AURA/NOAO ANNUAL REPORT
FY 2007
Submitted to the National Science Foundation September 30, 2007 Revised as Final and Submitted January 30, 2008
Emission nebula NGC6334 (Cat’s Paw Nebula): star-forming region in the constellation Scorpius. This 2007 image was taken using the Mosaic-2 imager on the Blanco 4-meter telescope at Cerro Tololo Inter- American Observatory. Intervening dust in the plane of the Milky Way galaxy reddens the colors of the nebula. Image credit: T.A. Rector/University of Alaska Anchorage, T. Abbott and NOAO/AURA/NSF NATIONAL OPTICAL ASTRONOMY OBSERVATORY
NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007 Submitted to the National Science Foundation September 30, 2007 Revised as Final and Submitted January 30, 2008
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...... 1 1 SCIENTIFIC ACTIVITIES AND FINDINGS ...... 2 1.1 NOAO Gemini Science Center ...... 2 GNIRS Infrared Spectroscopy and the Origins of the Peculiar Hydrogen-Deficient Stars...... 2 Supermassive Black Hole Growth and Chemical Enrichment in the Early Universe...... 4 1.2 Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory (CTIO)...... 5 The Nearest Stars...... 5 Electric Stars...... 6 A New Milky Way Satellite...... 6 The Nature of the Universe ...... 7 1.3 Kitt Peak National Observatory (KPNO)...... 7 Observing Programs Continue Broad Scientific and Educational Impact...... 7 2 THE GROUND-BASED O/IR OBSERVING SYSTEM ...... 9 2.1 The Gemini Telescopes—NOAO Gemini Science Center ...... 9 Support of U.S. Gemini Users and Proposers...... 9 Providing U.S. Scientific Input to Gemini...... 10 U.S. Gemini Instrumentation Program ...... 10 Gemini 2007 Science Meeting...... 11 2.2 CTIO Telescopes...... 11 Blanco 4-m Telescope...... 11 Southern Astrophysical Research (SOAR) Telescope ...... 12 SMARTS Consortium and Other Small Telescopes...... 12 Blanco Instrumentation ...... 13 SOAR Instrumentation...... 13 2.3 KPNO Telescopes ...... 14 WIYN 3.5-m...... 14 Mayall 4-m...... 14 2.1-m...... 15 Relations with the Tohono O’odham Nation...... 15 VERITAS Project...... 16 Operations and Instrumentation Partnerships ...... 16 Deferred Maintenance and Modernization ...... 16 Site Protection...... 17 2.4 Community Access to the Independent Observatories ...... 17 MMT Observatory and the Hobby-Eberly Telescope...... 17 Keck and Magellan Telescopes...... 18
i NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
2.5 Joint NOAO-NASA Time Allocation ...... 18 2.6 NOAO Survey Programs...... 18 2.7 NOAO Data Products Program...... 18 Data Management System...... 19 Pipelines ...... 19 NEWFIRM support ...... 19 Operations ...... 20 Science Support Software...... 20 3 NOAO MAJOR INSTRUMENTATION PROGRAM...... 21 3.1 NOAO Instruments ...... 21 NOAO Extremely Wide-Field IR Imager (NEWFIRM)...... 21 SOAR Adaptive Optics Module (SAM)...... 23 MONSOON Detector Controller ...... 24 4 NOAO AND THE DECADAL SURVEY PROJECTS...... 25 4.1 Giant Segmented Mirror Telescope Program Office (GSMTPO) ...... 25 Staffing...... 25 Web Site...... 25 GSMT Science Working Group (SWG)...... 25 ELT Development Support: AURA Proposal to NSF...... 26 ELT Development Support: TMT Design and Development...... 27 ELT Site Selection: Site Testing for the Thirty Meter Telescope ...... 27 FY07 Technical Papers by GSMTPO Staff...... 27 4.2 Large-Aperture Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST) ...... 28 Telescope and Site ...... 28 Training and Development...... 28 Science Collaborations ...... 29 LSST D&D Education and Public Outreach (EPO) Program...... 29 4.3 National Virtual Observatory (NVO)...... 29 4.4 Telescope System Instrumentation Program (TSIP)...... 30 4.5 Adaptive Optics Development Program (AODP)...... 31 UC Berkeley...... 31 CARA...... 32 Lawrence Livermore National Labs...... 33 Coherent Technology, Inc...... 33 5 PUBLIC AFFAIRS AND EDUCATIONAL OUTREACH...... 34 5.1 Educational Outreach (EO) ...... 34 Research Based Science Education (RBSE)...... 34 Spitzer Research Program for Teachers and Students ...... 35 Science Foundation Arizona: Astro BITS...... 35 Hands-On Optics...... 35 Science Foundation of Arizona: Expanding HOO in Arizona ...... 36 Project ASTRO...... 37 Family ASTRO...... 37 ASTRO-Chile ...... 38 GLOBE at Night...... 38
ii TABLE OF CONTENTS
Investigating Astronomy ...... 39 LSST D&D EPO Program...... 39 GSMT D&D EPO ...... 39 Tohono O’odham Outreach ...... 40 Research Experiences for Undergraduates (REU) ...... 40 Astronomy Education Review (AER) ...... 40 5.2 Public Outreach...... 41 Kitt Peak Visitor Center ...... 41 Other Public Outreach ...... 42 5.3 Media and Public Information ...... 44 Media Activity...... 45 Special Information Products...... 46 Image and Information Requests ...... 46 Web-Based Outreach...... 46 6 COMPUTER INFRASTRUCTURE AND NETWORK SERVICES...... 47 6.1 Tucson...... 47 6.2 Kitt Peak...... 47 6.3 NOAO South: La Serena & Cerro Tololo ...... 48 La Serena ...... 48 Cerro Tololo...... 49 Las Campanas...... 49
APPENDICES A NOAO Scientific Staff Activity B Scientific Staff Publications FY07 C Key Management and Scientific Personnel Changes D Publications Using Data from NOAO Telescopes E Observing Programs and Investigators—Semesters 2007A/B F New Organizational Partners and Collaborations in FY07 G Activities Encouraging Diversity within NOAO H Fourth Quarter Site Safety Report
iii
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This year’s annual report tells two stories. The first is of a year of transition, following the NSF Senior Review and a serious effort to develop an implementation plan for the recommendations of that report. The second is of a year of continuation along the paths of many of the day-to-day NOAO activities. On the transition side, this report describes the dramatic change in the activities of NOAO’s GSMT effort, from a collaborator to a program office that represents the entire U.S. community. On the continuation side, this report includes the delivery of NEWFIRM, a new wide- field IR imager to be shared between the Mayall and Blanco telescopes and to carry out exciting new surveys. These two types of activities have, by necessity, become intertwined, because many of the same personnel are responsible for both, and because aspects of change and of continuation have affected every program. The fundamental product of NOAO is scientific results and accomplishments, by both the staff and the broad community. FY2007 has been an impressive year in that regard. From Gemini, we have new understanding of the evolutionary processes involved in white dwarf mergers as well as the first studies of elemental abundances in QSO emission-line regions out to z ~ 6. From CTIO, we have fundamental data on the census of nearby stars, a discovery of a new dwarf satellite of the Milky Way, and continuing efforts aimed at understanding dark energy. From Kitt Peak, we have a number of studies of dark matter, of higher redshift star-forming galaxies, and discovery of an ancient nova shell around the dwarf nova Z Cam. The reason that scientific discoveries continue is because the instrumentation on our facilities is improved and replaced regularly. Instrumentation news in this report includes the delivery of NEWFIRM, a 4096 × 4096 near-IR imager, that promises to be a state-of-the-art survey tool for projects ranging from stellar populations in local group galaxies to Lyman-alpha galaxies at z ~ 10. Following NEWFIRM in the pipeline, the community can look forward to SAM (the SOAR Adaptive Module), the Dark Energy Camera and the One Degree Imager, two wide-field optical imagers, and two new Gemini instruments (NICI and FLAMINGOS-2). The other new development that is related to new instrumentation and new observing capabilities is the development of the NOAO End-to-End (E2E) system, which will allow the distribution of raw and, in some cases, reduced data to the entire community after the proprietary period expires. This is a major step into the new era of the National Virtual Observatory and is an important precursor activity to LSST. NOAO continues to provide access to non-federally funded facilities through TSIP and continues to explore the evolution of that access—and other possible new programs–—with the perspective of a public-private system. This is becoming a more basic context for the entire NOAO program, and integration of this access within the NOAO time allocation process, including elements such as the NOAO Surveys Program and Joint NOAO-NASA time allocation, is an important part. Although much of the NOAO GSMT Program Office activity has been aimed at establishing a new role that is both helpful and viable, that effort was moving more smoothly and effectively by the end of the period of this report. The NOAO LSST effort has become a major component of the LSST project as it moves through the final stages of design and development and prepares for construction in the near future. NOAO’s outreach activities continue to be recognized as excellent world-wide, as indicated not only by the metrics presented in this report, but also by the identification of the NOAO outreach personnel to play a major role in the planning for the upcoming International Year of Astronomy. Of course, along with the accomplishments, there were also some setbacks this year, including the accidental partial destruction of GNIRS at Gemini South and the threat of a wildfire near Kitt Peak.
1
1 SCIENTIFIC ACTIVITIES AND FINDINGS
1.1 NOAO GEMINI SCIENCE CENTER
GNIRS Infrared Spectroscopy and the Origins of the Peculiar Hydrogen-Deficient Stars
The Gemini Near-Infrared Spectrograph (GNIRS) conducted fascinating observations, presented in 2007, of a normally rare isotope of oxygen, 18O, in the atmospheres of two classes of unusual stars. The GNIRS spectra have provided the key clue in understanding the origins of these stars. The peculiar stars in question are the hydrogen-deficient carbon (HdC) stars and their variable cousins, the R Coronae Borealis (RCrB) stars. These particular stellar types are characterized by having almost no hydrogen, but quite large amounts of carbon. Two scenarios have been suggested to account for these chemically unusual classes of H-poor yet C-rich stars. In the first, it is postulated that in the normal transition from a luminous, cool asymptotic giant branch (AGB) star to its later planetary nebula stage, a final pulse of triple-alpha helium-burning occurs in a thin shell near the stellar surface, with the observable stellar atmosphere being polluted by the products of this burning. The combination of He-burning, to produce carbon, coupled to the mass loss of a hydrogen-rich envelope in the AGB-PN transition results in the C-rich and H-poor characteristics. In the second formation scenario, a binary system consisting of a carbon- oxygen white dwarf (CO-WD) and a helium white dwarf (He-WD) merge through a combination of magnetic braking and gravitational radiation. Such a white dwarf binary system results from the evolution of two normal low- to intermediate-mass stars in a relatively close binary system. The merging sequence would release large amounts of energy that would drive nuclear reactions that could produce 18O. Using GNIRS infrared spectra obtained from Gemini-South, G. Clayton (Louisiana State U.) and an international team of observational astronomers and nuclear astrophysicists detected significant enhancements of 18O in seven HdC and RCrB stars. The overabundances of 18O are enormous, being several hundred to a thousand times larger than in the Sun, when compared to the usually more abundant 16O isotope. The spectra showing the detection of 18O via molecular absorption from 12C18O is shown in Figure 1. This absorption is detected due to the isotopic shift from absorption due to what is usually the much more abundant 12C16O, which is also indicated in the figure. In modeling the two possible formation mechanisms, Clayton and collaborators conclude that the 18O can only survive in significant quantities as a result of the binary white dwarf merger picture. In the shell helium-burning pulse, the temperatures are so hot for such a length of time as to burn virtually all of the 18O to 22Ne. This work provides key data in attempts to understand the physics involved in white dwarf mergers. Studies of such mergers provide constraints on physical processes that occur in interacting binary systems containing white dwarfs. Interacting systems with one or more white dwarfs are interesting types of objects, as binaries with more massive white dwarfs are believed to be the source of supernovae of Type Ia (SN Ia). It is the type IA supernovae that first provided evidence for an accelerating universe. Thus, understanding more about interactions in white dwarf binaries is potentially significant in shedding light on the important SN Ia progenitor systems. The full paper can be found in The Astrophysical Journal (20 June 2007 issue) with authors G. Clayton, T. R. Geballe, F. Herwig, C. Fryer, and M. Asplund.
2 SCIENTIFIC ACTIVITIES AND FINDINGS
Figure 1: GNIRS spectra of HdC stars (top 3 and bottom 2) and RCrB stars (the 6 in the middle) with molecular absorption from CO indicated. The bandheads due to both 12C18O and 12C16O are indicated.
3 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Supermassive Black Hole Growth and Chemical Enrichment in the Early Universe
A set of infrared spectra obtained from both the Gemini-South and Gemini-North telescopes have been used by a team of astronomers from the U.S. and Germany, led by L. Jiang (U. Arizona, Steward Observatory), to study the kinematics and chemistry of some of the most distant and youngest known quasars. The six quasars observed are at redshifts ranging from z = 5.8 to 6.3 and correspond to a time when the universe was only about one billion years old. Using the Gemini Near Infrared Spectrograph (GNIRS) at Gemini South and the Near-Infrared Imager and spectrograph (NIRI) at Gemini North, the team found these very young quasars to be already super-enriched in heavy elements. The quasars are also powered by extremely massive black holes. The Jiang et al. results cast new light on the assembly of black holes and the chemical enrichment of the universe less than one billion years after the Big Bang. Quasars are thought to be powered by radiation from matter accreting onto supermassive black holes at the center of host galaxies in the process of forming. Dense gas in the region surrounding the black hole moves at high velocities. It gives rise to a broad line region (BLR) in spectra that can be used as a diagnostic of several properties of the gas itself and of the central black hole. Chemical abundances in the BLR are important in understanding the history of star formation in the host galaxy. In particular, the ratio of iron (Fe) to the so-called “alpha elements,” such as oxygen or magnesium, is expected to have a strong correlation with the time since star formation began. Oxygen and magnesium (Mg), for example, are produced and ejected very quickly in massive stars, while iron comes from longer-lived binary sytems that give rise to supernovae of Type Ia (SN Ia). Hence, most Fe enrichment happens roughly a billion years after the initial formation of stars. Emission line ratios from Fe II and Mg II in the infrared spectrum of the quasars provide measurements of the chemical abundances of these elements in the quasar BLR. The abundances of heavy elements, such as Mg or Fe (characterizing the gas metallicity, Z) are found to be super-solar at Zquasar ~ 4 Zsun. The Fe II/Mg II ratio is also important in understanding chemical evolution in the early universe. Jiang et al. show that the metallicity in the BLRs of high redshift quasars is super-solar, and that there is no sign of strong evolution in metallicity between the local universe to z ~ 6 (Figure 2). The high metallicity found at this redshift indicates that extensive and Figure 2: Fe II/Mg II abundance as a function of redshift indicating no rapid star formation, followed by significant relative chemical evolution as a function of age, even as significant element enrichment, has far back as z ~ 6. occurred in quasar host galaxies in the first billion years after the big bang. The presence of very luminous high-redshift quasars in the early universe also betrays the rapid growth of black hole mass when the first generations of galaxies and quasars formed. The bulk motions of the broad-line region (BLR) are used to determine the mass of the central black hole. The full paper can be found in The Astronomical Journal (September 2007 issue) with authors L. Jiang, X. Fan, M. Vestergaard, J. D. Kurk, F. Walter, B. C. Kelly, and M. A. Strauss.
4 SCIENTIFIC ACTIVITIES AND FINDINGS
1.2 CERRO TOLOLO INTER-AMERICAN OBSERVATORY (CTIO)
The Nearest Stars
The nearest star to the Sun is the faint M dwarf Proxima Centauri, a wide member of the alpha Centauri system. Although the census of nearby (within 10 parsecs) stars is complete for Sun-like and brighter stars, it is likely that many more faint red dwarfs remain to be discovered. None of these stars are visible to the naked eye but they are the dominant population by number and by mass in our galaxy. The RECONS (Research Consortium on Nearby Stars) group has been conducting a classical trigonometric parallax study to identify stars in the solar neighborhood. The survey uses the CTIO 0.9-m and 1.5-m telescopes within the SMARTS consortium and is led by T. Henry of Georgia State U. In the December 2006 issue of the Astronomical Journal, Henry et al. report on the identification of 25 new stars within 10 pc of the Sun. Most of these stars appear to be cool M dwarfs, but there are several L and T dwarfs, or brown dwarfs, stars that have never truly been able to sustain thermonuclear reactions in their interiors. The new stars amount to 16% of the total mass in the solar neighborhood. RECONS has also identified 33 new white dwarfs within 25 pc of the Sun (Subasavage et al. 2007), one of which may be within 10 pc. White dwarfs are faint, and a reasonably complete sample can only be drawn from the solar neighborhood. These local white dwarfs are important for constraining the underlying physics that govern the behavior of matter at high densities and for testing General Relativity.
Figure 3: The updated color magnitude diagram of the solar neighborhood. The new RECONS objects are marked as the larger filled circles.
5 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Electric Stars
Polars are a class of cataclysmic variables containing a highly magnetic white dwarf and a low mass main sequence companion, usually a late-type star such as an M or a brown dwarf. The two stars form a close, interacting binary system, and orbital periods are very short, just a few hours. Chromospheric activity in late-type stars (i.e., starspots, prominences) tends to decline with age, as these stars are fully convective and cannot sustain the dynamo that powers the Sun’s magnetic field. However, the secondary stars in some polars show signs of very strong activity, despite their being relatively old. Over the past two years a group of astronomers led by Styliani Kafka (NOAO) has been observing four polars and has resolved this conundrum by discovering that the activity on the late-type companion is actually triggered by the white dwarf. The very strong magnetic field of the white dwarf acts like a giant alternator and induces Figure 4: An artist’s concept of activity induced in the secondary of an interacting binary by a white dwarf electric currents in the companion, which in companion with strong magnetic field. turn produce activity such as starspots and prominences.
A New Milky Way Satellite Standard galaxy formation models predict the existence of a large population of satellite galaxies around the Milky Way. However, it is well known that the Galaxy is orbited by no more than 20 dwarfs, much fewer than the about 400 postulated by theory. One solution to this problem is to assume that the fainter dwarfs are suppressed—they never formed large amounts of stars and are mostly dark. Belokurov et al. (2006) may have found something of this kind. They used the CTIO Blanco 4-m to obtain a deep color magnitude diagram of a candidate dwarf in Boötes. They find that this object is very faint, but is much more extended than a globular cluster. It falls below the region of Milky Way globular clusters in the Kormendy diagram (which plots central surface brightness vs. absolute magnitude). Boötes appears to be a new kind of dwarf galaxy, rather than a globular cluster, although it has a single Figure 5: Color-magnitude diagram of the new dwarf satellite from Blanco data (Belokurov, et al. 2006) together stellar population (Figure 5). The SEGUE with ridgelines for the metal poor galactic globular cluster collaboration has also found several other M92. examples of faint, extended objects with
6 SCIENTIFIC ACTIVITIES AND FINDINGS
luminosities typical of globular clusters but much more diffuse. It may suggest the existence of a new population of “galaxies,” which further fill the parameter space of the Kormendy diagram, and demonstrates that the census of faint companion galaxies to the Milky Way may still be seriously incomplete.
The Nature of the Universe
After five years of operation, the ESSENCE supernova survey is now nearing completion. ESSENCE is aimed at improving our understanding of Dark Energy, using wide-field images taken at the Blanco 4-m with the Mosaic camera. Most of the data are now on hand and the results are starting to appear. Wood-Vasey et al. show that, assuming a flat Universe and with priors from the measurements of baryon acoustic oscillations, the equation of state parameter (w) found is consistent with the dark energy being a cosmological constant (w = -1). The result is strengthened if the supernovae discovered by the similar (northern) sample from the SuperNova legacy Survey are included. The ESSENCE results are also useful for improving our knowledge of supernovae themselves and for refining their use as distance indicators. For instance Hsiao et al. have partly used the public ESSENCE data to derive K-corrections for Type Ia supernovae.
