A Briefing Report on School District Debt

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Briefing Report on School District Debt Key Points of Report A Briefing Report on School District Debt February 1998 Overall Conclusion The magnitude of tax-supported, long-term school district debt may have implications to the State and to school districts. It is imperative that interested parties have complete and accurate information on school district debt and management and monitoring practices. Texas independent school districts throughout the State are experiencing rapid growth in student enrollment. To meet the demands of the increasing student population, these school districts are financing facility renovations and building new facilities by issuing debt. During our research of school district long-term debt we found issues that legislative leaders, the Texas Education Agency, and school district administrators and board members should consider. Issues for Further Consideration C The Texas Education Agency should develop guidelines for school districts to use when reporting accretion on capital appreciation bonds in the independent school districts’ annual financial reports. Long-term debt is understated in school districts’ annual financial reports due in part to a lack of specific guidance on the treatment of capital appreciation bond accretion. C The Permanent School Fund’s insurance capacity should be increased. Without an increase in the amount of bonds the Fund can insure it will reach capacity by 2002. As a result, school districts may be forced to purchase insurance from private companies at an increased cost. As of August 31, 1996, 84 percent of school district bonds were insured through the Fund. C The $300 fee charged by the Texas Education Agency to participate in the Permanent School Fund insurance program should be adjusted to reflect the costs of the program. C Texas should consider formulating a statewide policy on school district long-term debt management. School district debt is a local issue, controlled by local school boards. While complete state oversight of school district debt is not appropriate, the long-range impact of increasing school debt could have statewide implications. Contact Carol A. Smith, CPA, Audit Manager (512) 479-4700 Office of the State Auditor Lawrence F. Alwin, CPA This audit was conducted in accordance with Government Code, Section 321.0131. Table of Contents Overview .................................................... 1 School District Long-Term Debit Is Understated ................. 3 The Permanent School Fund Insures School District Bonds ...... 4 The Fund Bond Insurance Program Will Reach Capacity in 2002 .......... 5 The Fund’s Bond Insurance Fee Is A Bargain .......................... 5 There Is Limited State Oversight of School District Debt ......... 6 Bond Review Board Assesses School Districts on Their Debt Management Practices .......................................... 7 School Districts Do Not Have Specific Debt Management Policies ......... 8 School Board Members Need More Training in Debt Management ......................................... 10 Texas School Districts Refunded Bonds to Restructure Debt and Extend Payments .................................. 12 Key Debt Management Ratios Continue to Deteriorate ............................................... 13 Appendices 1 - Objectives, Scope, and Methodology ........................... 15 2 - Definition of Terms ........................................... 17 3 - The Debt Issuance Process .................................... 18 4 - Debt Instruments ............................................ 20 Overview Overall Conclusion since fiscal year 1993. In 1996, school districts issued $2 billion in bonds compared Texas independent school districts throughout to $650 million in fiscal year 1993. The the State are experiencing rapid growth in percentage of increase between fiscal years student enrollment. To meet the demands of 1995 and 1996 was 49 percent. the increasing student population, these school districts are financing Figure 2 facilities renovations and building new facilities by issuing debt. This Student Population Growth report explores numerous issues concerning the use of these debt 3,800 3,700 instruments and the results on 3,600 school district long-term debt. 3,500 3,400 3,300 3,200 3,100 Background 3,000 2,900 School district outstanding debt has 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 increased steadily since 1992. At Fiscal Years the end of fiscal year 1996, the Source: Texas Education Agency amount of bond principal outstanding was $10.9 billion compared to The student population in Texas has increased $8.3 billion at the end of fiscal year 1992 from 3.2 million to 3.7 million since 1988 (Figure 1). (Figure 2), a 15.97 percent increase, according Figure 1 to information obtained from Snapshots published by the Texas Education Agency. Amount of Bond Principal The annual growth has averaged 1.87 percent. Since fiscal year 1994, when the Texas Oustanding Education Agency began to keep this 12,000 particular data, the number of total schools 11,000 has increased at an annual rate of 2.42 10,000 percent. The number of high schools, 9,000 however, increased by 13.44 percent from 8,000 1,228 to 1,393 between fiscal year 1995 and 7,000 1996. 