PAPER C

SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS as at 31 DECEMBER 2007 (Q1, Q2 & Q3 07/08)

Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) E/13560/B Mr B Harvey E Unauthorised renovation & works to 21 June 06 H DIMISSED 48 a derelict building – Couthy Butt, 1 May 07 15 May 07 Downcourt Farm, St Catherines Down, Whitwell E/11271/F Mr & Mrs Kent E Change of use of land to multiple 2 June 06 WR ENFORCEMENT 53 residential through siting of 2 QUASHED caravans – Providence Cottage, 11 June 07 , P/00321/06 Mr B Harvey R Retention of agricultural storage 7 June 06 H DIMISSED 48 building – Couthy Butt, Downcourt 1 May 07 15 May 07 Farm, Whitwell P/01429/05 Tescos Stores Ltd R Retail store, vehicular access 20 June 06 I 28 Mar 07 WITHDRAWN alterations – land at junction of High 2nd Inquiry, 1 Oct 07 Street and Rectory Drive, Wootton 31 Oct. 07 E/27194 A Wheeler E Erection of shed within 20 m of 26 June 06 I DISMISSED 25 31 highway – 1 Albany Road, East 16 May 07 July 07 and enforcement upheld with corrections E/8694/H Mr D Vale E COU from garden centre to motor 15 Aug 06 H DISMISSED 37 vehicle sales & office – Car 27 Mar 07 1 May 07 Sales, Fighting Cocks Cross, Road, , Arreton P/02481/03 Wadham College R Outline for residential development – 22 Sep 06 I ALLOWED 29 Road 14 Mar 07 12 April 07

C - 1 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00394/06 Mr & Mrs Lord R Alterations to roof to provide 16 Oct 06 WR ALLOWED 33 additional living accommodation & 5 June 07 area for water storage tanks to include dormer & balcony – 10 Zig Zag Road, Ventnor P/01245/06 Mr Ian Murray RL LBC for internal alterations to provide 19 Oct 06 WR ALLOWED in 31 office accommodation, reception & part and stores; installation of under floor DISMISSED in heating – St Thomas Church, St part Thomas Street, 24 May 07 P/00456/06 Mr & Mrs Bailey R Detached house & double garage; 18 Oct 06 WR DISMISSED 26 vehicular access – l/r/o Hatherwood 20 April 07 & fronting Heatherwood Park Road, Bay P/01036/06 Miss G Fletcher R Alterations; 2 storey extension to 23 Oct 06 WR ALLOWED 24 provide additional living 11 April 07 accommodation–Pear Tree Cottage, Pallance Lane, Cowes P/01324/06 Miss S Begley R Continued siting of mobile home – l/a 23 Oct 06 WR DISMISSED 24 Bramhope Cottage, Cleveland Farm, 11 April 07 Sheepwash Lane, P/01712/06 Mr P Tyson R Demolition of garage & store; 30 Oct 06 WR ALLOWED 24 extension to form end terrace house 18 April 07 – 60 Nodes Road, Cowes P/01930/06 Mrs Davey-Sinclair R Demolition of house & studio; 2 26 Oct 06 WR DISMISSED 25 storey block of 4 flats – Douglas 18 April 07 Studio, Town Lane, Sandown P/01957/06 Mr D Bedding R Alterations; 2 storey extension for 3 Nov 06 WR WITHDRAWN additional living accommodation – 4 16 April 07 Alexandra Cottages, Westhill Lane, Norton

C - 2 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00752/06 Hepburns Town & R Conversion of barn 1 into office, 6 Nov 06 WR DISMISSED 24 Country Planning store & cottage to include conversion 23 April 07 Partnership of roofspace; conversion of barn 2 into residential unit to include conversion of roofspace & glazed conservatory link to adjacent barn; associated parking - Barns at Kite Hill Farm, Firestone Copse Road, Wootton Bridge P/01567/06 Mr & Mrs Hutchins ND Conversion of hotel into guest 8 Nov 06 WR DISMISSED 24 accommodation and single dwelling 23 April 07 house – Windsor Carlton Hotel, 4-5 Alexandra Gardens, Ventnor P/01279/06 A M Structures Ltd R COU from food distribution (B8) to 14 Nov 06 WR ALLOWED 29 general industrial (B2) – Woodlands 4 June 07 House, Embassy Way, Sandown P/01721/06 Mr A Bound R Outline for detached house with 17 Nov 06 WR DIMISSED 26 parking & vehicular access – land at 15 May 07 rear of 4 Hope Road, Ryde P/02170/04 Mr & Mrs O’Keefe R Conversion of redundant barn to unit 20 Nov 06 WR ALLOWED 20 of holiday accommodation with 10 April 2007 terrace on south west elevation; alterations to vehicular access – Gladices Barn, Gladices Lane, Green P/01656/06 Mrs G Andrew R Proposed end of terrace house – 28 Nov 06 WR ALLOWED 21 land adjacent, 37 Parkland Avenue, 23 April 07 Cowes P/02065/06 F B Construction Ltd R Proposed 2 storey bock of 2 flats – 29 Nov 06 WR ALLOWED 26 land rear of Bakewell Café fronting, 31 May 07 Tennyson Road, Freshwater