1.3 KITT PEAK NATIONAL OBSERVATORY (KPNO)
Observing Programs Continue Broad Scientific and Educational Impact
The telescopes of Kitt Peak National Observatory and of our sister observatories that share the lease to operate on Iolkam Duag (Kitt Peak) continue to have broad scientific and educational impact. Twenty- six telescopes currently operate on the mountain. These include those operated by the National Optical Astronomy Observatory, the National Solar Observatory, and the National Radio Astronomy Observatory, as well as many telescopes operated by individual and groups of universities. These facilities are used for basic astrophysical research and education. Those taught about the Universe range from the general public to students at all stages of their education. The students range in level from elementary through graduate school. They come from the Tohono O’odham Nation and from many countries around the world. The impact of the work enabled by Kitt Peak National Observatory continues to be broad and diverse. Kitt Peak telescopes continue to enable scientific results of the highest quality and at a rate comparable or higher than their larger 8-m cousins. For the past four years, KPNO publications have surpassed 145 refereed publications every year. The range of topics studied is extremely broad, ranging from the study of comets to the discovery of the most distant radio-loud quasar in the Universe (Cyanogen Jets and the Rotation Sate of Comet Machholz (C/2004 Q2)—Farnham, T. L. et al. 2007, AJ, 133, 2001; Ground-based Visible and Near-IR Observations of Comet 9P/Tempel 1 During the Deep Impact Encounter—Knight, M. M. et al. 2007, Icarus, 187, 199; Discovery of a z=6.1 Radio- Loud Quasar in the NDWFS—McGreer, I. D. et al. 2006, ApJ, 652, 157; Mid-Infrared Selection of Brown Dwarfs and High-Redshift Quasars—Stern et al. 2007, ApJ, 663, 677). The study of dark matter, first discovered in normal galaxies with the help of NOAO telescopes (Rubin and Ford 1970; Rubin, Thonnard, and Ford 1980), continues to be an area of active study for researchers using KPNO facilities. Major results in 2007 included a detailed Mayall 4-m (imaging) and Keck (spectroscopy) study of the Leo I dwarf spheroidal galaxy that found less dark matter than previously associated with this galaxy (Exploring Halo Substructure with Giant Stars. X. Extended Dark Matter or Tidal Disruption?—Sohn, S. T. et al. 2007, ApJ, 663, 960). KPNO telescopes often support space-based studies of dark matter, as they did with the COSMOS Survey’s reported three dimensional map of the mass distribution in a large volume of the nearby Universe (Dark Matter Maps Reveal Cosmic Scaffolding—Massey, P. et al. 2007, Nature, 445, 286).
7 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
The combination of KPNO optical and near-IR imaging data over large fields coupled with Spitzer Space Telescope mid-IR imaging continues to provide new insights in the study of galaxy evolution and the role of mergers in the mass assembly history of galaxies (e.g., The Role of Galaxy Interactions and Mergers in Star Formation at z<=1.3: Mid-Infrared Properties in the Spitzer First Look Survey—Bridge, C. R. et al. 2007, ApJ, 659, 931; The Evolving Luminosity Function of red Galaxies—Brown, M. J. I. et al. 2007, ApJ, 654, 858). When these kinds of data sets are compared with theoretical simulations of galaxies and their satellite galaxies in a dark matter dominated Universe, even stronger constraints can be placed on the relative importance of mergers in the evolution of the properties of galaxies (Evidence for Merging or Disruption of Red Galaxies from the Evolution of Their Clustering—White, M. et al. 2007, ApJ, 655, L69). Even the smallest telescope on which KPNO regularly offers observing time is still making contributions worthy of publication in Nature, as the discovery of an ancient Nova Shell around the Dwarf Nova Z Camelopardalis demonstrated (Shara, M. M. et al. 2007, Nature, 446, 159). Using groundbased images taken with the KPNO MOSAIC-1 camera on the WIYN 0.9-m telescope and UV images from the GALEX spacecraft, the newly revealed nova shell observationally links the prototypical dwarf nova Z Camelopardalis with the classical nova process. Previously completed NOAO Surveys continue to yield results at a high rate. For example, the NOAO Deep Wide-Field Survey, a large optical and near-IR imaging survey that completed data collection in 2003 and whose Boötes Field data products were released in 2004, has contributed to more than 60 refereed publications (http://www.noao.edu/noao/noaodeep/ndwfspublications.html). The educational impact of the operations on Kitt Peak continued at a high level of quality and activity. The KPNO telescopes supported more than 25 Ph.D. programs during FY07, including travel and observing expenses in addition to the observing time. The non-NOAO observatories on the mountain supported many others. Groups of students from all over the country, including the Santa Rosa School of the Tohono O’odham Nation and the Tohono O’odham Community College, took advantage of the PAEO nighttime observing program (three telescopes available each night) during FY07.
8
2 THE GROUND-BASED O/IR OBSERVING SYSTEM
2.1 THE GEMINI TELESCOPES—NOAO GEMINI SCIENCE CENTER
Support of U.S. Gemini Users and Proposers
The NOAO Gemini Science Center (NGSC) supports the U.S. community’s access to the International Gemini Observatory’s two 8.1-m telescopes. This support work includes informing the U.S. community of Gemini observing opportunities, answering questions about all aspects of Gemini from U.S. proposers and users, performing technical reviews for all Gemini proposals submitted to the NOAO TAC, providing assistance with U.S. Phase-II submissions for programs selected for Gemini telescope time, interfacing with Gemini on the implementation of U.S. programs, and providing certain types of operational support for Gemini. Observing opportunities on Gemini South were affected by a serious accident involving GNIRS in April 2007. The accident forced GNIRS out of service for the rest of 2007, and the NOAO infrared spectrograph Phoenix, which had been removed from the Gemini-South telescope in March 2007 (after having been a visiting instrument since 2002), was returned to the telescope. NOAO and NGSC helped to arrange the return of Phoenix to Gemini South, where it will remain available to the Gemini user community at least through the end of 2008A. The loss of GNIRS led to the need for a “Special Call” for replacement proposals to be submitted to replace GNIRS time requested for 2007B. The time from the Special Call deadline, through TAC ranking, selection, and being made ready for implementation on the Gemini-South telescope was unusually short and required special efforts from NOAO/NGSC staff, NOAO TAC members, and Gemini staff. However, the entire process went smoothly and all of the GNIRS time was replaced by TReCS, Phoenix, and GMOS-South programs. The U.S. community continued to show a strong demand for Gemini observing time, with 136 proposals to Gemini North in 2007B and 133 proposals to Gemini South. The total time requested was 166 nights on Gemini North and 210 nights on Gemini South, resulting in oversubscription factors of 2.6 for the north and 4.8 for the south. The proposals submitted to Gemini North consisted of 48 for GMOS-North, 31 for NIRI, 12 for NIFS, 15 for Michelle, and 13 for TEXES. The Gemini North total also included time trades with Keck and Subaru, with 11 proposals submitted for HIRES on Keck, and 1 and 5 proposals for SuprimeCam and MOIRCS, respectively, on Subaru. The NIRI and NIFS proposals included requests to use the Altair AO system, with 16 of the NIRI and 9 of the NIFS programs requesting AO. Of these AO proposals, 8 requested the Laser Guide Star (LGS) for a total of 16 requested nights using the laser. The Gemini South proposals contained 35 for GMOS-South, 38 for TReCS, and 38 for Phoenix. As the GNIRS accident occurred after the 2007B deadline for proposal submission, there were also 22 programs submitted for GNIRS. The Gemini observing process requires the submission of a Phase-II file once an observing program is approved. NGSC staff perform reviews of all U.S. program Phase-II submissions. The Phase-II file must describe an observation completely and error free, since the commands in this file are uploaded directly to the telescope and instrument when the observation is executed; any errors in the execution would result in lost telescope time. Few users submit a correct Phase-II initially, so this critical and complex process usually requires multiple iterations and communications between the NGSC staff contact and the program PI. NGSC organized a booth for the January 2007 AAS meeting held in Seattle, Washington. The booth featured displays on how to propose for Gemini observing time, details of all of the available instruments, and tutorials by NGSC staff with users on preparing Phase-II programs. Numerous users and other astronomers visited the booth and interacted with the NGSC staff. A meeting of all of the partner National Gemini Offices (NGO) was held in Iguaçu, Brazil on 15 June 2007; the meetings are held every 18 months, and this was the third such meeting of all of the NGO
9 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
offices. This particular meeting followed directly the second Gemini Science and Users meeting held at the same location over the four previous days. The NGO meeting focused primarily on technical discussions concerning Gemini instruments, software, observing, data reduction, and user support. The U.S. NGO was represented at the meeting by NGSC staff and V. Smith (Director, NGSC), who gave a presentation titled “How can we help users produce Gemini science?” NGSC provided observing support and maintenance for the NOAO-built Phoenix high- resolution infrared spectrograph on Gemini South. Phoenix was used in classical-only mode, with support astronomers provided by NGSC (staff members K. Hinkle, R. Blum, and V. Smith provided Phoenix support in FY07 for 27 nights from October 2006 to March 2007). Phoenix was removed from Gemini South in March 2007; however, the loss of GNIRS in April 2007 resulted in Phoenix being returned to the telescope in May 2007. During its continued use on Gemini South at least through the end of 2008A, Phoenix will be operated in queue mode, along with other Gemini instruments. NGSC staff members K. Hinkle and V. Smith helped train Gemini astronomers at the telescope so that Gemini now supports the continued use of Phoenix on Gemini South. In addition to the Phoenix nights, NGSC staff spent 64 nights visiting Gemini telescopes in 2006B and 2007A. In an AURA Observatory Council initiated review of the NOAO TAC process, V. Smith attended the ad hoc committee’s meeting on 9 November in Pasadena and gave a presentation on how U.S. Gemini proposals are handled by the NOAO TAC.
Providing U.S. Scientific Input to Gemini
The U.S. Gemini Science Advisory Committee (SAC), which serves as NGSC’s community-based advisory committee met in Tucson on 4–5 October. V. Smith briefed the SAC on the status of the Gemini telescopes and instruments, the U.S. instrumentation effort, and current scientific and technical issues. In addition, future observational and scientific opportunities on Gemini were discussed, while the SAC considered how the priorities of the U.S. community should be presented to the Gemini leadership. The current SAC membership can be found at www.noao.edu/usgp/staff.html. Two members of this group also serve on the NOAO Users’ Committee, which met in Tucson on 5–6 October (with a morning session overlap between the SAC and Users’ Committee), while three SAC members served on the Gemini Science Committee (GSC). The GSC met twice in FY07, the first time in Hilo from 25–26 October and again on 23–24 April in Tucson. V. Smith represented NOAO/NGSC at both meetings. In preparation for the April GSC meeting and May Gemini Board meeting, V. Smith organized a meeting of U.S. Gemini Board and U.S. GSC members, as well as NSF representatives, on 19 April in Chicago. The Gemini Operations Working Group (OpsWG) met twice in FY07, first in La Serena on 30–31 January and again in Melborune, Australia on 30–31 July. V. Smith represented the United States at both meetings and serves as the current chair of this committee.
U.S. Gemini Instrumentation Program
There are two components to the U.S. Gemini Instrumentation Program. One component consists of instruments being built or designed by NOAO for use on Gemini. These projects are discussed in the Major Instrumentation Program section of this report. The other component is U.S. Gemini instruments being built at other U.S. institutions under an AURA contract awarded by NOAO, with NGSC technical and managerial oversight. FY07 progress on two such instruments is described below.
NICI: the Near Infrared Coronagraphic Imager provides 1- to 5-micron dual-beam coronagraphic imaging capability on the Gemini-South telescope. Mauna Kea Infrared (MKIR) in Hilo built NICI, under the leadership of D. Toomey. In early FY07, NICI passed its acceptance testing and was shipped to Gemini South. NICI underwent its first light and initial commissioning on the telescope in January 2007, with a second commissioning run in
10 THE GROUND-BASED O/IR OBSERVING SYSTEM
June 2007. It is anticipated that the NICI Campaign Science program will begin later in 2007B, with NICI available as a facility instrument in 2008A.
FLAMINGOS-2: the near-infrared multi-object spectrograph and imager for the Gemini- South telescope. FLAMINGOS-2 will image a 6.1-arcminute field in imaging mode and will provide a 6.1×2-arcminute field for multi-object spectroscopy. It can also be used with the Gemini-South Multi-Conjugate Adaptive Optics (MCAO) system. Under the leadership of PI S. Eikenberry, U. Florida is building FLAMINGOS-2. In FY07, FLAMINGOS-2 underwent total integration and testing. It is expected that FLAMINGOS-2 will undergo acceptance testing towards the end of semester 2007B, with shipment to Gemini South in 2008A. As FY07 nears its end, the overall FLAMINGOS-2 project is 96% complete.
Gemini 2007 Science Meeting From 11–13 June 2007, more than 130 astronomers and staff from the seven-country Gemini partnership converged on Foz da Iguaçu, Brazil to attend the Second Gemini Science meeting. This second science meeting, a follow-on to the first held in Vancouver B.C., Canada in May 2004, was held to discuss current results, capabilities, and future research and collaborations related specifically to Gemini. The Laboratório Nacional de Astrofísica (LNA), acting as the Brazilian National Gemini Office, was responsible for the local organization of the meeting. Foz de Iguaçu was chosen as the meeting place because it combined an attractive location with excellent infrastructure for international conventions. The Scientific Organizing Committee worked under the lead of V. Smith (NOAO/NGSC). The 60 oral talks and about 45 posters covered all major themes of current forefront astrophysical research. Several specific Gemini tools like mid-infrared capabilities and the several integral field units for spectroscopic mapping (especially when fed by adaptive optics), were highlighted by a number of spectacular results presented at the meeting. These results demonstrate the extreme power these capabilities deliver on 8-m telescopes optimized for infrared observations and high spatial resolution. A one-day Users’ Meeting that focused on Gemini’s current observational capabilities, future instruments and opportunities, data reduction, and other user-related issues followed the three-day science meeting. The meeting was well attended, with over 100 participants, and was filled with numerous lively and productive discussions.
2.2 CTIO TELESCOPES
FY07 efforts were concentrated in four areas: (1) operating the Blanco telescope with a suite of wide-field instruments and planning enhanced operations support, and upgrades; (2) operating SOAR with two instruments while continuing engineering activities; (3) advancing the Dark Energy Survey (DES) project; and (4) facilitating operations of the small telescopes by the SMARTS II consortium.
Blanco 4-m Telescope The Blanco telescope has performed reliably throughout FY07, following a major engineering shutdown in FY06, during which the primary mirror edge supports were repaired, re-positioned, and in four cases replaced. Satisfactory progress was made on several fronts relating to the Dark Energy Survey (DES) project, which plans to conduct a 5000-square-degree imaging survey on the Blanco telescope starting in late 2010, using 30% of the observing time for five years to carry out a four-pronged project to study dark energy. The 500-Gpixel CCD camera (the Dark Energy Camera, DECam) and its data
11 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
system would also be available as a facility instrument for NOAO users. During FY07, the design and development phase continued, while the whole project, end-to-end, was positively reviewed by both NSF and DOE. The glass for the large five-element optical corrector, the critical path item, was ordered. Several milestones were passed, including achieving the noise-speed technical requirement for reading out the LBL fully-depleted CCDs. The NOAO-developed MONSOON controllers will be used for DECam, in addition to other instruments including NEWFIRM, to be shared between the Mayall and Blanco telescopes, and ODI at WIYN. With increased funding for CTIO telescope upgrades and maintenance, as a result of the recommendations made by the NSF Senior Facilities Review, a plan was formulated to provide better technical and scientific support for telescope operations, and to attend to deferred maintenance, restocking of spares, and several other spares issues. In particular, a project to replace the Telescope Control System (TCS) for the Blanco telescope was initiated. The new TCS will be a derivative of that used at SOAR and is of similar design to the TCS being developed for LSST.
Southern Astrophysical Research (SOAR) Telescope
During FY07, characterization and commissioning of telescope systems continued, in conjunction with scheduling for science at the 50% level, arranged as two-week blocks each month, centered on New Moon. The project to replace the primary mirror lateral supports with fully active mechanisms, reported on in FY06, was completely successful. The telescope image quality matches that of the site seeing monitor, with best optical images between 0.4 and 0.5 arc seconds and best images in the IR K band of 0.21 arc seconds. The primary mirror now stays fully tuned for periods of at least one hour. The two NOAO-provided instruments, SOI and OSIRIS, have been used for the scheduled science programs. The total downtime due to technical failure of either telescope or instruments was a commendably low 3%.
SMARTS Consortium and Other Small Telescopes The Small and Moderate Aperture Telescope Research System (SMARTS) consortium completed its first year of operation as SMARTS II in December 2006. The instrument complement and operations mode remains an attractive complement of imagers and spectrographs with classical, service, and queue operational modes available. The 1.5-m telescope can be deployed with either the wide-field U. Montreal IR Imager CPAPIR or the RC Spectrograph; all other telescopes have fixed instrumentation. NOAO users averaged 25% of the scheduled time on the 0.9-m, 1.0-m, 1.3-m, and 1.5-m telescopes over the course of FY07. U. North Carolina Panchromatic Robotic Optical Monitoring and Polarimetry Telescopes (PROMPT) project consists of six small telescopes that rapidly follow-up gamma-ray bursts discovered by the SWIFT satellite and subsequently trigger a target-of-opportunity interrupt at SOAR. At other times, the telescopes will make observations as part of an extensive education and outreach program in North Carolina. Full science operations for four of the telescopes began at the start of FY06, and the facility has successfully made GRB follow-up observations during this time. An IR imager and a polarimeter will be installed on the remaining two telescopes in early FY08 U.S. institutions operate two other telescopes on Cerro Tololo. U. Michigan operates the 0.6/0.9- m Curtis Schmidt telescope, which is used part-time in a NASA-funded project to catalog space debris in geosynchronous orbits. The SARA Corporation reached an agreement with Lowell Observatory to roboticize the 0.4-m Lowell telescope, and a technical analysis was undertaken. Discussions were held with several other U.S. institutions regarding siting of facilities on Cerro Tololo, in particular the WHAM project (lead institution U. Wisconsin), and Las Cumbres Observatory. CTIO continued to host a Global Oscillations Network Group (GONG) station; the Swarthmore Robotic Survey camera; the PICASSO project, operated by U. Illinois to study the Earth’s upper atmosphere and ionosphere; and a lunar scintillometer and transient camera belonging to the ALPACA project (lead institution Columbia U.).
12 THE GROUND-BASED O/IR OBSERVING SYSTEM
Blanco Instrumentation
Mosaic 2: The Mosaic imager at prime focus continues to be the most popular Blanco instrument, being scheduled for just under 50 percent of the observing time. It remains the pre-eminent wide-field optical imaging camera-telescope combination in the Southern Hemisphere.
ISPI: The Infrared Side Port Imager, in use at the Blanco for the last five years, remains the widest field large-telescope IR imager in the Southern Hemisphere, covering 10.25 arc minutes square with 0.33-arc-second-per-pixel sampling at 1–2.4 microns. This complements the small-field, high angular resolution near-IR imaging capability soon to be available at SOAR, and the infrared spectroscopic instrumentation at Gemini South.
HYDRA-CTIO: HYDRA is the third Blanco wide-field instrument; it can be installed concurrently with Mosaic and ISPI. Regular maintenance in FY07 has maintained a satisfactory level of reliability of this complex instrument.
RC Spectrograph: This spectrograph, still very popular, was scheduled in severely blocked mode in FY07. The RC spectrograph is to be retired when the SOAR Goodman spectrograph enters full operation, which is not expected until semester 2008B. This retirement will allow the Blanco telescope to be operated with three fixed instruments.
SOAR Instrumentation
Optical Imager: Built at CTIO, this instrument has been regularly used on SOAR for commissioning and science activities. Various improvements were reported in FY06. At the start of FY07, the triplet lens elements were found to be de-bonded; it is speculated that this was a result of a power-failure during a winter storm and consequent low in-dome temperatures. The center element of calcium fluoride has a much higher thermal expansion coefficient than the two outer lenses. Re-bonding was carried out with an improved process, and the triplet has remained intact so far throughout the present winter, despite it being the harshest for 40 years.
OSIRIS: The Ohio State Infrared Imager and Spectrometer, which is fitted with a CTIO 1K × 1K Rockwell HgCdTe array, was moved to SOAR after several years of use on the Blanco telescope and successfully commissioned in FY05. It provides both an imaging and a modest-resolution near-infrared spectroscopy (up to R=3000) for the NOAO and SOAR community. OSIRIS has been in regular use for science operations during FY07.
Other SOAR Instruments: A new detector system with Fairchild 4K CCD was purchased by SOAR partner U. North Carolina late in FY06 to be used with the Goodman spectrograph, following no science-grade CCDs being delivered to SOAR as the result of a Lincoln Labs foundry run. Problems with some of the optics have delayed resumption of commissioning the spectrograph until early FY08. Commissioning of the Michigan State U. 4K×4K IR imager SPARTAN was also delayed until early FY08, after a variety of delays during the test phase. The NOAO high-resolution IR spectrograph Phoenix was expected to move from Gemini to SOAR in late FY07, but now this move is not expected to happen until late FY08. The Brazilian-built Integral-Field-Unit spectrograph SIFS is not expected to arrive at SOAR before FY09.
13 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
SOAR Adaptive Module (SAM): This instrument is being built at CTIO as part of the NOAO Major Instrumentation program, and is described in that section.
2.3 KPNO TELESCOPES
FY07 saw major work continue on new instruments for the observatory. For WIYN, highlights include progress on three new imaging instruments and an upgrade of its main spectrograph. For the Mayall 4-m, preparations for the arrival of a major new near-IR imager were completed, and the instrument saw first light. Efforts continued to improve communication with the Tohono O’odham Nation, the hosts for our observatory, including an increase in coordinated outreach activities. The effort to preserve dark skies continued at both the local and federal level. We have also begun the process of addressing issues of deferred maintenance, renewing the staffing of the observatory, and modernizing some of our oldest systems.
