Do Statins Have Adverse Cognitive Effects?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CARDIOVASCULAR RISK AND DIABETES Diabetes Care Volume 39, Supplement 2, August 2016 S253 Remembering Statins: Do Statins Rafael Bitzur Have Adverse Cognitive Effects? Diabetes Care 2016;39(Suppl. 2):S253–S259 | DOI: 10.2337/dcS15-3022 The issue of statin-associated cognitive impairment has been a hot topic among both patients and health care providers, especially since the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a statement regarding rare postmarketing reports of ill-defined cognitive impairment associated with statin use. This statement was based on case reports, and no objective measures of cognitive function were used. Nevertheless, many patients at high risk of cardiovascular disease have expressed concerns about possible cognitive decline and may have opted to forgo statin therapy. In this overview, the evidence leading to the statement by the FDA is reviewed. Potential mechanisms of the effect of LDL cholesterol reduction and statin therapy on cognition are discussed. Evidence from observational and prospective randomized trials is summarized, leading to the conclusion that as for now, there is no good evidence that statins cause cognitive impairment to a significant degree. Reported cases seem to be rare, and a causal relationship has not been established. Hydroxymethylglutaryl CoA reductase inhibitors (statins) are a major contributor to cardiovascular disease prevention in patients with diabetes. In a prospective meta- analysis of more than 18,000 people with diabetes (mean age 63 years, with 43% over the age of 65 years) in 14 randomized trials, statins were shown to reduce both cardiovascular morbidity and mortality (1). As a result, both European (2) and U.S. (3) guidelines recommend statin treatment for almost all patients with diabetes. It is estimated that for people over the age of 55 years, statins would be recommended for 96.4% of men and 65.8% of women by the American College of Cardiology/ American Heart Association guidelines and 66.1% of men and 39.1% of women by European Society of Cardiology guidelines (4). With so many people eligible for treatment, even rare adverse effects become important. In 2012, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a statement regarding rare postmarketing reports of ill-defined cognitive impairment associated The Bert W. Strassburger Lipid Center, Sheba with statin use that was reversible upon statin discontinuation (5). This has led many Medical Center, Tel Hashomer, Israel people, patients and health care providers alike, to erroneously associate statins Corresponding author: Rafael Bitzur, rafael.bitzur@ with dementia and may have contributed to low adherence rates. sheba.health.gov.il. This review will deal with the relationship between cholesterol and cognitive This publication is based on the presentations function and the possible effects of statins on short- and long-term cognitive at the 5th World Congress on Controversies to function. Consensus in Diabetes, Obesity and Hyperten- sion (CODHy). The Congress and the publication Cholesterol and Cognitive Function of this supplement were made possible in The human brain contains ;25% of the total cholesterol of the body. Cholesterol is a part by unrestricted educational grants from AstraZeneca. major lipid constituent of the myelin sheath and the membrane lipid rafts in neurons © 2016 by the American Diabetes Association. and astrocytes, participating in regulation of ion channel permeability, signal trans- Readers may use this article as long as the work is duction, and other cellular functions (6). Lipoproteins have very limited permeabil- properly cited, the use is educational and not for ity of the intact blood-brain barrier. Therefore, essentially all brain cholesterol is profit, and the work is not altered. S254 Statins and Cognition Diabetes Care Volume 39, Supplement 2, August 2016 locally synthesized in astrocytes, which for 21 years), cognitive impairment or Alternatively, statins may exert pleiotro- are the main source of cholesterol for dementia (diagnosed by the DSM-IV cri- pic effects unrelated to their effect on neurons. teria) developed in 9% of the subjects. cholesterol. Several preclinical studies One of the pathological hallmarks of High mid-life total cholesterol levels using cell cultures and animal models Alzheimer disease (AD) is the develop- were a risk factor for more severe cogni- of AD have demonstrated that statins ment of extracellular senile plaques, tive impairment later in life (9). On the increase a-secretase activity and de- composed mainly of a small peptide other hand, in a study looking at 382 crease Ab production (8). In humans, known as amyloid-b (Ab), thought to subjects aged 70 years and free from de- lovastatin