Ïhe Freedom, Equaüty and Dignity of Humari Reason: a Reconsideration of Cartesian Duaiism

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Ïhe Freedom, Equaüty and Dignity of Humari Reason: a Reconsideration of Cartesian Duaiism ïhe Freedom, Equaüty and Dignity of Humari Reason: A Reconsideration of Cartesian Duaiism Sarah Marquardt A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Departnient of Philosophy University of Toronto Q Copyright by Sarah Marquardt 2001 uisiins and Acquisitions et "iBib iographic Setvices senriees bibliogaphiques The author has granted a non- L'auteur a accordé une licence non exclusive licence aiiowing the exclusive permettant à la National Library of Canada to Bibliothèque nationale du Canada de reproduce, loan, disûiie or sel1 reproduire, prêter, distniiuer ou copies of this thesis in microform, vendre des copies de cette thèse sous paper or electronic formats. Ia forme de microfiche/fïh, de reproduction sur papier ou sur format électronique. The author retains ownership of the L'auteur conserve la propriété du copyright in this thesis. Neither the droit d'auteur qui protège cette thèse. thesis nor substantial extracts fiom it Ni la thèse ni des extraits substantiels may be printed or otherwise de celîe-ci ne doivent être imprimes reproduced without the author's ou autrement reproduits sans son permission, autorisation. The Freedom, Equality and Dignity of Human Reason: A Reconsideration of Cartesian Dualism B Y Sarah Marquardt A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Deparmient of Philosophy University of Toronto Augus t 200 1 This dissertation offers a new perspective on Descartes' theory of mind-body dualisrn by situating it at the intersection of two tmjectories of thought in the 17~ceatury: Cartesianisrn and feminism. At the hem of my thesis is the proposition that any coherent understanding of human king requires the assurnption that sustains Descartes' duaiism: freedom of the mind. in order to demonstrate the importance of Descartes' ntionaiist argument for human freedom of rnind, 1 situate his work in the context of two other 17" century rationaiisis who argued for the emancipation of women: Marie de Gournay (1565-1645) and Fmçois Poulain de la Barre (1647-1723). in The Equality of Men and Women (1622) Gournay articdates a new logic of human relations: one of perfect equality between men and women. On this basis, she contradicts two kinds of inequaiity: in women's historicai representation and in their access to education. These arguments, 1 argue, are strengthened in Descartes' reforrnuIation of mind-body dualism in his Medirations on First Philosophy. Descartes' dualisrn supports a heory of sexuai equality by arpuing an equality of tbe Greedom of mind in the power of reason, The freedom of reason does not invohe negating the passions or the body, as some critics contend. This is because embodiment is an innate i&a of human reason and cannot legitimateiy be negagat. It is aIso because the passion and virtue of generosity, the universal standard of human virtue, does not cdfor negation, but for donal understanding of our passions. Generosity is the key to remedying the disorciers of other passions, and, importantiy, it is the basis of respect for other human beings. 1 argue that this respect does not merely mount to a recognition of the freedom of others, but it goes deeper than that: generosity is the basis for the promotion of human freedom. Poulain de la Barre draws on dualism, Freedom and generosity in order to articuiate, like Gournay, a theory of complete sexual equality. He argues that 'the mind has no sex.' Writing in the 1670s, his work thus bridges Cartesianisrn and earlier 17" century feminism. On his view, every hurnan freedorn, both interna1 and extemal, ought to be afforded to women. iii The Freeàom, Quaüty and Dignity of Human Reason: A Recoasideration of Cartesian Dualism Table of Contents Acknowledgements ................................................................................. vi .. Abbreviations ....................................................................................... .VJ Introduction ......................................................................................... .1 L Mind-Body Dualism Reconsidered: Primary Thesis L) Historical Background: Marie de Gournay, René Descartes, François Poulain de Ia Barre 2) Cartesianism and Feminism in the 17th Century Chapter One : Marie de Gournay : An earIy 17th century ntiondist critique of sexism .. 10 L introduction iT. htrinsic sexism IE Extrinsic sexism TV. Refuting extrinsic sexism V. The principIe of equality VI, Rewriting history W. Equality in education Cbapter Two : Descartes :The fieedom, equality and dignity of human reason ........ 29 L Introciuction IL Structure of the Meditarions m Nature of individual thedom 1) Where &dom hkres in the mùid 2) Freedom as httnith hown to the mind 3) The experience of individual kdom IV. The nature of the Cartesian mind 1) Second Mediration :the cogito argument 2) Sixth Meditation :real distinction between mind and body V. Self and Other 1) Introduction 2) Freedom and the body 1 3) Freedom and the passions 1 i) Historical anaiysis of generosity ii) Couteptuai analysis of generosity 4) Freedom and the body II 5) Freedom and the passions II 6) Generosity and respect 7) The natural equality of &dom Chapter Three :François Poulain de la Barre: Against Custom .......................... 