ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION ITANAGAR
ANNUAL REPORT 2020-21 Printed at Directorate of Printing, Naharlagun 279/2021-Dy-Registrar APIC-Itanagar-800-7-2021. ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION ITANAGAR
ANNUAL REPORT 2020-21 The real Swaraj will come not by the acquisition of authority by a few, but by the acquisition of capacity by all to resist authority when abused.
-MAHATMA GANDHI
“Laws are not masters but servants, and he rules them who obey them”.
-HENRY WARD BEECHER
“Democracy requires an informed citizenry and transparency of information which are vital to its functioning and also to contain corruption and to hold Government and their instrumentalities accountable to the governed” (Preamble, RTI Act 2005)
(i) ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This15thAnnual Reports of Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission 2020-21has been prepared in one volume. The data for preparation of this report are collected from the state Government Departments. According to Information provided by the departments, the total number of Public Authorities in the State is 78 and the number of Public Information Officers is more than 310.
The Right to Information Act, 2005 is a landmark legislation that has transformed the relationship between the citizen and the State. This legislation has been created for every citizen to hold the instrumentalities of Governance accountable on a day-to-day basis. The legislation perceives the common man as an active participant in the process of nation building by conferring on him a right to participate in the process through the implementation of the Right to Information Act.
It has been 15 years since the RTI Act has been in operation in the State. The State Public Information Officers and Appellate Authorities are quasi-judicial functionaries under the RTI Act with distinctive powers and duties and they constitute the cutting edge of this “Practical regime of information”, as envisaged in the preamble of the Right to Information Act. Together, they create an effective, mechanism for disposal of increasing numbers of requests for information being received from the citizen of India.
The Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission has prepared the Annual Report for the year 2020-21and while preparing the same, many government functionaries have extended help in many ways for bringing out this Annual Report.
We also acknowledge the contribution of the Chief Secretary, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, and Development Commissioner Finance and the Staff for their assistance in preparing the report.
Our thanks to the Director, Department of Printing, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, and his Staff for their role in bringing out this report in the most presentable form.
The Commission wishes to express special thanks to the Secretary cum Registrar, Deputy Registrar, Other Officers and Staff of the Commission, who have contributed in preparing this report.
(ii) We sincerely hope that this report will be helpful to the Public Authorities, Civil Societies, NGOs, the RTI activists, and citizens in maintaining transparency, accountability and in checking corruption at all level.
Dr. Joram Begi State Chief Information Commissioner
Shri Goto Ete Shri Leki Phuntso State Information Commissioner State Information Commissioner (Retired)
Shri Genom Tekseng Shri Gumjum Haide State Information Commissioner State Information Commissioner
Smti Sonam Yudron State Information Commissioner
(iii) CONTENTS
CONTENTS Page No.
CHAPTER-I 1 – 2 INTRODUCTION
CHAPTER-II 3 – 5 A BRIEF ABOUT ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION
CHAPTER-III 6 – 15 NOTIFICATION, REGULATIONS AND ORDERS
CHAPTER-IV 16 ANNUAL ACCOUNT OF THE COMMISSION
CHAPTER-V 17 – 18 YEAR WISE COMPLAINT/APPEAL RECEIVED AND DISPOSED OF BY THE COMMISSION AGAINST THE PUBLIC AUTHORITIES.
CHAPTER-VI
RTI COMPLAINT U/S 18(1) & SECOND APPEAL CASE U/S 19(3) WITH STATUS OF 19 – 38 EACH CASE IN THE ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION DURING THE YEAR-2020
CHAPTER-VII STATUS OF WRIT PETITION FILED AGAINST THE DECISION OF THE COMMISSION 39 – 40 BEFORE GAUHATI HIGH COUT
CHAPTER-VIII 41 42 PERIODICAL REPORT REGARDING EFFECTIVE IMPLEMENTATION OF RTI – ACT, 2005
CHAPTER-IX 43 – 44 RECOMMENDATION OF THE COMMISSION TO THE STATE GOVERNMENT
CHAPTER-X 45 – 51 PHOTO GALLERY
ANNEXURE 52 - 67 SOME OF THE SIGNIFICANT ORDERS/DECISIONS OF THE COMMISSION
NAME AND DESIGNATION OFSTAFFS OF ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION 68 - 69 COMMISSION.
(iv) ANNUAL REPORT, 2020-21 THE ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION
CHAPTER-I
INTRODUCTION
Freedom of information is a fundamental human right and this was recognized by the United Nations at its very inception in 1946 when the General Assembly resolved: “Freedom of Information is a fundamental human right and the touchstone for all freedoms to which the United Nations is consecrated” Enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the right’s status as a legally binding treaty organization was affirmed in Article-19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights which states – “Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression: this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers”. This has placed the right to access information firmly within the body of universal human rights law.
This right to information was explicitly held to be our fundamental right under Article-19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India for the first time by Justice K.K Mathew in the State of U.P –Vs- Raj Narain. This view was followed by the Supreme Court of India on numbers of decisions and, after public demand; the Right to Information Act, 2005 was enacted and brought into force.
The RTI Act is not new for India. Many of its States have already enacted similar Acts in the past. The RTI Laws were first successfully enacted by some State Governments of our Country, like – Tamil Nadu and Goa in 1997, Rajasthan and Karnataka in 2000, Delhi in 2001, Maharashtra and Assam in 2002, Madhya Pradesh in 2003 and Jammu & Kashmir in 2004. And there had already been a Law enacted called as ‘the Freedom of Information Act, 2002’. In order to ensure greater and more effective access to information the Government of India decided to repeal the Freedom of Information Act, 2002 and to enact another law for providing an effective framework for effectuating the right of information recognized under Article-19 of the Constitution of India. To achieve this object, the Right to Information Bill was introduced in the Parliament. The Right to Information Bill, having been passed by both the Houses of Parliament, received the assent of the President on 15th of June, 2005 and finally the same came into being as ‘the Right to Information Act, 2005 (Act 22 of 2005)’. Some provisions of the Act came into force with immediate effect from 15th June, 2005 when the President gave his assent so that the public authorities could make preliminary arrangements for implementation of the Act in the field of: designation of Central/State Public Information Officers; designation of Central/State Assistant Public Information Officers; designation of First Appellate Authorities senior to Public Information Officers; framing of rules for smooth implementation of the Act; setting up of Central/State Information Commission(s); preparation of 17 manuals for dissemination of pro-active
1 information, etc. And the Act later fully came into force in our Country, including in the State of Arunachal Pradesh, on 12th of October, 2005 after 120 days of enactment of the Act.
The Right to Information Act, 2005, is the first ever ‘sunshine law’ enacted by the Parliament which extends to the whole of India, in as much as, like most ‘sunshine laws’ it provides a right to all citizens to demand information from any public authority in India while also creating a positive obligation upon these authorities to pro-actively publish information about their functioning. It has been made applicable to all public authorities, viz, all Central and State Government Ministries; Departments; Organizations; Undertakings, Autonomous Bodies, Municipalities, Panchayat, etc, enacted by law and also covers the Union Territories. The Judiciary and the Legislature including Parliament and State Legislature are also covered under its purview.
The Right to Information Act, 2005, has been enacted to provide for setting out the practical regime of right to information for citizens. The basic objectives of this Act are to: empower the citizen to get information from any public authority; to promote transparency and accountability in the workings of the Government and its instrumentalities; to contain corruption and; to make our democracy work for the people in real sense.
The Right to Information Act, 2005, is divided into six chapters and contains thirty-one sections in the whole. All these sections of the Act had remained intact for a period of more than 15(fifteen) years from the date of its enactment on 15th of June, 2005. After such a long period of more than 15 (fifteen) years as aforesaid an amendment bill called as ‘the Right to Information (Amendment) Bill, 2019’ was introduced in the Lok Sabha by Minister of State for Personal, Public Grievances and Pension, Mr. Jitendra Singh on 19th of July, 2019 and the same which was passed by the both Houses of the Parliament was given assent to by the President of India on the 1st day of August, 2019 called as ‘the Right to Information (Amendment) Act, 2019 (24th Act of 2019)’ and by which provisions of Section(s)-13, 16 and 27 of the Principle/Original Act of 2005 have now been amended. And accordingly, the Ministry of Personnel , Public Grievances and Pensions( Department of Personnel and Training ) Govt. of India (Central Govt.) while in the exercise of Power conferred by clauses (ca) and (cb) of sub-section (2) of Section-27 of Right to Information Act,2005 (22 of 2005) framed the Rules, Vide Notification, New Delhi, the 24th October ,2019 called as the Right to Information (Terms of Office, Salaries,Allowances and Other Terms and Condition of Services of Chief Information Comimissioner, Information Commissioners in the Central Information Commission, State Chief Information Commissioners and State Information Commissioners in the State Information Commission.) Rule, 2019 which came into force with immediate effect on the date of the Notification.
2 CHAPTER- 2
A BRIEF ABOUT ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION
The Right to Information Act, 2005 is a landmark legislation that has transformed the relationship between the citizen and the state. This legislation has created for every citizen to hold the instrumentalities of Governance accountable on day to day basis. The legislation perceives the common man as an active participant in process of nation building by conferring on him the right to participate in the process through the implementation of Right to Information Act.
It has been more than 15 years since the RTI Act has been in operation in the state of Arunachal Pradesh.A key strength of the Act pertains to administrative and adjudicative autonomy of Information Commission.
The Right to Information Act 2005 came into force in Arunachal Pradesh along with the rest of the country on 12th October 2005 after 120 days of its enactment. As per the provisions of this Act, State Public Information Officers (SPIO) and Assistant Public Information Officers (APIO) were appointed by the Government of Arunachal Pradesh under separate notifications. In pursuance to the provisions of Clause 3 of Section 15 of the Right to Information Act, a selection committee was constituted for the appointment of State Chief Information Commissioner and State Information Commissioners. On 13th October 2006, Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission (APIC) was constituted and the State Chief Information Commissioner Shri NyodakYanggam and State Information Commissioners Shri Bani Danggen, Shri Habung Payeng and Shri Nipo Nabam were administered the oath of office by His Excellency Governor of Arunachal Pradesh, on 19th October 2006.As per Notification No. OM/51/2005/390 dated 14.11.2007 Shri Toko Anil was appointed as 4th SIC and was sworn in on 3rd December, 2007.
As provided under section 15 (1) of The Right to Information Act, 2005, the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh constituted the Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission vide Notification No. OM-51/2005 dated 13.10.2006 with 1 (one) Chief Information Commissioner and 3 (three) Information Commissioners with immediate effect.In exercise of the powers conferred by the Section 15 of the Right to Information Act 2005 (No.22 of 2005) and in partial modification of the Notification No. OM-51/2005 dated 13.10.2006, the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh constituted the Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission with a Chief Information Commission and 4(four) Information Commissioners with immediate effect vide Notification No. OM-51/2005/396 dated 14.11.2007.
The Commission started functioning after getting office accommodation at Secretariat Annexed building in the first week of December 2006 with office functionaries provided by the State Government. The Commission thereafter, entertained complaints, appeals and initiated proceedings to dispose of all the cases in accordance with the provisions
3 of the RTI Act. It also started monitoring the implementation of RTI Act and issued necessary instructions to various departments to comply with the provisions of RTI Act. The Commission has strived to educate the public and officials for proper implementation of RTI Act with the help of the State Government. Due to dismantling of the State Civil Secretariat for construction of new buildings, the Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission was shifted to Hotel Bomdila on 5th November 2008. The Commission continuedfunctioning from the same place without proper facilities like court room, office chamber, furniture, library facility, housing accommodation and supporting staffs and was delivering its duties under pathetic conditions.
However, the Commission has been shifted to the present location – earlier Planning Department premises, opposite to the Legislative Assembly, Arunachal Pradesh, since 28thFebuary 2017.
The Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission (APIC) has been rendering wonderful services for transparent and good governance since its inception in the state of Arunachal Pradesh since 2006. It is worth mentioning here that in the year 2009, the Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission was awarded the best InformationCommission of India for its effective implementation of Right to Information Act, 2005 in the state. This award was initiated by The Public Cause Research Foundation (PCRF), a Ghaziabad based NGO.
Shri Y.D. Thongchi, IAS (Rtd.) was appointed as the State Chief Information Commissioner and was administered oath of office on 1st March, 2011, as Shri NyodekYonggam demitted the post on 28thFebruary 2011. On 6th Oct’2015, the Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission bade farewell to Chief Information Commissioner Shri Y. D. Thongchi on his attaining the age of 65 as per section 16 (1) of the Right to Information Act, 2005.
Four Information Commissioners, Shri Matheim Linggi, Smti Nanom Jamoh, Shri Eken Riba and Shri Abraham K. Techi were appointed as State Information Commissioners of Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission (APIC) on 2nd January 2014 vide Notification F.NO. Ar-113/2011 and took Oath of office on 8th January 2014. Shri Eken Riba, SIC demitted office on 27/7/2016 on attaining the age of 65 years under section 16(2) of the RTI Act 2005.Shri Matheim Linggi, Smti Nanom Jamoh and Shri Abraham K. Techi demitted their office on 7th January, 2019 after completion of their tenure of 5 years.
Dr. Joram Begi was appointed as the State Chief Information Commissioner (SCIC) on 28th June, 2016 and was administered oath of office on 10th July, 2016 by the Hon’ble Governor, Shri Thatagata Roy. Shri Goto Ete was appointed as State Information Commissioner vide order No. AR-19/2017/142 dated 7th May, 2018 and was sworn in on 16th June, 2018 by the Hon’ble Governor, Brig (Dr.) B D Mishra (Rtd). Shri Leki Phuntso was appointed as State Information Commissioner vide order No. AR-133/2018 dated 4thJune, 2019 and was administered oath of office on 26th July, 2019 by the Brig. (Dr.) B.D Mishra and he demitted his office on 08-04-2020 on attaining age of 65 years.
4 ACTIVITIES UNDERTAKEN BY THE ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION DURING 2020-21
Awareness programme on RTI Act, 2005 at Yingkiong, Aalo and Menchuka District. Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission (APIC) conducted awareness programme on RTI Act, 2005 at Yingkiong, Aalo and Menchuka District on 28/01/2020 to 31/01/2020.Dr. Joram Begi Chief Information Commissioner (CIC) along with State Information Commissioners (SICs) Shri Goto Ete and Leki Phuntso visited Yingkiong, Aalo and Mechuka and elaborated how to seek information under section 6,7,18,19 and 20 of Act 2005 and also mentioned the role of SPIO/SAPIO under Section 7,8,9 and 11of RTI Act.
Conducted online hearing during the Covid-19 pandemic by Arunachal Pradesh information Commission, Itanagar.
During the Covid-19 pandemic the Commission had decided to conduct online hearing through Video/ Audio call. The decision was taken during a meeting between the state Chief Information Commissioner (SCIC) and the State Information Commissioner (SIC) on 20 April 2020. The Commission also decided that the receipt of appeals/complaints in physical form will be suspended until further orders. Those who intend to file an appeal or a complaint were advised to do so in the electronic form and e-mail it to [email protected]. Also, the SCIC and the SIC had volunteered to take a pay cut of 30 per cent from their gross salaries for a month and deposited the amount in the account of the Chief Minister’s Relief Fund for use in combating Covid-19.
5 CHAPTER – 3
F. No. OM-73/2005 GOVERNMENT OF ARUNACHAL PRADESH MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL, ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS &TRAINING DEPARTMENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS CIVIL SECRETARIAT, BLOCK NO.18 ITANAGAR
The 15th May, 2006 NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of section 27 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (Act No. 22 of 2005), the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh is hereby pleased to make the following rules to amend the Arunachal Pradesh Right to Information Rules, 2005, namely: -
1. Short title commencement :
(1) This rule may be called the Arunachal Pradesh Right to Information (1st Amendment) Rules, 2006.
(2) They shall come into force from the date of their publication in theArunachal Pradesh Gazette.
2. Amendments: In the Arunachal Pradesh Right to Information Rules, 2005 (hereinafter called the Principle Rules);
(1) For clause (b) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 2, the following clause shall be Substituted, namely:
"(b)" Competent authority" means the Public Information Office (PIO) or such Officer who is senior in rank to the Public Information Officer as the case may be".
