Der Briefwechsel Zwischen Ludwig Binswanger Und Eugen Bleuler Von 1907 – 1939 Im Spannungsfeld Von Psychoanalyse Und Psychiatrie in Der Ersten Hälfte Des 20

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Der Briefwechsel Zwischen Ludwig Binswanger Und Eugen Bleuler Von 1907 – 1939 Im Spannungsfeld Von Psychoanalyse Und Psychiatrie in Der Ersten Hälfte Des 20 Aus dem Institut für Ethik und Geschichte der Medizin der Universität Tübingen Direktor: Professor Dr. Dr. U. Wiesing Der Briefwechsel zwischen Ludwig Binswanger und Eugen Bleuler von 1907 – 1939 im Spannungsfeld von Psychoanalyse und Psychiatrie in der ersten Hälfte des 20. Jahrhunderts. Inaugural-Dissertation zur Erlangung des Doktorgrades der Medizin der Medizinischen Fakultät der Eberhard-Karls-Universität zu Tübingen vorgelegt von Susanne Apelt-Riel, geb. Apelt aus Cottbus 2009 Dekan: Professor Dr. I. B. Autenrieth 1. Berichterstatter: Professor Dr. G. Fichtner 2. Berichterstatter: Professor Dr. G. Buchkremer Inhaltsverzeichnis EINLEITUNG....................................................................... 4 Textgestaltung ...............................................................................................5 A. BIOGRAPHISCHE SKIZZEN ZU EUGEN BLEULER..... 7 UND LUDWIG BINSWANGER ........................................... 7 1. Eugen Bleuler (1857 – 1939) ....................................................................7 1. 1. Herkunft, Jugend- und Studentenzeit, erste Assistentenjahre, Studienreisen und Promotion (1857-1881) ................................................................................................ 7 1. 2. Die Rheinauer Zeit (1886-1898) ........................................................................ 22 1. 3. Wissenschaftliche Grundposition (1894) ........................................................... 26 1. 4. Direktor der Universitätsklinik Zürich "Burghölzli".......................................... 29 1. 4. 1. Antrittsvorlesung (1898) ........................................................................... 29 1. 4. 2. Hedwig Waser und Eugen Bleuler ............................................................. 33 1. 4. 3. Bleuler – Freud – Jung. Die Psychoanalyse am Burghölzli ...................... 35 1. 4. 4. Dementia praecox oder die Gruppe der Schizophrenien............................ 43 1. 4. 5. Klinikleiter und Therapeut ......................................................................... 47 1. 4. 6. Sozial- und Psychohygieniker: Bleulers Kampf gegen den Alkoholismus 53 1. 4. 7. Forensische Psychiatrie .............................................................................. 60 1. 5. 1. Die Naturgeschichte der Seele.................................................................... 62 1. 5. 2. Bleuler und die Stiftung Lucerna................................................................ 65 1. 5. 3. Abschiedsvorlesung.................................................................................... 67 2. Ludwig Binswanger (1881-1966) ...........................................................69 2. 1. Kindheit – Jugend – Studentenzeit (1881-1905) ................................................ 69 2. 2. Erstes Assistentenjahr am Burghölzli. Dissertation. .......................................... 84 2. 3. Entwicklung der Beziehung zu Eugen Bleuler................................................... 87 2. 3. 1. Entstehung von Vertrauen und Solidarität.................................................. 91 2. 3. 2. Klinische Zusammenarbeit......................................................................... 95 2. 3. 3. Wissenschaftliche Auseinandersetzungen und Kontroversen .................... 99 2. 3. 4. Gegenseitige Akzeptanz .......................................................................... 103 B. DER BRIEFWECHSEL (1907 – 1939) ....................... 106 Allgemeine Vorbemerkung.......................................................................106 1907 .......................................................................................................................... 110 1 1910 .......................................................................................................................... 112 1911 .......................................................................................................................... 120 1912 .......................................................................................................................... 127 1913 .......................................................................................................................... 147 1914 .......................................................................................................................... 162 1915 .......................................................................................................................... 186 1916 .......................................................................................................................... 196 1917 .......................................................................................................................... 220 1918 .......................................................................................................................... 224 1919 .......................................................................................................................... 234 1920 .......................................................................................................................... 246 1921 .......................................................................................................................... 267 1922 .......................................................................................................................... 281 1923 .......................................................................................................................... 