87 1. Introduction II. Nature vs. custom on the question of equaiity III* Cornmon opinion on the nature of women IV. An Historical conjecture on the origins of inequality v. Analysis of inequality on Descartes' theory of the passions VI. The mind has no sex VII. Reason's renewai through equal education m. The naturecustom divide in education K. A Cartesian didogue X. The ethics of singularity XI. Eulaiie's dream XII. Conclusion: reflections on freedorn by Gabrielle Suchon, a 17th century philosopher of freedorn Chapter Four :Two Contemporary Feminist Critiques of Descartes: Susan Bordo and Erica Harth ................................................................. 133 Conclusion: Prolegomena to any future (rationaiist) feminism ............................. 145 Appendix 1: Poulain de la Barre: Historicai Conjecture on the Origins of hequality ........................... 148 Appendix II: Eulalie's Dream ................................................................... 15 1 Above dl, this thesis is dedicated to my four parents, Pm,Kate, Richard and Nelson. This tbesis is a labour, not just of my love, but of theirs. Their unconditionai, unswerving love, support and understanding, but most of aii their faith in me, is my stren,gh. To them, 1owe everything. 1 want to thank my brother, James and my sister Michelle. James is my mode1 for tolerance and gwd-humoured but compassionate iasight. Michelle is an exceptional person, whose dynamism and tesilience are an inspiration to me. 1 thank my grandparents, Helen and Joe, and everyone in my family, for they have ail wonderfully supported my academic career. The depth of my gratitude to Mark Clamen is infinite and stands apart in a category of its own. Not only has Mark ken insi& of this jowney with me, but in the times of blindness, Mark has seen through my own eyes, showing me how to recognize what 1 already obscurely knew. Mark's exceptionai inteugence, intuition and deep kindness have sustained me throughout. 1 continue to be inspired by the courage, insight and support of Erin McCarthy, aiways a step ahead of me. The beautifd musical taients and passions of Stephen Ham have ken a chief inspiration to my thinking and he has been an important person in my Life during this time. 1 also owe thanks to Robert Cohen, for he too has been highly supportive of my choices. 1 want to thank, especially, my supervisors, André Gombay and Ronnie de Sousa, André is to my mind the mode1 of Cartesian geaerosity, and he has been a tremendously supportive presence for the duration of my PhD. I owe whatever knowledge 1have acquired about Descartes, and much about the 17~century, to André. Ronnie de Sousa is a thoughtful, perceptive reader, a generous supervisor, and has offered much timely advice about the direction of my thinking. The following abbreviations are used for primary sources fkquently cited in this dissertation. Works by Marie de Gournay EHF Égalité des hommes et desfemmes. In Marie de Gournay :Fragments d'un discoursféminin. Edited by Élyane Dezon-Jones. Paris: Librairie José Corti, 1988. Equality The Equality of Men and Women. Translated by Eileen O'Neiil. In James Sterba, editor. Social and Political Philosophy: Classical Western Texts in Feminist and Multicultural Perspectives. Belmont: Wadsworth, 1998. Wor ks by René Descartes AT Oeuvres de Descartes, 1 1 vols. Edited by C. Adam and P. Tannery. Paris: J. Vrin, 1964-76. Cited by volume and page number. CSM The Philosophical Writings of Descartes, 2 vols. Translated by John Cottingham, Robert Stoothoff and Dugald Murdoch. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985. Cited by volume and page number. CSMK The Philosophical Writings of Descartes, vol 3: The Conespondence. Translated by John Cottingbam, Robert Stoothoff, Dugald Murdoch. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985. Cited by volume and page number. Works by François Poulain de la Barre Égalité De l'égalité des deux sexes. Paris: Fayard, 1984. Éducation De l'éducation des dames pour la conduire de l'esprit dans les sciences et dans les mœurs :entretiens. Edited by Bernard Magné. Touiouse: Université de Toulouse le Mirail, 198 1. At any moment now, we shaii spit forth this Iife of ours, In the meantime, while we stiii draw breath, while we still remain among human beings, let us cultivate our humanity. Seneca, On Anger Reason would overstep aii its bounds if it undertook to explain ...how kedom is possible. - Immanuel Kant, Fomdarions of the Metaphysics of Morals But in history, as in traveling, men usuaily see what they already had in their minds. - John Stuart Mill, The Srlbjection of Women We must leam better What we are and are not. We are not the wind. We are not every vaptmood that tempts Our minds to giddy homeIessness. We must distinguish better Between ourseIves and strangers. There is much that we are noc. There is much that is not. There is much that we have not to be.