C - 3 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01648/06 Hall & Woodhouse R Proposed 6 low level lighting 23 Nov 06 WR DISMISSED 28 columns with lanterns to access 5 June 06 drive – Clarendon Hotel & Wight Mouse Inn, Church Place, Chale, Ventnor P/01423/06 Peter Ferns R Outline for dwelling; vehicular access 28 Nov 06 WR DISMISSED 21 – land rear of 33 Woodvale Road, 23 April 07 Cowes P/01360/06 Mr & Mrs Kindred R Outline for a dwelling; formation of 29 Nov 06 H DISMISSED 43 vehicular access – land between St 28 Sept 07 Martins & Dundas West, Afton Down, Freshwater P/01931/06 Mr D Walters R Outline for residential development 4 Dec 06 H WITHDRAWN and alterations to vehicular access – 26 July 07 Kingston Works, Kingston Road, P/00868/06 Mr M Denness R Conversion of barns (1 & 2) into 2 5 Dec 06 H WITHDRAWN units of holiday accommodation to 26 July 07 include bedrooms within roofspace – barns at Farm, Road, Queen Bower, Sandown P/01550/06 Mr & Mrs M Medway R Retention of alterations to widen 5 Dec 06 H DISMISSED 35 existing vehicular access – Old 25 July 07 7 Aug 07 Chapel House, High Street, Whitwell P/01434/06 Mr N Julian R Single/2 storey extension to provide 6 Dec 06 WR ALLOWED 25 additional living accommodation and 31 May 07 integral garage – 15 Strathwell Crescent, Whitwell, Ventnor

C - 4 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00819/06 Mr E Dunn-Coleman R Demolition of shop & storage 7 Dec 06 WR DISMISSED 25 building; outline for development of 8 31 May 07 flats, 2 maisonettes & 2 retail units - Colemans Carpets, Avenue Road, Freshwater P/00968/06 Mr & Mrs L Goulden R Two storey extension to form garage 18 Dec 06 WR ALLOWED 31 22 with hobbies room over; two storey May 07 extension to provide additional living accommodation - Ferndale, Newport Road, , Sandown P/01221/06 Mr A Attrill R Demolition of bungalow; proposed 20 Dec 06 WR DISMISSED 24 terrace of 3 houses – 80 Horsebridge 5 June 07 Hill, Newport P/02618/06 Mr R Stanley R Proposed semi-detached house – 20 Dec 06 WR DISMISSED 18 land adjacent 24 Sibden Road, 24 April 07 P/01986/06 Mr J Bewick R Outline for residential development 5 Jan 07 WR DISMISSED 22 (revised scheme), 21 Inglewood 7 June 07 Park, St Lawrence P/02580/06 Mr A Bound R Demolition of single storey side 8 Jan 07 WR DIMISSED 18 extension; proposed two storey 15 May 07 detached dwelling; alterations to vehicular access – 8 Hope Road, Ryde P/02509/06 Village R Demolition of side extension and 9 Jan 07 H ALLOWED 17 Developments garage, construction of terrace of 3 11 July 07 houses (revised scheme) – 65 St David’s Road, East Cowes E/23336/B Mr & Mrs M Medway E Retention of alterations to widen 11 Jan 07 H DISMISSED 30 existing vehicular access – Old 25 July 07 7 Aug 07 and Chapel House, High Street, Whitwell enforcement upheld with corrections C - 5 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) E/13764/C Mr & Mrs P Sibley E Siting of residential mobile home at 30 Jan 07 WR DISMISSED 45 Hi Profile, Cranmore Avenue, 14 December 07 Cranmore, Yarmouth P/01351/06 Mr C Clarke R Conversion of barn for storage 15 Jan 07 WR ALLOWED 29 purposes, to include roller shutters 9 Aug 07 on west elevation (revised scheme) – Cridmore Farm, Cridmore Lane, , Newport P/02095/06 Mr & Mrs J Gilland R Outline for a two bedroomed 11 Jan 07 WR DISMISSED 22 bungalow – land adjacent 141A 18 June 07 Sandown Road, Shanklin P/02764/06 Mr B Wright R Replacement of flat roof with pitched 11 Jan 07 WR ALLOWED in 22 to existing kitchen extension; 1st floor part & extension to provide additional living DISMISSED in accommodation – 33 Forest Road, part Winford, Sandown 18 June 07 P/01358/06 K Morris Ltd R Continued use of land to facilitate 12 Jan 07 H ALLOWED 45+ expansion of contractors depot 17 December 07 including provision of turning area for vehicles; outline for building to provide under-cover parking (revised scheme) – Park Place Farm, Road, Newport P/01968/06 Mr & Mrs T Swaffield R Conservatory on front elevation – 18 Jan 07 WR DISMISSED 20 Old School House, High Street, 8 June 07 , Sandown P/01184/06 Mr Mark Batchelor R 1st floor rear extension to form en- 18 Jan 07 WR ALLOWED in 21 suite bedroom; detached garage – part & 35 College Road, Newport DISMISSED in part 12 June 07