WIYN 3.5-m During FY07, QUOTA and WHIRC both saw first light and began the process of becoming new facility instruments. QUOTA is the prototype for the technology being developed for the One Degree Imager (ODI), scheduled for commissioning in 2010. QUOTA makes use of orthogonal transfer CCDs, allowing zonal fast guiding on-chip. Development of this technology is by WIYN Director G. Jacoby, D. Harbeck (Project Scientist for ODI), and their colleagues in the PanSTARRS project, led by J. Tonry of the U. Hawaii. These orthogonal transfer arrays of CCDs will enable superb delivered image quality over a wide field. A combination of WIYN partner funding and award from the NSF (ATI and TSIP programs) has provided the necessary funding to deploy QUOTA and continue the progress on ODI. While the main reason to build QUOTA was to enable on-schedule construction of ODI, once QUOTA has been fully commissioned, it will replace the aging imager Mini-Mo. The WIYN High Resolution Infrared Camera (WHIRC) saw first light during the summer of 2007. M. Meixner and collaborators at STScI, The Johns Hopkins University, U. Wisconsin, and NOAO built this high spatial resolution near-IR imager for WIYN. Commissioning of WHIRC integrated with the WIYN Tip/Tilt Module (WTTM) will be undertaken during FY08. Proposals for shared risk observing during semester 2008A are being accepted. WIYN continued to upgrade the Bench Spectrograph. Led by M. Bershady (U. Wisconsin), P. Knezek (WIYN), and M. Hunten (NOAO/MIP), this major upgrade to improve system throughput and sensitivity is currently scheduled for completion in FY08. The total system throughput will be improved as a result of the upgrade. DENSPAK, an integral field front end for the Bench Spectrograph that was originally built as a proof of concept for future instruments, was retired after many years of productive service. A large number of maintenance and repair projects were conducted during FY07 in order to continue the high level of operations expected from the most modern telescope on Kitt Peak. Included among the many tasks of a late summer shutdown was the successful recoating of the primary, secondary, and tertiary mirrors.
Mayall 4-m
Work to prepare the Mayall 4-m telescope for the arrival of the wide-field near-IR imager NEWFIRM in early 2007 was successfully completed on schedule. NEWFIRM (PI R. Probst) had two successful commissioning runs at the Mayall during 2007. This new instrument brings a powerful near-IR survey capability to NOAO’s 4-m telescopes. Mounting this large instrument on the Mayall required a new Cass Cage bottom to be constructed as well as the fabrication of a handling cart for installing the instrument on the telescope. KPNO engineering also was heavily involved in the design, fabrication,
14 THE GROUND-BASED O/IR OBSERVING SYSTEM
and testing of the guider for NEWFIRM. Proposals for shared risk observing were accepted in March of 2007 and our first visiting astronomers will use NEWFIRM during semester 2008B. During a late summer shutdown of the Mayall, a dome skirt was repaired and other general maintenance issues were addressed. Additional maintenance work was performed during the year. A new cooling station, necessary for NEWFIRM as well as several other instruments, is under design and will be built during FY07.
2.1-m
The oldest telescope that KPNO still operates, the 2.1-m, is becoming a test-bed for some of our newest instruments. IRMOS and FLAMINGOS, two near-IR spectrographs that were used to develop pioneering new technologies now being used in new instruments for 8-m telescopes and space observatories, were extensively commissioned and tested at the 2.1-m. D. Figer (RIT) has used the 2.1-m to test the on-sky performance of silicon pin-diode detectors, devices being considered for the LSST. A. Szymkowiak and his colleagues at Yale have used the 2.1-m to commission a new high-throughput optical spectrograph being considered for future use with the WIYN 3.5-m. While developing new technologies for astronomy, these groups have been able to use the 2.1-m to undertake astronomical research and involve students in the process of developing the next generation of astronomical instrumentation. J. Ge and his U. Florida colleagues are further examples of this use of the 2.1-m. Ge and his colleagues have had several successful science runs with their innovative, high-precision, radial velocity, fiber-fed, bench spectrograph. The optics project a fringe pattern from a Michelson interferometer at nearly right angles to the absorption features on the widened stellar spectrum. The recorded phase of the interference fringes is then extremely sensitive to small velocity shifts. The Florida team has been able to obtain 3.5-m/s repeatability, following a series of upgrades that provided significantly improved thermal stability. Very high throughput was achieved by acquisition of a larger diameter collimator and by implementing both beams of the interferometer. Use of the instrument on the 2.1-m now provides stable measurements on stars of 8th and 9th magnitude. During FY07, public programs were able to make use of this exciting instrument through an agreement between KPNO and U. Florida. The next step in improving long-term stability is to provide an interferometer with full passive thermal compensation, very similar to the design used in the GONG network. The Exoplanet Tracker will continue to be available to NOAO visiting astronomers in FY08.
Relations with the Tohono O’odham Nation
Improving communication between the Tohono O’odham Nation and the observatory continues to be a major focus of the KPNO Director’s Office and the PAEO. We are working to build on our strong relationships with many segments of the Nation’s government to further our mutual interests. We hosted and supported the 2007 Summer Horse Camp of the Boys and Girls Club of Sells, hosted nighttime observing sessions of school children and adults from the Nation, and supported the educational programs of PAEO. We worked closely with representatives of the Tohono O’odham Natural Resources Office as they work to better understand the ecology of Kitt Peak, known as Iolkam Duag to many of the Tohono O’odham Nation. We continued to work successfully with the Tohono O’odham Department of Public Safety, as evidenced by our joint success in dealing with the threat of the Alambre wildfire in July 2007. B. Jannuzi and J. Dunlop attended the inaugural ceremony held for Chairman Ned Norris, Jr., and Vice Chairman Isidro B. Lopez, August 3, 2007. We will continue to work with the leaders of the Tohono O’odham as we further the mission of NOAO and KPNO, while respecting the land, culture, and people of the Tohono O’odham Nation.
15 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
VERITAS Project
The scientific goal of VERITAS is to detect and characterize the extremely-high-energy gamma-rays that are produced by quasars, supernova explosions, and other compact objects by the optical flashes emitted when the gamma-ray photons smash into the Earth’s atmosphere. This project, which received high priority in the astronomy decadal survey, is led by Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory (PI T. Weekes), and includes a consortium of universities: Purdue, Iowa State, Washington at St. Louis, Chicago, Utah, UCLA, McGill, Dublin in Ireland, and Leeds in the U.K. The U.S. partners are funded by the Smithsonian Institution, DOE, and NSF. The observatory was designed to consist of four to seven 12-m (36-foot) optical imaging telescopes, each with 315 mirror segments, and a 3.5-deg field of view. The final array configuration is planned to be a filled hexagon with sides of 265 ft. The initially funded configuration consists of four telescopes. The telescope array does not need access to the horizons, but does need protection from ground-level lights. The project identified a bowl area, Horseshoe Canyon, suitable for placing the telescopes, support structures, and control building. After receiving approval to sub-lease a dedicated site of ~20 acres and beginning site preparation and telescope construction, work was halted by the NSF and DOE in summer 2005, in voluntary response to a subsequently dismissed lawsuit by the Tohono O’odham Nation requesting a halt to construction. The NSF decided to have a new Environmental Assessment and a Cultural Resources Report prepared. Both of these important efforts are now complete. The Cultural Resources Report found that significant negative cultural impact would occur if the VERITAS project were to be brought into operation on Kitt Peak. As part of the Section 106 consultation process, the NSF began discussions with Chairwomen Vivian Juan-Saunders and other representatives of the Tohono O’odham Nation to see if a mutually satisfactory path forward for the completion of the project might be possible. A government-to-government meeting was held at the Schuk Toak District Office in January 2006. At this meeting (attended by the acting KPNO director), the NSF expressed its appreciation for the concerns of the people of the Tohono O’odham Nation and its desire to identify mitigation measures that might be of interest to the people and government of the Tohono O’odham Nation. During a subsequent meeting of the Tohono O’odham Legislative Council in May 2006, the NSF presented a mitigation plan for the Nation to consider. A response from the Tohono O’odham Nation to the written version of this plan was anticipated in October 2006, but was not received until December 2006. The Nation rejected the mitigation plan and repeated their preference that VERITAS not be constructed on Kitt Peak. In January of 2007, the NSF proceeded to terminate Section 106 discussions. VERITAS has now seen “first light” with its four telescopes in operation at the Whipple Observatory base facility near Mount Hopkins in southern Arizona. A decision on the final location of VERITAS is still pending.
Operations and Instrumentation Partnerships During FY07, the Mayall 4-m operations partnership with Clemson U. and the instrumentation partnership with U. Maryland both continued successfully. Clemson used their guaranteed observing time to further the research activities of their faculty and students, including several groups of undergraduates that participated in their first astronomical research activities. The partnership with U. Maryland, through both their cash contributions and software expertise, helped ensure the successful “first light” of NEWFIRM and is now furthering the development of ODI for the WIYN 3.5-m.
Deferred Maintenance and Modernization The recommendations of the NSF’s Senior Review, reported in November of 2006, have led to an increased emphasis on addressing issues of deferred maintenance and modernization at KPNO and CTIO. During the end of FY07, KPNO made an assessment of the health and status of our joint infrastructure on the mountain and of each of our telescopes. The inspections and planning have led to
16 THE GROUND-BASED O/IR OBSERVING SYSTEM
the identification of significant repairs to be undertaken during the next five years, as well as projects designed to improve the quality of the capabilities we offer to our user community. We have also started to hire a new generation of technicians and engineers, so that they might be trained in how to run a state-of-the-art observatory by the time the generation that built and developed KPNO during its first 50 years of operation has retired. We have hired a new detector/electrical engineer and a new mechanical designer. We are actively recruiting for a new technical associate on the mountain, a new electronics maintenance technician, and a servo/electrical engineer. These new hires, along with new scientific staff hires being made by NOAO during FY08, will provide the necessary additional people-power to undertake more ambitious modernization and new instrumentation projects in the years ahead.
Site Protection
The rapid growth of the Tucson metropolitan area requires a proactive approach to minimize the impact of light pollution on the operation of the observatory. In FY07, the acting KPNO director, B. Jannuzi made appearances at various government meetings to speak on behalf of protecting the night skies with enforcement of existing lighting codes. Jannuzi was appointed by the City of Tucson and Pima County to their respective Outdoor Lighting Code Committees in 2005 and continued to serve on these committees in FY07. Working together with other “dark skies” advocates and local citizen groups, Jannuzi worked toward a successful legal settlement (finalized in August 2006) of several long- standing disputes between Pima County and Clear Channel Outdoor, the major owner and operator of billboards in the Tucson area. In FY07, the same group worked to monitor compliance to the terms of the agreement. A major benefit of this settlement is that all of the lighting of Clear Channel’s billboards will be brought into compliance with the outdoor lighting code. Jannuzi also chaired a meeting between the U.S. Border Patrol and the tenant observatories on Kitt Peak to facilitate communication between these groups over the possible impact on astronomy of proposed permanent border patrol check points in southern Arizona. These efforts to keep the environment for astronomy as healthy as possible in southern Arizona will continue in FY08.
2.4 COMMUNITY ACCESS TO THE INDEPENDENT OBSERVATORIES
NOAO continues to coordinate the time allocation process for telescope time that is made available to the broad community on the large, private telescopes through the Telescope System Instrumentation Program (TSIP) and its predecessor, the Facility Instrumentation Program (FIP).
MMT Observatory and the Hobby-Eberly Telescope
In the late 1990s, NSF’s Facility Instrumentation Program granted instrument funds to groups associated with the Multiple Mirror Telescope (MMT) and the Hobby-Eberly Telescope (HET). In return, the MMT Observatory agreed to schedule 162 nights at a nominal rate of 26 nights per year, and the HET agreed to carry out observations equivalent to 101 clear nights at a nominal rate of 17 nights per year for telescope programs approved by NOAO’s Time Allocation Committee (TAC). NOAO’s role in this program is limited to the time allocation and community interface activities. In semesters 2007A/B, NOAO received 22 proposals for time on the MMT, with requests totaling 47 nights. Overall, this amounts to an oversubscription rate of about 2. Ten of these 22 proposals were granted time. Seventeen proposals for time on the HET were received in the two 2007 semesters, requesting a total of 28.6 nights. This amounts to an oversubscription rate of about 1.9 over the time available. Nine of these proposals were granted some or all of the time requested.
17 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Keck and Magellan Telescopes
NOAO’s role in TSIP includes not only the distribution of telescope time, but also the management of the annual TSIP proposal peer-review process and oversight of the instrument development activities of successful proposers. Those aspects of the program are discussed in Section 4.4 of this Annual Report. In both 2007 semesters, time from TSIP awards was available to the community on the Keck and Magellan telescopes. In 2007A and 2007B, four nights were available on each of the Keck 10-m telescopes in each semester. For those semesters, a total of 75 proposals requesting 109.5 nights were received. The resulting over-subscription rate was about 9.1. Twelve of these observing proposals were granted time on one of the Keck telescopes. In each of the 2007 semesters, there were 5 nights available for the two Magellan telescopes combined, thus a total of 10 nights in 2007. NOAO received 16 proposals requesting a total of 33 nights, an oversubscription rate of 3.3. Five of these proposals were granted time.
2.5 JOINT NOAO-NASA TIME ALLOCATION
NOAO has organized several ad hoc programs to address the needs of projects that require time on ground-based telescopes associated with observations made on one of NASA’s Great Observatories (Chandra, HST, and Spitzer). The goal of these arrangements is to eliminate the double jeopardy of two peer reviews for proposals that require both sets of observations to accomplish their objectives. In FY07, two Spitzer proposals and two Chandra proposals were approved for NOAO observations. No HST proposals that requested NOAO time were approved in this cycle.
2.6 NOAO SURVEY PROGRAMS
The NOAO Survey Program has been very successful, with 20 surveys undertaken since inception in 1999. The surveys tend to be multi-year projects and often are aimed at generating complete data sets. In 2003, it was realized that NOAO should make an effort to adjust its allocation of telescope time to accommodate weather and instrument problems that survey projects have encountered in order to improve the chances of success. Consequently, no new survey proposals were solicited in 2003 or 2004. Instead, the annual meeting of survey PIs was held with the survey panel of the NOAO TAC as audience, and the PIs were asked to address the needs of their surveys for supplemental telescope time. In January 2005, the AURA Observatories Council reviewed the survey program and endorsed its continuation. The 2006B solicitation was the second opportunity to propose since the program was restarted, and two new surveys were approved. The most recent survey opportunity was in semester 2008A. NOAO received 22 proposals requesting Survey status on 17 September 2007. These proposals will be reviewed by an ad-hoc Survey panel.
2.7 NOAO DATA PRODUCTS PROGRAM
The NOAO Data Products Program (DPP) is responsible for data management for all NOAO facilities and some affiliated facilities (e.g., SOAR, WIYN). It is also responsible for developing and supporting software to support the reduction and analysis of those data, both for the Observatory and for the community. We have merged these responsibilities into a single program of data management and science support, attempting to align both concepts in an integrated plan for the flow of data from the telescopes through to the science undertaken by the end users, be they the PIs of the observations or archival users.
18 THE GROUND-BASED O/IR OBSERVING SYSTEM
Data Management System
The Data Products Program has focused on the development of an integrated data management and processing system that will provide efficient access to NOAO data and data products for the astronomical community. This system is referred to as the E2E, or End-to-End, data management system. Work on this system in FY07 was aimed at completing the development and the deployment of E2E v1.0 for the user community. The core components of this system are the NOAO Data Transport System (DTS), the NOAO Science Archive (NSA), the NOAO Pipelines (discussed in the next subsection), and the NOAO NVO Portal. Versions of both the DTS and NVO Portal have been deployed previously (in 2004 and 2006, respectively), so the deployment of E2E v1.0 has focused on the integration of those systems with the fully re-engineered NSA, a scaleable archive system based on a service-oriented architecture with multiple services that will be installed over the widely distributed system (six sites, including three mountaintops serving more than 10 telescopes and more than 30 instruments). The integrated E2E v1.0 system is targeted at supporting only the Mosaic CCD Imager and NEWFIRM instruments, specifically capturing the raw data from these instruments and making the data available to users through the NOAO NVO Portal. This system is being deployed for selected beta test users in October 2007, in preparation for a wider release in early 2008. The general user interface of the E2E system, the NOAO NVO Portal, has seen substantial public use since the release of the prototype in January 2007. Included in the release of E2E v1.0 is an update to the Portal that supports user logins based on the NVO single-sign-on protocols and libraries. This work is discussed further in the NVO section.
Pipelines
The DPP pipeline effort initially focused on developing an automated processing system for visiting observer Mosaic data. This required the development of a general pipeline infrastructure, the incorporation of many existing Mosaic algorithms available from the IRAF mscred package, and development of new algorithms to support automated reduction from a wide variety of user data acquisition strategies (some with dome flats, some with twilight flats, some with standards, and others with very few calibration frames at all!). During FY07 the Mosaic pipeline efforts culminated in the transition from intense development to extensive science verification on diverse data sets. These efforts continue during the transition to FY08, as we begin beta-release of Mosaic pipeline data products to visiting astronomers to obtain user feedback before producing the first generation of archive-ready Mosaic pipeline products. During FY07, work on data reduction pipelines moved from its early focus on the CCD mosaic imagers to include NEWFIRM, the wide-field near-IR imager that recently was installed on the Mayall 4-m at KPNO. This development is being undertaken with the assistance of two personnel from U. Maryland, a scientist and a software developer. The first release of the NEWFIRM pipeline was used to support commissioning of the instrument.
NEWFIRM support
DPP staff completed the development of the NEWFIRM Data Handling System (DHS), which captures the telemetry flowing out of the NEWFIRM’s MONSOON controllers and translates it into FITS files with appropriate extensions and headers. The DHS is also responsible for the real-time display of the data so that the observer can immediately see the fruits of the last exposure. In addition, DPP staff developed the mountain-based “quick look, quick reduce” platform for NEWFIRM data, which will provide the observer immediate feedback with preliminary reductions of data coming in from the camera. Both the DHS and quick look/reduce software were used extensively in the second NEWFIRM commissioning run in mid-2007 and are being finalized for the first visiting observer runs in early FY08.
19 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Operations
The NOAO DTS continued its uninterrupted operation (since August 2004), and has now accumulated more than 20TB of data. Raw data repositories are currently maintained in La Serena, Tucson, and at the National Center for Supercomputing Applications (NCSA). Additional methods of monitoring the data flow and identifying and fixing problems as they arise have been implemented to provide further security for the data being taken on NOAO facilities. Operations has also included continued growth of the current NOAO Science Archive, which only holds NOAO Survey datasets. Several additional reduced datasets from NOAO Surveys were added during FY07. The effort that will be needed to support the routine operation of the E2E system and support community use has begun to ramp up. Help desk and bug tracking systems have been in regular use, and the operations staff have developed a thorough testing system for all software being delivered by DPP development.
Science Support Software
DPP is also responsible for science support software. This currently includes IRAF and a limited set of VO tools and services available from the NOAO NVO portal (nvo.noao.edu). After more than a year of extremely limited resources, FY07 saw significant IRAF development funded by a combination of base budget and NVO grant money. By the end of FY07, a new version of IRAF, v2.14, was being finalized for beta release, with plans for a final release in Q1 or Q2 FY08. This release includes a variety of bug fixes and patches that have been developed during work on the pipeline and other DPP efforts, as well as new features such as official support for MacOS X/Intel and Cygwin platforms and support for new external packages including one for NEWFIRM data reduction. Additional work in IRAF has focused on VO-related improvements, discussed further in the NVO section of this report.
20
3 NOAO MAJOR INSTRUMENTATION PROGRAM
3.1 NOAO INSTRUMENTS
NOAO Extremely Wide-Field IR Imager (NEWFIRM)
NEWFIRM, a world-class capability for wide-field imaging in the near infrared, is a key element in the U.S. system of facilities provided by NOAO. It has a 27×27 arcmin field of view with 0.4 arcsec per pixel at 1–2.4 microns and will operate at the R-C focus on either 4-m telescope (Mayall or Blanco). The instrument per se will be complemented by a highly automated data reduction pipeline, which will feed the NOAO data archive. FY07 saw the completion of integration and testing and two successful commissioning runs on the Mayall telescope. FY07 began with the instrument undergoing reassembly for its first full-field optical test. This test was carried out in the NOAO Flexure Testing Facility using the original “engineering grade” Lens 8, which had localized regions of poor surface quality. This was also the first test with a fully populated focal plane, albeit with one of the four detectors still being a poor engineering-grade device. This test demonstrated that the image quality was acceptable all across the field of view, but the spatial sampling of the test procedure was sparse and did not allow detailed identification of the effects of the localized problems with Lens 8. During the test, the much better replacement version of Lens 8 was received from the vendor (Tinsley), but there was not sufficient time to warm the instrument and install it. During this final cold test, considerable work also was done to improve detector performance by tuning the detector operating parameters. In late January 2007, NEWFIRM was installed on the Mayall telescope for the first time (Figure 6). Thanks to the careful planning and preparation by the KPNO mountain engineering and support staff, the installation went very smoothly. The first few nights of the run were lost to a winter storm, but the commissioning team made good use of the time by running tests inside the closed dome and resolving software problems. On the first night after the storm, the commissioning team was on the sky and collecting data within an hour after opening the dome. During this run, the team demonstrated basic operation of the instrument from engineering-level software and obtained valuable in situ test data on most aspects of the integrated package of user software for observing, on-the-fly data examination, and observation scripting. In addition, science verification data were collected on various fields, most notably in the Orion Nebula (Figure 7), using both Figure 6: Combined forces of KPNO Engineering and MIP installing broad and narrowband filters. J. Bally NEWFIRM at the Cassegrain focus of the 4-m Mayall telescope for (U. Colorado) and J. Walawender (U. the first time. Hawaii) collaborated in this part of the science verification program.
