DOCSLIB.ORG

In the High Court of Karnataka Dharwad Bench

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
In the High Court of Karnataka Dharwad Bench R IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA DHARWAD BENCH DATED THIS THE 24TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2020 BEFORE THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE E.S. INDIRESH MFA No.100918/2020 (GM-CPC) c/w MFA NO.101088/2020 MFA NO.100918 OF 2020 Between : 1. Shree Samsthana Mahabaleshwara Deva Gokarna, Rep. by Shree Raghaveshwara Bharathi Swamiji Aged about 42 years, Peetadhipathi Shri Ramachadrapura Matha, Haniya Village, Hosanagara Taluka Shimoga District Administrative Office Shree Mahabaleshwara Temple Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada. 2. Shri Ramachandrapura Matha Rep by Shree Raghaveshwara Bharathi Swamiji, Aged 42 years Peetadhipathi Shri Ramachandrapura Matha Haniya Village, Hosanagara Taluka, Shimoga District, Administrative Office Shree Mahableshwara Temple Gokarna, Kumta Taluk. The Appellant No.1 is represented by the 2 Special Power of Attorney Holder Sri. Ganapati K.Hegde, S/o Krishnaiah Hegde Aged 71 years, Administrator Shree Samsthana Mahabaleshwara Deva, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, U.K. District. 3. Shri Krishna S/o Ganesh Bhat, Aged 65 years, Chief Executive Officer Shri Ramachandrapura Matha Administartive Office No.2-A J.C.Road, Girinagara First Phase, Bangalore, Rep. by GPA Holder Appellant No.2 i.e. Shri Ramachandrapura Matha. …Appellants (by Shri K.G. Raghavan, Sr. Counsel for Shri Prashant F. Goudar, Advocate) And : 1. U.F.M. Ananthraj S/o Dattatreya Adi Age 56 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 2. U.F.M. Vishweshwar S/o Gopal Adi Age 61 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 3. U.F.M. Laxminarayana S/o Venkatarama Adi Age 49 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 4. U.F.M. Suresh S/o Mahabaleshwar Adi Age 54 years, R/o Samudra Road Gokarna-581 319. 3 5. U.F.M. Subramanya S/o Chandrashekar Adi Age 45 years, R/o Nagabedi Gokarna-581 319. 6. U.F.M. Ganesh S/o Vishweshvar Adi Age 44 years, R/o Nagabedi Gokarna-581 319. 7. U.F.M. Vinayaka S/o Shivram Adimule Age 68 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 8. U.F.M. Dinesh S/o Rambavu Adimule Age 32 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 9. U.F.M. Maneshwar, S/o Narayan Adimule Age 69 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 10.U.F.M. Ganesh S/o Narayan Adimule Age 65 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna -581319. 11.U.F.M. Anant, S/o Narayan Adimule, Age 63 years, R/o Nagabedi Gokarna-581 319. 12.U.F.M. Narayan, S/o Krishna Adimule, Age 50 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 13.U.F.M. Vishnumurti, S/o Subhraya Adi, Age 42 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 14.U.F.M. Dhamodar, S/o Shivram Adimule, Age 65 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 4 15.U.F.M. Chandrashekar, S/o Shivram Adimule Age 49 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 16.U.F.M. Radhakrishna, S/o Ganapati Adimule Age 42 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 17.U.F.M. Laxmish, S/o Mahabaleshwar Adimule Age 47 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 18.U.F.M. Venkatraman, S/o Keshav Adimule Age 42 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 19.U.F.M. Sheshambhat, S/o Subhraya Adimule Age 54 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 20.U.F.M. Anant, S/o Ramakrishna Adimule, Age 45 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 21.U.F.M. Krishna Datta, S/o Subhraya Adimule, Age 57 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 22.U.F.M. Anant, S/o Ganesh Adimule, Age 69 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 23.U.F.M. Mahadev, S/o Ganesh Adimule, Age 67 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 24.U.F.M. Venkatraman, S/o Ganesh Adimule, Age 65 years, R/o Rathabeedi 5 Gokarna-581 319. 25.U.F.M. Gajanan, S/o Krishna Hire, Age 69 years, R/o Kotatirta Katte Gokarna-581 319. 