Proposed Amendments to the Constitution—Part 1 of 3
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Load more
Recommended publications
-
Affirm the Belhar? Yes, but Not As a Doctrinal Standard
AFFIRM THE BELHAR? YES, BUT NOT AS A DOCTRINAL STANDARD A Contribution to the Discussion in CRCNA John W. Cooper Professor of Philosophical Theology Calvin Theological Seminary August 2011 CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 3 My Position and Involvement in the Discussion A Momentous Decision: Our Doctrinal Identity and Integrity The Burden of Proof WHY THE BELHAR CONFESSION CANNOT BE A DOCTRINAL STANDARD 6 Confusion about “Confession” The Belhar Confession Lacks the Content of a Doctrinal Standard The Belhar Confession is Doctrinally Ambiguous The Social Gospel? Liberation Theology? Is the Gospel at Stake: Status Confessionis? Biblical Justice or Liberation Ideology? CONSEQUENCES OF ADOPTING THE BELHAR AS A DOCTRINAL STANDARD 20 Adopting the Belhar Confession Would Compromise Our Confessional Integrity The Belhar Confession and Ecumenical Relations A Gift, or an Offer We Can’t Refuse? Do Racial Justice and Reconciliation Require Adoption of BC as a Confession? The Belhar, CRCNA Polity, and Denominational Unity Simple Majority? Conscientious Objection? WHY WE SHOULD AFFIRM THE BELHAR AS A TESTIMONY 27 The Basic Objection Neutralized Principled Decision or Political Compromise? Faithful Witness to Biblical Justice and Reconciliation Benefits for Ecumenical Relations and Racial Reconciliation in CRCNA Can We Make a Confession a Testimony? 2 AFFIRM THE BELHAR? YES, BUT NOT AS A DOCTRINAL STANDARD INTRODUCTION My Position and Involvement in the Discussion Synod 2009 recommended that Synod 2012 adopt the Belhar Confession [hereafter BC] as the CRCNA‟s fourth Form of Unity, that is, as a definitive doctrinal standard.1 I oppose that recommendation because I believe that the confessional and theological identity and integrity of the CRCNA are at stake. -
Provisionally Adopt the Belhar Confession
COMMISSIONS 267 Synod in 2003 and met for the first time in November of that year. Since its organization, Michael Vandenberg has served as the commission’s moderator. As he ends his term of service on the commission and his leadership as moderator, the commission offers the fol- lowing resolution: R-79 Be it resolved that the two hundred and first General Synod of the Reformed Church in America expresses its appreciation for Michael Vandenberg’s four years of faithful service as moderator of the Commission on Christian Education and Discipleship. (ADOPTED) Report of the Commission on Christian Unity INTRODUCTION The General Synod is responsible for the RCA’s ecumenical relations (Book of Church Order, Chapter 1, Part V, Article 2, Section 5). In response to Christ’s prayer that we may all be one and to fulfill its constitutional responsibility, General Synod has constituted the Commission on Christian Unity (CCU) to oversee ecumenical commitments, to present an ecumenical agenda to the church, and to carry out ecumenical directives given by the General Synod. Since its creation in 1974 (MGS 1974, R-6, pp. 201-202) and adoption by General Synod in 1975 (MGS 1975, R-4, pp. 101-102) the CCU has served General Synod by coordinating a range of ecumenical involvements reaching all levels of mission in the RCA. CCU advises General Synod on ecumenical matters and communicates with other denominations, ecumenical councils, and interdenominational agencies. CCU educates the RCA on ecumenical matters and advocates for actions and positions consistent with the RCA’s confessions and ecumenical practices as outlined in “An Ecumenical Mandate for the Reformed Church in America,” which was adopted by General Synod in l996 (MGS 1996, R-1, p. -
Night at the Museum: the Secret Life of an Old Confession
Theology Matters A Publication of Presbyterians for Faith, Family and Ministry Vol 16 No 5 • Nov/Dec 2010 Night at the Museum: The Secret Life of an Old Confession by John L. Thompson The creation of a “Book of Confessions” in which the Westminster Confession of Faith is to be one among a number of confessional documents, and no longer the classic and regulative expression of Presbyterian theology, places it, to all practical intent, in a kind of theological museum, stripped of binding authority upon presbyters and regarded as irrelevant for today. 1 I’m embarrassed to confess that while I live and work the words of William Strong, quoted above, find a very close to the famous Norton Simon Museum in dismal fulfillment. But must this be the case? Pasadena, I have never been there. Oh, sure, I’ve driven by it many times. I’ve seen the outside of it on Our present BOC received its basic shape in 1965-67, in television when they broadcast the Rose Parade. I even the wake of a 1958 denominational merger that would know that it has some classic and valuable collections eventually see the Westminster Standards both trimmed of European and modern art, well worth a visit. But and supplemented by seven other confessional I’ve never been inside. documents—the Nicene Creed, the Apostles Creed, the Scots Confession, the Heidelberg Catechism, the It may be that I’m typical of many people—we are Second Helvetic Confession, the Barmen Declaration, proud of what our own towns and cities have to offer, and the still-to-be-written Confession of 1967 (C-67). -