21 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Figure 7: As part of the NEWFIRM Science Verification program, the Becklin-Neugebauer-Kleinman-Low (BNKL) nebula in the Orion Constellation was observed. The images were taken in the 2.12-micron line of molecular hydrogen, which is excited by shocks and by fluorescence at boundaries between ionized and molecular gas. The full NEWFIRM field is shown on the left; note the poor noise performance of the engineering grade array in the lower right quarter. The green blocks are masked bad pixels; too few dithered sub-images were taken to allow complete fill-in of all the bad pixels. A detail of part of the upper right quadrant is shown on the right side, to illustrate the generally excellent image quality. During the following months, a substantial amount of work was done to improve the performance of the MONSOON controller, the cryogenic system, the internal light baffling, and the data handling system software. The replacement Lens 8 from Tinsley was installed, and considerable effort was also devoted to addressing anomalies encountered during the first run, including fixing a wire that came loose inside the dewar during transport. Finally, the poor engineering-grade detector was replaced with an intermediate-quality unit obtained from Raytheon Vision Systems (RVS) during closeout of the detector production contract. In May, the dewar was closed up again, and the instrument went through another cold test in the flex rig before being returned to Kitt Peak in June. NEWFIRM was reinstalled on the Mayall telescope in late June and went through its second commissioning-plus-science-verification run in late June and early July. During this run, substantial improvements were seen in detector performance and cryogenic stability due to the work done between runs. The data handling system was improved, tuned, and used successfully, allowing initial testing of the automated quick-look data processing software. Also, the guider was calibrated and tested in a variety of modes. Some progress was also made in getting the guider, the data handling system, and the quick-look pipeline to work together under the control of automated observing scripts; this scripted observing mode is essential to efficient use of the instrument. All of this progress came under the pressure of slowly increasing lost time due to the arrival of the summer thunderstorms in Arizona. Also, the last nights of the run were lost when Kitt Peak was evacuated due to a nearby wildfire; the evacuation came just as the commissioning team was ready to demonstrate fully automatic scripted observing. When normal mountain activity resumed following the wildfire, NEWFIRM was brought back to Tucson for its final improvements and tuning. The intermediate-grade detector installed before the second run was replaced with a better device obtained through a separate arrangement with Raytheon Vision Systems, yielding a final focal plane with uniformly good response and low dark current. The final optimizations to the detector parameters were made, and a new filter was installed to enable a highly ranked science proposal. As FY07 closed, NEWFIRM was being closed up and tested in preparation for a return to Kitt Peak in late October 2007. Semester 2007B will see the first scheduled
22 NOAO MAJOR INSTRUMENTATIONMENTATION PROGRAM
science observations with NEWFIRM, thus marking the end of the commissioning phase and the beginning of NEWFIRM’s service life as a facility instrument.
SSOAROAR Adaptive Optics Module (SAM)
The SOAR 4.2-m telescope on Cerro Pachón will produce very high quality images over a field of view 10 arcminutes square. The SOAR Adaptive Optics Module (SAM) is designed to enhance this image quality by correcting the turbulence in the first 5–10 km of atmosphere, reducing the image size by half during appropriate atmospheric conditions, which are expected to be available about half the time. SAM will incorporate a UV laser guide star working in Rayleigh backscatter mode, with laser pulses and shutter timings coordinated to select the altitude of the reflection used for the wavefront correction. SAM is being implemented in two overlapping phases: the first phase for the main Adaptive Optics (AO) module, and the second phase for the Laser Guide Star (LGS) system. The main AO module will be commissioned first and can be used for some limited science applications in natural-guide-star mode prior to delivery of the LGS. The SAM team made considerable progress on detailed design and fabrication of components during FY2007. By the end of the year, all of the drawings for the plates making up the main module optical bench structure had Figure 8: Engineering drawing of the SAM main module as it will be on the SOAR telescope during commissioning. SAM is been completed and released to the shop installed on the “side” port of the Instrument Support Box. The for fabrication (Figure 8). A large round blue dewar of the dedicated CCD imager appears at the number of components had been top of SAM, and the High-Resolution Camera used for fabricated ahead of the plates, allowing commissioning and alignment in “natural-guide-star” mode appears on the visitor port at the bottom. assembly and integration of various subsystems including the wavefront sensor to proceed ahead of the optical bench (Figure 9). In addition, the remaining optics for the main module including the Off-Axis Paraboloids were received from the vendors and accepted. Integration of the entire main module can thus proceed rapidly as soon as the optical bench plates are made. The SAM team completed the preliminary design for the Laser Guide Star system, the second major phase of the project. The laser itself will mount to the side of the telescope, and the auxiliary equipment such as power supplies and cooling pumps will mount as close as possible, consistent with suitable locations. The laser launch telescope will mount behind the secondary mirror. The laser beam will be transferred to the launch telescope along an enclosed optical path with a minimal number of reflections. Completion of this design required definition of a number of interfaces with the SOAR telescope and resolution of numerous telescope modifications with the SOAR staff. In all cases, solutions were identified that meet the needs of the project and satisfy the requirements of the observatory for ease of maintenance and prevention of interference with other telescope functions. Basic safety requirements for laser operation and maintenance were also spelled out. The SAM team completed a successful Preliminary Design Review for the LGS system 28 September 2007. The current state of the work should permit delivery of the Main Module to the SOAR telescope sometime around the end of FY08, with delivery of the LGS system occurring about nine months later.
23 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Figure 9: Two subsystems of the SAM Main Module. On the left is the High-Resolution Camera fully assembled, and on the right is the Wave Front Sensor Module during its first test-fit assembly with the glass lenses.
MONSOON Detector Controller The MONSOON image acquisition system is the NOAO solution for scalable, multi-channel, high- speed image acquisition systems required for next-generation projects. MONSOON is designed to be flexible enough to support CCD, CMOS, and IR diode imaging arrays in a wide variety of uses, including science instruments, acquisition and guide cameras, and wavefront sensors. It is under development jointly by staff at both NOAO North in Tucson and NOAO South in La Serena. FY07 saw the delivery of several additional CCD controllers ordered by the Dark Energy Camera consortium for their detector characterization and design development work, and a second unit to Indiana U. for their “copy” of the FHIRE instrument. Continued development work on the CCD version led to the first successful implementation of on-chip guiding by the MONSOON system for the Orthogonal Transfer Array (OTA) CCDs in the QUOTA system. QUOTA is a small-scale testbed instrument for WIYN, in preparation for the full- scale One Degree Imager (ODI) instrument. Software and firmware for OTA control were developed jointly by staff from the Major Instrumentation Program and WIYN Observatory. Much work was also devoted on the IR versions to tuning the NEWFIRM system for optimal performance and minimum noise in the telescope environment, and to achieving uniform performance across the 2×2 mosaic focal plane. This work extended across two commissioning runs at the Mayall telescope and months of work in Tucson between the runs. Brief but intense support was also given to the WHIRC instrument team (including personnel from Space Telescope Science Institute, Johns Hopkins U., and U. Wisconsin) during the final preparations for their first commissioning run on the WIYN telescope in July. As FY07 closed, the MONSOON team was hard at work defining, with the WIYN ODI team, the complete implementation of MONSOON for the ODI system. It is expected that this work will be the dominant focus of the MONSOON effort during FY08.
24
4 NOAO AND THE DECADAL SURVEY PROJECTS
4.1 GIANT SEGMENTED MIRROR TELESCOPE PROGRAM OFFICE (GSMTPO)
During the year, the NOAO GSMT Program Office evolved from the AURA New Initiatives Office (NIO), while retaining its core mission of “ensuring broad astronomical community access to a 30-m- class telescope that will be contemporaneous with ALMA and JWST, by playing a key role in scientific and technical studies leading to the creation of the Giant Segmented Mirror Telescope (GSMT).” This evolution was a result of new direction from the National Science Foundation, following the conclusion of the AST Senior Review. During the first months of FY07, still operating as NIO, efforts focused on: (1) support of the activities of the Giant Segmented Mirror Telescope Science Working Group, a broadly-based group charged with providing advice regarding investments in a GSMT that will achieve the goal of community access to a 30-m-class telescope by the middle of the next decade; and (2) active participation in the technical and scientific working groups critical to advancing the TMT concept during its Design and Development Phase. Subsequently, AURA was directed to withdraw as a partner from TMT, but to continue its efforts to define community needs and develop community support for public access to a GSMT. Most of the staff engaged in TMT design and development were therefore shifted to support of other projects, most notably LSST and ATST. The GSMT SWG was reconstituted with a modified membership matched to its revised mission; GSMTPO is charged with continuing to provide scientific and technical support to the group.
Staffing
The GSMTPO is staffed by NOAO engineers and scientists, located in Tucson, Arizona and La Serena, Chile. In addition, three former members of the NIO staff are now based in Pasadena, holding key positions—Optics and Systems group leaders and Observatory Scientist—in the TMT Project Office, while retaining their AURA affiliation.
Web Site The GSMTPO public Web site at http://www.gsmt.noao.edu is an essential vehicle for communicating ongoing GSMTPO activities. The Web site, which is updated periodically, also contains copies of project presentations and links to the sites of other Extremely Large Telescope (ELT) groups.
GSMT Science Working Group (SWG)
In 2002, AURA created a community-wide GSMT Science Working Group (SWG) in response to a request from the National Science Foundation. The charge to the SWG is to “advise the NSF Division of Astronomical Sciences on a strategy for guiding federal investment in a Giant Segmented Mirror Telescope (GSMT).” Rolf-Peter Kudritzki, Director of the Institute for Astronomy at U. Hawaii, is the chair of the GSMT SWG, with NOAO’s S. Strom as vice-chair. The SWG provides a public forum for discussion of technical progress and scientific capabilities of the two ongoing U.S. ELT programs: Giant Magellan Telescope (GMT) and Thirty Meter Telescope (TMT). Following the new direction from the NSF, the membership of the SWG was modified to include a greater proportion of representatives not directly involved with TMT/GMT. The SWG has also enjoyed high-level representation from the Japanese astronomical community. NIO
25 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
staff members supported several investigations of the GSMT SWG by carrying out technical, performance simulation, and project planning studies. By the end of FY05, the SWG had completed two major reports, “Frontier Science Enabled by a Giant Segmented Mirror Telescope,” (available at www.gsmt.noao.edu/gsmt_swg/SWG_Report/SWG_Report_7.2.03.pdf) and “A Giant Segmented Mirror Telescope: Synergy with the James Webb Space Telescope” (available at www.aura- astronomy.org/nv/GSMT_SynergyCase.pdf). In summer 2005, the GSMT SWG was charged with developing an understanding of the scientific performance of ELTs as a function of telescope aperture. The SWG carried out a number of simulations for key ELT science programs aimed at quantitative understanding of performance versus aperture and determining whether there are any obvious “cliffs.” Preliminary drafts of the essential elements of the report were reviewed in August 2006. The report material is expected to be included in the supporting documentation for the GSMT “Design Reference Mission” that the SWG has been asked to prepare for the NSF. In support of these activities, a meeting combining the members of both the previous SWG and the new SWG (many of whom are the same) was scheduled for early November 2007. The intent of the meeting is to lay out future activities by the SWG.
ELT Development Support: AURA Proposal to NSF
The July 2004 proposal submitted by AURA to NSF requested $39.4M to provide:
1. The public portion ($17.5M) of the funds needed to carry out the Design and Development Phase for a 30-m diameter segmented-mirror, optical/infrared telescope (i.e., TMT).
2. Funds ($14M) sufficient to advance to the Design and Development Phase an alternative 20–30-m-class concept, such as the Giant Magellan Telescope (GMT), to the point where its performance, cost, and risk can be assessed.
3. Technology development ($2M) common to both TMT and the alternative concept.
4. $1.5M for community groups to carry out conceptual designs for two instruments: one for TMT and one for the alternative concept.
5. $3.5M to support an education and public outreach program.
6. $0.9M to support a Theory Challenge program aimed at engaging theorists in shaping the design of ELTs.
The first of these investments was to leverage the $35M in non-federal funding (donated by the Moore Foundation to the California Institute of Technology and U. California), plus funds requested of the Canadian Foundation for Innovation (CFI). The TMT project partnership, after AURA’s withdrawal, comprises the Association of Canadian Universities for Research in Astronomy, the California Institute of Technology, and U. California, The second major investment supports a design study aimed at developing an alternate technical approach. Following review of two proposals from the community, a review panel was selected for support of the Giant Magellan Telescope (GMT), a concept that provides the collecting area of a 21.5-m telescope by combining the light from seven 8.4-m mirrors. The GMT project is a partnership among the Carnegie Institution of Washington, Harvard U., Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory, U. Arizona, U. Texas at Austin, U. Michigan, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Texas A&M U., and Australian National U.
26 NOAO AND THE DECADAL SURVEY PROJECTS
AURA will ensure strong community participation by both observers and theorists in shaping each of the ELT designs via the GSMT SWG, so that the resulting facility performance fully meets community aspirations. In addition, both TMT and GMT have invited AURA representatives as observers to design reviews and project working group meetings. This approach will allow AURA to keep apprised of the progress of both ELT programs in order to maximize transparency of technical studies, and to ensure that the imagination and technical talent in the U.S. community is fully engaged in developing key technologies and instrument concepts. Initial funding in the amount of $1M was received at the end of FY05, $2M was received during FY06, and an additional $5M was received in FY07. These funds are split between TMT and GMT, on behalf of the U.S. community. The distribution is intended to provide equal cumulative contributions to both projects, including allowance for NOAO in-kind contributions to the TMT DDP, by the end of FY08.
ELT Development Support: TMT Design and Development During the first part of FY07, NOAO staff continued contributions to technical development activities key to the successful completion of the Design and Development Phase for TMT. The efforts, which followed the TMT Cost Review in September 2006, mainly comprised design modifications aimed at reducing overall project costs. Following the NSF-directed withdrawal from the partnership, the staff involved in the design efforts worked to provide a smooth hand-over of work done to date, which was completed by the beginning of January 2007. Although most staff were transferred to other AURA projects at the time, TMT has subsequently contracted with NOAO to continue some efforts, largely in areas related to optical modeling and systems engineering, at less than 1 FTE. AURA had been represented on the TMT Scientific Advisory Committee by four members, of whom three were AURA employees and the fourth, C. Telesco of U. Florida, was from the general community. The AURA members were withdrawn in October 2006, but TMT chose to request that Telesco continue to participate as a U.S. community representative. GMT is expected to appoint a similar representative to their Science Working Group.
ELT Site Selection: Site Testing for the Thirty Meter Telescope Starting with a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the California Extremely Large Telescope (CELT) group in FY02, AURA has played a major collaborative role in evaluating candidate sites for TMT. This effort is expected to conclude in 2008 with TMT final site selection and publication of the site survey data. The list of candidate sites has been narrowed by investigations of logistical issues such as land ownership, as well as by a series of remote sensing studies that have used satellite data to quantify the number of clear nights and the precipitable water vapor for each site. Each prime candidate site has also been modeled using computational fluid dynamics to investigate the boundary layer turbulence over the site under various wind speeds and directions. In-situ site testing equipment has been developed, and multiple copies have been purchased and assembled. This equipment includes weather stations, differential image motion monitors (DIMMs) capable of recording integrated seeing through the upper atmosphere and ground-layer, and multi- aperture scintillation sensors (MASS) capable of mapping turbulence profiles above candidate sites. Weather stations, DIMM and MASS units have been deployed on five candidate sites. Results to date indicate that all of the sites being investigated are excellent astronomical sites. The survey result will therefore be of value to future telescope projects other than TMT.
FY07 Technical Papers by GSMTPO Staff
No technical papers related to GSMTPO activities were published in FY07 by GSMTPO staff.
27 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
4.2 LARGE-APERTURE SYNOPTIC SURVEY TELESCOPE (LSST)
The LSST project is being carried out by the LSST Corporation, which is a non-profit corporation chartered in the state of Arizona. LSSTC now has 21 members; NOAO is a founding member of the corporation. Interest in joining the corporation has been expressed by several European organizations, and discussions are ongoing. The LSST project is now about halfway through the Design and Development (D&D) Phase, with the NSF Concept Design Review (CoDR) successfully completed 21 September 2007. NOAO’s primary responsibility is for the telescope and site. The Department of Energy, led by SLAC, is responsible for the camera. Data management responsibilities will be shared by LSSTC, NCSA at U. Illinois, and, very likely, IPAC at Caltech.
Telescope and Site
The concept design for the telescope and its supporting analysis were completed this year culminating in the preparation and execution of the project-wide CoDR, which was held in Tucson 17–21 September 2007. The NSF-commissioned review panel recommended immediate advancement to the Preliminary Design Phase. Leading up to the CoDR, a series of subsystem design reviews focused on each of the major elements of the Telescope and Site WBS. The concept design and the supporting material are consistent with the reference design provided in the LSST MREFC proposal. Analyses completed to support the design work include a design study of high-resolution, high-load-capacity hexapod systems, the impact of wind on image motion, primary mirror hard point stress, primary mirror cell stresses, error allocation analysis, and detailed mirror requirements analysis. Prototype efforts completed this year include: aluminum/silver coating test samples, the telescope control system (TCS) kernel, observatory control system middleware abstraction tools, data distribution service software, and a network of hardware to support a prototype LSST control system. Prototyping has demonstrated that the architecture chosen for the control system will support a distributed system with diverse components and large command, control, and telemetry streams. The prototype C++ shell developed for the TCS kernel and connected to this middleware as well as the middleware abstraction code is now planned for use in the upgrade of the 4-m Blanco telescope at CTIO. The geotechnical survey of El Peñón, the peak where LSST will be sited on Cerro Pachón, has been completed. The report shows that the rock is of high quality and integrity. A 30-m tower has been erected on site with four anemometers positioned at various heights. The wind conditions at each sensor are now being logged continuously. The IR all-sky camera has been delivered and checked and has been deployed in Tucson and on Mt. Bigelow for commissioning campaigns. C. Claver presented the LSST project to the Chilean business and science communities at a meeting organized by SOFOFA, the Chilean equivalent to the Chamber of Commerce, in June 2007, in Santiago, Chile.
Training and Development J. Barr, a senior at U. Arizona, who has now graduated with a Bachelor’s degree in mathematics and physics, worked with the telescope and site group on site data analysis and the development of an automated photometry algorithm for use on the CTIO-developed all-sky cameras. The telescope and site group at NOAO provided mentors and advisors for T. J. Rodigas, a senior at U. Virginia, while he participated in the NOAO/KPNO REU program. He worked on the development of a prototype wavefront sensing pre-processor pipeline to analyze crowded star fields and prepare them for curvature sensing.
28 NOAO AND THE DECADAL SURVEY PROJECTS
Science Collaborations
Ten science collaborations with participants drawn from the LSSTC membership have been established to guide the project team with respect to scientific requirements and to assist with commissioning and quality assurance. Each collaboration deals with a specific science topic that will be addressed by the LSST. The topics range from astrometry and the study of nearby stars to the characterization of dark energy. An open call for scientists at non-member institutions to join the collaborations will be issued this winter, and a preliminary description of this opportunity appeared in the “NOAO/NSO Newsletter” in September.
LSST D&D Education and Public Outreach (EPO) Program
The LSST EPO program continued at a high level of activity with S. Croft taking the lead in educational project development. In the asteroid characterization project, a set of classroom activities and supporting curricular materials was completed and posted on a dedicated Web site. Testing in middle-school earth science classrooms was begun. To provide flexibility to the teacher, several projects were developed: a “short version” on asteroids that includes a one-day introduction to asteroids and a simple observing experience; a “long version” that includes a one- to two-week introduction to asteroids, meteorites, and their connection to earth rocks and geologic processes; and an open-ended observation project. Assessment and testing of the curriculum by outside reviewers and classroom teachers is continuing. In the visualization project, designed to develop educationally effective interactions of students and the general public with large-format astronomical images, an exploratory activity was developed by S. Croft in conjunction with the HiRISE Mars camera project at U. Arizona; and development of a user-friendly computer interface was begun by a team at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, led by physics faculty member J. Keller.