decreased serum Ab levels be a major causative agent in the de- mentia at baseline who were followed in a dose-dependent manner when velopment of AD. Cholesterol is be- for 18 years, 24% developed dementia given to subjects without dementia (14). lieved to be an important factor in (diagnosed by the DSM-III-R criteria). In a study looking at brain autopsies the regulation of Ab production, with High cholesterol levels in late life were from 110 subjects, ages 65–79 years, high cholesterol levels being linked to associated with decreased dementia risk neuropathologic findings were com- increased Ab generation and deposi- (10). One way of avoiding the risk of re- pared between statin users and nonus- tion. Lower cholesterol levels shift verse causation is to look at genetic stud- ers. The risk for typical AD pathology amyloid precursor protein processing ies. In one small study, patients with (Braak stage IV and Consortium to to nonraft regions of the membrane familial hypercholesterolemia showed a Establish a Registry for Alzheimer’s Dis- where the benign a-secretase cleavage high incidence of mild cognitive impair- ease [CERAD] rating moderate) was re- pathway is favored (6). ment compared with subjects without duced in statin users (15). Unlike lipoproteins, oxysterols, like the disease. Importantly, this did not 27-hydroxycholesterol, efficiently pass seem to be due to vascular dementia, Case Reports Concerning Cognitive Effect the blood-brain barrier. Hypercholes- since patients with a history of stroke of Statins terolemia is associated with increased or transient ischemic attack were ex- In 2003, Wagstaff et al. (16), using the brain levels of 27-hydroxycholesterol, cluded and the finding was unrelated MedWatch drug surveillance system of which may affect Ab production. Alter- to findings on brain MRI (11). Another the FDA, found 60 reports of patients natively, high LDL cholesterol (LDL-C) study, using a Mendelian randomization who had memory loss associated with levels may damage the blood-brain approach, looked at the association be- statins. Since then, several other case re- barrier by inflammatory mechanisms, tween genotype risk scores for four ports and case series have suggested a thus enabling leakage of serum choles- blood lipid phenotypes (including total potential negative association between terol and other amyloidogenic factors to and LDL-C) and late-onset AD. No such statins and cognitive function. In most the brain. Thus, higher levels of LDL-C association was found, leading the au- reports, the main symptom related to were associated with greater brain thors to conclude that genetic predispo- statins was short-term memory loss amyloid measured by positron emis- sition to increased blood cholesterol is that occurred a few months after the sion tomography using the tracer carbon not associated with elevated AD risk start of statin therapy or after a dosage 11C-labeled Pittsburgh compound B, (12). increase. Cognitive impairment was which specifically binds to Ab plaques, usually reversible upon discontinuation independently of apolipoprotein E geno- Statins and Cognitive Function of statin therapy. The cases did not ap- type (7). Cholesterol is vitally important for brain pear to be associated with fixed or pro- Paradoxically, in some epidemiologi- function. While the brain represents ;2– gressive dementia, such as AD. No cal studies, a low serum cholesterol 3% of total body weight, 25% of the cho- association was found between cogni- level was associated with an increased lesterol in the body is found in the brain, tive impairment and a specificstatin risk of developing AD. However, this where it plays important roles in mem- (lipophilic or hydrophilic), age, statin finding may be due to reverse causa- brane function. Because cholesterol dose, or concomitant medications. tion, since some studies included el- synthesis is essential for the normal It should be noted that causality can- derly participants who might have functioning of the brain, it is theoreti- notbedeterminedbythistypeofstudy. already had AD at enrollment, making cally possible that excessive inhibition First, the patient population receiving it difficult to distinguish between effects of cholesterol synthetic pathways may statinsisalreadyatriskformemory of cholesterol on the development of AD result in neurocognitive adverse effects. loss because of cardiac risk factors and and alteration of cholesterol level Statins may reduce cholesterol synthe- advancing age, which could lead to de- because of the catabolic state and path- sis in the brain and interfere with myelin tection bias. Second, no objective mem- ophysiological changes that accompany formation and function. In a mouse ory tests were performed. In fact, a AD. Indeed, studies finding a negative model, simvastatin impaired