6,000 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 Recently passed legislation will also Fiscal Years contribute to the increase in construction. The Source: Bond Review Board 75th Legislature passed the Facilities Allotment Program (FAP) effective The percentage of increase between fiscal September 1, 1997. years 1995 and 1996 was 14.58 percent, the largest annual percentage increase since 1992. The FAP provides assistance to school Texas school districts issued $2.15 billion in districts in making debt service payments on new-money bonds in fiscal year 1996. This is qualifying bonds and lease purchase 55 percent of all bonds issued by Texas agreements. The FAP will allow school governments during the fiscal year. The amount of bonds issued has increased steadily FEBRUARY 1998 A BRIEFING ON SCHOOL DISTRICT DEBT PAGE 1 Overview districts that could not previously support new implications for future school district debt to do so. The Legislature appropriated solvency, and the amount of debt associated $200 million for the FAP, authorizing the with each type; and (3) review the roles of the distribution of $100 million during each of the Texas Education Agency, the Attorney next two years. General's Office, and the Texas Bond Review Board to determine the extent of oversight and Since enactment of the FAP, school districts to identify gaps in oversight responsibilities. have rushed to hold bond elections to qualify for the program. On September 27, 1997 San The scope of this project included (1) all Antonio ISD voters passed a record $483 school district long-term debt; (2) the roles of million bond issue to renovate and build new the Attorney General's Office and the Texas facilities. The bond package was presented to Education Agency in the issuance of the voters as a win-win situation. long-term debt by the school districts; (3) the role of the Bond Review Board in collecting, The district showed how the new Homestead compiling, and reporting information on Exemption and the FAP would save the school district long-term debt; and (4) statutes majority of homeowner's money, even if the and regulations related to the issuance of bonds passed. school district debt. Summary of Objectives and Scope The objectives of this project were to (1) analyze the increase in new debt; (2) determine types of alternative debt, PAGE 2 A BRIEFING REPORT ON SCHOOL DISTRICT DEBT FEBRUARY 1998 Section 1: School District Long-Term Debit Is Understated School district long-term debt is understated in the What are Capital Appreciation Bonds? annual financial reports of the school districts. In Capital appreciation bonds are deep discounted our review of 34 school district annual financial debt instruments. When a CAB is issued or sold, reports (AFRs) with a total of $1 billion of bonds the issuer sells the bond and promises to pay the outstanding, we found 20 districts with capital bondholder the principal and interest at a future appreciation bonds (CABs) with a face value of date. There no regular interest payments $71 million. Of the 20 school districts, 18 did not associated with CABs. disclose $67 million (94 percent) in liability associated with the CABs in their financial During the time the bond is outstanding, the CAB “accretes” interest until the bond matures. The statements. Without an accurate and total accretion is the difference between the face reporting of the accretion of the CABs, the total value of the bond and the price of the bond amount of outstanding long-term liability is bought at an original discount. The accretion unknown. remains a liability of the school district until the CAB matures or is extinguished through a School districts have not been consistent in refunding. reporting CAB accretion in the financial statements because of a lack of specific guidance from the Government Accounting Standards Board and the Texas Education Agency on the treatment of CAB accretion. School districts report bonds payable in the General Long Term Debt Account Group (GLTDAG) in accordance with generally accepted government accounting principles. Additional information, such as description of new issues and refundings, are disclosed in the Notes to the Financial Statements (Notes). Debt service payments are also disclosed in the Notes in the form of a Debt Service Schedule. School districts can: & Report the annual CAB accretion in the GLTDAG. & Disclose the accretion in the Notes to the Financial Statements. & Not report or disclose the accretion at all. (Most school districts have chosen not to report or disclose the accretion, with a few disclosing the accretion in the Notes and even fewer reporting the accretion on their balance sheet.) Although most school districts have not recognized their future liability on the balance sheet, they have not totally ignored it either. Future CAB principal and interest payments are included in the debt service schedules in the Notes to the AFRs. To pay for the CABs as they mature, school districts normally include the maturity amount in the school district's budget in the year of maturity.
