Tone Building Strategies Used for Beginning High School Choirs Frances R
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2014 Tone Building Strategies Used for Beginning High School Choirs Frances R. Fonza Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF MUSIC TONE BUILDING STRATEGIES USED FOR BEGINNING HIGH SCHOOL CHOIRS By FRANCES R. FONZA A Dissertation submitted to the College of Music in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Degree Awarded: Spring Semester, 2014 Frances R. Fonza defended this dissertation on April 7, 2014. The members of the supervisory committee were: Judy Bowers Professor Directing Dissertation David Okerlund University Representative Andre J. Thomas Committee Member John Geringer Committee Member The Graduate School has verified and approved the above-named committee members, and certifies that the dissertation has been approved in accordance with university requirements. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I extend deepest appreciation to all who helped make this dissertation and degree possible – to Dr. Bowers for offering many hours of guidance, teaching me how to say ‘no,’ and pushing me to reach my potential; to Dr. Thomas for believing in me and providing tough love and encouragement when each was needed; to Dr. Geringer for advice and generosity with time; to Professor Okerlund for support and encouragement. To Dr. Fenton, Dr. Madsen, Dr. Darrow, Dr. Fredrickson, Dr. Hodges, Dr. Porter and Professor Gerber, your influence has been profound. To my extended family and friends, I cannot thank you enough for your thoughtfulness, kind words, and smiles throughout this journey. To my colleagues, to whom I have grown close while pursuing this degree, your friendship and support mean the world to me. The master teachers who participated in this study must remain anonymous, so I am unable to thank them by name. Yet, I was privileged to gain from their wisdom and experience. For their willingness to participate, I am grateful beyond words. Finally, God has richly blessed my life in many ways, especially through my supportive family. To Mom, Dad, Sister, and Brother, thank you for your patience, sacrifices, wisdom, advice, and optimism iii TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Tables .................................................................................................................................. v List of Figures ............................................................................................................................... vii Abstract ........................................................................................................................................ viii 1: INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................... 1 Purpose ................................................................................................................................ 2 Research Questions ............................................................................................................. 3 Definition of Terms ............................................................................................................. 3 Delimitations ....................................................................................................................... 4 2: REVIEW OF LITERATURE .................................................................................................... 5 Developing Healthy Tone ................................................................................................... 6 Developing Tone in the Choral Ensemble ........................................................................ 24 Choral Warm-up ............................................................................................................... 31 Additional Influencing Factors ......................................................................................... 36 Summary ........................................................................................................................... 40 Need for Study .................................................................................................................. 41 3: METHOD ................................................................................................................................ 43 Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 43 Participants ........................................................................................................................ 43 Equipment/Interview ......................................................................................................... 48 Procedure .......................................................................................................................... 49 Purpose .............................................................................................................................. 52 4: RESULTS ................................................................................................................................ 54 The Interview ..................................................................................................................... 54 Strategies and Demonstrations ........................................................................................ 108 Modeling ......................................................................................................................... 117 Modeling versus Analogy/Metaphor/Imagery Descriptions ........................................... 118 Summary of Individual Teaching: Teacher Profiles ...................................................... 119 Summary of Group Commonalities ................................................................................ 132 5: SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION ......................................................................................... 133 Research Question #1 .................................................................................................... 133 Research Question #2 .................................................................................................... 149 Research Question #3 .................................................................................................... 157 Research Question #4 .................................................................................................... 160 Concluding Thoughts ..................................................................................................... 160 Conclusion and Professional Implications ..................................................................... 161 Suggestions for Further Study ....................................................................................... 164 APPENDICES ............................................................................................................................ 166 Appendix A: Interview Questions ................................................................................. 166 Appendix B: Human Subjects Approval Form .............................................................. 168 Appendix C: Example of Interview Transcript .............................................................. 171 Appendix D: Example of Observation Transcript ......................................................... 172 REFERENCES ........................................................................................................................... 173 BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH ...................................................................................................... 180 iv LIST OF TABLES Table 1: Jordan Warm-Up Hierarchy .......................................................................................... 33 Table 2: Gackle Warm-Up Sequence .......................................................................................... 35 Table 3: Most Advanced Degree ................................................................................................. 56 Table 4: Hours of School/District In-Service .............................................................................. 57 Table 5: Hours of Conference Interest Sessions .......................................................................... 58 Table 6: Learned Strategies Rank Ordered .................................................................................. 59 Table 7: Conferences Attended in the Past Year ......................................................................... 59 Table 8: Tone Building Strategies for Breath .............................................................................. 61 Table 9: Tone Building Strategies for Resonance ....................................................................... 62 Table 10: Tone Building Strategies for Range Extension ........................................................... 63 Table 11: Tone Building Strategies for Phonation ...................................................................... 64 Table 12: Tone Building Strategies for Vowel Development ..................................................... 64 Table 13: Analogy/Metaphor/Imagery for Teacher A ................................................................. 67 Table 14: Analogy/Metaphor/Imagery for Teacher B ................................................................. 67 Table