Recommended publications
  • L' Honnête Femme
    L’ Honnête Femme: The Respectable Woman in Society and the New Collection of Letters and Responses by Contemporary Women JACQUES DU BOSC • Edited and translated by SHARON DIANE NELL AND AURORA WOLFGANG Iter Inc. Centre for Reformation and Renaissance Studies Toronto 2014 Iter: Gateway to the Middle Ages and Renaissance Tel: 416/978–7074 Email: [email protected] Fax: 416/978–1668 Web: www.itergateway.org Centre for Reformation and Renaissance Studies Victoria University in the University of Toronto Tel: 416/585–4465 Email: [email protected] Fax: 416/585–4430 Web: www.crrs.ca © 2014 Iter Inc. & Centre for Reformation and Renaissance Studies All rights reserved. Printed in Canada. Iter and the Centre for Reformation and Renaissance Studies gratefully acknowledge the generous support of James E. Rabil, in memory of Scottie W. Rabil, toward the publication of this book. Iter and the Centre for Reformation and Renaissance Studies gratefully acknowledge the generous support of the National Endowment for the Humanities toward the publication of this book. Library and Archives Canada Cataloguing in Publication Du Bosc, Jacques, –1660, author L’Honnête femme : the Respectable woman in society and the New collection of letters and responses by contemporary women / Jacques Du Bosc ; edited and translated by Sharon Diane Nell and Aurora Wolfgang. (The other voice in early modern Europe: the Toronto series ; 31) “This translation is based on the 1658 edition of L’Honnête femme and the 1642 edition of Nouveau recueil de lettres des dames de ce temps.”—introduction. Includes bibliographical references and index. Issued in print and electronic formats.
    [Show full text]
  • Durham Research Online
    Durham Research Online Deposited in DRO: 04 April 2018 Version of attached le: Accepted Version Peer-review status of attached le: Peer-reviewed Citation for published item: O'Brien, John (2014) 'Gournay's Gift : a special presentation copy of the 1595 Essais of Montaigne.', The seventeenth century., 29 (4). pp. 317-336. Further information on publisher's website: https://doi.org/10.1080/0268117X.2014.974068 Publisher's copyright statement: This is an Accepted Manuscript of an article published by Taylor Francis in The seventeenth century on 303/11/2014, available online:http://www.tandfonline.com/10.1080/0268117X.2014.974068 Additional information: Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in DRO • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full DRO policy for further details. Durham University Library, Stockton Road, Durham DH1 3LY, United Kingdom Tel : +44 (0)191 334 3042 | Fax : +44 (0)191 334 2971 https://dro.dur.ac.uk Gournay’s Gift: A Presentation Copy of the 1595 Essais John O’Brien A hitherto unrecorded copy of Montaigne’s 1595 Essais, now in the Russell Library at St Patrick’s College, Maynooth, derives from the press of Abel L’Angelier, the essayist’s first Parisian printer.