C - 6 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01379/06 Mr Stephen Mills R Retention of stable block – land rear 23 Jan 07 WR DISMISSED 23 of Chillerton Farm Barns, Main Road, 4 July 07 Chillerton, Newport

P/02085/06 Mr N & Mr R Payne ND Demolition of dwelling & garage; 24 Jan 07 WR WITHDRAWN proposed 2 detached houses with 13 June 07 garages; alterations to vehicular access (aorm) – 74 Baring Road, Cowes P/02404/06 Ncink Ltd R Demolition of petrol station & 9 Feb 07 WR ALLOWED 19 showroom; construction of 2 storey 18 June 07 block of 14 flats to include accommodation in roofspace; alterations to vehicular access – Wight Motors Ltd, Garfield Road, Ryde P/02406/06 Ncink Ltd RC Conservation area consent for 9 Feb 07 WR ALLOWED 19 demolition of petrol station & 18 June 07 showroom in connection with construction of 2 storey block of 14 flats to include accommodation in roofspace; alterations to vehicular access – Wight Motors Ltd, Garfield Road, Ryde P/02386/06 Mr & Mrs D Lewis R Conversion of garage/workshop into 7 Feb 07 WR DISMISSED 22 annexed accommodation to include 11 July 07 glazed link to existing dwelling; replacement garage – Shima, Bedbury Lane, Freshwater P/01515/06 Mrs Toni Scott R Demolition of garage; 2 storey block 14 Feb 07 WR DISMISSED 21 of 2 flats with parking & alterations to 11 July 07 vehicular access – land adjacent 43 Salters Road, Ryde C - 7 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01809/06 Messrs Barbour & R Demolition of builders store; 23 Feb 07 WR DISMISSED 18 Gough construction of 3 storey block of 5 20 July 07 flats; cycle racks, bin store & landscaping - S and J Builders Merchant, Brunswick Road, Cowes P/01672/06 Mr R McLinden R Outline for chalet bungalow – land 27 Feb 07 WR ALLOWED 19 adjacent Emandge, Worsley Drive, 19 July 07 Wroxall, Ventnor P/02649/06 Mr N J Hawkins R Retention of wooden access steps to 6 Mar 07 WR DISMISSED 17 beach (revised scheme) - Linstone 4 July 07 Management Co Ltd, Monks Lane, Freshwater P/01693/06 Sandown IC Continued use of land for go-kart 12 Mar 07 WR ALLOWED 17 Investments track and associated buildings – land 19 July 07 adjacent Westridge Centre, Brading Road, Ryde P/01707/06 Mr V J Sanders R Replacement enlarged roof to 7 Mar 07 WR DISMISSED 18 provide living accommodation within 13 July 07 roof space to include dormer windows on front & rear elevation - 2 Wyatts Lane, Cowes P/02112/06 Mr V Jenkins R Demolition of dwelling & 16 Mar 07 WR DISMISSED 21 outbuildings; construction of terrace 13 Aug 07 of three houses & pair of semi- detached houses with alterations to vehicular access; parking & landscaping (revised scheme) – 21a Horsebridge Hill, Newport

C - 8 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02627/06 Mr P Ferns R Demolition of garage; construction of 13 Mar 07 WR ALLOWED 22 a pair of semi-detached houses with 14 Aug 07 parking and alterations to vehicular access (revised scheme) - land adjacent Trent House, 42 Newport Road, Cowes P/01573/06 West Island R Proposed detached bungalow with 13 Mar 07 WR DISMISSED 17 Developments parking & alterations to vehicular 11 July 07 access – Plot 11, Coopers Close, Freshwater P/01634/06 The Salvation Army R Demolition of the Salvation Army Hall 16 Mar 07 I WITHDRAWN Trustee Co Ltd & development of a direct access 30 Aug 07 hostel for the homeless & new public car park; alterations to vehicular access (revised scheme) – Salvation Army and the Public Car Park, Green Street,/Station Road, Ryde P/03035/06 Mr A Alexander R Outline for two residential units 19 Mar 07 WR DISMISSED 20 (revised scheme) – land adjacent 7 Aug 07 Paddock, Corbett Road, Ryde P/01902/06 Mr Paul Watkins R Demolition of properties; residential 22 Mar 07 WR DISMISSED 24 development of four houses with 5 Sept 07 parking & alterations to vehicular access off New Road (revised scheme) – 16 New Road, Brading