26.Shri Kshetra Upadvivant Mandal Represented by its Secretary At/Po:Gokarna, Taluk:Kumata Dist: Karwar-581319. …Respondents (By Shri. S.S.Naganand, Senior Counsel for Shri. A.P.Hegde Janmane & Vijay M. Malali, Advocates for R1 to R25) This MFA is filed under Section 104 read with Order XLIII Rule 1(r) of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908, against the Order dated 19.02.2020 passed in Original Suit No.2/2016 on the file of the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Uttara Kannada, Karwar, allowing the I.A.No.1 filed under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 of CPC. MFA NO.101088 OF 2020 Between : Shri Kshetra Upadhivanta Mandal (Registered) Gokarna, Kumta Taluk Rep. by its Secretary Balakrishna Ganapati Jambhe Vaidik Age 60 years, Occupation: Secretary Shri Kshetra Upadhivanta Mandal At/Po: Gokarna Taluk: Kumata Dist: Karwar-581 319 ….Appellant 6 (by Shri K.G. Raghavan, Senior for Shri Akshay A. Katti, Advocate) And : 1. U.F.M. Ananthraj S/o Dattatreya Adi Age 56 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 2. U.F.M. Vishweshwar S/o Gopal Adi Age 61 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 3. U.F.M. Laxminarayana S/o Venkatarama Adi Age 49 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 4. U.F.M. Suresh S/o Mahabaleshwar Adi Age 54 years, R/o Samudra Road Gokarna-581 319. 5. U.F.M. Subramanya S/o Chandrashekar Adi Age 45 years, R/o Nagabedi Gokarna-581 319. 6. U.F.M. Ganesh S/o Vishweshvar Adi Age 44 years, R/o Nagabedi Gokarna-581 319. 7. U.F.M. Vinayaka S/o Shivram Adimule Age 68 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 8. U.F.M. Dinesh S/o Rambavu Adimule Age 32 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 9. U.F.M. Maneshwar, S/o Narayan Adimule Age 69 years, R/o Rathabeedi 7 Gokarna-581 319. 10.U.F.M. Ganesh S/o Narayan Adimule Age 65 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna -581319. 11.U.F.M. Anant, S/o Narayan Adimule, Age 63 years, R/o Nagabedi Gokarna-581 319. 12.U.F.M. Narayan, S/o Krishna Adimule, Age 50 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 13.U.F.M. Vishnumurti, S/o Subhraya Adi, Age 42 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 14.U.F.M. Dhamodar, S/o Shivram Adimule, Age 65 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 15.U.F.M. Chandrashekar, S/o Shivram Adimule Age 49 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 16.U.F.M. Radhakrishna, S/o Ganapati Adimule Age 42 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 17.U.F.M. Laxmish, S/o Mahabaleshwar Adimule Age 47 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 18.U.F.M. Venkatraman, S/o Keshav Adimule Age 42 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 19.U.F.M. Sheshambhat, S/o Subhraya Adimule 8 Age 54 years, R/o Manibhadra Road Gokarna-581 319. 20.U.F.M. Anant, S/o Ramakrishna Adimule, Age 45 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 21.U.F.M. Krishna Datta, S/o Subhraya Adimule, Age 57 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 22.U.F.M. Anant, S/o Ganesh Adimule Age 69 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 23.U.F.M. Mahadev, S/o Ganesh Adimule Age 67 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 24.U.F.M. Venkatraman, S/o Ganesh Adimule Age 65 years, R/o Rathabeedi Gokarna-581 319. 25.U.F.M. Gajanan, S/o Krishna Hire, Age 69 years, R/o Kotatirta Katte Gokarna-581 319. 26. Shree Samsthana Mahabaleshwara Deva Gokarna, Rep. by Shree Raghaveshwara Bharathi Swamiji Aged about 42 years, Peetadhipathi, Shri Ramachandrapura Matha, Haniya Village, Hosanagara Taluka, Shimoga District Administrative Office Shree Mahabaleshwara Temple, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada. 27.Shri Ramachandrapura Matha Rep. by Shree Raghaveshwara Bharathi Swamiji, 9 Aged 42 years Peetadhipathi Shri Ramachandrapura Matha Haniya Village, Hosanagara Taluka, Shimoga District, Administrative Office Shree Mahableshwara Temple Gokarna, Kumta Taluk. 28.Shri Krishna S/o Ganesh Bhat, Aged 65 years, Chief Executive Officer Shri Ramachandrapura Matha Administrative Office No.2-A J.C.Road, Girinagara I Phase, Bangalore, …Respondents (By Shri. S.S.Naganand, Senior Counsel for Shri A.P. Hegde, Janmane, Advocate for R1 to R25) This MFA is filed under Section 104 read with Order XLIII Rule 1(r) of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908, against the Order dated 19.02.2020 passed in Original Suit No.2/2016 on the file of the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Uttara Kannada, Karwar, allowing the I.A.No.1 filed under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 of CPC. In these Appeals arguments being heard, judgment