    [Show full text]
  • A History of Women's Political Thought in Europe, 1400-1700
    This page intentionally left blank A HISTORY OF WOMEN’S POLITICAL THOUGHT IN EUROPE, 1400–1700 This ground-breaking book surveys the history of women’s political thought in Europe, from the late medieval period to the early modern era. The authors examine women’s ideas about topics such as the basis of political authority, the best form of political organisation, justifications of obedience and resistance, and concepts of liberty, toleration, sociability, equality, and self-preservation. Women’s ideas concerning relations between the sexes are discussed in tandem with their broader political outlooks; the authors demonstrate that the development of a distinctively sexual politics is reflected in women’s critiques of marriage, the double standard, and women’s exclusion from government. Women writers are also shown to be indebted to the ancient idea of political virtue, and to be acutely aware of being part of a long tradition of female political commentary. This work will be of tremendous interest to political philosophers, historians of ideas, and feminist scholars alike. jacqueline broad is an Honorary Research Associate in the School of Philosophy and Bioethics at Monash University. She is author of Women Philosophers of the Seventeenth Century (2002) and co-editor with Karen Green of Virtue, Liberty, and Toleration: Political Ideas of European Women, 1400–1800 (2007). karen green is Associate Professor in the School of Philosophy and Bioethics at Monash University. She is author of Dummett: Philosophy of Language (2001) and The Woman of Reason (1995). A HISTORY OF WOMEN’S POLITICAL THOUGHT IN EUROPE, 1400–1700 JACQUELINE BROAD AND KAREN GREEN Monash University CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521888172 © Jacqueline Broad and Karen Green 2009 This publication is in copyright.
    [Show full text]
  • Early Modern Women Philosophers and the History of Philosophy
    Early Modern Women Philosophers and the History of Philosophy EILEEN O’NEILL It has now been more than a dozen years since the Eastern Division of the APA invited me to give an address on what was then a rather innovative topic: the published contributions of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century women to philosophy.1 In that address, I highlighted the work of some sixty early modern women. I then said to the audience, “Why have I presented this somewhat interesting, but nonetheless exhausting . overview of seventeenth- and eigh- teenth-century women philosophers? Quite simply, to overwhelm you with the presence of women in early modern philosophy. It is only in this way that the problem of women’s virtually complete absence in contemporary histories of philosophy becomes pressing, mind-boggling, possibly scandalous.” My presen- tation had attempted to indicate the quantity and scope of women’s published philosophical writing. It had also suggested that an acknowledgment of their contributions was evidenced by the representation of their work in the scholarly journals of the period and by the numerous editions and translations of their texts that continued to appear into the nineteenth century. But what about the status of these women in the histories of philosophy? Had they ever been well represented within the histories written before the twentieth century? In the second part of my address, I noted that in the seventeenth century Gilles Menages, Jean de La Forge, and Marguerite Buffet produced doxogra- phies of women philosophers, and that one of the most widely read histories of philosophy, that by Thomas Stanley, contained a discussion of twenty-four women philosophers of the ancient world.
    [Show full text]
  • THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY PAUL SCOTT, University of Kansas
    THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY PAUL SCOTT, University of Kansas 1. GENERAL Orientalism and discussions of identity and alterity form part of an identifiable trend in our field during the coverage of the two calendar years. Another strong current is the concept of libertinage and its literary and social influence. In terms of the first direction, Nicholas Dew, Orientalism in Louis XlV's France, OUP, 2009, xv+301 pp., publishes an overview of what he terms 'baroque Orientalism' and explores the topos through chapters devoted to the production of texts by d'Herbelot, Bernier, and Thevenot which would have an important reception and influence during the 18th century. The network of the Republic of Letters was crucial in gaining access to and studying oriental works and, while this was a marginal presence during the period, D. reveals how the curiosity of vth-c. scholars would lay the foundations of work that would be drawn on by the philosophes. Duprat, Orient, is an apt complement to Dew's volume, and A. Duprat, 'Le fil et la trame. Motifs orientaux dans les litteratures d'Europe' (9-17) maintains that the depiction of the Orient in European lit. was a common attempt to express certain desires but, at the same time, to contain a general angst as a result of incorporating scientific progress and territorial expansion. Brian Brazeau, Writing a New France, 1604-1632: Empire and Early Modern French Identity, Farnham, Ashgate, 2009, x +132 pp., selects the period following the end of the Wars of Religion because this early period of colonization gave rise to some of the most enthusiastic accounts as well as the fact that they established the pioneering debate for future narratives.
