THESE Agathe Colléony D'histoire NATURELLE MUSEUM NATIONAL
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MUSEUM NATIONAL D’HISTOIRE NATURELLE Ecole Doctorale Sciences de la Nature et de l’Homme – ED 227 Année 2016 N°attribué par la bibliothèque |_|_|_|_|_|_|_|_|_|_|_|_| THESE Pour obtenir le grade de DOCTEUR DU MUSEUM NATIONAL D’HISTOIRE NATURELLE Spécialité : Sciences de la Conservation Présentée et soutenue publiquement par Agathe Colléony Le 14 Octobre 2016 Evaluation du potentiel des zoos à reconnecter les citoyens à la nature et aux enjeux de conservation -------------------------- Evaluating the potential of zoos in reconnecting people with nature and conservation issues Sous la direction de : Anne-Caroline Prévot, co-dirigée par Susan Clayton et Michel Saint Jalme JURY : M. Pascal Marty Directeur de recherche, Ecole Normale Supérieure de Lyon Rapporteur Mme Birgitta Gatersleben Senior Lecturer, Université de Surrey, Guildford Rapporteure M. François Bousquet Centre de coopération International en Recherche Agronomique pour le Examinateur Développement, Montpellier Mme Laure Kloetzer Assistant Professor, Université de Neuchâtel Examinatrice Mme Anne-Caroline Prévot Directrice de recherche CNRS, Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle, Paris Directrice de thèse Mme Susan Clayton Professor, College de Wooster, Ohio Co-directrice de thèse M. Michel Saint Jalme Directeur de la Ménagerie et Maitre de conférence, Muséum national d’Histoire Co-directeur de thèse naturelle, Paris Acknowlegments I would like to first thank the two reviewers, Birgitta Gatersleben and Pascal Marty, as well as Laure Kloetzer and François Bousquet, who also examined my PhD thesis. I am also grateful to Barbara Bonnefoy and Véronique Servais, whose advices contributed a lot to the effective conduct of the project. A special thank to my PhD supervisors, Anne-Caroline, Susan and Michel, without whom none of this would have been possible. Anne-Caroline, thank you for being so kind and always available for me (even when I asked you to review several manuscripts at once…), for being always positive and encouraging in your manuscript reviews, and for all the great ideas that came out from discussing with you. Susan, thank you for your kindness and very useful advices. Because supervising my project from overseas might not have been so easy, thank you for having dedicated some of your time to our regular skype sessions, for receiving me in the US, and for your visit in Paris to help me finalize the thesis. Michel, thank you for being so kind, and for endless discussions on zoo animals and events. Thank you also for having dedicated me some of your time, as the management of the Menagerie may take a huge amount of time. I am grateful to the three of you, who all contributed to the effective conduct of the project, through (necessary) complementary areas of expertise. Finally, and most importantly, I want to thank you for your continuing support, which contributed to the overall great experience of PhD I add in the past three years. I also want to thank the directors of two zoos I focused on during this project, Rolland Simon and Sophie Ferreira, for giving me the opportunity to conduct research in the zoos, and for facilitating procedures to do so. I would also like to thank the persons in charge of educational programs at the zoos, Elisabeth Quertier, Mathilde Rebuffaut and Patrick Roux, for their help. Additionally, I am glad to have met Gerald Dick, Markus Gusset and Tiago Pinto-Pereira at zoo conferences, three very nice persons I spent time with at conferences where I did not know anybody at first. Moreover, this project would not have been the same without the various interns I (more or less) supervised (Thank you again Anne-Caroline for your HUGE help in supervising them!): Julie, Noémie, Nadine, Chloé, Vincent, Hélène and Léo. They helped me explore different elements regarding my overall research question, which contributed to the shaping of the project. I am also grateful for their kindness and good works. I want to thank all the members of the CESCO lab, who contribute to its great and friendly atmosphere in which I am glad to have conducted my thesis. Despite this highly friendly atmosphere, the lab remains a hub of a large variety of strongly qualified researchers that I am glad to have somehow worked or interacted with. I am thus grateful first to Romain Julliard and Denis Couvet, present and former directors of the lab. More specifically, I would like to thank Aurélie, Ariane, Hortense, Leyli and Christie, who were at the middle (or end) of their PhDs when I started mine. Aurélie, thank you for your kindness and good advices, first as the “colleague