DOCSLIB.ORG

The Impacts of Incarceration on Crime

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Impacts of Incarceration on Crime The impacts of incarceration on crime David Roodman1 Open Philanthropy Project September 2017 1 I thank Holden Karnofsky for guidance and support, Mark Schaffer for advice on applying the Anderson-Rubin test; Tim Carr for generous assistance with data from Georgia; Peter Ganong, Steven Levitt, and Thomas Marvell for sharing data; Ilyana Kuziemko for sharing code and arranging access to data; Donald Green and Alex Tabarrok for sharing or posting data and code; and David Abrams, John Berecochea, Paolo Buonanno, Chloe Cockburn, Gordon Dahl, Rafael Di Tella, Joseph Doyle, Peter Ganong, Donald Green, Randi Hjalmarsson, Ilyana Kuziemko, Gerry Gaes, Karalyn Lacey, Edward Miguel, Michael Mueller-Smith, Daniel Nagin, Emily Owens, Steven Raphael, Max Schanzenbach, Alex Tabarrok, Ben Vollaard, David Weisburd, and Crystal Yang for reviewing full or partial drafts. Thanks also to my GiveWell colleagues for valua- ble feedback. All views expressed are attributable to me alone. Contents 1. Introduction .............................................................................................................................................................. 5 2. Conceptual preliminaries ......................................................................................................................................... 9 2.1. Swiftness, certainty, and severity ................................................................................................................... 9 2.2. Causal channels from incarceration to crime ........................................................................................... 10 2.2.1. Before incarceration: deterrence ........................................................................................................ 10 2.2.2. During incarceration: incapacitation ................................................................................................. 10 2.2.3. Aftereffects ........................................................................................................................................... 10 2.3. On measuring crime .................................................................................................................................... 11 2.4. Five confounders ......................................................................................................................................... 11 2.4.1. Aging ...................................................................................................................................................... 11 2.4.2. Replacement ......................................................................................................................................... 13 2.4.3. Illicit industry destabilization ............................................................................................................. 14 2.4.4. Cognitive framing ................................................................................................................................ 14 2.4.5. The parole effect .................................................................................................................................. 16 3. Process .................................................................................................................................................................... 18 3.1. Searching ....................................................................................................................................................... 18 3.2. Filtering .......................................................................................................................................................... 18 3.3. Reanalyzing ................................................................................................................................................... 20 4. Summary of reviews .............................................................................................................................................. 22 5. Deterrence: Swiftness and certainty ................................................................................................................... 27 5.1. Weisburd, Einat, and Kowalski (2008), “The miracle of the cells: An experimental study of interventions to increase payment of court-ordered financial obligations,” Criminology & Public Policy . 27 5.2. HOPE ............................................................................................................................................................ 28 5.2.1. Hawken and Kleiman (2009), “Managing drug involved probationers with swift and certain sanctions: Evaluating Hawaii’s HOPE”; Hawken et al. (2016), “HOPE II: A follow-up to Hawaiʻi’s HOPE evaluation” ................................................................................................................................................ 28 5.2.2. Lattimore et al. (2016), “Outcome findings from the HOPE demonstration field experiment: Is swift, certain, and fair an effective supervision strategy?”, Criminology & Public Policy; O’Connell, Brent, and Visher (2016), “Decide Your Time: A randomized trial of a drug testing and graduated sanctions program for probationers,” Criminology & Public Policy ............................................................ 30 5.3. Summary: Swiftness and certainty ............................................................................................................. 