305 1924 .......................................................................................................................... 316 1925 .......................................................................................................................... 346 1926 .......................................................................................................................... 366 1927 .......................................................................................................................... 371 1928 .......................................................................................................................... 383 1929 .......................................................................................................................... 422 1930 .......................................................................................................................... 434 1931 .......................................................................................................................... 451 1932 .......................................................................................................................... 458 1933 .......................................................................................................................... 473 1934 .......................................................................................................................... 493 1935 .......................................................................................................................... 501 1936 .......................................................................................................................... 502 1937 .......................................................................................................................... 505 1938 .......................................................................................................................... 511 1939 .......................................................................................................................... 512 C. ANHANG .................................................................... 515 1. FESTREDE EUGEN BLEULERS ZUM 75. JUBILÄUM DES SANATORIUMS BELLEVUE IN KREUZLINGEN ................................................................................... 515 2. Abkürzungsverzeichnisse......................................................................522 2.1. Allg. Abkürzungsverzeichnis ............................................................................ 522 2.2. Bibliographische Abkürzungen von z.T............................................................ 523 historischen Zeitschriften ......................................................................................... 523 2. 3. Psychoanalytische Zeitschriften erschienen in der Zeit von 1907 bis 1938..... 525 3. Quellen ..................................................................................................526 3. 1. Verzeichnis der benutzten Ordner im Binswanger-Archiv Tübingen............. 526 3. 2. Unveröffentlichte Quellen................................................................................ 527 2 4. LITERATURVERZEICHNISSE ................................... 528 4. 1. Eugen Bleuler Werke ........................................................................528 4.2. Ludwig Binswanger Werke................................................................541 4.3. Sekundärliteratur ................................................................................548 5. INDEX DER NAMEN................................................... 563 3 Einleitung Der Briefwechsel zwischen Eugen Bleuler und Ludwig Binswanger von 1907 bis 1939 ist ein eindrucksvolles psychiatriehistorisches Dokument, das zum einen die Charakteristika ihrer Kommunikation und ihrer persönlichen Beziehung widerspie- gelt, zum anderen eine Fülle von Informationen zum historischen, wissenschafts- theoretischen und geisteswissenschaftlichen
Recommended publications
  • Oskar Vogt: the First Myeloarchitectonic Map Of
    Communication • DOI: 10.2478/v10134-010-0005-z • Translational Neuroscience • 1(1) • 2010 • 72–94 Translational Neuroscience OSKAR VOGT: THE FIRST MYELOARCHITECTONIC MAP OF Miloš Judaš1 THE HUMAN FRONTAL CORTEX Maja Cepanec1,2 Abstract 1University of Zagreb School of The aim of this paper is threefold: (a) to provide the translation in English of Oskar Vogt’s seminal 1910 paper Medicine, Croatian Institute for Brain describing the first myeloarchitectonic map of the human frontal cortex, introduced by a brief historical review Research, Šalata 12, 10000 Zagreb, of Cécile & Oskar Vogt’s contribution to neuroscience; (b) to provide an annotated bibliography of major works of Croatia cortical cytoarchitectonics and myeloarchitectonics in the tradition of the Brodmann-Vogt architectonic school 2University of Zagreb, Faculty of (Supplement 2); and (c) to provide an annotated bibliography of major works of the Russian architectonic school Education and Rehabilitation Sciences, Department of Speech and which was founded by Oskar Vogt (Supplement 3). Language Pathology, Developmental Neurolinguistics Lab, 10000 Zagreb, Keywords Croatia Brodmann-Vogt architectonic school • cytoarchictonics • myeloarchitectonics cerebral cortex • Russian architectonic school • history of neuroscience Received 04 March 2010 © Versita Sp. z o.o. Accepted 20 March 2010 1. Introduction (the chief of the university psychiatric clinic) In the Spruce Mountains (Fichtelbirge) who firmly believed that mental disorders had region, there was an exclusive resort called Cécile and Oskar Vogt were pioneers of an anatomical basis. Oskar Vogt graduated as Alexandersbad, and in the summer of 1896 modern neuroscience who opened new a physician in 1893, and in 1894 obtained his Vogt accepted position there as a physician horizons and pointed to directions for future doctorate in medicine from Jena University, to (Kurarzt).
