Appendix 1
Development Control Report
Planning Control Committee 14 August 2014 Index Planning Control Committee 14 August 2014 Item Page Application Address Proposal Recommendation No. No. No. 1 1 - 5 04/14/00494 32 Evans Avenue, Single storey rear To grant planning Allestree. extension to dwelling permission with house and alterations to conditions patio 2 6 - 12 04/14/00545 2 Cowley Street, Change of use from To grant planning Derby. (Victoria Hotel residential care home permission with Care Home) (Use Class C2) to conditions student accommodation (Sui Generis use) 3 13 - 17 02/14/00283 London Road Installation of 25m To grant planning Community Hospital, monopole, 6 x antennas, permission with London Road, Derby. equipment cabinets and conditions ancillary development 4 18 - 26 02/14/00268 75 St. Albans Road, Retention of change of To grant planning Derby. use of domestic permission with outbuilding to music conditions studio for teaching purposes (Use Class D1) 5 27 - 31 06/12/00685 The George Hotel, 15 Installation of 8 To grant planning Midland Road, Derby. replacement ground permission with floor double glazed conditions timber windows Committee Report Item No: 1
Application No: DER/04/14/00494 Type: Householder
1. Application Details Address: 32 Evans Avenue, Allestree
Ward: Allestree
Proposal: Single storey rear extension to dwelling house and alterations to patio
Further Details: Web-link to application documents: http://eplanning.derby.gov.uk/acolnet/planningpages02/acolnetcgi.gov?ACTION=UN WRAP&RIPNAME=Root.PgeDocs&TheSystemkey=96278 The application property is a 1930/40’s two-storey detached house of traditional brick and tile construction. It is located within a linear garden plot on the western side of Evans Avenue. The property’s rear garden abuts Allestree Park and the garden slopes down towards the park boundary. To the rear of the site there is a public footpath. The Park is allocated as an area of nature conservation interest and an area of public open space. The park boundary also defines the limits of the World Heritage Buffer Zone. The application site itself lies outside of these designated areas. The streetscene along Evans Avenue is generally comprised of individually designed two-storey dwellings of a similar size to the application property. Plot sizes within the locality are also fairly similar and there is a regular urban grain. Planning permission is sought to erect a single storey rear extension on the property. The extension would project approx. 6m from the rear elevation of the existing house and would be constructed of bricks and tiles to match the existing house. It would have a gabled roof which would measure approx. 4.2m at its highest point and approx. 2.9m to eaves height. The rear elevation and northern side elevation of the extension would be predominately glazed. At present the property is served by split level raised patio area which extends some 5m into the garden. As part of the application the applicant also seeks permission to extend this patio area towards the side garden boundaries and approx. 1.4m further into the garden.
2. Relevant Planning History: No planning history
3. Publicity: Neighbour Notification Letter - 2 This publicity is in accordance with statutory requirements and the requirements of the Council’s adopted Statement of Community Involvement.
4. Representations: Four letters/emails of objection have been received. The issues raised are summarised below:
1
Committee Report Item No: 1
Application No: DER/04/14/00494 Type: Householder
No properties along the lakeside have been extended – the extension will be highly visible from the Allestree Park Lake. The development is described as a single storey extension, however because the land slopes fairly steeply away from the house its floor level will be over 6 feet high at its end point in the garden. Loss of privacy - the majority of the building will be glass allowing views over neighbouring properties. The height of the extension will effectively make this a view platform over neighbouring properties. The extension will be out of character with the existing house. It will be very large and overbearing, and disproportionate for the size of the houses. The extension will result in loss of the open aspect of the neighbourhood and reduce the desirability of the area Overshadowing/loss of light
5. Consultations: DCC Archaeologist: The proposal will have no archaeological impact.
6. Relevant Policies: Saved CDLPR policies H16 Housing Extensions GD4 Design and the Urban Environment GD5 Amenity E4 Nature Conservation E23 Design The above is a list of the main policies that are relevant. Members should refer to their copy of the CDLPR for the full version or access the web-link. http://www.cartogold.co.uk/DerbyLocalPlan/text/00cont.htm Over-arching central government guidance in the NPPF is a material consideration and supersedes earlier guidance outlined in various planning policy guidance notes and planning policy statements.
7. Officer Opinion: Key Issues: In this case the following issues are considered to be the main material considerations which are dealt with in detail in this section. Design/Visual Impact The extension would not be visible from the front of the property and therefore would not impact upon the character streetscene along Evans Avenue itself. Although views of the application property are available from the public footpath to the rear, I do not feel the introduction of the extension would be detrimental to views from this path, nor do I feel the proposals would cause any undue harm to the character and appearance of the area. Over time the extension would be screened by the existing 2
Committee Report Item No: 1
Application No: DER/04/14/00494 Type: Householder
conifers along the rear boundary of the site, which would help to soften any visual impact. The proposal is considered to be a reasonable addition to the property and whilst it is of a fairly contemporary style with a large amount of glazing in the rear elevation, I am satisfied that it would not be harmful to the character and appearance of the dwelling, or the character and appearance of the wider locality. Accordingly the proposal would comply with saved policies E23, GD4 and H16 of the adopted CDLPR. Impact upon the amenity of neighbours: The main bulk of the extension would sit approx.1.7m from the common boundary with number 34 Evans Avenue. The neighbouring property has a small extension to the side and is separated from the application site by high level fencing and vegetation. There are no main habitable windows within the neighbouring property which will be impacted by the proposed extension. Taking into consideration the location and scale of the proposed extension I am satisfied that it would not have an adverse impact upon the residential amenities of number 34 through loss of light, or massing/overbearing impact. Given the minimal amount of glazing in the side elevation facing no. 34 and the existing boundary treatment, I am also satisfied that there would be no undue loss of privacy as a result of the extension, or the extended patio area. The extension would be situated approx. 6.5m from the common boundary with no. 30 Evans Avenue, a sufficient distance to ensure there would be no loss of amenity as a result of massing or loss of light. Whilst there is a large amount of glazing in the elevation facing towards number 30, given existing boundary treatment, vegetation screening and the distances involved, I do not feel the proposal would have a significant adverse impact upon the amenities of the occupiers of number 30 Evans Avenue to warrant refusal of the application. I am also satisfied that the modest increase in the raised patio area would not result in any direct overlooking. Overall it is considered that the proposals would reasonably comply with saved Local Plan policies GD5 and H16 in terms of the impact upon neighbour amenity. 8. Recommended decision and summary of reasons: To grant planning permission with conditions. Summary of reasons: The proposed development is considered to be acceptable in terms of its design, impact upon the character of the surrounding area and impact upon the residential amenity of surrounding properties. Conditions: 1. Standard 3 year time limit 2. Standard plan reference condition: 1:1250 site location plan 1:500 block plan Proposed elevations (drawing no: 1410/03) Proposed plan (drawing no: 1410/02)
3
Committee Report Item No: 1
Application No: DER/04/14/00494 Type: Householder
3. Condition controlling external materials of construction Reasons: 1. Standard reason for time limit 2. For the avoidance of doubt 3. In the interest of visual amenity…saved policies H16, GD4 and E23 Informative Notes: None required S106 requirements where appropriate: None required Application timescale: The target timescale for determination of this application expired on the 18th of June. Four objections have been received on this application and, as the application was received prior to the recent constitutional changes, promises were made to neighbours that the application would be considered by the Committee.
4
64.9m
Pump Overflow House
Gorses' Wood 570
Allestree Park 21 22 Committee Report Item No: 1 566
Application No: DER/04/14/00494 Type: Householder
562 15
68.9m 11a Lake 8
10
11 1
411 2 1 9
EATON CLOSE 7
18
10
Track 9
Weir 550
73.2m 13
Lake
28
401 25 548
DUFFIELD ROAD Weir EVANS AVENUE
LB 13 72.2m
1 24
25 76.5m LANE FORD
76.8m 16
19
14
546 2
40
1 15 25
30 RUSHUP CLOSE
38 Post 3
Path 39
SHORT AVENUE 37
391 2 36
20 FROGGATT CLOSE 16
37 10
1 20 80.2m 34
18 35 Crown copyright and database rights 2014 5 Ordnance Survey 100024913 12
42
DRIVE
AVENUE 537 6 22
1 SHORT 31
SPENBECK
15 536a 5 2 DRIVE MAIN AVENUE 4 24
2 MEDWAY 536
47 PADLEY CLOSE 27
16
El
Sub Sta 21
1 12
379
7 24
54 532
12
377a
44
377
10 57
42
83.5m 14
32 19 375
52 24 Committee Report Item No: 2
Application No: DER/04/14/00545 Type: Full
1. Application Details Address: 2 Cowley Street, Derby
Ward: Darley
Proposal: Change of use from hotel (Use Class C1) to student accommodation (Sui Generis use)
Further Details: Web-link to application documents: http://eplanning.derby.gov.uk/acolnet/planningpages02/acolnetcgi.gov?ACTION=UN WRAP&RIPNAME=Root.PgeDocs&TheSystemkey=96331 The application property is a two-storey Victorian former hotel/public house which is located at the junction of Cowley Street and Watson Street. The surrounding area is predominantly residential in character and is generally comprised of traditional terrace dwellings. In 2010 planning permission was granted to use the building as a residential care home. Although the internal conversion works were undertaken the use did not commence as the scheme was deemed financially unviable. Permission is now sought to covert the building into student accommodation which would effectively be a large scale house in multiple occupation. The accommodation would be privately run and would not be an official hall of residence operated by the University of Derby. The applicant could however apply to have the accommodation accredited by the University. The conversion would provide 13 en-suite bedrooms in total, together with associated communal facilities such as lounge/dining areas and kitchens. To the rear of the building there is an existing first floor roof terrace, the principle of which was granted in connection with an earlier application at the property as a residential care home. This area is decked and high level boundary treatment has already been installed around the perimeter of the terrace. The terrace also provides access to an external summer house. There are presently two vehicle accesses into the site, one from Watson Street and one from Cowley Street. In total 5 off-street car parking spaces are to be provided for use by future occupants. Areas for bin and cycle storage are also indicated on the submitted drawings.
2. Relevant Planning History: DER/02/10/00128 - Change of use from Hotel (Use Class C1) to Residential Care Home (Use Class C2) including alterations to elevations – conditionally granted – 28/05/2010 DER/07/09/00820 - Change of use from Hotel (Use Class C1) to Residential Care Home (Use Class C2) including alterations to elevations – refused – 17/11/2009 Reasons for refusal: ‘In the opinion of the Local Planning Authority, the proposed residential home for elderly residents fails to provide an adequate amount of private external 6
Committee Report Item No: 2
Application No: DER/04/14/00545 Type: Full
garden/amenity space for future occupiers of the proposed residential home for elderly residents to enjoy. In the absence of such provision, the proposal is contrary to policies H13 and GD5 of the adopted City of Derby Local Plan Review.’ ‘The proposed amendments to the existing windows and ornamental gables, by virtue of the proposed design, character, and appearance, are considered to have a detrimental impact on the character of the existing building; therefore, the proposal would be contrary to policies GD4 and E23 of the adopted City of Derby Local Plan Review.’
3. Publicity: Neighbour Notification Letter - 27 Site Notice – yes This publicity is in accordance with statutory requirements and the requirements of the Council’s adopted Statement of Community Involvement.
4. Representations: 12 letters/emails of objection have been received. The issues raised are summaries below: Amenity concerns - noise, loud music, partying, drinking, antisocial behaviour, increased traffic levels and general disturbance Parking concerns – the street is already extremely congested due to the lack of parking facilities for current residents. Additional accommodation will only exacerbate the problem. Highway safety concerns – during term time the levels of parking are dangerous and preclude swift access for fire services. As this is a major school route the high levels of parking make visibility for small children crossing the road difficult. Suggestion that the whole traffic situation in the Cowley St/Mackworth Rd/Merchant St are is addressed as part of any approval and any cost to deal with this be implemented as a S106/278 agreement with the developer. There should be a restriction on parking permits for future residents. There should be a barrier installed to prevent rat running between Ashbourne Road and Kedleston Road. There is already a lot of student accommodation within the area which does not always get filled. An objection has been received from Cllr Repton which raises the following issues; Concerns about the effect on the surrounding street scene of Victorian terraced properties, loss of amenity to local residents, increased noise, nuisance and parking problems in an already congested area.
7
Committee Report Item No: 2
Application No: DER/04/14/00545 Type: Full
5. Consultations: Highways DC: The proposed plan shows that there are 13 student rooms, with a total of 5 car parking spaces, the guidelines call for 1 space per 4 students. Therefore a minimum of 3 spaces should be provided for the students. The guidelines also call for 1 space per 2 members of staff. The junction of Cowley Street and Watson St is subject to a “no waiting at any time” order. Mackworth Road is has pay and display max 2hrs Mon- Sat 8am to 6pm (permit holders exemption) and no waiting (Mon-Fri 8am to 6pm). Should planning permission be granted a condition relating to the provision of cycle parking is recommended. Resources & Housing (HIMO): No response received Environmental Health: To be reported orally
6. Relevant Policies: Saved CDLPR policies GD1 Social Inclusion GD4 Design and the Urban Environment GD5 Amenity H13 Residential Development H14 Re-use of Underused Buildings E23 Design E25 Building Security and Measures T1 Transport Implications of New Development T4 Access, Parking and Servicing T6 Provision for Pedestrians T7 Provision for Cyclists T10 Access for Disabled People LE3 University District The above is a list of the main policies that are relevant. Members should refer to their copy of the CDLPR for the full version or access the web-link. http://www.cartogold.co.uk/DerbyLocalPlan/text/00cont.htm Over-arching central government guidance in the NPPF is a material consideration and supersedes earlier guidance outlined in various planning policy guidance notes and planning policy statements.
7. Officer Opinion: Key Issues: In this case the following issues are considered to be the main material considerations which are dealt with in detail in this section. The principle of development: The loss of the hotel/public house was assessed and accepted during the consideration of planning application reference: DER/02/10/00128. It was noted that
8
Committee Report Item No: 2
Application No: DER/04/14/00545 Type: Full
there are no specific policies relating to the protection of licensed hotels. Even if the public house use was assessed as a ‘community facility’ it would be difficult to resist its loss given that the area is still well served by public houses. This is an existing residential area situated within a highly sustainable location close to the City Centre. It is within walking distance to amenities such as shops and other services and is well served by public transport. Therefore, in principle, it is an acceptable location for residential development to be located. The site is also situated within the University Quarter of the City where policy LE3 of the CDLPR allows for development associated with the University. Whilst the proposed accommodation would not be an official hall of residence operated by the University, the addition of this type of bespoke student accommodation can help to relieve pressure on the existing housing stock in the area and ensure it remains available as general family housing. Saved policy H14 of the Local Plan states that the City Council will support the re-use of underused buildings for residential purposes, provided the scale and intensity of the use is sufficiently similar to the surrounding area, so that it would not detract from its general character or amenity. In this instance it is considered that the accommodation proposed would not have an adverse impact upon the overall character of the area. Issues in respect of residential amenity are considered below. Residential amenity issues A large number of objection letters received have expressed concerns about possible noise and anti-social behaviour from future residents of the conversion. This concern appears to be exacerbated by the presence of the first floor terrace and how this may be used. Issues relating to noise and social gatherings within the building or on the roof terrace are matters that should be dealt with through appropriate management of the building. To address this, the applicant has submitted a supporting statement which explains that a local accommodation management team would oversee day to day running of the residential accommodation. The team would enforce all terms and conditions on the tenancy agreement to make sure they are strictly followed. The statement details some of the measures proposed to reduce noise disturbance. Ultimately anti-social behaviour may result regardless of the manner in which the building is being occupied. To refuse an application based on the perceived increase in noise, disturbance and anti-social behaviour which local residents believe may occur would be difficult to substantiate. In assessing the acceptability of proposed residential use, I am also mindful that the building’s former as a public house/hotel could have resulted in far more noise and disturbance in terms of comings and goings than the residential use now proposed. In order to provide some comfort to nearby residents, it is considered appropriate to condition a management plan for use of the external roof terrace. It is also considered appropriate to condition that that the high level boundary treatment around to roof terrace remains in place, to prevent overlooking of neighbouring gardens. Should noise nuisance issues arise as a result of the proposed use, Environmental Health legislation can also be used to control such matters.
9
Committee Report Item No: 2
Application No: DER/04/14/00545 Type: Full
In terms of the internal spaces proposed, it is considered that the development would create a satisfactory living environment for future occupiers. Bedrooms are of an acceptable size and are adequately served by natural light. However it is recommended that the number of occupiers within the accommodation is restricted to no more than 13 by condition. The applicant would be required to get relevant consents from the City Council for use as the building as a House in Multiple Occupation. Overall, whilst I can understand the neighbour objections relating to possible noise and disturbance, I feel refusal on these grounds would be difficult to substantiate. Other legislation is also in place to deal with noise nuisance issues. I am satisfied that the proposed use would comply with saved policies H14, H13 and GD5 of the CDLPR in terms impact on neighbours and creation of a satisfactory living environment. Highway/parking issues: Policy T4 of the Local Plan seeks to reduce the level of parking provision in order to encourage people to use their cars less. It states that car-free developments will be encouraged, where appropriate. For this type of use Local Plan parking standards require that 1 parking space should be provided per 4 students - a minimum of 3 parking spaces in this instance. Whilst the application form mentions 2 members of staff the applicant has confirmed that this refers to a cleaner and a member of the management team who would not be based permanently at the property. Overall the 5 off-street parking spaces provided are considered to be acceptable based on Local Plan standards. Secure cycle parking and bin storage areas can be accommodated within the site and the Highways Officer has raised no objections to the proposals in terms of the level of off-street parking or other highway safety matters. It is noted that some of the surrounding streets are already subject to parking restrictions. Many of the neighbour objection letters cite the number of parking spaces as a concerns and it is understood that there are concerns about the level of on-street parking within the locality. Whilst these comments have been taken into consideration, based on the advice from the City Council’s Highways Officer and the highly sustainable location of the site, it is considered that a refusal could not be substantiated on these grounds. The proposal is considered to reasonably comply with saved policy T4 of the Local Plan Review. Conclusion: The site is within a highly sustainable location which is well served by public transport and is within walking distance of nearby shops and other amenities. It is acknowledged that the proposal would create a fairly intensive residential use, but this is not considered to be to the detriment of the general character of amenity of the locality. The proposals are also considered to be acceptable in terms of parking issues, provision of a satisfactory living environment and impact upon the amenity of neighbouring properties. On balance, it is considered that the proposed use generally meet the aspirations of the Local Plan policies set out within section 9 of this report and it is recommended that planning permission be granted.
