Maine DOT Historic Bridge Survey, Phase II Final Report & Historic
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Maine State Library Digital Maine Transportation Documents Transportation 8-2004 Maine DOT Historic Bridge Survey, Phase II Final Report & Historic Context. 2004 Lichtenstein Consulting Engineers Maine Department of Transportation Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalmaine.com/mdot_docs Recommended Citation Lichtenstein Consulting Engineers and Maine Department of Transportation, "Maine DOT Historic Bridge Survey, Phase II Final Report & Historic Context. 2004" (2004). Transportation Documents. 33. https://digitalmaine.com/mdot_docs/33 This Text is brought to you for free and open access by the Transportation at Digital Maine. It has been accepted for inclusion in Transportation Documents by an authorized administrator of Digital Maine. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Maine DOT Historic Bridge Survey Phase II Final Report & Historic Context Free/Black Bridge, Brunswick #0323. Photo Courtesy MHPC. Prepared by Lichtenstein Consulting Engineers August 2004 PHASE II OF THE HISTORIC BRIDGE SURVEY - FINAL REPORT Table of Contents Introduction .................................................................... iv Section I. Methodology for Field Inspection, Research, and Evaluation ...................I-1 Field Inspection ............................................................I-1 Research ................................................................I-2 Determining Eligibility .......................................................I-3 Criteria for Determining Significance ............................................I-4 Applying the National Register Criteria for Ev aluation ...............................I-5 Bridges in Historic Districts ...................................................I-7 Integrity ..................................................................I-7 Methodology for Finalizing Evaluations of the Stringer, T Beam and Slab Bridges .........I-9 Summary of Results .......................................................I-10 List of Preparers ..........................................................I-11 Section II. Historic Context for Bridge Technology in Maine ........................... II-1 A. Truss Bridges .......................................................... II-1 Wood Truss Bridges ................................................. II-2 Pre-1900 Metal Truss Bridges ......................................... II-3 Post-1900 Steel Truss Bridges ......................................... II-5 B. Movable Bridges ........................................................ II-9 Swing Span Bridges ................................................. II-9 Vertical Lift Bridges ................................................ II-10 C. Suspension Bridges .................................................... II-13 D. Arch Bridges .......................................................... II-15 Stone Arch Bridges ................................................. II-15 Reinforced Concrete Arch Bridges ..................................... II-17 Steel Arch Bridges ................................................. II-21 Structural Steel Plate Corrugated Arches ................................ II-22 E. Rigid Frame Bridges .................................................... II-23 Low-Rise Rigid Frame Bridges ........................................ II-23 High-Rise Rigid Frame Bridges ....................................... II-23 F. Girder-Floorbeam Bridges ............................................... II-24 G. Culverts ............................................................. II-31 Pipe Culverts ..................................................... II-31 Box Culverts ...................................................... II-32 H. Stringer Bridges ....................................................... II-33 I. Reinforced Concrete Slab and T Beam Bridges ................................ II-36 J. Stone Slab (Post and Lintel) Bridges ........................................ II-38 Section III. Highway Bridge Building in Maine by the Maine State Highway Commission, 1905- 1956 ...................................................................III-1 Introduction ..............................................................III-1 The Maine State Highway Commission is Established and Enters the Business of Building Bridges, 1905-1916. .................................................III-2 Activities of the Bridge Div ision, 1916-1928 ....................................III-10 Activities of the Bridge Div ision, 1929-1941 ....................................III-17 Activities of the Bridge Div ision, 1942-1956 ....................................III-24 Conclusion .............................................................III-29 i Section IV: Master List of Surveyed Bridges and Recommendations .....................IV-1 Section V. National Register Listed/Eligible Historic Bridges ........................... V-1 Section VI. Bibliography ........................................................VI-1 Appendix 1. Sample Survey Form for Truss, Arch, Rigid Frame, Movable, Suspension, Girder- Floorbeam and Culvert Bridge Types. Appendix 2. Sample Survey Form for Stringer, T Beam, and Slab Bridge Types. List of Figures Figure II-1. Truss Types ........................................................... II-1 Figure II-2. Bennett Bridge (Lincoln Plantation #1005) .................................... II-2 Figure II-3. Common Truss Designs ................................................. II-4 Figure II-4. St. John Street Underpass (Portland #0327) .................................. II-5 Figure II-5. New Sharon Bridge (Sharon #2608) ........................................ II-6 Figure II-6. Truss Nomenclature .................................................... II-6 Figure II-7. Androscoggin Riv er Bridge (Gilead #5084) ................................... II-7 Figure II-8. Piscataquis River Bridge Detail (Howland #3040) .............................. II-7 Figure II-9. Durham Bridge (Durham #3334) ........................................... II-9 Figure II-10. Songo Lock Draw (Naples #2780) ........................................ II-10 Figure II-11. Swing Span Nomenclature ............................................. II-10 Figure II-12. Vertical Lift Nomenclature .............................................. II-11 Figure II-13. Sarah Mildred Long Bridge (Kittery #3641) ................................. II-12 Figure II-14. The W ire Bridge (New Portland #3383) .................................... II-13 Figure II-15. W aldo-Hancock Bridge (Prospect #3008) .................................. II-14 Figure II-16. Deer Isle-Sedgwick Bridge (Deer Isle (#3257) ............................... II-15 Figure II-17. Stone Arch Bridge Nomenclature ......................................... II-16 Figure II-18. The Arch Bridge (Pembroke #2021) ....................................... II-16 Figure II-19. Reinforced Concrete Arch Bridge Nomenclature ............................. II-18 Figure II-20. Pope Memorial Bridge (East Machias #2682) ............................... II-18 Figure II-21. Carabasset Bridge (New Portland #5131) .................................. II-19 Figure II-22. Chisolm Park Bridge (Rumford #2990) .................................... II-19 Figure II-23. Blue Hill Falls Bridge (Blue Hill #5038) .................................... II-20 Figure II-24. Stanley Brook Bridge (Mt. Desert #0559) ................................... II-21 Figure II-25. Morse Bridge (Rumford #2585) .......................................... II-22 Figure II-26. Rigid Frame Bridge Nomenclature ........................................ II-23 Figure II-27. Partridge Bridge (Whitefield #2650) ....................................... II-24 Figure II-28. Girder Bridge Nomenclature ............................................ II-25 Figure II-29. Park Av enue Underpass (Portland #0326) .................................. II-26 Figure II-30. Frankfort #1136 ...................................................... II-27 Figure II-31. Comm on Street Bridge (Saco #1354) ..................................... II-28 Figure II-32. Tom Collins Bridge (Bingham #2845) ..................................... II-30 Figure II-33. Stringer Bridge Nomenclature ........................................... II-34 Figure II-34. Somesville Bridge (Saco #3412) ......................................... II-35 Figure II-35. Typical Slab Bridge .................................................. II-36 Figure II-36. Old Buffam Bridge (Wells #0821) ........................................ II-36 Figure II-37. Typical T-beam Section ................................................ II-37 Figure II-38. Kingman Road Bridge (Macwahoc Plantation #5021) ......................... II-37 Figure II-37. W atsons Bridge (Waterford #0747) ....................................... II-38 ii Figure III-1. 1910 Annual Report Accounting ...........................................III-4 Figure III-2. International Bridge, Van Buren, 1911 ......................................III-5 Figure III-3. Steel Stringer Bridge, Lisbon Falls, 1911 ....................................III-6 Figure III-4. Llewellyn Edwards, Maine s First State Bridge Engineer........................III-11 Figure III-5. Misaligned Upper Chord from L. Edwards 1922 Paper .........................III-12 Figure III-6. Fairbanks Bridge, Farmington . ..........................................III-14 Figure III-7. Bailey Island Bridge ...................................................III-15 Figure III-8. 1924 Bridge Survey Form ...............................................III-16