reserved, coming on for pronouncement through video conferencing, this day, the court delivered the following: J U D G M E N T It is said: "If a man seeks unity in deity, then he must necessarily learn to seek unity with the interests of the world also and has to work with it and should learn to live in peace & harmony. ” 10 These matters were taken up for final hearing by the consent of learned senior counsel on both sides on 09 th March 2020. The matter was heard in part and again it was called on 11 th March, 2020. On that date, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants submitted that, he has some more submissions to make. He was accordingly permitted to do so, as there was no objection from the other side.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Cultural Policing in Dakshina Kannada
    Cultural Policing in Dakshina Kannada Vigilante Attacks on Women and Minorities, 2008-09 March, 2009 Report by People’s Union for Civil Liberties, Karnataka (PUCL-K) Publishing history Edition : March, 2009 Published : English Edition : 500 copies Suggested Contribution : Rs. 50 Published by : PUCL-K Cover Design by : Namita Malhotra Printed by : National Printing Press Any part of this Report may be freely reproduced, copied or transmitted as necessary. PUCL-K only asserts the right to be identified with the reproduced version. Contents Chapter I- Introduction ................................................... 1 1.1 Need and Purpose of the Report 1.2 Background to Dakshina Kannada 1.3 Consolidation of Hindutva Forces in Karnataka 1.4 Methodology Chapter II - Vigilante Attacks in Dakshina Kannada ...... 8 2.1 Amnesia Pub Incident 2.2 Intimidation of Independent Voices 2.3 Valentine’s Day Offensive 2.4 Continuing Attacks with Renewed Impunity Chapter III - Understanding Cultural Policing in Dakhina Kannada ......................................26 3.1 Strategy of Cultural Policing 3.2 Role of Organizations Professing Hindutva 3.3 Role of the Police 3.4 Role of the Media 3.5 Role of the Public 3.6 Impact of Cultural Policing Chapter IV - Cultural Policing leading to Social Apartheid: Violation of the Constitutional Order .......39 Chapter V - Civil Society’s Response to Cultural Policing ...43 5.1 Komu Souharde Vedike (KSV) 5.2 Karnataka Forum for Dignity (KFD) 5.3 Democratic Youth Federation of India (DYFI) 5.4 People’s Movement for Enforcement
    [Show full text]
  • In the High Court of Karnataka Dharwad Bench
    1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA DHARWAD BENCH DATED THIS THE 17 th DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2013 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANAND BYRAREDDY WRIT PETITION No.77242 OF 2013 AND WRIT PETITION NOS.77249-77259 OF 2013 (GM-RES) BETWEEN: 1. Sri. Balachandra Prabhakar Kodlekare, Aged 27 years, Resident of Kotithirtha Kodlekar House, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. 2. Sri. Gajanan Shamba Upadhyaya, Aged 43 years, Resident of Near Sanskrith School, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. 3. Sri. Shivram Vinayak Adi, Aged 32 years, Resident of Ratha Beedhi, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. 2 4. Sri. Vishwanath @ Vishu Paniraj Gopi Bhat, Aged 45 years, Resident of Near Mahabaleshwar Temple, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. 5. Sri. Raju @ Rajgopal Mahadev Adi, Aged 38 years, Resident of Ratha Beedhi, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. 6. Sri. Manu Bhaskar Navada, Aged 24 years, Resident of Naga Beedhi, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. 7. Sri. Neelakanth Vasudev Joglekar, Aged 21 years, Resident of Near Gokarna Temple, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. 8. Sri. Niranjan Murthy @ Niranjan Gajanan Joshi, Aged 35 years, Resident of Ratha Beedhi, Opposite Hittal Ganapathi Temple, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, 3 Uttara Kannada District. 9. Sri. Ganesh Vasudev Joglekar, Aged 45 years, Resident of Near Mahabaleshwar Temple, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. 10. Sri. Somanath Vasudev Joglekar, Aged 40 years, Resident of Near Mahabaleshwar Temple, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. 11. Sri. Pani Raj Saka Ram Gopi Bhat, Aged 78 years, Resident of Sarashanakali Road, Gokarna, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District.