Recommended publications
  • Consumer Credit Counseling
    CENTRAL VIRGINIA LEGAL AID SOCIETY, INC. 1000 Preston Ave, Suite B 101 W Broad, Ste 101 2006 Wakefield Street Charlottesville, VA 22903 Richmond, VA 23241 Petersburg, VA 23805 434-296-8851 (Voice) 804-648-1012 (Voice) 804-862-1100 (Voice) 434-296-5731 (Fax) 804-649-8794 (Fax) 804-861-4311 (Fax) Consumer Credit Counseling You may have bills and debts you can’t pay. You are not alone. Many agencies try to help people get out of debt. These are called “credit counseling agencies” or “debt counseling agencies.” You should be very careful about consumer credit counseling. Many agencies do more harm than good. What services does a credit counseling agency offer? Credit counseling usually offers three services. • Budget counseling to help you pay your debts on your own. • A debt management plan, or debt repayment plan, run by the agency. • Referral to other agencies, such as social, financial and legal services. What is a debt management plan? In this plan, the agency arranges lower payments with your creditors. Usually these are your credit cards. Your payments are lower because your creditors agree on lower interest rates. When all the creditors who are in your plan agree, you make one monthly payment to the agency. The agency uses that money to make your lower payments to your creditors. When should I think about a debt management plan? You should think about a plan if two things are true. (1) You can’t pay all your bills and debts, and can’t keep current on all your accounts. (2) You have income or property you could lose to a creditor.
    [Show full text]
  • Tips on Choosing a Reputable Credit Counseling Agency
    NATIONAL CONSUMER LAW Consumer CENTER INC 77 Summer Street, 10th Fl Boston, MA 02110 for Older 617 542-8010 www.nclc.org Facts Americans Tips on Choosing A Reputable Credit Counseling Agency There have been a lot of problems with credit counseling agencies in recent years. For example, the vast majority of credit counseling agencies are non-profit organizations, yet many behave like for-profit businesses. These non-profits in disguise spend huge amounts of money on advertising and aggressively try to sell “debt relief” products to consumers. You should be careful if you think you want to go to a credit counseling agency for help with credit card debt. Credit counseling can be very useful in some cases. Unfortunately, not all credit counseling agencies are acting in your best interests. Below are a few tips to help you decide whether credit counseling is right for you and to help you find a reputable agency. Do You Need a Credit Counseling Agency? 1. Are You In Financial Trouble? Some warning signs of financial trouble are clearer than others. For example, if you are consistently late in paying bills or are already behind in paying some debts, you probably know that you need help. Other warning signs of financial trouble are not so obvious. If your total debt payments, excluding your mortgage and car, are between one-quarter and one-half of your after-tax income, you could benefit from credit counseling or other forms of financial assistance. You should consider seeking assistance even if you are current on all bills.
    [Show full text]
  • State of Alaska State Bond Committee Debt Management Policies
    March 8, 2013 Update State of Alaska State Bond Committee Debt Management Policies Page 1 of 21 State of Alaska – Debt Management Policies TABLE OF CONTENTS • Executive Summary Page 3 • Introduction Page 5 • Discussion of Credit Ratings and Applicable Ratios Page 5 • Current Debt Position Page 10 • Affordable Level of Additional GO Debt Page 12 • School Debt Reimbursement Program Page 14 • Level and Impact of Moral Obligations Page 15 • Consideration of Debt Structuring Elements Page 16 • Evaluation of Refunding Opportunities Page 19 Appendix A – Alaska Public Debt Report Tables Appendix B – State’s Post Issuance Policy Appendix C - “U.S. State Government Tax-Supported Rating Criteria” Appendix D - Risk Management Policy Appendix E - “U.S. State Debt Service Ratios” Appendix F - “2012 State Debt Medians Report” Page 2 of 21 State of Alaska – Debt Management Policies Executive Summary The national credit rating agencies have placed State of Alaska among the highest echelon of states in the United States. In January 2013, the State was awarded a “AAA” rating from Fitch Ratings, Inc., the agency’s highest rating. Fitch joined Standard and Poor’s (whom upgraded the State to AAA in December 2011) and Moody’s Investors Service (whom upgraded the State to Aaa in November 2010) as recognizing the strength of the State’s current strong fiscal position. The ability of the State to maintain this elite position is a function of many factors including: financial management, moderate debt levels and strong and responsible leadership. A carefully considered debt management plan can be a useful tool to policy leaders and government professionals to determine appropriate levels of debt while meeting the need of funding the State’s capital program The State of Alaska is unique in both its strengths and challenges.