4.3 NATIONAL VIRTUAL OBSERVATORY (NVO)
Creation of a National Virtual Observatory (NVO) was the highest ranked priority initiative of the National Academy of Sciences decadal survey in the small project (less than $100M) category. NOAO has been involved with the development of the NVO from its inception and has continued to play a significant role as this project has moved from the conceptual to the development stages and finally towards operations. In FY07, the contributions from NOAO to the NVO continued at both the management and programmatic levels. D. De Young continued as a member of the NVO Executive Committee and as the Project Scientist of the NSF/ITR NVO initiative. De Young also took on the role of chair of the International Virtual Observatory Alliance (IVOA). He continued as a member of the IVOA Theory Working Group. DPP showed a stronger participation in NVO team meetings with M. Fitzpatrick, C. Miller, and C. Smith all participating in discussions and development of NVO plans. M. Fitzpatrick served as one of three editors for the “NVO Book,” based on lectures given at the NVO Summer Schools. This book is being positioned to provide an in-depth introduction to the wide variety of tools and services available in the NVO. DPP continued to play a leading role in the development of VOEvent, the emerging VO standard for astronomical announcements, most specifically announcements with a time-critical component. NOAO hosted“Hot-wiring the Transient Universe: a Joint VOEvent/HTN Workshop” (www.cacr.caltech.edu/hotwired) in Tucson, 4–7 June 2007. This event was co-sponsored by NOAO and NVO, as well as by LSST, LANL and eSTAR, and was chaired by DPP staff member R. Seaman. P. Warner, M. Fitzpatrick, and C. Smith made significant contributions to this successful workshop. Seaman will co-edit the proceedings. P. Warner has continued an implementation that has become a distributable set of VOEvent components for authoring, publishing, archiving, and/or relaying events.
29 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Warner has been working with S. Barthelmy of NASA GSFC to re-layer the Gamma-ray bursts Coordinates Network (GCN) on VOEvent using NOAO’s Java-based broker. Several DPP staff attended the IVOA InterOp meeting in Beijing, China. M. Fitzpatrick worked with IVOA colleagues on the applications messaging protocol in the IVOA Applications Working Group, jointly moderating several sessions. C. Miller presented the NOAO NVO Portal and related scientific use of the VO. P. Warner reported on progress deploying the NOAO VOEvent broker, both in general and specifically in support of the ESSENCE supernova survey. Funding from NVO research award 8601-06861 is gratefully acknowledged for this work. NVO work extended into significant IRAF-related development efforts, resulting in a VO package for IRAF together with a new “vo-cl” command line agent. These developments bring the VO into IRAF, allowing users to access a variety of VO tools and services from the cl command line. The capabilities are based on a new “VO-client” which can serve as an interface between code-level host VO calls and distributed VO services, not only for IRAF calls but also for other codes such as those written in FORTRAN. The DPP Portal team developed a new version of the NOAO NVO portal, a browser-based tool that enables users to visually discover, access, and analyze data that exist under VO-compliant access points. The NOAO NVO Portal was debuted at the January 2006 AAS meeting and has been active since. DPP Operations was responsible for deploying and operating the Portal and the NOAO NVO Web page, and they monitor user statistics, which continue to indicate that roughly 10–20 unique users per day access the NOAO NVO Portal. The Portal provides a “Google-maps”style front-end, where users see instrument wire-frames distributed across the sky. The Portal currently provides access to NOAO Science Archive images, HST, Chandra, XMM, CNOC, and the SDSS DR3 archive. Users can select data from multiple archives with the simple click of a mouse and download multi-archive datasets from one centralized location. The Portal also provides a time (calendar) view, so that users can see when data were taken. Finally, the Portal provides a direct link to NVO analysis services, like the WESIX source extraction tool and the NOAO WCSFixer tool. The most important new feature of the NOAO NVO Portal is the full implementation of the NVO Single-Sign-On functionality and its integration into the full E2E system, in collaboration with R. Plante at the NCSA. This VO security effort continues to move forward in its collaborative development, and NOAO will be the first major astronomical archive to be using this important new NVO service.
4.4 TELESCOPE SYSTEM INSTRUMENTATION PROGRAM (TSIP)
TSIP has the goal of strengthening the system of public and private optical/IR facilities by funding the development of facility instruments for large private telescopes, and thereby broadening community access to these telescopes. The program was established in FY02 as a $4M per year program administered and coordinated by NOAO for NSF. Because of this year’s continuing budget resolution, it was not clear that TSIP would be funded beyond previous commitments. However, the full $4M annual allocation was funded and a call for proposals put out in April 2007. By the May 11 deadline, six letters of intent for new instruments were received along with two letters proposing system access. TSIP clearly remains a significant and popular funding avenue for the private observatories in the U.S. system. An independent review committee is set to meet in October 2007 to recommend new allocations (chair, A. Kinney, NASA). The table below shows the current summary of past TSIP allocations and the system access they have provided to the broad U.S. astronomical community.
30 NOAO AND THE DECADAL SURVEY PROJECTS
TSIP Funding and Time Allocation Summary: 2002–Present Start of Time Year Awards Instrument Amount Nights Telescope Cost/night Allocated 2002 CARA OSIRIS $2.75M 29 Keck $47,400 2003A CARA KIRMOS $1.14M 12 Keck $47,400 2003A 2003 Harvard SAO MMIRS $2.5M* 54 MMT/Magellan $23,000 2004A CARA KIRMOS $1.1M 12 Keck $45,800 2004A 2005 CARA MOSFIRE $2.45M 24 Keck $51,000 2006B WIYN ODI $1.64M* 40 WIYN $12,300 † 2006 CARA MOSFIRE $4.9M* 48 Keck $51,000 2007A Ohio State MODS $2.6M 25 LBT $52,000 2007A‡ Carnegie Mosaic2§ $648K 15 Magellan $21,600 2007A
Totals $19.7M 259 * Over 3 yrs. † Nights to be taken with ODI, which is not yet completed ‡ Planned start § New CCD mosaic for the IMACS instrument at Magellan
The current projects being overseen by the TSIP program office at NOAO are: Mosaic2, a new CCD focal plane for the IMACS imager at Magellan; the One Degree Imager, a large orthogonal transfer CCD focal plane for WIYN; MODS2, the dual channel multi-object spectrometer for LBT (copy 2, by Ohio State); and MOSFIRE, the Keck near-infrared multi-object spectrometer. Highlights for the year include a trip to UCLA to attend the MOSFIRE detailed design review (DDR). The review committee passed on the final design for MOSFIRE and the team is now busy placing orders and putting drawings into the shop for fabrication. The centerpiece of MOSFIRE is a cold-configurable multi-object focal plane mask being constructed by the Swiss Centre for Micro-Electronics (CSEM). Throughout FY07, R. Blum and M. Trueblood participated in management oversight activities for the instrumentation projects listed above. These activities included monthly reports (both written and via teleconference) from the projects.
4.5 ADAPTIVE OPTICS DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM (AODP)
No additional awards were made in FY07 for the approved AODP projects from the FY05 proposals, and no additional funding has been granted by the NSF. The AODP has four remaining projects still being worked on. Those are the two detector development projects to develop low-noise detectors for wavefront sensors and two to develop reliable sodium lasers. Three of these four projects have been totally funded and all of those requested and were granted no-cost extensions to complete the work. All four of the projects ran into delays associated with the research activities, but are slowly getting back on track to complete the efforts.
UC Berkeley “A Noiseless Imaging Detector for AO with Kilohertz Frame Rates:” The initial statement of work included producing a working vacuum tube containing the GaAs photocathode and Medipix2 anodes. The project continues to be delayed arising from problems in achieving a high vacuum in the tube; there have been leaks associated with the brazing of the tubes. The current work plan includes rebuilding the tube using a He leak checker at each stage of fabrication. Some success was achieved in
31 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
proving that the Medipix2 chip will survive the 350-degree bakeout cycle in the tube complete with the wire bonds. The electronics readout has also been successfully demonstrated. A no-cost extension was requested and authorized contingent upon the successful completion of the work for year 3, to proceed with performance of the work for year 4 beginning 1 September 2007, and concluding on 31 March 2008. UC Berkeley has received all of the total award of $900,233.
CARA
“Development of the Next Generation Optical Detectors for Wavefront Sensing:” CARA has been granted a 1-year, no-cost extension for the effort to end on 31 December 2007. The project had been delayed with MIT/LL so the detectors could be piggy-backed onto another development project. The phase 1 devices with the planar JFET amplifier (CCID-56) took longer than expected to complete back-side processing. Two wafers were selected for thinning and then the QE was pinned using an MBE process. These parts were on a wafer run with some x-ray imagers (for the Constellation X satellite project), and for which no AR coating is wanted. As a result, these parts had to be masked off when AR coating the CCID-56b parts. When the AR coating was done, the masking was incompletely removed over the parts, and the AR coating was poor as a result. MIT/LL decided to remove the AR coating using an acid etch and try again. They also had some problems with the light shield mask, and as a result did not complete packaging of the back-side parts until the end of 2006. Parts were finally shipped to the CCD lab at UCO/Lick and to SciMeasure in March 2007. R. Stover was able to test the first CCID-56b part and discovered that the QE was very poor and the dark current elevated. After dicussing this with MIT/LL, they admitted (somewhat sheepishly) that the acid etch to remove the bad AR coating had probably destroyed the MBE layer, resulting in the poor QE, and this had also created defects on the back-side layer that resulted in the elevated dark current. This is a significant setback to testing of what is believed to be a very low-noise device. MIT/LL has been able to obtain permission from the primary wafer customer (the Constellation X project) to take two more wafers from the lot and process them for this project without masking off the X-ray imagers (effectively sacrificing those imagers). This process will take approximately two more months. Some CCID-56 parts with the planar JFET amplifier were also placed on a PanSTARRS wafer run that was done late last year. These parts are designated the CCID-56d because of an additional signal (a no-connect pin on the CCID-56b) that is used to deplete the substrate, a feature of the PanSTARRS device design. These parts are on a wafer with imagers that have very similar QE requirements, so there is no masking needed, and there are some wafers that have been back-side processed and AR coated. Some of these parts are being packaged and should ship to the CCD lab and SciMeasure for testing. In summary, the project is still waiting for confirmation of the low-noise performance of the front-side devices on usable back-side parts, but this should take place shortly. A readout system and cryostat are ready to use with the device, and it is planned to characterize this complete system at WMKO with the intention of installing it on the Keck I AO system when the new guide-star laser is installed at the end of this year. The Phase II design has benefited from further work with the CfAO on the system level design of the polar coordinate detector. The project team has been working with S. Thomas, a CfAO post- doc., and with D. Gavel, director of the Laboratory for Adaptive Optics, on this activity. Sandrine will be giving a paper on this work at the OSA meeting in Vancouver, in June. The Phase II design has been refined to include adjustment of the number of pixels in the elongation direction as a function of sub-aperture offset from the center of the telescope aperture (also the center of laser projection) and to employ S. Adkin’s original concept for the readout architecture, which is to “snake” the shift register from sub-aperture to sub-aperture instead of using multiplexing. Since charge shifting is essentially noiseless, and the multiplexer is not, and since readout speed is
32 NOAO AND THE DECADAL SURVEY PROJECTS
very important due to the TMT’s wavefront computation needs, the design needs to balance readout speed and noise; and it turns out that the snaked shift register offers the best performance. We are planning to begin final layout of this device, and hope to get on a PanSTARRS wafer run planned for this summer.
Lawrence Livermore National Labs
“Pulsed Fiber Laser for Guide Stars:” LLNL has been waiting for delivery of a replacement amplifier after one failed last fall due to a faulty switch in the system. No recent work has been completed. The amplifier arrived in early June, but the signal combiners have been delayed until the first week of July. The effort will be re-started with the arrival of the signal combiners. LLNL has begun bringing personnel back to the project to complete the work. It is expected that within the next six months, the system will be field hardened and a control system added so that the system can be deployed to Lick Observatory sometime late this calendar year or early next. LLNL has received the entire award of $1.5 million.
Coherent Technology, Inc.
“Compact Modular Scalable Versatile LGS Architecture for 8–100-m Telescopes:” LMCTI has been waiting delivery of replacement waveguide power amplifiers, so no progress has been made on the higher power levels desired. They also suffered a loss of some key personnel and have been rebuilding the team. Meanwhile, they have begun testing of the delivery fiber. They have tested it with low power cw (2.5 W) at 589 nm and have achieved about 40% efficiency. They are continuing optimization of the coupling and the beam. Power through the 100-m fiber has been increased to about 6 W up to the SBS limits. By reducing the length of the fiber to a more practical length of 30 m, a 10 W signal should be achieved. This effort is continuing and a report will be released by mid-summer. The team will be working on setting up both legs of the laser and a higher power demonstration should be completed in early fall. A no-cost extension was requested for Phase II through 31 December 2007, and an extension for Phase III through 30 June 2009. CTI has received $1,858,584 of the total award of $3,295,226.
33
5 PUBLIC AFFAIRS AND EDUCATIONAL OUTREACH
5.1 EDUCATIONAL OUTREACH (EO)
NOAO’s Educational Outreach group is responsible for managing and developing the national observatory’s efforts in formal and informal science education. NOAO EO programs train teachers and astronomers to communicate scientific research principles and the latest discoveries in astronomy to pre-college students. The EO group also supports the Research Experiences for Undergraduate programs at Kitt Peak and Sacramento Peak, and helps facilitate graduate and post-graduate opportunities at KPNO and CTIO. FY07 highlights in educational outreach included the continued worldwide success of GLOBE at Night in its second year (including innovative use of handheld sky-quality meters), two major grant awards from Science Foundation Arizona, and a NASA group achievement award for the Spitzer Research Program for Teachers and Students.
Research Based Science Education (RBSE)
In FY07, the NOAO RBSE program for high school teachers—now completely core-funded— continued to attract a large oversubscription. The program is tightly focused on its primary objectives: acquisition of astronomy content knowledge by teachers and bringing astronomical research to the classroom. We have also expanded our repertoire of teacher/student research projects. The 2007 cadre of 18 teachers, selected from over 60 applicants, came from 15 different states. The cadre completed a 14-week distance learning course and then met in Tucson for a very successful, culminating, 10-day summer workshop covering astronomy content, research protocol, and introducing research in the classroom. During the on-line class, each teacher selected one of the five different research projects as their concentration, choosing from searching for nova, membership of open clusters, spectroscopy of variable stars, identification of AGNs, and solar magnetic fields. The teachers spent four nights on Kitt Peak observing with four different telescopes, and each research group presented their results on the final day of the workshop. The NOAO Web site for the RBSE project continued development, with documentation and data sets added in all project areas. This site is available to any teacher who wants to offer astronomy research to their students, and has been promoted at the National Science Teachers Association meeting and the INTEL International Science & Engineering Fair (see www.noao.edu/education/arbse). Students working on RBSE projects also entered (and won honors at) science fairs, both regional and national (see next section). The RBSE Journal, our research journal for students whose teachers have completed this program, continues to do well. These papers are based on the research projects the teachers have instigated in their classrooms, as well as some related projects, including the Spitzer student and teacher research project, which is available to RBSE program graduates. All teachers and students receive detailed feedback on their submissions. This was the fourth year of the follow-on RBSE program known as the Teacher Observing Program (TOP), where teachers and small groups of students can propose to make observing runs for unique research projects at KPNO. The proposals accepted were of continuing high quality. Two TLRBSE-related workshops were held at the National Science Teachers Association meeting in St. Louis in April 2007. In addition, several alumni of the program made presentations of their own, which were well attended by other conference participants.
34 PUBLIC AFFAIRS AND EDUCATIONAL OUTREACH
The American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics honored RBSE teachers K. Borders and T. Spuck with their Educator Achievement Award. The award was presented to seven K-12 teachers nationally in December 2006.
Spitzer Research Program for Teachers and Students
The Spitzer Science Center (SSC) and NOAO have continued their program for RBSE-based teacher and student research using director’s discretionary observing time on the Spitzer Space Telescope. The program has multiple goals with one being testing the ability of teachers and students to obtain and work with high-level astronomical data. Teams led by NOAO scientists S. Howell and G. Rudnick were particularly active this year. Howell’s research team made nearly simultaneous observations from Kitt Peak while Spitzer was observing their target object. Rudnick’s team is preparing posters for the January 2008 AAS meeting. A number of students in the program received awards: A. Herrold’s student, Z. Schroeder received a fourth place in the Physics and Astronomy division at the Intel International Science and Engineering Fair at Albuquerque, NM in May. R. Hemphill’s student, E. Petroff, received the Priscilla and Bart Bok Second Place Award from the American Astronomical Society and the Astronomical Society of the Pacific at the ISEF. She also received the American Association of Physics Teachers Outstanding Physics Student of the Year Award. Program mentors G. Rudnick, R. Finn, and V. Desai supported Petroff’s cluster work. J. Adkins’ students M. Mulaveesala, T. Travagli, and A. Morton presented a science fair project on the results of observing S5 0716+714 using the Spitzer Space Telescope and a ground-based telescope. They won a fourth place at the California State Science Fair and received a medallion from the Yale Science and Engineering Association for Most Outstanding 11th Grade Exhibit in Computer Science, Engineering, Physics or Chemistry. The Spitzer Space Telescope Program for Teachers and Students was awarded a NASA Group Achievement Award.
Science Foundation Arizona: Astro BITS NOAO’s educational outreach programs recently received two of nine “K-12 Student & Teacher Discovery Program” grants from Science Foundation Arizona. The Research Based Science Education program was awarded $125,000 to enable math/science teachers to have research experiences in astronomy and image processing, and then implement these high-tech topics in their classrooms through a new initiative called Building Information Technology Skills (BITS) Through Astronomy. Astro BITS targets Arizona middle school teachers, particularly at rural and minority schools, and offers help in preparing their students for science career pathways through the excitement of astronomy. The first year (of a planned three-year program) saw a cadre of eight teachers who learned about imaging and related projects. They spent two nights at Kitt Peak and will offer their students opportunities to use modern image-processing technology in the coming year.
Hands-On Optics The NSF-funded informal science education program “Hands-On Optics” (HOO) continued its expansion to new sites and provided support to previously established programs. The program completed a fourth-year, no-cost extension with a program end date for the NSF grant of 31 August 2007. The HOO core team is R. Sparks, C. Walker, and S. Pompea (Project Director and Co-PI). Most of the professional development has been conducted by Sparks and Walker. They have conducted professional development workshops this year in Colorado (Longmont), Maryland (Baltimore), The Timothy Smith Network (Boston), The California Science Center (Los Angeles), the Chabot Science Center (Oakland), The New York Hall of Science, and Albuquerque, New Mexico. Shorter workshops
35 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
on the Hands-On Optics mini-kit, Terrific Telescopes, were presented at the SPIE meeting in San Diego and the Astronomical Society of the Pacific meeting in Chicago. Hands-On Optics continued to expand its productive collaborations with the Boys & Girls Clubs. Weekly HOO programs were presented at the Boys & Girls Club in South Tucson in the fall of 2006 and continued in the spring of 2007. The program also had three weeks of summer sessions at the South Tucson Boys & Girls Club and started a new set of sessions in fall 2007. The program at the Sells Boys and Girls Club was held every other week in the fall of 2006 and the spring of 2007. The project also had a six- week session at the Sells Boys & Girls Club over the summer. Our bi-weekly sessions are continuing in fall 2007 NOAO ceased assembly of the HOO kits by contracting with Learning Technologies Inc. (LTI) to provide kits for interested users. LTI has supplied approximately 90 each of modules 4–6 and 30 each of modules 1–3. Efforts are underway to market all of the kits through LTI. R. Sparks worked with LTI to ensure kit quality and continuity of all of the kit parts. HOO mini-workshops were also conducted as part of NOAO’s involvement in the NSF-funded “Astronomy from the Ground Up” (AFGU) project at workshops held at the Boston Museum of Science and the St. Louis Science Center. The project also developed a session for the AFGU Distance Learning Course. HOO was presented through distance learning programs to educators during 1–6 March and 18–22 June. HOO was also featured as part of AFGU’s “Continuing Explorations” series in July. The HOO program, in partnership with GEAR-UP and U. Arizona’s Flandrau Science Center, ran three one-week optics camps during the month of June. Students experienced most of the HOO activities, as well as field trips to Kitt Peak, the Steward Mirror Lab, the Steward Observatory telescope, UA Optical Sciences Lab, Mars HiRISE program, and the UA Radiology Lab. A similar camp was presented in partnership with the Saguaro Girl Scouts in early August. The NOAO HOO program was featured in a plenary talk at the biannual International Conference on Education and Training in Optics and Photonics in Ottawa, Ontario. Four contributed talks on Hands-On Optics and our programs were also presented. The NOAO educational outreach and public outreach groups co-hosted four booths with numerous activities from Hands-On Optics and Project ASTRO at the fifth annual Math, Science, and Technology Funfest at the Tucson Convention Center. Held in conjunction with the yearly Southern Arizona Regional Science and Engineering Fair (SARSEF), FunFest brings together scientists and elementary through high school students to share in the wonders and excitement of science. During the March 2007 FunFest, NOAO hosted two sessions each day on different HOO themes. Together, the sessions (The Essence of Luminescence, Hit the Target,) attracted more than 1,000 students and 200 adults over the three days. The booths were staffed by NOAO staff, students working with the HOO program, and a student from Grinnell College. Another major event was the St. Michael’s Optics Fest. Held in conjunction with their science fair, students from around Tucson are invited to participate in a series of optics activities led by NOAO staff and students. A “Hit the Target” competition is also held. Almost 40 teams and over 100 students participated in this event last year. Prizes were provided by the Arizona Optics Industry Association and various AOIA companies.