10
Committee Report Item No: 2
Application No: DER/04/14/00545 Type: Full
8. Recommended decision and summary of reasons: To grant planning permission with conditions. Summary of reasons: The site is within a highly sustainable location which is well served by public transport and is within walking distance of nearby shops and other amenities. The proposed conversion would create a satisfactory living environment for future residents, without causing undue harm to the character of the area, or the amenity of neighbours and would be acceptable in terms of its impact upon highway safety and provision of off- street parking. Conditions: 1. Standard time limit condition 2. Standard plan reference condition 3. Condition restricting the number of residents to no more than 13 4. Condition controlling cycle parking on site 5. Condition controlling the provision of a disabled parking bay 6. Condition controlling the retention of the high level screening around the first floor roof terrace 7. Condition requiring a management plan for the roof terrace Reasons: 1. Standard reason for time limit 2. For the avoidance of doubt 3. To ensure that a satisfactory living environment is provided for residents and the ensure sufficient off-street parking is provided…in accordance with saved policies H13, H14, GD5 and T4 4. To promote sustainable transport….in accordance with saved policy T7 5. To ensure that an appropriate level of off-street parking and servicing are provided….in accordance with saved policy T10 6. To protect the amenity of neighbours…policy GD5 7. To protect the amenity of neighbours…policy GD5 Informative Notes: None required S106 requirements where appropriate: None required Application timescale: The target date for determination of this application expired on the 20th of June 2014. The application is brought to committee because of the number of objections received.
11
57 80
61.0m 34
84 45 24 43
PARK GROVE 57.3m 37
192
Newton's Walk 42 27 14a
SD 14 63.4m
186 41
Markeaton 19
Primary 60.4m
School 46
15 62
31
SM 5
SM
61 Trees 28
FS 36
27 FS
15
Tennis Court
51
The Jonty 59.1m
Farmer
16 49 50 (PH)
BROMLEY STREET
14 24 Newton's Walk
15
63.4m
57.6m 41
13
3 40 39
WHEELDON AVENUE
4 14
140 STATHAM STREET 179
54.3m 138
1 3 132 29
59.1m
29
58.5m 2
167 130
183
28
28 4 126
KEDLESTON ROAD 155 124 57.9m
Medical Centre 19
WHITE STREET
102 114 54.3m 17
112 18
16 143
FB Path
139 100 9
57.6m 98a
18 8
98
59.1m 129
LB 16
TCB 127 Committee Report Item No: 2 86 PO 84
Markeaton
5 Application No: DER/04/14/00545 Type:117 Full 82
47 115 Brook 57.6m 1 15 CLOSE
58 74
24 2
53.9m BROOKSIDE
63 105
Games Court 97
84 46
El Sub Sta
33
49 93
40
12 1 REDSHAW STREET 83
TIVOLI GARDENS 56.1m 58 36
23
72 46
39
37 34 8
Path (um)
LEYLAND El 7 2 Sub
STREET Leyland
34 Sta Court
29
207
24
2
70 1 21 LEYLAND GARDENS
COWLEY STREET 28
43 11
25
19 44 14
195 4 2
55.2m
1 56
33 16
WATSON STREET 2
13 20
54
18
185 34
175
FB
163
21 4
153 1
WALTER STREET 22 Whitecross House
PH
11
141
54.6m 12 1 Allotment Gardens 3
135 Playground 52 1
13 Track 9 15 11
Whitecross Gardens 61
2 63
121
41
43
42 16
Mundy Pleasure Ground 40 4
14 2 109 45 85
47
12
MACKWORTH ROAD 10
68
66
28 26
54.6m
Whitecross Nursery
School
52 Milner House73 to 79 50
17 19
21 23 71
25 WATSON STREET 27
Crown copyright and database rights 2014 15 to 9
Weir Ordnance Survey 100024913 7 to 1 LB Trees
54.3m Track
63 to 69 St Anne's Church 12 WHITECROSS STREET Weir 55 to 61
Markeaton Recreation Ground
Institute
1 to 11 SM
53
Weir 2 to 36
51
St Anne's Close
34
24
32 22 Weir Community 25 to 47
Centre
28
161 Britannia Mill 18
(University of Derby) 35 to 1
26 MACKWORTH ROAD 16
GISBORNEGREEN 97
Ps
Weir 35
LEAPER STREET TCB 17
54.3m 33 15
89
El Sub Sta
147
25 7
1 to 23 23
77
12 5
14 Brook Gardens 59
Trees
69 53
41
18 135 Markeaton Brook 2 13
SM
El Sub Sta 33 Shaws Green Bowling Green
MUNDY STREET
Merchants 31 54.3m Corner
1 33 32
1 to 18 30
23 MUNDY CLOSE
18
27
2 24
35 4 21 1
129 Bowling Green 36 2
12 33
34 El Sub Sta
25
119 11
55.8m
43
10
63 9 7
EATON COURT Allotment Gardens
SHAW STREET 1
19
11 to 32 to 11
48
107 69 1
MERCHANT STREET
Nunnery Court 95 76 13
53 University of Derby MARKEATON STREET
El 85 Sub Sta
44 58 66
7
77
59 109
52a 58a 126 68 75
54
65 Enterprise 119a 42 Centre 57.0m
1 56
17 to 27 59 El Sub Sta The 42 NUN'S STREET
54 57 1 to 10 Nunnery
Melton 6 Court BUCKLAND CLOSE 30
28
1 to 16 to 1
50 1 Nun's Bridge
138 73
20
47 65 to 71 to 65
56.4m 29 43
4
35 10
121
40 49b
27 Westgate
49a
1 to 8 to 1 38 15 Hotel
154
57 El Sub 15 to 9 Warehouse
Sta 1 to 28
17
20 to 24 to 20 32 1 Vicarage St Christophers Court 30a
Place 15a MILL STREET University of Derby 55.5m 30 PH
10 to 21 1 to 12 to 1
51 ASHBOURNE ROAD 37
24
29
22
22 Mill Gate 24
1
14 to 16 to 14
23
17 to 17
20 26
22
6 11
Ward Bdy 2
1
27 25
3 to 9
CR 31
27 7
35 29 55.2m BRICK STREET
9 25 28 11
10 10 67
27 8 21 25 6 4a 13 66b
17 4 15 2 66a
18 66
1
9
3 55.2m Headless Cross
7 (site of) School (dis) 5
3 65b
Surgery
FOWLER STREET 64
SLATER AVENUE
9 to 14
69 68 1
PH 1 1 8 TCB
3 61
FB Mast (Telecommunication) 70 60a
AshbourneCourt 71
53.9m FRIAR GATE
27 4 1
30 29
2 Committee Report Item No: 3
Application No: DER/02/14/00283 Type: Full
1. Application Details Address: London Road Community Hospital, London Road, Derby.
Ward: Arboretum
Proposal: Installation of 25metre monopole, 6 antennas, equipment cabinets and ancillary equipment
Further Details: Web-link to application documents: http://eplanning.derby.gov.uk/acolnet/planningpages02/acolnetcgi.gov?ACTION=UN WRAP&RIPNAME=Root.PgeDocs&TheSystemkey=96046 This application relates to an area of land within the London Road Community Hospital. The precise siting of the proposed telecommunication mast is toward the south-west corner of the Hospital site, near to Keble Close. The mast would be located upon an existing grass verge within a car park area, between parking bays. To the immediate north are hospital buildings; to the east is the Hospital car park, Hospital buildings and residential housing off Keble Close. To the south is further housing and to the west is Osmaston Road. The proposed development consists of the installation of a 25metre high monopole mast, 6 antennas with associated ground level equipment cabinets in order to offer high speed 4G mobile coverage for Vodafone Ltd and 02 Ltd networks. The proposed mast would be made of galvanised steel with a colour green finish. A 2.1m high close boarded compound fence, to enclose the monopole and cabinet equipment, is also proposed. The installation has been designed to be in full compliance with the requirements of the radio frequency public exposure guidelines of the International Commission on Non-Ionising Radiation Protection (ICNIRP), as expressed in the EU Council recommendation of 12 July 1999. As such, an ICNIRP certificate accompanies the application.
2. Relevant Planning History: DER/12/13/01416: Installation of solar panels and associated equipment. Granted - March 2014.
3. Publicity: Neighbour Notification Letters Site Notice This publicity is in accordance with statutory requirements and the requirements of the Council’s adopted Statement of Community Involvement.
4. Representations: A petition has been received from the Rosehill Infant and St James Junior Schools with 75 signatures registering their objection to the proposed development on the basis of ‘the impact on the well-being of individuals’ 13
Committee Report Item No: 3
Application No: DER/02/14/00283 Type: Full
5. Consultations: Highways DC: The monopole is located within a verge area, which isn’t clearly visible to traffic travelling along London Road. Furthermore, the location of this equipment isn’t in an area where it could cause obstruction. Access for maintenance can be easily achieved by parking in the parking bays. No significant highway implications.
6. Relevant Policies: Saved CDLPR policies GD5 Amenity T4 Access, parking and servicing (Monty format assistance needed) The above is a list of the main policies that are relevant. Members should refer to their copy of the CDLPR for the full version or access the web-link. http://www.cartogold.co.uk/DerbyLocalPlan/text/00cont.htm Over-arching central government guidance in the NPPF is a material consideration and supersedes earlier guidance outlined in various planning policy guidance notes and planning policy statements.
7. Officer Opinion: Key Issues: In this case the following issues are considered to be the main material considerations which are dealt with in detail in this section. At the present time a temporary telecommunications mast has been installed elsewhere in the Hospital car park, near to Osmaston Road. This is only a temporary measure and will be removed once a permanent mast structure is in place. Siting and design In terms of the appropriateness of the siting of the mast and associated equipment, the location would be acceptable in visual amenity terms, for the following reasons. The Hospital setting contains an array of structures, buildings, car parks and hard surfaced areas and the proposed mast would, in my opinion, assimilate reasonably well into such a built environment. I appreciate that the overall height of the mast would be 25metres and so would be visible and noticeable from some vantage points beyond the hospital curtilage, particularly along Keble Close and Osmaston Road. Yet, the lower sections of the structure would be obscured (seasonally) by perimeter deciduous trees scattered along Keble Close and part way along Osmaston Road. It is acknowledged that the proposal would be visible from differing aspects and at shorter distances the mast would be seen in context of the large Hospital buildings and surrounding infrastructure, but such a context is entirely acceptable. A colour finish of dark green is stated in the application form – which is acceptable. With regard to the application site in relation to nearby residential dwellings on Keble Close, when viewed from all directions only those properties facing North West (toward the car park) would overlook the proposed monopole, with the remaining properties only having views of the proposed mast from acute angles. I do acknowledge that the mast would be visible and prominent but the outlook for nearby residents would not differ greatly. The proposed siting has the additional benefit of replacing an existing 15m lighting column structure, rather than utilising an unused 14
Committee Report Item No: 3
Application No: DER/02/14/00283 Type: Full
grassed area. Also, the site in question would have no impact or remove any Hospital parking spaces within this car park, which is welcomed. Based on the above, the proposal would assimilate into the fabric of the hospital site reasonably well and is therefore acceptable on siting and appearance terms. Health related implications A petition has been submitted from a nearby local infant and junior school. The objection statement reads “we, the undersigned, are concerned parents, staff and governors who object to the application and the impact this may have on the well- being of individuals”. The possible health implications of the proposed development are clearly an issue of concern as reflected with the petition. In this regard, the advice contained within paragraph 45 of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) on this matter is very clear: Local planning authorities should not determine health safeguards if the proposal meets International Commission guidelines for public exposure. Moreover, case law (Harrogate (2004) before the Court of Appeal) has reinforced the requirement of local planning authorities to assess telecommunications proposals on siting and visual amenity grounds only. As the NPPF advises, if an application is certified to meet ICNIRP guidelines the local planning authority should not seek to challenge this. Highway considerations The application site is situated within a grass verge within a car park and the proposed mast would not affect vehicular visibility or impede any of the surrounding car parking spaces. The ancillary equipment cabinets would be positioned directly next to the mast and enclosed by the 2.1metre high close boarded fence that would not obstruct vehicle or pedestrian movement. Our Highways Development Control Team raises no objections and so on that basis, and in accordance with saved policy T4, the proposal is acceptable. Conclusion For the reasons given above, I consider that the siting and design of the equipment are consistent with local and national planning policy and do not feel that a comprehensive case could be put forward to offer grounds on which to object to the proposal. Given the slim-line design of the equipment proposed and the surrounding context, I am satisfied that the proposal would not have any unreasonable impact upon visual amenities or the surrounding environment. 8. Recommended decision and summary of reasons: To grant planning permission with conditions. Summary of reasons: The proposal has been considered against the City of Derby Local Plan Review and against the National Planning Policy Framework. It constitutes a telecommunications development that would improve the network in this part of the city without having a significantly detrimental effect upon local amenities. Conditions: 1. Standard condition 100 (approved plans) 2. Standard condition 03 (time limit)
15
Committee Report Item No: 3
Application No: DER/02/14/00283 Type: Full
3. Unique condition (removal of the existing temporary equipment within an agreed timeframe) Reasons: 1. Standard reason E56 2. Standard reason E52 3. Unique reason (to ensure a satisfactory overall development of the site and to safeguard visual amenities in the immediate area) Application timescale: The 8 week target date expired 25 April 2014 and it has been brought before committee given the level of local objection received. Officers have sought an extension of time for the application.
16
FB 106
Depot 62.2m 127
FB 129
110 112
Mortuary 123
WELLINGTON STREET 114 137
PH
141
116 FB 141a 12
10 118
129 143 8 49.9m to 7 145 6
129a Sloping masonry 5 147 4 1 TCBs
LONDON ROAD 3 114 120 PH 2 149 LITCHURCH STREET
PH 48.7m
El 42
Sub Sta 44
45 118 2
Hollybush House Hotel 4
1 to 12 153 to 157
124 El Sub Sta HPO Committee Report Item No: 3
Magee Court
26
13 to 20 to 13 to
Application No: DER/02/14/00283 Type: Full 21 126 159
163
128
130 130 REGENT STREET
Shelter 165 132
167 134
124a 61.4m London Road 138
Community Hospital 136 6
140
142 LEONARD STREET 134
1
St James'
Church of England
49.4m
Aided Infant School OXFORD STREET 148
55.8m The Dovedale
Day Hospital
1 170
3
2 LITCHURCH STREET
Post 4
8 Chy
6
4 2 18 Rauche Court 59.8m 2
20
180 23 Alder Walk 21 Arboretum 6
House 27
25 3
39
41
1 7
5 Tank
37 35
43
1 182 41
2 52.7m
25 33
3 15 23
13 5 1
Lambe Court 8 STREET OSMASTON ROAD
9
1 190
10 KEBLE CLOSE 2 54.9m 12 14 MORLESTON 24
34 12
11 32
45 31 33 ARBORETUM ST 47 Playground 35
9 TCB 31 60 Day Centre Oriel Court 19 62 29
LB
42 5 32 15
22 25 44
134 133
141 48
20 143
151 52 19 1
153 50 11 135 21
145 59.5m 54 155
139 86
149 84
159 76
147 137 74 51.5m 66
64 61.0m 157 56 161 163
171 173 13
181 183
25 165 Bowling Green 175
185
Works 34
169 32 179 30
177 189 28
167
187 191 22
193 ARBORETUM STREET 20 201 18 203 53.3m Centre Court 211 12 213 1
195
205 Posts 19 BLOOMFIELD CLOSE
215 199 5 209
219 207 1 197 Club
217 2
4
8 1 52.7m 3 ARBORETUMSQUARE
5
7 4
61.9m Ladygrove Cottages
62.2m Crown copyright and database rights 2014
SIDNEY STREET 1 5 El Sub Sta
62.2m Ordnance Survey 100024913
6
68 66
St James' 28 26 40 Aided
Junior School 10 42 Church of England 57.7m 44 27
46 29 56
17 54
61.3m 52 50
REGINALD STREET 206
7 Rosehill Infant 59.4m 208 and Nursery School Beechwood Court 60.7m
55.6m 1 to 6 to 1
1 to 14 212 The Bank
Surgery Arboretum
59.4m Committee Report Item No: 4
Application No: DER/02/14/00268 Type: Full
1. Application Details Address: 75 St Albans Road
Ward: Abbey
Proposal: Retention of change of use of domestic outbuilding to music studio for teaching purposes (Use Class D1)
Further Details: Web-link to application documents: http://eplanning.derby.gov.uk/acolnet/planningpages02/acolnetcgi.gov?ACTION=UN WRAP&RIPNAME=Root.PgeDocs&TheSystemkey=96030 This application seeks retrospective planning permission for the continued use of an outbuilding for business purposes in the form of music tuition. The site itself is located on the north side of St Albans Road at the junction with St Wystans Road. The application dwelling fronts St Albans Road and the outbuilding is located in land to the rear of the site, fronting St Wystans Road. The immediate surrounding locality is predominantly residential consisting mainly of semi-detached dwellings together with some detached properties. To the front of the application dwelling an area of hardstand driveway exists which provides off-street parking for up to 6 vehicles. The outbuilding structure adjoins the common boundary to No. 3 St Wystans Road. The single storey mono-pitched roof outbuilding has been used for a commercial business operation in the form of a music studio for the purposes of music related tuition. It consists of 3 teaching rooms/booths and 1 W.C. facility. The building measures approximately 9.1m in width, 4.7m in depth and 4m in height (at its highest point). Four velux windows exist in the roof above each tuition room. Sound insulation has been inserted into the fabric of the outbuilding during its construction. The accompanying Planning Statement states that the music studio operates Monday – Friday between the hours of 12:00 and 21:00 and on Saturday between the hours of 09:00 and 18:00. The studio is closed on Sundays and public holidays. Lessons are split into 30 minute slots with one tutor and one pupil occupying a room at any one time. The Planning Statement indicates the studio can facilitate a maximum of 54 pupils per day. No external alterations or extensions to the building are proposed and the application relates to the retention of use only.