    [Show full text]
  • Debt Relief Services & the Telemarketing Sales Rule
    DEBT RELIEF SERVICES & THE TELEMARKETING SALES RULE: A Guide for Business Federal Trade Commission | ftc.gov Many Americans struggle to pay their credit card bills. Some turn to businesses offering “debt relief services” – for-profit companies that say they can renegotiate what consumers owe or get their interest rates reduced. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the nation’s consumer protection agency, has amended the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) to add specific provisions to curb deceptive and abusive practices associated with debt relief services. One key change is that many more businesses will now be subject to the TSR. Debt relief companies that use telemarketing to contact poten- tial customers or hire someone to call people on their behalf have always been covered by the TSR. The new Rule expands the scope to cover not only outbound calls – calls you place to potential customers – but in-bound calls as well – calls they place to you in response to advertisements and other solicita- tions. If your business is involved in debt relief services, here are three key principles of the new Rule: ● It’s illegal to charge upfront fees. You can’t collect any fees from a customer before you have settled or other- wise resolved the consumer’s debts. If you renegotiate a customer’s debts one after the other, you can collect a fee for each debt you’ve renegotiated, but you can’t front-load payments. You can require customers to set aside money in a dedicated account for your fees and for payments to creditors and debt collectors, but the new Rule places restrictions on those accounts to make sure customers are protected.
    [Show full text]
  • Debt Management Program Package 2/18/18
    Debt Management Program Package 2/18/18 937.853.1600 CCCS of the Miami Valley is a program HomeOwnershipDayton.Org/CCCS of The HomeOwnership Center. 2 Client Disclosure Consumer Credit Counseling Service of the Miami Valley (CCCS) has over 30 years of experience in helping people with financial problems. Our role is to provide you with information and alternatives to make informed decisions to reach your financial goals. CCCS provides a variety of services such as Financial Counseling and Education, Housing Counseling Services, and Education, and Debt Management Programs. You are under no obligation to use other services or referrals offered. Please let us know if you are limited in English proficiency or otherwise in need of a professional interpreter and CCCS will provide one at no cost for your counseling session. In order to assist you, it is essential that you provide us with information that is accurate and as complete as possible. CCCS will complete a written budget analysis that will examine your financial situation, examine factors that may be the cause of problems, review housing status, and explore all alternatives for developing a reasonable plan for resolving them. For many people we counsel, the budget and personalized action plan provide all the advice needed to handle their financial situation. In some situations, especially if there is significant credit card or other unsecured debts, clients may find that enrolling in an alternative payment schedule such as a Debt Management Plan (DMP) is the best option for them to reach their financial goals. Participation in a DMP may have some bearing on the establishment of future credit.
    [Show full text]
  • Public Forum on Proposed Debt Relief Amendments Transcript
    1 1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2 FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 3 4 5 6 7 PUBLIC FORUM ON DEBT RELIEF AMENDMENTS 8 TO THE TELEMARKETING SALES RULE 9 10 11 12 WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 4, 2009 13 14 9:00 a.m. 15 16 17 18 FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 19 6TH AND PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE, N.W. 20 WASHINGTON, D.C. 21 22 23 24 25 For The Record, Inc. (301) 870-8025 - www.ftrinc.net - (800) 921-5555 2 1 I N D E X 2 3 4 PANEL: PAGE: 5 Welcome 3 6 The Proposed Advance Fee Ban 12 7 Implementation Issues Raised by the 8 Proposed Advance Fee Ban 90 9 The Proposed Disclosure & 10 Misrepresentation Provisions 146 11 Definitions & Scope 226 12 Open Microphone 261 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 For The Record, Inc. (301) 870-8025 - www.ftrinc.net - (800) 921-5555 3 1 P R O C E E D I N G S 2 - - - - - 3 MR. WINSTON: Good morning. We are going to get 4 started now. I would like to welcome you to the Federal 5 Trade Commission and today's public forum. My name is 6 Joel Winston, I am the FTC's Associate Director for 7 Financial Practices in the Bureau of Consumer 8 Protection. 9 We're here this morning in this important room 10 in this historic new era. I see one of our former 11 commissioners here who spent time in this room, Andy 12 Strenio. This is the Commissioners's room where they 13 conduct formal business, for example deciding whether to 14 bring lawsuit against someone who violated the law.
