• Abstract and Figures
• Public Full-text

Antisymmetric cross-correlation of line-intensity maps as a probe of reionization Gabriela Sato-Polito,1, ∗ Jos´eLuis Bernal,1 Ely D. Kovetz,2 and Marc Kamionkowski1 1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA 2Department of Physics, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Be'er Sheva 84105, Israel We present a new estimator for the cross-correlation signal between line intensity maps to probe the Epoch of Reionization. The proposed estimator is the hitherto neglected antisymmetric com- ponent of the cross-correlation, under the exchange of line-of-sight positions. We consider the cross-correlation between HI and CO fluctuations, and forecast the improvement in precision on reionization parameters when the antisymmetric contribution is accounted for. As a way to break the degeneracy between astrophysics and cosmology in the intensity mapping power spectrum, we study the ratio between the antisymmetric and symmetric components. While our results depend on the highly uncertain astrophysical modelling, we show that in most standard scenarios including the antisymmetric contribution as a complementary probe can lead to a significant gain in information. I. INTRODUCTION to be an excellent probe of large-scale structure at high- redshifts, and will help elucidate the properties of the Line-intensity mapping (LIM) is a technique that mea- first stars and galaxies. Using different lines in conjunc- sures the integrated emission from atomic or molecular tion, such as 21-cm and CO, will enable the mapping of transitions of all sources along the line of sight [1]. This both the neutral gas in the IGM and the galaxy distri- can be used to measure the spatial fluctuations in the in- bution over the same cosmological volumes [6, 7]. Cross- tensity of a given spectral line, with the radial position of correlation between these lines holds great promise for the source determined by the frequency of the redshifted probing the onset and evolution of reionization [21]. line. While observations of the cosmic microwave back- In its most general form, the two-point correlation ground (CMB) and galaxy surveys have mapped the early function depends on the orientation and position of the and late Universe with great precision [2, 3], large cos- two points. While it is often assumed that the corre- mological volumes at intermediate redshifts remain un- lation function is invariant under the exchange in posi- charted. At high redshifts galaxies become too faint and tion r ! −r, this does not necessarily hold for cross- sparse, such that individual detections are insufficient for correlations between different tracers of the matter den- statistically significant cosmological measurements. sity field. This asymmetry in the galaxy cross-correlation LIM of different spectral lines across a wide range under the exchange of galaxy pairs has been studied of redshifts will bridge between the volumes probed by both in Fourier and configuration space. Several po- CMB experiments and galaxy surveys (see e.g., [4{9]). tential contributions to the antisymmetric part of the The 21-cm spin-flip transition in neutral hydrogen has cross-correlation have been pointed out, which include been extensively studied as a probe of large-scale struc- gravitational redshift [24, 25], gravitational lensing [26], ture over a wide range of redshifts (see e.g., [10{19]). Doppler shift, light-cone effect, redshift evolution and the Along with these efforts, several other lines have been Alcock-Paczynski effect [27, 28], as well as biased halo proposed as candidates for intensity mapping, such as clustering, local-type primordial non-Gaussianity, early- the rotational lines from carbon monoxide (CO), [CII], Universe vector fields, etc. [29]. Hα, and Hβ, with particular attention given to the com- plementarity between different tracers (see e.g., [20{23]). When applied to LIM, the antisymmetric component The Epoch of Reionization (EoR) is a landmark tran- of the power spectrum is sensitive to the difference in redshift evolution of the temperature and bias of the arXiv:2005.08977v1 [astro-ph.CO] 18 May 2020 sition in the history of the Universe that can be uniquely probed with LIM on cosmological scales. During this pe- cross-correlated lines. We may therefore expect a signifi- riod, the first galaxies and quasars ionized the surround- cant antisymmetric signal during the EoR, as a transition ing neutral hydrogen gas. Upcoming measurements of in the intergalactic medium is rapidly progressing. On the EoR will provide key insights into both astrophysics the other hand, line-intensity fluctuations carry informa- and cosmology. The intensity and distribution of emis- tion about astrophysics and cosmology, and disentangling sion lines during the EoR trace the underlying matter them is one of the main challenges to LIM observations distribution and are sensitive to the astrophysical pro- (see e.g., Ref. [30]). Here we propose two estimators in cesses that took place. The LIM signal therefore promises order to address these challenges: the LIM antisymmetric cross-correlation estimator and the ratio between the an- tisymmetric and symmetric components. We study the detectability of both estimators and forecast their sensi- ∗ [email protected] tivity to reionization parameters as a proof of concept. 