2. Relevant Planning History: DER/11/11/01391: Erection of outbuilding (music studio). Granted conditionally - January 2012.
3. Publicity: Neighbour Notification Letters to surrounding residents Site Notice This publicity is in accordance with statutory requirements and the requirements of the Council’s adopted Statement of Community Involvement. 18
Committee Report Item No: 4
Application No: DER/02/14/00268 Type: Full
4. Representations: At the time of writing a total of 23 letters of support and 11 objections have been received. A petition of objection with 39 signatures has been submitted. The main points of objection include: The parking issues/congestion created on St Wystans Road due to the music studio Environmental issue of idling cars and exhaust fumes Infringement on privacy of neighbouring occupants. Safety issue of cars parked so close to junction The applicant knowingly submitted a false application DER/11/11/00391, to develop the studio “for the sole purpose of the applicant to play musical instruments”. Volume of parking is far greater than those quoted in the applicants supporting statement Opening hours constitute anti-social activity in a residential context Music/noise emitted from studio when velux windows open Music school offers no value to community Issues of private disputes between applicant and neighbouring property as a result of the unauthorised use of the music studio Large groups of people loiter outside studio The building is too large and out of keeping The application does not accord with the development plan, particularly policies GD5 – Amenity and LE1 – Education Uses. The proposal is harmful to the amenities of the area by way of loss of privacy, noise, pollution, traffic generation and car parking The music studio creates adverse impacts which significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits. The main points raised in the letters of support include Useful having music teaching in the local vicinity The music studio appears unobtrusive with little disturbance Music studio build bridges in the local community as it caters for people of all backgrounds regardless of colour, race, disability, age and gender Several local disabled residents rely on lessons at the school The studio is an ideal location and is accessible by foot or by bus Pupils live local and walk or cycle to the studio It provides a valuable service to the local community
19
Committee Report Item No: 4
Application No: DER/02/14/00268 Type: Full
Benefits of young adults/children attending lessons there Very convenient Large number of local residents have friends or families which attend The music studio has a small capacity and limited scope for further expansion Any educational service which could inspire the next generation of British musicians should be encouraged. The surrounding area is not entirely residential The music school is the only facility which caters for disabled learners.
5. Consultations: Highways DC: The site is located at the junction of St Albans Road and St Wystans Road, both of which are adopted highway and maintainable at public expense. At this location there are permit holders (which operate 8am to 6pm Monday to Friday) or 2 hours No return within 1 hour parking bays along both St Albans Road and St Wystans Road. The applicant has stated that there are currently six off - street car parking spaces. The exact parking arrangements for the new development will need to be clarified by the applicant. There is an existing 3.66 metre wide vehicular crossing over the footway of the public highway on St Albans Road at the front of the dwelling to allow access to and from the property. However, the City Council would normally require a minimum of 4.25 metres to allow 2 vehicles to safely pass each other at such locations. The development is close to frequent bus services which run along St. Albans Road and connect this area with Derby City Centre. It is therefore considered that the development is a sustainable one and is acceptable. The redundant vehicle access to and from the property on St. Wynstans Road shall be removed and reinstated as new footway at this location. This will be at the applicant’s expense. The existing protective entrance marking along the West kerb line of the junction of St. Albans Road and St. Wystans Road shall be extended such that the extended marking wholly covers the vehicle crossing for No. 75 St. Albans Road. This will be at the applicant’s expense. Environmental Services (Health – Pollution): The proposal involves the use of a music studio within a predominantly residential area. As a result, the development will inevitably cause a degree of noise disturbance. However, the building has been constructed with a reasonable degree of sound insulation but I would expect there to be a significant amount of noise break-out when the windows of the building are open. Based on the information available and due to the proximity of residential buildings, I would state that I have some concerns regarding the potential for nuisance to occur, but it may be possible with good management practices to minimise nuisance. Members should note that the site and building has been inspected by an officer of the Noise & Pollution Team in conjunction with the case officer to assess the building when in operation. A member of the Noise & Pollution Team will be at the meeting.
20
Committee Report Item No: 4
Application No: DER/02/14/00268 Type: Full
6. Relevant Policies: Saved CDLPR policies GD1 Social Inclusion GD5 Amenity EP13 Business and Industrial Development in Other Areas LE1 Education Uses L11 New Community Facilities T4 Access, Parking and Servicing T7 Provision for Cyclists The above is a list of the main policies that are relevant. Members should refer to their copy of the CDLPR for the full version or access the web-link. http://www.cartogold.co.uk/DerbyLocalPlan/text/00cont.htm Over-arching central government guidance in the NPPF is a material consideration and supersedes earlier guidance outlined in various planning policy guidance notes and planning policy statements.
7. Officer Opinion: Key Issues: In this case the following issues are considered to be the main material considerations which are dealt with in detail in this section. The impact of the proposal on the residential amenities of neighbouring properties Traffic generation / parking issues Firstly, it should be made clear that the outbuilding studio itself was granted planning permission in 2011. See section 2 of this report. In the intervening period the owner has materially altered, beyond incidental use, the function of the premises from a domestic ancillary use to a commercial / business music tuition use, hence the submission of an application to regularise matters. The site of the proposal is not allocated for any particular use in the CDLPR. Policy LE1 allows for the development of educational facilities provided that they are well related to the public transport network, a travel plan is in place to encourage the use of non-car modes of transport, the proposal is in keeping with the general scale, and character of the surrounding area and, in the case of development in residential areas, the site or building is sufficiently large and self-contained to prevent unacceptable levels of disturbance to nearby properties. In this regard, the studio does not contain any specified waiting area for visitors within the building itself. Consequently, on some occasions waiting occurs outside the premises. Yet, this does not mean the site or building is insufficiently sized or not self-contained, as the outbuilding accommodates the music tuition activity adequately and provides some off-street parking for tutors and pupils. Policy L11 of the Local Plan is also of relevance to this particular application. The Policy allows for new community facilities provided the proposal is well related to the population it is intended to serve. In this instance, the facility’s catchment covers the local area and the city as a whole and, although a city centre location would perhaps have been preferable, the application site is relatively well served by public transport, 21
Committee Report Item No: 4
Application No: DER/02/14/00268 Type: Full
particularly along St Albans Road. Therefore, in principle, this is a suitable location for such a facility. Whilst is terms of sustainability, the location may be acceptable, one of the key issues to be considered is the impact of the proposal upon the residential amenity of neighbouring properties. Policy GD5 of the CDLPR states that new development will only be granted where it would not cause unacceptable harm to the amenity of nearby areas. Residential amenity The issue of noise disturbance from the playing of amplified and non-amplified music in this particular context is raised by a number of objectors. In taking into account the nature of the music creation proposed, involving live instruments and amplified music a site assessment with the Environmental Health officer was undertaken. The site visit confirmed that when the velux windows and main entrance door are closed then music related noise (a piano was being played) is not audible from outside the premises on St Wystans Road. Yet once the velux window to the room was opened then the playing of music was audible and noticeable from St Wystans Road, when standing directly opposite the music studio. Therefore, a mitigating condition which requires non-opening velux windows to be installed and the existing velux windows to be removed could remedy the issue of sound dispersal from the premises. This would largely address noise emissions from the music studio outbuilding. In saying this I understand that no noise nuisance complaints have been made to Environmental Health since the music studio has commenced use. Given that sound insulation measures have already been inserted into the fabric of the building, together with the non-opening window condition, this should secure adequate noise attenuation from the studio when music is played / performed. Importantly a suitable condition prohibiting the making of new window/door openings in all elevations of the building and roof would, in this instance, be justified. Whilst I note that the applicant wishes to use the music studio from 12:00 until 21:30 Monday – Friday, I feel that there should be some further restrictions in the evening, when the occupiers of nearby residential properties can expect a reasonable level of privacy. Therefore, I suggest that restricting the use to 12:00 - 19:30 Monday - Friday would be more acceptable, as a compromise. The use of the studio on Sundays and Bank Holidays would be prohibited through a relevant condition and Saturday operating hours are stated as 09:00 – 18:00. The neighbour objection letters suggest that the occupiers of nearby dwellings have experienced anti-social behaviour from pupils, tutors and parents gathering outside of the application site and close to the frontage of No.3 St Wystans Road. It is considered that the objections regarding people congregating outside of the unit or peering into front elevation windows need to be addressed through appropriate management of the facility by the owners. In terms of increased comings and goings to and from the music studio building, it is anticipated that there would be no more than 3 pupils on site at any one time, with three members of staff present. Taking into account the entire area of the outbuilding to be used by the educational facility, and the frequency of people arriving and departing for music lessons, it can be viewed that the proposal does result in an increased number of people accessing the site at different times of day and evening, 22
Committee Report Item No: 4
Application No: DER/02/14/00268 Type: Full
over a six day period. In this case, the business use of an outbuilding in a residential curtilage is not in itself unusual as residential outbuildings do undergo conversions for commercial purposes. Here, the 3 teaching rooms do not, in my opinion, make the use excessive in its scale of business operation. The immediate neighbouring property at No.3 St Wystans Road is affected by the general activity of the music studio, due to its close proximity. Those neighbouring residents have expressed serious concern relating to noise disturbance, traffic and pedestrian disruption directly attributable to the music studio, the hours of operation constituting anti-social activity and the potential continued expansion of the business if granted permission. In response, the noise disturbance matter when windows and doors are open can be controlled through a suitable condition, the hours of operation can also be limited and any business expansion is essentially limited by the one to one nature of tutorials occurring in no more than 3 rooms at any one time. As for traffic and pedestrian disruption, this issue is discussed below. Traffic generation / parking issues The site is located at the junction of St Albans Road and St Wystans Road - both residential streets. St Albans Road is a busy thoroughfare road while St Wystans Road is a quieter cul-de-sac street, with on-street restrictions limiting parking to a maximum of two hours for non-residents. The application property benefits from a large front driveway which the applicant claims to accommodate up to 6 vehicles, to be used by teachers and pupils. I note the comment in the Highways DC consultation response that ‘the exact parking arrangements for the new development will need to be clarified’. In short, there is no travel plan and no parking management associated with the continued use of the music studio. Consequently, ad-hoc on-street parking along St Wystans Road occurs at different times of the day and evening which is attributable to the lesson drop-off / collection scenario created by the music studio. Indeed, a number of objectors raise the issue of hazards stemming from roadside parking, particularly given the predominance of pupils being dropped off and picked up. In addition, a number of objectors stress the problems of restricted access to St Wystans Road caused by vehicles being parked outside the entrance to the studio. In truth, the precise number of pupils attending by foot, cycle, bus and car can only be speculated. Given the nature of the use of the outbuilding for teaching purposes people do (and will) park on St Albans Road and St Wystans Road as a result of people arriving and departing by car to visit the application site. No mitigating conditions can control or restrict ad-hoc on-street parking, cars obstructing driveways, the sound of motorised engines, car doors slamming, noise of voices of people outside the studio, parents waiting in their vehicles with car windows opened. Even if the above factors do occur it cannot be contended that continuous disruption occurs at all times while lessons take place. Any disturbance is likely to be dispersed according to the number of people attending and departing by car at any given time during operating hours.
23
Committee Report Item No: 4
Application No: DER/02/14/00268 Type: Full
Third party objections state that at certain times on-street parking intensifies to cause congestion and inconsiderate parking in this residential locality. Context is obviously important and it appears that any increase in on-street parking occurs is confined to this southern end of St Wystans Road near to the music studio. Nonetheless, there is little to suggest that the studio use would cause excessive harm to highway safety or vehicular - pedestrian conflicts or continued excessive on- street parking. The driveway area of the application dwelling can be utilised for drop off / collections for 2 or 3 cars at any time, the site is very close to public transport links and pupils can access the studio by means of walking and cycling. While neighbour objections highlight concerns about the level of on-street parking within the locality, given the varied levels of additional traffic generated in a concentrated part of St Wystans Road and St Albans Road the resulting highway impact could not be deemed to be significantly adverse as to warrant the refusal of the application on highways grounds. On the basis of the above, a recommendation to grant conditional planning permission is given.
8. Recommended decision and summary of reasons: To grant planning permission with conditions. Summary of reasons: The proposal to retain the use of this outbuilding as a music studio for teaching purposes would be acceptable in accordance with the policies stated in section 6 of the report. It is acknowledged that the proposal would intensify the use of the site in this residential context but this is not considered to be excessively detrimental to the general character of the area or the residential amenities enjoyed in the immediate locality. The proposal is considered to be acceptable in terms of parking issues and impacts upon residential amenity. On balance, it is considered that the continued use would meet the provisions of Local Plan Policies.
Conditions: 1. Standard condition 100 (Approved plans) 2. Unique condition (Hours of operation: Monday - Friday 12:00 -19:30 Saturday 09:00 – 17:00 Closed Sunday/public holidays) 3. Unique condition (Requiring non-opening velux windows to be installed and no additional doors or windows to be installed) 4. Unique condition (use of driveway frontage for staff/visitors only) 5. Unique condition (retention of sound insulation measures within the fabric of the building) 6. Unique condition (requiring re-instatement of vehicle access and provision of on-site cycle parking to serve the use)
24
Committee Report Item No: 4
Application No: DER/02/14/00268 Type: Full
Reasons: 1. Standard reason (E04) Avoidance of doubt 2. Standard reason (E07) Protection of residential amenity 3. Standard reason (E07) Protection of residential amenity 4. Standard reason (E09) Satisfactory development 5. Standard reason (E04 and E07) For the avoidance of doubt and the protection of residential amenity 6. Standard reason (E19) Traffic safety and to facilitate the provision of cycle parking Application timescale: The 8 week application expired on 5 May 2014.
25
79.8m 33
41 53 80.8m 45
37
43 54 55 59
39 67
36 34
CALIFORNIA GARDENS
80
Fire Station
58
384
52 50
Mast (Telecommunication)
1 to 5 36 46 56 66 Training Centre El Sub Sta 6 to 11 76 Cannock Court
65 STOCKBROOK ROAD 78.7m
64 50
TCB 389 Post 47 396 57
Tennis Courts
12 to 16 to 12 Posts Ps 61a
Post 17 to 20 92
400 63 43
KINGSWAY
401 62
38
77.1m 31 410 Posts
Shelter 79.8m
75
TCB 71
RADCLIFFE DRIVE
79
418 413 43
LB 104
26
50
61 21
89
1 2 UTTOXETER NEW ROAD 423 Committee Report Item No: 4
420 Application35 No: DER/02/14/00268 Type: 74
Full 116 49
14
Allotment Gardens 118a 79.5m 72a
40 11
78
101
118 42
BEDFORD STREET
435 33
37
ST WYSTAN'S ROAD 73
434 73.4m
30
83 34
103
78.4m 1
30 2
1
437 126
25 135 147
Ward Bdy 159 123
CR 446
161
19 18 447 111 71.8m
ST ALBANS ROAD
2 20 173
76.9m
ST CUTHBERT'S ROAD 99
142 132 12 71.5m 113 13
11 71.1m 122 152
457 112
6
Littleover
162
185 136
5
102
10 85 Brook
Brook
12 Littleover 172 MANOR ROAD
83 123 467 6 92
TCB 1 69.6m 21
77
71.7m
2 182 75 82
31 2
71 20 37
21 80
LB 47 61 11 ST ALBANS
ROAD 31 72.7m 76 6 Rykneld BEDFORD CLOSE
74.3m 73.9m 1 1
Sinks 72
76.6m
28
26
68 El Sub Sta 28 1
CR
40 14 11
3 7
54 42 Community Centre PC
30 1 to 6 DALTON AVENUE 2 6 ST DAVID'S PC CLOSE Rykneld Recreation Ground
77.7m ST SWITHIN'S
34
7 to 18 to 7 1
2 El Sub Sta
Bishop's Green 4
2
40 38
46 9 CLOSE 76.8m Gas Governor Playground 5 11
39 7 44 24 to 19
4
18 2 16 8 6 Trees 1 10 Posts
CLOSE
LOUVAIN ROAD 14 NAMUR
CRECY CLOSE 60 58 4
15 12
6
9
2
4
1 11 Crown copyright and database rights 2014
2 42
Ordnance37 Survey 100024913
CONSTABLE LANE PH
36
34 12
MANOR AVENUE
5 to 29 to 5 35
24 22
1 17
2 38 34 40 10 36 26 El Sub Sta 26
79.2m 28 10 21 24 ST QUENTIN CLOSE
12
26 Committee Report Item No: 5
Application No: DER/06/12/00685 Type: Full
1. Application Details Address: The former George Hotel, 15 Midland Road, Derby.
Ward: Arboretum
Proposal: Installation of replacement ground floor double glazed timber windows
Further Details: Web-link to application documents: http://eplanning.derby.gov.uk/acolnet/planningpages02/acolnetcgi.gov?ACTION=UN WRAP&RIPNAME=Root.PgeDocs&TheSystemkey=93212 The former George Hotel is sited on a corner plot close to the Midland Station and it fronts both Midland Road and Carrington Street. The property is not a listed building but lies within the Railway Conservation Area. The building is presently undergoing renovation to bring it back into use as a restaurant and this work has been on-going for some time. The building is of two storeys with a low pitched roof. It is rendered and the first floor windows are sliding sash units. The ground floor has ornate windows with stone heads, comprising 3 on Midland Road and 4 on Carrington Street. The corner of the building accommodates a different style ground floor window and there are entrance doors on both sides. The ornate windows on the ground floor have a horizontal emphasis in contrast to the sash windows above. The existing ground floor windows are divided vertically into 3 sections, with the central section including an oval leaded light with stained glass. The upper quarter of each window has leaded lights, opening inwards. The larger panes and the oval decorative sections are non-opening. There is a decorative detail within the glazing which is the logo of the former ‘Offiler’s’ brewery. The ground floor corner window is a similar proportion to the first floor sash windows, but is divided into 4 sections, the upper two being leaded and occupying the top quarter of the window. Above this particular window is a pediment. Information supplied by the applicant states that the 8 ground floor windows with the oval decorative section are not original features but date from the 20th Century. Members should note that this application originally sought planning permission to remove the ground floor windows and install a range of sash windows to sit beneath the first floor sash windows. Amended plans of 11 September 2012 illustrate that arrangement. The application has been amended again and it is the applicant’s intention to remove the ground floor single glazed windows and install timber double glazed replacements. Negotiations have been on-going about the proposed replacement windows and I understand that the applicant has commissioned the production of the new timber units. Clear glazed units are proposed and it is proposed to paint the frames brown. Unfortunately the existing ground floor windows have all been damaged at some point in the recent past and this is regrettable given the historical associations of the decorative detail.