(2) In rule 3 of Principal Rules; the following proviso shall be inserted namely:
"Provided further that the PIO/APIO shall assist the person requesting for Information in filling up the form-A to ensure complete details of information required. Provided further that person's residing outside the Capital Complex as well as District headquarters are allowed to apply on plain paper."
(3) In Rule 4 of the Principal Rules, (i) for Sub-clause (1) following sub-rule shall be substituted by the following namely:(i)"(1) If the requested information does not fall within the jurisdiction of the competent authority, it shall transfer the remaining part to the concerned PIO/APIO
6 of the Department/office with intimation to the applicant in form 'B' as soon as practicable, normally within fifteen days and in any case within thirty days of the receipt of the application, advising the applicant. Wherever possible, about the competent authority to whom the applicant should approach for the remaining part of the information. The application fee deposited in such cases shall not be refunded, nor is the applicant liable to pay application fee again on transfer of application for the remaining part of the information".
(ii) For sub-rule (3), the words, "reject the remaining part giving reasons thereof" shall be substituted by the words, namely:
"Transfer the remaining part to the competent authority of the concerned Department/Office thereof. Provided that the application for information shall not be rejected unless it is exempted from discloser".
(4) In Rule 5 of the Principal Rules, Sub-clause 3 (a) & (b) shall be omitted. (5) In Rule 6 of the Principal Rules, Sub-Rule (1) shall be omitted.
(5) In Rule 8 of the Principal Rules,
(1) for-clause (ii) of Sub-Rule (1) (A), the following clause shall be Substituted, namely:"
(i) Information in the form of Two rupees per page, Communication/ letter etc.
(ii) for-serial number-2 of Sub-Rule (1)(B), the following shall be substituted namely:
(2) For other than priced publication -Two rupees per page"
(iii) in clause (B) of Sub-rule (1) of rule 8, after serial No. 2, the following serial number and entries shall be added namely:"
(3) For inspection of records, no fee for - Rupees five”. the first hour; and for each subsequent hour (or fraction thereof).
(6) The existing particulars of Form - B prescribe' under Rule 4 (1) shall be Substituted by the following particulars namely:
7 "To
……………………………………………………….. ………………………………………………………..
Subject: - Forwarding of application for information
Sir,
I am forwarding herewith an application received from Shri/Smti……...... dated ...... ……………………. addressed to undersigns regarding supply of information on ......
2. The requested information falls within your jurisdiction and therefore, you are requested to take necessary steps to furnish the required information to the applicant.
3. This is in supersession of the acknowledgment given to the applicant vide No...... dated………………. Yours faithfully,
Competent Authority e-mail ...... …...... website ...... Tel. No………………
Shri/Smti …………………………...... he is requested to approach the above-mentioned officer for the information required".
K.K. Sharma Commissioner & Secretary to the Government of Arunachal Pradesh
8 NOTIFICATION, REGULATIONS AND ORDERS
(TO BE PUBLISHED IN ARUNACHAL PRADESH GAZETTE) GOVERNMENT OF ARUNACHAL PRADESH DEPARTMENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS CIVIL SECRETARIAT: BLOCK NO.4, 4TH FLOOR ITANAGAR
Dated Itanagar the 13th November, 2014
NOTIFICATION
No.AR-47/2014: In exercise of powers conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 27 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (Act No. 22 of 2005) the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh is pleased to make the following rules further to amend the Arunachal Pradesh Right to Information Rules,2005, namely; -
1. Short title and commencement: -
(i) The rules may be called the Arunachal Pradesh Right to Information Act (7th Amendment) Rule, 2014.
(ii) They shall come into force the date of their publication in the Arunachal Pradesh Gazette.
2. Amendment : In the Arunachal Pradesh Right to Information Rules,2005, in clause (B) of rule 8, after serial No.3, the following serial number and entry shall be inserted, namely; -
I. Information in the form of communication / - Two rupees per page Letter etc. II. For other than priced publication - Two rupees per page III. Copy of large size paper - Actual charge or cost price IV. Samples or models - Actual cost or price V. For information provided in CD or DVD - Actual cost of CD/DVD VI. For inspection of Records: No fee for first - Five rupees VII. Hour and for the subsequent each 15 minutes VIII. (or fraction thereof)
Sd/- Ramesh Negi Chief Secretary to the Government of Arunachal Pradesh
9 Note: - The principal rules were published in the Gazette of Arunachal Pradesh vide Department of Administrative Reforms No. OM-43/2003 dated 15/9/05 and subsequently amended vide: -
Notification No. Date Published in the Gazette of Arunachal Pradesh
1. OM-73/2005 15-05-2006 31-05-2006 2. OM-73/2005 01-05-2007 01-05-2007 3. OM-73/2005 19-12-2007 31-01-2008 4. OM-43/2003 28-01-2009 31-01-2009 5. AR-05/2009 24-04-2009 6. AR-99/2010 14-09-2010 01-10-2010
(K.R. Meena) Commissioner & Secretary to the Government of Arunachal Pradesh
10 GOVERNMENT OF ARUNACHAL PRADESH DEPARTMENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS BLOCK NO. 4, 4TH FLOOR ARUNACHAL PRADESH CIVIL SECRETARIAT ITANAGAR
NOTIFICATION
The 28th June, 2016
No. AR-102/2015-In exercise of the powers conferred under sub- section (3) of Section 15 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (Act No. 22 of 2005) the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh on the recommendation of the Committee constituted for the said purpose is hereby pleased to appoint Dr. Joram Begi as State Chief Information Commission.
The Governor of Arunachal Pradesh is further pleased to order that Dr. Joram Begi shall hold the office for a term of 5 (five) years from the date on which he enters upon his office or till he attains the age of 65 (Sixty-five) Years which ever is earlier.
The pay and allowance and other conditions of services shall be governed by the provisions of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (No. 22 to 2005).
(By order and in the name of the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh)
Satya Gopal Principal Secretary to the Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Department of Administrative Reforms, Itanagar.
11 F.NO. AR-19/2017 GOVERNMENT OF ARUNACHAL PRADERSH DEPARTMENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS CIVIL SECRETARIAT, BLOCK NO. 4, 4th FLOOR ITANAGAR - 791 111
NOTIFICATION
The 1st May, 2018
In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 16 (3) of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (No.22 of 2005) and on the recommendation of the Committee chaired by the Chief Minister, Arunachal Pradesh, the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh is hereby pleased to appoint Shri Goto Ete, Advocate as Information Commissioner, Arunachal Pradesh information Commission (APIC).
(By order and in the name of the Governor)
(Azimul Haque) Secretary to the Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar.
12 DEPARTMENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS CIVIL SECRETARIAT, BLOCK NO. 4, 4th FLOOR ITANAGAR - 791 111
NOTIFICATION
The 1st May, 2018
In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 15 (3) of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (No.22 of 2005) and on the recommendation of the Committee chaired by the Chief Minister, Arunachal Pradesh, the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh is hereby pleased to appoint Shri Leki Phuntso as State Information Commissioner, Arunachal Pradesh information Commission (APIC) in the pay Scale Rs 2,25,000 (Rupees two lakhs twenty five thousand ) only fixed per month and other allowances as admissible from time to time with effect from the date he assumes the charge of the office.
The Governor of Arunachal Pradesh if further, please to order that Shri Leki Phuntso shall hold the office for a term of 5 (five) years from the date on which he enters upon his office or till he attains the age of 65 (Sixty-five) years, whichever is earlier.
The Governor of Arunachal Pradesh is also, please to order that the pay and allowances and conditions of services of Shri Leki Phuntso shall be governed by the Arunachal Pradesh Information Commision (salaries, Allowances and other conditions of Service) Regulations, 2015, Notified vide Notification No.AR-203/2015 dated 12th January, 2016.
(By order and in the name of the Governor)
(Juhi Mukharjee, IAS) Secretary to the Government of Arunachai Pradesh, Department of Administrative Reforms. Itanagar.
13 File No. AR-24012/3/2020-SECT-1-AR/34 GOVERNMENT OF ARUNACHAL PRADESH DEPARTMENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS BLOCK NO.4,4TH FLOOR, AP CIVIL SECRETARIAT ITANAGAR-791111
Dated Itanagar, the 3rd February, 2021 NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 15 (3) of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (No.22 of 2005) and recommendation of the Selection Committee meeting dated 21.01.2021 Chaired by the Hon’ble Chief Minister, Arunachal Pradesh, the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh is hereby pleased to appoint the following as Information Commissioner, Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission:
1. Shri Genom Tekseng. 2. Smti Sonam Yadron. 3. Shri Gumjum Haider.
Further, in terms of Section 16 (2) of the said Act, read with Rule 12 of Right to Information (Term of Office, Salaries, Allowances and Other Terms and Conditions of Services of Chief Information Commissioner, Information Commissioners in the Central Information Commission, State Chief Information Commissioner and State Information Commissioners in the State Information Commission) Rule,2019, the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh is pleased to order that the three Information Commissioners shall hold office for 3 (three) years from the date of their entering upon the office to till they attain the age of 65 (sixty five) years whichever is earlier.
(By order and the name of Governor of Arunachal Pradesh)
(Ajay Chagti) Secretary to the Government of Arunachal Pradesh.
14 ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION- 2020-21
Sl. No. Name & Designation Contact number
Dr. Joram Begi 09436040316(Mobile) 1 State Chief Information Commissioner 0360-2213952 (O)
Shri Goto Ete 2 08794259266(Mobile) State Information Commissioner
Shri Leki Phuntso 3 09436288559(Mobile) State Information Commissioner (Retired)
Shri Genom Tekseng 4 09436040171(Mobile) State Information Commissioner
Shri Gumjum Haider 5 09436040637 (Mobile) State Information Commissioner
Smti Sonam Yudron 6 07431815780 (Mobile) State Information Commissioner
REGISTRY :
Sl. No. Name & Designation Contact number
Shri Habung Donyi. 1 APCS, Secretary-cum-Registrar 9862200001(Mobile) (From 01-03-2021 till date)
Smti M. Padung. 9436046333(Mobile) 2 APCS,Deputy Registrar (From 09-03-2017 till date)
Shri Jacob Lego. 3 Finance and Account Officer 9436041001(Mobile) (From 11-12-2020 till date)
Shri Rintu Saikia. 9436041570(Mobile) 4 Counsel of the APIC
15 CHAPTER-4
ANNUAL ACCOUNT OF THE COMMISSION Major Head 2070 OAS, Demand No. 67 (2020-21)
Fund Allocation (in SL. No. Sub Head Expenditure Rupees thousand) 1. 01-Salary 19900000 13556276
2. 02-Wages 2233000 2706507
3. 03-Overtime Allowance Nil Nil
4. 11-Domestic TE 700000 81248
5. 13-OE 1600000 1598260
20-Other Administrative 6. 100000 100000 Expensive
7. 27-Minor Work 500000 487203
8. 28-Professional Services 400000 280000
9. 30-Professional Services 875000 873964
10. 50- Other Charges 1500000 1493935
11. 13- Office Expenses (POL) 700000 704328
12. 01-salaries(LTC) 200000 Nil
Total 28708000 21881721
16 CHAPTER-5
YEAR WISE COMPLAINT/APPEAL RECEIVED AND DISPOSED OF BY THE COMMISSION AGAINST THE PUBLIC AUTHORITIES. Complaint/Appeal U/S 18(1) and Second Appeal U/S 19(3) of RTI Act, 2005 implemented of Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission in the Year 2020-21.
SL. No Name of Public Authority Complaint Appeal Disposed Pending
1 2 3 4 5 6
1. PWD 1 28 24 4
2. RWD 2 21 21 2
3. District Administrative Nil 11 11 Nil
4. DFO 3 8 8 3 5. APPSC Nil 2 1 1 6. DDSE Nil 5 5 Nil 7. Elementary Education Nil 3 3 Nil 8. Horticulture Nil 3 3 Nil Director Animal Husbandry 9. Nil 1 1 Nil and Vity Deptt 10. Hydro Power Dept. Nil 5 5 Nil
11. Tax & Exercise Dept Nil 1 1 Nil
12. WRD 1 15 13 3
13. Himalayan University Nil 3 3 Nil
15. Electrical Dept. of Power Nil 5 4 1
16. DMO Nil 2 Nil 2 17. APEDA Nil 2 2 Nil
19. ADCF Nil 1 1 Nil
20. Civil secretariat Nil 13 12 1
Judicial Magistrate-cum- Civil 21. Nil 1 1 Nil Judge
22. Geology & Mining Office Nil 4 2 2
23. State Project Director Nil 2 1 1
17 1 2 3 4 5 6
24. Director Health Nil 1 1 Nil
25. PHE Nil 5 5 Nil
27. Agriculture Nil 1 1 Nil
28. DLRSO Nil 2 2 Nil
29. DEO Nil 1 1 Nil
30. UD & Town Planning Nil 2 2 Nil
31. Police Nil 3 3 Nil
32. Transport Dept Nil 3 3 Nil
33. Axis Bank 1 Nil Nil 1
34. DRDA Nil 3 3 Nil
35. NEEPCO Nil 4 3 1 State Council of Science & 36. Nil 2 2 Nil Technology 37. BDO Nil 1 1 Nil
38. Staff Selection Board Nil 2 Nil 2 Development Corporation 39. Nil 2 2 Nil Limited, High Region Land Revenue & Settlement 40. Nil 1 Nil 1 Office 41. Election Nil 1 1 Nil
Total 8 170 156 26
18 CHAPTER-6
RTI COMPLAINT U/S 18(1) & SECOND APPEALCASE U/S 19(3) WITH STATUS OF EACH CASE IN THE ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION DURING THE YEAR-2020-21
Apellant / DATE OF DATE OF SL. CASE Respondent/ COMMIS- DISPOSED/ Complainant CASE CASE NO. NO. DEPARTMENT SIONER PENDING Addres OPENED DISPOSED
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 APIC- Shri ArsangPertin& Shri Tani Taki , SCIC, Joram 08.01.20 Disposed 04-02-20 01/2020 Shri Popok Darin, PIO-cum- Begi Appeal VilageKiyit P.O Executive engineer, Mebo, East Siang PWD, Pasighat District, A.P Division, Govt. of A.P, East Siang District, A.P
2 APIC- Shoney Pertin MLA Executive Engineer SCIC, Joram 08.01.20 Disposed 04-02-20 02/2020 Contestant 39 PWD Division Begi Appeal Mebo(AC) & Pasighat , Govt. of President Siang A.P Right form ward no- 6 PO/PS Pasighat Dist. East Siang (A.P)-791104
3 APIC- Tatum Mima Gen- PIO- Executive Shri Leki 08.01.20 Disposed 13.03.20 03/2020 Sec, Dulom welfare Engineer / plu-II Phuntso Appeal Society Vill. Mima Rural Work PO/PS Daporijo , Division Daporijo Upper Subansiri Dist. District Upper Subansiri (A.P)
4 APIC- Shri Dado Kakum& ByabangTagu E.E Gotoete, SIC 08.01.20 Yet to be 04/2020 Dado Tadak 6- Kilo PWD Jamin disposed Appeal Itanagar near NH-52, Division Dist. PO/PS Itanagar, Dist. KraDaadi (A.P) Papumpare
5 APIC- Shri KanggongPertin Er. Tani Taki E.E Shri Leki 08-01-20 Disposed 10-02-20 05/2020 Near Model Church , PWD Division Phuntso Appeal Upper BaRSKATA Pasighat Govt. of PASIGHAT po/ps A.P East Siang Dist. A.P
6 APIC- Shri Nong HageLailang, Adl- Shri Leki 08-01-20 Disposed 23-06-20 06/2020 PermePasighat Ward Deputy Phuntso Appeal No.-06 PO/PS CommionerMebo Pasighat , East Siang East Siang Dist. Dist. (A.P) Govt. of A.P
7 APIC- TakhengLamnio and V.K Jawal DFO , Gotoete, SIC 08.01.20 Yet to be 07/2020 Ram Veo Rayo, Vill- Kellong Forest disposed Appeal Nirjuli , Dist- Division Papumpare (A.P) Bhalukpong , West Kameng Dist. Bomdila , Govt. of A.P
19 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
8 APIC- Case of F/No. APIC- Bate Koyu, Deputy SCIC, Joram 08-01-20 Disposed 23-01-20 08/2020 155/2019, Bengia Secretary , APPSC, Begi Appeal Jayanta Itanagar.