Science Foundation of Arizona: Expanding HOO in Arizona NOAO received a $250,000 grant from the Science Foundation of Arizona to expand the presence of HOO in Arizona to new venues. The grant gives us the ability to expand the HOO presence in Arizona to areas outside of Tucson, focusing on rural Arizona towns with Boys & Girls Clubs, based on our proven success in South Tucson and Sells. The Bisbee Boys & Girls Club sent a representative to be trained in the modules in early August, and a program will begin there this fall. We are currently negotiating with the Prescott Boys & Girls Club, Discovery Park in Safford, and Whipple Observatory to establish HOO programs at these venues. The HOO camp that was held in conjunction with the Girl Scouts has opened up the
36 PUBLIC AFFAIRS AND EDUCATIONAL OUTREACH
possibility of running HOO programs with Girl Scouts in Southern Arizona. Talks are underway to explore these possibilities. Other locations currently under consideration for expansion include Lowell Observatory, the Boys & Girls Club in Yuma, and the Boys & Girls Club of Santa Cruz County (Nogales).
Project ASTRO
In late September 2006, PAEO hosted the annual two-day Project ASTRO-Tucson training workshop, partnering astronomers with teachers new to the program. Held at U. Arizona, the workshop trained the partners in a dozen hands-on activities, mostly on the solar system. Three motivational high points were a talk on Pluto by planetary scientist M. Sykes, a talk on teaching and learning astronomy from E. Prather, and a nighttime trip to Kitt Peak National Observatory. On 10 March 2007, participants in Project ASTRO and Family ASTRO were treated to a special workshop on how to participate with the unaided eye and/or a sky brightness meter in a program to preserve dark skies called GLOBE at Night. The evening’s activities included an introduction to (1) take-home kits with hands-on materials to heighten students awareness about light pollution (e.g., a shielding activity); (2) a home-grown NOAO activity called “Constellations at Your Fingertips” to introduce students to easy-to-make, glow-in-the-dark templates to help find constellations in the night sky; and (3) Sky Quality Meters that participants received to use with their students to measure quantitatively the brightness of the night sky. A total of 25 new teacher-astronomer Project ASTRO partnerships were formed in FY07. Together with the 180 teachers and 91 astronomers estimated to be currently active, they directly impacted an estimated 5,000–7,000 students in Tucson and surrounding communities in FY07. An exciting development this year is that Project ASTRO has gone international. Three teachers from Sonora, Mexico were trained at the Fall Project ASTRO workshop and subsequently brought the program to their students in Club de Astronomía Galileo, where it is flourishing. The annual Site Leaders Meeting for Project and Family ASTRO was held in Houston, Texas, at the Space Center, in May 2007. In addition to presenting an update report on behalf of the Tucson site, NOAO site leader C. Walker gave a presentation on GLOBE at Night and on the Hands-on Optics program; site Leaders also were enthusiastic about the HOO “Hit the Target challenge.” These two programs may be disseminated through Project ASTRO in the near future.
Family ASTRO
During October and November 2006, Family ASTRO training workshops were conducted on “Night Sky Adventures,” “Moon Mission,” “Race to the Planets,” and “Cosmic Decoders.” NOAO has trained about 70 Family ASTRO event leaders to date, with the expectation that each will conduct at least one event for their communities. Family ASTRO training in 2006 included members of the local amateur astronomy club, another staff person from Pima County Parks and Recreation, graduate students in astrophysics from U. Arizona, and local teachers. Input from applicants and trained event leaders indicates that Family ASTRO materials are being used in creative ways to augment public star parties, school science nights, and public programs at local attractions such as Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum and Pima County Parks and Recreation, in addition to more standard Family ASTRO after- school events. NOAO staff themselves sponsored Family ASTRO activities at a University of Arizona College Academy for Parents event in February, the Astronomy Day on Kitt Peak event in April, and three “Family Astronomy Nights” at the Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum during the summer. Over 400 people attended these events. Family ASTRO this year received a second invitation to host a bilingual Family ASTRO workshop in Chile, and a new invitation to host a bilingual workshop in Argentina. About 20 teachers and science educators were trained in “Race to the Planets” and “Cosmic Decoders” in La Serena, Chile, and the same number were trained in “Moon Mission” and “Night Sky Adventure” in Buenos Aires, Argentina. Most, if not all, of the materials were in Spanish. A. Garcia from Gemini
37 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Observatory helped C. Walker from NOAO with both workshops. Both Garcia and V. Bianchi (from Gemini in Argentina) are trying to top their 2006 record of 10 Family ASTRO events apiece, where over 300–400 people attended from both countries. They are well on their way to achieving that. An article for the winter 2007 edition of Mercury magazine on Family ASTRO in South America was written by C. Walker.
ASTRO-Chile
The ASTRO-Chile educational videoconference program has developed original curriculum with the formulation, fine-tuning and field-testing of new comparative remote-sensing activities on Earth and Mars for bilingual science students at middle schools and high schools in Tucson and their counterparts in Chile. In October 2006, students used a remote sensing activity to identify features in satellite images taken first of their own location and then of the other location. The students then acted as rovers, taking pictures from the ground for students in the other location based on e-mail communications. This activity was written by NOAO astronomer R. Probst. The capstone event was a student-to-student ASTRO-Chile videoconference between NOAO North and South at the end of November. Several hundred students in Chile participated in the activity over the previous months. More than 50 of those students were in attendance in the AURA-Gemini conference room in La Serena. There were about that many students in attendance at the videoconference in the Tucson main conference room, with most presentations given in Spanish. In March 2007, the remote sensing activity on Mars was launched. Students could transfer what they learned about the geology and geography of Earth to acquaint themselves with the geography and geology of Mars, while continuing their experience to interact directly with fellow students in another hemisphere. Part 1 of this activity was created by the education group at Arizona State U. Part 2 of this activity used newly released HiRise images of Mars and was written by U. Arizona graduate student, in education and in planetary science, S. Buxner, with guidance and testing from C. Walker and H. Ochoa in PAEO. Once again the capstone event was a student-to-student videoconference between NOAO North and South in May 2007. From late May to mid-August 2007, an REU student with the PAEO department, G. Angeli (UC Berkeley Computer Science major), was tasked with building a working model of the Mars rover which could be operated remotely over the Internet. The completed, working model will be shipped soon to the Centro de Apoyo a la Didáctica de la Astronomía (CADIAS) astronomy education center near La Serena, Chile. Students at CADIAS and from Tucson will be able to control it as it traverses a newly built Mars garden. Its on-board camera will be used to study “rocks from Mars.” This project will provide an attractive exhibit to encourage schools and tourists to visit the CADIAS science education center. Funded primarily by NOAO and Gemini, CADIAS hosted more than 3,000 people and programs for star parties and astronomy programs in FY07, and a thousand more attended its mobile planetarium program. In August, the public library at CADIAS received long-awaited Internet connectivity, which should greatly increase its general activity in FY08. Led by H. Ochoa, NOAO South outreach staff also made good progress on preparing to automate a 16-inch telescope (El Enano) that was removed from CTIO and donated to PAEO.
GLOBE at Night The GLOBE at Night 2007 citizen-science campaign generated nearly double the number of measurements of the world’s dark (and not so dark) skies compared to its first year. Almost 8,500 unaided eye observations from 60 countries were submitted on-line by citizen scientists measuring the darkness of their local night skies by looking at the constellation Orion during the two-week GLOBE at Night event in March 2007. The program also successfully demonstrated a prototype digital data- collection effort that aims to grow to a global scale by 2009 during the International Year of Astronomy. Close to 1,000 measurements were made, primarily in the U.S. using meters from Unihedron to quantitatively measure sky brightness.
38 PUBLIC AFFAIRS AND EDUCATIONAL OUTREACH
PAEO staff presented a press conference and a poster on these impressive results of the GLOBE at Night program at the May 2007 AAS/AAPT meeting in Honolulu. Widespread news coverage included stories on space.com. NOAO staff are working with a GIS expert to further interpret the GLOBE at Night data sets.
Investigating Astronomy
The “Investigating Astronomy” NSF instructional materials development (IMD) project with TERC and the ASP remained very active this year with S. Croft playing a key role in completing NOAO’s commitments to this new national high school, standards-based astronomy curriculum. S. Pompea continued his role as Co-PI, attending team meetings and coordinating translation into Spanish of designated instructional materials. All content materials were completed, including 24 “Going Further” research and observational projects designed for the high-end student. These materials stressed current scientific research areas. The scientific review of all six modules was completed by Croft and other scientists in and external to NOAO. The project manuscript is being submitted to the publisher and is scheduled to become available in 2008.
LSST D&D EPO Program The LSST EOP outreach program continued at a high level of activity with S. Croft taking the lead in educational project development. In the asteroid characterization project, a set of classroom activities and supporting curricular materials was completed and posted on a dedicated Web site. Testing in middle school earth science classrooms was begun. To provide flexibility to the teacher, several projects were developed: a “short version” on asteroids that includes one day’s introduction to asteroids and a simple observing experience; a “long version” that includes one to two week’s introduction to asteroids, meteorites, and their connection to earth rocks and geologic processes; and an open ended observation project. Assessment and testing of the curriculum by outside reviewers and classroom teachers is continuing. In the visualization project, designed to develop educationally effective interactions of students and the general public with large-format astronomical images, an exploratory activity was developed by S. Croft in conjunction with the HiRISE Mars camera project at U. Arizona, and development of a user-friendly computer interface was begun by a team at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, led by physics faculty member J. Keller.
GSMT D&D EPO One of the two designated tasks of the NOAO’s PAEO group in support of the GSMT project is the design, development, testing, and evaluation of online educational modules aimed at middle and high school students. S. Pompea and S. Croft have principle responsibility in developing the modules. Two topics have been selected for the modules: Astronomical Site Selection and Systems Engineering. Existing site selection data from the TMT and GMT projects have been reviewed, specific grade-level content for inclusion has been considered, and possible designs for the modules have been identified. A presentation of the GSMT module plans will be made as part of an Astronomy Village workshop that will be held at the national education conference of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific, 5–7 September 2007. Development work has begun on activities illustrating the principles of adaptive optics. Various techniques are being explored to illustrate the concept of atmospheric refraction. A model of a Shack- Hartmann sensor has also been built to illustrate how AO systems can measure atmospheric distortion. Although the design needs work to improve usability, it has proven able to illustrate the functioning of a Shack-Hartmann sensor. We are also starting to experiment with different types of flexible mirrors to illustrate how AO systems correct atmospheric distortion.
39 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
A presentation was given on our initial work on adaptive optics in April at the Arizona Association of Physics Teachers spring meeting. A visit was made to Carthage College in September to meet with D. Arion, whose group has done some excellent work in adaptive optics education and in preparing adaptive optics demonstrations.
Tohono O’odham Outreach
Outreach on the Tohono O’odham nation has been increasing. The Hands-On Optics program at the Sells Boys & Girls Club is now a robust program, with Kitt Peak staff presenting programs ever few weeks during the school year. This has led to other interactions, the most important being the request for the summer horse camp to be held at the summit of Kitt Peak. Over 60 children and adults spent a weekend in June at the Kitt Peak picnic grounds, learning how to manage the horses, and by extension, themselves. Collaboration with Tohono O’odham Community College continues, with a request to help them prepare for a fundraising capital campaign. The college president visited the observatory for a photo shoot in February. NOAO has been approached by the Indian Oasis-Baboquivari School District (Sells) for support of their new attendance incentive program, “Reach for the Stars.” We are working to develop a regular program of visits to the fifth and seventh grade classrooms this year. The new Science Foundation of Arizona grant for the Astro BITS program received, and accepted, two applications from teachers at Tohono O’odham schools.
Research Experiences for Undergraduates (REU)
NOAO continued its long-standing participation in the NSF Research Experiences for Undergraduates (REU) program, preparing future generations of professionals who will sustain U.S. preeminence in astronomy and contribute to a scientifically literate nation. NOAO North scientist K. Mighell is the site director for the KPNO REU summer program in Tucson; NOAO South research associate S. Kafka headed the CTIO program in La Serena throughout this year. Over the FY07 summer, the six undergraduate students in the KPNO program (including two females) worked closely with NOAO Tucson staff for a 10–12 week period, developing skills as scientific researchers and furthering their professional development. In the southern summer of 2006, CTIO hosted six U.S. REU students (including four females) and two Chilean undergraduates under the similar Prácticas de Investigación en Astronomía (PIA) program. (Three more REU students worked with staff of the National Solar Observatory in summer 2007, with direct logistical support from PAEO staff.) The opportunity to present original research findings at the most important national meeting of U.S. astronomy is one of the most prized benefits enjoyed by REU students in NOAO site programs. Students from the KPNO and CTIO 2006 programs did so at the January 2007 meeting of the American Astronomical Society (AAS) in Seattle. As one measure of success, recent data shows that 80 percent of the KPNO REU students from the past five years have gone on to careers in science, technology, engineering and math.
Astronomy Education Review (AER) The Astronomy Education Review (AER), a refereed online journal at aer.noao.edu, is now in its sixth year of operation. The goal of the journal, which is edited by S. Wolff and A. Fraknoi (Foothills Community College), is to disseminate research about astronomy and space science education, along with innovative ideas for classroom use, resource lists, reviews, and commentary. During the past year, the AER published papers on a variety of topics such as what every beginning astronomy professor needs to know, the requirements for working with human subjects in
40 PUBLIC AFFAIRS AND EDUCATIONAL OUTREACH
education research, and the design of materials for visually impaired visitors to an observatory. A paper published in Mercury (Volume 36, No. 3, p. 24) provides an overview of the journal and its contributing authors, readers, and papers. This year the American Astronomical Society established a special committee to recommend whether or not the AAS should take over responsibility for publishing AER. The Committee recommended to the Council in June that the AAS should assume responsibility for publishing AER. Their rationale was:
“Education, particularly at the college level, is an important career responsibility of a large fraction of all AAS members. For the size of the profession, astronomy plays a larger role in general science education at all levels than any other science. Astronomers also invest more effort in public outreach than those in most other disciplines. Increasing emphasis from funding agencies and overseers of higher education on outreach and accountability implies that these will play a yet larger role in the future efforts of the AAS membership. Until the advent of the AER, there was no easily accessible, dedicated forum for publication of research on education in astronomy or discussion of the practical aspects of teaching and outreach. Although begun as an experiment, AER has proven the importance and potential of an astronomy education journal by attracting a large number of authors and a wide reading audience.”
During calendar year 2008, the AER editors will be working with AAS to develop the editorial policy and business plan for the journal and to facilitate the transfer to the AAS.
5.2 PUBLIC OUTREACH
NOAO’s Public Outreach group manages all activities at the Kitt Peak Visitor Center, including the center’s educational exhibits and retail operations, three daily tours of Kitt Peak observatories, the Kitt Peak docent program, and the popular fee-based nighttime observing experiences for both the general public and advanced amateurs.
Kitt Peak Visitor Center
Visitor Center operations had a challenging year due to being shut down for twelve days due to two fires and a rockslide. The high price of gas was also a factor for most of the year. Poor weather in January/February reduced attendance and revenue from the Nightly Observing Program (NOP). With all of this, we still managed to have a record month of March as far as NOP attendance, and hit an overall revenue record for the NOP program, with the third observatory now open regularly.
The formal Kitt Peak membership group for the public grew to over 170 members in FY07. This program ($35 individual, $55 family) entitles the member to special discounts, a newsletter, and a members-only star party, among other benefits.
More than 16 special classes and workshops were held throughout the year, including “Stars and Music,” “Kitt Peak Junior Astronomers,”and “Astronomy Day 2007.”
A Kitt Peak Visitor Center Interpretative Plan was created and is the first in a series of plans that are being developed by staff. The plan will chart the future of exhibits throughout the mountain and pave the way for the development of a formal exhibit plan and strategic plan.
41 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Public outreach-related improvements to the Visitor Center and mountain facilities included a five-foot diameter, rotating model of the Earth at Kitt Peak Visitor Center FY07 Program Attendance night to be used in a dark skies exhibit. A new and General Visitors telescope mirror exhibit and new MP3 audio self- [vs. FY06] guided telescope tour are in final development. The Visitor Center 20-inch telescope dome was Guided Public Tours 7,363 automated with special NSF grant funds. New poster displays were created for the Mayall visitor [12,326] gallery. A new historical display for the solar telescope lobby and visitor center to highlight School Groups K-12 998 some historical documents recently found is being [529] prepared. An educational kit on meteorites was developed for use by the docents for public Special Tours 154 visitors and school kids. [104]
Upgrades to the computer system and the Point of Nightly Observing 6,673* Sale (POS) system in the gift shop were also made Program [6,136] during this year, and an inventory-based POS program was installed at year’s end. Advanced Observing 312 Three new Kitt Peak images have been chosen for Program posters and are scheduled for production in [274] October. Total General Visitors 60,000 (est.) Articles on the Kitt Peak Visitor Center and its [63,000] programs were published in the Travel section of the New York Times, AAA Highroads magazine, Sunset magazine, National Geographic Geotourism Map, the Arizona Daily Star, and the Tucson Citizen.
The Kitt Peak Visitor Center hosted more than a dozen different travel writers doing stories on Southern Arizona Tourism.
Film, TV and radio station interviews, and visits to Kitt Peak included KMSB Fox 11, KNST Radio, John C. Scott Radio interview, KGVY Radio Interview, KOLD TV 13, the BBC, and Interstellar Studios.
PO staff developed a new school-based program. This program is for teachers visiting Kitt Peak who want to do more that just tour the telescopes. The hands-on activities tie into the State of Arizona science standards and include pre- and post-visit activities. A marketing piece and teacher-planning packet have been developed.
Other Public Outreach
PAEO partnered with the Exploratorium science center in San Francisco to offer a webcast of the 8 November 2006 Mercury transit of the Sun live from Kitt Peak public outreach 16-inch telescope.
42 PUBLIC AFFAIRS AND EDUCATIONAL OUTREACH
PAEO staff designed and produced a new color brochure for the SCOPE group of southwestern observatories and made several presentations at the group’s December 2006 meeting at Whipple Observatory.
Major events supported by PO staff include: Astronomy Day, Prescott, AZ; ADASS conference at Kitt Peak; Elderhostel at U. Arizona; College Academy for U. Arizona parents; Pima County Educator Fair; Mars Phoenix Mission Day at Pima Air & Space Museum; the Texas Star Party; and the Advanced Imaging Workshop in San Jose.
The following 2006–2007 data goes to mid-August 2007.
School Group Tours
1,600 1,401 1,400 1,220 1,200 1,107 1,028 998 1,000
# School Kids 800 662 529 600 491
400
200
- 1999-2000 2000-2001 2001-2002 2002-2003 2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 Fiscal Year
AOP Program Participants 6-Year Total
350 312
274 268 300
250 212 183 200 161 # Participants 150
100
50
- 2001-2002 2002-2003 2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 Fiscal Year
43 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
NOP Program* Participants 6-Year Total
8,000 7,017 6,895 6,504 6,673 6,136 7,000
6,000 4,157 5,000
# of Participants 4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
- 2001-2002 2002-2003 2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 Fiscal Year
* Note: Lost 75 NOP nights due to bad weather in FY07, compared to 81 in FY06. Visitation levels were also hurt by high gasoline prices, and the fact that we were closed for 12 days (8 days for the fire, 2 days for a rockslide, and 2 nop nights due to fire in March). Estimated loss in revenue was around 12 to 14K. The month of September (445 on average) is estimated.
Guided Public Tours
16000 14,490 12,930 14000
12000 10,546
10000 8,141
# of Participants 8000
6000 4,274
4000
2000
0 2002-2003 2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 Fiscal Year
5.3 MEDIA AND PUBLIC INFORMATION
NOAO’s media and public information group coordinates news releases, media events and visits, fact sheets, posters, the NOAO Newsletter, and other visual products that explain NOAO’s latest research and organizational activities. It also coordinates NOAO’s public Web presence and external use of NOAO imagery, and serves as the primary response point for public inquiries and general emails. Associate Director for PAEO D. Isbell was named by the AAS as the co-chair of the U.S. program committee for the planned IAU/UNESCO “International Year of Astronomy” in 2009, and he tapped S. Pompea and C. Walker to lead major subgroups on a new inexpensive telescope kit and dark skies awareness.
44 PUBLIC AFFAIRS AND EDUCATIONAL OUTREACH
Media Activity
NOAO issued 10 formal press releases in FY07 (through August) and worked extremely closely with the Gemini Observatory, the Spitzer Science Center, and LSST Corp. on several others (see table below). News stories about NOAO, NSO, and Kitt Peak appeared regularly in the Arizona Daily Star and local Tucson media, including extensive coverage of the Alambre wildfire that was very positive from a Kitt Peak perspective; at the very same time, the observatory was named one of the “Seven Wonders of Southern Arizona” by the readers of the Arizona Daily Star. PAEO Associate Director D. Isbell and R. Wilson were interviewed by KOLD-TV Tucson during a series of live news broadcast interviews on 28 June, followed by live views of Jupiter and the Moon during the 10 P.M. broadcast from the Visitor Center Observatory.