27
Committee Report Item No: 5
Application No: DER/06/12/00685 Type: Full
As part of the revised submission the agent has included details of proposed replacement doors on the Midland Road elevation. The agent has stated that the proposed doors would be identical in size and thickness to the existing with glazed panels being introduced in lieu of wooden panels.
2. Relevant Planning History: The upper floor of this building is being converted to residential accommodation and that, together with other small scale extensions and alterations, were granted planning permission in 2012. The proposed conversion of the ground floor to a restaurant is a permitted change.
3. Publicity: Neighbour Notification Letter Site Notice Statutory Press Advert This publicity is in accordance with statutory requirements and the requirements of the Council’s adopted Statement of Community Involvement.
4. Representations: One objection has been received which states that the existing ground floor windows relate to the Offiler’s brewery that are unique in so far as that no other former Offiler's public house still retains the company windows. They represent an important piece of the city's brewing heritage as Offiler's was the last, large scale brewery in the city, before closing in 1966.
5. Consultations: CAAC: Object and recommend refusal as the original proposal to install sash windows to the ground floor compromises the integrity of the conservation area. The existing windows have historic interest and should be retained and repaired. Built Environment: The former George Hotel is a corner building to Midland Road and Carrington Street. Map evidence highlights that it was built prior to 1855, around same time as Railway Cottages and Midland Place. It is likely that sash window were original nineteenth Century window arrangement. In some cases this is what we would wish to pursue. However, vital new information has been found on the early 20th Century windows, that are to be removed, that make them more significant than originally thought and an important part of the evolution of the building. Therefore, in light of this information the windows should be repaired and retained. The windows do look to be rare survivals showing the logo of the Offiler’s Brewery which produced beer in Derby until the 1960's. A member of the Built Environment Team will also be on-hand at the meeting to advise.
28
Committee Report Item No: 5
Application No: DER/06/12/00685 Type: Full
6. Relevant Policies: Saved CDLPR policies E18 Conservation Areas E23 Design The above is a list of the main policies that are relevant. Members should refer to their copy of the CDLPR for the full version or access the web-link. http://www.cartogold.co.uk/DerbyLocalPlan/text/00cont.htm Over-arching central government guidance in the NPPF is a material consideration and supersedes earlier guidance outlined in various planning policy guidance notes and planning policy statements.
7. Officer Opinion: Key Issues: In this case the following issue is considered to be the main material consideration. The impact of the proposed window replacements in the wider context of the Railway Conservation Area and whether or not the proposed replacements would preserve or enhance the special character of the area. Negotiations have been on-going with the applicant to pursue the repair and retention of the existing ground floor windows. Unfortunately the existing window units are damaged and the applicant has elected to replace the windows with timber double glazed units. Therefore, the size, form and materials of construction of the windows would be consistent with the existing windows although the detail within the glazing of the existing windows would not be replicated. In this case I am satisfied that the proposed replacement windows, by virtue of their size, form and materials of construction, would preserve the character of the wider area and, in accordance with the provisions of the Planning (Listed Buildings & Conservation Areas) Act and saved policy E18 of the adopted CDLPR, this is the principal policy test. It is regrettable that glazing detail would be lost but this does not lead me to conclude that the proposed works would be unduly detrimental to the special character of the wider area. I raise no objections to the design and form of the proposed replacement entrance doors to the Midland Road frontage and these would form part of the overall programme of works for the building. I understand that the applicant’s agent will be providing information about the replacement windows before the meeting and any relevant information will be provided to members in the form of oral updates or supplementary information. 8. Recommended decision and summary of reasons: To grant planning permission with conditions. Summary of reasons: The proposal would preserve the special character of the Railway Conservation Area.
29
Committee Report Item No: 5
Application No: DER/06/12/00685 Type: Full
Conditions: 1. Time Limit. 2. Revised Plans. Reasons: 1. E56 – Standard time limit reason. 2. E04 – For the avoidance of doubt. Informative Notes: None Application timescale: The applicant’s agent has agreed to an extension of time to accommodate the additional time that has gone into the resolution of this application.
30
Albion
Street Mill Fleam 48.7m STATION APPROACH Depot
Copecastle Derby Junction
Square Depot 2 to 6 to 2 PRIDE PARKWAY FB 45.1m Car Park 44.8m
Depot Devonshire Walk
48.3m Westfield Centre 49.4m Car Park Track
44.8m 48.4m
SIDDALS ROAD Works STATION APPROACH
Castle Walk 49.4m
Works
Castle 48.5m Nursery School 176 COPELAND STREET Red Cross Depot Path (um) 176 El Sub Sta Headquarters
48.2m Works 2 Copeland Walk Boro Const & Ward Bdy
Factory River Derwent Works
4 50.1m WRVS Headquarters LB
STATION APPROACH Club 13 to 18 48.5m SIDDALS 218 to 220
ROAD
48.2m
Track 1 to 6 19 to 24 Path and Cycle Track
Castle House CR Subway
Warehouse Gas Gov
201 1
3 STREET Works 203 PRIDE PARKWAY PH Amber House
48.3m
TRAFFIC
1 t0 2 FB
MP 128 2 18
to NEW STREET JOHN STREET 30 Hopper Works
57.0m
17 11
9 to 14 Pump House HOPE STREET Warehouse CANAL STREET
LIVERSAGE 60 47.9m
1 El Sub Sta 15
PH
Nightingale
30
62 to 66 to 62 STREET 3 Mews
53.3m
Warehouse 36
CR 8
Tennis Court 47.9m
El Sub Sta 13
Warehouse
Tennis Courts 48.4m Wyvern House
4
23 2
52.4m
1 49
26 Liversage Walk S Gantry
LIVERSAGE PLACE
33 47.5m 50
PH Liversage Ward Bdy Warehouse S Gantry 83b Court 6
S Gantry Works Swimming Pool CALVERT STREET 47.9m 6a 73
5
6b 43 61 81 85a 1 9 83 40
87a CARRINGTON STREET 63 85 89 Sheffield Place 1
87 Liversage
4
7
LB Almshouses Works 8 10
Cycle Track and Path 8 53 Car Park
The Carrington Club 11 48.4m
48.5m 107 LIVERSAGE ROAD
LONDON ROAD 13
107a
5 7 50 15 LEEDS WAY PLACE Car Park
Florence 100
Committee Report Item No: 5 Court 65 TCBs
RAILWAY TERRACE
BRADSHAW Florence 1 Devonshire 12 to 1 Nightingale 109 Club Pride Park House Statue Application No: DER/06/12/00685 Type: Full PARK STREET
115 Holy Trinity
El Sub Sta Pentecostal 7 Church MIDLAND PLACE
15 FB CANAL STREET The Derby College Princess 47.5m Health Anne Centre 21 Training Community 7
Centre Centre Wellington Crescent 28 50.0m
TRINITY STREET 22
London Road 12 Wilderslowe PH
47.9m Community Hospital 11 Tower
Public Health 1 WELLINGTON STREET PH Laboratory
24
Nurses Training Unit 25 Nurses' Home and
121a CARRINGTON STREET 119 45
26 47.5m 27 PH Derby Midland
28 Station PARK STREET
Hotel Queen Victoria Statue 121 119
El Sub Sta
ROUNDHOUSE ROAD School of Nursing Shelter
32 100
Queen's OSMASTON ROAD Hall 48.2m Wilderslowe 62.8m WELLINGTON STREET
El 96 House Sub 125
Sta 2 121 Aston Court Shelter 49.2m Hotel
123 47.9m Queen's Hall
98 21a
Methodist Mission Hotel 100 Wilderslowe Court WELLINGTON 47.9m STREET Depot
21
FB 106 20 2
El Sub Sta Depot 47.7m 62.2m 127 17 FB 129
110 Midland Hotel 16
George 112 War Hotel Memorial Mortuary 123 WELLINGTON STREET MIDLAND ROAD
15 114 137
14 HUDSON WAY PH 14a 47.8m
141 Churnet
116 FB 141a House 12
10 110 118
129 CARRINGTON STREET 143 8 49.9m to 7 Posts 145 6
129a Sloping masonry 5 147 Car Park 4 1 TCBs LONDON ROAD 3
7 114 120 PH 2 149 LITCHURCH STREET
PH 48.7m
El 42 Sub Sta 44 NELSON STREET
Rutland House
45 118 2
Hollybush House Hotel 4 112 1 to 12 153 to 157
124 El Sub Sta HPO Midland House Head Post Office 8 Pride Park
Magee Court
26
13 to 20 to 13 to
21 126 159 163
NOBLE
128 130
130 REGENT STREET
Shelter 165 STREET 132 167
ESS 134
124a 61.4m London Road 138
Community Hospital 136 6 140 2 El Sub Sta
175 Posts
142 LEONARD STREET 134 Hotel 1 47.9m NELSON ST Crown copyright and database rights 2014 47.2m Ordnance Survey 100024913
Tank
St James' El Sub Sta Church of England
49.4m HULLAND STREET
Aided Infant School OXFORD STREET 48.8m 148
55.8m The Dovedale 31 Day Hospital Car Park
156
1 Posts 170
3
TCB 160
2 LITCHURCH STREET
Post Ward Bdy
4 MP O
8 Chy
CR
6
4 2 18 Rauche Court Government 59.8m 2 St Andrew's House
20 Offices
180 23 Alder Walk 21
Arboretum 6 27
House Shelters
25 3
39
41
1 7 48.8m
5 Tank BLOOMFIELD ST 48.5m
London Road 37 35 Posts
Junction
43
1 182 Shelter 41
2 52.7m
25
33
15 3 23
13 5 1
Lambe Court 8 STREET OSMASTON ROAD
9
1 190
10 KEBLE CLOSE 2 54.9m 12 14 Tank MORLESTON 24
34
12 CLIFTON STREET
11 32
45 31 Derwent Park 33 ARBORETUM ST 47 Playground 35 Navigation 9 TCB 31 60 House Day Centre Oriel Court 19 62 29 Tank
LB 42 5
32 15 L Twr
22 25 44 El Sub Sta
134 133
141 48
20 143
52 Gas Governor 19 151 1
153 50 11 135 21
145 49.2m 59.5m 54 155
139 86
149 84 76 LONDON ROAD
159
147 137 74 51.5m 66 64 48.5m
OSBORNE STREET 61.0m 157 56 161 163
171 173 13
181 183
25 165 Bowling Green 175
185 Works 34
169 32 15 30 13 179
177 189 28 167
19
187 191 22
193 11 ARBORETUM STREET 20 201 18 203 BARLOW STREET 53.3m Centre Court 211 12 213 16 1 Gantry
195 CENTRE
205 Posts 19 BLOOMFIELD CLOSE COURT
215
10 199 5 209
219 207 9 1 197 Club 48.7m 217 2 Bateman
4
8
8 1 Court 52.7m 3 ARBORETUMSQUARE
5
7 4
61.9m Ladygrove Cottages 62.2m
52.7m Signal Box
SIDNEY STREET 1 5 El Sub Sta 62.2m
6 El Sub Sta
68 66
St James' 28 26 40 El Sub Sta Aided
Junior School 10 42 Church of England 57.7m 44 27 46 29
SL
56 54 Works
Track Research Laboratory
61.3m 52
BATEMAN STREET 50
52.8m
REGINALD STREET 206
7 Rosehill Infant 59.4m 208 and Nursery School Beechwood Court 49.4m 60.7m
55.6m 1 to 6 to 1
1 to 14 212 The Bank
Surgery Arboretum
Bowling Green 59.4m
LITCHURCH 47 Derby City Council Delegated Decisions Made Between 01/06/14 and 31/07/14
Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 11/12/01327/PRI Advertisement consent Birchover House, Church Retention of non illuminated banner sign Refuse 06/06/2014 Lane North, Darley Abbey, Planning Derby, DE22 1EU Permission
11/12/01400/PRI Local Council own Raynesway View, Foyle Retention of plant and erection of guard rail to Granted 09/07/2014 development Reg 3 Avenue, Chaddesden, flat roof Conditionally Derby, DE21 6TZ
11/12/01464/PRI Outline Planning Land rear of 79 Residential development Invalid - Finally 18/06/2014 Permission Palmerston Street and 80, Disposed of Fairfield Road, Derby, DE23
01/13/00043/PRI Full Planning 141 Pastures Hill, Front extension to dwelling (sitting room and Granted 04/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 porch) and alterations to roof to form additional Conditionally 7AZ storey (4 bedrooms, bathroom and en-suite)
02/13/00159/PRI Full Planning 1 Larkhill Crescent, Sinfin, Two storey extension to dwelling house Granted 15/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE24 9PP (lounge,w.c.,sitting room, two bedrooms and Conditionally en-suite)
02/13/00173/PRI Local Council own Derby Golf Club, Retention of alterations to changing room and Granted 04/07/2014 development Reg 3 Shakespeare Street, conversion of store room to shop (Use Class A1) Conditionally Sinfin, Derby, DE24 9HD
03/13/00242/DCC Advertisement consent Lighting columns on Display of banners on 29 lighting columns Granted 01/07/2014 Morden Green and Prince Conditionally Charles Avenue. Mackworth, Derby
03/13/00243/DCC Advertisement consent Lighting columns on Display of banners on 19 lighting columns Granted 01/07/2014 Kedleston Road, Derby Conditionally
04/13/00393/PRI Full Application - Bothe Cottage 9 St. Retention of replacement windows on front Granted 08/07/2014 Article 4 Edmunds Close, Allestree, elevation Conditionally Derby, DE22 2DZ
Page 1 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 05/13/00554/PRI Full Planning Land at west end of Erection of 10 dwelling houses and associated Refuse 06/06/2014 Permission Wordsworth Avenue, works Planning Sinfin, Derby Permission
05/13/00566/PRI Advertisement consent 28 Humbleton Drive, Display of internally Illuminated fascia sign Granted 09/07/2014 Derby, DE22 4AT Conditionally
07/13/00785/PRI Full Planning 78-80 Cameron Road, Change of use from factory to three flats (Use Refuse 24/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE23 8RS (Double Class C3) including demolition of part of factory Planning K J Textiles Ltd) and alterations to elevations Permission
08/13/00906/PRI Listed Building Rosehill House, 1 Wilfred Extension and alteration to dwelling house Granted 19/06/2014 Consent -alterations Street, Derby, DE23 8GG (external staircase) and insertion of 3 doors Conditionally
08/13/00919/PRI Outline Planning Land at 49 - 51 Edmund Residential development (3 dwelling houses) Granted 15/07/2014 Permission Road, Spondon, Derby, Conditionally DE21 7HJ (access via Edmund road & Arnhem Terrace)
08/13/00952/PRI Full Planning 201A Duffield Road, Demolition of detached garage. Two storey Granted 09/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE22 1JE extension to dwelling house (garage, bedroom Conditionally and en-suite)
10/13/01193/PRI Full Planning Avenue Cottage, 64 West Two storey and single storey rear extensions to Granted 25/06/2014 Permission Avenue North, Chellaston, dwelling house Conditionally Derby, DE73 1SG
10/13/01257/PRI Full Planning Land at side of The Erection of two dwelling houses Granted 11/06/2014 Permission Willows, Old Hall Avenue, Conditionally Littleover, DE23 6EN
10/13/01261/PRI Full Planning 36 Freehold Street, Derby, Retention of boundary fence Refuse 25/06/2014 Permission DE22 3RA Planning Permission
11/13/01309/PRI Full Planning Silecroft, 2 Friars Close, Formation of rooms in roof space (bedroom, Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Darley Abbey, Derby, en-suite bathroom, study, storage and juliet Conditionally DE22 1FD balcony) and erection of detached garage and games room
Page 2 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 11/13/01341/PRI Full Planning 159A St. Thomas Road, Retention of change of use to residential (Use Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE23 6RH Class C3) Conditionally
11/13/01388/PRI Full Planning 63 Melbourne Street, Extension and change of use from residential Refuse 24/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE1 2GF (Use Class C3) to Care Home (Use Class C2) Planning Permission
11/13/01402/PRI Full Planning 3 Cricklewood Road, Erection of single storey attached self contained Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE22 4DP flat for dependent relative Conditionally
12/13/01426/PRI Variation/Waive of Land rear of 16 to 24 and Demolition of dwelling house (No 20) and Granted 26/06/2014 condition(s) site of 20 Devonshire erection of 13 dwelling houses and associated Conditionally Avenue, Allestree, Derby, roads (Variation of Condition No. 2 of previous DE22 2AT (including land approved planning permission Code No. at rear of 9a - 15 Kings DER/06/13/00644 to amend House Type) Croft)
12/13/01461/PRI Full Planning 31 Princes Drive, Extensions to dwelling house (dining room, 2 Granted 06/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 bedrooms, bathroom, linen store and Conditionally 6DX enlargement of kitchen utility room, shower room and playroom)
12/13/01474/PRI Full Planning Unit 1, Southgate Retail Demolition of adjacent retail unit, extension to Granted 11/06/2014 Permission Park, Normanton, Derby, shop (warehouse, bakery freezer/prep and shop Conditionally DE23 6UQ (Lidl) floor) and formation of additional parking spaces
