Research Collection
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Research Collection Doctoral Thesis Molecular and transcriptomic characterization of natural resistance to cassava brown streak viruses in cassava Author(s): Anjanappa, Ravi B. Publication Date: 2015 Permanent Link: https://doi.org/10.3929/ethz-a-010572922 Rights / License: In Copyright - Non-Commercial Use Permitted This page was generated automatically upon download from the ETH Zurich Research Collection. For more information please consult the Terms of use. ETH Library DISS. ETH NO. 22704 Molecular and transcriptomic characterization of natural resistance to cassava brown streak viruses in cassava (Manihot esculenta, Crantz) A thesis submitted to attain the degree of DOCTOR OF SCIENCES of ETH ZURICH (Dr. sc. ETH Zurich) Presented by Ravi Bodampalli Anjanappa Master of Science in Plant Biotechnology, University of Agricultural Sciences, Bangalore Born 12th August 1979 Citizen of India Accepted on the recommendation of Prof. Dr. Wilhelm Gruissem, examiner Prof. Dr. Hervé Vanderschuren, co-examiner Dr. Maruthi M. N. Gowda, co-examiner 2015 Table of Contents Abstract 1 Zusammenfassung 3 Abbreviations 5 General Introduction 7 Chapter 1: Natural Resistance to Plant Viruses 13 Chapter 2: Characterization of brown streak virus-resistant cassava 55 Chapter 3: Transcriptome modulation in susceptible and resistant cassava 82 varieties inoculated with cassava brown streak viruses Chapter 4: Identification and characterization of a resistance-breaking 131 Cassava brown streak virus isolate Chapter 5: Discussion and persceptives 159 Acknowledgements 169 Curriculum Vitae 170 Abstract Cassava (Manihot esculenta Crantz) production in eastern and central African countries is adversely impacted by cassava brown streak disease (CBSD), thereby threatening food security. CBSD is caused by two viral species, Cassava brown streak virus (CBSV) and Ugandan Cassava brown streak virus (UCBSV) which are collectively termed as cassava brown streak viruses (CBSVs). Both are (+) single stranded (ss) RNA viruses of the genus Ipomovirus; family Potyviridae. The prevalence of mixed infections of the two ipomoviruses CBSV and UCBSV along with cassava mosaic geminiviruses (CMGs) that cause cassava mosaic disease (CMD) is now well known. In the present study, 14 elite cassava cultivars (selected from the cassava germplasm and breeding programmes) were assayed using top cleft grafting procedures for identifying novel sources of resistance against the multiple CBSV and UCBSV isolates. These infection assays identified cassava varieties with contrasting levels of virus resistance. KBH 2006/18 and KBH 2006/26, two elite breeding lines from the IITA breeding programme were identified as highly resistant as they remained symptom-free and did not support replication for both CBSV and UCBSV isolates. Importantly, challenging with a mixed infection of CBSVs and East African cassava mosaic virus (EACMV-Ug) could not break the virus resistance. Independent grafting experiment using scions resistant KBH 2006/18 and KBH 2006/26, moderately resistant TMS 30001 and susceptible 60444 varieties was performed over a time course (16, 22 and 28 dag) to identify early molecular interactions. As expected, these assays revealed variable CBSV titers across the different time points. Comparative transcriptome analysis of resistant KBH 2006/18 and susceptible 60444 varieties were performed using Illumina Hiseq2000 from both CBSV-infected and virus-free scions collected at 28 dag. The RNA-seq analysis revealed that an average of 83.5% of the total reads mapped to phytozome cassava reference genome v9 and identified 26,206 genome transcripts. A total of 853 (60.3% of them up-regulated) and 334 (35.6% of them up-regulated) differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were identified in susceptible 60444 and resistant KBH 2006/18 varieties, respectively. Further functional characterization of the DEGs using the MapMan software to identify processes and pathways, revealed 27 and 24 bins MapMan bins or functional classes in susceptible and resistant varieties, respectively. In variety 60444, signaling (MapMan bin 30) was modulated with majority of the DEGs (85 %) being up-regulated while in contrast KBH 2006/18 only 27% of the DEGs were modulated in signaling pathway. In KBH 2006/18, 90% of DEGs related to stress (MapMan bin 20) were up-regulated while 70% of DEGs were up-regulated in susceptible variety. In both the varieties DEGs implicated in photosystem were down-regulated (100%). Further, de novo assembly of unmapped reads determined novel cassava (host) genes, in addition to complete genome sequences of CBSV (TAZ:DES:01) (8,975 nt) and partial sequence of TAZ:DES:02 (6,645 nt). Moreover, analysis 1 of host genes using RT-qPCR, revealed