C - 9 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02933/06 South Wight Housing RC Conservation Area Consent for 29 Mar 07 WR WITHDRAWN Association Limited demolition of former bus depot in 9 July 07 connection with construction of 21 flats in a 3 storey block with parking & alterations to vehicular access – former depot/garage site, Pound Lane, Ventnor P/02884/06 South Wight Housing R Demolition of former bus depot; 29 Mar 07 WR WITHDRAWN Association Limited construction of 21 flats in a 3 storey 9 July 07 block with parking & alterations to vehicular access – former depot/garage site, Pound Lane, Ventnor P/02246/06 Mrs Sharon Cowley R Alterations; two storey rear extension 29 Mar 07 WR DISMISSED 19 to provide additional living 9 Aug 07 accommodation – 20 Coronation Road, Cowes P/02885/06 Mr Alan Hider R Demolition of lean-to; conversion of 30 Mar 07 WR DISMISSED 19 barn/store into dwelling to include 13 August 07 accommodation within roof space – barn adjoining Apsewood Cottage, Apse Manor Road, Shanklin Appeals received between 1 April 07 and 30 June 07 P/01746/06 Mr C James R Outline for end of terrace house & 3 April 07 WR DISMISSED 18 garage (revised scheme)(revised 7 Aug 07 description)(readvertised application) P/03125/06 Procter/Ganley Ltd IC Amendment to approval under 10 April 07 WR WITHDRAWN TCP/27735/B to provide additional 9 July 07 parking & access/footpath crossing – 6 High Street, Wootton Bridge

C - 10 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02813/06 Mr V Lewis R Demolition of building; proposed pair 18 April 07 WR ALLOWED 20 of maisonettes - land adjacent 30 August 07 Noah’s Ark, High Street, Newport P/02972/06 Mr V Lewis RC Conservation Area Consent for the 18 April 07 WR ALLOWED 20 demolition of the Old School Hall – 30 Aug 07 Land adjacent Noah’s Arc, Carisbrooke High Street, Newport P/00294/07 Dr Mark Patterson R Greenhouse – Wolverton Manor, 11 April 07 WR DISMISSED 29 , Newport 04 December 07 P/03185/06 Mr D Holmes R Vehicular access and 19 April 07 WR ALLOWED 19 hardstanding/turning area – 4 Sept 07 Hurstview, New Road, P/01774/06 Park Resorts Group R Change of use of land for siting of 15 16 April 07 WR WITHDRAWN Limited holiday lodge caravans - Land at, 24 May 07 Lower Hyde Holiday Park, Landguard Road, Shanklin

P03103/03 Mr P Gillett R Proposed farm access road & 24 April 07 WR DISMISSED 20 improvements to Newport Road 10 Sept 07 access – Luton Farm, 439 Newport Road, Cowes P/02053/06 Mr M Haslin R Change of use of land to expand 24 April 07 WR DISMISSED 16 holiday camp for provision of 13 Aug 07 additional unit space - land adjacent Cheverton Copse Holiday Park, Scotchells Brook Lane, Sandown P/02411/06 Mr R J Dean R 2 storey side extension to form 24 April 07 WR ALLOWED 18 enlarged lounge with bedroom over – 4 Sept 07 Bower Villa, Alverstone Road, Queen Bower, Sandown

C - 11 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00007/07 Mr P Brown R Proposed 1st floor rear extension to 25 April 07 WR DISMISSED in 21 hotel to form 2 en-suite bedrooms; part and proposed conservatory to managers ALLOWED in accommodation (The Cottage) – part Appley Manor House Hotel, Appley 21 Sept 07 Road, Ryde P/00284/07 Mr M Lambert R Demolition of extension & 26 April 07 WR DISMISSED 21 conservatory; pari of semi-detached 19 Sept 07 houses; vehicular access – land between 10 Witbank Gardens and 1 Oaklyn Gardens, Shanklin P/02393/06 Mrs J A Georgiou R Proposed end of terrace house; 30 April 07 WR DISMISSED 21 parking – 85 Upton Road, Ryde 21 Sept 07 P/03007/06 Mrs Brenda Mouland R Demolition of house; residential 10 May 07 WR DISMISSED 16 development of 3 storey block of 9 30 Aug 07 flats & 1 detached house; parking & alterations to vehicular access – Bucklands, Church Path, East Cowes P/02842/06 Mr M Ward R Demolition of launderette; 10 May 07 WR DISMISSED 26 replacement building to form 08 November 07 launderette on ground floor & offices on 1st & 2nd floors - 14 York Avenue, East Cowes P/00310/07 Mr Roger Bowers R Demolition of building & part garage; 14 May 07 WR ALLOWED 25 outline for 3 dwellings with garages 05 November 07 and parking; vehicular access – 10 Wykeham Close, Ryde