12/13/01480/PRI Full Planning Land at rear of 488 - 496 Erection of dwelling house and domestic garage Refuse 25/07/2014 Permission Duffield Road, Derby, Planning DE22 Permission
12/13/01494/PRI Outline Planning Land at side of 255 Residential development (1 dwelling) Granted 16/06/2014 Permission Keldholme Lane, Conditionally Alvaston, Derby, DE24 0ST
12/13/01496/PRI Full Planning Jamia Mosque, 6 Rosehill Extension of car park, installation of gates and Granted 03/06/2014 Permission Street, Derby, DE23 8GB formation of vehicular access to Holmes Street Conditionally
Page 3 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 01/14/00029/PRI Full Planning Bramble Business Centre, Change of use from offices (use class B1) to 13 Granted 18/07/2014 Permission Becket Street, Derby, DE1 apartments (use class C3) Conditionally 1HT
01/14/00030/PRI Listed Building Bramble Business Centre, Alterations to form change of use from offices Granted 18/07/2014 Consent -alterations Becket Street, Derby, DE1 (use class B1) to 13 apartments (use class C3) Conditionally 1HT
01/14/00037/PRI Advertisement consent Chellaston Neighbourhood Display of externally illuminated double sided Granted 05/06/2014 Centre, Royal Glen Park, freestanding sign Conditionally Rowallan Way, Chellaston, Derby DE73 5WX
01/14/00042/PRI Full Application - 84 Chester Green Road, Installation of two replacement doors to the front Granted 16/06/2014 Article 4 Derby, DE1 3SF elevation Conditionally
01/14/00058/PRI Full Planning 30 Windmill Hill Lane, Enlargement of detached outbuilding to form Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE22 3BQ summer house, w.c and storage/play area Conditionally
01/14/00065/PRI Full Planning 7 Coriander Gardens, Two storey side and rear extensions to dwelling Granted 24/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 house (garage, store, kitchen, lounge, utility, 2 Conditionally 7UB bedrooms and 2 en-suites)
01/14/00078/PRI Full Planning 3 Adelphi Close, Two storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 24/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 (family room, en-suites, and enlargement of Conditionally 3XJ lounge, kitchen and two bedrooms)
01/14/00080/PRI Full Planning 224A Normanton Road, Change of use from residential (Use Class C3) to Granted 03/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE23 6WA financial and professional services (Use Class A2) Conditionally on first floor
01/14/00090/PRI Full Planning 11A Havenbaulk Lane, Two storey front extension to dwelling house Granted 18/07/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 (porch and bedroom) Conditionally 7AA
01/14/00096/PRI Full Planning 1 St. Peters Way, Derby, Change of use from Shop (Use Class A1) to Hot Refuse 04/06/2014 Permission DE1 2NR Food Takeaway (Use Class A5). Planning Permission
Page 4 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 01/14/00109/PRI Full Planning Chesapeake Family Change of use from Family Centre (Use Class D1) Granted 15/07/2014 Permission Resource Centre, 22 to six flats (Use Class C3) including alterations to Conditionally Chesapeake Road, elevations and alterations to garage to form bike Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 and bin store 6RB
01/14/00115/PRI Full Planning 2 Albemarle Road, Change of use to supported living Refuse 26/06/2014 Permission Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 accommodation (Use Class C2) including two Planning 6UG storey side and rear extensions, formation of Permission rooms in roof space with dormers and conversion of outbuilding
01/14/00116/PRI Full Planning 134 Carsington Crescent, Two storey front extension to dwelling house Granted 17/06/2014 Permission Allestree, Derby, DE22 (entrance hall, bathroom, w.c. and enlargement Conditionally 2QX of bedroom)
01/14/00117/PRI Full Planning 26 Chapter Close, Two storey side and single storey rear extensions Granted 04/06/2014 Permission Oakwood, Derby, DE21 to dwelling house for dependent relative (living Conditionally 2BG room, bedroom ,kitchen, shower room, 2 bedrooms, en-suite and conservatory)
02/14/00150/PRI Full Planning Tall Trees, Lime Lane, Single storey front extension to dwelling house Granted 15/07/2014 Permission Oakwood, Derby, DE21 (conservatory) Conditionally 4RF
02/14/00153/PRI Advertisement consent The Spinning Wheel PH, Display of internally illuminated fascia sign, Granted 04/07/2014 96 Wood Road, ATM sign, externally illuminated post sign and Conditionally Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 various non illuminated signage 4LZ
02/14/00158/PRI Full Planning 693 Harvey Road, Derby, Single storey front extensions to dwelling house Granted 25/06/2014 Permission DE24 0EH (covered entrance, hall and sitting room) Conditionally
02/14/00160/PRI L B C alterations and Rolls Royce Works, Refurbishment and change of use from factory to Granted 18/07/2014 demolition Nightingale Road, Derby, community centre with offices, nursery, cafe and Conditionally DE24 healthcare provision including partial demolition and erection of entrance and lift to rear
Page 5 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 02/14/00162/PRI Full Planning 70 Elmwood Drive, Single storey side and rear extension to dwelling Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Breadsall, Derby, DE21 house (dining room, utility and garage) and Conditionally 4GA erection of boundary fence
02/14/00163/PRI Full Planning 106 Porter Road, Derby, Change of use from dwelling house (Use Class Granted 06/06/2014 Permission DE23 6RA C3) to a Place of Religious Instruction (Use Class Conditionally D1)
02/14/00187/PRI Full Planning 164 Willson Avenue, Two storey side and rear extension to dwelling Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 house (shower room, bedroom and enlargement Conditionally 7TW of kitchen and bedroom)
02/14/00192/DCC Local Council own Perth House, Athlone Single storey extension to residential care home Granted 04/07/2014 development Reg 3 Close, Derby, DE21 4BP (conservatory) Conditionally
02/14/00207/DCC Local Council own Moorfield Childrens Home, Demolition of buildings, erection of 2 Granted 05/06/2014 development Reg 3 400 Sinfin Lane, Sinfin, accommodation buildings, garage store and Conditionally Derby, DE24 9HN formation of hard landscaped areas including car parking, access and multi-use games area - Variation of condition No. 2 or previously approved planning permission Code No. 08/13/00926 to amend site layout
02/14/00220/PRI Full Planning Land at side of 66 Erection of two dwelling houses Refuse 04/06/2014 Permission Somerset Street, Derby Planning Permission
02/14/00222/PRI Full Planning 44 Hilton Close, Two storey and single storey extensions to Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Mickleover, Derby, DE3 dwelling house (2 bedrooms and enlargement of Conditionally 5EH lounge and kitchen/dining room)
02/14/00223/PRI Prior Notification Flat 1, 1 Friary Street, Change of use from offices (use class B1) to Refuse 26/06/2014 Derby, DE1 1JF residential (use class C3) Planning Permission
02/14/00229/PRI Full Planning 3 Falmouth Road, Two storey and single storey side extension to Granted 19/06/2014 Permission Alvaston, Derby, DE24 dwelling house (two bedrooms, garage, w.c. and Conditionally 0NB enlargement of kitchen)-
Page 6 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 02/14/00230/PRI Full Planning 622 Burton Road, Two storey rear extension to dormer bungalow Granted 04/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 (family room, breakfast room and two bedrooms) Conditionally
02/14/00231/PRI Full Planning Land at side of 5 Demolition of workshop and erection of 2 flats Granted 19/06/2014 Permission Manchester Street, Derby, Conditionally DE22 3GD
02/14/00240/PRI Full Planning 19 Mandarin Way, Single storey side extension to garage block Granted 25/06/2014 Permission Alvaston, Derby (workshop and w.c.) Conditionally
02/14/00253/PRI Full Planning 11 Hardwick Drive, Single storey rear and side extension Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Mickleover, Derby, DE3 (dining/kitchen, lounge, bedroom and en-suite) Conditionally 5BN
02/14/00259/PRI Full Planning 71 Grange Road, Alvaston, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 24/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE24 0JY (sitting room) Conditionally
02/14/00261/PRI Full Planning 4 Poplar Avenue, Two storey extension to dwelling house (utility Granted 04/06/2014 Permission Spondon, Derby, DE21 room, shower room and bedroom) Conditionally 7FJ
02/14/00264/PRI Full Planning Land to the rear of 2 & 3 Erection of two dwelling houses Granted 01/07/2014 Permission Lonsdale Place, Derby, Conditionally DE22 3NQ (access via 50A Hoult Street)
02/14/00267/PRI Full Planning Sinfin Moor Church, Single storey extensions and re-roofing of church Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Arleston Lane, Stenson Conditionally Fields, Derby, DE24 3DH
02/14/00271/PRI Full Planning 16 Hilltop, Oakwood, Two storey and single storey side extensions to Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE21 4FX dwelling house (living room, w.c, office, Conditionally bedroom and en-suite)
02/14/00272/PRI Full Planning 17 Medina Close, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Alvaston, Derby, DE24 (family room) Conditionally 0UD
Page 7 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 02/14/00279/PRI Advertisement consent Derby Moor Community Display of illuminated fascia signage Granted 15/07/2014 School, Moorway Lane, Conditionally Littleover, Derby, DE23 7FS
03/14/00295/PRI Advertisement consent 2 Siddals Road, Derby, Retention of display of non-illuminated fascia Granted 19/06/2014 DE1 2PB signage Conditionally
03/14/00303/PRI Full Planning 13 Duffield Road, Derby, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 25/06/2014 Permission DE1 3BB (enlargement of kitchen/dining room) in Conditionally connection with change of use of dwelling house (Use Class C3) to House in Multiple Occupation (Sui Generis) for 7 people
03/14/00311/PRI Full Planning 11 Moorhead Avenue, Single storey and first floor rear extensions to Granted 16/06/2014 Permission Alvaston, Derby, DE24 dwelling house (wet room, en-suite bathroom Conditionally 0AT and enlargement of kitchen/dining room and bedroom)
03/14/00315/DCC Local Council own Springfield Primary Erection of classroom block (4 classrooms), Granted 10/06/2014 development Reg 3 School, West Road, formation of parking spaces and play area. Conditionally Spondon, Derby, DE21 7AB
03/14/00317/DCC Local Council own Former Glasshouses and Demolition of glass houses and formation of car Granted 02/06/2014 development Reg 3 Nursery Buildings, park and access road Conditionally Markeaton Park, Markeaton Lane, Derby
03/14/00318/PRI L B C alterations and Long Mill and West Mill Demolition of loading bay, two storey stairwell Granted 11/06/2014 demolition Darley Abbey Mills, Darley extension to former `Mechanics Shop` together Conditionally Abbey, Derby, DE22 with repairs to mills
03/14/00333/PRI Advertisement consent 28-32 Iron Gate, Derby, Display of externally illuminated hanging sign Granted 03/06/2014 DE1 3GL (The Standing Conditionally Order P H)
03/14/00334/PRI Listed Building 28-32 Iron Gate, Derby, Display of externally illuminated hanging sign Granted 03/06/2014 Consent -alterations DE1 3GL (The Standing Conditionally Order P H)
Page 8 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 03/14/00338/PRI Advertisement consent The Master Locksmith PH, Display of various illuminated and Granted 13/06/2014 Meteor Centre, Derby, non-illuminated signs Conditionally DE21 4SY
03/14/00356/PRI Full Planning 148 Manor Road, Derby, Formation of room in roof space (en-suite Granted 08/07/2014 Permission DE23 6BT bathroom) together with installation of rear Conditionally dormer
03/14/00359/PRI Full Planning Land to rear of The Erection of 4 dwelling houses Granted 25/06/2014 Permission Kingfisher, Lexington Conditionally Road, Chaddesden, DE21 6UZ
03/14/00361/PRI Full Planning Linden, Potter Street, Installation of a pitched roof to single storey Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Spondon, Derby, DE21 extension Conditionally 7LH
03/14/00370/PRI Full Planning 6-8, Stenson Road, Derby, Change of use of part of ground floor from retail Granted 16/06/2014 Permission DE23 7JA (Use Class A1) to offices (Use Class A2) Conditionally
03/14/00372/PRI Full Planning St. Phillips Church, Erection of store Granted 11/06/2014 Permission Taddington Road, Conditionally Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 4JF
03/14/00381/PRI Full Planning 189 Allestree Lane, Derby, Extension to dwelling house (utility room, Granted 16/06/2014 Permission DE22 2PG garage/store, bathroom, bedroom and Conditionally enlargement of kitchen and bedroom)
03/14/00394/PRI Full Planning 255 Morley Road, Two storey side extension (double garage, Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Oakwood, Derby, DE21 bedroom and en-suite) Conditionally 4TD
03/14/00399/ Full Planning Faraday House and Hartley Change of use from research and development Granted 04/06/2014 Permission House, RTC Business office (use class B1) to training centre (use class Conditionally Centre, London Road, D1) Derby, DE24 8BQ
Page 9 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 03/14/00400/PRI Full Planning 171 Nottingham Road, Two storey and single storey rear extension to Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Spondon, Derby, DE21 dwelling house (kitchen and two bedrooms) Conditionally 7GZ
03/14/00401/ Full Planning 50 Chapel Lane, Two storey rear extension to dwelling house (sun Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Spondon, Derby, DE21 room and enlargement of two bedrooms) Conditionally 7JW
03/14/00409/PRI Advertisement consent 14 Sadler Gate, Derby, Display of non illuminated fascia and wall signs Granted 09/06/2014 DE1 3NF Conditionally
03/14/00416/PRI Advertisement consent 100 Douglas Street, Derby, Display of non illuminated fascia, freestanding Granted 24/06/2014 DE23 8LJ sign and wall signs Conditionally
03/14/00418/PRI Certificate of 47 Arundel Drive, Formation of room in roof space (bedroom and Granted 04/06/2014 Lawfulness Proposed Spondon, Derby, DE21 rear dormer) Use 7QX
03/14/00420/PRI Certificate of 61 Ford Lane, Allestree, Single storey side extension to dwelling house Granted 02/06/2014 Lawfulness Proposed Derby, DE22 2EY (cloak room, store and utility room) and Use installation of side dormer
03/14/00424/PRI Full Planning The Five Lamps PH, 25 Extension to Public House (rear canopies) Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Duffield Road, Derby, DE1 Conditionally 3BH
03/14/00426/PRI Certificate of 149 Smalley Drive, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 06/06/2014 Lawfulness Proposed Oakwood, Derby, DE21 (breakfast/dining room) Use 2SQ
03/14/00427/PRI Full Planning Anglian Window Centres, Installation of replacement doors and windows Granted 18/07/2014 Permission 37-38 Queen Street, Conditionally Derby, DE1 3DS
03/14/00434/DC5 Full Planning Land in front of 2a Erection of replacement 15m high Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Chestnut Avenue, telecommunications pole, 3 antennae, 2 Conditionally Mickleover, Derby, DE3 equipment cabinets and ancillary works
Page 10 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 03/14/00437/PRI Non-material Walter Evans C Of E Erection of 3 classroom block and enlargement Granted 24/07/2014 amendment School, Darley Abbey of hall, with provision of additional parking - Drive, Darley Abbey, non-material amendment to previously approved Derby, DE22 1EF permission DER/11/13/01328 to amend condition 11: The additional area of hard playground to be provided as part of the approved development shall be implemented and made available for use upon completion of the project.