that four DEGs (RDRP1, NTL9, NIMIN2 and BG3) where up-regulated in early time points samples (16 and 22 dag) in susceptible 60444 variety. Further, expression analysis of these genes in moderately resistant TMS 30001 variety also confirmed consistent up-regulation in presence of the virus. CBSV-like symptoms were first reported in resistant variety KBH 2006/18 in a field trail in the Chambezi province in Tanzania in 2012. Field-collected material was multiplied in the greenhouse and used to inoculate KBH 2006/18 scions. CBSD was graft-transmissible to healthy KBH 2006/18, which developed typical CBSD symptoms. We used conserved sequences between CBSV and UCBSV genome sequences to develop primers and amplify fragments of the isolates infecting KBH 2006/18. We detected only one CBSV isolate in the field-collected material that we named CBSV TAZ: Cham:14. Comparing the resistant breaking TAZ:Cham:14 isolate to other isolates (TAZ:DES:01, TAZ:DES:02, and UG:Kab4-3:07) revealed specific mutations in the proteins from the TAZ:Cham:14 isolate with the exception of the 6K1 protein which was identical between TAZ:DES:01 and TAZ:Cham:14. As expected, the sequence diversity was greater between the two CBSVs species (~74.5% identical) than within CBSV isolates (88% identical). This is the first report on CBSV isolates differing in virulence and further efforts are being made to develop infectious clones and to identify molecular virulence determinants of TAZ:Cham:14 in the KBH 2006/18 line. 2 Zussamenfassung Die Produktion von Maniok (Manihot esculenta Crantz) wird in Ost- und Zentralafrikanischen Ländern von der Braunstreifen-Krankheit (Cassava Brown Streak Disease, CBSD) bedroht und gefährdet damit die Ernährungssicherheit in dieser Region. CBSD wird von zwei Virusspezies verursacht, Cassava brown streak virus (CBSV) und Ugandan Cassava brown streak virus (UCBSV), die kollektiv als Cassava brown streak viruses (CBSVs) bezeichnet werden. Beides sind Positive Einzelstrang-RNA Viren der Gattung Ipomovirus; Familie Potyviridae. Die beiden Ipomoviren CBSV und UCBSV treten häufig als Mischinfektion mit Cassava-Mosaik Geminiviren (CMGs) auf, welche die Cassava-Mosaik-Krankheit (Cassava Mosaic Disease, CMD) verursachen. Zur Identifizierung von neuen Resistenzquellen gegen die zahlreichen CBSV und UCBSV Isolate wurden in der vorliegenden Arbeit 14 Elite Maniok-Sorten (von der Maniok Keimplasma-Bank und Zuchtprogrammen selektiert) mittels Aufpfropfen auf infizierte Wurzelstöcke untersucht. Durch diese Infektionsassays wurden Maniok-Sorten mit unterschiedlich stark ausgeprägter Virusresistenz identifiziert. KBH 2006/18 und KBH 2006/26, zwei Elite-Zuchtlinien aus dem IITA Zuchtprogramm, blieben symptomfrei und erlaubten keine Replikation der beiden CBSV und UCBSV Isolate. Auch durch Mischinfektionen mit CBSVs und East African cassava mosaic virus (EACMV-Ug) konnten die Virusresistenz nicht gebrochen werden. Zur Identifizierung von frühen molekularen Wechselwirkungen wurden unabhängige Pfropf-Experimente mit den resistenten Sorten KBH 2006/18 und KBH 2006/26, der mässig resistenten Sorte TMS30001 und der anfälligen Sorte 60444 durchgeführt. Dabei wurden in einem Time-Course-Experiment Proben an 16, 22 und 28 Tagen nach der Pfropfung (TNP) entnommen. Wie zu erwarten zeigten diese Versuche variable CBSV Titer zwischen den verschiedenen Zeitpunkten. Des Weiteren wurden vergleichende Transkriptom-Analysen mit der resistenten Sorte KBH 2006/18 und der anfälligen Sorte 60444 durchgeführt. Dazu wurden CBSV infizierte und virusfreie Pflanzen 28 TNP mittels Illumina Hiseq2000 analysiert. Durchschnittlich 83.5% der gelesenen Fragmente (reads) wurden dem Phytozome Maniok Referenzgenom v9 zugeordnet und 26,206 Transkripte identifiziert. Insgesamt wurden 853 (davon 60.3% hochreguliert) und 334 (davon 35.6% hochreguliert) differentiell exprimierte Gene (DEGs) in 60444 resp. KBH 2006/18 identifiziert. Zur Identifikation von physiologischen Prozessen und Stoffwechselwegen wurden diese DEGs mittels MapMan Software analysiert. Die funktionelle Charakterisierung dieser DEGs ergaben 27 MapMan bins oder funktionelle Klassen in anfälligen und 24 in resistenten Sorten. In 60444 waren hauptsächlich Signaltransduktionsvorgänge (MapMan bin 30) moduliert mit mehrheitlich hochregulierten DEGs (85%), im Gegensatz zu KBH 2006/18 27% DEGs in Signalwegen moduliert waren. 90% der DEGs die im Zusammenhang mit Stress (MapMan bin 20) stehen waren in KBH 2006/18 hochreguliert während in 60444 nur 70% der DEGs 3 hochreguliert waren. In beiden Sorten waren die ins Photosystem involvierten DEGs runterreguliert (100%). Des Weiteren konnten durch die de novo Assemblierung von nicht zugeordneten Fragmenten, nebst der kompletten Genomsequenz von CBSV (TAZ:DES:01) (8975 nt) und der partiellen Sequenz von TAZ:DES:02 (6645