    [Show full text]
  • Need Help with Debts?
    Need Help with Debts? Don’t get burned by scammers – know the facts about debt relief! March 2018 Print in PDF Debt relief is the generic name for different ways you can manage your bills. This fact sheet covers different types of debt relief and what you should watch out for. Debt relief scammers often target people in financial distress, such as those affected by a natural disaster. So people looking for assistance after a hurricane, flood, or fire should be especially cautious about scams. DEBT SETTLEMENT Companies offering debt settlement tell you to pay them instead of your creditors. They promise that if you make payments to them instead. They will settle your debts for a smaller lump sum payment once you have saved enough money in a special account. What you should know: Companies charge monthly fees for debt settlement plans, often for years. Debt collectors will keep calling you and may even sue you if you stop paying them. Your bills will keep growing with interest and late fees until there is a settlement (if there ever is one). If a debt settlement plan works, it can take years to complete, but many people drop out because they can’t afford it. There are no guarantees. Your creditors don’t have to agree to accept a smaller lump sum payment. and some will not even talk to debt settlement firms. Debt settlement is unlikely to help you resolve your debts, and you may even end up owing more than when you started. DEBT CONSOLIDATION Some companies offer to help you combine all your old bills into one new, bigger loan.
    [Show full text]
  • In Re Wark, 15-40558
    SO ORDERED. SIGNED this 17th day of December, 2015. ___________________________________________________________________________ IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF KANSAS In re: Case Nos. Wark 15-40558 Tetuan/Milholen 15-40566 Ellsperman 15-40609 Blacksmith 15-40641 Rayton 15-40644 Neu 15-40647 Tinkham 15-40654 Parker 15-40655 Hayes 15-40661 Huggins, 15-40681 Debtors. Memorandum Opinion and Order Can a below median income debtor in bankruptcy, impoverished and struggling to meet monthly financial obligations, choose to file a Chapter 13 petition instead of a Chapter 7 petition? What if that debtor wishes to have assistance of competent counsel to navigate the complex bankruptcy system with its myriad forms, rules and schedules, to help ensure she exits bankruptcy with a discharge and the best fresh Case 15-40558 Doc# 75 Filed 12/17/15 Page 1 of 107 start the law allows? What if that counsel comes with a comparatively high $3100 presumptively reasonable fee for a Chapter 13 case, but will charge “only” $1800 to handle a Chapter 7 case? What if the debtor, instead of choosing to delay filing bankruptcy while attempting to save funds to pay counsel for the cheaper Chapter 7 option, or perhaps worse yet, choosing to navigate the bankruptcy system pro se, elects to instead immediately file a Chapter 13 petition where she can pay her counsel’s fee through her Chapter 13 plan? What justification must the debtor present for her choices? Is it enough if she is being garnished 25% of her income? How about merely harassing phone calls from her creditors? Or is something more required? The United States Trustee (the “U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Long-Term Debt Management Plan
    The Regional Municipality of York Long-Term Debt Management Plan Includes Capital Financing and Debt Policy 2014 Long-Term Debt Management Plan Introduction .................................................................................................................. 3 1. The Region’s Needs for its Long-Term Debt and Financial Obligations Over a Multi- Year Period .................................................................................................................. 2 2. Projections of the ARL for Each Year of the Multi-Year Period Compared to Existing and Proposed Long-Term Debt-Related Payments ..................................................... 3 3. Risk and Mitigation Strategies Associated with the Region’s Long-Term Debt Strategy, Including Interest Rate Risk and Foreign Currency Exposure ...................... 7 4. Long-Term Debt and Financial Obligations Policy ..................................................... 12 5. Prudent and Cost-Effective Management of Existing and Projected Long- Term Debt and Other Financial Obligations ................................................................................. 13 6. Estimated 2014 Needs of the Region for Temporary Borrowing ................................ 13 7. Evaluation and Comparison of 2013 Projections and Outcomes ............................... 14 8. Conclusion ................................................................................................................. 15 APPENDIX 1: Determination of Annual Repayment Limit (ARL) .....................................
