Running Head: SELFIES, PERSONALITY, and NARCISSISM 1 Selfies, Personality, and Narcissism by Asha Amber Lynn Madsen-Humeniuk
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Running head: SELFIES, PERSONALITY, AND NARCISSISM 1 Selfies, Personality, and Narcissism by Asha Amber Lynn Madsen-Humeniuk A dissertation to fulfill the requirements for a Doctor of Psychology in Counseling Psychology at Northwest University 2019 Approved: K. Kim Lampson, Ph.D., Chair Kristin Mauldin, Ph.D., Committee Member Cherri K. Seese, Ph.D., Committee Member Leihua Edstrom, Ph.D., Director, College of Social and Behavioral Sciences Matt Nelson, Ph.D., Dean of College of Social and Behavioral Sciences July 18, 2019 SELFIES, PERSONALITY, AND NARCISSISM 2 Abstract The purpose of this study was to determine whether there is a statistically significant relationship between the frequency of capturing selfies and extraversion, agreeableness, and self-esteem and whether these measures could give rise to a new predictive assessment scale for narcissism. Participants were recruited through the social media website Facebook. Two hundred and six individuals were administered a brief demographic questionnaire about their social media usage and the frequency with which they captured selfies. They were also administered the Narcissistic Personality Inventory (NPI), the Big Five Inventory (BFI), and the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSES) through Qualtrics. Two hundred and five participants’ results were analyzed for this study by performing a Pearson correlation and a multiple regression analysis. Based on the data collected, not all of the hypotheses were supported. However, the findings did reveal a statistically significant positive relationship between the frequency of selfies an individual captured and their scores on the NPI. Additionally, it was determined through a multiple regression analysis that extraversion BFI scores, agreeableness BFI scores, and RSES scores could be predictive of scores on the NPI. Further testing should be implemented with a greater sample size to validate the reliability of using extraversion BFI scores, agreeableness BFI scores, and RSES scores as a predictive measure of scores on the NPI. Keywords: narcissism, self-esteem, social media, selfies SELFIES, PERSONALITY, AND NARCISSISM 3 Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................................................... 2 Acknowledgements............................................................................................................. 5 List of Tables...................................................................................................................... 6 List of Figures..................................................................................................................... 7 Chapter One........................................................................................................................ 8 Online Social Networking........................................................................................10 Selfies.......................................................................................................................12 Benefits and Risks of Social Media and Selfies......................................................14 Selfie Research.........................................................................................................17 Selfie and Personality............................................................................................. 20 The Big Five................................................................................................. 21 Narcissism..................................................................................................... 22 Rationale for the Study........................................................................................... 28 Research Question.................................................................................................. 30 Chapter Two...................................................................................................................... 32 Methods................................................................................................................... 32 Participants.............................................................................................................. 33 Materials and Procedures........................................................................................ 33 Narcissistic Personality Inventory................................................................ 34 Big Five Inventory........................................................................................ 35 Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale....................................................................... 35 Data Analysis 35 SELFIES, PERSONALITY, AND NARCISSISM 4 Summary ................................................................................................................. 36 Chapter Three.................................................................................................................... 37 Results..................................................................................................................... 37 Analytic Strategy.......................................................................................... 37 Findings........................................................................................................ 37 Summary ....................................................................................................... 51 Chapter Four..................................................................................................................... 53 Discussion............................................................................................................... 53 Interpretation................................................................................................. 53 Limitations.................................................................................................... 53 Low Sample Size................................................................................ 53 Self-Esteem......................................................................................... 54 Demographics..................................................................................... 54 Narcissistic Inventory......................................................................... 55 Integration..................................................................................................... 55 Application to Counseling and Future Directions........................................ 57 Conclusion.............................................................................................................. 60 References......................................................................................................................... 62 Appendices........................................................................................................................ 62 Informed Consent.................................................................................................... 72 Demographics Questionnaire.................................................................................. 74 Narcissism Personality Inventory (NPI)................................................................. 75 Big Five Inventory (BFI)........................................................................................ 78 Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSES) 79 SELFIES, PERSONALITY, AND NARCISSISM 5 Acknowledgements I want to thank everyone that has helped me on my journey towards completing my doctoral degree. Specifically, I want to thank my husband and family for always supporting me throughout this process, especially through several late nights. Also, I want to thank my cohort members for pushing me to be successful. Additionally, I want to thank my committee, in particular, my chair, Dr. Kim Lampson for pushing me to do my best work. Dr. Mauldin and Dr. Seese, thank you for helping me throughout this stage in my life and helping me grow as a person. Finally, I want to thank Dr. Edstrom for always being a listening ear and being supportive when I needed help advocating for my needs. Thank you everyone! Asha Amber Lynn Madsen-Humeniuk SELFIES, PERSONALITY, AND NARCISSISM 6 List of Tables Table 1 - Descriptive Statistics......................................................................................... 38 Table 2 - Paired Samples Statistics.................................................................................. 38 Table 3 - Frequency of Selfie Posting and BFI ExtraversionScore..................................39 Table 4 - Frequency of Selfie Posting and BFI AgreeablenessScore...............................40 Table 5- Frequency of Selfie Posting and RSES Score..................................................41 Table 6 - Frequency of Selfie Posting and NPI Score...................................................... 42 Table 7 - Model of Summary........................................................................................... 44 Table 8 - ANOVA............................................................................................................ 44 Table 9 - Coefficients....................................................................................................... 44 Table 10 - Descriptive Statistics (Selfie Only Group).....................................................47 Table 11 - Selfie Posting (Selfie Only Group) and BFI Extraversion Score................... 47 Table 12 - Selfie Posting (Selfie Only Group)