9 APIC- Mani PabinVill- TanyangTatak , SCIC, Joram 16-01-20 Disposed 23-06-20 09/2020 Lising Po/Ps- Boleng DDSE Boleng , Begi Appeal , Siang District. A.P Siang Dist. A.P
10 APIC- Mani PabinVill- PIO- O/o the SCIC, Joram 16-01-20 Disposed 08-09-20 10/2020 Lising Po/Ps- Boleng, Deputyh Begi Appeal Siang District. A.P Commissioner Boleng , Siang Dist. A.P
11 APIC- MamuSonu , LLB PIO- Elementary Gotoete, SIC 16-01-20 Disposed 19-11-20 11/2020 student (ALA) Education Appeal Middle SoodVill- Department , Govt. Naharlugan, of A.P Papumpare Dist. A.P
12 APIC- MamuSonu , LLB PIO- Elementary Gotoete, SIC 16-01-20 Disposed 18.03.2020 12/2020 student (ALA) Education Appeal Middle SoodVill- Department , Govt. Naharlugan, of A.P PapumpareDist. A.P
13 APIC- MamuSonu , LLB PIO- Horticulture Gotoete, SIC 16-01-20 Disposed 19.02.20 13/2020 student (ALA) Department , Govt. Appeal Middle SoodVill- of A.P Itanagar Naharlugan, Papumpare Dist. A.P
14 APIC- Shri Nabam Natung , Re. TechiTotu , Shri 16-01-20 Disposed 29-10-20 14/2020 Vill- Dilla-II Silsanga E.E RWD, Sagalee LekiPhuntso Appeal Circle , Dist. Division Dist. Papmpare , A.P Papumpare . A.P
15 APIC- TechiNanli Tara, Dr.Tachi, Join Gotoete, SIC 16-01-20 Disposed 02-07-20 15/2020 Vill- Nirjuli , Director Animal Appeal Secondary School Husbandary and back side VityDeptt.
16 APIC- Shri Marbul Lego , Shri Gobo Yirang, SCIC, 16-01-20 Disposed 16-06-20 16/2020 son of Lt. Odi Lego, PIO-cum-SSW JoramBegi complaint Vill- Silluk,P.OMebo, Chief Engineer, P.S Pasighat Dist. Central zone-8, Siang (A.P) PWD Pasighat Division, Govt. of A. P., East Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
17 APIC- Shri TadakTarish , OtemJamoh ADC Shri 16-01-20 Disposed 18-02-21 17/2020 Pachin Colony Nyapin ADC LekiPhuntso Appeal Naharlugan, PO/PS Nyapin Dist. Naharlugan- Near KurungKumey, Abotani Vidya A.P Niketan School Pachin
20 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
18 APIC- Techi Lali, Sagalee Shri TechiTotu, Shri Leki 16-01-20 Disposed 18-10-20 18/2020 Kairo Colony, Dist. E.E RWD Sagalee Phuntso Appeal Papumpare . A.P Division , Dist. Papumpare (A.P)
19 APIC- Shri Doge Riba , DD Er. KaromPerme , Shri Leki 16-01-20 Disposed 09.03.2020 19/2020 Studio Building, S.E (Coord) Phuntso Appeal Vivek Vihar, College DHPD, Itanagar road, Itanagar- O/o the 791113 papumpare Superintending (A.P) Engineer(Coord) Dept. of Hydro Power Development, Vidyut Bhawan, Itanagar A.P
20 APIC- Lido Ete , Vill- Bene, Executive Engineer SCIC, Joram 16-01-20 Disposed 18.06.20 20/2020 PO/PS- Aalo, West RWD Aalo Begi Complaint Siang A.P Division , West Siang Aalo
21 APIC- MamuSonu , Middle PIO- Tax & Shri Leki 20-01-20 Disposed 09.03.2020 21/2020 SoodVill- Exercise Dept. Phuntso Appeal Naharlugan, Govt. of A.P, Papumpare Dist. A.P Itanagar
22 APIC- Shri Murbyo Er. TadamLigu, Gotoete, SIC 20-01-20 Disposed 02-07-20 22/2020 Panyang, D.D studio superintending Appeal Building , Vivek Engineer Cum Vihar, collage Road Chief Engineer Itanagar -791113 West Zone , Water Papumpare Dist. A.P Resource Dept (WRD) Vivek Vihar, Itanagar A.P
23 APIC- Moharammed Sajid PIO- O/o the SCIC, Joram 20-01-20 Disposed 18.02.2020. 23/2020 Hussain S/o registrar , Begi Appeal Mahammed Mujeeb Himalayan Hussain 9-8-168/16/A University Jullang Golconda Fort Bada Village, Near Bazar Hydrabad Central Jail , 500008, Contact No- Itanagar A.P 9966898124
24 APIC- Moharammed Sajid PIO- O/o the SCIC, Joram 20-01-20 Disposed 24.01.2020 24/2020 Hussain S/o registrar , Begi Appeal Mahammed Mujeeb Himalayan Hussain 9-8-168/16/A University Jullang Golconda Fort Bada Village, Near Bazar Hydrabad Central Jail , 500008, Contact No- Itanagar A.P 9966898124
25 APIC- Moharammed Sajid PIO- O/o the SCIC, Joram 20-01-20 Disposed 18.02.2020 25/2020 Hussain S/o registrar , Begi APPEAL Mahammed Mujeeb Himalayan Hussain 9-8-168/16/A University Jullang Golconda Fort Bada Village, Near Bazar Hydrabad Central Jail , 500008, Contact No- Itanagar A.P 9966898124
21 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
26 APIC- Vinod Kumar Yadav PIO-DDSE, East Gotoete, SIC 20-01-20 Disposed 20-08-20 26/2020 Vill- Siswa (Bhanti) KamengSeppa, A.P APPEAL P.S- BhatniTehasi, Dist. Deoriauttar Pradesh
27 APIC- Shoney pertin Add. Er. Tarik Mize, Shri Leki 28-01-20 Disposed 06.02.2020 27/2020 Airfield, Ward No.06, E.E Pasighat Phuntso Appeal PO/PS- Pasigaht, Electrical Dept. of East Siang Dist. Power ,Pasighat,Govt. of A.P
28 APIC- Shoney pertin Add. Er. R.N Singhb , Shri Leki 28-01-20 Disposed 25-08-20 28/2020 Airfield, Ward No.06, E.E PWD Division Phuntso Appeal PO/PS- Pasigaht, Yingkiong, upper East Siang Dist. Siang District, Govt of A.P
29 APIC- Mr. MimarDirchi, Er. Kendo Zirdo, SCIC, 28-01-20 Disposed 16-06-20 29/2020 Lipu Village Lower E.E Likabali JoramBegi Appeal Siang Dist. A.P Electrical Division, Dept. of Power.(A.P)
30 APIC- Mr.TalinDignium, Shri MilloPushang, Gotoete, SIC 28-01-20 Disposed 01-10-20 30/2020 OBT, Nitivihar, District Planning Appeal Ward no-8 IMC/D-99 Officer, Dept. of Gadda colony Ita. Planning Upper Distt. Papumpare Subansiri dist. Daporijo
31 APIC- Shri Amin Danggen , Dr. D.Bagra DMO SCIC, 28-01-20 Disposed 12-05-20 31/2020 Vill- Simong, PO/PS- Cum PIO DMO JoramBegi Appeal Yingkiong Dist. Upper Siang Upper Siang A.P- District (A.P)- 791002 791002
32 APIC- Shri BengiaRidek, Circle Officer Gotoete, SIC 28-01-20 Disposed 03-09-20 32/2020 Karsingsa PO/PS- (Highway) Appeal Barderdewa , Dist. Itanagar Capital Papumpare. A.P Complex. A.P
33 APIC- AmimDanggen, vill- Er. G. Lipir E.E SCIC, Joram 28-01-20 Disposed 17-Mar-20 33/2020 Simong PO/PS RWD, Yionkiong Begi Appeal Yionkiong Distt. Division, O/O E.E Upper Siang (A.P) RWD. Post Office Yionkiong
34 APIC- Shri Shoney Pertin, Er. TamoJamoh Gotoete, SIC 28-01-20 Disposed 15-10-20 34/2020 MLA, contestant 39- E.E WRD Division Appeal Mebo A/C cum Pasighat Govt. Of President Siang A.P Right Pasighat Airfield Word No-6 Po/Ps-Pasighat East Siang Distt.
22 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
35 APIC- Shri Doge Riba, C/O Shri Likha Tatum, Shri Leki 28-01-20 Disposed 29-09-20 35/2020 D.dStidio Building, Administrative Phuntso Appeal Vivek Vihar Collage Officer -cum- PIO Road, Itanagar APEDA, Itanagar o/o the Director Arunachal Pradesh Energy Development Agency, Urja Bhawan, Tadar Tang Marg, Itanagar
36 APIC- Mr. Vijay Pertin Mr. AdukParon, Shri Leki 28-01-20 Disposed 18-08-20 36/2020 Vill- Ithili DFO, PO, Roing, Phuntso Appeal PO/PS -Roing Lower PS Roing, Lower Dibang Valley Dibang Valley
37 APIC- Shri Hemmar Diyum Er. OjirTekseng, SCIC, Joram 28-01-20 Disposed 07-07-20 37/2020 Village, Bene Po/Ps PIO-cum Executive Begi Appeal Aalo West Siang Engineer distt. Yionkiong, Electrical Division Upper siang. A.P.
38 APIC- Birendra Tallong C/o Er. Nani That PIO- Gotoete, SIC 12.02.20 Disposed 13-08-20 38/2020 TechiTajum Village- cum Executive Appeal Chimpu-1 Po/ps RK. Engineer, Mission Distt/ Naharlagun Papumpare Highway Division PWD, A.pNirjuli
39 APIC- Shri BarotPertin S/o PIO-cum CEO SCIC, Joram 11.02.20 Disposed 09-06-20 39/2020 Shri Pire Pertin PSCDCL, Begi Appeal Village- silluk, Mebo HighRegion Po. Mebo, psPasighat PO/PS - Pasighat East siang Distt/ East Siang A.P
40 APIC- Shri BarotPertin S/o PIO-cum- DLSRO SCIC, Joram 11.02.20 Disposed 09-06-20 40/2020 Shri Pire Pertin East Siang, Begi Appeal Village- silluk, Mebo Pasighat Po. Mebo, psPasighat East siang
41 APIC- Smti Rani Jamoh TalomDupak PIO- Shri Leki 16.03.2020 Disposed 24-03-20 41/2020 Tawe A-Sector, cun- ADC, Capital Phuntso Appeal Naharlagun Ward Complex o/o No. 24 Distt, Deputy Papumpare, Commissioner Capital Complex, Itanagar
42 APIC- Smti Rani Jamoh K.R.S Krishnan, Gotoete, SIC 13.02.2020 Disposed 04-06-20 42/2020 Tawe A-Sector, Under Secretary to Appeal naharlagun Ward Cs, Civil Secretariat, Block No.24 Distt no-2 th floor, Pappumpare Itanagar
23 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
43 APIC- LibiMarde, OBT, T. Ligu, PIO WRD Shri Leki 13-02-20 Disposed 10-12-20 43/2020 NitiVihar, Ward O/o Chief Engineer Phuntso Appeal No,08 IMC/D.99, W/zone Vivek Itanagar, Distt Vihar, Itanagar Papumpare
44 APIC- LibiMarde, OBT, T. Ligu, PIO WRD Shri Leki 13.02.2020 Disposed 10-12-20 44/2020 NitiVihar, Ward O/o Chief Engineer Phuntso Appeal No,08 IMC/D.99, W/zone Vivek Itanagar, Distt Vihar, Itanagar Papumpare
45 APIC- Shri Ragi Neri, Executive Gotoete, SIC 17.02.2020 Disposed 27-08-20 45/2020 Pacha Morang, New Engineer, RWD, Appeal Seppa East Kameng Bameg Division, A.P Distt. East Kameng.
46 APIC- Shri Ragi Neri, Executive Gotoete, SIC 17.02.2020 Disposed 27-08-20 46/2020 Pacha Morang, New Engineer, RWD, Appeal Seppa East Kameng Bameg Division, A.P Distt. East Kameng.
47 APIC- Shri Batem Pertin PIO-cum- Extra SCIC, 15.10.19 Disposed 03-11-20 47/2020 S/O Donggong pertin Assistant JoramBegi Appeal Kiyit Village, Mebo Commissioner Po/mebo, Ps- Distt. East Siang Pasighat Distt. Pasighat, A.P East kameng
48 APIC- Shri Batem pertin, PIO-cum-Chief Gotoete, SIC 22.10.19 Disposed 22-03-21 48/2020 KiyitVill- Mebo, PO Judicial Appeal Mebo, PS -Pasighat, Magistrate-cum- Distt. East Siang Civil Judge( Sr. Diva) Dist/ East Siang, Pasighat
49 APIC- Shri Birendra Executive Engineer Shri Leki 18.02.20 Yet to be 49/2020 TallongVill- Jolly, RWD, Seppa Phuntso disposed Appeal Po/Ps Seijosa. Distt, Division Distt. East Pakke Kesang Kameng
50 APIC- Shri Ram Veo Rayo Er. T.K.Tagin Gotoete, SIC 19.02.20 Disposed 25-06-20 50/2020 Colony, PO/PS PIO-cum- Appeal Nirjuli Distt/ Se(coordination) Papumpare RWD, Itanagar, Govt of A.P
51 APIC- Shri Tadar tai PIIO/ Jummar Gotoete, SIC 21.02.20 Disposed 08.05.20 51/2020 NyokumLapang, Kamdak, Chief Appeal Itanagar, PO/PS Engineer (W.Zone) Itanagar Deptt. Of Hydro Power
52 APIC- Shri Tadar Tai, Er.W. Hondique, Gotoete, SIC 21.02.20 Disposed 20.08.20 52/2020 NyokumLapang, EE RWD, Laying Appeal PO/PS Itanagar yangte Division, Distt. KurungKumey. A.P
24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
53 APIC- Shri Tadar Tai, Er. T.Welly, Chief Gotoete, SIC 21.02.20 Disposed 30.06.20 53/2020 NyokumLapang, Engineer,(W.Z) Appeal PO/PS Itanagar RWD, Govt. of A.P, Itanagar.
54 APIC- Shri Tadar Tai, Er. T.Welly, Chief Gotoete, SIC 21.02.20 Disposed 20.08.20 54/2020 NyokumLapang, Engineer,(W.Z) Appeal PO/PS Itanagar RWD, Govt. of A.P, Itanagar.
55 APIC- Shri Ajay Tajo, Sono DFO, Seppa, East SCIC, Joram 25.02.20 Disposed 26.05.20 55/2020 Tajo c/o Taje Tajo Kameng Begi complaint Medical colony Seppa Distt. East KamengA.p
56 APIC- Shri Bini NogaVill, Er. Nani Chilyang, SCIC, Joram 25.02.20 Disposed 27-10-20 56/2020 Kherbari EE/ PWD, Zero Begi Appeal PO/Kalptukar, Distt. Lower ps/Raga SDO subansiri. A.P Dollunmukh Distt. Kamle
57 APIC- Shri TafangVeo, Er. M.Ronya, EE, Gotoete, SIC 27.02.20 Rejected 12-11-20 57/2020 Boso Colony, Seppa, RWD Bameng Appeal East Kameng Division, East District. A.P Kameng Seppa.
58 APIC- Smti Rani Jamoh Shri TalomDupak, Gotoete, SIC 27.02.20 Disposed 02-07-20 58/2020 Tawe A-Sector, ADC, DC office, Appeal Naharlagun Ward capital Complex No. 24 Distt, Itanagar, Distt. Papumpare, Papumpare
59 APIC- Shri Dibru Menjo, Shri Jotin Linggi, SCIC, Joram 27.02.20 Disposed 29-09-20 59/2020 c/o Shri Odi Menjo PIO-cum- Geology Begi Appeal O/o APIC, Itanagar &Minig Officer Lower Dibang Valley, Roing
60 APIC- Shri Dado Kagung, Shri Avao, Zivik, Gotoete, SIC 03.03.20 Disposed 25-06-20 60/2020 New Palin, PO/PS EE, RWD, Jamin Appeal Palin, Distt. Kra- Division, Distt. Daadi Kra-Daadi
61 APIC- Shri Mani Pabin, Shri Boken Pao, SCIC, Joram 06.03.20 Disposed 30-06-20 61/2020 new palin, PO/PS DFO-cum-PIO, Begi Appeal palin, Distt. Kra- Mouling wildlife Daadi, A.P sanctuary.