C - 12 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02088/06 Mr & Mrs C J R Demolition of public house & 14 May 07 WR DISMISSED 16 Plucknett outbuildings; residential development 3 Sept 07 comprising 4 pairs of semi-detached houses and 2 storey block of 2 flats with parking & alterations to vehicular access off Silcombe Lane (Revised scheme) –Prince of Wales, Princes Road, Freshwater P/02254/06 Mr R Dixcey R Proposed 2 storey block of 2 Rec’d 11 WR Invalid appeal – maisonettes (revised scheme) – land May 07 late submission adjacent, 42 Chapel Street, Newport not accepted by PINS P/00179/07 Mr P Bartlett R Demolition of porch; pair of semi- 18 May 07 WR DISMISSED 24 detached houses – land between 84 05 November 07 & 88 Fairlee Road, Newport P00588/07 Mr P Hoare R Conversion of existing coach house 18 May 07 WR DISMISSED 28 into dwelling to include addition of 30 November 07 conservatory and 1st floor extension – land between 30 and 32 Argyll Street, Ryde P/00347/07 Mr J O’Neill R Formation of vehicular access and 23 May 07 WR DISMISSED 22 hardstanding/turning area – 50 23 October 07 Queens Road, Ryde P/00569/07 Mr A Wright R Demolition of garage; pair of semi- 22 May 07 WR ALLOWED 27 detached houses with parking and 26 November 07 access off Laundry Lane – land rear of 81 & 83 Carisbrooke Road, Newport

C - 13 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02531/06 Mr P Bull R Enlarged roof to provide additional 1 June 07 WR ALLOWED 19 living accommodation within 24 October 07 roofspace to include dormer window & 2 dormer windows on front & rear elevations with French doors & balustrading – 32 Zig Zag Road, Ventnor P/02832/06 Mr P Fallon R Demolition of garage; alterations; 13 June 07 WR ALLOWED 19+ single storey extension to form 29 October 07 double garage; 2 storey side extension to provide additional living accommodation – Sea Strand, Shore Road, Ventnor P/02874/06 Mr & Mrs Norris R Demolition of dwelling; outline for 7 June 07 WR ALLOWED 19+ nine dwellings with parking and 29 October 07 alterations to vehicular access – Magdala, Slay Lane, Whitwell, Ventnor P/00228/07 Mr J Taylor R Pair of semi-detached houses; 13 June 07 WR WITHDRAWN alterations to vehicular access 26 Sept 07 (revised scheme) (revised plans) – land adjacent, Little Rosery, Westfield Road, St Helens P/00576/07 Mr Jack Hammerton R Siting of caravan as unit of living 5 June 07 WR DISMISSED 22 & Mr Stephen accommodation – Downsview, 05 November 07 Sheppard Whitehouse Road, Newport P/00344/07 Mr A Wilkes R Demolition of 2 houses & garages; 13 June 07 WR DISMISSED 22 outline for residential development of 05 November 07 13 flats with access off Parkhurst Road, (revised scheme)

C - 14 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00254/07 Mr & Mrs R R Demolition of garage; detached 11 June 07 WR DISMISSED 19 Cummings house with vehicular access and 04 October 07 parking – land rear of 56 Mill Hill Road, Cowes P/00329/07 Mr & Mrs G Hearl R Demolition of garage; 3 storey block 12 June 07 WR DISMISSED 19 of 3 flats – land rear of 1 Garfield 26 October 07 Road fronting Brook Road, Shanklin P/00301/07 Mr B Hamilton R Demolition of single storey 20 June 07 WR ALLOWED 17 extension; outline for end of terrace 15 October 07 house with parking; vehicular access (revised scheme) – 16 Beatrice Close, Ryde P/02550/06 Garth Homes R Demolition of garage; conversion of 29 Jun 07 Inquiry ALLOWED 20 former Friends’ Meeting House & 23 Oct 07 WITH COSTS single storey extension to form 2 12 November 07 flats; construction of 2/3 storey block of 22 flats; detached building to form bin store/bicycle store – Friends Meeting House and Trafalgar Car Sales, Crocker Street, Newport P/02850/06 Garth Homes RC Conservation Area Consent for 29 Jun 07 Inquiry WITHDRAWN demolition of garage in connection 23 Oct 07 12 November 07 with conversion of former former Friends’ Meeting House & single storey extension to form 2 flats; construction of 2/3 storey block of 22 flats; detached building to form bin store/bicycle store – Friends Meeting House and Trafalgar Car Sales, Crocker Street, Newport

C - 15 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00997/07 Mr Albert Button IC Renewal: Conversion of unit 1 to 27 Jun 07 WR form one holiday unit; conversion of unit 2 to form two holiday units; formation of swimming pool & patio area; alterations to vehicular access & formation of parking area – land adjacent Noke Common, Newport P/00529/07 Mr L R Thorne R Alterations; ground floor & 1st floor 26 June 07 WR DISMISSED 17 extension to provide additional living 22 October 07 accommodation, balcony on east and west elevations – Beach Cottage, Castlehaven Lane, Undercliff, Ventnor P/00643/07 Mr & Mrs G Brimson R Outline for dwelling; vehicular access 26 June 07 WR DISMISSED 16 off Elm Grove & parking/turning area 16 October 07 (revised scheme) – land rear of 3 Woodbine Villas St Johns Road and fronting Elm Grove, Newport E/22278/F Mr L Sixsmith E Allegation of operation of a car lot 5 July 07 WITHDRAWN from property without permission – 24 September 07 Merrie Gardens Farm, Newport Road, Sandown E/13180/N Moustaf Sallam E Allegation of change of use from a 13 July 07 Inquiry dwelling into a hotel/b&b; allegation 2 April 07 of cars for sale and storage of a container – Brencliff, 2 Park Road, Shanklin P/00250/07 F W Developments R Single/3 storey block of 2 flats, 9 July 07 WR ALLOWED 21 (IW) Ltd vehicular access & parking (revised 04 December 07 scheme) - land between 82/84 and 86 Mill Hill Road, Cowes Appeals received between 1 July 07 and 30 September 07