working beside me”, then as a friend. Ariane, who first was the “colleague working behind me”, thank you for helping me socially integrate in the lab, and for your kindness and infectious laugh, but also for being (one of) the “mean” person. I would also like to thank Hortense, with whom I share common interest for horses, for her incredible liveliness, and for organizing memorable crazy parties. Christie, thank you for your kindness, no matter what happens, and for being present, either at coffee breaks or more personal discussions. Leyli, thank you for being the person you are (especially for being so little receptive to second degree humor!), and for your kindness and support at a moment I strongly needed it, although you were finishing your PhD. Among the “former” of the lab, it is also worth mentioning Reto, originally from Quebec and Switzerland, but who worked in France and now in UK, for his kindness and very nice accent, Pierre-Yves, for stopping by my office when visiting people at the lab, for nice conversations, first on how to integrate ecological economics in my project (I finally did it!), then on more personal topics, and Marine Legrand, for our very nice conversations on human-nature relationships, and for the “piece of nature” from Scotland she offered me to wish me good fortune. Sharing my work space with Julie M., Fanny (until she left us for another [more quiet?] office), Aurélie, Baptiste, Alan, Flavie, Roman and Minh-Xuan was a great experience. The atmosphere of our office would not have been the same without Julie and her (repeated) phone calls (no offense). I am glad to have shared my office with such a kind person, who will soon be my neighbor! Fanny and Baptiste were also very nice persons who provided me good advices when needed. Although Alan left the lab a few months ago, his jokes still resonate in the office. Minh-Xuan took his desk as soon as Alan left it (yes, it’s a bit the jungle law for office places in the lab). I would like to thank Minh-Xuan for being so nice and supportive, even if he made me feel incompetent taking care at plants. Although we do not see Roman that often, his “nice” posters of cats remind us about his presence. Now that Hortense has left the lab, I can still discuss about horses with Flavie, so kind and supportive as well. Her recent adventures with her students brightened our working days, although I’m not sure she appreciated it that much. Caro does not really share our office, but she is pretty close. I would like to thank Caro for her kindness, infectious laugh, and for our future climbing sessions together. I am also grateful to Ana-Cristina, Nelida, Gabrielle, Kevin, Simon and Fabien for being so nice and supportive, and because I often interrupted their working days for coffee breaks. A special thank to Ana-Cristina, with whom I spent great moments, and who really cares about “human-beans”. Nelida brought Spanish energy (and food!) to the lab, and Gabrielle a bit of bohemian style (which I really like!). I also thank Simon, for his kindness, Kevin, for our nice conversations and hiking, and Fabien, for his kindness, support and jokes (even if I hated him when I found out about the background image of computer). I also thank Fred, for finally accepting to include salsa in his musical playlists. I am also grateful to Jean-François for being so kind and helpful. The trio of bearded men contributed also on a large extent to the nice atmosphere of the lab. The lab would not be the same without his mascot, Theo, with his endless jokes (I really don’t know where you get all these from!). I shouted at a concert (of Theo’s group, by the way) for the first time thanks to Charles. It felt good! I would also like to thank Martin, with whom I discovered (and appreciated) Paris, for his support and for all the great moments we spent together. I would like to particularly thank Maud, Pauline C. and Anne, for their kindness and support, especially when I really needed it. I really appreciated when Maud “rescued” me after I missed the last metro at the end of a party, and our discussions around a cup of tea. The lab would not be the same without Anne, so kind and always willing to help or organize social events. I also deeply thank Pauline C. for her support, kindness, and contagious laugh. I would like to also thank Diane and Romain L. for our future climbing sessions, Claire L. for her help with G.I.S. maps, Marine Levé for her help and for including me in a collaborative project, Léo, for his kindness, enthusiasm and humor, and Nico for his contagious cheerfulness, and for always being ready to help, or join. I am also very grateful to Joanne, with whom I shared great discussions on corporeality.