NOAO Press Releases Issued in FY2007 And Associated Media Coverage I.D Date Title Highlights of Media Coverage 06-12 10/26/06 Watch Mercury Transit the Sun on Exploratorium museum live November 8 Live from Kitt Peak National Webcast Observatory 06-13 11/03/06 NOAO in the NSF Astronomy Senior Arizona Daily Star, major science Review magazines 06-14 11/14/06 Twenty New Stars in the Neighborhood Space.com, www.astrobio.net, www.spacedaily.com, FoxNews.com, www.sciencenews.org,Yahoo.com LSSTC-05 1/5/07 Google Joins LSST Project 07-01 1/07/07 Calling Dr. Frankenstein! : Interactive MSNBC.com, FoxNews.com, Binaries Show Signs of Induced SkyTonight. com Hyperactivity 07-02 1/07/07 New Images of the Bubble Nebula and Slacker Astronomy video podcast Barnard 163 from Kitt Peak 07-03 1/10/07 Spiral Galaxy Image Benefits From Space.com,BadAstronomy.com, Vigilance on Dark Skies StarStryder blog, 07-04 3/07/07 Two Ways to Participate in GLOBE at Richmond Times-Dispatch, Night 2007: Classic and Digital Huntsville Times, Pasadena Star- News, Honolulu Star-Bulletin, Astronomy magazine Chandra Science 3/12/07 NOAO Deep-Wide Data Helps Capture Center release Black Hole Evolution 07-05 3/21/07 Buell T. Jannuzi Named Director of Kitt Peak National Observatory 07-06 5/16/07 Image of Star-Forming Region Released in Honor of Stephen Strom 07-07 5/28/07 Classic and Digital Versions of GLOBE at Space.com, NewScientist.com Night Thrive in 2007 Science 6/1/07 Science Foundation Arizona Awards $3.2 Tucson Citizen, Arizona Daily Star,
Foundation Million Through its K-12 Student & Business Journal of Phoenix Arizona release Teacher Discovery Program Spitzer Science 8/06/07 Monster Galaxy Pileup ABCNews.com,NewScientist.com, Center release BBCNews.com
45 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Special Information Products
Public Affairs produced a variety of special posters and brochures in FY07, including a cohesive set of posters on the “system,” three large new exhibit-sized images from the Mayall 4-m telescope, new handouts on SMARTS and SOAR, posters for the VOEvent workshop, and continued graphical support for LSST, including a major science poster session at the January 2007 AAS meeting.
Image and Information Requests More than 1,990 individual email questions about astronomy or requests to use NOAO images for commercial and non-commercial applications were processed in FY07, including approved requests for use in calendars, amateur astronomy software packages, children’s educational magazines, textbooks, and popular books. Over 1,750 mailings were sent out last year, as well as countless individual responses to requests for information on astronomy and our public programs received via telephone and walk-ins.
Web-Based Outreach NOAO continues to present a timely and lively public “face” on the Internet, changing the featured image on the main home page 38 times in FY07, and adding 19 images to the popular NOAO Image Gallery. New Web sites were created for Renewing Small Telescopes for Astronomical Research (ReSTAR) part of the O/IR System, and an Asteroids resource page for teachers and students. The Web pages for the AURA New Initiatives Office received a redesign as that office changed to the GSMT Program Office. Additionally the O/IR System Web site was redesigned, as well as the Astronomy RBSE Web site, which transitioned from the TLRBSE Web site. Images from NOAO telescopes were highlighted 10 times on the popular “Astronomy Picture of the Day” Web page and were featured four times on the Space.com “Image of the Day.” NOAO Web pages had 4.3 million unique visitors from October 2006 through September 2007, resulting in 15.2 million page views and more than 65 million hits.
46
6 COMPUTER INFRASTRUCTURE AND NETWORK SERVICES
6.1 TUCSON
The downtown Tucson computing facilities continue to evolve as older systems are replaced by newer systems that are more cost-effective and easier to maintain, while providing enhanced services (higher processor speed and increased disk storage) to our computer users. In general, we try to replace our “core” facilities every 3 to 4 years. In particular, new rack-mounted systems running FreeBSD (with external RAID arrays where necessary) were installed in FY07 as our Web server (www.noao.edu) and ssh bastion host (ssh.noao.edu). Staff computing resources continue to be a mix of PCs running Windows, Macintosh systems, and Linux systems. The infrastructure in the Tucson computer lab was continually upgraded to meet the demands of computer installations for the various groups and projects within NOAO Tucson. In FY07, a keycard entry system was installed on both doors leading to the lab allowing control and tracking of access. A multi-year effort was begun to study and improve the cooling and power systems in the computer lab. The network infrastructure in the downtown Tucson office building was upgraded in FY07 to increase performance and reliability. At several wiring centers around the headquarters building, sets of older Ethernet switches were replaced by newer, high-capacity, switches that provided Gigabit connections to individual offices and multiple-Gigabit backhaul to the network backbone. An audit was begun of network cables in the building since many of the original cable labels had faded into illegibility. Efforts to improve the security and robustness of our network continued in FY07. Elderly SunOS systems were removed from direct contact with the Internet and from duty as secondary DNS servers. Attempts were begun to reduce the number of machines exposed to the Internet for ssh and ftp connections.
6.2 KITT PEAK
Many new computers, all running Linux, were installed at Kitt Peak telescopes in the past year. At the 4-m, eight computers were installed in the computer room to run the software for NEWFIRM. The NEWFIRM computer functions and the number of systems for each function are: observing (1), MONSOON PAN (2), data handling (2), pipeline (2), and guider (1). Other embedded systems and controllers are on the NEWFIRM instrument. At WIYN, two computers were installed for each of the new instruments: QUOTA and WHIRC. One of these computers is for observing, and the other is the MONSOON PAN system. At the 2.1-m, a new observing computer was installed and the old SunOS system (lapis) was relegated to the computer room for data acquisition. The IR SunOS data acquisition computer (royal) was upgraded, and a similar upgrade is planned for the Coude Feed observing computer (indigo). Additional memory for the old SUN systems was purchased, and refurbished spare SparcStations were prepared. All the KPNO/WIYN DVD writers were upgraded to provide faster writing speeds and support for dual-layer format. Several fast Ethernet switches at the telescopes were upgraded to gigabit switches. Some of the Linux operating systems were upgraded. On our new systems, we are using the CentOS version of Linux, moving from the Fedora Core releases in order to have a more stable platform. A Linux-based replacement for the CAMAC electronics at the 2.1-m was developed and installed a couple of months earlier than planned when the CAMAC system failed and was not repairable.
47 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
In the next fiscal year, the main control computer (cinnamon) at the 4-m will be upgraded, and a control computer will be installed at the 2.1-m. At WIYN, a MONSOON controller and two supporting computers will be installed for the Bench Spectrograph. Also at WIYN, a test system for the primary mirror active controllers will be installed using software based on LabView.
6.3 NOAO SOUTH: LA SERENA & CERRO TOLOLO
In the south this past year we made massive inroads into owning our own IP space. For many years this space, 139.229.0.0/16, had been the property of NASA, and it has caused us great concern should NASA decide to reclaim the space for its own usage. However, working with the people at Marshall, we were able to convince them of our dependence on these addresses; their willingness and cooperation helped us to transfer officially the space to be administered by AURA South. Additional highlights of the year follow:
Our contract with Las Campanas has been continued with a renewal of the MOU with more explicit terminology mutually agreed upon by both parties.
Network security continues to take up much of a full person’s time, and we have recently installed a Barracuda virus and spam filter for NOAO South.
At the end of FY07, we are canceling our Commercial Internet service with Telmex. This was a circuit over the Reuna link to Santiago and then a portal to Telmex. In FY08, we will utilize our direct link to Miami for all International Commercial traffic and increase the bandwidth to 5Mb vice 4Mb. The I2 link with Lauren has performed reliably and only experienced one outage of a couple of days for the whole year. This link will be upgraded to 155Mb on the East coast for support of DECam, and we will see a westcoast circuit from Santiago to Los Angeles later this year of 1.2Gb.
VOIP has essentially been on hold due to funding levels, but we are optimistic next year will enable us to move forward on this project. Wiring offices has commenced.
At the commencement of FY07, CISS was formally transferred to report directly to the CTIO Director, as opposed to ETS as in the past.
The CISS manager has spent 10% of his time attending to LSST computer and networking support.
CISS continues to maintain the entire shared network infrastructure enjoyed by Gemini and SOAR, both internal and external networks.
La Serena
We have continued with Fedora OS and are using version 6 in some machines. There does not seem to be any pressure to change OS at this stage. Typically, we install the latest good known version of Fedora as new machines arrive. Some 64-bit versions are also in use. We installed four new rack-mounted servers with RAIDs for our mail, WWW, and central visitor servers. These machines all have second private Ethernet ports for backups. We are in the process of installing card-locked metal doors for entrance to the Computer room in La Serena. This is part of the security measures that are being adopted in response to the NSF initiatives.
48 COMPUTER INFRASTRUCTURE AND NETWORK SERVICES
The DPP has added more equipment to the computer room, and TMT has installed two servers. This increase in machines has added to the heat problems that are overwhelming the aging A/C unit. The computer room air conditioner is now 20 years old and is starting to show its age. We have been attempting to have the Chile reps come and give the unit a complete upgrade and overhaul but this has taken most of the year to accomplish. Our old backup server utilizing LaCie disk drives has been replaced with an ASL 2U RAID with 2.5TB of storage. This essentially backs up daily all the User Home directories. We also have a backup unit for Windows users. Due to the large outlay for a central UPS unit for the computer room, we have adopted rack units, mainly of 3KvA each. Apple Mac machines have become more ubiquitous, both as central servers and desktops, so there is the need to supply service for these units. CISS is slowly coming up to speed for this objective. We have retired our old Cat5000 and Cat4000 central switches and moved to a Cat6500 9-slot unit, which serves all network ports in La Serena with GigE. The Cat4000 was transferred to DPP for their use in Tucson. Support has continued for the SMSN/Essence project, but this may be the final year of our involvement. Service to the REU students and their machines continues, and this year promises to see an increase in students. Considerable resources are spent attending to the students during their time at CTIO.
Cerro Tololo
We are still maintaining the systems for Arcon. The computer hardware is no longer supported by the manufacturers, so we buy parts from Ebay to clone machines. All of the telescope Arcon systems are cloned in case of failure. Some work has been accomplished to decrease the number of screens in the computer room, i.e., utilize a central observing machine connected via VNC to the instrument computers in the 4-m console room. CISS continues to service SMARTS for their computer and networking needs. The new Cat6500 switch is fully functional to support the mountaintop with GigE wherever needed. We will be upgrading to Supervisor 2 modules in a short period.
Las Campanas J. Hughes has managed this account and reports that the CISS effort the past year involved the following activities:
Planned, documented, configured and deployed firewalls, new routers and switches to successfully segment the LCO network.
Developed component purchase lists for new managed network appliances, system servers, telescope operator and user workstations, and spares.
Wrote and disseminated LCO network diagrams and documents, progress reports, training documents, and WWW pages.
Planned, documented and executed switch of LCO computers to new IP numbers at the Polish, bodega, Nagoya, Lodge, ASB, 100, 40, and AUX subnets.
49 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
Dealt with LCO security at administrative, firewall, network appliance, host, and application levels including prevention, monitoring of break-ins, and recovery.
Maintained LCO’s older and Plone-based WWW server, email, DNS, DHCP and other servers, and LCO’s JIRA bug-tracking system.
Supported scientific software developement and debugging for turbina, PGPLOT, MONGO, IRAF, IDL, and other packages.
Developed and deployed upgraded Microsoft, Linux, and Apple system software for existing and new machines as requested or needed.
Monitored LCO system operation and fixed detected or reported problems due to failures of computers or network devices.
Provided on-site and helpdesk support for LCO system, security, and network problems and issues (including new instrument deployment).
Provided consultation services for other network, security, and computer issues.
50
APPENDIX A NOAO SCIENTIFIC STAFF ACTIVITY
¬New appointment in FY07 Non-NSF (external) funding ±Term ended in FY07
FY07 Accomplishments and FY08 PLANS
HELMUT A. ABT, Astronomer Emeritus
Research Interests Formation and evolution of double stars; publication statistics
FY07 Accomplishments: Abt considered the binary characteristics of metal-poor and metal-normal stars. He found that they have very different period distributions, which explains why previous observers obtained differing binary frequencies for those stars. Also, they imply different formation histories. Abt found that in five sciences (astronomy, chemistry, geophysics, math, and physics) the numbers of papers published annually during the past 30 years were proportional to the memberships of their societies (e.g., AAS) and showed no jumps as new equipment (new spacecraft, telescopes, detectors, computers, etc.) came into operation. The conclusion is that the bottleneck is the numbers of scientists. For a conference in Brussels in June, Abt surveyed sources of references in A&A and ApJ during the past 50 years and found that those that were increasing in frequency (journals, preprints, reviews) are the ones now available on-line, while the remainder (observatory publications, theses, conference papers, monographs, etc.) are decreasing in frequency.
FY08 Plans Abt has been obtaining MK classifications for the northern stars in visual multiples and brighter than B = 8. The first 2000 classifications have been published and the remaining 600 are being obtained. He has also been concerned with the orbital characteristics of the discovered exoplanets and their similarity with multiple stars, rather than with solar system planets.
DMITRY BIZYAEV, Research Associate ±
ROBERT BLUM, Associate Astronomer (TSIP Program Manager)
Research Interests The Galactic Center; massive star formation; resolved stellar populations; astronomical instrumentation
FY07 Accomplishments Blum, along with PI K. Cunha and CO-Is V. Smith, K. Sellgren, S. Ramirez, and D. Terndrup, finished the first part of a long-term project to measure alpha element abundances in the Galactic Center’s central few parsecs. This groundbreaking work finds alpha enhancements in a young population, an unexpected result from standard chemical enrichment and SFH scenarios. The Galactic center may be enriched by material lost from AGB stars in the Galactic bulge, and a top heavy IMF in the central regions could also produce the observed abundances. New data used in the analysis were obtained as part of Blum’s work using Phoenix (the NOAO IR echelle) on Gemini South.
A-1 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
FY08 Plans Blum will continue to participate in the Spitzer SAGE survey of the LMC. Blum leads the evolved star group. A new postdoc will be hired to help in this effort. Former SAGE postdoc Sean Points left to take a permanent position at CTIO/SOAR. Blum will observe SAGE sources in November at SOAR for near infrared follow-up and spectral type assignment of a large set of SAGE AGB and YSO being observed in Cycle 4 with Spitzer. The ground-based data will be key in modeling the LMC AGB stars and identifying sub-groups in the YSO population. Graduate student S. Srinivasan of JHU will use the new spectra as part of his thesis work aimed at calculating detailed mass loss rates from the SAGE data set. Blum plans on participating in the Flamingos 2 Galactic Center Survey this year (PI S. Eikenberry, UF). This near infrared MOS will be used to obtain many hundreds of spectra in the Galactic Center to be used as tracers of the SFH there.
TODD BOROSON Astronomer (Interim Director, NOAO)
Research Interests Structural and physical properties of active galactic nuclei; stellar populations and their evolution; O/IR instrumentation; analysis and mining of large astronomical data sets
FY07 Accomplishments Boroson completed the development of tools for processing the many thousands of SDSS QSO spectra that have now been released and measuring line and continuum parameters. These tools will provide a uniform and objective set of data for analysis to better understand the more subtle relationships among observable characteristics and physical parameters in these objects. In addition, in collaboration with D. Schneider and M. Eracleous (Penn State U.), he has obtained initial (first epoch) spectra of a sample of ten possible binary black hole AGN, in which the H-beta line peak is offset from the systemic velocity by thousands of km/s.
FY08 Plans Boroson plans a 9-month sabbatical to start before the end of FY08, during which he will use the automatic tools developed in the past two years to complete the analysis of the low-redshift SDSS QSO spectra and interpret the observed characteristics in terms of physical parameters. Spectra of the sample of possible binary black hole AGN will be analyzed in search of evidence that the offset H- beta peaks are varying with time, indicating orbital motion.
MARK BRODWIN, Postdoc Research Associate¬
Research Interests Galaxy formation and evolution; high redshift galaxy clusters and their evolution; observational cosmology; astrophysics in the near– and mid–infrared; photometric redshifts and multi–wavelength selection techniques
FY07 Accomplishments Brodwin was a key coauthor on a major paper submitted in FY07 that described a large survey of galaxy clusters discovered using the photometric redshifts he calculated from NOAO Deep Wide-Field Survey (NDWFS) optical and Spitzer mid-infrared data. The sample contains 335 galaxy clusters, some of which are over 10 billion light years away. Brodwin also submitted a follow-up paper in which the clustering properties of these galaxy clusters were determined. This analysis showed that these distant clusters have masses of about 1014 solar masses, and that their clustering is similar to that of nearby clusters. Measurements like this will be required to accurately constrain cosmological parameters in upcoming large-scale cluster surveys.
A-2 NOAO SCIENTIFIC STAFF ACTIVITY
FY08 Plans Brodwin is a member of several collaborations, including the IRAC Shallow Cluster Survey, the Far- Infrared Extragalactic Legacy Survey (FIDEL, PI Dickinson), the Spitzer Deep-Wide Field Survey (SDWFS), the HST Cluster Supernova Survey, the Blanco Cosmology Survey (PI Mohr), and the FLAMINGOS Extragalactic Survey (FLAMEX, PI Gonzalez). He plans to study the properties of massive high redshift cluster galaxies using mid-IR data from Spitzer and high-resolution imaging from HST. He also plans to calculate consistent photometric redshifts across all the FIDEL fields to facilitate comprehensive studies of the properties of massive star-forming galaxies between redshift 1 and 2, at the peak era of star formation.
CHRISTINE CHEN, Research Associate (Spitzer Fellow, NASA)
Research Interests Star and planet formation
FY07 Accomplishments Chen, in collaboration with M. Jura (UCLA) and J. Najita, has begun analysis of Spitzer MIPS 24- and 70-micron observations of 113 F- and G-type stars in Sco-Cen. We have discovered ~40 new dusty disks, some with fractional infrared luminosities commensurate with that observed toward beta Pictoris. We have measured 24-micron disk fractions of 6/18 (33% ±14%), 19/49 (39% ±9%), and 8/46 (17% ±6%) for Upper Scorpius (~5 Myr), Lower Centaurus Crux (~16 Myr), and Upper Centaurus Lupus (~17 Myr), respectively. We show that the 24-micron excess observed toward solar- like stars peaks at an age of ~15 Myr, suggesting that giant planet formation may trigger the production of debris in disks around young stars. We searched for signs that disk properties are dependent on stellar mass, but found no convincing evidence that disk properties are (anti-)correlated with stellar mass.
FY08 Plans Chen plans to complete her Spitzer MIPS study of F- and G-type stars in Sco-Cen. In addition, she hopes to complete a MIPS 24-and 70-micron study of 155 zero-age main sequence A-type stars, in collaboration with M. Jura (UCLA), to try to determine whether the infrared excess produced by small grains in these systems is generated by steady state grinding of parent bodies or stochastic events such as planet migration during the final stages of planetary system evolution. With the IRS Disks team (lead by D. Watson, U. of Rochester), she plans to use Spitzer IRS in low-resolution mode to follow- up debris disk candidates identified in these surveys to (1) search for spectral features that provide insight into grain composition and size and (2) characterize the emergent SED to contrain the spatial distribution of the circumstellar dust.
CHARLES F. CLAVER, Scientist
Research Interests Age and history of the Milky Way; stellar populations; large optical/infrared telescopes; Large Synoptic Survey Telescope; astronomical instrumentation; atmospheric physics
FY07 Accomplishments As telescope/site scientist and Systems Engineer for the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST), Claver has continued his work on the design and development of the 8.4-m, 3.5-degree field-of-view telescope system. Claver was one of the primary authors of the LSST’s MREFC proposal to the NSF. As part of the design effort, Claver and Gressler (NOAO) worked with a commercial company to develop a detailed non-sequential optical model of the LSST to analyze the affects of stray and scatter light in the LSST. Claver has continued his development work for new wavefront curvature analysis
A-3 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007
software to work with the unusual pupil geometry. Claver and Mighell (NOAO) worked with REU student T. J. Rodigas over the summer to develop a MATLAB-based prototype of the LSST wavefront sensing image processing pipeline. In the systems engineering role, Claver has developed a comprehensive systems engineering model that has become the LSST project’s primary configuration control and requirements management tool.