33 6. Deterrence: Severity .............................................................................................................................................. 33 6.1. Ross (1982), Deterring the Drinking Driver ............................................................................................ 33 6.2. Drago, Galbiati, and Vertova (2009), “The Deterrent Effects of Prison: Evidence from a Natural Experiment,” Journal of Political Economy ......................................................................................................... 35 6.3. Two studies of “Three Strikes” .................................................................................................................. 36 6.3.1. Helland and Tabarrok (2007), “Does Three Strikes deter? A nonparametric estimation,” Journal of Human Resources .............................................................................................................................. 37 6.3.2. Iyengar (2008), “I’d rather be hanged for a sheep than a lamb: The unintended consequences of ‘three-strikes’ laws,” NBER working paper ................................................................................................. 41 6.4. Abrams (2012), “Estimating the deterrent effect of incarceration using sentencing enhancements,” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics .............................................................................................. 42 6.5. Summary: Severity ........................................................................................................................................ 48 7. Incarceration versus highly supervised release: incapacitation and aftereffects ........................................... 48 7.1. Deschenes, Turner, and Petersilia (1995), “A dual experiment in intensive community supervision: Minnesota’s prison diversion and enhanced supervised release programs,” Prison Journal ......................... 48 7.2. Di Tella and Schargrodsky (2013), “Criminal recidivism after prison and electronic monitoring,” Journal of Political Economy .................................................................................................................................. 49 7.3. Summary: Incarceration versus highly supervised release ...................................................................... 51 8. Incapacitation......................................................................................................................................................... 51 8.1. Levitt (1996), “The effect of prison population size on crime rates: Evidence from prison overcrowding litigation,” Quarterly Journal of Economics ................................................................................ 51 8.2. Owens (2009), “More time, less crime? Estimating the incapacitative effect of sentence enhancements,” Journal of Law and Economics ................................................................................................. 60 8.3. Buonanno and Raphael (2013), “Incarceration and incapacitation: Evidence from the 2006 Italian collective pardon,” American Economic Review ................................................................................................ 61 8.4. Vollaard (2013), “Preventing crime through selective incapacitation,” Economic Journal .............. 64 8.5. Lofstrom and Raphael (2016), “Incarceration and crime: Evidence from California’s public safety realignment reform,” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science .............................. 67 8.6. Summary: Incapacitation versus standard release ................................................................................... 77 9. Aftereffects ............................................................................................................................................................. 78 9.1. Berecochea, Jaman, and Jones (1973), “Time served in prison and parole outcome: An experimental study: Report number 1”; Berecochea and Jaman (1981), “Time served
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Here in Our Own City, Baltimore
    THE WIRE Series Wrap-Up David Simon, Series Creator Welcome to a special series of podcasts by the Center for Emerging Media. On Sunday, the Wire will air its final episodes, marking the end of five seasons of intense social and political commentary transmitted in the form of a groundbreaking tv drama, set right here in our own city, Baltimore. I sat down with the showscreator, David Simon, who also serves as a writer and producver, to ghear his thoughts on what the Wire has meant to him and what he thinks The Wire says to all of us in the 21st century. Here is our conversation. The conversation I had with Ed was really good, we were talking a lot about the philosophy behind it and it’s funny, I said to him about whose characters were whose and how you work together to write things and he said that McNulty was probably more you than him. No, I say it’s more Ed than me. I do, listen, there’s some of me in there and there’s some of Ed in there and there’s some of nobody, there’s some of Dominic West. So, ultimately, I think plausible deniability requires Ed to say it’s more of me and requires me to say it’s more of Ed. We were talking about how the characters in this, those that stand up against the system, those that have some sense of honor and righteousness no matter who and what they do, are the ones that seem to always get it in the end, or get hurt in the process and not be able to come out on top.