    [Show full text]
  • On Philosophical Style Virpi Lehtinen
    On Philosophical Style Virpi Lehtinen To cite this version: Virpi Lehtinen. On Philosophical Style. European Journal of Women’s Studies, SAGE Publications (UK and US), 2007, 14 (2), pp.109-125. 10.1177/1350506807075817. hal-00571300 HAL Id: hal-00571300 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00571300 Submitted on 1 Mar 2011 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. On Philosophical Style Michèle Le Dœuff and Luce Irigaray Virpi Lehtinen UNIVERSITY OF HELSINKI ABSTRACT Irigaray and Le Dœuff diagnose the problem of woman and philosophy in terms of love. The differing solutions to the problem can be found in their styles. Irigaray’s style is loving and dialogic, transforming the inherent structure of love and reminding us of the traditional feminine position defined by men. Le Dœuff’s style is critical and pluralistic and relates to her perception of the feminine way of philosophical writing. These styles take into account the undervaluation of the feminine in the apparently ‘neutral’ practices of philosophizing and surpass the traditional or unreflected notions of the feminine style. Ultimately, the con- sciously ‘subjective’ styles, with the inherent aims of self-reflectivity and openness for other persons and texts, prove necessary when striving for truth and objectiv- ity.
    [Show full text]
  • THE OTHER VOICE in EARLY MODERN EUROPE: INTRODUCTION to the SERIES Margaret L
    THE OTHER VOICE IN EARLY MODERN EUROPE: INTRODUCTION TO THE SERIES Margaret L. King and Albert Rabil Jr. THE OLD VOICE AND THE OTHER VOICE n western Europe and the United States, women are nearing equality in the Iprofessions, in business, and in politics. Most enjoy access to education, re- productive rights, and autonomy in financial affairs. Issues vital to women are on the public agenda: equal pay, child care, domestic abuse, breast cancer re- search, and curricular revision with an eye to the inclusion of women. These recent achievements have their origins in things women (and some male supporters) said for the first time about six hundred years ago. Theirs is the “other voice,” in contradistinction to the “first voice,” the voice of the educated men who created Western culture. Coincident with a general reshaping of European culture in the period 1300–1700 (called the Renais- sance or early modern period), questions of female equality and opportunity were raised that still resound and are still unresolved. The other voice emerged against the backdrop of a three thousand— year history of the derogation of women rooted in the civilizations related to Western culture: Hebrew, Greek, Roman, and Christian. Negative attitudes toward women inherited from these traditions pervaded the intellectual, medical, legal, religious, and social systems that developed during the Euro- pean Middle Ages. The following pages describe the traditional, overwhelmingly male views of women’s nature inherited by early modern Europeans and the new tradition that the “other voice” called into being to begin to challenge reign- ing assumptions. This review should serve as a framework for understanding the texts published in the series “The Other Voice in Early Modern Europe.” Introductions specific to each text and author follow this essay in all the vol- umes of the series.
    [Show full text]
  • UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations
    UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title A Sense of the Real: Experimental Writing and the Sciences, 1879-1946 Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/16t8422v Author Cecire, Natalia Aki Publication Date 2010 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California A Sense of the Real: Experimental Writing and the Sciences, 1879-1946 by Natalia Aki Cecire A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in English in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor C. D. Blanton, chair Professor Lyn Hejinian Professor Mark Goble Professor Suzanne Guerlac Fall 2010 A Sense of the Real: Experimental Writing and the Sciences, 1879-1946 © 2010 by Natalia Aki Cecire 1 Abstract A Sense of the Real: Experimental Writing and the Sciences, 1879-1946 by Natalia Aki Cecire Doctor of Philosophy in English University of California, Berkeley Professor C. D. Blanton, Chair This American literature dissertation offers an account of the critical category of “experimental literature,” arguing that, nebulous as the term appears to be, it is rooted in ideas of scientific experiment that were under debate in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. While experimental literature is often described in terms of “formal innovation,” this dissertation reads literary form not as an autonomous category in its own right but as an indicator of epistemological investments. Borrowing Lorraine Daston and Peter Galison’s concept of the “epistemic virtue,” this dissertation argues that experimental literature seeks to produce a “sense of the real,” not by thematically treating scientific ideas or even by emulating scientific methods, but rather by using literary form to negotiate the changing landscape of what constituted scientificity in the first place.
