arXiv:physics/0303103v3 [physics.class-ph] 5 May 2003 B neuto 7 f[]wt h norc in h eie eutfrt for that result fact desired the the using sign; by incorrect simply the obtained with o the there [1] flux at thus of time-dependent sink b (7) the and equation curent that at field in note a charges (we electric and net magnetostatics time-dependent time-dependent wire of a domain are the create there of charges when end These only one possible at is source carr this current can a length is finite latter there of the wire whereas straight the situation, A that Maxwell–Amp`ere magnetostatic say equations’. CG time-independent results, a different to in here lead laws Biot–Savart and yCnesfrDsaeCnrladPeeto sitne or intended is Prevention and Control Disease for Centers by sin eeaie ogv orcl h lcrcadmgei ed u og to due fields magnetic and sources current electric and the charge correctly give to generalized Abstract USA 26505, WV Morgantown, Road, Health, and Willowdale Safety 1095 Occupational for Institute National Hnizdo V wire’ finite a of field magnetic the ‘About on Comment antcfil tapredclrdistance current a perpendicular carrying a wire at field magnetic qain [2–4]: equations Phys. h antcfil u oasrih urn-arigwr ffiiele t Amp`ere law, finite the of to According wire current-carrying results. different straight law to a Biot-Savart lead to Amp`ere and laws due the these field apply magnetic [1] (CG) the Graner and Charitat length. finite of wire current-carrying straight ∗ hscmeti rte yVHid nhspiaecpct.N capacity. private his in Hnizdo V by written is comment This = α ewudlk opitotta ohteCuobadBo–aatlw h laws Biot–Savart and Coulomb the both that out point to like would We µ ntelf-adsd hr utequal must there side left-hand the on 24 0 E Il/ 6]frteueo h itSvr a ntecluainof calculation the in law Biot–Savart the of use the for 267] , ( a spitdoti h utfiaingvnb hrttan Charitat by given justification the in out pointed is flaw A . r (2 t , πr = ) √ B r 4 ( 2 r πǫ 1 + t , 0 = ) l Z 2 tergthn ieo qain()o 1 for [1] of (3) equation of side right-hand (the ) I d is 4 3 µ ρ r π 0 B ′ ( " r Z t , ρ = d ( and ) r R 3 µ r ′ 0 t , 2 ′ I/ " ′ ) J (2 R J ˆ ( πr R ( r + r ′ 2 t , t , ,wieteBo–aatlwgvsti uniyas quantity this gives law Biot–Savart the while ), cR ′ l/ .Teegnrlztosaegvnb Jefimenko’s by given are generalizations These ). 1 ) r √ 1 + ∂q ∂ρ rmtemdon ln h egh2 length the along midpoint the from r ( cR 2 ( t 1 ∂t r ) + /∂t ′ ′ ∂ t , l J 2 ′ .T xli h atta h Amp`ere the that fact the explain To ). ) ( ∂t = R r ˆ ′ ′ − t , − hudb inferred. be should I ′ ) ). c # 2 ffiilspoto endorsement or support official o 1 t R ′ = t ∂ − J R/c hseeti edi used is field electric this f h antcfil u oa to due field magnetic the ( omri plcbeonly applicable is former ∂t emgei edcnbe can field magnetic he s‘ eea ouinof solution general ‘a is r rbe sotiethe outside is problem emagnitude he rnr[2003 Graner d B nrltime-dependent eneral × ′ ′ urn nywhen only current a y t , t nso h wire. the of ends oth gh n oethat note and ngth, R otepolmof problem the to s antb orc as correct be cannot h te end—and other the ′ ˆ ) # t ′ = ∗ t − R/c v obe to ave B u.J. Eur. fthe of l fa of (2) (1) where R = r r′ , Rˆ = (r r′)/R, and t′ = t R/c is the retarded time. Equations (1) and (2) are| − the| exact causal− (retarded) solutions− to Maxwell’s equations for given time- dependent charge and current densities ρ(r, t) and J(r, t). They can be obtained from the retarded scalar and vector potentials

′ ′ 1 3 ′ ρ(r , t R/c) µ0 3 ′ J(r , t R/c) V (r, t)= d r − A(r, t)= d r − (3) 4πǫ0 Z R 4π Z R of the well-known Lorentz-gauge solution to Maxwell’s equations by performing the spatial differentiations in

E(r, t)= ∇V (r, t) ∂A(r, t)/∂t B(r, t)= ∇ × A(r, t) (4) − − with due regard for the implicit dependence of the quantities ρ(r′, t R/c) and J(r′, t R/c) on the coordinate r through the retarded time t r r′ /c [4]. A comparison− of equation− (3) −| − | with equations (1) and (2) shows that while the Lorentz-gauge potentials can be obtained by a straightforward ‘retarding’ of the electrostatic scalar and magnetostatic vector potentials, the general expressions for the fields directly in terms of the sources contain terms that are additional to those of the simply ‘retarded’ Coulomb and Biot–Savart laws. Jefimenko’s equation (2) for the magnetic field reduces to the standard Biot–Savart law only when one can replace in the integrand the retarded time t′ with the present time t and drop the term with the time derivative of the current density. Obviously, this can be done when the current density is constant in time, but, nontrivially, also when the current density at the retarded time t′ is given sufficiently accurately by the first-order Taylor expansion about the present time t (see [4], problem 10.12):

∂J(r′, t) R ∂J(r′, t) J(r′, t′) J(r′, t)+(t′ t) = J(r′, t) . (5) ≈ − ∂t − c ∂t The Biot–Savart solution to the problem under discussion is thus correct when the con- dition (5) is satisfied, as, for example, when the current I is constant in time or varies with time only linearly. However, CG’s contention that the standard Biot–Savart law is a general −2 solution of the Maxwell–Amp`ere equation ∇×B = µ0J + c ∂E/∂t is incorrect. Contrary to an assertion of CG, the curl of a non-retarded vector potential (the r2 in equation (8) of [1] for this quantity is obviously a misprint) does not result in a magnetic field that satis- fies that equation in general. Only the curl of the retarded vector potential, which yields Jefimenko’s generalization (2) of the Biot–Savart law, J r′ J r′ ′ J r′ ′ µ0 ∇× 3 ′ ( , t R/c) µ0 3 ′ ( , t ) 1 ∂ ( , t ) ×Rˆ d r − = d r 2 + ′ (6) 4π Z R 4π Z " R cR ∂t #t′=t−R/c is, together with Jefimenko’s generalization (1) of the Coulomb law, the solution of Maxwell’s equations with general time-dependent sources. Charitat and Graner have expressed an agreement with the substance of this comment [5].

2 [1] Charitat T and Graner F 2003 About the magnetic field of a finite wire Eur. J. Phys. 24 267–270 [2] Jefimenko O D 1966 Electricity and Magnetism (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts) Jefimenko O D 1989 Electricity and Magnetism 2nd edn (Star City, West Virginia: Electret Scientific) [3] Jackson J D 1999 Classical Electrodynamics 3rd edn (New York: Wiley) [4] Griffiths D J 1999 Introduction to Electrodynamics 3rd edn (Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Prentice Hall) [5] Charitat T and Graner F 2003 Personal communication

3