C - 16 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00896/07 Oliver Cohen R Pair of two storey semi-detached 10 July 07 WR DISMISSED 17 dwellings – land rear of 20 Medina 15 October 07 Avenue, Newport P/02271/06 Mr Andrew Turnbull ND Conservation Area Consent for 12 July 07 WR DISMISSED 16 demolition of building; construction 02 November 07 of 4 storey block of 9 flats – 21 The Strand, Ryde P/02272/06 Mr Andrew Turnbull ND Demolition of building; construction 12 July 07 WR DISMISSED 16 of 4 storey block of 9 flats – 21 The 02 November 07 Strand, Ryde E/27093 Cliff Mottram E Allegation of unauthorised structure 4 July 07 WR Invalid appeal – – land south of Dairy Cottage, late submission Wilmingham Lane, Freshwater not accepted by PINS P/00318/07 O2 (UK) Ltd R Prior Notification for 18 July 07 WR DISMISSED 16 telecommunications installation 07 November 07 comprising 15m high column with 300mm dish; associated grounded based equipment cabinet & ancillary development – Holiday Camp, Pondwell Hill, Ryde P/00965/07 Mr C E Graham R Outline for dwelling (revised scheme) 19 July 07 WR DISMISSED 18+ – land adjacent Graytiles, St. 27 November 07 Catherines Road, Niton Undercliff, Ventnor P/00498/07 Ms C Bowkiss R Change of use from holiday 10 July 07 WR ALLOWED 16 accommodation to private dwelling – 20 November 07 Chestnut Mews, 16-22 Vaughan Way, Shanklin P/02744/06 Mr D McKenna RLDC Certificate of Lawfulness for 19 July 07 WR continued use of property as private dwelling – Fairsea, Lower Woodside Road, Wootton Bridge, Ryde C - 17 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00531/07 Mr & Mrs Runco R Detached chalet bungalow with 24 Aug 07 WR DISMISSED 16 integral garage; parking; vehicular 12 December 07 access from York Lane – land rear of Dubari, Alum Bay New Road, Totland Bay P/02501/06 J & F Owen R Demolition of outbuildings; 28 Aug 07 H conversion and extension of 27 February outbuildings to form arena for horse 08 back falconry; ancillary office, bird welfare hospital and associated managers accommodation – Appuldurcombe House, Appuldurcombe Road, Wroxall P/01179/07 Mr & Mrs J Terlouw IC Retention of 2 storey side extension 15 Aug 07 WR DISMISSED 16 to form enclosed stairs – 25 Shore 04 December 07 Road, Cowes P/00883/07 Mr & Mrs D Hegarty R Balcony & French doors on rear 28 Aug 07 WR ALLOWED 14 elevation – 17 Fitzroy Street, 04 December 07 Sandown P/00831/07 Peter Ferns R Demolition of garage; proposed end 31 Aug 07 WR Architecture Ltd of terrace house; vehicular access & parking - land adjacent 32 Fieldway Crescent, Cowes P/01476/07 Mr A H Button R Change of use of barn from 6 Sep 07 WR DISMISSED 14 agricultural to storage & distribution 12 December 07 (Class B8) – Noke Common Dairy, 45 Noke Common, Newport

C - 18 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00330/07 James Avey R Two storey extension and conversion 10 Sep 07 WR of house into three units of living accommodation comprising a two storey house and two flats; vehicular access and parking (revised scheme) – 97 Clarence Road, East Cowes P/00010/07 Mr W R Button R Demolition of bungalow; two pairs of 11 Sep 07 WR semi-detached houses with alterations to vehicular access; parking and landscaping (revised scheme) – 17 Albert Road, Cowes P/01458/07 Mr W R Button R Demolition of bungalow; two pairs of 11 Sep 07 WR semi-detached houses with alteration to vehicular access; parking and landscaping (revised scheme) – 17 Albert Road, Cowes P/00757/07 Mr & Mrs Phillips R Outline for residential unit – land 14 Sep 07 WR adjacent Byways, Buckbury Lane, Newport P/01259/07 Mr P Hayes ND Demolition of bungalow & garage; 14 Sep 07 WR two detached dwellings with roofspace accommodation; vehicular access (revised scheme) – Little Cedars, Old Seaview Lane, Seaview P/00468/07 Monview Limited R Demolition of six garages; two storey 20 Sep 07 WR blck of two maisonettes with parking – land adjacent 79 Elm Grove Newport P/00599/07 Orchid IC Conversion of ground and 1st floor 12 Sep 07 WR Developments Ltd offices into six flats – 23 – 27 Denmark Road, Cowes