62 APIC- Shri Debia Soram, Mrs. T. Narah, Gotoete, SIC 06.03.20 Yet to be 62/2020 Prem Nagar, PIO-cum- Deputy disposed Appeal Naharlagun, PO/PS, Director Health Naharlagun Service , Naharlagun
63 APIC- Shri Tamchi Sima, PIO/O/o Director SCIC, Joram 09.03.20 Disposed 21-04-20 63/2020 lower Bhalukpong, APEDA, govt. of Begi Appeal PO-Bhalukpong, arunachalpradesh, westKameng A.P Itanagar
25 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
64 APIC- Shri Hillang State Project SCIC, Joram 09.03.20 Disposed 26.05.20 64/2020 Tadh, D-sector, B-1 Director,PIO) SSA Begi Appeal Quarter, Itanagar Rajya Mission,Itangar
65 APIC- Shri LishiTajum, PIO, PHE & W.S Gotoete, SIC 03.03.20 Disposed 15-11-20 65/2020 Vill- Toru Po Deed, Ziro. A.P Appeal Ps Ziro, Lower subansiri, A.P.
66 APIC- Shri Lido Ete, vill- PIO-cum- SCIC, Joram 03.03.20 Disposed 07-07-20 66/2020 Aalo, West Siang Executive Engineer Begi Complaint District,A.P WRD, Aalo Division, West Siang Districts.
67 APIC- Shri Shoney Pertin, EE-cum-PIO SCIC, Joram 06.03.20 Disposed 19-05-20 67/2020 MLA, contestant 39- PWD, Division, Begi Appeal Mebo A/C cum Yingkiong, President Siang Upper Siang, Right Pasighat District, A.P Airfield Word No-6 Po/Ps- Pasighat East Siang Distt.
68 APIC- Shri Vijay Pertin, PD.DRDA, Roing. SCIC, 16.03.20 Disposed 26.05.2020 68/2020 Vill: lthili, JoramBegi Appeal PO/PS - Roing, Lower DibangValley District
69 APIC- Shri TadarTadang, Shri T.K Takang, Gotoete, SIC 17.03.20 Disposed 25.06.2020 69/2020 your colony, SE-Coordination, Appeal Naharlagun RWD, Itanagar.
70 APIC- Miseallinears cases of PIO, ADCF for Gotoete, SIC 18.03.20 Disposed 11-02-21 70/2020 file no Apic-13/2017, chief conservator Appeal OlingMudi of forest Central Arunachal Pradesh, Circle Pasighat.
71 APIC- Hugli Riram, Shri Margi Ete, SCIC, Joram 19.03.20 Disposed 22-09-20 71/2020 yamkobagru, west PIO-cum-DAO, Begi Appeal siang district, Aalo. O/o oistrict Agriculture Officer, Aalo, West Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
72 APIC- Shri Dibi Marde, PIO, Oling SCIC, Joram 20.03.20 Disposed 02.06.20 72/2020 OBT, NitiVihar, Padung, SW (civil) Begi Appeal Ward No. 8IMC/D- W/Zone, O/o the Chief Engineer 99, Itanagar P/pare. W/Zone Dept. of Hydro Power Development, Itanagar.
26 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
73 APIC- Shri Tamchi, Shri Narang Tani Gotoete, SIC 04.05.20 Disposed 17-12-20 73/2020 C/o Tai Tasuk, PIO-cum-Joint Appeal APST Colony, Director, Ganga, RK, Mission, Office of the Directorate Horticulture, Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh.
74 APIC- Shri Gomi Taipodia, Smti Pakgi Koyu Gotoete, SIC 04.05.20 Disposed 24.09.2020 74/2020 & Shri TakamHapu, (Lombi) Appeal C/o Nyiko Printing PIO-cum-DDSE, Press Near UCO, Likabali, Bank Tinali, Itanagar Lower Siang Dist. A.P
75 APIC- Shri Takheng Shri Tuggu Loya, SCIC, Joram 12.05.20 Disposed 09-06-20 75/2020 Gohpur Near, KV2 ADC-cum- Begi Appeal School, Itanagar, ERO(PR-02- Chimpu, Rk Mission Bameng) East Zilla Parishad constituency.
76 APIC- Shoney Pertin & Sri Er. S.S. Singh SCIC, Joram 12.05.20 Disposed 11-08-20 76/2020 Kanggong Pertin EE, Pwd O/O Begi Appeal Pasighat, Airfield Khupa, Hayuliang Ward No-4, PO/ps- Division, Anjaw. Pasighat East siang.
77 APIC- Shoney Pertin & Shri Reri Kato, SCIC, Joram 14.05.20 Disposed 25-08-20 77/2020 Kanggong Pertin EE, RWD, Begi Appeal Pasighat, Airfield Division, Kaying Ward No-4, PO/ps- Govt of A.P Siang Pasighat East siang. District
78 APIC- Shoney Pertin & EE,PWD, Division SCIC, Joram 14.05.20 Disposed 18-08-20 78/2020 Kanggong Pertin Boleng Siang Begi Appeal Pasighat, Airfield District. Ward No-4, PO/ps- Pasighat East siang.
79 APIC- Shri Birendra Teli, Er. Tarh Gungkap Gotoete, SIC 19.05.20 Disposed 22-10-20 79/2020 vill- Chimpu-II PO/ (EE) PWD, Capital Appeal R.K mission Distt. Division-B, P/Pare Itanagar,A.P
80 APIC- Shoney Pertin & Sri Er. S.S. Singh SCIC, Joram 01.06.20 Disposed 11-08-20 80/2020 Kanggong Pertin EE, Pwd O/O Begi Appeal Pasighat, Airfield Khupa, Hayuliang Division, Anjaw. Ward No-4, PO/ps-Pasighat East siang.
81 APIC- Smti Rani Jamoh PIO/ Shri Gari Tai, Gotoete, SIC 05.06.20 Disposed 18-03-21 81/2020 Tawe A-Sector, Dy Superintending Appeal Naharlagun Ward Of Police Capital No. 24 Distt, Complex, Itanagar Papumpare,
27 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
82 APIC- Shri Tadar Tai, PIO/Er. Bamang Gotoete, SIC 05.06.20 Disposed 11.02.2021 82/2020 NyokumLapang, Tadh, E.E, PHE & Appeal PO/PS Itanagar WS Sangram layang Division Distt. Kurung Kumey. A.P
83 APIC- Mr. Birendra Teli, Er Tarh Gungkap SCIC, Joram 09-06-20 Disposed 01-10-20 83/2020 Vill- Chimpu-1, PIO, E.E PWD, Capital Begi Compalint RK Mission, Division-B, DistPapumpare Itanagar.
84 APIC- Sri Tabia Riang, PIO/ C. Wangsu, SCIC, 15-06-20 Disposed 03-11-20 84/2020 PWD Colony, DTO, Yupia Road, JoramBegi Appeal Itanagar, PO/PS NLG. PO/PS Nlg. Itangar, Dist. P/Pare
85 APIC- Sri Tabia Riang, PIO/ Sumit Burah, SCIC, Joram 15-06-20 Disposed 24-11-20 85/2020 PWD Colony, DTO, Bomdila, Begi Appeal Itanagar, PO/PS PO/PS Itangar, Dist. P/Pare BomdilaDist west kameng.
86 APIC- Sri Tabia Riang, PIO/ Dumbing SCIC, Joram 15-06-20 Disposed 24-11-20 86/2020 PWD Colony, Lamnio, DTO Begi Appeal Itanagar, PO/PS Seppa, PO/PS Itangar, Dist. P/Pare SeppaDist East kameng.
87 APIC- Shri Tabing Lamgu, PIO/ Dy. Gotoete, SIC 15-06-20 Disposed 01-10-20 87/2020 Guwahati High Commissioner(DC) Appeal court, Itangar Seppa PO/PS Permanent Branch SeppaDist- East kameng
88 APIC- Shri Tam Tarak and PIO/ E.Executive, Gotoete, SIC 15-06-20 Disposed 05-11-20 88/2020 TeliTahar, Nyakum RWD, KraDaadi, Appeal Colony, Nirjuli, Division Jamin Nahrlagun Camp Palin
89 APIC- Sri Takheng Lamino, PIO/ Sri Lobsang SCIC, Joram 15-06-20 Yet to be 89/2020 Gohpur Near KV Yeshi (SE) Office Begi disposed Appeal School, Itanagar, of the Western PO/RK mission, (CE) Zone, PWD, Itanagar A.P, Itanagar
90 APIC- Sri Haro Dodum, PIO/Axis Bank, Gotoete, SIC 15-06-20 Yet to be 90/2020 GohpurTinali Back O-Point Tinali, disposed Complaint Side PO/ RK Itangar Mission, Itangar
91 APIC- Sri Raj Pao- Sri Otem Tayeng, SCIC, Joram 17-06-20 Disposed 13-10-20 91/2020 Chairman APYCSC, JDEE-cum PIO Begi Appeal Edu. Society, Abotani Directoriate Of colony, Itanagar Elementary Education Govt of A.P, Itangar
92 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, Sri Jongge Yirang SCIC, Joram 17-06-20 Disposed 15-09-20 92/2020 District- Pasighat, (DDSE) Dy. Begi Appeal NPP, East Siang, Directoriate of Pasighat, Right School Education, Form, PO/PS East Siang District- Pasighat, Ward No-4 Pasighat
28 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
93 APIC- Sri Morgam Ori, C/o PIO. EE, PWD, Gotoete, SIC 17-06-20 Disposed 24.09.2020 93/2020 Eastern Horizon & Capital Division-A, Appeal Offset Printing Press. Itangar T.T marg, Bank Tinali, Itangar
94 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, Sri Sibo Passing SCIC, Joram 17-06-20 Disposed 13-10-20 94/2020 District- Pasighat, EAC (Election) Begi Appeal NPP, East Siang, pasighat, Election Pasighat, Right Officer, East Siang Form, PO/PS Pasighat, Ward No-4
95 APIC- Sri Ngurang Tana, GS Meena, Gotoete, SIC 17-06-20 Disposed 03-09-20 95/2020 Tumru- Lekha Commissioner Appeal Segment, Doimukh& Power, Itangar, PO-PS, Itangar PO/PS Itangar
96 APIC- Sri Bengia Sagung, DK Baishya,(HOP) SCIC, Joram 19-06-20 case 25-08-20 96/2020 Tumru- Lekha PHE, NEEPCO, Begi dismissed Appeal Segment, Doimukh& Ltd Doimukh PO-PS, Itangar Distt-P/Pare, A.P
97 APIC- Sri Bengia Sagung, DK Baishya,(HOP) SCIC, Joram 19-06-20 case 25-08-20 97/2020 Tumru- Lekha PHE, NEEPCO, Begi dismissed Appeal Segment, Doimukh& Ltd Doimukh PO-PS, Itangar Distt-P/Pare, A.P
98 APIC- Sri Bengia Sagung, Sri PIO Yakar Gotoete, SIC 19-06-20 case 20.08.2020 98/2020 Tumru- Lekha Dawe, CO Yupia dismissed Appeal Segment, Doimukh& O/o Dc Yupia and PO-PS, Itangar NakapHina Nabam DLSRO, Yupia
99 APIC- Sri BengiaSagung, Pekhi Nabam Gotoete, SIC 19-06-20 case 03.09.2020 99/2020 Tumru- Lekha ( Under Secretary dismissed Appeal Segment, Doimukh& Hydro Power) PO-PS, Itangar PO/Ps Itangar
100 APIC- Sri Bengia Sagung, DK Baishya,(HOP) SCIC, Joram 19-06-20 case 25-08-20 100/2020 Tumru- Lekha PHE, NEEPCO, Begi dismissed Appeal Segment, Doimukh & Ltd Doimukh PO-PS, Itangar Distt-P/Pare, A.P
101 APIC- Sri Takheng Lamino, Sri Dohey Sangro, Gotoete, SIC 23.06.2020 Disposed 01.04.2021 101/2020 Gohpur Near KV PIO-Cum- DEO Appeal School, Itanagar, Seppa, East PO/RK mission, Kameng District. Itanagar
102 APIC- Shri HageTachang, PIO/ Joint Director SCIC, Joram 30-06-20 Disposed 15-09-20 102/2020 Papu Hi;; Colony, Of UD & Town Begi Appeal Opposite, SE, PWD, Planning, Itangar. Nlg.
29 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
103 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, EE, RWD, SCIC, Joram 30-06-20 Disposed 13-10-20 103/2020 District- Pasighat, Division, Tawang, Begi Appeal NPP, East Siang, Govt of A.P Pasighat, Right Form, PO/PS Pasighat, Ward No-4
104 APIC- Sri JesunYangfo, EE, PWD, Gotoete, SIC 06-08-20 Appeal 12-11-20 104/2020 Jollang. PIO RK Chayang Tajo, Rejected Appeal mission, Ps-Itangar East Kameng District.
105 APIC- Sri JesunYangfo, EE, PWD, Gotoete, SIC 06-08-20 Appeal 12-11-20 105/2020 Jollang. PIO RK Chayang Tajo, Rejected Appeal mission, Ps-Itangar East Kameng District.
106 APIC- Sri MamuSonu, Jt.Director -cum- SCIC, 06-08-20 Disposed 03-11-20 106/2020 Middle Sood, Village- PIO/APIO, JoramBegi Appeal Naharlagun Horticulture Department Govt.
107 APIC- Sri Mani Pabin, EE(E) cum- PIO SCIC, 06-08-20 Disposed 22-09-20 107/2020 Misram-Vill. Near Yiokiong, JoramBegi Appeal Litchi, School, Electrical Division Pasighat. East Siang Department Of District. Power Yinkiong.
108 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, Er. Galling Lipin, SCIC, Joram 14-08-20 Disposed 08-12-20 108/2020 District- Pasighat, Executive Begi Appeal NPP, East Siang, Engineer, RWD- Pasighat, Right Division, Form, PO/PS Yionkiong, Upper Pasighat, Ward No-4 Siang District.
109 APIC- Sri RoshmanTausik, Sri Pama Bagang, Gotoete, SIC 25-08-20 Disposed 01-04-21 109/2020 E-252, Tanla Nagar, PD, DRDA, Anjaw Appeal Near KBM School District, DRDA Tezu, Lohit District. Office, Hawai
110 APIC- Sri RoshmanTausik, Sri Pama Bagang, Gotoete, SIC 25-08-20 Disposed 01-04-21 110/2020 E-252, Tanla Nagar, PD, DRDA, Anjaw Appeal Near KBM School District, DRDA Tezu, Lohit District. Office, Hawai
111 APIC- Sri RoshmanTausik, Er. TomoPertin Gotoete, SIC 25-08-20 Disposed 03-11-20 111/2020 E-252, Tanla Nagar, (EE) WRD, Anjaw Appeal Near KBM School Districts, A.P Tezu, Lohit District. Hawai, Anjaw District.
112 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, Er. Galling Lipin, SCIC, Joram 26-08-20 Disposed 08-12-20 112/2020 District- Pasighat, Executive Begi Appeal NPP, East Siang, Engineer, RWD- Pasighat, Right Division, Form, PO/PS Yionkiong, Upper Pasighat, Ward No-4 Siang District.