    [Show full text]
  • The Wire the Complete Guide
    The Wire The Complete Guide PDF generated using the open source mwlib toolkit. See http://code.pediapress.com/ for more information. PDF generated at: Tue, 29 Jan 2013 02:03:03 UTC Contents Articles Overview 1 The Wire 1 David Simon 24 Writers and directors 36 Awards and nominations 38 Seasons and episodes 42 List of The Wire episodes 42 Season 1 46 Season 2 54 Season 3 61 Season 4 70 Season 5 79 Characters 86 List of The Wire characters 86 Police 95 Police of The Wire 95 Jimmy McNulty 118 Kima Greggs 124 Bunk Moreland 128 Lester Freamon 131 Herc Hauk 135 Roland Pryzbylewski 138 Ellis Carver 141 Leander Sydnor 145 Beadie Russell 147 Cedric Daniels 150 William Rawls 156 Ervin Burrell 160 Stanislaus Valchek 165 Jay Landsman 168 Law enforcement 172 Law enforcement characters of The Wire 172 Rhonda Pearlman 178 Maurice Levy 181 Street-level characters 184 Street-level characters of The Wire 184 Omar Little 190 Bubbles 196 Dennis "Cutty" Wise 199 Stringer Bell 202 Avon Barksdale 206 Marlo Stanfield 212 Proposition Joe 218 Spiros Vondas 222 The Greek 224 Chris Partlow 226 Snoop (The Wire) 230 Wee-Bey Brice 232 Bodie Broadus 235 Poot Carr 239 D'Angelo Barksdale 242 Cheese Wagstaff 245 Wallace 247 Docks 249 Characters from the docks of The Wire 249 Frank Sobotka 254 Nick Sobotka 256 Ziggy Sobotka 258 Sergei Malatov 261 Politicians 263 Politicians of The Wire 263 Tommy Carcetti 271 Clarence Royce 275 Clay Davis 279 Norman Wilson 282 School 284 School system of The Wire 284 Howard "Bunny" Colvin 290 Michael Lee 293 Duquan "Dukie" Weems 296 Namond Brice 298 Randy Wagstaff 301 Journalists 304 Journalists of The Wire 304 Augustus Haynes 309 Scott Templeton 312 Alma Gutierrez 315 Miscellany 317 And All the Pieces Matter — Five Years of Music from The Wire 317 References Article Sources and Contributors 320 Image Sources, Licenses and Contributors 324 Article Licenses License 325 1 Overview The Wire The Wire Second season intertitle Genre Crime drama Format Serial drama Created by David Simon Starring Dominic West John Doman Idris Elba Frankie Faison Larry Gilliard, Jr.
    [Show full text]
  • The Wire and Drug Policy
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by LJMU Research Online “No One Wins. One Side Just Loses More Slowly”: The Wire and Drug Policy Steve Wakeman Liverpool John Moores University Abstract This article presents a cultural analysis of HBO’s drama series, The Wire. It is argued here that, as a cultural text, The Wire forms a site of both containment and resistance, of hegemony and change with recourse to the regulation of illicit drug markets. In this sense The Wire constitutes an important cultural paradigm of drug policy debates, one that has significant heuristic implications regarding both the present consequences and future directions of illicit drug policy. Ultimately, it is demonstrated below that through its representations of the tensions and antagonisms characteristic of drug control systems, The Wire reveals larger predicaments of governance faced by neoliberal democracies today. Keywords Cultural criminology, drugs, regulation, representations, The Wire 1 Introduction Real is pretend, and pretend is real. From the autobiography of Felicia ‘Snoop’ Pearson (Pearson and Ritz, 2007).1 Recent years have seen the significant growth of criminological interest in various forms of media and their symbolic and textual meanings. Photographic images (Carrabine, 2012), children’s cartoons (Kort-Butler, 2012), video games (Groombridge, 2008), and films (O’Brien et al., 2005; Tzanelli et al., 2005; Rafter, 2007) have all been fruitfully investigated with recourse to the role(s) they play in the construction and development of public understandings of crime and justice. Since television programmes are one of the most powerful vehicles driving and informing such popular understandings, their inclusion within criminological analysis is not only justified, but critically important to the continued development of criminology as a field of study.
