Protocol for a Randomised Controlled Trial: Efficacy of Donepezil Against
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BMJ Open: first published as 10.1136/bmjopen-2013-003533 on 25 September 2013. Downloaded from Open Access Protocol Protocol for a randomised controlled trial: efficacy of donepezil against psychosis in Parkinson’s disease (EDAP) Hideyuki Sawada, Tomoko Oeda To cite: Sawada H, Oeda T. ABSTRACT ARTICLE SUMMARY Protocol for a randomised Introduction: Psychosis, including hallucinations and controlled trial: efficacy of delusions, is one of the important non-motor problems donepezil against psychosis Strengths and limitations of this study in patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD) and is in Parkinson’s disease ▪ In previous randomised controlled trials for (EDAP). BMJ Open 2013;3: possibly associated with cholinergic neuronal psychosis the efficacy was investigated in patients e003533. doi:10.1136/ degeneration. The EDAP (Efficacy of Donepezil against who presented with psychosis and the primary bmjopen-2013-003533 Psychosis in PD) study will evaluate the efficacy of endpoint was improvement of psychotic symp- donepezil, a brain acetylcholine esterase inhibitor, for toms. By comparison, this study is designed to prevention of psychosis in PD. ▸ Prepublication history for evaluate the prophylactic effect in patients this paper is available online. Methods and analysis: Psychosis is assessed every without current psychosis. Because psychosis To view these files please 4 weeks using the Parkinson Psychosis Questionnaire may be overlooked and underestimated it is visit the journal online (PPQ) and patients with PD whose PPQ-B score assessed using a questionnaire, Parkinson (http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/ (hallucinations) and PPQ-C score (delusions) have Psychosis Questionnaire (PPQ) every 4 weeks. bmjopen-2013-003533). been zero for 8 weeks before enrolment are ▪ The strength of this study is its prospective randomised to two arms: patients receiving donepezil design using the preset definition of psychosis Received 3 July 2013 hydrochloride or patients receiving placebo. The using PPQ (hallucinations/illusion and delu- Accepted 30 August 2013 patients are then followed for 96 weeks. The primary sions). However, it could also be a limitation; outcome measure is the time to the event, defined as because other types of psychosis cannot be getting 2 points or more on the PPQ-B score or PPQ-C evaluated. http://bmjopen.bmj.com/ score, which is assessed using a survival time ▪ Another limitation is the sample size estimation. analysis. The hypothesis being tested is that donepezil Because there have never been any randomised prevents psychosis in patients with PD. Efficacy will be trials for the prevention of psychosis, previous tested statistically using the intention-to-treat analysis data for sample size estimation were insufficient. including a log-rank test or Cox proportional hazard To resolve this issue we estimated the sample size models. Secondary outcomes, such as changes of PPQ based on our previous retrospective cohort study. scores and Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale scores from baseline will be assessed. or postural reflex disturbance. These motor Ethics and dissemination: Ethics approval was on September 25, 2021 by guest. Protected copyright. symptoms are caused by the depletion of received from the Central Review Board of the National dopamine in the striatum. Dopamine Hospital Organization, Tokyo, Japan. The trial was declared and registered to the Pharmaceuticals and Medical Devices replacement therapy can improve motor dis- Agency(PMDA), Japan (No. 22-4018). All participants will turbances in PD. However, many patients receive a written informed consent that was approved by suffer from psychiatric symptoms, such as the Central Review. A completed written informed consent hallucinations and delusions, during their is required to enrol in the study. Severe adverse events will long therapy process.12 be monitored by investigators and in cases where a severe In previous studies the efficacy of antidopa- adverse event was previously unreported, it will be minergic drugs, including clozapine,34olan- reported to the PMDA. zapine,5 quetiapine67and risperidone,8 was Clinical Trial Registration Number: UMIN000005403. investigated based on the possibility that psych- osis may be caused by excessive dopamine Clinical Research Center, replacement therapy. Although the efficacy of National Hospital of Utano, clozapine against psychosis without worsening Kyoto, Japan INTRODUCTION of motor symptoms of PD was established in Parkinson’s disease (PD) is a neurodegenerative the French Clozapine Parkinson Study4 and Correspondence to 4 Dr Hideyuki Sawada; disorder presenting with motor disturbances, the PSYCHOPLOS study, clozapine has a risk [email protected] including muscular rigidity, tremor, bradykinesia of granulocytopenia and requires careful Sawada H, Oeda T. BMJ Open 2013;3:e003533. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2013-003533 1 BMJ Open: first published as 10.1136/bmjopen-2013-003533 on 25 September 2013. Downloaded from Open Access blood cell monitoring. Previous randomised clinical to demonstrate significant differences between active trials (RCTs) demonstrated that olanzapine improves drugs and placebo. Therefore, in this study, the main psychosis, but there were no significant differences in outcome measure is the prophylactic efficacy of donepe- improvement between the olanzapine groups and the zil and the efficacy will be analysed using a survival time placebo groups. In addition, olanzapine worsened analysis. motor symptoms in PD compared with placebo.5 Two Because psychosis may be overlooked and underesti- other RCTs demonstrated that quetiapine does not mated, it is assessed using Parkinson Psychosis worsen motor symptoms; however, its efficacy against Questionnaire (PPQ)22 given every 4 weeks. The PPQ psychosis was not superior to placebo.67A small-sized consists of four categorical dimensions: sleep disturb- RCT comparing risperidone and clozapine demonstrated ance, hallucinations/illusions, delusions and orienta- that risperidone improves psychosis as well as clozapine; tions. Eligible patients are those whose scores on the however, risperidone worsened motor symptoms.8 There PPQ-B (hallucinations/illusion) and PPQ-C (delu- have been no clinical trials regarding other antipsychotic sion) are zero at least for 8 weeks before enrolment drugs against psychosis in PD. Taken together antidopa- and the primary endpoint is the occurrence of psych- minergic drugs, except for clozapine, insufficiently osis that is defined as PPQ-B ≥2 or PPQ-C ≥2, because improve psychosis. the situations when PPQ-B or PPQ-C is ≥2canresult Cholinergic neurons of the basal forebrain play an in clinically harmful conditions. important role in cognitive function and disruption of To exclude patients with dementia with Lewy bodies the cholinergic system has been proposed in (DLB) and PD with dementia, patients with Minimental Alzheimer’s disease.910Previous reports demonstrated State Examination (MMSE) score less than 24 are that the cholinergic neurons are degenerated, as are excluded. The risk of psychosis is low in patients with an dopaminergic neurons in PD,11 suggesting the possibility H-Y stage of 2 or less and the evaluation of psychosis is that psychosis could be caused by cholinergic neuronal difficult in patients with H-Y stage of 5. Therefore, damage, but not by dopaminergic replacement therapy.12 patients with H-Y stage of 1−2 or 5 are excluded. The Previously we investigated the clinical risk factors for length of time to the occurrence of psychosis is com- psychosis in a retrospective cohort study (unpublished pared between participants who were prescribed placebo data). In this study, 334 patients with PD were followed and those who were prescribed donepezil. until the occurrence of psychosis in 24 months. PD fi psychosis was signi cantly associated with the severity of Hypothesis to be examined in the study PD, PD duration and cognitive function. These data Psychosis may be caused by dysfunction of brain cholin- demonstrated that psychosis is associated with the severity ergic neurons. We examine the hypothesis that donepe- of the disease and cognitive function and the results are – zil prevents psychosis in patients with PD. http://bmjopen.bmj.com/ very consistent with previous reports.13 15 In addition, the influence of medications was analysed using a case- crossover study comparing medications at the endpoint METHODS AND ANALYSIS (occurrence of psychosis or end of the study) and those Study design for 1 or 3 months before the endpoint, and the analysis A multicentre, double-blinded, placebo-controlled, ran- showed that the use of anticholinergic drugs was a signifi- domised trial. A two arm study. cant risk factor for psychosis. In these results psychosis may have been caused by the degeneration of cholinergic Sites where the study is performed on September 25, 2021 by guest. Protected copyright. neurons and deterioration of cognitive function. Eight hospitals of the National Hospital Organization: Donepezil hydrochloride is an inhibitor of acetylcho- – Utano National Hospital, Hokkaido Medical Center, line esterase in brain neurons16 18 and activates choliner- 16 19 20 et al21 Sagamihara National Hospital, Shizuoka Institute of gic neurons. Manganelli have demonstrated, Epilepsy and Neurological Disorders, Kyoto Medical by using a neurophysiological technique, the short Center, Minami Kyoto Hospital, Toneyama National latency afferent inhibition, a functional involvement of Hospital and Nagasaki Kawatana Medical Center. central cholinergic