04/14/00439/PRI Full Planning 104 Allestree Lane, Derby, Formation of vehicular access, hard standing and Granted 24/06/2014 Permission DE22 2HT erection of boundary wall Conditionally
04/14/00440/PRI Full Planning 112 Old Mansfield Road, Extension to dwelling house (rear balcony) Granted 04/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE21 4SA Conditionally
03/14/00441/DC5 Prior Notification Highway verge north-east Erection of replacement 15 metre high Granted 24/06/2014 of 221 Uttoxeter Road, monopole, 3 antennae, equipment cabinet and Conditionally Mickleover, Derby, DE3 ancilliary works
04/14/00447/PRI Full Planning 78 Darley Abbey Drive, Retention of single storey rear extension to Granted 03/06/2014 Permission Darley Abbey, Derby, dwelling house (kitchen/dining room) Conditionally DE22 1EF
04/14/00448/PRI Full Planning T C Harrison, Chequers First floor extension to offices, installation of Granted 26/06/2014 Permission Road, West Meadows aluminium roof and alterations to elevations to Conditionally Industrial Estate, Derby, include wall cladding and installation of DE21 6EN additional windows to the first floor
04/14/00449/PRI Advertisement consent Staples Stationery Store, Display of 3 internally illuminated facia signs Granted 02/06/2014 Unit 26, Meteor Centre, and non-illuminated transom sign Conditionally Mansfield Road, Derby, DE21 4SY
04/14/00453/PRI Full Application - 58 Otter Street, Derby, Installation of replacement windows to the front Granted 28/07/2014 Article 4 DE1 3FB and rear elevation Conditionally
04/14/00455/PRI Full Planning 11 Ferrers Way, Derby, Single storey side and front extensions to Granted 09/07/2014 Permission DE22 2AB dwelling house (kitchen, porch and replacement Conditionally roof to garage/utility)
Page 11 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 04/14/00457/PRI Full Planning 59 Bank View Road, Erection of two storey side extension to dwelling Granted 09/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE22 1EL house (kitchen/dining room, utility, store, Conditionally bedroom, bathroom and en-suite)
04/14/00460/PRI Full Planning 34 Spindletree Drive, Two storey side extension to dwelling house Refuse 24/06/2014 Permission Oakwood, Derby, DE21 (drive through, bedroom and en-suite bathroom) Planning 2DG Permission
04/14/00462/DC5 Prior Notification Highway verge west of Erection of replacement 15 metre high Raise No 25/06/2014 Petrol Filling Station, monopole, 3 antennae, 2 equipment cabinets Objection Harvey Road, Derby, DE24 and ancilliary works
04/14/00468/PRI Full Planning 72A Pastures Hill, Alterations and extensions to bungalow to form Granted 19/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 two storey dwelling house Conditionally 7BB
04/14/00471/PRI Variation/Waive of Site of Merrill College, Erection of 88 dwellings with associated access Granted 06/06/2014 condition(s) Jubilee Road, Shelton and balancing facility for surface water discharge Conditionally Lock, Derby, DE24 - variation to condition No 1 to previously approved permission DER/05/11/00513 to amend design and location of car port on plot 53
04/14/00476/PRI Full Planning 7 Highfield Cottages, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 16/06/2014 Permission Highfield Lane, (kitchen) Conditionally Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 6PR
04/14/00478/PRI Full Planning 12 Farncombe Lane, Single storey and two storey extensions to rear of Granted 11/06/2014 Permission Oakwood, Derby, DE21 dwelling house (kitchen/sun lounge and Conditionally 2AY enlargement of bedroom)
04/14/00481/PRI Full Planning Unit 1, Sinfin District Erection of 1.8m high fence and gate to rear Granted 04/06/2014 Permission Centre, Arleston Lane, access, increase width of the rear access door Conditionally DE24 3DS (Co-op Funeral and installation of air conditioning condensers to Care) rear elevation
04/14/00487/PRI Full Planning 1 Oxford Street, Derby, Demolition of workshop and associated buildings Granted 25/06/2014 Permission DE1 2TE within the Railway Conservation Area Conditionally
Page 12 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 04/14/00488/PRI Full Planning 52 Beeley Close, Allestree, Two storey extension to dwelling house (garden Granted 17/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE22 2PX room, utility room, porch, garage, two bedrooms, Conditionally en-suite, dressing room and enlargement of hall) and installation of two bay windows to the front elevation
04/14/00489/PRI Full Planning 26 Mickleover Manor, Single storey extension to dwelling house Granted 09/07/2014 Permission Mickleover, Derby, DE3 (conservatory) Conditionally 5SH
04/14/00490/PRI Works to Trees under 179 Station Road, Crown reduction by 5m of Norway Maple Refuse 09/06/2014 TPO Mickleover, Derby, DE3 protected by Tree Preservation Order No 8 Planning 5FH Permission
04/14/00491/PRI Full Application - 13 Marcus Street, Derby, Installation of replacement windows to front Granted 27/06/2014 Article 4 DE1 3SE elevation Conditionally
04/14/00493/PRI Certificate of 12 Clifton Road, Allestree, Single storey side and rear extensions to Granted 06/06/2014 Lawfulness Proposed Derby, DE22 2PH dwelling house (conservatory and store) Use
04/14/00495/ Full Planning 30 Stoney Lane, Spondon, Single storey side extension to dwelling house Granted 02/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE21 7QH (utility room and dining room) Conditionally
04/14/00496/PRI Full Planning 16 The Crest, Darley Rear and side extensions to dwelling (garage, Granted 06/06/2014 Permission Abbey, Derby, DE22 2BR utility room and enlargement of kitchen) and Conditionally formation of rooms in roof space together with raising of eaves (2 bedrooms and bathroom) and widening of access
04/14/00498/PRI Full Planning 18 Milldale Road, Single storey rear extension to dwelling (lounge, Granted 04/06/2014 Permission Spondon, Derby, DE21 bedroom, en-suite and dayroom) Conditionally 7PJ
04/14/00502/PRI Full Planning 11 Oakridge, Chaddesden, Erection of detached garage Refuse 25/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE21 4RB Planning Permission
Page 13 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 04/14/00503/PRI Reserved Matters Land rear of 36 Glenwood Residential development (2 dwelling houses) - Granted 04/06/2014 Road, Chellaston, Derby, approval of reserved matters of scale, Conditionally DE73 6UB appearance and landscaping under Outline permission Code No. 04/13/00399
04/14/00504/PRI Full Planning 2 Whinbush Avenue, Alterations to existing two storey extension to Granted 17/07/2014 Permission Allenton, Derby, DE24 rear roof from hip to gable, together with the Conditionally 9DP formation of rooms in roof space and installation of rear dormer. Alterations to previously approved planning permission Code No. DER/02/11/00194.
04/14/00505/PRI Works to Trees under 26 St. Georges Close, Felling of two cherry trees protected by Tree Granted 02/06/2014 TPO Allestree, Derby, DE22 1JH Preservation Order No 288 Conditionally
04/14/00506/PRI Full Planning 4 Darley Park Road, Derby, Two storey extension to dwelling house (utility Granted 04/06/2014 Permission DE22 1DB room , two en-suites and enlargement of kitchen) Conditionally
04/14/00508/PRI Full Planning 12 Lashley Gardens, Two storey side and single storey rear extensions Granted 24/06/2014 Permission Oakwood, Derby, DE21 to dwelling house (garage, w.c., utility room, Conditionally 2UR family room, bedroom, en-suite bathroom and enlargement of kitchen)
04/14/00510/PRI Prior Notification 117-119 Peet Street, Change of use from offices (use class B1) to Approval Not 09/06/2014 Derby, DE22 3RG residential (use class C3) required
04/14/00513/PRI Full Planning 69 Robincroft Road, Two storey side and single storey rear extension Granted 24/06/2014 Permission Allestree, Derby, DE22 to dwelling house (dining room, kitchen, utility Conditionally 2GL room, garage, bedroom and shower room)
04/14/00514/PRI Full Planning 67 Locko Road, Spondon, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 27/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE21 7AP (kitchen/dining room and bathroom) Conditionally
04/14/00515/PRI Full Planning 5 Silverburn Drive, First floor extension to dwelling house (two Refuse 20/06/2014 Permission Oakwood, Derby, DE21 2JJ bedrooms) Planning Permission
04/14/00517/PRI Full Planning 23 Holyhead Drive, Single storey side and rear extensions to Granted 20/06/2014 Permission Oakwood, Derby, DE21 dwelling house (study, utility, kitchen and sun Conditionally 2TD room)
Page 14 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 04/14/00518/PRI Full Planning 12 Porters Lane, Oakwood, Erection of detached workshop/store/garage Granted 11/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE21 4FZ Conditionally
04/14/00520/PRI Full Planning Land to side and rear of 23 Erection of detached bungalow, demolition of Refuse 04/06/2014 Permission Old Hall Road, Littleover, garage and relocation of access gates Planning Derby, DE23 6GG Permission
04/14/00521/PRI Full Planning 17 Wingfield Drive, Two storey side extension to dwelling house Refuse 16/06/2014 Permission Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 (bedroom and passageway) Planning 4PW Permission
04/14/00522/PRI Full Planning 107-109 St. Peters Street, Change of use from Use Class A1 (retail) to Use Refuse 18/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE1 2AD Class A2 (financial and professional services) on Planning ground floor, minor changes to shop front, Permission installation of 2 air conditioning condenser units to rear and 2 satellite dishes
04/14/00524/DCC Advertisement consent Highway verge, north side Display of free standing post mounted sign board Granted 11/06/2014 of Kingsway, Derby Conditionally
04/14/00525/DCC Advertisement consent Highway verge between Display of free standing post mounted sign board Granted 11/06/2014 A52 westbound and Conditionally Chequers Road, West Meadows Industrial Estate, Derby
04/14/00526/PRI Full Planning 113 Locko Road, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 05/06/2014 Permission Spondon, Derby, DE21 (enlargement of lounge and dining room) Conditionally 7AP
04/14/00528/PRI Full Planning 58 Colwyn Avenue, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 25/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 (kitchen), installation of side dormer and front Conditionally 6HG ramp
04/14/00529/PRI Works to Trees under 43 Kedleston Road, Derby, Reduction by 1.5m of Yew tree protected by Granted 02/06/2014 TPO DE22 1FP Tree Preservation Order No 84 Conditionally
04/14/00531/PRI Prior Notification 1-3, Dickinson Street, Change of use of part of Ground Floor from Granted 16/06/2014 Derby, DE24 8WJ Financial and Professional Services (Use Class A2) to flat (Use Class C3)
Page 15 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 04/14/00532/PRI Full Planning 48 Meadow Lane, Two storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 (dining room/kitchen and bedroom) Conditionally 6PU
04/14/00538/PRI Full Planning 1 Brunswood Close, First floor extension to dwelling house (bedroom, Granted 04/06/2014 Permission Spondon, Derby, DE21 en-suite and enlargement of bedroom) Conditionally 7LB
04/14/00539/PRI Full Planning 1280 London Road, Derby, Change of use of first floor from solicitors office Granted 27/06/2014 Permission DE24 8QP (Use Class A2) to beauticians (Sui Generis Use ) Conditionally
04/14/00542/PRI Full Planning 17 Darwin Road, Two storey side and rear extension to dwelling Granted 04/06/2014 Permission Mickleover, Derby, DE3 house (w.c., store, bedroom, en-suite, bathroom Conditionally 5HT and enlargement of kitchen)
04/14/00543/PRI Full Planning 146 Chaddesden Lane, Two storey extension to dwelling house (living Granted 22/07/2014 Permission Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 room, utility room, w.c., bedroom, en-suite, Conditionally 6LJ dressing room and dormers)
04/14/00546/PRI Full Planning Land west of 91 Erection of dwelling house Granted 23/07/2014 Permission Borrowfield Road and Conditionally south of 2a Kirkdale Avenue, Spondon, Derby, DE21 7HG
04/14/00547/PRI Full Planning 66 Arundel Drive, Two storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 11/06/2014 Permission Spondon, Derby, DE21 (kitchen and bedroom) Conditionally 7QW
04/14/00550/PRI Full Planning Former Dunelm Mill Store, External alterations to retail unit Granted 18/06/2014 Permission Ascot Drive, Derby, DE24 Conditionally 8GW
04/14/00551/PRI Advertisement consent Former Dunelm Mill Store, Display of 2 internally illuminated fascia signs, 7 Granted 17/06/2014 Ascot Drive, Derby, DE24 externally illuminated product signs and various Conditionally 8GW non- illuminated signs
04/14/00553/ Works to Trees under St. Josephs RC Church, Crown reduction by 3-4m of two trees protected Granted 18/07/2014 TPO Burton Road, Derby, DE1 by Tree Preservation Order No. 146 Conditionally 1TJ
Page 16 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 04/14/00554/PRI Certificate of 13 Bonsall Avenue, Derby, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 09/07/2014 Lawfulness Proposed DE23 6JX (conservatory) Use
04/14/00555/PRI Prior Notification 1-3 Dickinson Street, Change of use from offices (Use Class B1) to Approval Not 16/06/2014 Derby, DE24 8WJ Single Flat (Use Class C3) on First Floor required
04/14/00556/PRI Full Planning Asda, Sinfin District Change of use of part of car park to hand car Granted 03/07/2014 Permission Centre, Sinfin, Derby, wash and erection of cabin and canopy Conditionally DE24 3DS
04/14/00557/PRI Full Planning Derby College, Erection of catering marquee for temporary Granted 24/07/2014 Permission Roundhouse Road, Pride period between June 2014 to February 2015 Conditionally Park, Derby, DE24 8JE
04/14/00560/PRI Works to Trees under 32 Melbourne Close, Felling of Ash Tree protected by Tree Granted 02/06/2014 TPO Mickleover, Derby, DE3 Preservation Order no. 491 5LG
04/14/00566/PRI Full Planning 12 Templeton Close, Single storey side extension to dwelling house Granted 05/06/2014 Permission Mickleover, Derby (garage, playroom and store) Conditionally
04/14/00568/PRI Full Planning 263 Station Road, and Demolition of detached garage and Granted 03/07/2014 Permission land to the South, conservatory/greenhouse. Erection of three Conditionally Mickleover, Derby, DE3 detached dwelling houses and extension to 5FB dwelling house (garage)
04/14/00569/PRI Full Planning 3 Centro Place, Pride Park, Installation of air ventilation grilles to external Granted 16/06/2014 Permission Derby facade Conditionally
04/14/00570/PRI Works to Trees under Trees at Ridgeway Court, Felling of purple plum tree and cutting back of Granted 02/06/2014 TPO 224, Warwick Avenue, branches to 3 metres away from property of Blue Conditionally Derby, DE23 6HP Cedar Tree protected by Tree Preservation Order No. 231
04/14/00571/PRI Works to Trees under Trees at 2, Longshaw Pollarding of 9 Lime trees and crown lift by 1m Granted 26/06/2014 TPO Gardens, Alvaston, Derby, of Silver Birch tree all protected by Tree Conditionally DE24 0EY Preservation Order No 334
Page 17 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 04/14/00572/PRI Full Planning 33 Church Lane, Darley Single storey rear and first floor side extensions Granted 02/07/2014 Permission Abbey, Derby, DE22 1EX to dwelling house (sun/playroom, bedroom and Conditionally en-suite)
04/14/00573/PRI Full Planning 361 Uttoxeter Road, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 11/06/2014 Permission Mickleover, Derby, DE3 (dining room, kitchen, store, w.c and shower Conditionally 5AH room)
04/14/00575/ Advertisement consent Land at east end of car Display of 10 metre high internally illuminated Granted 23/06/2014 park, Wyvern Retail Park, pole sign Conditionally Wyvern Way, Chaddesden, Derby (Costa Coffee)
04/14/00576/PRI Full Planning 24 Chevin Road, Derby, Demolition of garage and single storey side Granted 24/06/2014 Permission DE1 3EX extension to dwelling house (playroom and Conditionally enlargement of hall and shower room/W.C)
04/14/00577/PRI Works to Trees under 15 Woodminton Drive, Crown reduction by 2m of Ash tree protected by Granted 24/06/2014 TPO Chellaston, Derby, DE73 Tree Preservation Order No 59 1RZ
04/14/00578/PRI Full Planning Asda, Sinfin District Erection of canopy Granted 01/07/2014 Permission Centre, Sinfin, Derby, Conditionally DE24 3DS
04/14/00579/PRI Full Planning 17 Constable Drive, Two storey extension to dwelling house (guest Granted 03/07/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 room, sun lounge, 2 bedrooms and 2 en-suites) Conditionally 6EQ
04/14/00580/PRI Full Planning Derwent House, Railway Installation of cooling chillers on roof, lowering Granted 25/06/2014 Permission Technical Centre Business of roof door, installation of soil and vent pipes Conditionally Park, London Road, Derby, together with partial replacement of windows DE24 8UP
Page 18 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 04/14/00581/PRI Full Planning McDonalds, Unit 10, Formation of additional 'drive thru' lane and Granted 27/06/2014 Permission Wyvern Retail Park, associated works together with extension to booth Conditionally Wyvern Way, Chaddesden, and installation of two customer order points Derby, DE21 6NZ with associated canopies
04/14/00582/PRI Advertisement consent McDonalds, Unit 10, Display of various signage Granted 24/06/2014 Wyvern Retail Park, Conditionally Wyvern Way, Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 6NZ
04/14/00587/PRI Prior Notification Highway verge at Junction Erection of replacement 15m high monopole, 3 Raise No 19/06/2014 of Derby Road/Parkway, antennae, 2 equipment cabinets and associated Objection Chellaston, Derby works
04/14/00588/PRI Works to Trees under Land adjacent to 15 Felling of various trees protected by Tree Granted 24/06/2014 TPO Whistlestop Close, Preservation Order No 172 Conditionally Mickleover, Derby, DE3 9DA
04/14/00589/DCC Local Council own Land at Green Park, Derby, Formation of 8 parking bays Granted 11/06/2014 development Reg 3 DE22 Conditionally
04/14/00590/PRI Full Planning 5 South Drive, Two storey side extension to dwelling house Granted 16/06/2014 Permission Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 (utility room, shower room, bedroom and Conditionally 6RZ enlargement of kitchen/diner)
04/14/00591/PRI Certificate of 13 Kirkistown Close, Single storey side extension to dwelling house Invalid - Finally 16/06/2014 Lawfulness Proposed Alvaston, Derby, DE24 (enlargement of kitchen) Disposed of Use 0SW