FY08 Plans Claver plans to continue his work on the LSST project toward detailing system requirements, developing an operations model, and advancing the telescope design and control in preparation of a Preliminary Design Review. Claver, with others from the LSST project, will use the recently installed infrared all-sky camera on Cerro Pachón to evaluate the relationship between IR imagery and visible extinctions as part of LSST calibration studies. He will also continue leading the development of the alignment and wavefront sensing strategy for the LSST active optics control system. Claver will also continue in his role as the LSST Systems Engineer. He plans to continue his observation work on old open clusters in the Milky Way.
STEVEN K. CROFT, Senior Science Education Specialist (Astronomer)
Research Interests Variable stars; planetary geology and geophysics
FY07 Accomplishments Croft continued his work in formal and informal science education. He completed work on the Investigating Astronomy project in partnership with TERC, providing scientific content and images to the effort that will produce the first new astronomy textbook in 20 years aimed at high school students. He also continued to develop an asteroid research project aimed at middle school students in support of the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope educational outreach effort, including completion of a beta version, middle school curriculum presently available online. Croft helped develop the new “Building Information Technology Skills through Astronomy (BITS)” program and conduct the first year’s workshops. He also continued work on the educational outreach project supporting the Giant Segmented Mirror Telescope project. He continued in the A-RBSE program, providing technical support and running the project’s remote-controlled telescope program.
FY08 Plans Croft will continue development of educational modules for the GSMT project. He will also continue development and classroom testing of the asteroid research project for the LSST EPO program. He will continue development of the BITS project, including school-year teacher support and the second year of workshops. Finally, he will also continue coordinating the remote telescope portion of the Teacher Observing Program and provide technical support to the A-RBSE program.
ARJUN DEY, Associate Astronomer
Research Interests Galaxy evolution; high-redshift galaxies; large-scale structure; AGN evolution and clustering
FY07 Accomplishments Dey spent most of FY07 on sabbatical at U. Hawaii’s Institute for Astronomy, the Spitzer Science Center, and UC Santa Cruz. Dey is one of the two PIs (with B. Jannuzi) of the NOAO Deep Wide- Field Survey (NDWFS), an investigation of galaxy evolution and clustering over an unprecedented volume. This survey has spurred a huge investment in ground- and space-based resources (VLA, Westerbork, Spitzer, MMT, Keck, GALEX, Chandra), and the resulting unique multi-wavelength
A-4 NOAO SCIENTIFIC STAFF ACTIVITY
database is allowing a comprehensive study of galaxy evolution and structure formation in the 0 FY08 Plans Dey will continue to work primarily on galaxy evolution and clustering, using the NDWFS and related survey data. He plans to continue studying the clustering and evolution of the red envelope galaxy population, investigating the growth of the central black holes in these systems, and studying the high- z Lyman break galaxy population. He supervises two thesis students at the U. Arizona Astronomy Dept. Along with M. Prescott (U. Arizona graduate student), Dey is studying the space density of large Lyman Alpha-emitting nebulae and the constraints they place on the formation of massive galaxies. With S. Bussmann (U.Arizona graduate student), he is studying the physical properties of a sample of high-redshift obscured AGN. Dey is also a member of a team attempting a very large survey of red giant stars in the halo of the Andromeda Galaxy. Dey will participate in the WFMOS Conceptual Study (being led by the AAO) in the role of Survey Scientist, organizing the core science teams to carry out the two key scientific projects (a Dark Energy study and a Galactic Archaeology study). He serves on the NOAO working group on the Evolution of the System of OIR Facilities. DAVID DE YOUNG, Astronomer Research Interests Theoretical astrophysics, especially non-linear phenomena; galaxy clusters; active galactic nuclei; extragalactic radio sources; MHD and hydrodynamic phenomena FY07 Accomplishments De Young, in collaboration with T.W. Jones (U. Minnesota) and S. M. O’Neill (U. Minnesota) has carried out a series of three-dimensional time dependent MHD simulations of the evolution of radio sources in rich clusters of galaxies. The intent of these calculations is to examine the degree of mixing and heating of the intracluster medium (ICM) that results from their formation and evolution. This in turn will test the popular idea that AGN “feedback” can solve the cluster “cooling flow” problem. Preliminary results from these calculations show that the presence of magnetic fields with correlation lengths of order of the scale of the radio source serve to inhibit mixing and heating of the ICM. This is consistent with earlier two-dimensional results, even though many new features appear in the three- dimensional calculations. De Young also co-organized a week-long scientific meeting on relativistic jets (with T. Rector, U. Alaska), held in Anchorage, Alaska in May 2007. Approximately 100 astronomers and astrophysicists from the U.S., Europe, and Latin America attended this international meeting. A-5 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007 FY08 Plans De Young will complete the series of three-dimensional MHD calculations described above, including several different field geometries and scales. Work will also continue on the entrainment of mass in extragalactic jets in the presence of magnetic fields, as will calculations of the evolution of “heavy” jets from AGN in order to explain the extreme degree of collimation seen in many extragalactic outflows. De Young will also continue ongoing research with T. Rector (U. Alaska) on the evolution of compact outflows from the nuclei of active galaxies. MARK DICKINSON, Associate Astronomer Research Interests Galaxy formation and evolution; high redshift galaxies; active galactic nuclei FY07 Accomplishments Dickinson is principal investigator for a new Legacy science survey with the Spitzer Space Telescope, the Far-Infrared Deep Extragalactic Legacy Survey (FIDEL). This program is obtaining the deepest Spitzer far-infrared (70 and 160 microns) imaging covering approximately 0.6 square degrees in three premier survey fields, to study thermal dust emission from infrared-luminous and ultraluminous galaxies and active galactic nuclei at redshifts out to z=2. The data were obtained throughout FY07, and are currently being reduced and analyzed; the first public data release was in June 2007, with more upcoming. Dickinson and his colleagues from his earlier Spitzer Legacy program, the Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey (GOODS), have continued to publish results on high redshift galaxy evolution, most notably two recent papers (Daddi et al. 2007, ApJ, 670, 156 and 173), which comprehensively study the nature of mid-infrared emission from massive galaxies at redshift 1.4 < z < 2.5, and which uncovered a very large population of previously unknown, dust-obscured AGN, Compton-thick to X-ray emission. Dickinson is supervising three NOAO post-doctoral researchers working on various aspects of galaxy evolution: S. Salim, N. Reddy, and M. Brodwin. He is also supervising the Ph.D. thesis research of U. of Arizona graduate student S. Juneau. FY08 Plans Dickinson will be leading the continued analysis of the FIDEL Spitzer data, including the reduction of the various data sets, their correlation with other multiwavelength data on these fields, the preparation of a series of public data releases, and the publication of scientific results, including studies of the dust properties of distant, luminous starburst galaxies, the cross-calibration of various independent star formation rate indicators, and the search for Compton thick AGN at moderate redshifts (where they are expected to dominate the hard X-ray background). He is a member of several other active science collaborations, including two Hubble Treasury programs: the “PEARS” ACS grism survey of the GOODS fields led by S. Malhotra (ASU); and a program of NICMOS imaging covering about 1/6th of the GOODS areas, targeting (primarily) massive galaxies at z~2–3 (PI C. Conselice, Nottingham UK). Dickinson expects to make use of KPNO’s new, wide-field, near-infrared camera, NEWFIRM, both in his own research on galaxy evolution and as a member of the team developing the data reduction pipeline for the instrument. GREGORY DOPPMANN, Postdoc Research Associate¬ JONATHAN H. ELIAS, Astronomer (Manager, GSMT Program Office) Research Interests Star formation and evolution; Magellanic Clouds; supernovae A-6 NOAO SCIENTIFIC STAFF ACTIVITY FY07 Accomplishments Elias provided scientific oversight of the AURA New Initiatives Office (NIO) as it transitioned from direct support of the Thirty-Meter Telescope project to an oversight role, with increased importance attached to the AURA GSMT Science Working Group. At the same time, NIO began the process of combining with other parts of NOAO as a more general “OIR system development” activity. FY08 Plans Elias’s scientific activities planned for FY08 will be in support of GSMT and OIR System development, including, but not limited to, support of the GSMT Science Working Group. KATY GARMANY, Associate Scientist (Senior Science Education Specialist) Research Interests Formation and evolution of massive stars FY07 Accomplishments Garmany continued management of the RBSE program, including recruiting teachers, teaching an on- line component, and organizing the summer workshop, which included four nights at Kitt Peak, using four different telescopes. She managed the teacher/student observing program (TOP) and handled groups at the 0.9-m, and developed a student project using data from this telescope. She taught Astronomy 102 at the Tohono O’odham Community College in Sells. She wrote a successful proposal to Science Foundation Arizona for an “RBSElite” program for Arizona middle school teachers, and conducted the first of its three annual workshops, titled “Astro BITS.” She is a co-editor for the ASP Conference proceedings for the 2007 annual meeting. Garmany collaborated with K. Cunha on a Magellan observing proposal, which has been awarded time in December. FY08 Plans Garmany will continue managing the RBSE program and the Astro BITS program, with particular emphasis on putting material on the NOAO Web site for teachers to use. She will develop a program for the Tohono O’odham schools, at their request, entitled “Reach for the Stars.” She expects to observe with the Magellan telescope in late December. KENNETH H. HINKLE, Scientist Research Interests Peculiar and late-type stars; circumstellar and interstellar matter; molecular spectroscopy; instrumentation FY07 Accomplishments Hinkle continued his work on the evolution of late-type binary systems. In collaboration with Brittain (Clemson) and Lambert (Texas), Hinkle published an analysis of the circumbinary disk of the prototype post-AGB binary HR 4049. High-resolution spectra of the CO and H2O line profiles provided insight into the mechanism for the release of gas by circumbinary grains and the accretion of this gas to the stellar surface. In collaboration with Fekel (Tennessee State), Joyce (NOAO), Lebzelter (Vienna), and Wood (ANU), Hinkle published the fifth paper in a series on symbiotic binary orbits. The systems analyzed all contained a white dwarf secondary and red giant primary. With Lebzelter, Hinkle completed a publication on the final flash evolution of the stellar remnant V605 Aql. Hinkle also published papers with McSaveney and collaborators (ANU) on LMC/SMC AGB star abundances and, with Lebzelter and collaborators, on Spitzer observations of dust around 47 Tuc AGB stars. A-7 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007 FY08 Plans Hinkle will be working with Joyce (NOAO), Jaffe (Texas), Bernstein (Michigan), Brittain (Clemson), and Kulesa (Arizona) on a proposal for a high-resolution, near-infrared spectrograph. Hinkle plans to continue his collaboration with Brittain on post-AGB stars with a publication on the peculiar binary HD 44179. With García-Hernández and Lambert (Texas), Hinkle will continue his work on the detailed CNO abundances of the HdC class of stellar remnants. Abundance analysis of the rare oxygen isotopes, which are conspicuous in Phoenix spectra observed in 2007 at Gemini, will constrain the evolutionary history. Additional observations and publications of evolved late-type binary orbits will be done in collaboration with Fekel and Joyce. Hinkle plans a publication with Wallace (NOAO) and Richter (U.C. Davis) on the circumstellar chemistry of ethylene. Hinkle and N. Smith (Berkley) are planning a paper on the spectral imaging of resonance scattered CO lines in the circumstellar shells of several massive evolved stars. STEVE B. HOWELL, Associate Scientist Research Interests Observational studies of interacting binary stars; photometric time-domain surveys; CCD instrumentation FY07 Accomplishments Howell used Spitzer Space Telescope observations to discover circumbinary dust disks around interacting binary stars. These disks were unexpected and will have implications for the evolution of binary stars. Studying the low mass companions to white dwarfs in interacting binary stars, Howell and collaborators have found high levels of stellar activity and evidence for solar-like cycles on very late M stars and 30–50 Jupiter-mass brown dwarfs. The activity seems to be induced by the white dwarf’s very high magnetic field, which drives electric currents in the interior of the low mass companion. Howell continued his work as a member of the NASA Kepler mission, concentrating this year on methods to monitor the health of the spacecraft focal plane CCD detectors while in orbit and modeling the expected population of eclipsing binaries (likely false-positive transit events) that Kepler will observe. FY08 Plans Howell will continue work on the NASA Kepler mission now slated for launch in early 2009. Howell will start selection and observation of a control group of stars within the Kepler field of view to help characterize the host stars eventually found by Kepler to harbor Earth-like planets. Howell will be involved in two large-area ground-based photometric surveys: one to search for exo-planet transits and the other to aid the LSST project in planning for variability and transient object science. Infrared spectroscopy will continue as a means of identification and study of the low mass companions in interacting binary stars. Howell will continue Spitzer Space Telescope observations of the dust surrounding interacting binaries, concentrating on spectroscopic observations at 5–14 microns and model fits to these data. BUELL T. JANNUZI, Astronomer (Director, Kitt Peak National Observatory) Research Interests Observational cosmology; formation and evolution of large-scale structure; quasars and quasar absorption line systems; instrumentation for surveys FY07 Accomplishments Jannuzi became Director of Kitt Peak National Observatory in March 2007. Jannuzi continued work as Co-PI with A. Dey on the NOAO Deep Wide-Field Survey (NDWFS), an 18-square-degree optical A-8 NOAO SCIENTIFIC STAFF ACTIVITY and near-IR imaging survey designed to study the formation and evolution of galaxies and large-scale structure in the Universe. The survey covers two sub-fields located in the constellations Boötes and Cetus. Imaging observations for the NDWFS were completed in 2004, but processing of the images continued in FY07. The Boötes field images and catalogs were released in October 2004. Jannuzi has been preparing the Cetus data for release. Over 100 papers have already made use of these data to study a variety of astrophysical problems, and additional papers are in preparation. Jannuzi co- authored 10 of these papers (appearing or submitted in 2007), which cover a diverse set of topics that range from the role of mergers in galaxy evolution to the use of mid-infrared observations to find rare objects. Jannuzi co-authored four additional papers not related to NDWFS in FY07. These addressed topics ranging from the SNe Ia rate out to redshift 1.5 to a measurement of the AGN X-ray Luminosity function at high redshift. FY08 Plans Jannuzi will continue to study the physical properties of Lyman-alpha absorption line systems using HST/STIS UV spectroscopy of intermediate redshift quasars. He continues to collaborate (with Bechtold, Morris, and Carswell) on comparing measurements of the spatial distribution of gas in the IGM to the distribution of galaxies in order to study the physical relationship between these two populations of baryons in the Universe. He will also remain involved in analysis of several recently completed surveys: AGES (AGN Galaxy Evolution Survey; PIs Kochaneck and Eisenstein), and CHAMP (The Chandra Multi-wavelength Project; PI P. Green). Jannuzi is a Co-I in the new Spitzer Deep Wide Field Survey (PI Stern), using IRAC to greatly extend the quality of the IRAC images of the NDWFS Boötes Field. Jannuzi is also Co-I on several smaller HST and Spitzer programs approved for time during 2007. With these programs, he will study the evolving properties of galaxies as a function of time. With P. S. Smith and G. Schmidt (Steward Observatory), Jannuzi will revisit his past studies of the polarization properties of BL Lac Objects, using new observations to investigate the variability of the polarization properties on 20-year time-scales and the resulting constraints on the physics of the “jets” producing the polarized emissions from these objects. RICHARD R. JOYCE, Scientist Research Interests Late-type stars; mass loss; infrared detector and instrumentation development FY07 Accomplishments Joyce continued a long-term project with Hinkle (NOAO), Fekel (TSU) and Wood (ANU) to determine orbits of symbiotic stars by measurement of their radial velocities at infrared wavelengths, emphasizing the largely unstudied Southern sky. The results for three S-type symbiotics were published, and those for several more are in preparation. Joyce also collaborated in a study, accepted for publication, of the ejecta from the final flash star V605 Aql using HST and Gemini/Hokupa’a. IRMOS spectra of the planetary nebula NGC 7027 at R = 3000 have been reduced and are being analyzed in a search for lines of uncommon elements whose presence may be diagnostic of neutron- capture processes in the progenitor star. FY08 Plans Joyce will continue the infrared radial velocity measurements of the Southern symbiotic stars and the abundance studies of globular cluster stars. He will use observing time with IRMOS on the Mayall telescope to extend the high spectral resolution infrared study of Planetary Nebulae to targets with a range of excitation values. A-9 NOAO ANNUAL REPORT FY 2007 TOM KINMAN, Astronomer Emeritus RESEARCH INTEREST Galactic structure; galactic halo; horizontal branch stars; RR Lyrae stars FY07 ACCOMPLISHMENTS Kinman acquired and partly reduced 430 frames of 77 RR Lyrae stars mostly in Lick Survey fields using the 32-inch Tenagra telescope. Kinman, Cacciari, et al. (2007) showed that the RR Lyrae but not BHB stars at the NGP showed retrograde motion. Kinman, Salim, Clewly (Oxford) (2007) showed that GALEX photometry could be used to isolate BHB stars. Kepley, Morrison, Helmi, Kinman, et al. (AJ accepted) investigated Halo Streams in the Solar neighborhood. Kinman began a program with Feast (Capetown) to derive absolute magnitudes for RR Lyrae stars using new Hipparcos data. Kinman continued work on the identification of BHB stars at the N. Galactic Pole. FY08 PLANS Kinman will continue CCD photometry of RR Lyrae stars in Lick fields, if the Tenagra telescope is available. Kinman hopes to complete his paper on the isolation of BHB stars at the NGP and to start a new program on the space-motions of BHB stars in the Anti-Center with Cacciari (Bologna) and Spagna (Turin). Kinman will continue work with Feast on RR Lyrae absolute magnitudes and with Morrison (Case) on the analysis of the motions of nearby halo stars using angular momenta diagrams for the discovery of Halo streams. TOD R. LAUER, Associate Astronomer Research Interests Extragalactic astronomy; normal galaxies; nuclear black holes; stellar populations; cosmology; astronomical image processing; space-based dark energy investigations FY07 Accomplishments Lauer led the completion and publication of three major papers in collaboration with the HST “Nuker” Team. The first uses the central structure of elliptical galaxies to argue that the most massive galaxies may host black holes more massive than those previously detected. The second paper compiles a large sample of HST photometry of the centers of early type galaxies to show that the elliptical galaxies can be cleanly divided into two structural classes based on the onset of the core phenomenon at high galaxy luminosity. The last paper argues for the possible existence of strong bias in probes that seek to measure the co-evolution of black holes on their hosting galaxies over the age of the Universe. Lauer and collaborators are completing an investigation into the structure and composition of the blue cluster of stars surrounding the M31 black hole. Lauer (with NASA funding) has led the science and engineering teams that are defining the Destiny concept for the NASA and DOE Joint Dark Energy Mission. In terms of functional activities, Lauer continued to supervise the NOAO survey program and serves on the DPP customer team. FY08 Plans Lauer will continue to lead defintion of the Destiny mission concept with the goal of proposing for the mission in 2008. He hopes to complete work on an HST investigation to detect the M32 main sequence. Lastly he hopes to complete analysis of adaptive optics observations obtained at Keck to search for extremely massive black holes in brightest cluster galaxies. JANICE LEE, Postdoc Research Associate (Hubble Fellow)± A-10 NOAO SCIENTIFIC STAFF ACTIVITY TING-HUI LEE, Research Associate (NASA) ± Research Interests Galactic and extra-Galactic planetary nebulae (PNe); mechanisms of shaping PNe; eclipsing binaries; extrasolar planets FY07 Accomplishments Lee and collaborators published their results on searching magnetic fields in central stars of bipolar planetary nebulae (PNe), and also results of optically thick radio cores of narrow-waist bipolar nebulae. Lee, in collaboration with Stanghellini (NOAO) and Shaw (NOAO) to study PNe in Magellanic Clouds, has analyzed high-resolution optical spectra of more than 50 PNe to obtain their chemical abundances. In addition, Lee, Howell (NOAO), and collaborators have obtained light curves of over 60,000 stars in Cygnus region to search for extrasolar planet transit candidates, and to characterize the stellar variability in this region in preparation for Kepler mission. JENNIFER LOTZ, Research Associate (Leo Goldberg Fellow) Research Interests Galaxy evolution; galaxy mergers; extra-galactic globular clusters; dwarf galaxies FY07 Accomplishments Lotz completed her project to measure the galaxy merger rate in the Extended Groth Strip. Her measurements of weak evolution in the fraction of galaxy mergers at 0.2 < z < 1.2 were presented in Sintra, Portugal at “At the Edge of the Universe” conference and published in the Astrophysical Journal. With co-author B. Miller, she also published work on the globular cluster luminosity functions in Virgo and Fornax dwarf elliptical galaxies in the Astrophysical Journal. Lotz continued her project to calibrate the timescales of merger-induced morphological disturbances with N- body/hydrodynamic simulations and presented preliminary results at the “Galaxy Mergers” conference in Baltimore, MD. Lotz was on the local organizing committee for the “Massive Galaxies over Cosmic Time 2” conference sponsored by NOAO and held in Tucson. FY08 Plans Lotz plans to continue her work using the simulations of galaxy mergers to calibrate morphological disturbance timescales and star-formation indicators. She also plans to compare the kinematic signatures and morphological signatures of galaxy mergers with a pilot WIYN Sparsepak program. C. ROGER LYNDS, Astronomer±