30 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
113 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, Er Tamo Jamoh, SCIC, Joram 26-08-20 Disposed 27-10-20 113/2020 District- Pasighat, EE, WRD, ER. Begi Appeal NPP, East Siang, GonongPertin, EE, Pasighat, Right WRD, Division Form, PO/PS Pasighat Pasighat, Ward No-4
114 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, EE-cum-PIO, SCIC, Joram 26-08-20 Yet to be 114/2020 District- Pasighat, RWD, Division Begi disposed Appeal NPP, East Siang, Yiokiong, Govt of Pasighat, Right A.P Form, PO/PS Pasighat, Ward No-4
115 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, Er. Gonong Pertin, SCIC, Joram 26-08-20 Disposed 27-10-20 115/2020 District- Pasighat, EE, WRD, Division Begi Appeal NPP, East Siang, pasighat, Govt Of Pasighat, Right A.P Form, PO/PS Pasighat, Ward No-4
116 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, Er. Galling Lipin, SCIC, Joram 26-08-20 Disposed 08-12-20 116/2020 District- Pasighat, Executive Begi Appeal NPP, East Siang, Engineer, RWD- Pasighat, Right Division, Form, PO/PS Yionkiong, Upper Pasighat, Ward No-4 Siang District.
117 APIC- Mr. TokoNikam, PIO-cum- DFO- 03-09-20 Yet to be 117/2020 Opp. PLM School, Ziro Lower disposed Complaint Hapoli, PO/PS- Ziro, Subansiri District. Lower Subansiri District.
118 APIC- Sri Kango Taku, Sri Higio Tala Gotoete, SIC 03-09-20 Disposed 19-11-20 118/2020 RojotGaduk, (Under Secretary) Appeal SirdeyMacket, Near office of the Helipad Ground. Registrar of NLG. Society, Block-4 AP, Civil Secretariat.
119 APIC- Sri Kango Taku, Sri Bomken Basar, Gotoete, SIC 03-09-20 Disposed 19-11-20 119/2020 RojotGaduk, PIO & Dy Appeal SirdeyMacket, Near Superindent-Rural Helipad Ground. Yupia, Office of the NLG. S>P, Papumpare, Rural Yupia.
120 APIC- Sri Nikil Pareek, 6/21 PIO, DC, Hawai, SCIC, Joram 08-10-20 Disposed 12-01-21 120/2020 Batra vihar, Anjaw District. Begi Appeal Bengdubi Military Station,734424, Dist. Darjeeling West Bengal
121 APIC- Takio Ameladoes, Rakhi Tara Tara, 14-10-20 Yet to be 121/2020 Add.Lekha Tumree Sir Marager disposed Appeal Segment, Doimukh, (Adm)-cum-Public Relation Officer,Hydro Power Electric Project, NEEpco, ltd Doimukh
31 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
122 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, Er.RN Singh, EE, SCIC, Joram 14-10-20 Disposed 24-11-20 122/2020 District- Pasighat, PWD, Division, Begi Appeal NPP, East Siang, Yionkiong, Upper Pasighat, Right Siang Form, PO/PS Pasighat, Ward No-4
123 APIC- Sri AmliDanggen, DDSE, Upper SCIC, Joram 14-10-20 Disposed 05-01-21 123/2020 vill-Simong, PO/PS Siang District, Begi Appeal Yionkiong, Yionkiong,O/o the upperSiang DDSE, Near DC Office, Yionkiong, Upper Siang District.
124 APIC- Sri Shoney Pertin, Er.RN Singh, EE, SCIC, Joram 14-10-20 Disposed 24-11-20 124/2020 District- Pasighat, PWD, Division, Begi Appeal NPP, East Siang, Yionkiong, Upper Pasighat, Right Siang Form, PO/PS Pasighat, Ward No-4
125 APIC- Shri TadarTakang Bamang APO O/o Gotoete, SIC 19-10-20 Disposed 17-12-20 125/2020 Yawn colony, NLG, State Council Appeal PO/PS Scinence& Technology.
126 APIC- Shri TadarTakang Hage Mobin, EE, Gotoete, SIC 19-10-20 Yet to be 126/2020 Yawn colony, NLG, WRD, Ziro disposed Appeal PO/PS Division, Dist Lower Subansiri.
127 APIC- Shri Tadar Takang Bamang APO Gotoete, SIC 19-10-20 Disposed 17-12-20 127/2020 Yawn colony, NLG, O/o State Council Appeal PO/PS Scinence& Technology.
128 APIC- Dabo Loda, Shri Soglaom, Gotoete, SIC 19-10-20 Disposed 01-04-21 128/2020 NyokumLapang, Bago Balom, EE, Appeal Itanagar. PWD, Bameng Distt, East Kameng, Seppa.
129 APIC- Shri MikreTaso& MrBajum Taba, SCIC, Joram 20-10-20 Disposed 12-01-21 129/2020 Shri KarbaRiba, Divisional Forest Begi Appeal Upper Colony, Office, Likabali, Likabali, L/Siang Lower Siang District. District,
130 APIC- Shri Mikre Taso & MrBajumTaba, SCIC, Joram 20-10-20 Disposed 09-02-21 130/2020 Shri Karba Riba, Divisional Forest Begi Appeal Upper Colony, Office, Likabali, Likabali, L/Siang Lower Siang District. District,
131 APIC- Shri Mikre Taso & Mr Bajum Taba, SCIC, Joram 20-10-20 Disposed 09-02-21 131/2020 Shri Karba Riba, Divisional Forest Begi Appeal Upper Colony, Office, Likabali, Likabali, L/Siang Lower Siang District. District,
32 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
132 APIC- Shri Gani Sarang, Accounts Officer Gotoete, SIC 29-10-20 Disposed 25-02-21 132/2020 samabagang, Director, Geology Appeal lalulochung, SRPL & Mining Office, colony, plot no-2, near DC, Office chandranagar, Chandra Nagar Itanagar.
133 APIC- Shri Tali Dignium, Shri Hage Khonya, Gotoete, SIC 29-10-20 Disposed 25-02-21 133/2020 C/o- Advo. Office of the CE, Appeal LibiMarde, OBT, PWD,Central NitiVihar, Ward No- Zone-A, govt of 08,IMC-0/99, A.P, Itanagar Itanagar.
134 APIC- Shri Karto Tao, vill- Er. Tadam SCIC, Joram 29-10-20 Disposed 09-02-21 134/2020 PO/PS-Likabali, Kanchan, Begi Appeal Lower Siang, Distt, EE,WRD, Likabali present add. Liru, Division, Lower Likabali. Siang District. A.P
135 APIC- Shri Tabia EE,PWD, Gotoete, SIC 05-11-20 Yet to be 135/2020 Riang,PWD Colony, Naharlgun Division disposed Appeal Itanagar, District Papum Pare.
136 APIC- Mr Neelam Talum, Mr Bate Koyu, Gotoete, SIC 05-11-20 Yet to be 136/2020 Emchi Po, Doimukh, Under Secretary, disposed Appeal Dist. Papumpare O/o APPSC, Itanagar
137 APIC- Yajum Nomukh, Kiba Sara, EE, SCIC, Joram Disposed 12-01-21 137/2020 Add, Nomuk Village- PHE & WS Begi Appeal Kamba, West Siang Division Aalo, West Siang
138 APIC- Shri Kengo Ori, C/o Registrar Society SCIC, 05-11-20 Disposed 19-01-21 138/2020 M.Ori, O/o Principal Civil Secretariat, JoramBegi Appeal Secretary Finance Itanagar, Govt of Civil Secretariat, A.P Itanagar
139 APIC- Shri Shoney Pertin, Er. Tani Taki E.E SCIC, Joram 12-11-20 Disposed 16.02.2021 139/2020 MLA, contestant 39- PWD Division Begi Appeal Mebo A/C cum Pasighat Govt. of President Siang A.P Right Pasighat Airfield Word No-6 Po/PsPasighat East Siang Distt.
140 APIC- Shri Shoney Pertin, Er. KipaRinia, EE, Gotoete, SIC 12-11-20 Disposed 18.03.2021 140/2020 MLA, contestant 39- RWD, Division, Appeal Mebo A/C cum Pasighat President Siang Right Pasighat Airfield Word No-6 Po/PsPasighat East Siang Distt.
33 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
141 APIC- Shri Shoney Pertin, Er. Tani Taki E.E SCIC, Joram 12-11-20 Disposed 16-02-21 141/2020 MLA, contestant 39- PWD Division Begi Appeal Mebo A/C cum Pasighat Govt. of President Siang A.P Right Pasighat Airfield Word No-6 Po/PsPasighat East Siang Distt.
142 APIC- Shri Shoney Pertin, Er. GonongPertin, SCIC, Joram 12-11-20 Disposed 02-02-21 142/2020 MLA, contestant 39- EE, WRD, Division Begi Appeal Mebo A/C cum pasighat, Govt Of President Siang A.P Right Pasighat Airfield Word No-6 Po/PsPasighat East Siang Distt.
143 APIC- Shri Shoney Pertin, Er. Tani Taki E.E SCIC, Joram 12-11-20 abeyance 02-02-21 143/2020 MLA, contestant 39- PWD Division Begi Appeal Mebo A/C cum Pasighat Govt. of President Siang A.P Right Pasighat Airfield Word No-6 Po/PsPasighat East Siang Distt.
144 APIC- Shri Shoney Pertin, Er. Hibu Tana, SE, SCIC, Joram 12-11-20 Disposed 16-02-21 144/2020 MLA, contestant 39- RWD, Circle, Begi Appeal Mebo A/C cum Pasighat President Siang Right Pasighat Airfield Word No-6 Po/PsPasighat East Siang Distt.
145 APIC- Shri Shoney Pertin, Er. R.N Singh , E.E SCIC, Joram 12-11-20 Disposed 02-02-21 145/2020 MLA, contestant 39- PWD Division Begi Appeal Mebo A/C cum Yingkiong, upper President Siang Siang District, Right Pasighat Govt of A.P Airfield Word No-6 Po/PsPasighat East Siang Distt.
146 APIC- Shri TakarGoi, Shri GonongPertin, SCIC, Joram 16-11-20 Disposed 16-02-21 146/2020 Vill-Yangreng, PIO-cum- Begi Appeal PO/Yangreng, East EE(WRD), Siang, Pasighat Pasighat Division, East Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
147 APIC- Shri Ajoy Tajo, BDO, Block Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 29-04-21 147/2020 S/o Shri Tajom Tajo, Development Appeal Vill- Domdila Tajo, Officer, Chayang PO/PS Chayang Tajo, PO/PS Tajo, Dist East Seppa, Distt- East Kameng Kameng
34 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
148 APIC- Shri Takar Goi, PIO- Likha Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 20.05.2021 148/2020 Vill-Yangreng, Sampu, Under Appeal PO-Yangreng, East Secretary Siang, Pasighat (Political) Govt of A.P
149 APIC- Shri Takar Goi, PIO- Likha Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 20.05.2021 149/2020 Vill-Yangreng, Sampu, Under Appeal PO-Yangreng, East Secretary Siang, Pasighat (Political) Govt of A.P
150 APIC- Shri Takar Goi, PIO- Likha Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 20.05.2021 150/2020 Vill-Yangreng, Sampu, Under Appeal PO-Yangreng, East Secretary Siang, Pasighat (Political) Govt of A.P
151 APIC- Shri Takar Goi, PIO- Likha Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 20.05.2021 151/2020 Vill-Yangreng, Sampu, Under Appeal PO-Yangreng, East Secretary Siang, Pasighat (Political) Govt of A.P
152 APIC- 152/2020 Shri Takar Goi, PIO- Likha Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 20.05.2021 Appeal Vill-Yangreng, Sampu, Under PO-Yangreng, East Secretary Siang, Pasighat (Political) Govt of A.P
153 APIC- Shri Takar Goi, PIO- Likha Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 20.05.2021 153/2020 Vill-Yangreng, Sampu, Under Appeal PO-Yangreng, East Secretary Siang, Pasighat (Political) Govt of A.P
154 APIC- Shri Takar Goi, PIO- Likha Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 20.05.2021 154/2020 Vill-Yangreng, Sampu, Under Appeal PO-Yangreng, East Secretary Siang, Pasighat (Political) Govt of A.P
155 APIC- Shri Takar Goi, PIO- Likha Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 20.05.2021 155/2020 Vill-Yangreng, Sampu, Under Appeal PO-Yangreng, East Secretary Siang, Pasighat (Political) Govt of A.P
156 APIC- Shri Takar Goi, PIO- Likha Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 20.05.2021 156/2020 Vill-Yangreng, Sampu, Under Appeal PO-Yangreng, East Secretary Siang, Pasighat (Political) Govt of A.P
35 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
157 APIC- Shri Shoney Pertin, Er. Gonong Pertin, Gotoete, SIC 16-11-20 Disposed 02-02-21 157/2020 MLA, contestant 39- EE, WRD, Division Appeal Mebo A/C cum pasighat, Govt Of President Siang A.P Right Pasighat Airfield Word No-6 Po/PsPasighat East Siang Distt.
158 APIC- Shri Raju Kejamdo, EE, RWD, Gotoete, SIC 17-11-20 Disposed 20-04-21 158/2020 Polo colony, Daporijo, Upper Appeal Daporijo, PO/PS Subansiri, Distt. Daporijo
159 APIC- Targa Byaling, EE. RWD, Gotoete, SIC 17-11-20 Disposed 04-05-21 159/2020 Sigremsijo, PO/PS, Daporijo, Upper Appeal Daporijo, Distt, U/ Subansiri, Distt Subansiri
160 APIC- Teli Naga, Shri Nangram Gotoete, SIC 17-11-20 Yet to be 160/2020 C/o Principal, Pinkap, DY, State disposed Appeal Arunachal Law Project Director, Academy, Lekhi, (ISSe), Itanagar, PO/PS Nirjuli, Distt. PO/PS Itanagar, Papumpare Dist. Papumpare
161 APIC- Sri Papu Dadda, Shri B.Darang, Gotoete, SIC 20-11-20 Yet to be 161/2020 AneDonyi Colony, DCF, PIO, DFO, disposed Appeal Seppa Distt. East Shergaon forest Kameng Officer, Shergaon Forest Division, Rupa, West Kameng
162 APIC- Shri Sanjay Yangfo PIO, O/o Director Gotoete, SIC 20-11-20 Yet to be 162/2020 (Asst. General Directorate of disposed Appeal Secretary) All East geology & Mining. Kameng District, Govt Of A.P Students Union,(AEKDSO)
163 APIC- Shri Bharat Cheda, Shri Joram Lona, Gotoete, SIC 02-12-20 Yet to be 163/2020 Chimpu, Itanagar, PIO-cum- disposed Appeal Distt. Papumpare Directorate Department of Geology & Mining, Govt of A.P
164 APIC- Shri Nimya Angu, BagunTaba, DFO, SCIC, Joram 07-12-20 Disposed 02-02-21 164/2020 C/o Talen Nyita, Hill (Forest), Likabali, Begi complaint Top JNC, Campus, Lower Siang Pasighat Districts. (A.P)
165 APIC- Vijay Pertin, Dr. R. Tatar, SCIC, Joram 07-12-20 Disposed 16.03.2021 165/2020 Vill-Ithill, PO/PS DMO, Lower Begi Appeal Roing, District. Dibang Valley, Lower Dibang Districts, Roing Valley, Roing 792110
36 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
166 APIC- Vijay Pertin, Smti Rupa Mimi, SCIC, Joram 07-12-20 Disposed 20-04-21 166/2020 Vill-Ithill, PO/PS Assistant Engineer Begi Appeal Roing, District. (Hydro Power) Lower Dibang Lower Dibang Valley, Roing Valley Roing
167 APIC- Vijay Pertin, Shri Bengia Pada, Gotoete, SIC 07-12-20 Yet to be 167/2020 Vill-Ithill, PO/PS O/o EE.(WRD) disposed Appeal Roing, District. Lower Dibang Lower Dibang Valley Roing Valley, Roing
168 APIC- Shri Sangha Tarey, EE. PHE, Yupia, Gotoete, SIC 07-12-20 Disposed 29-04-21 168/2020 Yeri Kaku, (A.P) papumpare Appeal DughPoshi, Upper Distt. A.P Hollongi, Distt. Papumpare
169 APIC- Tech iTargam Party, Sri Rimmar Gotoete, SIC 07-12-20 Disposed 17-06-2021 169/2020 Nyobia Colony, Taso, SE (CSQ) Appeal Itanagar, Papumpare C/o Chief District. Engineer,(CSQ), PWD, Itanagar, A.P.
170 APIC- Shri Dara Takuk, PIO, Pasighat, SCIC, Joram 08-12-20 case 09-02-21 170/2020 Vill-Ngopok- Mebo, Smart city Begi dismissed Appeal PO- Mebo& PS Development Pasighat Distt, East Corporattion Siang Limited, High Region, Pasighat Distt. East Siang, A.P.