C - 19 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00118/07 Mrs E M Long R Demolition of garage; 2 storey block 10 Sep 07 WR of 4 flats, (revised scheme) (revised plans) – land adjacent Spring Villa, Well Road, East Cowes P/00455/07 Mr Steve White R Demolition of garages; detached 5 Oct 07 H dwelling with parking – land adjacent Cranford House, Road, Ryde E/22092/F Hall & Woodhouse E Unauthorized lighting to gate piers 21 Sept 07 I Ltd and floodlights to car parking area – 14 May 08 The Wight Mouse Inn, Church Place, Chale P/00907/07 Mr & Mrs R Carder R Conversion of part of barn into farm 19 Oct 07 WR shop & store with parking (revised scheme) – farm buildings, Mottistone, Newport P/01429/07 Mr S Field R Alterations and conversion of 03 Oct 07 WR property into two dwellings; vehicular access & hardstanding – 21 Oaks Close, East Cowes P/01884/07 Mr Barry Wright R Replacement of flat roof with pitched 30 Oct 07 WR to existing kitchen extension; first floor extension to provide additional living accommodation (revised scheme) – 33 Forest Road, Winford, Sandown P/01198/07 Mrs M S Nigh R Demolition of garage; proposed end 08 Oct 07 WR of terrace dwelling with parking – 82 Wilton Road, Shanklin

C - 20 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01762/07 Mr & Mrs James R Conversion of redundant signal 05 Oct 07 I Cooper station into unit of holiday accommodation – Niton Radio Station, Road, Niton, Ventnor P/01464/07 Mr & Mrs W R Variation of condition no 7 on 11 Oct 07 WR Headington TCP/26285/B which states that no dwelling shall be occupied until space has been laid out within the site for vehicles to turn so that they may enter & leave the site in forward gear. The space shall not thereafter be used for any purposes other than that approved – land adjoining 218 Park Road, Cowes P/00652/07 Dr M Patterson R Conversion of storage building into 16 Oct 07 WR medical consulting unit – Wolverton Manor, Shorwell, Newport P/00727/07 Dr M Patterson RL LBC for conversion of storage 16 Oct 07 WR building to medical consulting unit – Wolcverton Manor, Shorwell, Newport P/00162/07 Stephenson R Demolition of bungalows; residential 25 Oct 07 WR Developments development of 5 houses & 9 (Gurnard) Ltd apartments with parking; formation of vehicular access; landscaping (revised scheme) – 24 and 25 and land adjacent Princes Esplanade, Cowes

C - 21 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01126/07 Mr A Gatrell R Demolition of garage & extension; 2 18 Oct 07 WR x 2 storey extensions & conversion of house to form 6 flats; parking & alterations to vehicular access off Queens Road – 30 Queens Road, Shanklin Appeals received between 1 Oct 07 to 31 Dec 07 P/00973/07 Bank Machine Ltd R Retention of A.T.M. cash machine 27 Nov 07 WR on front elevation – Wroxall Stores, High Street, Wroxall, Ventnor P/01247/07 Mr A Wilkes R Demolition of garage; outline for 26 Oct 07 WR terrace of three 3-storey houses P/00635/07 A P & J Williams R Proposed bungalow with improved 09 Nov 07 WR access and parking; provision of access, parking and turning area for existing bungalow (revised scheme) P/00501/07 Sibbick Court ND Residential development of 2 09 Nov 07 H Associates detached houses and terrace of 3 houses with access off St Davids Road (revised scheme) – land adjacent 74-82 St Davids Road rear of 113-121 and between 111 & 113 Adelaide Grove, East Cowes P/01030/06 Harbour IC Continued engineering operation 12 Nov 07 WR Improvements Com works to maintain access channel pany Ltd to Bembridge Harbour – part of access channel Bembridge Harebour off Embankment Road, Bembridge

C - 22 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01303/07 Mr J W Dolton R Retention of shed – 6 Chillerton 13 Nov 07 WR Farm Barns, Main Road, Chillerton, Newport P/00428/07 Ms P Percival R Construction of dwelling (revised 16 Nov 07 WR scheme) – Broadlands Court, 14 Palmerston Road, Shanklin P/01924/07 F Stay & Co Ltd R Pair of semi-detached houses with 26 Nov 07 WR parking (revised scheme) – land adjacent 25 Bellmead Lane, Newport P/00589/07 D J White & M R Outline for bungalow – land 22 Nov 07 WR White between and rear of The Glen & Lyttlestone, Heathfield Road, Bembridge P/01791/07 Mr I Mackie R Demolition of garage; proposed 01 Nov 07 WR detached dwelling with parking & vehicular access; single storey extension to form utility area & wc & construction of vehicular access for no 24 – land at and adjacent 24 Marina Avenue, Ryde P/0428/07 Mr A Gibbs R Demolition of dwelling; 04 Dec 07 H construction of 2 chalet bungalows with garages/parking & alterations to vehicular access (revised scheme) – Copperfields, Youngwoods Way, Alverstone Garden Village, Sandown P/00964/07 Mr P Seeley R Reinstatement of barn – Bottom 17 Dec 07 WR Barn, Brook, Newport