04/14/00592/PRI Works to Trees under 9 St. Georges Close, Crown reduction by 3 metres of Sycamore tree Granted 24/06/2014 TPO Allestree, Derby, DE22 1JH protected by Tree Preservation Order No 288 Conditionally
04/14/00593/PRI Advertisement consent Balfour Beatty Ltd, West Display of illuminated fascia sign Granted 26/06/2014 Service Road, Raynesway, Conditionally Derby
Page 19 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 04/14/00594/DC5 Prior Notification Highway verge, Shardlow Erection of replacement 15 metre high Raise No 20/06/2014 Road, Alvaston, Derby monopole, 1 equipment cabinet and ancilliary Objection (adjacent junction with works Elvaston Lane)
04/14/00595/DC5 Prior Notification Land east of junction of Erection of replacement 15 metre high Raise No 19/06/2014 Chellaston Road / Merrill monopole, 3 antennas, 2 equipment cabinets Objection Way, Allenton, Derby, and ancilliary works DE24
04/14/00596/DC5 Prior Notification Highway verge adjacent Erection of replacement 12.5 metre high Raise No 19/06/2014 164, Max Road, monopole, 2 equipment cabinets and ancilliary Objection Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 works 4HA
05/14/00597/PRI Full Planning 1238-1242 London Road, Change of use from use Class A1 (retail) to use Granted 11/07/2014 Permission Alvaston, DE24 8QP Class D1 (Veterinary Surgery) Conditionally
05/14/00598/PRI Works to Trees under 482A Burton Road, Derby, Deadwood and crown thinning by 20-25% of Granted 24/06/2014 TPO DE23 6AL Quercus (T1) and deadwood, crown thinning by Conditionally 20-25% and crown lifting to 5m of Quercus (T2) protected by Tree preservation Order No 16
05/14/00599/PRI Prior Notification 643 Osmaston Road, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 02/06/2014 Derby, DE24 8NF the rear wall of the original house by 4m, required maximum height 3.5m, height to eaves 2.6m) to dwelling house
05/14/00602/PRI Listed Building 8 Cornhill, Allestree, Installation of replacement windows and door Granted 02/07/2014 Consent -alterations Derby, DE22 2FT and alterations to conservatory Conditionally
05/14/00604/PRI Full Planning 59 Duncan Road, Derby, Rear and side extensions to dwelling house Refuse 11/06/2014 Permission DE23 8TS (kitchen and 3 bedrooms) Planning Permission
05/14/00605/PRI Advertisement consent Pharmacy, 46 Station Display of internally illuminated fascia sign and Granted 24/06/2014 Road, Mickleover, Derby, internally illuminated projecting sign Conditionally DE3 5GH
Page 20 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 05/14/00606/PRI Full Planning 16 Brentford Drive, Derby, Two storey side and single storey front extensions Refuse 19/06/2014 Permission DE22 4BN to dwelling house (store, bedroom and Planning enlargement of porch, utility and w.c) Permission
05/14/00607/PRI Full Planning 34 Bridgeness Road, Erection of two storey side extension to dwelling Granted 03/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 house (bedroom, bathroom and enlargement of Conditionally 7UJ kitchen and dining room)
05/14/00608/PRI Variation/Waive of 9 Little Woodbury Drive, Erection of outbuilding to be used as dog Granted 25/06/2014 condition(s) Littleover, Derby, DE23 grooming parlour - removal of condition 1 of Conditionally 7UN previously approved permission DER/03/13/00332/PRI to allow permanent use as dog grooming parlour
05/14/00610/PRI Full Planning 116 Pear Tree Crescent, Extensions to dwelling house (2 bedrooms and Refuse 26/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE23 8RR enlargement of lounge and kitchen) together Planning with formation of room in roof space (bedroom) Permission and installation of rear dormer
05/14/00611/DCC Works to Trees under Asda, Derby Road, Crown raise to 4m of two London Plane trees Granted 26/06/2014 TPO Spondon, Derby, DE21 protected by Tree Preservation Order No 407 Conditionally 7UY
05/14/00614/PRI Full Planning Bombardier Erection of buildings for use as office for Granted 22/07/2014 Permission Transportation, Litchurch temporary period Conditionally Lane, Derby, DE24 8AD
05/14/00615/PRI Full Planning Bombardier Litchurch Enlargement of car park and formation of Granted 24/07/2014 Permission Lane, Litchurch Lane, vehicular access Conditionally Derby, DE24 8AD
05/14/00616/PRI Prior Notification 12 Hampton Close, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 09/06/2014 Spondon, Derby, DE21 the rear wall of the original house by 3.71m, required 7QD maximum height 3.63m, height to eaves 2.59m) to dwelling house
Page 21 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 05/14/00617/PRI Prior Notification 245 St. Thomas Road, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 09/06/2014 Derby, DE23 8RJ the rear wall of the original house by 6.0m, required maximum height 3m, height to eaves 3m) to dwelling house
05/14/00618/PRI Full Planning 12 Buttermere Drive, Erection of first floor extension to dwelling house Granted 24/06/2014 Permission Allestree, Derby, DE22 (bedroom and shower room) Conditionally 2SN
05/14/00620/PRI Full Planning 95 Havenbaulk Lane, Extension to dwelling house (porch and Granted 11/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 enlargement of bedroom) together with erection Conditionally 7AD of gable and pitched roof to front elevation
05/14/00621/PRI Full Planning Barclays Plc, 22-26 St. Installation of air conditioning unit and erection Granted 27/06/2014 Permission Peters Street, Derby, DE1 of security cage Conditionally 1SH
05/14/00623/PRI Full Planning 52 Crewe Street, Derby, Two storey and single storey rear extension to Granted 01/07/2014 Permission DE23 8QL dwelling house (bathroom and bedroom) Conditionally
05/14/00625/PRI Full Planning 95 Station Road, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 11/06/2014 Permission Mickleover, Derby, DE3 (porch and enlargement of breakfast Conditionally 5FP room/kitchen) together with erection of detached garage and formation of additional access off Station Road
05/14/00626/PRI Works to Trees under 2 Tiber Close, Alvaston, Felling of Oak tree protected by Tree Refuse 27/06/2014 TPO Derby, DE24 0TQ Preservation Order No 563 Planning Permission
05/14/00627/PRI Full Planning 5 Westcroft Avenue, Single storey and two storey rear extensions to Granted 11/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 dwelling house (bedroom and enlargement of Conditionally 7NN kitchen and dining room)
05/14/00628/PRI Full Planning 23 Shardlow Road, Change of use of ground floor from education Granted 02/07/2014 Permission Alvaston, Derby, DE24 0JG training (Use Class D1) to Beauty Salon (Sui Conditionally Generis Use)
Page 22 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 05/14/00629/PRI Non-material 1 Woodcroft, Littleover, Two storey side and single storey front extensions Granted 04/06/2014 amendment Derby, DE23 7DR to dwelling house (porch, living room, 2 bedrooms and enlargement of garage) non-material amendment to previously approved planning permission DER/02/14/00258 to amend ground floor window to circular bay window)
05/14/00631/PRI Prior Notification 11a, Birches Road, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 09/06/2014 Allestree, Derby, DE22 the rear wall of the original house by 8.0m, required 2HY maximum height 4m, height to eaves 2.8m) to dwelling house
05/14/00632/PRI Prior Notification 104 Morley Road, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Refuse 16/06/2014 Chaddesden, Derby, DE21 the rear wall of the house by 5.2m, maximum Planning 4QX height 3m, height to eaves 3m) to dwelling Permission house
05/14/00633/DCC Variation/Waive of Site of Clarion Works, Demolition of printing works, erection of nine Granted 04/07/2014 condition(s) Webster Street, Derby, DE1 dwellings with access, layout of car parking, Conditionally landscaping and boundary treatment - removal of condition 9 and variation to condition 1 (site plan) of previously approved planning permission Code No.DER/01/10/00035/PRI
05/14/00637/PRI Full Planning 5 Donington Drive, Single and two storey extension to rear of Granted 02/07/2014 Permission Sunnyhill, Derby, DE23 dwelling house (enlargement of kitchen, dining Conditionally 7LZ room and bathroom) and erection of detached garage
05/14/00640/PRI Local Council own 37 Buttermere Drive, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 30/06/2014 development Reg 3 Allestree, Derby, DE22 (lobby, shower room/w.c) Conditionally 2SP
05/14/00641/DCC Local Council own St. Giles School, Extension to school (lobby entrance) Granted 04/07/2014 development Reg 3 Hampshire Road, Derby, Conditionally DE21 6BT
Page 23 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 05/14/00642/PRI Full Application - 127 Birchover Way, Single storey extension to dwelling (utility room, Granted 30/06/2014 disabled People Allestree, Derby, DE22 bathroom and enlargement of kitchen) and Conditionally 2DB installation of access ramps
05/14/00643/PRI Advertisement consent Site of former Derby Police Display of 2 externally illuminated projecting Withdrawn 12/06/2014 Station, Full Street, signs, 4 internally illuminated building mounted Application Derby, DE1 2EN vertical signs, 1 internally illuminated building mounted fascia sign and 1 no. internally illuminated projecting sign.
05/14/00645/ Full Planning 62 Lincoln Avenue, Derby, Two storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 21/07/2014 Permission DE24 8QX (enlargement of kitchen and bedroom) Conditionally
05/14/00646/ Certificate of 115 Locko Road, Erection of garage Granted 18/07/2014 Lawfulness Proposed Spondon, Derby, DE21 Use 7AP
05/14/00647/PRI Full Planning 137B Rykneld Road, Installation of metal railings and 1.9m high Granted 09/07/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 double gates to front boundary Conditionally 4AL
05/14/00648/PRI Advertisement consent The 3AAA County Ground, Display of two non illuminated signs Granted 09/07/2014 The Gateway Centre, Conditionally Grandstand Road, Derby, DE21 6AF
05/14/00649/PRI Full Planning 154 Carsington Crescent, Two storey and single storey rear extensions to Granted 30/06/2014 Permission Allestree, Derby, DE22 dwelling house (dining room, bedroom and Conditionally 2QU enlargement of kitchen)
05/14/00650/ Full Planning 851 Osmaston Road, Change of use from Retail (Use Class A1) to Nail Granted 02/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE24 9BR Bar (Sui Generis Use) Conditionally
05/14/00651/PRI Prior Notification 4 Realm Close, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Refuse 24/06/2014 Chellaston, Derby the rear wall of the original house by 4.7m, Planning maximum height 3.4m, height to eaves 2.4m) to Permission dwelling house
Page 24 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 05/14/00652/PRI Prior Notification 32 Burnside Drive, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 25/06/2014 Spondon, Derby, DE21 the rear wall of the original house by 5.1m, required 7QQ maximum height 3.9m, height to eaves 2.6m) to dwelling house
05/14/00653/PRI Works to Trees under 1 East Avenue, Mickleover, Felling of Pine tree protected by Tree Granted 18/07/2014 TPO Derby, DE3 5FR Preservation Order No 8 Conditionally
05/14/00655/DCC Local Council own St. Clares School, Rough Installation of replacement windows, doors and Granted 25/06/2014 development Reg 3 Heanor Road, Mickleover, cladding Conditionally Derby, DE3 5AZ
05/14/00656/PRI Full Planning Land at Wilmore Road, Formation of vehicular access Granted 28/07/2014 Permission Sinfin, Derby Conditionally
05/14/00659/PRI Full Planning 8 Haddon Close, Allestree, Erection of detached garage Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE22 2LU Conditionally
05/14/00661/PRI Prior Notification 78 Hillsway, Littleover, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Granted 16/06/2014 Derby, DE23 7DX the rear wall of the original house by 6.0m, maximum height 3.75m, height to eaves 2.4m) to dwelling house
05/14/00662/PRI Local Council own 6 St. Michaels View, Single storey side extension to dwelling house Granted 25/06/2014 development Reg 3 Alvaston, Derby, DE24 (bedroom and shower room) Conditionally 0SY
05/14/00664/PRI Prior Notification 107 Dale Road, Spondon, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 16/06/2014 Derby, DE21 7DJ the rear wall of the original house by 5.98m, required maximum height 3.78m, height to eaves 2.4m) to dwelling house
Page 25 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 05/14/00665/PRI Non-material 116 Birchover Way, Two storey extension to dwelling house Granted 24/06/2014 amendment Allestree, Derby, DE22 (bedroom, en-suite, utility room, w.c. and 2DA enlargement of garage, kitchen and bedroom) - non-material amendment to previously approved planning permission DER/10/11/01268 to change garage/store to office/study, amend garage door to window, enlarge extension by 62 mm, relocate windows in ensuite, amend front window and remove side window in bedroom 3 and internal amendment to master bedroom
05/14/00666/PRI Full Planning 25 Evans Avenue, Installation of side dormer window and pitched Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Allestree, Derby, DE22 roof to garage Conditionally 2EL
05/14/00667/PRI Full Planning 458 Duffield Road, Derby, Two storey side and single storey rear extensions Granted 30/06/2014 Permission DE22 2DH to dwelling house (sitting room, larder, study, Conditionally bedroom, en-suite, dressing room, balcony and enlargement of dining room), formation of rooms in roof space (2 bedrooms, bathroom and walk in wardrobe) and erection of detached double garage
05/14/00670/PRI Full Planning 207 Blagreaves Lane, Two storey side and rear extensions to dwelling Granted 24/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 house (sitting room, wet room, utility room and 2 Conditionally 7PW bedrooms) and single storey front extension (porch)
05/14/00671/PRI Prior Notification 11 Mill Street, Derby, DE1 Change of use from offices (Use Class B1) to Granted 24/07/2014 1DY residential (Use Class C3) on top floor and part of ground floor
05/14/00673/PRI Full Planning 18 St. Peters Street, Derby, Change of use from Use Class A1 (retail) to Use Refuse 18/07/2014 Permission DE1 1SH Class A2 (financial and professional services) and Planning Use Class B1 (offices) Permission
05/14/00674/PRI Full Planning 13 Ford Lane, Allestree, First floor extension to dwelling house (bedroom Refuse 16/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE22 2EX and en-suite/dressing room) Planning Permission
Page 26 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 05/14/00675/PRI Demolition-Prior Derwent Cogeneration Demolition of 5 storage tanks, 2 water tanks, 1 Granted 20/06/2014 Notification Limited Power Station, cooling tower plant and equipment and Conditionally Holme Lane, Spondon, administrative buildings Derby, DE21 7BS
05/14/00676/PRI Full Planning 25 Thorntree Lane, Derby, Alterations to front elevation including Granted 15/07/2014 Permission DE1 2JZ (Britannia Cafe reinstatement of timber windows and door Conditionally Bar)
05/14/00678/ Full Planning 47 Shardlow Road, Single storey rear extension (enlargement of Granted 15/07/2014 Permission Alvaston, Derby, DE24 0JP kitchen) and erection of detached garage Conditionally
05/14/00679/PRI Variation/Waive of London Road Community Installation of solar panels and associated Granted 15/07/2014 condition(s) Hospital , London Road, equipment - variation of condition 2 to amend Conditionally Derby, DE1 2QY plans of previously approved planning permission Code No. DER/12/13/01416
05/14/00680/PRI Full Planning 7 Brindle Way, Littleover, Conversion of garage to habitable room (living Invalid - Finally 16/06/2014 Permission Derby room) Disposed of
05/14/00684/PRI Full Planning 38 Chain Lane, Two storey and single storey rear extensions to Granted 19/06/2014 Permission Mickleover, Derby, DE3 dwelling house (kitchen, dining room and Conditionally 5AL bedroom)
05/14/00685/PRI Full Planning 117 Brisbane Road, Two storey side extension to dwelling house (two Granted 01/07/2014 Permission Mickleover, Derby, DE3 bedrooms and enlargement of kitchen) Conditionally 5LP
05/14/00688/ Full Planning 26 Eastcroft Avenue, Single storey side extension to dwelling (living Granted 25/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 room, bedroom and wetroom) Conditionally 7NL
05/14/00690/PRI Full Planning 32 Hilltop, Oakwood, Formation of rooms in roof space including Refuse 08/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE21 4FX installation of front dormer window Planning Permission
05/14/00691/PRI Full Planning 3 Bath Road, Mickleover, Extensions to bungalow (kitchen/dining/sitting Granted 11/07/2014 Permission DE3 9BW room, en-suite and enlargement of bedroom) Conditionally
Page 27 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 05/14/00694/PRI Certificate of 157 Stenson Road, Derby, Extension to dwelling (rear dormer) Granted 21/07/2014 Lawfulness Proposed DE23 7JJ Use
05/14/00695/PRI Full Planning 3 Regis Close, Oakwood, First floor extension to dwelling house (bedroom Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE21 2QL and en-suite) Conditionally
Page 28 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 05/14/00696/PRI Non-material Derby Dance Centre Extensions to dance centre (theatre wing, lobby Granted 25/07/2014 amendment (Deda) ,19 Chapel Street, and link). Non-material amendment to amend Derby, DE1 3GU the wording of Conditions 3 and 4 of previously approved planning permission Code No. DER/09/13/01082:
3.The construction of the theatre right wing shall not take place until a Written Scheme of Investigation for archaeological monitoring has been submitted to and approved by the Local Planning Authority in writing. The scheme shall include an assessment of significance and research questions; and 1. The programme and methodology of site investigation and recording 2. The programme and provision to be made for post investigation analysis and reporting; 3. Provision to be made for publication and dissemination of the analysis and records of the site investigation 4. Provision to be made for archive deposition of the analysis and records of the site investigation 5. Nomination of a competent person or persons/organization to undertake the works set out within the Written Scheme of Investigation.
No development shall take place other than in accordance with the approved archaeological Written Scheme of Investigation.
4. The right wing shall not be occupied until the site investigation and post investigation reporting has been completed in accordance with the programme set out in the archaeological Written Scheme of Investigation approved under condition 3 and the provision to be made for publication and dissemination of results and archive deposition has been secured.