171 APIC- Shri Dara Takuk, PIO-Cum DFO, SCIC, Joram 08-12-20 case 09-02-21 171/2020 Vill-Ngopok- Mebo, Pasighat Distt. East Begi dismissed Appeal PO- Mebo& PS Siang, A.P Pasighat Distt, East Siang
172 APIC- Shri Lamnio Bagang, Er. Joram Gotoete, SIC 08-12-20 Yet to be 172/2020 Chandra Nagar, PO, Lali,(EE) Office of disposed Appeal RK Mission, Itanagar the EE capital; Electrical Division, Itanagar
173 APIC- Mr. Gekap Nguba, Joint Secretary, Gotoete, SIC 16-12-20 Yet to be 173/2020 C-sector, Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh disposed Appeal A.P staff selection Board Itanagar, C- sector
174 APIC- Shri Margqm Ori, Shri Talom Dupak, SCIC, Joram 16-12-20 Disposed 23-03-21 174/2020 C/o Eastern ADC, DC office, Begi Appeal Horizone& offset capital Complex printing press T.T Itanagar, Distt. Marg Bank Tinal, Papumpare Itanagar
37 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
175 APIC- Mr. Gekap Nguba, Joint Secretary, Gotoete, SIC 16-12-20 Yet to be 175/2020 C-sector, Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh disposed Appeal A.P staff selection Board Itanagar, C-sector
176 APIC- Shri Dana Takuk, PIO-cum- district SCIC, Joram 16-12-20 case 16-03-21 176/2020 c/o Lt Shri Land Revenue & Begi dismissed Appeal TakarTakuk, village settlement officer Ngopok, Mebo, PO district east Mebo 7 Ps Pasighat siangpasighat District East Kameng
177 APIC- Shri Tania June Shri Kago Habung, Gotoete, SIC 16-12-20 Disposed 10-06-21 177/2020 Vill-Linia, upper executive Appeal Yachuli Lower Engineering (PHE) Subansiri Distt. Ziro Ziro division A.P L/Subansiri District, Ziro
Total Cases, Disposed, Penalty, Compensation, ArrestWarrant, disciplinary action and pending Cases in High Coutr for the year 2020-21.
SL. No. Year 2019 Total
1. Total cases 177
2. Total Case Disposed 157
3. Total Penalty Imposed Rs: 1,40,000/-
4. Total Amount Compensation Rs:26,000/-
5. Total No. of Arrest Warrant issued Nill
6. Total No. of disciplinary action taken Nil
7. Total No. of cases pending in High Court 15
38 CHAPTER – 7
STATUS OF WRIT PETITION FILED AGAINST THE DECISION OF THE COMMISSION BEFORE GAUHATI HIGH COUT
Sl. WRIT PETITION No. Remarks. Case No. No.
1 2 3 4
WP(C) No. 260 (A.P)/2016. (Shri APIC No-01/2016 1. Pending Ramakant Deuri -Vs- APIC &ors) Appeal
WP (C) No. 84 (AP)/2016. (The State of APIC No-519/2012 2. Pending AP &Anr -Vs- The APIC &Anr). Appeal
WP(C) No.248(AP)/2016. (Ramakrishna APIC No-33/2016 3. Pending Mission Hospital -Vs-APIC&Ors) Appeal
WP(C) No.327(AP)/2015. (Shri Pending APIC No-05/2015 4. GyamarTachung -Vs- APIC ) Appeal
WP(C) No.598(AP)/2016 (Arunachal Pradesh State Co-operative APIC No-152/2015 5. Apex Bank Ltd. Pending Appeal -Vs- APIC &Anr.)
WP(C) No.279(AP)/2018. ( Er. Kirba APIC No-108/2018 6. Pending Sora -Vs - The APIC &Ors.) Appeal
WP(c) No. 573/2015. (Shri 7. EkenRiba&Ors - Vs- The state of A.P Pending SIC-13/2014-2015 &Ors.)
WP(c) No. 637/2017. APIC No-121/2106 8. Pending ( Er. HageBida - Vs- The APIC &Anr.) Appeal
WP(c) No. 77/2020. (Shri APIC No-152/2019 9. MibangBorang - Vs- The state of Pending Appeal A.P & Ors.) WP(c) No. 217/2018. (Public APIC No-35/2018 10. Information Officer, RWC - Vs- Pending Appeal The APIC &Ors.)
WP(c) No. 168/2017. (Shri Tai Shiva - APIC No-16/2014 11. Pending Vs- The APIC & 2 Ors.) Appeal
WP(c) No. 129/2018. (Shri DagbomRiba APIC No-32/2018 12. Pending - Vs- The state of A.P &Ors.) Appeal
39 1 2 3 4
Contempt case No. 14/2017. (Shri 13. NyodekYonngam - Vs- Pending APIC-62/court case/2016/68 Smty. Shakuntala Gamlin&Ors.)
WP(c) No. 46/2017.( Shri NyageGeyi - APIC No-247/2016 14. Pending Vs- The APIC &Ors.) Appeal
WP(c) No. 295/2019.( Shri APIC No-143/2020 15. RojumTayeng - Vs-The state of A.P Pending Appeal &Ors.)
WA (C) 14 AP/2020.(BatemPertin Vs- APIC No-108/2019 16. – disposed State of AP &ors) Complaint
Wp (c) No. 315 (BatemPertin Vs- The APIC No-108/2019 17. – disposed state of AP &ors.) Complaint
40 CHAPTER – 8
PERIODICAL REPORT REGARDING EFFECTIVE IMPLEMENTATION OF RTI ACT, 2005
RTI APPLICATION RECEIVED & DISPOSED OF BY PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICERS OF VARIOUS PUBLIC AUTHORITIES IN THE YEAR- 2020-21
Total No. Total No. Of 4(1) of 4(2) cited outside cited outside jurisdiction jurisdiction Name of Total under under RTI Total Total Sl. Department Ref.Letter Furnished/ RTI Amendment Application Fee No. No/Dated Disposed Amendment Rule Received Paid. Off Rule (3rd (3rd Amendment Amendment Rules, Rules, 2007) 2007)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 No.HD/AC- O/o the Executive 19/RTI/2020- Engineer, 21/65-67 1. Hayuliang Division, 12 12 Nil Nil Rs:1016 PWD, Arunachal Dated:30/04/2020 Pradesh-792104
O/o Chief Engineer No.PHED(WZ)- PHE& W/SD V/04-16/Vol- 2. (Western Zone), V/86-87 05 03 01 Nil Rs:50 Senkhi Park, Itanagar Dated:08/06/2020 O/o the No.PHECI/A- Superintending 154/12-13/VOL- 3. Engineer PHE & I/162-63 Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil WS Itanagar: Circle: Naharlugan Dated: 3/07/2020 No.JD/RTI/2020- O/o the Executive 21/181 4. Engineer,Jang 01 01 Nil Nil Rs:524 PWD:Jang-790105 Dated: 04/07/2020 O/O the Deputy No.BJ/RTI-2/16- Commissioner, 17/1245 5. West Kameng 03 Nil Nil Rs. 10/- District. Dated 3rd-April- Bomdila. 2020
No.PHED(WZ)- O/o the Chief V/04-16/Vol- Engineer PHE & V/694-95 02 6. W/SD(western 03 (partially 01 Nil Rs.124/- zone): Senkhi Park, furnished) Itanagar. Dated: 7th-Aug- 2020
41 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 No.BJ/RTI-2/16- O/O the Deputy 17/1246 Commissioner, 7. 03 Nil Nil Rs.10 West Kameng Dated: 1st- July- District. Bomdila. 2020 No.EAC/RTI/201 O/o the Chief 5/61/66-67 Conservator of 8. Forests, Eastern 06 06 Nil Nil Rs:368 Arunachal Dated:5th Aug- Circle:Tezu 2020
NO.PHECI/A- O/o the 154/12-13/VOL- Superintending I/170-71. 9. Engineer PHE & 02 02 Nil Nil Rs:156/- WS, Itanagar. Dated: 6-Oct- Circle: Naharlugan 2020
No.JD/RTI/2020- O/o the Executive 21/7 10. Enginner, Jang 05 01 Nil Nil NA PWD:Jang-790105 Dated:16th Oct 2020
No.PHED(WZ)- O/o the Chief V/04-16/Vol- Enginner PHE & 01 V/1171-72 11. W/SD (Westren 12 (partially 01 Nil Rs:296 Zone): Senki Park: furnished) Dated: 14 Oct Itanagar 2020
O/o the No.PHECI/A- Superintending 154/12-13/VOL- 12. Engineer PHE & I/175-76 Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil WS, Itanagar: Circle: Naharlugan Dtd: 6-Jan-2021
No.PHED(WZ)- O/o the Chief V/04-16/Vol- Engineer PHE & V/1599-1600 13. W/SD (Western 13 Nil Nil Nil Rs:200/- Zone): Senki Park, Dtd: 14th Oct- Itanagar. 2020
O/o the District No.WS/AGRI/RT Agriculture Officer, I/2019-2020/854 Rs:1550 14. 07 07 Nil Nil West Siang Dist. /- Aalo. Dtd:7-Jan-2021
O/o the Deputy No.BJ/RTI-2/16- Comissioner West 17/10735 Rs:1288 15. 03 03 Nil Nil Kameng Dist. /- Bomdila. Dtd:21-01-2021
42 CHAPTER-9
RECOMMENDATION OF THE COMMISSION TO THE STATE GOVERNMENT
As per Section 25 (3)(g) the Commission would like to reiterate the following recommendation to the Government of the Arunachal Pradesh for effective implementation of the RTI Act in the state.
REGULAR REPORT RETURN FROM PUBLIC AUTHORITIES
Although Sub Sections (2) and (3) of Section 25 of the RTI Act mandate that each Ministry and Department in relation to the Public Authorities within their jurisdication, shall collect and provide such information to the State Information Commission, as is required to prepare the Annual Report. It has been found that only 78 State Public Information Officers (PIOs)/APIOs out 310, have submitted the report return for the purpose. The State government, through the nodal department should direct all the PIOs to submit the quareterlyreportof the Public Authority as specified under the provisions of section to the State Information Commission regularly.
INADEQUATE PERFORMANCE OF THE FIRST APPELATE AUTORITY
As per Section 19(1)Any person who does not receive decision within the time specified or aggrievedby the decision of the State Public Information Officer (SPIO), may within 30 days from the expiry of such period or from the receipt of such a decision, prefer an appeal to such officer who is senior in rank to the State Information officer in each public authority.
It has been observed that this provision of First Appelate Autority is being done by a very few public authorities and most of the First Appellate Authorities do not function in the state so much so that, the department of Administrative Reform (AR) the nodal department, has not yet brought out the Rules on the First Appellate Authority.
For effective implementation of the Act, the provision of the First Appellate Authority (FAA) is to be complied with strictly. For this, the appropriate initiative is required from the nodal department of the government.
43 PROACTIVE DISCLOSURE
As per Section 4 of the RTI Act, it is the obligation of every Public Authority to disclose certain information onSuo Motu basis as laid down under sub-section (1) of the Section.
As per Sub Section (2) of the Section, it shall be a constant endeavor of every Public Authority to take steps in accordance with the requirments of the clause (b) of the Section 1 to provide as much information Suo-Motu to the public at regular intervals through various means of communication including internet, so that public have minimum resourt to the use of the Act to obtain information.
It has been observed that most of the Public Authorities are not strictly complying with the provisions of the Section by proactive disclosure of the activities undertaken by the Public Authority. It is also, abserved that many of the Public Authortiyare not even having website containing upto date information. If more and more Suo-Motu disclosure is made by the Public Authorities, undoubtedly there would be less and less people to resort to this Act for seeking information. Therefore, the Commission recommends that the Chief Secretary of the State should direct all the Public Authorities of the state to comply with the provisions of the Act strictly.
44 CHAPTER-10
PHOTO GALLERY
Dr. Joram Begi, MA, Ph. D STATE CHIEF INFORMATION COMMISSIONER
Shri Goto Ete, B.A, LL.B. STATE INFORMATION COMMISSIONER
45 Genom Tekseng State Information Commissioner
Smti Sonam Yudron State Information Commissioner
Gunjum Haider State Information Commissioner
46 Shri Habung Donyi, APCS, Registrar-cum-Secretary. From 01/03/2021 to till date
Smti Maman Padung, APCS, Deputy Registrar. From 9/3/2017 to till date
Shri Jacob Lego, Finance & Accounts Officer. From 11/12/2020 to till date
47 Three-day training programme on Sensitization of RTI Act-2005 with Chief Information Commissioner Dr. Joram Begi.
48 A view of audiance of the Awareness Programme-2020 of RTI Act 2005.
Awareness programme of RTI Act 2005 conducted on 29/01/2020 at Aalo by Dr. Joram Begi State Chief Information Commissioner, Shri Goto Ete State Information Commissioner and Shri Leki Phuntso State Information Commissioner.
49 Conducted Online hearing during the Nation-wide Lockdown through Video Conferencing on 21 April 2020 by Dr. Joram Begi (SCIC), APIC.
Online Video Conferencing Hearing session conducted in the Hon'ble Court of Shri Goto Ete (SIC) on 22th May 2020.
50 Newly appointed SIC Shri Genom Tekseng taking oath at Raj Bhawan
Newly appointed SIC Shri Gunjum Haider taking oath at Raj Bhawan
Newly appointed SIC Smti Sonam Yudron taking oath at Raj Bhawan
51 ANNEXURE
SOME OF THE SIGNIFICANT ORDERS/DECISIONS OF THE COMMISSION
ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION ITANAGAR ------
BEFORE THE DOUBLE BENCH COURT OF DR. JORAM BEGI, STATE CHIEF INFORMATION COMMISSIONER & SHRI LEKI PHUNTSO, STATE INFORMATION COMMISSIONER.
No.APIC-08/2020 Dated,Itanagar the 23rd January, 2020
ORDER
Shri NimaTondrang, Secretary i/c of Arunachal Pradesh Public Service Commission, Itanagar had made an appeal vide his letter No. PSC/RTI/177/2019 dated 3rd December’2019 for review of Order and judgment on case No. APIC-155/2019/254 dated 17.12.2019 passed by Shri GotoEte, State Information Commissioner on the case of Shri Bengia Jayanta –vs- Shri Bate Koyu, PIO-cum-Deputy Secretary, Arunachal Pradesh Public Service Commission, Itanagar to the State Chief Information Commissioner, stated to be under provision of Sub Section (2 ) and (3) of Section (23) of the RTI Act 2005.
The appeal was examined by the Commission, and the Commission found no provision under the Act to re-hear the parties and set aside and quashed the oder No. APIC-155/2019/254 dated 17.12.2019 passed by Shri Goto Ete, State Information Commissioner.
Howeverr, keeping the natural justice in view the Commission has decided to give a hearing to the parties by a double bench consisting of Dr. Joram Begi, State Chief Information Commissioner and Shri Leki Phuntso , State Information Commissioner and summoned order was issued to both the parties for hearing on 23rd January 2020 at 1030 hrs.
52 The hearing was held on 23rd January’2020 at 1100 hrs, Shri Bate Koyu, PIO- cum-Deputy Secretary, APPSC, Itanagar, Shri Tumi Gangak, APIO-cum-Under Secretary, APPSC, Itanagar, Adv. Nani Anju ,the legal counselor of APPSC, Itanagar and the Appellant of the Case APIC-155/2019 (Appeal) Shri Bengia Jayanta were present during the hearing. The hearing took place at 1100 hrs due to the Appellant Shri Bengia Jayanta reached the Court late due to heavy traffic.