    [Show full text]
  • ELECTRICITY AS the MEDIUM of PSYCHIC LIFE Argument "Here in Front of My Eyes, in the Graph with All Its Peaks and Numbers
    ELECTRICITY AS THE MEDIUM OF PSYCHIC LIFE PSYCHOTECHNICS, THE RADIO, AND THE ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM IN WEIMAR GERMANY Cornelius Borck Argument The commodification of electricity since 1900 furnished the 'civilized' world with new attractions and revolutionized everyday-life with all forms of tools and gadgets; it also opened up – technically and intellectually – a new space for investigating psycho-physical interaction, reviving ideas of a close linkage between psychic life and electricity. The paper traces the emergence of this electro-psychological framework beyond 'electroencephalography,' the recording of electrical brain waves, to 'diagnoscopy,' a personality profiling by an electric phrenology. Diagnoscopy opens up a window on to the scientific and public cultures of electricity and psychical processes in Weimar Germany. It garnered enormous attention in the press and was quickly taken up by several institutions for vocational guidance, because it offered a rapid and technological alternative to laborious psychological testing or 'subjective' interviewing. Academic psychology and leading figures in brain research reacted with horror; forging counter measures which finally resulted in this technique being denounced as quackery. A few years later, the press celebrated electroencephalography as a mind reading device, whereas Berger's colleagues remained skeptical of its significance and the very possibility of an 'electroencephalogram,' before they adapted electroencephalography as a tool for representing various neuro-psychiatric conditions in patterns of recorded signals. The blending of holistic psychophysiology and electrical engineering marks the formation of an electric epistemology in the scientific as well as public understanding of the psyche. The transformations of electrodiagnosis, from Bissky and popular electric psychophysiology to Berger, are indicative of a larger cultural shift in which electricity changed its role from being the power source for experimental apparatuses to becoming the medium of psychic processes.
    [Show full text]
  • 2 Hans Berger's Long Path to The
    Brainwaves In the history of brain research, the prospect of visualizing brain processes has continually awakened great expectations. In this study, Cornelius Borck focuses on a recording technique developed by the German physiologist Hans Berger to register electric brain currents; a technique that was expected to allow the brain to write in its own language, and which would reveal the way the brain worked. Borck traces the numerous contradictory interpretations of electroencephalography, from Berger’s experiments and his publication of the first human EEG in 1929, to its international proliferation and consolidation as a clinical diagnostic method in the mid-twentieth century. Borck’s thesis is that the language of the brain takes on specific contours depending on the local investigative cultures, from whose conflicting views emerged a new scientific object: the electric brain. Cornelius Borck is Professor of History, Theory and Ethics of Medicine and Science and Director of the Institute of History of Medicine and Science Studies at the University of Lübeck, Germany. Science, Technology and Culture, 1700–1945 Series Editors Robert M. Brain The University of British Columbia, Canada and Ernst Hamm York University, Canada Science, Technology and Culture, 1700–1945 focuses on the social, cultural, industrial and economic contexts of science and technology from the ‘scientific revolution’ up to the Second World War. Publishing lively, original, innovative research across a broad spectrum of subjects and genres by an international list of authors,
    [Show full text]