Critical revision of the genus eucalyptus Volume 3: Parts 21-30 Maiden, J. H. (Joseph Henry) (1859-1925) University of Sydney Library Sydney 2002 http://setis.library.usyd.edu.au/oztexts © University of Sydney Library. The texts and images are not to be used for commercial purposes without permission Source Text: Prepared from the print edition of Parts 21-30 Critical revision of the genus eucalyptus, published by William Applegate Gullick Sydney 1917. 223pp. All quotation marks are retained as data. First Published: 1917 583.42 Australian Etext Collections at botany prose nonfiction 1910-1939 Critical revision of the genus eucalyptus volume 3 (Government Botanist of New South Wales and Director of the Botanic Gardens, Sydney) “Ages are spent in collecting materials, ages more in separating and combining them. Even when a system has been formed, there is still something to add, to alter, or to reject. Every generation enjoys the use of a vast hoard bequeathed to it by antiquity, and transmits that hoard, augmented by fresh acquisitions, to future ages. In these pursuits, therefore, the first speculators lie under great disadvantages, and, even when they fail, are entitled to praise.” Macaulay's “Essay on Milton” Sydney William Applegate Gullick, Government Printer 1917 Part 21 CXIII. E. cinerea F.v.M. In Bentham's Flora Australiensis iii, 239 (1866). FOLLOWING is the original description:— A moderate-sized tree, with a whitish-brown persistent bark, somewhat fibrous, the foliage more or less glaucous or mealy white. Leaves opposite, sessile, cordate ovate or ovate-lanceolate, obtuse or acute, mostly 2 to 4 inches long (or narrow lanceolate, which are alternate and much longer.—J.H.M.). Peduncles axillary or in short terminal corymbs, terete or nearly so, each with three to seven (or more.—J.H.M.) pedicellate flowers. Calyx broadly turbinate, about 2 lines diameter or rather more. Operculum conical, shorter than the calyx-tube. Stamens 2 to 3 lines long, inflected in the bud; anthers small but ovate, with distinct parallel cells. Ovary convex in the centre. Fruit semiglobose or subglobose-truncate, about 3 lines diameter, often slightly contracted at the orifice, the rim thin, the capsule very slightly sunk but the valves protruding. (B.Fl. iii, 239.) Normal form.—The normal form was long believed to be, as far as leaves are concerned, as defined by Bentham, as figured by Mueller in Eucalyptographia as E. pulverulenta Sims, and best known to New South Wales botanists as the “Argyle Apple.” Many years ago I found narrow lanceolate leaves on the Argyle Apple, thus giving the foliage a distinctly dimorphic shape it was not previously believed to possess. To summarise, it has bark, fibrous; timber, reddish, of inferior value for economic purposes as a rule, but it would appear that the timber of variety nova- anglica is the most durable of that of any of the forms. Further data are required as to the durability of the timber of all the forms. a. Flowers in threes. b. Leaves mostly broad. c. Yet lanceolate also in flowering branchlets. Varieties. 1. multiflora, var. nov. (See p. 7.) 2. nova-anglica, var. nov. (See p. 9.) Synonyms. 1. E. pulverulenta F.v.M., non Sims. (See p. 3.) 2. E. Stuartiana secunda of F.v.M. (See p. 4.) 3. E. pulverulenta F.v.M. var. lanceolata Howitt. (See p. 4.) 4. E. Stuartiana F.v.M., var. cordata Baker and Smith. (See p. 5.) Range. The species in its normal form occurs in northern Victoria, thence in New South Wales, in the southern mountainous country from about Tumut to Berrima, and thence in the Bathurst district. Connecting localities between the southern and western ones will doubtless be found. “N.S.W.—Lachlan River near Bathurst, A. Cunningham, also Lake George, Herb. F. Mueller” are the localities quoted in B.Fl. iii, 239. These are mentioned by Mueller in Fragm. ii, 70, for E. pulverulenta Sims, with which he had originally identified it. The locality “Lachlan River” is doubtless erroneous. Mueller's words in Fragm. are “In vicinia fluminis Lachlan oppidum Bathurst versus.” There is no evidence that the species has been collected on the Lachlan, and probably Cunningham's Wattle Flat locality is referred to. The Lachlan reference is apparently a mere slip of the pen. In the “Eucalyptographia” Mueller has the following localities for E. pulverulenta (F.v.M. non Sims). (1) Upper Lachlan, (2) Cox's River, (3) Marulan to Yass, (4) Berrima, (5) Lake George, (6) Castlereagh River (the above are New South Wales). (7) Lake Omeo, (8) Buchan River, (9) Between the Avon and Mitchell Rivers, (10) Towards Walhalla (these are Victorian localities). (1) Already referred to. (2) This is E. pulvigera A. Cunn. (E. pulverulenta Sims). (3), (4), (5) This is E. cinerea. I