    [Show full text]
  • What You Should Know About Bankruptcy
    FACTS FOR OLDER CONSUMERS National Consumer Law Center® What You Should Know About Bankruptcy What Is Bankruptcy? Bankruptcy is a process under federal law designed to help people and businesses get protection from their creditors. An important goal of bankruptcy is to give individuals with debt problems a chance for a fresh financial start. For some elders, bankruptcy does this by eliminating the legal obligation to pay debts. Others gain an opportunity to get current on mortgages and car loans or to pay off debts at a reduced amount. Filing bank- ruptcy also immediately stops most creditors from seeking to collect debts, at least until things are sorted out in the bankruptcy process. Things to Think About Before Deciding Whether to File A decision to file bankruptcy should be made only after determining that bankruptcy is the best way to deal with your financial problems. Other options to deal with unmanage- able debt usually should be considered first. • Credit Counseling When done well, credit counseling can be very helpful for consumers in financial distress. Unfortunately, there are many people who offer counseling and credit repair in order to rip you off. You should be careful to avoid scams and offers of costly debt consolidation plans as a way out of debt. Most of these deals will only make your situation worse. If you decide to go ahead with bankruptcy, the law requires that you meet with an ap- proved credit counseling agency first to consider your options in credit counseling. You should be very careful in choosing an agency for the required counseling.
    [Show full text]
  • Four Cornerstones of Financial Literacy
    FOUR CORNERSTONES OF FINANCIAL LITERACY The Four Cornerstones of Financial Literacy program was written and developed by Darryl Dahlheimer through a federal grant administered by the Minnesota Department of Human Services, Office of Economic Opportunity and in partnership with the Minnesota Community Action Association. The curriculum was developed for use by agencies that serve low-income individuals and families, to teach economic empowerment skills and financial knowledge using a learning-circle group method. It is not intended to provide any specific legal, tax, or investment advice for individual situations, but is a road map and resource to help people find their way into financial well-being. Table of Contents PART ONE: BUDGETING TO CREATE SAVINGS Income and Savings Plans: First Steps to Making a Workable Budget ............................................................ 1 The Put-and-Take Account: saving for periodic expenses ............................. 3 Cash Flow Chart: for when you have to live check-to-check .......................... 4 Weekly Spending Tracker .............................................................................. 5 Categories for Tracking in a Spending Plan ................................................... 6 Debt Tracker Worksheet ............................................................................... 7 Spending Plan Monthly Tracker ..................................................................... 8 Thriftiness Tip Sheet ...................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Debt Management Plan
    Debt Management Plan I. Plan Objective and Goals A. Objective a. Empower and prepare Harper College students to be successful in debt management and money matters. B. Goals a. Help students make informed decisions about how to borrow wisely and reduce the amount borrowed. b. Educate borrowers about their loan rights and responsibilities. c. Educate borrowers about repayment plans and loan forgiveness. d. Help borrowers manage their loans and repayment. e. Educate students about money management and financial literacy. f. Build campus wide awareness about debt and money management issues. g. Reduce Harper College’s Cohort Default Rate. h. Educate Harper College staff about the complexities of student loans and how to advise students about loan management. II. Situational Analysis A. College Costs vs. Financial Aid a. Education related expenses rise about 4 to 6 percent per year b. Perception of Community Colleges are that they are an affordable choice c. Government grants and scholarships are underfunded B. Growing use of federal loan funds by students and parents a. Need-based grants have not been keeping pace with increases in college costs. b. Estimate that two-thirds of college seniors who graduated in 2011 had student loan debt, with an average indebtedness of $26,6001 c. Average indebtedness among 2011 graduates in Illinois was $26,4701 d. $1 trillion in outstanding student loan debt; second largest form of consumer debt (mortgages are the largest) e. More than 7 million borrowers were delinquent or in default on federal or private student loans (more than 90 days late on a payment – as reported by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, June 2013) 1 The Project on Student Debt / The Institute for College Access & Success.
    [Show full text]