić Sector for Criminal Police Support Cyprus Mr Demetris European Union and International Ms Maria Charalambous European Union and International Demetriou Police Cooperation Directorate Police Cooperation Directorate Czech Republic Ms Šárka International Police Cooperation - Mr Václav Rukner International Police Cooperation - Havránková Police Presidium Police Presidium Ministry of Interior Ministry of Interior Estonia Mr Ivo Kolk Head of Intelligence Management Ms Mirja Virve Estonian Liaison Bureau Bureau Police and Border Guard Board Finland Mr Timo Antero National Police Board Ms Marja Kartila National Police Board Saarinen Ministry of Interior Ministry of Interior
    [Show full text]
  • Work Programme 2015
    European Crime Prevention Network Work Programme 2015 February 2015 Table of content Background ……………………………………………………………………………………..……… p. 3 Funding ………..…………………………………………………………………………………………….. p. 3 The present Trio …........................................................................................... p. 3 Latvian Presidency, January 20115 – June 2015 ………………………………………. p. 4 Luxembourgish Presidency, July 2015 – December 2015 …………………………. p. 4 Activities in the Network in 2015 …………………………………………………………….. p. 5 A) To be a point of reference for the target groups of the Network ………. p. 5 B) To disseminate qualitative knowledge on crime prevention ……………… p. 8 1. Projects ……………………………………………………….………………. p. 8 2. Actions and tasks associated with Strategic Goal B ………. p. 12 C) To support and facilitate crime prevention activities at national and local level ………………………………………………………………………………………… p. 14 D) To develop various aspects of crime prevention at EU level in respect of the EU strategy of crime prevention …………………………………………………. p. 15 E) To develop a new Multiannual strategy and develop a concrete proposal for the future of the EUCPN and its secretariat ………………………………. p. 17 Annex 1 Work Programme Projects ………………………………………………….. p. 18 2 Background This EUCPN Work Programme succeeds that of March 2014. The Work Programme 2015 is in accordance with Article 4 of the Council Decision 2009/902/JHA and Article 12 of the Rules of Procedures for the EUCPN. As foreseen in the Multiannual Strategy for the EUCPN, this document defines the activities of the Network to be completed in 2015 in order to promote the achievement of the strategic goals, namely: A) To be a point of reference for the target groups of the Network. B) To disseminate qualitative knowledge on crime prevention. C) To support crime prevention activities at national and local level.
    [Show full text]
  • Présidential Election in Estonia
    PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION IN ESTONIA 29th and 30th August 2011 European Elections monitor President of the Republic Toomas Hendrik Ilves is running for re-election as Head of Estonia from Corinne Deloy Translated by Helen Levy The presidential election will take place on 29th and 30th August next in Estonia. The 101 members of the Riigikogu, the only chamber in Parliament, are being invi- ANALYSIS ted to appoint the new Head of State. Toomas Hendrik Ilves, the Head of State in 1 month before office, announced last December that he would be running for re-election. He has the poll the support of the Reform Party (ER) led by Prime Minister Andrus Ansip, the Pro Patria Union-Res Publica (IRL), member of the government coalition and the Social Democratic Party (SDE), T. Ilves’s party. The 23 MPs of the Pro Patria Union-Res Publica have 7) by the main opposition party, the Centre Party already signed a document expressing their support (KE), on 18th June last. Indrek Tarand is the son to the outgoing Head of State. “From our point of of former Prime Minister (1994-1995) and former view, thanks to his work, Toomas Hendrik Ilves, has MEP (2004-2009), Social Democrat, Andres Tarand. helped towards the development of civil society and In the last European elections on 4th-7th June 2009 has encouraged debate over problems that Estonia he stood as an independent and came second with has to face. The President of the Republic also suc- 25.81% of the vote, i.e. just behind the Centre Party ceeded in taking firm decisions during the crises that (26.07%) rallying a great number of protest votes the country experienced, such as for example, the to his name.