    [Show full text]
  • Crime, Class, and Labour in David Simon's Baltimore
    "From here to the rest of the world": Crime, class, and labour in David Simon's Baltimore. Sheamus Sweeney B.A. (Hons), M.A. (Hons) This thesis is submitted to Dublin City University for the award of Ph.D in the Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences. August 2013 School of Communications Supervisors: Prof. Helena Sheehan and Dr. Pat Brereton I hereby certify that this material, which I now submit for assessment on the programme of study leading to the award of Ph.D is entirely my own work, and that I have exercised reasonable care to ensure that the work is original, and does not to the best of my knowledge breach any law of copyright, and has not been taken from the work of others save and to the extent that such work has been cited and acknowledged within the text of my work. Signed: ___________________________________ (Candidate) ID No.: _55139426____ Date: _______________ TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction 1 Literature review and methodology 17 Chapter One: Stand around and watch: David Simon and the 42 "cop shop" narrative. Chapter Two: "Let the roughness show": From death on the 64 streets to a half-life on screen. Chapter Three: "Don't give the viewer the satisfaction": 86 Investigating the social order in Homicide. Chapter Four: Wasteland of the free: Images of labour in the 122 alternative economy. Chapter Five: The Wire: Introducing the other America. 157 Chapter Six: Baltimore Utopia? The limits of reform in the 186 war on labour and the war on drugs. Chapter Seven: There is no alternative: Unencumbered capitalism 216 and the war on drugs.
    [Show full text]
  • I:\28531 Ind Law Rev 46-2\46Masthead.Wpd
    THE WIRE AND ALTERNATIVE STORIES OF LAW AND INEQUALITY ROBERT C. POWER* INTRODUCTION The Wire was a dramatic television series that examined the connections among crime, law enforcement, government, and business in contemporary Baltimore, Maryland.1 It was among the most critically praised television series of all time2 and continues to garner substantial academic attention in the form of scholarly articles,3 academic conferences,4 and university courses.5 One aspect * Professor, Widener University School of Law. A.B., Brown University; J.D., Northwestern University Law School. Professor Power thanks Alexander Meiklejohn and John Dernbach for their comments on an earlier draft of this Article. He also thanks Lucas Csovelak, Andrea Nappi, Gabor Ovari, Ed Sonnenberg, and Brent Johnson for research assistance. 1. Substantial information about the series is available at HBO.COM, http://www.hbo.com/ the-wire/episodes#/the-wire/index.html [hereinafter Wire HBO site]. This site contains detailed summaries of each episode. Subsequent references to specific episodes in this Article refer to the season, followed by the number of the episode counting from the beginning of season one, and then the name of the episode. For example, the first episode of season four, which introduces the four boys who serve as protagonists in season four, is The Wire: Boys of Summer (HBO television broadcast Sept. 10, 2006) [hereinafter Episode 4-38, Boys of Summer]. Additional information is available at The Wire, IMDB.COM, http://www.imdb.com/ title/tt0306414/ (last visited Mar. 26, 2013) [hereinafter Wire IMDB site]. Several books contain essays and other commentaries about the series.
    [Show full text]
  • The Wire and the Democracy of Fiction
    NARRATIVES / AESTHETICS / CRITICISM THE WIRE AND THE DEMOCRACY OF FICTION ARIANE HUDELET Name Ariane Hudelet antecedents, and in its meta-narrative story arc in season Academic centre Paris Diderot University 5, the show reflects on the fictional process and on the E-mail address [email protected] different media which filter reality to try and represent it. This article analyzes how The Wire explores the moral KEYWORDS implications of fiction-making and the different meanings The Wire; Fiction; Realism; David Simon; Mise-en-scène. of the term, from fiction as counter-fact, or counter-truth, to fiction as experimentation. Through the case study of the final season, we see how the series plays out its ABSTRACT ambivalence toward fictional codes and advocates a mode Beyond its oft-praised “realism”, The Wire (HBO, 2002- of critical fictional representation as an alternative to the 2008) – precisely because of its closeness to non-fiction current, devious modes of safety policy and journalism. – explores the modalities and functionalities of fiction and This article demonstrates how, by delegating fiction- investigates what fiction is and what fiction can do. The making to characters as it does, more particularly in season series above all reflects on the ethical stakes of fiction- 5, The Wire inscribes itself in what Jacques Rancière calls making. In the game it establishes with its non-fiction “fictional democracy”. 77 SERIES VOLUME IV, Nº 2, WINTER 2018: 77-90 DOI https://doi.org/10.6092/issn.2421-454X/8335 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF TV SERIAL NARRATIVES ISSN 2421-454X NARRATIVES / AESTHETICS / CRITICISM > ARIANE HUDELET THE WIRE AND THE DEMOCRACY OF FICTION It is a truth universally acknowledged that The Wire (HBO, season, the series does indeed explore the moral implications 2002-2008) is a realistic series, based on a close observation of fiction-making and the different meanings of the term, of the reality of Baltimore by its co-creators David Simon and from fiction as counter-fact, or counter-truth, to fiction as Ed Burns.
