Transformational Education the Togolese Case
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AMERICAN UNIVERSITY- HONORS CAPSTONE Transformational Education The Togolese Case Tchilalou Sogoyou-Bekeyi University Honors in International Service Spring 2012 Dr. Patrick Ukata School of International Service Tchi Sogoyou Transformational led-type Education – The Togolese Case 1 Tchi Sogoyou Transformational led-type Education – The Togolese Case 2 Abstract Through the case study of Togo, I hope to demonstrate that transformational education, i.e. a mix of certain values-based educations, moral and civic education in particular, is the key in forming responsible, proactive, and ingenious individuals and good leaders in Sub-Saharan Africa. The assumption is that certain values, including universal held democratic values, in addition to country specific values and active citizenship will mold the Togolese in becoming a good and responsible citizen. Such an education will break through barriers of ethnic, group, or family based identities and subsequently creates a nation of people willing to build and maintain a functioning and accountable state. Unlike most of today’s leadership, individual brought under a transformational style led education will take initiatives on the behalf of their communities and country, and will ultimately not rely on prebendalistic behaviors or clientelism for personal enrichment. Personal rule and bad governance will decrease, thus enabling Togo’s development. This study reveals that such learning is brought about largely through a combination of more settled learning environments, more positive teacher–student and student–student relationships, enhanced self-esteem and a greater sense of corporate responsibility, this latter especially when forms of service learning or other social engagement strategies are explicitly incorporated. I choose this topic because of my personal beliefs in education, and the tremendous effects it can have on a population. As broad as education can be defined, it is undeniable that cultures, norms, and values are transmitted through teaching. I have a keen interest in development, and deeply believe that values based education may in fact be the solution for developing countries like Togo. Tchi Sogoyou Transformational led-type Education – The Togolese Case 3 Transformational Education – The Togolese Case Introduction Ethics is about developing new habits, new attitudes. It is about becoming sensitive to different cues, susceptible to different passions, and to redefine and reassess priorities (O’ Brien 1991, 25). Through the case study of Togo, I hope to demonstrate that transformational education, i.e. a mix of certain values-based education, moral and civic education in particular, is the key in forming responsible, proactive, and ingenious individuals and good leaders in Sub-Saharan Africa. The assumption is that certain values, including universal held democratic values, in addition to country specific values and active citizenship will mold the Togolese in becoming a good and responsible citizen. Such an education will break through barriers of ethnic, group, or family based identities and subsequently creates a nation of people willing to build and maintain a functioning and accountable state. Unlike most of today’s leadership, individual brought under a transformational led-style education will take initiatives on behalf of their communities and country, and will ultimately not rely on prebendalistic behaviors or clientelism for personal enrichment. Personal rule and bad governance will decrease, thus enabling Togo’s development. This study reveals that such learning is brought about largely through a combination of more settled learning environments, more positive teacher–student and student–student relationships, enhanced self-esteem and a greater sense of corporate responsibility, this latter especially when forms of service learning or other social engagement strategies are explicitly incorporated. I choose this topic because of my personal beliefs in education, and the tremendous effects it can have on a population. As broad as education can be defined, it Tchi Sogoyou Transformational led-type Education – The Togolese Case 4 is undeniable that cultures, norms, and values are transmitted through teaching. I have a keen interest in development, and deeply believe that values-based education may in fact be the solution for developing countries like Togo. This essay is an attempt at developing such a theory; it also serves as a preliminary work for a field research that I intend to undertake in the next couple years. The choice of Togo lays in fact that I am Togolese, and as many will condone, there is no better feeling than giving back to thy country! Literature Review The literature on Togo’s education is relatively poor. There is a prominent data on the disparity between male and female and its effect on the education, mainly referring to the lagging female enrolment (Sossou, and Tuwor 2008). Biraimah’s (1984) study on the impact of Western notions of gender-based role expectations in third world education with Lome Secondary School as a case study notes that: “the informal curriculum reproduce[s] a significant pattern of sex-role differentiation even though the school outwardly reflect[s] uniformity and equality.” The study also talks about schools’ ability to impact female roles expectations. Though revealing, for it shows the importance of gender role in the Togolese education, it has yet to relate to how such education shape both girls and boys in becoming better and responsible citizens. The misuse of educational funds is another point of discussion in the literature. Kogoe (1985) in one of his researches focuses on two measures -the reduction of both the enrollment and the price of education, and the improvement of the quality and quantity of the primary education- designed to improve the effective and equitable use of public funds for education in Togo. He further adds that education leaders in Togo miss the necessary skills for “the satisfactory functioning of schools” (Kogoe 1985). Similarly, Assiah and Pierre (2006) argue that: “unsuitable teaching methods [and] overloaded Tchi Sogoyou Transformational led-type Education – The Togolese Case 5 curricula” are the causes of Togo’s educational inefficiency. Furthermore, the relationship between community participation and access to quality education is highlighted. Indeed, Bray (2003) underscores the importance of community participation in education. Evidently, neither the type and structure of Togo’s education nor its role in forming great leaders is discussed. Hence, the need of a study, which offers alternatives such as a transformational led-type education to what Togo may currently have. Methodology Data collection for this paper was done using scholarly articles relating to education in general and values, character, moral, and civic education in both developed and non-developed countries in particular. A data analysis was then conducted by: 1) putting the question of education in perspective as it relates to Sub-Saharan African countries, notably Togo and the need of a change given the current political and social climate; 2) defining transformational education with an in-depth focus on moral and civic education. At which point, the case of values education was made, and Togo as a case study introduced. The final step was to propose recommendations based on successful attempts in the field. Personal Rule in Africa-Effects Much of the literature on development has focused on “economic development” with the assumption that economic growth is needed to lift the majority of developing countries out of their misery. It is undeniable that a certain type of economic growth may in fact bring about development and to a larger extent an improvement of living standards for the population in general. Yet, the case of developing nations, like China for instance, speaks volumes about such outcomes. Interestingly enough, many Africanists have noted most, if not all of, the issues related to the lack of development in Sub-Saharan Africa; Tchi Sogoyou Transformational led-type Education – The Togolese Case 6 ranging from mismanagement of resources, heritage of the colonial area, ethnic rivalries and bad leadership to the nonexistence of democracy, human capital, and knowledge know-how. Amongst these, bad governance or leadership seems to have been the most discussed. The amount of money extorted and stolen each year from developing countries is over ten times the approximately $100 billion in foreign assistance being provided to them by all the governments and civil society organizations in the world (UNDP 2008, 10). In many ways, corruption adversely affects a country’s development, and slows down or hinders any initiatives at becoming effective and accountable to the citizenry. UNDP (2008) refers to corruption as an exacerbating factor on poverty. It negatively affects economic growth, undercuts government capacity to collect revenue and reduces its ability to deliver social services (Lash 2003; Mauro 1997). Additionally, corruption reduces spending on health care and education, and redirects this spending towards the wealthy. Corruption affects state legitimacy by eroding state institutions and public confidence when elections are rigged and the will of the public is ignored. It fosters an anti-democratic environment characterized by uncertainty, unpredictability, declining moral and ethical values and disrespect for constitutional institutions and authority (UNDP 2008). Richard Sandbrook and Barker