The State Chief Information Commissioner at the very outset made it clear that there is no provision of re-hearing the parties and set aside and quashed the oder issued by another Information Commissioner under the RTI Act-2005. However, for the sake of natural justice this hearing is being done. He has also stipulated out that the hearing would be done in 2(two) parts, first the procedural aspects and the second on the subject matter. In the procedural part, the Chief Information Commissioner asked the PIO that under what provision/ section of the RTI Act 2005 the present appeal is being made to the State Chief Information Commissioner by the PIO/ the public authority. The PIO, requested the Commission to allow Legal Counselor of the APPSC to represent him. The Legal Counselor said that the APPSC had made this appeal for re-hearing of the case No. APIC-155/2019/254 dated 17.12.2019 passed by Shri GotoEte, State Information Commissioner under Sub Section (2) and (3) of Section (23) of the RTI Act 2005. The Chief Information Commissioner said that the matter has no Sub Sections nor the said content exist under Section (23) of the RTI Act 2005 and he read out the actual content of the relevant section. It was found that the legal counselor was pleading on the basis of Sub Section (2) and (3) of Section(23) of the Central Information Commission (Management) Regulation 2007. The Chief Information Commission has told her that the said Sub Sections (2) and (3) of Section (23) have already been amended and deleted by the Central information Commission on 28th October’2008 and accordingly the Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission has also amended and deleted the Sub Sections vide U.O. No. SCIC/02/2008 dated 28th December’2008. Therefore, the appeal has no locus standi. The legal counselor also accepted the fact.
In the second part, first asked the appellant Shri Bengia Jayanta 2(two) questions. -(1) Wheather, he was a candidate of the Assistant Engineer Selection Examination (2012-13) conducted by APPSC or not and if so whether, he was candidate of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) or Assistant Engineer (Civil) ? (2) Why he is seeking information after the lapsE of 7(seven) years and why not immediately after the declaration of the result? Shri Bengia Jayanta the appellant of the case no. APIC-155/209 (Appeal) said that he was the candidate of the Assistant Engineer Examination (2012-13) for the post of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) not of the Civil Engineering. His answer to the second question was that he is working as Junior Engineer and posted in interior place and so could not find time earlier to seek the information. The Commission said that since he was not a candidate of Assistant Engineer (Civil) he cannot insist information of Sl.no. 3 i.e. the Detail Mark list of top 50(fifty) Civil Engineering Candidates along with Details of Marks scored in each papers during 2012 Assistant Engineer (Civil) recruitment, as sought in his Form-A.
Then the Commission asked the PIO why the information sought under S.L. No. 1, 2, and 4 were not provided to the information seeker as directed by the earlier order of the Commission. The PIO replied that they have a rule which restricts providing of such information beyond 180 days i.e. 6(six) months. The Commission asked the PIO under what section of the RTI Act 2005 the rules have been framed. The PIO has admitted that these rules have not been framed under any section of the RTI Act.
53 The Commission also said that the rules can be framed either under section 27 of the RTI Act by the appropriate government or under section 28 by the competent authority. The PIO of the Arunachal Pradesh Public Service Commission admitted that said rules have not been framed under any section of the RTI Act. The Commission referred to Section (22) of the RTI Act that any other act or rules framed is being superseded by the section of the Act in regards to disclosure of information. The Commission further said that the working rules, manuals, guidelines can be framed but within the framework of the Act and Suo Motu disclosure should be done as per Sub clause (v) of clause (b) of Sub Section (I) of Section (4) of the RTI Act 2005 and hence information sought under Sl.no.5 of Form-A by the information seeker should be provided even after lapse of 7(seven) year as per Sub-Section (3) of the Section (8) of the Act .
The Legal counselor of the Arunachal Pradesh Public Service Commission was trying to convince the State Information Commission to reconsider the case on the basis of Supreme Court judgment, Union Public Service Commission and other –vs- Angesh Kumar and other that the for the greater public interest their plea should be accepted. The Commission said that the case referred is of exemption under Section (8) and (9) of the RTI Act 2005 and the present case does not attract any of these two section of the Act and hence it does not apply.
In view of the above hearing the Commission came to the conclusion that there is no reason as to why the case No. APIC-155/2019/254 dated 17.12.2019 passed by Shri GotoEte, State Information Commissioner be set aside and quashed.
Therefore, the case is hereby disposed of.
Sd/- Sd/- (Leki Phuntso) (Dr. Joram Begi) State Information Commissioner State Chief Information Commissioner Arunachal Pradesh Information Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission Commission Itanagar Itanagar
54 ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION ITANAGAR
------
BEFORE THE COURT OF DR.JORAM BEGI, STATE CHIEF INFORMATION COMMISSIONER
No.APIC-23/2020 Dated,Itanagar the 18th February, 2020
Under Section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005
Appellant Respondent
Shri Mohammed Sajid Hussain, Shri Kido Bagra, PIO-cum- PRO, S/o Mohammed Mujeed Hussain, Himalayan University, 9-8-168/16/A Golconda Fort Bada Jullang Village, Near Central Jail, Bazar, Hyderabad-500008. Vs Itanagar-791111.
Date of hearing: 18th February’2020.
O R D E R
Whereas, an appeal under Section 19(3) of RTI Act, 2005 has been received from Shri Mohammed Sajid Hussain, S/o Mohammed MujeedHussain, 9-8-168/16/A Golconda Fort Bada Bazar, Hyderabad-500008, for non-furnishing of information, by Public Information Officer, Himalayan University, Jullang Village, Near Central Jail, Itanagar, as sought, by the Appellant under section 6(1) of RTI Act, 2005 on 20/05/2019.
Whereas, the 1st hearing was held on 4th February’ 2020.Shri Kido Bagra, PIO-cum- PRO Himalayan University, Jullang, Itanagar was present during the hearing. The Appellant ShriSajidHussain was found absent. The Registrar, Himalayan University, Itanagar, vide HU/JUL./PIO/Rply/19-20/185 Dated 03.02.2020 informed the Commission that Reg. NO. 525162880082157 & Admission No. 293459 as given by the Appellant does not exist in their records and hence are not correct. The PIO informed the Commission that the Appellant was
55 asked to submit his original documents for verification but the Appellant did not submit his original documents. The PIO also informed the Commission that the Himilayan University, Jullang (Itanagar) does not offer the course of Bachelor of Science (Medical Laboratory Technology) and the Himilayan University, Itanagar began in the year 2014 and its first convocation was held on December, 2017. Whereas, the Certificate submitted by the Appellant is issued in the year 2016. Therefore, the certificate submitted by the Appellant seems to be fake, the same has been conveyed to the Appellant vide letter No. HU/JUL./PIO/Rply/19-20/185 Dated 03.02.2020.
Whereas, the Commission directed the PIO to file FIR at Itanagar Police Station and the nearest Police Station of Golconda Fort Bada Bazar, Hyderabad if they disown the Certificate and bring a copy of the same in the next date of hearing.
Whereas, the 2nd hearing was held on 18thFebruary’ 2020.Shri Kido Bagra, PIO- cum-PRO Himalayan University, Jullang, Itanagar was present during the hearing. The Appellant Shri Sajid Hussain was found absent. The PIO informed the Commission that the Registrar of the Himalayan University, Itanagar has lodged a complaint against the Appellant of cheating & forgery at Police Station, Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh. The PIO submitted a copy of complaint received, signed and sealed by the Police Incharge, Police Station Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh.
Whereas, the Commission viewed that the Appellant remain absent for two consecutive hearing without intimation and the PIO has disowned the certificate submitted by the Appellant and a Complaint of cheating & forgery has been lodged in the Police Station Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh.
Therefore, the case is hereby disposed of.
Sd/- (Dr.Joram Begi) State Chief Information Commissioner Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission Itanagar
56 ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION, (APIC) ITANAGAR, ARUNCHAL PRADESH
Appeal U/S 19(3) of RTI Act, 2005 vide No. APIC-98/2020
BEFORE THE HON’BLE COURT OF SHRI GOTO ETE, THE STATE INFORMATION COMMISSIONER
Shri Bengia Sagung PO/PS Doimukh, Papumpare District Arunachal Pradesh ………………………...... Appellant
-VERSUS –
Shri Nakab Hina Nabam PIO-cum-DLRSO Papumpare District, Yupia, Arunachal Pradesh ...... Respondent
Date of Judgment/order: 20.08.2020
JUDGMENT/ORDER
Brief fact of the case is that that the above named appellant filed an RTI application under Form-A on 07.03.2020 before the PIO of the Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Papumpare District, Yupia, whereby, seeking various information regarding Pare & Ranga NadiHydrpoElectrict Project, NEFCO Ltd Doimukh, Arunachal Pradesh. And the same, received in the Office of the PIO-cum-CO of the Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Yupia, was transferred to the District Land Revenue & Settlement Officer (DLRSO), Papumpare District, Yupia, vide letter No.PP/RTI/YPA-480 Dated- 16th of March’2020. The applicant, having not received any response from the PIO, filed a First Appeal before the Chief Secretary Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar, on 08.05.2020. The Chief Secretary on receipt of the First Appeal from the appellant as aforesaid issued an order for directing the PIO to prove the required information to the applicant. After such issue of the order by the State Chief Secretary PIO-cum-DLRSO of Papumpare, Yupia, vide his letter No.LR-LM/RTI -07/001(Pt-II) Dated- 26th May’2020 furnished the information sought to the applicant. The applicant, being not satisfied with the information received as incomplete, filed a Second Appeal before the Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission on 13.06.20 and Registry of the Commission, on receipt of the same registered the appeal as APIC-98/2020 and processed it to the Commission for hearing and disposal.
57 Accordingly, this appeal has come up for the first time today for hearing. Appellant Shri BengiaSagung is, though not present, represented by his learned counsel Mr. Tai Shiva (Advocate) before the Commission in person. Mr. NakapHina Nabam, PIO-cum-DLRSO of the DC’s Office, Yupia, is present through video conferencing. Both parties being heard. The PIO submitted that the all information sought have already been furnished to the appellant vide his letter dated-26.05.2020. The learned counsel for the appellant admitted to have received the information but the information furnished against Sl.No.(f) of the Form-A application is incomplete as the names of the affected persons receiving the compensations have not been disclosed. It has been revealed during the hearing that the Deputy Commissioner happened to be the First Appellate Authority of PIO-cum-DLRSO, Yupia, but the appellant, instead of filing his First Appeal before the Deputy Commissioner, Yupia, directly filed his First Appeal before the Chief Secretary of the State of Arunachal Pradesh. After hearing the parties I have also carefully read all available materials on record.
Having considered the respective submissions of the either party it appears to me that the PIO-cum-DLRSO, Yupia, is the PIO of the Land Record Department of the DC’s Office, Yupia. The appellant, who had not been responded by the PIO had a right of First Appeal for a period of 30 days from the first day of expiry of 30 days of his filing the application under Form-A before the PIO. That is to say, he had a right of First Appeal before the First Appellate Authority within a period of 30 from 08.03.2020 to 07.04.2020. And in the present case the PIO-cum-DLRSO, having been working under the administrative unit of the District Administration of Papumpare District, cannot reasonably be disbelieved to have been headed by the Deputy Commissioner, Papumpare District, Yupia, as the First Appellate Authority of the PIO. But the learned counsel of the appellant has no denial of the fact that the appellant had mistakenly filed his First Appeal before the Chief Secretary instead of filing the same before the Deputy Commissioner, Papumpare District, Yupia. Apart from filing the First Appeal before the wrong forum the appellant is found to have filed the First Appeal on 08.05.2020 after a lapse of a month of the expiry of the appeal period for filing of the First Appeal under the RTI Act. Now the fact remains that no First Appeal under sub-section (1) of Section-19 of the RTI Act has yet been filed by the appellant and without which the appellant has no legality to file this Second Appeal under sub-section (3) of Section-19 of the Act.
In view of facts and circumstances aforesaid I find this appeal fit to be dismissed. And, accordingly, this appeal is dismissed and stands disposed for once for all. Judgment/ order pronounced in the presence and hearing of the either parties on this 20th day of August’2020. Each copy of this judgment/order be furnished to the parties.
Given under my hand and seal of this Court/ Commission on this 20th day of August’2020.
Sd/- (GOTO ETE) State Information Commissioner Arunachal Pradesh Information, Itanagar
58 ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION, (APIC) ITANAGAR, ARUNACHAL PRADESH
Appeal U/S 19(3) of RTI Act, 2005 vide No.APIC-81/2020
BEFORE THE HON’BLE COURT OF SHRI GOTO ETE, THE STATE INFORMATION COMMISSIONER:
Smti Rani Jamoh Tawe A-Sector Naharlagun, Ward No.24 Papumpare Dist. PO/PS Naharlagun Arunachal Pradesh ...... Appellant
-VERSUS - 1. Smty Gari Tai PIO-cum-DSP, PHQ Itanagar, Capital Complex, Itanagat, A. Pradesh.
2. Smty P. Yaku PIO-cum-Officer-Incharge Women Police Station, Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh ...... Respondents
Date of judgment/order: 04.02.2021
ORDER
This appeal vide No.APIC-81/2020 is a second appeal lying pending disposal before the Commission (APIC). Brief fact of the case is that the appellant filed an RTI application under Form-A before the PIO-cum-DySP, PHQ Itanagar, on 28.01.2020, whereby, seeking informations’ as under:
(1) Certified true copy of forwarding letter for forensic report of CCTV Footage in connection with WPS Case No.80/17 U/S 354/353/34 IPC R/W Sec-3 of PDPP Act.
(2) Certified true copy of detail report of CCTV Footage, sent for forensic test/confirmation in connection with above mentioned case.
PIO-cum-DySP, PHQ Itanagar, whereupon, vide her letter vide No.SPC/ITA/CR- 97/20 dated-29th January, 2020 transferred the appellant’s application to the PIO-cum- Officer-In-charge of the Itanagar Women Police Station on the very next day in terms of Section-6(3) of RTI Act, 2005. The appellant, having not received the informations’ so sought from the both PIO’s, filed the First Appeal on 27.02.2020 before the First Appellate Authority-cum-Superintendent of Police, Capital Complex, Itanagar. Appellant, again having not received any response from the FAA, filed the Second Appeal before the Arunachal
59 Pradesh Information Commission on 26.05.2020. And the Commission (APIC) on receipt of this Second Appeal registered the same, being Appeal No APIC-81/2020, and issued processes for its hearing and disposal. And, hence, the case.
Appeal came up for hearing before the Commission on 6(six) consecutive dates, i.e, on 03.09.2020, 01.10.2020, 15.10.2020, 05.11.2020, 10.12.2020 and 04.02.2021. During the first hearing on 03.09.2020 the PIO-cum-DySP, PHQ Itanagar, Smty Gari Tai submitted a written as well as a verbal submission before the Commission that since the information(s) sought were concerned with the Itanagar Women Police Station the application of the appellant seeking the said information was immediately transferred U/S 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005 on the very next day of the receipt whereof to the PIO-cum-Officer In-Charge of the Itanagar Women Police Station with a request to her (PIO of Women PS) to directly furnish the informations’ so sought to the appellant from her end. PIO-cum-DySP, PHQItanagar, further submitted that a copy of the said letter transferring the application vide letter No.SPC/ITA/CR-97/20 dated- 29.01.2020 was also duly served to the appellant in terms of the said provisions of the RTI Act but she does not have any idea about howcome the transferee officer had not acted upon the transferred application. The Commission, after such hearing of the appellant and PIO-cum-DySP PHQ, Itanagar, including – after having careful considerations of the available materials on record, found the PIO-cum-OC WPS, Itanagar, required to be impleaded as a necessary party and, accordingly, directed for issue of a notice for her appearance in person on the next date fixed on 01.10.2020. Accordingly, on the next date fixed on 01.10.2020 the appellant and PIO-cum-DySP PHQ, Itanagar, were both present but Smty P. Taku PIO-cum OC WPS, Itanagar, was not present. However, one Smty N. Rupa the then I/C OC WPS, Itanagar, sent a letter informing the Commission that the Smty P. Taku, who had been detected positive of Covid-19, was under home quarantine. During the third hearing fixed on 15.10.2020 appellant was represented by her husband Shri Kamta Tawe and both PIOs Smty Gari Tai (DSP) and Smty P. Taku (Inspector) were present during which the representative of the appellant disclosed the fact that the PIO-cum-OC of the WPS, Itanagar, who had received his transferred application under Form-A, in lieu of furnishing the information directly to him from her end, had admittedly furnished only the information sought against item no.1 of his application through the PIO-cum-DySP PHQ, Itanagar, at belated stage sometime in the first Week of September, 2020. After hearing the parties and also after having careful considerations of the available materials on record the Commission found the PIO-cum-DySP PHQ, Itanagar, Smty Gari Tai as no more required in the proceeding and, as such, discharged from the case. However, the Commission found a prima- facie case well established against Smty/ Inspectior P. Taku, PIO-cum-OC WPS, Itanagar, liable for imposing reasonable penalty under sub-section (1) of Section-20 of the RTI Act, 2005 and, accordingly, ordered for issue of a show cause notice against her for giving her an opportunity of being heard as provided in the proviso to sub-section (1) of Section-20 of the Act as to why she should not be imposed a reasonable penalty for her refusal or neglect in furnishing the information sought under RTI Act within prescribed period of time. And, accordingly, a show cause notice dated-16.10.2020 was issued against the said Smty P. Taku with a direction to her to appear in person before the Commission on 5th of November’ 2020 for furnishing replies to the show cause notice in question.