    [Show full text]
  • Traditional Knowledge Systems of India and Sri Lanka
    Traditional Knowledge Systems of India and Sri Lanka Papers presented at the COMPAS Asian Regional Workshop on Traditional Knowledge Systems and their Current Relevance and Applications 3-5 July 2006, Bangalore A. V. Balasubramanian and T. D. Nirmala Devi (eds) Compas series on Worldviews and sciences 5 Centre for Indian Knowledge Systems, Chennai September 2006 This book is the fifth in the Compas series on Worldviews and sciences Other volumes are: 1. Education Intra e Intercultural: Alternatives a la Reforma Educativa Neocolonizadora (Intra- and intercultural education: Alternatives for neo-colonialist educational reforms) Edition Plural, La Paz Bolivia 2006 Editors: Freddy Delgado B and Juan Carlos Mariscal C 2. Dialogo Intercultural e Interscientifico para el Fortalecimiento de las Ciencias de los Pueblos Indigenal Originarios (Intercultural and interscientific dialogue for strengthening the sciences of the original peoples in the Americas) Edition Plural, La Paz 2006 Editors: Freddy Delgado B and Cesar Escobar V. 3. African Knowledge and Sciences: a potential for endogenous development UDS / Compas / CTA 2006 Editors: David Millar, Stephan Bugu Kendie, Agnes Atia Apusiga and Bertus Haverkort 4. Moving worldviews: Reshaping sciences, policies and practices in Europe ETC / Compas, Leusden 2006 Editors: Bertus Haverkort and Coen Reijntjes 5. Traditional Knowledge Systems of India and Sri Lanka COMPAS / CIKS September 2006 Editors: A. V. Balasubramanian and T. D. Nirmala Devi 6. Endogenous development and bio-cultural diversity: the interplay between worldviews, globalisation and locality Compas / CDE (in preparation) 2 Title Traditional Knowledge Systems of India and Sri Lanka Publication September 2006 Editors A.V. Balasubramanian and T.D. Nirmala Devi Copy - editing Sashikala Asirvatham Editorial Assistance R.
    [Show full text]
  • Final Booklet 3
    # 49, Second Floor, Khanija Bhavan, Race Course Road, Bangalore - 560 001, India. Tel: 91 80 22352828 Email: [email protected] K a r n a t a k a T o u r i s m Land Bank Profiles A land blessed by Nature, Karnataka's rich heritage and unique culture make it a tourists' paradise. For the tourism industry, this translates into exciting opportunities to tap the immense potential it offers. I invite you to partner Karnataka's emergence as a global tourist destination and assure you of full support in such endeavors. B S Yeddyurappa Chief Minister, Govt. of Karnataka. Karnataka is renowned as the land of heritage sites, architectural spectacles, wildlife sanctuaries, idyllic beaches, art and culture. Another sobriquet that should be added to the list is the 'Land of Opportunities'. We eagerly invite investments across various tourism destinations as listed in this booklet. I assure you of my complete support as well as that of the Department of Tourism, Government of Karnataka in all your endeavors. Look forward to a mutually successful partnership. G Janardhana Reddy Minister for Tourism and Infrastructure Development, Govt. of Karnataka. Karnataka Tourism, Investment opportunities To make your investment decision and process easier, the Department of Tourism, Government of Karnataka has compiled this profiles of land available with the Government of Karnataka and private owners. We are especially keen to have you invest in some of the lesser developed but high potential destinations. The Director of Tourism and Joint Commissioner will be happy to hear from you and will provide you the required support and guidance.
    [Show full text]
  • An Introduction to Smarta – Smartism – Smartha Traditions
    An Introduction to Smarta – Smartism – Smartha Traditions. A. Background History About. Smartism is a sect of Hinduism that allows its followers to worship more than one god, unlike in sects like Shaivism and Vaishnavism, in which only Shiva and Vishnu are worshipped, respectively. Smartas, followers of Smartism, may actually worship one or more of the five main Hindu gods - Vishnu, Shiva, Ganesha, Surya and Shakti - as they are all considered equal. This practice is called panchayatana puja in Sanskrit. Smartism was founded by the Hindu spiritual guru, Adi Shankaracharya. The idea behind the founding of Smartism was to do away with certain practices in Hinduism, such as animal sacrifice; and also because Adi Shankaracharya believed in the concept of Advaita Vedanta, in which Brahman is the fundamental and highest reality above all gods. Smartism follows the Vedas, the sacred Hindu texts, and abides by orthodox Hindu philosophy. The sect recognizes God as both Saguna and Nirguna. God as Saguna is a representation of infinite nature and traits such as love, compassion and justice. God as Nirguna symbolizes pure consciousness, or Brahman, the creative principle and key concept of the Vedas, because they accept all the major Hindu Gods, they are known as liberal or nonsectarian. They follow a philosophical, meditative path, emphasizing man's oneness with God through understanding. *** most Hindus follow the Smarta/Smartha traditions, philosophies and practices. More Detail. Smartism is an ancient brahminical tradition reformed by Shankara in the ninth century. Worshiping five forms of God (Ganesha, Shiva, Vishnu, Durga, and Surya), this liberal Hindu path is monistic, nonsectarian, meditative and philosophical.
    [Show full text]