Essential Tenets & Confessional Standards
Essential Tenets & Confessional Standards Essential Tenets Presbyterians have been of two minds about essential tenets. by recognizing and receiving His authoritative self- We recognize that just as there are some central and revelation, both in the infallible Scriptures of the Old and foundational truths of the gospel affirmed by Christians New Testaments and also in the incarnation of God the everywhere, so too there are particular understandings of the Son. We affirm that the same Holy Spirit who overshadowed gospel that define the Presbyterian and Reformed tradition. the virgin Mary also inspired the writing and preservation of All Christians must affirm the central mysteries of the faith, the Scriptures. The Holy Spirit testifies to the authority of and all those who are called to ordered ministries in a God’s Word and illumines our hearts and minds so that we Presbyterian church must also affirm the essential tenets of might receive both the Scriptures and Christ Himself aright. the Reformed tradition. Recognizing the danger in reducing the truth of the gospel to propositions that demand assent, we We confess that God alone is Lord of the conscience, but this also recognize that when the essentials become a matter freedom is for the purpose of allowing us to be subject always primarily of individual discernment and local affirmation, they and primarily to God’s Word. The Spirit will never prompt lose all power to unite us in common mission and ministry. our conscience to conclusions that are at odds with the Scriptures that He has inspired. The revelation of the Essential tenets are tied to the teaching of the confessions as incarnate Word does not minimize, qualify, or set aside the reliable expositions of Scripture. -
A Study of the Belhar Confession Contents
What is the Belhar Confession, and why does it matter? In this five-session study, learn how the Belhar was born, what it has to say about unity in the church, reconciliation between Christians, and justice in the world, and how it speaks to Christians everywhere. Visit www.crcna.org/belhar for accompanying videos and a 28-day devotional guide. A Study of the Belhar Confession Contents Introduction . .3 Important Dates in Belhar History �����������������������������������������������������������4 A Statement of Introduction by the CRC and RCA �������������������������������5 Original 1986 Accompanying Letter . .6 The Confession of Belhar ���������������������������������������������������������������������������9 A Study of the Using This Study Guide �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������13 Belhar Confession Session 1: The Belhar: What Is It? Why Does It Matter? . .17 Session 2: The Belhar Calls for Unity . .25 Session 3: The Belhar Calls for Justice . .33 Session 4: The Belhar Calls Us to Reconciliation . .43 by Susan Damon Session 5: What Shall We Do with This Gift? . .51 Unless otherwise indicated, Scripture quotations in this publication are from the Holy Bible, New International Version®, NIV®, © 1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.™ Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide. From the Heart of God: A Study of the Belhar Confession (Revised), © 2010, 2013, Christian Reformed Church in North America, 2850 Kala mazoo Ave. SE, Grand Rapids, MI 49560. All rights reserved. This study is updated from the 2010 version prepared for study of the Belhar Confes sion prior to Synod 2012’s deliberation whether to adopt the document as a confession of the Christian Reformed Church in North America. On June 12, 2012, synod adopted the Belhar Confession as an Ecumenical Faith Declaration. -
Download the Belhar Study Guide
C o n t e n t s I n t ro d u c t i o n . .1 Belhar Confession . .3 Notes to Discussion Leaders . .7 Using This Study Guide . .9 G round Rules for Constructive Communication . .1 0 Session 1: Introduction to the Study Guide . .1 1 Session 2: All Creation Gro a n s . .1 3 Session 3: One God, One Churc h . .1 7 Session 4: The Belhar Speaks to Us . .2 3 Session 5: The Belhar Speaks of Justice . .2 9 Session 6: The Belhar Speaks of Reconciliation . .3 5 Session 7: The Belhar As a Call to Action . .4 1 Session 8: The Belhar As an Aff i rmation of Hope . .4 7 Session 9: What Shall We Do with This Gift? . .5 1 Appendix A: Readings . .5 5 Appendix B: Songs . .7 7 Appendix C: Worship Materials . .8 7 Appendix D: Dictionary of Relevant Te rm s . .9 1 Appendix E: Welcoming Diversity Inventory . .9 3 Appendix F: World Recipes . .9 7 To order, contact Faith Alive Christian Resources at (800) 333-8300 or [email protected]. REFORMED CHURCH IN AMERICA FOLLOWING CHRIST IN MISSION rca.org © 2006 REFORMED CHURCH PRESS Unity, Reconciliation, and Justice Introduction The Belhar Confession was first drafted in 1982 by the Dutch Reformed Mission Church in South Africa. It was adopted in 1986, and later it would become one of the standards of unity (along with the Belgic Confession, the Canons of Dort, and the Heidelberg Catechism) for the Uniting Reformed Church in Southern Africa, a merger denomination of two South African Reformed churches. -