60 The OC WPS, Itanagar, Inspector P. Taku vide letter dated 04.11.2020 furnished her written replies to the show cause notice in question and the same was placed before the Commission (APIC) for consideration during the hearing fixed on 05.11.2020. Relevant contents of the written replies to show cause notice of Inspector P. Taku reads as quoted – “ …. that sir, RTI application dated 29/01/2020 filed by Smty Rani Jamoh Tawe W/O Shri Kamta Tawe was forwarded from, PIO Smty Tai Gari, DySP (HQ) and the same was received on 31.01.2020 at Women Police Station, Itanagar which was endorsed. Due to personal reasons, I availed leave from 25 February 2020 and joined back on 4 June 2020.” During hearing of the show cause Inspector P. Taku took the same plea in her verbal submissions as made in her written submission as aforesaid. Apart from the facts as disclosed aforesaid the said OC WPS, Itanagar, further submitted, among others, that during her leave period she endorsed this RTI matter to those officer(s) taking charges of the OC WPS, Itanagar, namely, Inspector N. Rupa and Inspector M. Mibang, who could have also furnished the information sought within the stipulated period of 30 days. On such plea being raised by her (Inspector Taku) notices were issued against 2(two) other officers and were being heard on 10.12.2020. During the hearing both Officers Inspector N. Rupa and Inspector M. Mibang stated before the Commission in the presence and hearing of Inspector P. Taku that the PIO-cum-OC WPS, Itanagar, Smty P. Taku had not ever intimated or informed them anything about the RTI application of the appellant during their respective tenure as Incharge of the OC WPS, Itanagar. After hearing the said two other officers of the WPS, Itanagar, the Commission had a reason for believing of the fact that the said Inspector P. Taku had been negligent in dealing with the RTI application of the appellant and was accordingly about to pass an appropriate order against her. In the meantime, Inspector P. Taku, who was also then participating the hearing through audio video conferencing, requested the Commission for giving her one more chance of hearing in respect of the show cause notice issued against her and, accordingly, she was given a last chance of hearing in respect of the show cause aforesaid on the next date fixed on 04.02.2021.
Today is the date given as a last chance to Inspector P. Taku on her own request for a further hearing, if any, in respect of the show cause notice issued against her as to why she should not be imposed a reasonable penalty for her refusal or neglect in furnishing of the information sought under RTI Act within prescribed period of time as provided in sub-section (1) of Section-7 of the RTI Act, 2005. Appellant is present as usual but surprisingly Inspector P. Taku is not present today, i.e, on this 4th day of February’ 2021. In fact, a letter has been received from the Officer In-Charge of the Women PS, Itanagar, wherein, informing the Commission that Inspector P. Taku is on earn leave for 47 days. Since this is a date fixed on her own request for giving her a last opportunity for a further hearing in respect of the show cause notice issued against her as aforesaid and since she has neither submitted any other reason as on date other than the reason mentioned his written replies to the show cause notice for necessary consideration nor has she requested for hearing the matter on any other suitable date, I do not find any reason for giving any more chance to Inspector P. Taku for any further hearing on this aspect of the show cause notice issued against her.
61 And, accordingly, appellant being heard in absence of the PIO-cum-OC WPS, Itanagar, Inspector P. Taku in respect of the appeal along with the matter relating the show cause notice issued against the said PIO. All available materials on record,including – written & verbal replies of Inspector P. Taku to the show cause notice issued against her and the verbal statements of Ispector N. Rupa and Inspector M. Mibang, have been carefully considered. Having done so, it transpires that Inspector P. Taku, who received the RTI application of the appellant on 31.01.2020 as PIO-cum-OC WPS, Itanagar, on transfer U/S 6(3) of RTI Act, 2005 from the PIO-cum-DySP (HQ) had 25 days at her hand before she had availed a long leave from 25.02.2020 to 03.06.2020 within which she could have furnished the information to the appellant for maintaining the prescribed period of 30 days as provided under subsection (1) of Section 7 of the RTI Act. And, since furnishing of information within 30 days of receipt of the request/application is time bound under sub-section (1) of Section 7 of the RTI Act, Inspector P. Taku, by virtue of being PIO-cum-OC WPS, Itanagar, was under a bounden or lawful duty to instruct or inform the officer taking her charge of the OC WPS, Itanagar, to furnish the information so sought under RTI Act in remaining 5(days) of the prescribed period of 30 days. But those officers taking her charge as OC WPS, Itanagar, during her long leave period, namely; Inspector N. Rupa and Inspector M. Mibang have stated before the Commission on 10.12.2020 in her presence & hearing through audio/video conferencing that she (Inspector P. Taku) had not ever intimated or informed them (Inspector Rupa & Inspector Mibang) anything about RTI application of the appellant which goes without saying that Inspector P. Taku had been negligent either in furnishing of the information by herself within 25 days of her receipt of the RTI application or in getting the same furnished by the Officer(s) taking her charge as OC WPS, Itanagar, in remaining 5 days of the prescribed period of 30 days from the date of her receipt of the application on 31.01.2020.
In view of the facts and circumstances as discussed aforesaid Inspector P. Taku, PIO-cum OC WPS, Itanagar, is found liable for imposing a reasonable penalty under subsection (1) of Section 20 of the RTI Act, 2005. And, accordingly, she is held liable for imposing penalty under the Act and ordered as follows:
1. That, PIO-cum-OC WPS, Itanagar, Inspector P. Taku shall pay a fine amounting to Rs.25000/-(rupees twenty five thousand) only until before next date of hearing fixed on 18.03.2021. The fine amount shall be deposited through challan payment in the name of the Registrar of the Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission (APIC), Itanagar, against the Head of Account No.0070.
2. That, she shall also pay a compensation amount of Rs.5000/-(rupees five thousand) only to the appellant until before the next date of hearing as mentioned above for the losses and suffering meted to her (appellant) for filing of this Appeal. This compensation amount shall be paid in the mode convenient to the PIO.
62 3. That, she shall submit all records or payment receipts made against both fine and compensation to the Commission on or before the next date of hearing for enabling the Commission for final disposal and closure of this appeal.
4. In the event of her neglect or failure in complying with all or any of the above order(s) the provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 20 of the RTI Act, 2005 for a disciplinary proceeding against her under the related service rules applicable to her may be invoked.
Given under my hand and seal of this Commission’s Court on this 4thday of February, 2021.
Sd/- (Goto Ete) Information Commissioner APIC, Itanagar
63 ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION (APIC) NEAR APPSC OFFICE, ITANAGAR.
Case No. APIC-21/2020 Dated Itanagar, the 13th March’2020
BEFORE THE HON'BLE COURT OF L.PHUNTSO, INFORMATION COMMISSIONER
UNDER SECTION 19(3) OF RTI ACT,2005 (Appeal)
Shri Mamu Middle Sod Vill- Naharlagun, -Appellant Papumpare Dist. Aruncahal Pradesh.
Vs
Public Information Officer (PIO) O/o the Tax & Exercise Department, -Respondent Itanagar, Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
The Commissioner Tax & Exercise, Department, Itanagar. - First Appellant Authority Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh.
JUDGEMENT ORDER
The appeal under section 19(3) of RTI, Act,2005 has been received from Shri Mamu Sono, appellant Middle Sood Village, Naharlagun, Papumpare District, Arunachal Pradesh, for non-furnishing of information by the Public Information Officer O/o the Tax & Exercise Department, Itanagar, Papumpare, Dist. Arunachal Pradesh as sought, by the appellant under section 6 (1) of RTI Act,2005 on dtd 01.11.2019.
Whereas, the 1st hearing was held on 17th February the appellant Shri Mamu Sono, appellant Middle Sood Village, Naharlagun, Papumpare District, Arunachal Pradesh was present in the hearing while , Shri Tago Koyu, APIO Tax, Exercise & Narcotic Department was present.
64 Heard both the parties. The APIO stated that whatever information sought by the appellant had already furnished to the appellant and sent by register post but the appellant did not received the copies of information furnish by APIO due to postal delay and so on.
However the APIO admitted that he will furnish the information as sought by appellant on 2nd March 2020. In view of the Commission has fixed next date of hearing on 2nd March 2020 at 10.30 am in this Commission.
The 2nd hearing was on 2nd March 2020, both appellant and PIO were present in the hearing. The appellant informed that the information regarding mode of appointment of candidates should be submitted in column wise and APIO assured to furnish information as desired by appellant latest by 9th March 2020.The Commission directed the appellant to inform the Commission whether he is satisfied or not satisfied within stipulated date. The appellant further stated that the information sought at Sl. No (d) & (e) has been dropped since he wants to file afresh application on same matter. Till such time the instant case has been kept reserved. Hoverer, later on an application had received from Shri Mamu Sono, appellant Middle Sood Village, Naharlagun, Papumpare District, Arunachal Pradesh and informed that he wants to disposed of the case NO.APIC 21/2020. The appellant stated that whatever information furnished by PIO has been satisfied and requested for closure of the appeal.
Therefore, the Commission in view of that further hearing of same case No.APIC- 21/2020 is not necessary.
Hence, the instant case is disposed off herewith today 09.03.2020. The judgment order is forwarded to both the parties for information.
Given under my had and seal.
Sd\- Leki Phuntso Information Commission APIC, Itanagar.
65 ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION (APIC) NEAR APPSC OFFICE, ITANAGAR.
Case No. APIC-03/2020 Dated Itanagar, the 18th March’2020
BEFORE THE HON'BLE COURT OF L.PHUNTSO, INFORMATION COMMISSIONER
UNDER SECTION 19(3) OF RTI ACT,2005 (Appeal)
Shri Tatum Nima Gen.Secretary. Dulom Welfare Society, -Appellant Vill-Nima, PO/PS Daporijo, Arunachal Pradesh.
Vs
Public Information Officer (PIO) PMGSY, (RWD), Itanagar -Respondent O/o the Chief Engineer, Dist. Papumpare, Arunachal Pradesh
Executive Engineer/PIU-II Rural Work Division, Daporijo. -Respondent Dist. Upper Subansiri, Arunachal Pradesh.
The Chief Engineer, RWD,PMGSY Cell -First Appellant Authority Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh.
JUDGEMENT ORDER
The 4th hearing was held on 13.03.20.The PIO E.E Shri Taluk Jiram, RWD Division, Daporijo and PIO O/o the Chief Engineer RWD, Itanagar was also present. During the hearing Shri Tatum Nima appellant informed the Commission that he is not satisfied with the information furnished to him. Since the utilization Certificate was not furnished to him by PIO of Chief Engineer, Office RWD, Itanagar till 13.03.20. The Commission received application from the appellant wherein he had informed that Utilization Certificate (UC) is not furnished by PIO of Chief Engineer Office, Itanagar. The Commission asked the PIO that as to why he could not furnished the Utilization Certificate as of now. The PIO replied that he did not receive any order from the Commission to furnish particular information to the appellant by him.
66 However, the PIO said that he had received the hearing notice of dtd 11.03.2020. So he appeared on the day of hearing on 13.03.20.
Therefore, heard both appellant and PIO of Chief Engineer, RWD, Office Itanagar. During the course of hearing the PIO, Daporijo was present informed that he had furnished all the required information to appellant pertaining to the jurisdiction of his division and said that remaining documents related to Kamle District has been transferred to EE, RWD Raga under Kamle District for the necessary action.
While enquiring about Utilization Certificate of PMGSY Scheme of CE Office RWD, Itanagar informed and assured that he would furnish within a day or two i.e before 16.03.20 to appellant .The appellant has been directed collect and inform the Commission accordingly and at the same time PIO has been directed to provide the documents without further delay.
In view of above observation the appeal is reserved till 16.03.20 for final disposal of appeal.
After passing the Order by this Commission the PIO of Chief Engineer Office, Itanagar has furnished the Utilization Certificate for the period of 2018-19 and also up to 22.01.20 respectively. The appellant informed the Commission that he had received the information sought by him on 13.03.20 copy of letter submitted by appellant is available in the file.
Now therefore no further hearing of appeal is necessary. Hence, the instant case is disposed off wherewith today dtd 13,03.20.
Copy of the Order is forwarded to the concerned appellant and PIO’s for information.
Sd\- Leki Phuntso Information Commission APIC, Itanagar.
67 Name and Designation of Staff year 2020-21
Sl. Name of the Staff Designation / Charter of duties Contact No. No 1 2 3 4 1. Smti Yajum Tali ASO of Establish Branch 9402280001 2. Shri T. Tatak Accountant 9402257788 3. Shri Rigo Dirchi PS to SCIC, (Dr. Joram Begi) 7640910415 4. Shri Kirkar Riba PS to SIC ( GotoEte) 7005542757 5. Shri Dorjee Phinjo Sona PS to SIC ( Ms Sonam Yudron) 8415080199 6. Shri Odi Menjo P. A to SCIC 8794249305 7. Smti Taba Pumin P.A. to Registrar 8787785458 8. Shri Karke Lona P. A to GotoEte (SIC) 9402960651 9. Shri Tamo Gara PA to SIC (GenomTekseng) 8837312104 10. SmtiDagngamGara PA to SIC ( Gumjum Haider) 8837312104 11. Ms Tsering Yangzom PA to SIC ( Ms Sonam Yudron) 8787308975 12. Shri Tage Padi Computer Programmer 8256927762 13. Shri Nani Andrews Huto LDC 7005244346 14. Smti Nonie Boje L.D.C (issue and dispatch) 8787799409 Computer Operator to Goto Ete 15. Shri PiyeEte 9402247670 (SIC) Computer Operator to 16. Shri Gemin Miyu 6909180702 GenomTekseng (SIC) Computer Operator to Gumjum 17. Shri Kikam Haider 8258890671 Haider (SIC) Computer Operator to Gumjum 18. Shri Benjamin Messar 8258890671 Haider (SIC) 19. Ms. Ching Chung Dazangzu Computer Operator 8256936337
20. Smti Dari Mamta Peon to SCIC 7005371743
21. Miss Hage Ampi MTS to Dy. Registrar 9774547635 22. Miss Gambom Diyum MTS (RTI Case) 9402235169 23. Mrs Marter Lollen MTS (Computer Operator) 9402227298
24. Smti Kiri Ori MTS to Esstt. Branch 8787587712 Smti Nyadam Gamlin 25. MTS to Registrar 9436844218 (Gadi)
68 1 2 3 4 26. Smti Yape Yonggam MTS to SCIC 9436847925
27. Smti Tongam Nomuk MTS to Registrar (Estt.) 9436898700 28. Smti Yaper Bamang MTS to Goto Ete(SIC) Nil 29. Shri Toko Tash MTS (issue and despatch) 7005645928 30. Shri Bani Taki MTS to Registrar 9862510738 31. Miss TaruYanku MTS 9862246155 32. Shri Tunka Camder MTS 9774132270 33. Miss Bamang Rogi MTS 6009363159 34. Shri Ternga Gadi MTS (Account Section) 9436848045 35. Shri Karbi Tali Chowkidar 9402461033 36. Smti Junu Roy Sweeper Nil 37. Shri W. Wangsu Peon to Account Section Nil 38. Shri Bali Jini Driver to Registrar 9436095112 39. Shri Penya Ronya Driver to Registrar 7005280038 40. Shri Nima Tsering Megegi Driver to SCIC 9436071917 41. Shri Kharsen Ete Driver to Goto Ete (SIC) 8732806349
42. Shri Anu Kihon Driver to GenomTekseng (SIC) 8119937833
43. Shri Pasang Tsering Driver to SonamYudron (SIC) 8257855327
44. Shri Kali Lomb Driver to Dy. Registrar 6009786098
69