    [Show full text]
  • Marie Le Jars De Gournay, Eine Unabhängige Intellektuelle Des Frühen 17
    93 Ursula Beitz Marie le Jars de Gournay, eine unabhängige Intellektuelle des frühen 17. Jahrhunderts Glücklich bist du Leser, wenn du nicht zu dem Geschlecht gehörst, dem man alle Güter verwehrt, indem man ihm Freiheit versagt, indem man es zu keinen Pflich- ten, Ämtern und öffentlichen Funktionen zulässt: mit einem Wort, indem man es der Macht beschneidet, wo doch durch die Beschränkung dieser sich erst Tugenden formen können; so dass ihm schließlich als einziges Glück, als einzige Tugend die Unwissenheit bleibt, […]. Glücklich auch der, der ohne ein Verbrechen zu begehen weise sein kann; dein Mann-Sein gesteht dir bedeutsames Handeln, anspruchsvolles Urteilen und Spekulation zu, was man den Frauen allesamt verbietet. (Gournay 2002, 1074 f.)1 Ungestraft gelehrt und weise sein zu können, war schon früh der Wunschtraum von Marie de Gournay, die 1565 als älteste von sechs Geschwistern in Paris geboren wurde. Als sie 12 Jahre alt ist, stirbt ihr Vater, woraufhin ihre nun mit- tellose Mutter die Metropole verlassen muss und sich mit den Kindern auf dem Anwesen der Familie in Gournay sur Aronde niederlässt, einem Weiler in der picardischen Provinz. Auch heute noch hat er nicht mehr als 600 Einwohner. Die Möglichkeit, auf eigenen Besitzungen zu leben, rettete die Familie zwar vor größter Verarmung, aber für die wissbegierige Jugendliche bedeutete es gähnende Langeweile und den Verzicht auf formale Bildung. Einzige Zuflucht vor der mütterlichen Absicht, sie auf die traditionelle weibliche Bestimmung von Ehe und Spinnrocken vorzubereiten, stellt die väterliche Bibliothek dar, in der sich auch Schriften der römischen Antike befinden, wo sie sich »in heimlich abgezweigten Stunden die klassische Literatur und sogar Latein beibrachte, ohne Grammatik und Hilfe, nur indem sie die französischen Übersetzungen mit den Originalen verglich«, wie sie über sich selbst schreibt (Gournay 2002, 1862).
    [Show full text]
  • Dominican History Newsletter
    INSTITUTUM IIlSTORICUM ORDINIS FRATRUM PRAEDICATORUM DOMINICAN HISTORY NEWSLETTER XXI 2012 Roma Angelicum University Press ISSN 1357-2806 Direttore responsabile: Carlo Longo Autorizzazione del Tribunale di Roma del 14.V.2012, n. 137/2012. INSTITUTUM HISTORICUM ORDINIS FRATRUM PRAEDICATORUM DOMINICAN HISTORY NEWSLETTER XXI 2012 edited by Carlo LONGO & Fabio SIMONELLI Roma Angelicum University Press Address Istituto Storico Domenicano, largo Angelicum, I-00184 ROMA [email protected] tel.: (+39) 0667021 fax.: (+ 39) 066702270 Administration Angelicum University Press, largo Angelicum, I 1-00184 ROMA editori [email protected] t tel.: (+39) 066702439 Distribution Viella Libreria Editrice, via delle Alpi, 32 1-00198 ROMA [email protected] tel.: (+39) 068417758 fax: (+39) 0685353960 PERIODICA RECENSA "XVII° siècle", nn. 254-257(2012). "ABEi. Bollettino di informazione", 21(2012). "Abrente", 40-41(2008-2009)-44(2012). "Accademie e biblioteche d'Italia", n. s., 5(2010)-7(2012). "Acta historiae artium", 50(2009)-53(2012). "Actas y comunicaciones del Instituto de historia antigua y medieval", 8(2012). "Aevum", 86(2012). "African Studies Review", 53(2010)-55(2012). "Agorà", n. 31 (20 I 0)-n. 42(2012). "Alberca", 7(2009)-10(2012). "Albertiana", I 1-12(2008-2009)-15(2012). "Almagest", 1(2010)- 3(2012). "Almaig. Estudis i documents", 25(2009)-28(2012). "Alpha omega", 14(2011)-15(2012). "Àmbitos: Revista de estudios de ciencias sociales y humanidades", n. 23(20 I 0)-n. 28(2012). "América sin nombre"," 15(2010)-17(2012). "Anagn6risis", n. 1(2010) - n. 6(2012). "Analecta ordinis Praedicatorum", 102(2012). "Analecta Praemonstratensia", 88(2012). "Analecta sacra Tarraconensia", 85(2012). "Anales de historia del arte", 19(2009)-22(2012).