    [Show full text]
  • Anniversary Publication
    Ten Years of Europol 1999-2009 TEN YEARS OF EUROPOL, 1999-2009 Europol Corporate Communications P.O. Box 90850 2509 LW The Hague The Netherlands www.europol.europa.eu © European Police OfÞ ce, 2009 All rights reserved. Reproduction in any form or by any means is allowed only with the prior permission of Europol Editor: Agnieszka Biegaj Text: Andy Brown Photographs: Europol (Zoran Lesic, Bo Pallavicini, Max Schmits, Marcin Skowronek, Europol archives); EU Member States’ Law Enforcement Authorities; European Commission; European Council; Participants of the Europol Photo Competition 2009: Kristian Berlin, Devid Camerlynck, Janusz Gajdas, Jean-François Guiot, Lasse Iversen, Robert Kralj, Tomasz Kurczynski, Antte Lauhamaa, Florin Lazau, Andrzej Mitura, Peter Pobeska, Pawel Ostaszewski, Jorgen Steen, Georges Vandezande Special thanks to all the photographers, EU Member States’ Law Enforcement Authorities and Europol Liaison Bureaux for their contributions 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction 7 I. Birth of an Idea, 1991-1998 11 1. Ideas behind Europol: Tackling International Crime 11 2. Maastricht Treaty: the ‘Founding Article’ 12 3. First Step: the Europol Drugs Unit 12 4. The Hague: a Fitting Location 13 5. Formal Status: the Europol Convention 14 6. European Union: New Members and a New Treaty 15 II. The First Years, 1999-2004 21 1. Facing the Challenges: Stabilisation and Consolidation 21 2. Changing Priorities, Flexible Organisation 24 3. Information Exchange and Intelligence Analysis: Core Business 27 4. The Hague Programme: Positioning Europol at the Centre of EU Law Enforcement Cooperation 34 5. Casting the Net Wider: Cooperation Agreements with Third States and Organisations 36 6. Europol’s Most Important Asset: the Staff and the ELO Network 37 III.
    [Show full text]
  • Republic of Estonia Country Report Table of Contents
    m o c 30 km . s p a m - 20 mi d © Maardu Tallinn Rakvere Kohtla- Sillamäe Narva Kiviõli Järve Jõhvi Keila Tapa Haapsalu Paide Jõgeva Viljandi Tartu Pärnu Kuressaare Põlva Võru Valga Republic of Estonia Country Report Table of contents Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................................. 2 One of the three Baltic States occupied by the Soviet Union from 1940 until 1991, Estonia has made impressive economic and political progress since regaining independence. Read more. History ................................................................................................................................................................ 2 Estonia, slightly smaller in area than New Hampshire and Vermont combined, is bordered by Latvia, Russia, the Baltic Sea, and the Gulf of Finland. Read more. Government and Economy.................................................................................................................................. 3 Estonia is a mature, stable parliamentary democracy with legislative, executive, and judicial branches, of which the unicameral Parliament (Riigikogu) holds the most power. Its 101 members are popularly elected every four years. Read more. Foreign Policy ...................................................................................................................................................... 4 Estonia has good relations with its Baltic neighbors and is a member of the Council of Baltic
    [Show full text]
  • 101 Biograafiat-2021-June.Pdf
    101 BIOGRAPHIES The 14th Riigikogu June 17, 2021 Tallinn 2021 Compiled on the basis of questionnaires completed by members of the Riigikogu / Reviewed semi-annually Compiled by Marge Allandi, Rita Hillermaa and Piret Pärgma / Translated by the Chancellery of the Riigi- kogu / Estonian edition edited by Gerli Randjärv, English edition by Piret Pärgma / Cover by Tuuli Aule / Layout by Margit Plink / Photos by Erik Peinar ISSN 2674-3205 Copyright: Chancellery of the Riigikogu, National Library of Estonia CONTENTS Members of the 14th Riigikogu 3 Members of the Riigikogu by Constituency 114 Members of the Riigikogu by Faction 117 Members of the Riigikogu by Committee 120 Members of the Riigikogu Whose Mandate Has Been Suspended or Has Terminated 124 List of Riigikogus 148 Abbreviations and Select Glossary 149 CONTENTS CONTENTS 2 Members MEMBERS OF Merry Aart Uno Kaskpeit Kristen Michal Erki Savisaar THE 14TH RIIGIKOGU Annely Akkermann Erkki Keldo Marko Mihkelson Helir-Valdor Seeder Yoko Alender Kert Kingo Madis Milling Andrus Seeme Tiiu Aro Signe Kivi Aadu Must Sven Sester Riho Breivel Toomas Kivimägi Eduard Odinets Priit Sibul Dmitri Dmitrijev Aivar Kokk Jevgeni Ossinovski Riina Sikkut Ivi Eenmaa Rene Kokk Ivari Padar Imre Sooäär Enn Eesmaa Mihhail Korb Hanno Pevkur Mihhail Stalnuhhin Peeter Ernits Andrei Korobeinik Heljo Pikhof Timo Suslov Hele Everaus Siret Kotka Õnne Pillak Margit Sutrop Kalle Grünthal Heiki Kranich Siim Pohlak Aivar Sõerd Helle-Moonika Helme Igor Kravtšenko Kristina Šmigun-Vähi Anti Poolamets Mart Helme Eerik-Niiles Kross
    [Show full text]