have not been able to confirm (6) for E. cinerea; the locality is farther to the north-west than that of any form known to me. Nos. (7) to (10) are all E. cinerea var. multiflora. Typical Form. New South Wales. Limekilns near Wattle Flat, about 20 miles northerly from Bathurst. Locally called “Peppermint.” Fine trees about 60 feet high. On the track taken by Allan Cunningham in April, 1823; see his “Journal of a route from Bathurst to Liverpool Plains,” as described by him in Barron Field's “Geographical Memoirs on N.S.W.” p. 133 (R. H. Cambage and J.H.M.). Now we come to southern localities:— Near Coal Mine, Berrima (J.H.M.); Jerrara, near Bungonia (H.J. Rumsey); “Blue Peppermint,” Wingello (J. L. Boorman and J.H.M.); Barber's Creek (H. J. Rumsey; “Blue-leaved Apple” Marulan (A. Murphy); “Turpentine,” “Messmate,” “Bastard Stringybark.” Typical of the forest growth on an extensive belt of country in the Jerrawa district. The country it grows in is useless for farming or grazing, as the soil consists of a barren sandy shale of Silurian age (Jerrawa Shales). See Proc. Aust. Assoc. Adv. Science xiii, 106 [1911] (A. J. Shearsby). “Silver-leaved Peppermint,” generally called “Turpentine, used for oil distillation. Fairly abundant in Gunning and Yass districts, and grows on very poor country along the small flats and watercourses” (G. H. Sheaffe). Yass to Bowning, 21/2 miles out, 1,600 feet above sea-level. (R. H. Cambage, No. 2,036); Yass (Revd. J. W. Dwyer). Tree about 30 feet, trunk matted stringy-bark up to branches, then strips off, near Gundaroo (Revd. J. W. Dwyer). About 40 feet; appearance of Stringybark. Bark ragged, fibrous, matted, reddish brown on trunk and larger limbs, then on smaller limbs coming off in strips and curling inwards, leaving creamy-white smooth branchlets.” Nelanglo Creek, near Gundaroo, also hills near Burrinjuck and Goodradigbee (Revd. J. W. Dwyer). Lake George (Revd. Dr. Woolls). Tumut, in varying degrees of glaucousness (E. Betche, W. W. Froggatt). Tumut, West Blowering Road and Lacmalac (J. L. Boorman and J.H.M.). Victoria. “Peppermint.” Fibrous bark up to 3 inches thick. Leaves all lanceolar. Beechworth (Falck). Affinities. This species, while it has not many synonyms as compared with some species, has a most complicated synonymy, and I will endeavour to make the situation clear. 1. With E. pulverulenta Sims (the “pulverulenta confusion).” In Fragm. ii, 71 (1860) Mueller, in identifying Bathurst and Lake George specimens (erroneously as we knew later) with E. pulverulenta Sims, says, he formerly distributed this species under the name E. cinerea F.v.M. (correctly as we knew later). This is the first mention of the name cinerea. In 1866 Bentham (B.Fl. iii, 239) described the plant E. cinerea F.v.M. under Mueller's manuscript name. Bentham goes on to say:— F. Mueller (Fragm. ii, 70) unites this (E. cinerea) with E. pulverulenta, of which it may be a variety, but as far as the specimens go, the differences in the leaf, in the size of the flower, and in the shape of the fruit appear to be constant. It may, however, be an opposite-leaved state of E. dealbata, and, possibly, as well as that species, a form of E. viminalis. In this passage Mueller was referring to E. pulverulenta, the plant known as the “Argyle Apple,” while Bentham had in his mind the true pulverulenta of Sims, of which E. pulvigera A. Cunn. is a synonym. In the “Eucalyptographia” Mueller again erroneously placed his E. cinerea under E. pulverulenta Sims, and repeated this in his Second Census. Later on I followed Mueller, but Messrs. Baker and Smith (“Research on the Eucalypts”) pointed out that E. pulverulenta Sims and E. cinerea F.v.M. were distinct, and that Bentham's views were correct. 1a. Then Howitt (Proc. Aust. Assoc. Adv. Science vii, 517 [1898]) founded his E. pulverulenta Sims (F.v.M.) var, lanceolata Howitt following Mueller as regards E. pulverulenta. He says:— 1. Typical pulverulenta is not found in Victoria. (As regards the broad-leaved form he is correct so far as the records go, but he was not aware that his “typical E. pulverulenta” may have narrow lanceolate leaves.) 2. Only that form is found in Victoria with opposed, elongated lanceolar leaves in the aged trees, and this he called E. pulverulenta var. lanceolata. He quotes the range of his variety as “Between the Pilot Range and Beechworth (F.v.M.), near the Ovens River (C. Falck), and in the Ovens district (D. Ingle). In Gippsland I have observed it near Buchan, at Providence Ponds (between the Avon and Mitchell Rivers), near Ostler's Creek, on the Walhalla Road, between Darlimurla and Mirboo North, at Monkey Creek between Sale and Port Albert, and at Moe.” He presented me with specimens of all he collected.