Copy of the Proposed Amendments to the Constitution
Proposed Amendments to the Constitution—Part 2 of 3 Confession of Belhar Approved by the 219th General Assembly (2010) and recommended to the presbyteries for their vote. Including: Confession of Belhar and Accompanying Letter, Letter from the Stated Clerk, General Assembly information on Belhar Confession, Introduction to the Confession of Belhar, a study guide, and an article on “Confessions of Faith in the Reformed Tradition” NOTE FROM THE STATED CLERK The 219th General Assembly (2010) of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) approved and recommended to the presbyteries for their affirmative or negative votes the addition of Confession of Belhar to The Book of Confessions. If approved by a two-thirds majority of presbyteries and by the 220th General Assembly (2012), the Constitution will be amended. Please be sure time is taken by the presbytery to study the Confession of Belhar and its Accompanying Letter, using the materials enclosed prior to voting. You will note that reference is made to Item 16-12. That indicates the assembly committee report related to Confession of Belhar. This item number also indicates where to find background information from various entities that was available electronically to the assembly commissioners prior to the General Assembly. (That information may now be accessed at http://www.pc- biz.org/Explorer.aspx?id=3353&promoID=174.) The ―Item Number‖ references are the same as will be found in the Minutes of the 219th General Assembly (2010), Part I [Minutes], which are expected to be available to the presbyteries by the time they consider the amendments. Unless otherwise indicated, new language to be added to The Book of Confessions is on page 6. -
PRESBYTERIAN HERITAGE SPRING 2012 AMY PLANTINGA PAUW [email protected] T/W/Th, 8:30 Am – 9:50 Am Schlegel 121
PRESBYTERIAN HERITAGE SPRING 2012 AMY PLANTINGA PAUW [email protected] T/W/Th, 8:30 am – 9:50 am Schlegel 121 Course Description: This course serves as an introduction to the Reformed tradition as embodied in the history, faith, institutions, and practices of the Presbyterian churches, with particular attention devoted to the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.). The course surveys major figures and movements, recurring theological themes, and perennial and recent challenges to the life of the church. The course also provides for close and contextual readings of Reformed creeds and confessions. The course assumes a basic knowledge of Christian theology and of church history as a prerequisite. The completion of Faith Seeking Understanding (FQI) and History of Christian Experience I & II, or equivalent previous course work in theology and history, is required to participate in this intermediate level of instruction and learning. Objectives: Students will explore both the diversity and the common witness of expressions of Reformed faith across time, examine the nature of a religious tradition and its ethos, and develop the analytical and interpretive skills necessary to participate faithfully in the ongoing witness of the church today. Requirements: 1. Preparation and participation. Your preparation and thoughtful contribution to class discussion (especially on Wednesday discussion days and Wildcard sessions) will represent 25% of your final grade. 2. Short discussion papers: You are asked to write 5 one-page (single-spaced) papers out of 7 possible options, as indicated in the Calendar of Lectures and Discussion Topics for 2/22, 3/6, 3/7, 3/29, 4/4, 4/18, and 4/25. -
Confession of Belhar
Belhar Resources The Christian Reformed Church in North America decided at its 2009 Synod to encourage its churches to study the Belhar Confession (see below for copy) and consider adopting it as a fourth confession along with the Three-Forms of Unity (Heidelberg Catechism, Belgic Confession and Canons of Dort) which all office-bearers subscribe to currently as teaching faithfully the Word of God. The CRCNA has offered several resources for study (www.crcna.org/belhar) and 1st CRC in Seattle, WA, has offered a resources page (www.seattlecrc.org/BelharConfession) – being the congregation that originated the request for the CRC to adopt the Belhar. To truly consider and study the Belhar, congregations and individuals need to understand both the pros and the cons of adopting the Belhar in our context. Most of the resources put forth by the denomination tend to advocate for adoption. Below are listed some additional resources that provide a balance to that view. Granted, most of the resources below do not favor the Belhar Confession for various reasons, but since the CRC’s resources already lay out the benefits, it was thought best to focus on the cautions we need to consider. Dr. John Cooper (Calvin Seminary professor of philosophical theology): “Belhar Yes. Doctrinal Standard No!” – August, 2011 Dr. John Bolt (Calvin Seminary professor of theology) – ”Belhar Reflections”: www.crconnect.blogspot.com – scroll down through the older posts. There seems to be three of them there. Dr. Bolt also has a debate with Shiao Chong that is available here: http://www.christiancourier.ca/Belhar.html Rev. -