C - 23 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01886/07 Sandham Court R Demolition of garage; proposed 17 Dec 07 WR Developments terrace of 6 houses with parking & access off New Street – former coach garage off New Street, Sandown P/00915/07 Mr & Mrs Gregory R Demolition of garage; proposed 10 Dec 07 WR two storey detached dwelling with parking; alterations to vehicular access – 33 Station Road, Wootton Bridge P/00966/07 Mr P Seeley RL LBC for reinstatement of barn – 17 Dec 07 WR Bottom Barn, Brook, Newport P/01459/07 Mr K Blamey R Proposed 1.83m high boundary Rec’d 23 WR fence – 123 St Edmunds Walk, Nov 07 Wootton Bridge Awaiting validation P/01679/07 A Bound R Demolition of garage and porch; Rec’d 28 WR proposed 2 storey dwelling to form Nov 07 terrace of 3 – land adjacent 8 Awaiting Hope Road, Ryde Validation P/01393/07 Mr A Brown R 2 storey side extension to form Rec’d 29 WR additional living accommodation – Nov 07 92 Fairfield Gardens, Sandown Awaiting Validation P/01236/07 Mrs S Hillman RL Parking for 6 cars; conversion of Rec’d 30 WR existing car park; removal of side Nov 07 fence; 2 post mounted signs – 11 Awaiting The Strand, Ryde Validation

C - 24 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00950/07 K Hutchins, S Martin R Demolition of timber store; Rec’d 03 WR & S Pointon single/two storey rear extension to Dec 07 form honeymoon suite, two en- Awaiting suite bedrooms and store – Validation Sandhill Private Hotel, 6 Hill Street, Sandown P/03147/06 Mr & Mrs Bunyon R Outline for semi-detached chalet Rec’d 12 WR bungalow; closure of vehicular Dec 07 access & construction of new Awaiting vehicular access – 11 Oaklands Validation Close, Ryde P/01097/07 Ruddell Homes Ltd ND Demolition of house & bungalow; Rec’d 12 WR construction of a pair of semi- Dec 07 detached houses & 1 block of 5 Awaiting terraced houses with parking & Validation vehicular access off Heytesbury Road – 6 & 8 Heytesbury Road, Newport P/01016/07 County R Detached bungalow; vehicular Rec’d 18 WR Developments UK access & parking – land between 6 Dec 07 Ltd Whitecross Avenue & 1 Cedar Awaiting Drive, Shanklin Validation E/06257/K Bank Machine Ltd E Unauthorised installation of ATM Rec’d 18 WR on front elevation – Wroxall Dec 07 Stores, 1 West Street, Wroxall Awaiting Validation P/01369/07 Mr S Chides R Demolition of existing property; Rec’d 19 WR pair of semi detached houses with Dec 07 parking and vehicular access – Bridge House, Baring Road, Cowes

C - 25 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01370/07 Mr S Chides R CAC for demolition of existing Rec’d 19 WR property in connection with Dec 07 proposed pair of semi detached houses with parking and vehicular access – Bridge House, Baring Road, Cowes P/01385/07 Mr S Chides R Demolition of existing property; Rec’d 19 WR pair of semi-detached houses – Dec 07 Bridge House, Baring Road, Cowes P/01386/07 Mr S Chides R CAC for demolition of existing Rec’d 19 WR property in connection with Dec 07 proposed pair of semi-detached houses – Bridge House, Baring Road, Cowes P/01070/07 Mr M Ferris R Demolition of bungalow; detached Rec’d 21 WR house with integral garage & roof Dec 07 terrace (revised scheme) – 19 Denmark Road, Cowes P/01192/07 M G Heating Ltd R Residential development of 2 Rec’d 04 WR houses & 7 flats; parking & Jan 08 alteration to vehicular access; pavement widening in Newnham Road (revised scheme) – Mountain Ash, Newnham Road, Ryde

C - 26

KEY

Type Appeal Procedure

R = Refusal of planning permission WR = written representations RL = Refusal of listed building consent H = hearing RC = Refusal of conservation area consent I = public inquiry RA = Refusal of advertisement consent IC = Imposition of condition on planning permission ND = Failure to determine application with prescribed period E= Enforcement notice RLDC= Refusal for lawful development certificate

SUMMARY OF SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS FOR Q1, Q2 & Q3 ENDING 31 DECEMBER 2007

Number of new appeals 103

Number appeals in progress 55

Number of appeals withdrawn/invalid 15

Number of appeals determined 98

Dismissed 63 (64%) Allowed 35 (36%) (above figures include 4 split decisions)

C - 27