2 for LIM fluctuations the smoothing due to the limited an- We present a general framework for the antisymmet- gular resolution of LIM experiments. This can be mod- ric and symmetric components of the LIM angular power X eled as an effective Gaussian beam B` that smooths the spectrum. Since the amplitude of the antisymmetric sig- temperature fluctuations on small scales, restricting the nal depends on the bias and temperature evolution with number of accessible modes. Similarly, the spectral reso- redshift, the only requisite for the choice of spectral lines lution would smooth modes along the line-of-sight. This is that they must evolve unevenly over redshift. We contribution can be neglected as long as the redshift bins choose to study the fluctuations in the intensity of the are larger than the width of the frequency channel. emission produced by the spin-flip transition of neutral The observed transfer function is therefore given by hydrogen (which we refer to as HI line), since they probe Z the spatial structure of reionization directly. We cross- ∆X;zi (k) = dzBX W X (z; z )∆X (k; z); (2) correlate the intensity of this line with the CO(2-1) ro- ` ` i ` tational transition, an excellent tracer of star formation. where Assuming simple analytical models for the line emis- sions, we forecast the uncertainties on reionization pa- `(` + 1)(θX )2 BX = exp − FWHM ; (3) rameters for futuristic LIM experiments. We find that ` 16 log 2 the antisymmetric and symmetric components of the cross-correlation have different degeneracies and there- X θFWHM is the full width at half maximum of the beam fore lead to complementary constraints on the EoR. Al- profile of the experiment targeting the spectral line X, X though the precise gain in information from consider- and W (z; zi) is a normalized window function centered ing the antisymmetric cross-correlation is highly model- on zi which we assume to be a Gaussian. The contribu- dependent, we show that it can be an important addi- X tion to the transfer function ∆` (k; z) for a spectral line tional probe in most scenarios, especially with low noise. X that is related with intrinsic clustering is given by This paper is organized as follows. In Section II we de- scribe our approach to model the LIM power spectrum X X X and its noise. In Section III we present the novel antisym- ∆` (k; z) = T (z)b (z)D(z)j`[kr(z)]; (4) metric estimator, as well as the estimator for the symmet- ric part, and the ratio between them. We then discuss where D(z) is the growth factor defined such that D(0) = 1, j` is a spherical Bessel function of order `, r(z) is the covariance for each estimator. The detectability for a X particular astrophysical model and survey configuration the comoving distance, T (z) is the spatially aver- aged brightness temperature of the spectral line X, and are shown in Section V. The precision to which each esti- X mator can constrain the parameters that describe reion- b (z) is its bias. In Eq. (4) we neglect nonlinear contri- ization, as well as how these constraints depend on the as- butions to clustering and bias, a valid approximation on trophysical modelling and instrumental noise, are shown sufficiently large scales. in Section V as well. We conclude in Section VI. We consider only two contributions to the covariance We adopt the standard ΛCDM cosmology throughout, of the LIM angular power spectrum: sample variance and with the following parameters from Planck 2018 [2]: h = instrumental noise. Residual foreground contamination 0:674, Ω = 0:315, Ω = 0:049, n = 0:965, and σ = 0:8. is another source of noise, but as this work focuses on the m b s 8 cross-correlations between different lines, we can safely neglect it. The instrumental noise power spectrum in a II. LIM ANGULAR POWER SPECTRUM single dish or an interferometer experiment are given by 2 TsysΩfield Our fundamental observable is the spatial fluctuation N dish = ; ` ∆νt N N N of the brightness temperature of a given spectral line, obs feeds pol ant 2 (5) defined as δT ≡ T − hT i. The brightness temperature interf TsysΩfieldΩFOV N` = ; fluctuations can be projected on the sky and expanded ∆ν tobsNfeedsNpolns using spherical harmonics. The angular power spectrum is then defined as the expectation value of the square of where Tsys is the system temperature, Ωfield is the solid the spherical-harmonic coefficients. angle of the sky probed by the survey, ∆ν is the band- The angular power spectrum between two tracers X width corresponding to the redshift bin width, tobs is the observing time, N is the number of antennas with and Y of the matter density field at redshift shells zi and ant N detectors each, that measure N = 1; 2 polar- zj, respectively, is given by feeds pol izations.

Load more

  9

Copy Link