    [Show full text]
  • The Wire's Love Affair with Baltimore
    “And All the Pieces Matter” The Wire’s Love Affair With Baltimore ECENTLY MY PHOTOGRAPHY 2007. “I’m not thinking about the Baltimore Police Chief, Ed Norris also job sent me to an inner-city general reader. My greatest fear is that appears on the show as a Homicide school in Baltimore. As my co- the people in the world I’m writing about named after himself. R workers and I drove through will read it and say, ‘Nah, there’s nothing The story lines also mirror real-life the streets, I realized much of the area there.’ The characters feel real and hu- Baltimore events. For instance, former looked familiar. I had never been in this man, which is why the show has received Mayor Kurt Schmoke’s infamous policy particular section of the city, but I had so much critical praise. of legalizing drugs was brought to life seen many of the streets – Calhoun, To anyone who has ever lived there, in the third season, when a renegade North Avenue, and Fulton. I recognized The Wire is Baltimore. As a Baltimore District Commander proposes a similar a Footlocker, a middle school and even Sun reporter on the crime-beat in the idea. Likewise, the rise of fictional City street corners. late 1980’s, Simon saw the devastation Council President Tommy Carcetti is not Why was I familiar with this area his city was going through. In 1988, too far removed from that of former when I had never ventured this way be- he followed Homicide detectives for a Baltimore Mayor (and current Maryland fore? I had seen these places on HBO’s year.
    [Show full text]
  • Exploring American Cultural Myths and Social Inequality in the Wire
    Exploring American Cultural Myths and Social Inequality in The Wire Jurković, Tin Master's thesis / Diplomski rad 2020 Degree Grantor / Ustanova koja je dodijelila akademski / stručni stupanj: University of Zagreb, University of Zagreb, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences / Sveučilište u Zagrebu, Filozofski fakultet Permanent link / Trajna poveznica: https://urn.nsk.hr/urn:nbn:hr:131:221679 Rights / Prava: In copyright Download date / Datum preuzimanja: 2021-09-28 Repository / Repozitorij: ODRAZ - open repository of the University of Zagreb Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences Odsjek za anglistiku Filozofski fakultet Sveučilište u Zagrebu DIPLOMSKI RAD Exploring American Cultural Myths and Social Inequality in The Wire (Smjer: književno-kulturološki smjer, amerikanistika) Kandidat: Tin Jurković Mentor: dr.sc. Sven Cvek Ak. godina: 2019. /2020. Table of Contents Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………3 1. The creation of the show and its influence………………………………………………5 2. On modern television………………………………………………………………….....8 2.1. Quality television and good television………………………………………..10 3. Abandoning the cop show trope? ………………………………………………………17 3.1. Defining “real” police………………………………………………………...20 4. Defining Baltimore’s postmodern institutions………………………………………….25 5. Analyzing the “game”…………………………………………………………………..29 6. The Wire as an ethnography of a city…………………………………………………...38 7. The sociopolitical background of local politics’ inefficiency…………………………..43 Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………………50 Works cited………………………………………………………………………………...52 Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………….56 2 Introduction This paper will focus on how HBO’s The Wire subverts dominant cultural narratives through an exploration of social inequality and the decline of modern institutions. This primarily concerns ideas elementary to the discourse of Americanness such as equality of opportunity (in terms of moving up the social ladder) as well as the idea of a democracy that serves the people’s best interest via functional institutions.