    [Show full text]
  • Tacitus' Germania and the Jesuit Relations: Intertextuality in the Transatlantic World of the Early Jesuits in New France
    Tacitus' Germania and the Jesuit Relations: Intertextuality in the Transatlantic World of the Early Jesuits in New France. by Renée Girard, BA MA Program in History Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree Master of Arts Faculty of Humanities, Brock University St Catharines, Ontario 2015 Abstract The first Europeans who wrote about the Indigenous people of the newly discovered Americas, not only used medieval, but also classical literature as a tool of reference to describe 'otherness.' As true humanists, the French Jesuits who arrived in the New World were deeply influenced by their classical education and, as claimed by Grafton, reverted to ancient ethnographic texts, like Tacitus' Germania, to support their analyse of the Indigenous people they encountered. Books talk to books. Inspired by Germania, the early French Jesuits managed to convey to their readers a subtle critique of their own civilization, enhancing, like Tacitus, the virtuous aspect of the so-called barbarians they described while illustrating the corruption of their respective civilized worlds. This thesis suggests that the essence of Tacitus' work is definitively present in Pierre Biard's letters and his Relation. His testimonies illustrate the connection the early French Jesuits had with the humanist thought of their time. Keywords: Jesuits, Jesuit Relations, New France, Tacitus, Germania. Acknowledgements The idea of this research materialized after I heard the same comment in two different courses. Dr. Mike J. Carter in History of the Roman Empire, and Dr. Daniel J. Samson in Pre-Confederation Canada both discussed texts which, while describing 'the Other,' had served as a critique of their own societies.
    [Show full text]
  • Gabrielle Suchon a Woman Who Defends All the Persons of Her Sex: Selected Philosophical and Moral Writings
    Philosophy in Review XXXI (2011), no. 2 Gabrielle Suchon A Woman Who Defends All the Persons of Her Sex: Selected Philosophical and Moral Writings. Edited and trans. Domna C. Stanton & Rebecca M. Wilkin. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press 2010. 448 pages US$95.00 (cloth ISBN 978-0-226-77920-1) US$35.00 (paper ISBN 978-0-226-77921-8) The idiosyncratic seventeenth-century philosopher Gabrielle Suchon published a voluminous treatise on ethics and politics (1693) and another one on the voluntary celibate (1700), in which she introduced, and vindicated, the status of neutraliste, a name for people (mostly women) who shunned marriage as well as the convent, because both involved a surrender of personal freedom to the authority of others. Today, Suchon is known only to intellectual historians and literary critics interested in the cultural history of seventeenth-century France, and even among them few will have read her books. It is therefore to be welcomed that we now have an excellent translation of large parts of her writings, ably introduced and annotated by Domna Stanton and Rebecca Wilkin. It is published in the University of Chicago Press series, ‘The Other Voice in Early Modern Europe’, which over the past ten years has done a wonderful job to make available translations of early-modern French, Italian, Spanish and German pro-woman writings. To anyone teaching courses in early modern cultural and intellectual history, the series is an invaluable resource. Central to Suchon’s philosophical position is her approach to freedom. That she valued it highly is apparent from the story of her life.
    [Show full text]