Page 29 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date
05/14/00697/PRI Works to Trees in a 22 North Parade, Derby, Felling of 5 Eucalyptus Trees within Strutts Park Raise No 16/06/2014 Conservation Area DE1 3AY Conservation Area Objection
05/14/00698/PRI Certificate of 40 Grange Road, Alvaston, Formation of room in roof space Granted 21/07/2014 Lawfulness Proposed Derby, DE24 0JX Use
05/14/00699/PRI Works to Trees under 82 Chestnut Avenue, Felling of Horse Chestnut Tree protected by Tree Granted 23/07/2014 TPO Mickleover, Derby, DE3 Preservation Order No. 8 Conditionally 5FS
05/14/00700/PRI Works to Trees under 80A Chestnut Avenue, Removal of branch of Horse Chestnut tree Granted 23/07/2014 TPO Mickleover, Derby, DE3 protected by Tree Preservation Order No. 8 Conditionally 5FS
05/14/00701/DC5 Prior Notification Land at Bus Terminal, Erection of 12.5m high replacement monopole, Raise No 09/07/2014 corner of Wellesley 3 antennae, 2 equipment cabinets and ancilliary Objection Avenue and Stenson works Road, Derby, DE23
05/14/00703/PRI Full Planning 18 Glenwood Road, Two storey side extension to dwelling house Granted 27/06/2014 Permission Chellaston, Derby, DE73 (kitchen and bedroom) Conditionally 1UB
05/14/00704/PRI Works to Trees in a 178 Duffield Road, Derby, Felling of 4 Conifer trees within Strutts Park Raise No 16/06/2014 Conservation Area DE22 1BH Conservation Area Objection
05/14/00707/PRI Full Planning 8 Eaton Close, Allestree, Conversion of garage and single storey Granted 22/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE22 2FD extensions to form annexe (bedroom, en-suite, Conditionally kitchen/living area) and conservatory
05/14/00708/PRI Works to Trees under Land at rear of 9a - 15 Removal of sorbus tree protected by Tree Granted 23/07/2014 TPO Kings Croft, land rear of 16 Preservation Order No.471 Conditionally to 24 and site of 20 Devonshire Avenue, Allestree, Derby, DE22 2AT
05/14/00712/PRI Full Planning 9 Pavilion Road, First floor side extension to dwelling house Granted 25/06/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 (bedroom and en-suite) Conditionally Page 30 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 6XL
05/14/00713/PRI Full Planning 22 Highfield Road, Derby, Extension to dwelling house (side dormer) Granted 30/06/2014 Permission DE22 1GZ Conditionally
05/14/00714/PRI Advertisement consent McDonalds Restaurant, Display of non illuminated sign Granted 22/07/2014 Kingsway, Derby, DE22 Conditionally 4AA
05/14/00715/DC5 Full Planning 254, Abbey Street, Derby, Installation of 6 replacement antennae and Granted 02/07/2014 Permission DE22 erection of 4 equipment cabinets
05/14/00716/PRI Prior Notification 43 Pinglehill Way, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 25/06/2014 Chellaston, Derby, DE73 the rear wall of the original house by 3.5m, required 1NB maximum height 3.2m, height to eaves 2.1m) to dwelling house
05/14/00719/PRI Prior Notification 12 Weirfield Road, Darley Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 24/06/2014 Abbey, Derby, DE22 1DH the rear wall of the original house by 5m, required maximum height 4m, height to eaves 2.7m) to dwelling house
05/14/00720/PRI Works to Trees under 11 Knoll Close, Littleover, Crown reduction of beech tree by 2.5m protected Granted 23/07/2014 TPO Derby, DE23 7SG by Tree Preservation Order No. 30 Conditionally
05/14/00721/PRI Works to Trees in a 2 Etwall Road, Mickleover, Crown reduction by 3-4m of Sycamore tree Raise No 03/07/2014 Conservation Area Derby, DE3 5DL within Mickleover Conservation Area Objection
05/14/00725/PRI Advertisement consent 44 Sadler Gate, Derby, Display of non-illuminated fascia and hanging Granted 23/07/2014 DE1 3NQ sign Conditionally
05/14/00726/PRI Prior Notification 27 Field Lane, Alvaston, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 25/06/2014 Derby, DE24 0GP the rear wall of the original house by 3.815m, required maximum height 3.1m, height to eaves 2.25m) to dwelling house
05/14/00728/PRI Full Planning 53-55 Normanton Road, Erection of detached garage block Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE1 Conditionally
05/14/00732/PRI Full Planning Cemetery, Nottingham Erection of 1.8m high railings and gates, Granted 28/07/2014 Permission Road, Derby, DE21 6FN erection of shelter, formation of road and path Conditionally network and 24 parking bays Page 31 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date
05/14/00733/PRI Full Planning 6 Kelmoor Road, Alvaston, Extension to dwelling house (formation of Granted 27/06/2014 Permission Derby, DE24 0PJ pitched room to side extension) and erection of Conditionally detached garage
05/14/00734/PRI Prior Notification 4 & 5 Trinity Terrace,109 Change of use from offices (Use Class B1) to 3 Granted 24/07/2014 London Road, Derby, DE1 flats (Use Class C3) on ground floor 2QS
06/14/00735/DC5 Full Planning Nottingham Road Fire Installation of a replacement 15m high Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Station, Nottingham Road, telecommunications column, 12m high flagpole Conditionally Derby, DE21 6PD and replacement equipment cabinet
06/14/00737/PRI Prior Notification 168 Slack Lane, Derby, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 25/06/2014 DE22 3EE the rear wall of the original house by 6m, required maximum height 2.75m, height to eaves 2.75m) to dwelling house
06/14/00738/PRI Advertisement consent Dean & Smedley Chemist, Display of 1 internally illuminated fascia sign Granted 24/07/2014 Unit 2, Heatherton District and 1 non-illuminated fascia sign Conditionally Centre, Hollybrook Way, Littleover, Derby, DE23 7TU
06/14/00739/PRI Full Planning Expo Unit 8, Prime Park Change of use from storage and distribution (Use Granted 21/07/2014 Permission Way, Derby, DE1 3QB Class B8) to car sales (Sui Generis use) Conditionally
06/14/00741/PRI Prior Notification 85 Grasmere Crescent, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 03/07/2014 Sinfin, Derby, DE24 9HT the rear wall of the original house by 4.5m, required maximum height 3.25m, height to eaves 2.25m) to dwelling house
06/14/00743/PRI Prior Notification 11 Moorside Crescent, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 26/06/2014 Sinfin, Derby, DE24 9PH the rear wall of the original house by 6m, required maximum height 3m, height to eaves 3m) to dwelling house
06/14/00744/PRI Advertisement consent 18 St. Peters Street, Derby, Display of internally illuminated fascia sign and Withdrawn 29/07/2014 DE1 1SH internally illuminated projecting sign Application
06/14/00746/PRI Full Planning Lawn Junior & Infant Re-cladding of front elevation of school Granted 03/07/2014 Permission School, Norbury Close, Conditionally Page 32 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date Allestree, Derby, DE22 2QR
06/14/00747/PRI Full Planning 29-33, Nightingale Road, Change of use from retail (Use Class A1) to five Granted 21/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE24 8BG apartments (Use Class C3) including alterations Conditionally to the front and rear elevations
06/14/00748/PRI Full Planning 1 Pastures Avenue, Front, side and rear extensions to dwelling Granted 02/07/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 (sitting room, utility room, w.c, dining room, Conditionally 7BE living room and enlargement of bedroom and porch) and erection of detached double garage to front of property
06/14/00749/PRI Full Planning Unit A3, Cranmer Road, Change of use from General Industrial (Use Class Granted 21/07/2014 Permission West Meadows Industrial B2) to Business (Use Class B1), Industrial (Use Conditionally Estate, Derby, DE21 6JL Class B2) and storage (Use Class B8)
06/14/00750/PRI Full Planning 163 Holcombe Street, Erection of detached refrigerated storage Granted 04/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE23 8JD building Conditionally
06/14/00751/PRI Full Planning Unit A4, Cranmer Road, Change of use from General Industrial (Use Class Granted 21/07/2014 Permission West Meadows Industrial B2) to Business (Use Class B1), Industrial (Use Conditionally Estate, Derby, DE21 Class B2) and storage (Use Class B8)
06/14/00752/PRI Full Planning Unit A6, West Meadows Change of use from General Industrial (Use Class Granted 21/07/2014 Permission Industrial Estate, Cranmer B2) to Business (Use Class B1), Industrial (Use Conditionally Road, Derby Class B2) and storage (Use Class B8)
06/14/00753/PRI Full Planning Unit A5, Cranmer Road, Change of use from General Industrial (Use Class Granted 21/07/2014 Permission West Meadows Industrial B2) to Business (Use Class B1), Industrial (Use Conditionally Estate, Derby, DE21 Class B2) and storage (Use Class B8)
06/14/00755/PRI Advertisement consent Chapel Street Car Park, Display of non-illuminated banner PVC mesh Granted 28/07/2014 Chapel Street, Derby, DE1 sign. Conditionally
06/14/00761/PRI Full Planning 46 Eastwood Drive, Rear extensions to dwelling house (kitchen, Granted 24/07/2014 Permission Littleover, Derby, DE23 dining room, cloakroom, pantry and 2 bedrooms) Conditionally 6BN
06/14/00763/PRI Full Planning 41 Caroline Close, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 24/07/2014 Permission Alvaston, Derby, DE24 (sun room and enlargement of kitchen) Conditionally 0QX Page 33 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date
06/14/00766/PRI Full Planning 100 Booth Street, Erection of garage/garden room Granted 02/07/2014 Permission Alvaston, Derby, DE24 Conditionally 8PH
06/14/00767/PRI Works to Trees in a Hawthorn Court, 27 Pruning of various trees within Strutts Park Raise No 26/06/2014 Conservation Area Kedleston Road, Derby, Conservation Area Objection DE22 1FY
06/14/00769/PRI Full Planning 78 Littleover Lane, Derby, Single storey front extensions to dwelling house Granted 02/07/2014 Permission DE23 6JG (enlargement of hall and dining room) Conditionally
06/14/00773/PRI Full Planning 67 Fairway Crescent, Single storey front extension to dwelling house Granted 18/07/2014 Permission Allestree, Derby, DE22 (bay window and canopy) Conditionally 2PB
06/14/00775/PRI Prior Notification 18 Beech Drive, Derby, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 03/07/2014 DE22 1AT the rear wall of the original house by 3.5m, required maximum height 3.6m, height to eaves 2.25m) to dwelling house
06/14/00776/PRI Prior Notification 10 Chesterton Avenue, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 03/07/2014 Sunnyhill, Derby, DE23 the rear wall of the original house by 3.9m, required 7GS maximum height 3m, height to eaves 3m) to dwelling house
06/14/00778/PRI Full Planning Unit A, Chequers Lane, Installation of external condenser units and Granted 28/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE21 6AW replacement of 3 ventilation louvres and Conditionally associated works
06/14/00779/PRI Full Planning Pentaxia, 40 Longbridge External alterations to include installation of new Granted 28/07/2014 Permission Lane, Derby, DE24 windows and fire escape, erection of boundary Conditionally fence and gates.
06/14/00782/PRI Full Planning 86 Empress Road, Derby, Formation of rooms in roof space (2 bedrooms Granted 23/07/2014 Permission DE23 6TE and shower room) and installation of side Conditionally dormer.
06/14/00783/PRI Full Planning 42 Streatham Road, Single storey front and side extension to Granted 17/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE22 4AZ dwelling house (porch and cloakroom) Conditionally
06/14/00787/PRI Prior Notification 105 Brisbane Road, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 11/07/2014 Page 34 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date Mickleover, Derby, DE3 the rear wall of the original house by 4m, required 5LQ maximum height 3m, height to eaves 2.1m) to dwelling house
06/14/00789/PRI Works to Trees under 7 Lindford Close, Reduction by 3m of 2 overhanging branches, Granted 23/07/2014 TPO Oakwood, Derby, DE21 crown reduction by 1-2m and crown thin by 5% Conditionally 4TA of Oak tree protected by Tree Preservation Order No 11
06/14/00790/PRI Works to Trees under 9 Lindford Close, Deadwooding and reduction by 3m of Granted 23/07/2014 TPO Oakwood, Derby, DE21 overhanging branches of 3 Oak trees protected Conditionally 4TA by Tree Preservation Order No 11
06/14/00791/PRI Prior Notification 1a, Friary Street, Derby, Change of use from offices (use class B1) to Withdrawn 26/06/2014 DE1 1JF residential (use class C3) Application
06/14/00794/PRI Full Planning 7 Orlando Court, Two storey side extension to dwelling house Granted 24/07/2014 Permission Chellaston, Derby, DE73 (family room, bedroom, and en-suite) and Conditionally 5BJ formation of rooms in roof space (bedroom and en-suite) and installation of 2 dormer windows - amendment to previously approved planning permission Code No. DER/02/14/00190
06/14/00804/PRI Works to Trees under Croft House, 5 Siddals Felling of sycamore, reduction in height to 6m Granted 28/07/2014 TPO Lane, Allestree, Derby, of Yew trees , reduction to 4-5m of Holly trees Conditionally DE22 2DY and crown lifting to 3m of Sycamores all protected by Tree Preservation Order No 107
06/14/00806/PRI Full Planning The Spinning Wheel, 96 Change of use of first floor to 2 apartments (Use Permitted 20/06/2014 Permission Wood Road, Chaddesden, Class C3) Development Derby, DE21 4LZ
06/14/00808/PRI Works to Trees under 20 Otter Street, Derby, Felling of Silver Birch tree protected by Tree Granted 18/07/2014 TPO DE1 3FB Preservation Order No. 307 Conditionally
06/14/00811/PRI Full Planning 6-8, Stenson Road, Derby, Installation of satellite antennae, aerial and 3 air Granted 23/07/2014 Permission DE23 7JA conditioning units Conditionally
06/14/00812/PRI Advertisement consent 6-8, Stenson Road, Derby, Display of internally illuminated fascia sign and Granted 21/07/2014 DE23 7JA internally illuminated projecting sign Conditionally
06/14/00821/PRI Full Planning Land adjacent 98 St. Erection of bungalow Granted 23/07/2014 Page 35 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date Permission Chads Road, Derby Conditionally
06/14/00826/PRI Full Planning 143 Osmaston Park Road, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 24/07/2014 Permission Derby, DE23 8WL (dining room and kitchen) Conditionally
06/14/00827/PRI Prior Notification 9 Ainsworth Drive, Derby, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 18/07/2014 DE23 7GJ the rear wall of the original house by 6m, required maximum height 2.65m, height to eaves 2.65m) to dwelling house
06/14/00833/PRI Non-material Mcdonalds Restaurant, Formation of additional 'drive thru' lane, Granted 16/07/2014 amendment Kingsway, Derby, DE22 reorganisation of car park to include formation of 4AA an additional 13 spaces, installation of 2 customer order display units, re-location of a booth window and installation of cladding to booth- non material amendment to previously approved Code No. DER/03/13/00247 to relocate booth windows
06/14/00834/PRI Non-material Rolls Royce Plc, Wilmore Demolition of ancillary buildings and removal of Granted 30/06/2014 amendment Road, Derby, DE24 9BD temporary structures. Extension of PTF building (office and manufacturing space) reconfiguration of internal access roads, erection of gatehouse and formation of additional parking spaces together with landscaping and associated engineering works - Non-material amendment to previously approved planning permission DER/10/13/01208 to amend the design of elevations and permanent closure of Gate 7 including removal of paved area and replacement with associated landscaping and footway
06/14/00835/PRI Full Planning 27 Malvern Close, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 24/07/2014 Permission Mickleover, Derby, DE3 (orangery) Conditionally 5SX
06/14/00837/PRI Works to Trees under 24 Charingworth Road, Felling of Hawthorn tree protected by Tree Granted 28/07/2014 TPO Oakwood, Derby, DE21 Preservation Order No 31 Conditionally 2QD
Page 36 of 37 Enclosure Application No Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Date 06/14/00848/PRI Prior Notification 204 Rykneld Road, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 24/07/2014 Littleover, Derby, DE23 the rear wall of the original house by 4.95m, required 4AN maximum height 3.4m, height to eaves 3.4m) to dwelling house
06/14/00850/DCC Local Council own Griffon Gale Flats, Elton Erection of roof over recyle bin store Granted 23/07/2014 development Reg 3 Road, Derby, DE24 8ED Conditionally
06/14/00855/PRI Full Planning 24 Holborn Drive, Derby, Single storey rear extension to dwelling house Granted 28/07/2014 Permission DE22 4DW (dining room) Conditionally
06/14/00856/PRI Outline Planning Land rear of 34 Glenwood Residential development (one dwelling house) Refuse 23/07/2014 Permission Road, Chellaston, DE73 Planning 6UB Permission
06/14/00860/PRI Works to Trees in a 58 Arthur Street, Derby, Felling of 2 Lime trees within Strutts Park Raise No 23/07/2014 Conservation Area DE1 3EH Conservation Area Objection
06/14/00881/PRI Prior Notification 20 Summerville Close, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 24/07/2014 Littleover, Derby, DE23 the rear wall of the original house by 4.5m, required 3UU maximum height 3.57m, height to eaves 2.25m) to dwelling house
06/14/00887/PRI Demolition-Prior Rolls Royce, Moor Lane, Demolition of Data Centre and Canteen Granted 17/07/2014 Notification Sinfin Derby
07/14/00890/PRI Prior Notification 221 Uttoxeter Road, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 24/07/2014 Mickleover, Derby, DE3 the rear wall of the original house by 5.175m, required 5AX maximum height 4.297m, height to eaves 2.35m) to dwelling house
07/14/00898/PRI Prior Notification 46 Kenilworth Avenue, Single storey rear extension (projecting beyond Approval Not 28/07/2014 Derby, DE23 8TY the rear wall of the original house by 4.3m, required maximum height 3.8m, height to eaves 2.7m) to dwelling house
Total Number of Delegated Decisions made during this period: 324
Page 37 of 37 Enclosure