    [Show full text]
  • INVESTIGATING the CW. GUEST EDITED by MÉLANIE BOURDAA, CLAIRE CORNILLON and SHANNON WELLS-LASSAGNE VOLUME IV, No 02 · WINTER 2018
    INVESTIGATING THE CW. GUEST EDITED BY MÉLANIE BOURDAA, CLAIRE CORNILLON AND SHANNON WELLS-LASSAGNE VOLUME IV, No 02 · WINTER 2018 EDITORS Veronica Innocenti, Héctor J. Pérez and Guglielmo Pescatore. ASSOCIATE EDITOR Elliott Logan GUEST EDITORS Mélanie Bourdaa, Claire Cornillon, Shannon Wells-Lassagne SECRETARIES Luca Barra, Paolo Noto. EDITORIAL BOARD Marta Boni, Université de Montréal (Canada), Concepción Cascajosa, Universidad Carlos III (Spain), Fernando Canet Centellas, Universitat Politècnica de València (Spain), Alexander Dhoest, Universiteit Antwerpen (Belgium), Julie Gueguen, Paris 3 (France), Lothar Mikos, Hochschule für Film und Fernsehen “Konrad Wolf” in Potsdam- Babelsberg (Germany), Jason Mittell, Middlebury College (USA), Roberta Pearson, University of Nottingham (UK), Xavier Pérez Torio, Universitat Pompeu Fabra (Spain), Veneza Ronsini, Universidade SERIES has two main purposes: first, to respond to the surge Federal de Santa María (Brasil), Massimo Scaglioni, Università Cattolica di Milano (Italy), Murray Smith, University of Kent (UK). of scholarly interest in TV series in the past few years, and compensate for the lack of international journals special- SCIENTIFIC COMMITEE izing in TV seriality; and second, to focus on TV seriality Gunhild Agger, Aalborg Universitet (Denmark), Sarah Cardwell, University of Kent (UK), Sonja de Leeuw, Universiteit Utrecht through the involvement of scholars and readers from both (Netherlands), Sergio Dias Branco, Universidade de Coimbra the English-speaking world and the Mediterranean and
    [Show full text]
  • From Rationalism to Realism in the Wire
    “Umjetnost riječi” LX (2016) • 3–4 • Zagreb • July – December RESEARCH PAPER Matija J E L A Č A (Juraj Dobrila University of Pula) FROM RATIONALISM TO REALISM IN THE WIRE UDK 791-24:316.7 One of the most striking and frequently praised aspects of HBO’s cult TV series The Wire is its purported realism. Why this series is virtually unanimously perceived as realistic is the main question that this paper will attempt to answer. The question is addressed from the perspective of Robert Brandom’s neo-pragmatist rationalist philosophical project in general, and his account of the appearance/reality distinction in particular. The first part of the paper introduces Brandom’s neo-pragmatist rationalist account of the relation between appearance and reality as explicated in his book Reason in Philosophy. The second part addresses 261 the question of the verisimilitude of The Wire in these Brandomian rationalist terms. It is thereby suggested that, first, The Wire appears to be real because it is rational—i.e. because it rationally integrates all its commitments into a single unified whole—and second, it is recognized as real because it exhibits an expressively progressive structure—i.e. it gradually makes explicit the commitments that were held implicitly throughout the course of its five seasons. Keywords: The Wire, Robert Brandom, neo-pragmatism, rationalism, realism, verisimilitude. INTRODUCTION “Don’t seem possible. That’s some Spiderman shit there.” As every fan of HBO TV series The Wire will recognize, these memorable words are uttered by Marlo Stanfield, as he gazes in disbelief at the fourth story balcony window through which Omar Little jumps and disappears, while being shot at by Marlo’s ‘muscle’ (“The Dickensian Aspect”, S05E06).
    [Show full text]