The Confession of 1967
THE CONFESSION OF 1967 [TEXT] The Confession of 1967 In approving the Confession of 1967, the United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America adopted its first new confession of faith in three centuries. The turbu- lent decade of the 1960s challenged churches everywhere to restate their faith. While the Second Vatican Council was reformulating Roman Catholic thought and practice, Pres- byterians were developing the Confession of 1967. The 168th General Assembly (1956) of the United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America (UPCUSA) received an overture asking that the Westmin- ster Shorter Catechism be revised. The 170th General Assembly (1958) proposed in- stead that the church draw up a “brief contemporary statement of faith.” A committee labored at the task seven years. The 177th General Assembly (1965) (UPCUSA) vigorously discussed the commit- tee’s proposal and sent an amended draft to the church for study. Sessions, congrega- tions, and presbyteries suggested changes and additions. In response, a newly appointed Committee of Fifteen made revisions. The 178th General Assembly (1966) (UPCUSA) debated this draft, accepted it, and forwarded it to the presbyteries for final ratification. After extensive debate, more than 90 percent of the presbyteries voted approval. Final adoption came at the 179th General Assembly (1967) (UPCUSA). Modestly titled, the Confession of 1967 is built around a single passage of Scrip- ture: “In Christ God was reconciling the world to himself . .” (2 Cor. 5:19, NRSV). The first section, “God’s Work of Reconciliation,” is divided into three parts: the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, the love of God, and the communion of the Holy Spirit. -
Being a Confessional Church C a L V I N Th E O L O G I C a L Se M I N a R Y from the President Foru M Cornelius Plantinga, Jr
C ALVIN THEOLOGI C AL SEMINARY FORUM S PRING 2008 Being a Confessional Church C ALVIN THEOLOGI C AL SEMINARY from the president FORUM Cornelius Plantinga, Jr. Providing Theological Leadership for the Church Volume 15, Number 2 Spring 2008 Dear Brothers and Sisters, REFLECTIONS ON We Calvinists have always wanted reform according to the Word of God. That’s BeinG A confessionAL CHUrcH the first thing “Reformed” means. We want a straightedge to guide reforms, espe- cially because sin has twisted our thinking. We want an outside word, an inspired 3 and infallible word, which defines “good” and “evil” not by human opinions, Why Be a Confessional Church? but by the wisdom of God. We want a picture of the kingdom of God so we can by Lyle D. Bierma see how life is supposed to go and then judge how life needs to be reformed in 5 order to go that way. We want the same Holy Spirit who had originally inspired Theology That Sings: A Discussion Scripture to inspire us when we take Scripture in hand to read or preach it. That’s on the Confessions Today why there’s a “prayer for illumination” not right before the sermon, but right before the reading of Scripture. We know that unless the Holy Spirit breathes 9 through Scripture all over again as it’s read, we might not hear it the right way With Integrity of Heart and Spirit and we might not believe it. by Henry De Moor But in thinking about applying Scripture to life, the Reformers faced a 11 problem, namely, that it’s hard to guide a program of reform by reference to the Is It Time for a New Confession? whole Bible, which is very large, or by reference to a single verse from it, which is by Kathy Smith very small. -
Book of Confessions for All Saints’ Presbyterian Church Doctrinal Standards As Expressed in Our Book of Confessions
* * * Book of Confessions for All Saints’ Presbyterian Church Doctrinal Standards as Expressed in Our Book of Confessions Preface “Beloved, while I was very diligent to write to you concerning our common salvation, I found it necessary to write to you exhorting you to contend earnestly for the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints.” (Jude 3) The Word of God is our only infallible and inerrant rule of faith and life. Yet, in Scripture there is abundant proof attesting to the value of the use of creeds, confessions, and catechisms. Creed is a term from the Latin, credo, “I believe.” Confession is based on the Greek, homologeo, “I confess.” The term catechism is also from a Greek word, katacheo, “to answer, to echo.” In the expanse of the church’s victorious history, the affirmations of our faith have been as simple as “Jesus is Lord” (Acts 10:36, 1Cor. 12:3, Phil. 2:11) in the face of those who would require, “Caesar is Lord.” And, they have been as detailed as the Westminster Confession with an unparalleled definitiveness and have expressed the faith as personally and warmly as the Heidelberg Catechism. A strong Biblical basis may be gleaned for creedal statements and confessions of faith. They function to summarize biblical truths (1 Tim. 3:16) and “retain the standard of sound words” (II Tim. 1:13). They are used as means of confessing the gospel faith in a formal way at baptism, ordination, and similar times of spiritual significance (1Tim.. 4:14, 6:12; Acts 8:12).