Donald Insall Associates Chester One City Plan

DONALD INSALL ASSOCIATES C h a r t e r e d A r c h i t e c t s , H i s t o r i c B u i l d i n g & P l a n n i n g C o n s u l t a n t s

CHESTER ONE CITY PLAN M a n i f e s t o f o r C o n t e m p o r a r y D e s i g n : M a y 2 0 1 0 a !b LC9{Çh Ch w /h b Ç9a th w!wò 59{LDb

a / / C / 5 W

/h b Ç9b Ç{ t

L!"

I$%$%$ % &'( ) $ % '

* ! ++, % &" - /%

. /%$ % !+/ 0""

1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

3 a t&

!&&!"

!&&!0 w" ! "

!&&!0 90" ( /!.9 +, !$ & "+$

D O N A L D I N S A L L A S S O C I A T E S C h a r t e r e d A r c h i t e c t s , H i s t o r i c B u i l d i n g & P l a n n i n g C o n s u l t a n t s

Bridgegate House 5 Bridge Place CHESTER CH1 1SA

Tel: 01244 350063 Fax: 01244 350064 Email: [email protected] Web: www.insall-architects.co.uk

BATH BELFAST CAMBRIDGE CANTERBURY CHESTER CONWY LONDON SHREWSBURY

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants

L!"

{&5$ !" a t6 t6 "%"6 & ! &"/( 56 W% I, a t6 t( / t+ {"/ D$ /5 a t6 a 5" !)

a í a

5 í L !

7% C'/

5"( ) % W

Ç% !"( &'%! " ! ""( &/ % " &" % ! % h // t8 C, $ % " % h // t " &! % !"( ( / ' '2" % +8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants *

L!"

/%% í ! /% /"6 %$% % $"/ /% w"6 % !+&! $/6 5, % :h // t;6 $! !+&( ! +( % %" % /% // ! ( ( ! +8

t % &" % ++! $ % %" &" /%; &%/" +( ! !!$ %, %/ "/ &"+! " !$ "( 6 ! , % 0 %/ " ' " &6 &$'! !$ 0""8

/% w"6 %$% " Dë! % &&! 5! L !"6 "%" , % &"( , 5$ , % %" '!$6 % &"8

Ç% & & % % ' &&! "( & % h // t , % &" ( &% )

° !!$ % %" +( = ° !!$ % &" "%$ ! && "$ /%; %" ( ! $= ° !!$ %, !+&( &" &/ &= ! ° $ %, % & &" ( / ' ( &+! % !! % "( 8

Ç% ( ! '2"+ % h // t , ' !+! %$% % ( $$ [" 5+&( C( , 5 ?[5C@ /%% í ! /%8 Ç% % / &$ !"( % , $! $, % /% ! " % , % .$%8 Ç% h // t , ( % / {$/ &" % ( !"( % [5C8 Ü & !& % / {$/ , ' % ""B / &$ !"( $! &$6 !+&( 6 ! +( !"

L &&$ % &6 5! L !" ?5L!@ %+ , 5! " "& , % % /% w" ( ! , % % ""/ ( ! Dë!8 5L! % "! , % ( / % & ! " ++! , % % t$ ! 5+&( a $( &" /%8 ! % , % , %( , %+ "! ! !&&!0 % !"( 8 ?!&&!0 @

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants .

I$%$%$ % &'( ) $ % '

! , 5 ! % "/ /% ! ( ( ! %! + ' "/ +/ &"! "%" ! !/8 C " ! + 5 % + ! & ( ! "%" % "/ ( $ ! !$ ( &8 Ç% 0" % ( & ! ( ( +/ , !/ ""!$ % 0&" % !+! ! % , / %/ &! % +( 6 ' ( ' ( &%! % ( " % ( & ( ( ++!8

C " && % &%/" &" % "/ " &!6 '!$ !/ ! "+ $ % " !/ 8 C + % '!$ ! &" ( % ( ( / $ + ( $ ! 0&"8

Ç% %+ ' ( ( & !"' % &%/" ! & "%"" % "/ , %"% $! % ( & ? {" *@8 {( % "%"" !! "/, !6 ( ( / ' &"+! ""$ , % % %" " ?%, + % ( / ' !!@ ! ( ( / &&/ ( ( ' 8 ! % ! ""! % % ( & ! !"+ "%"" /% $" !$ % %" +( 8 Ç%/ % !"+ &6 % " ! % !$ -/ !+! '!$ ! &"8

Ç% ( - , %"% % & !! %, % - 0"" ! !"+ " ' &&!6 ! , % &' %"! ! %, 0"" " " $ ' %( 5 /%; !+&( 8

!%$% "/ "$! "% /% "$/ :, !C"; "/8 C( % & %! "( % ! " "6 %$% % !+&( &"6 :, !C"; &" ! "%"8

I+$ !"! % 0&" % " & , 5$ ! % "/ ! % % 0&" , ! ' $ 6 - " % % 0&" -/ $ ! ( ( ' %$% % , 58

t % "/6 &"/ &%& ?' "/ 0"+/@ % ( ! & % , 6 $ $/ ! &"/ "+ ? % @8 h % & % "/6 &%& ( % !+&( ( % ( ! % "/6 ! %!/ $ % ( ! ( ( /8 ò % & $ '$ &"/ "+6 +$ 2$ 6 , 6 + %8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants 1

I$%$%$ % &'( ) $ % '

L " / % %+ ' ( ' !+&( , %"%6 '/ $ " %+ % % + 0"" !$ , %"% % "/ & ! , %"% !+8

Ç% & 5 - , %/ % % %&&! ! &( , / $ % !!8

Ç% & 5 '!6 %" +, ! "$ % % !$6 !+/ ! " %$% -/ ' +( ++ , ! $ "( ( ! :&/;8 Ç% && % & 6 , % '$ &"" ' "6 0( ! ! &" , %"% "( &/ ! ( 5 "( ( ! "% % % !+&( &" &!" "( % %$% -/8

I+$ ! && % & , " '/ $ , % &"/ &" ' /% ! % " , %"%6 5 $% ( 5 -8 L " , % / ( % &'( "! , % /$ " , !+&( ! , %/ % ( !( ! !$ $! 8

í ( !! % , $ " % % $+( "( ( ! !$ !! ! % %$% + $/ ! !+/ $( 5 &( !$ $ +8

Ç% & % ""! , % :a 5$; , %"% ( ! && &( $ $! -/ !$ , %"% " ' "$! +! "/ !! /%; !/ "% &/ '!$8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants 3

* ! ++, % &" - /%

* Ç

L ! !$ ! & , "" ! !+&( , % /% ( &+ &&" ! !! % & "%"" /%; ' ( , %"%6 !+!/ "( ' $+ - -/8

Ç% "/ /%6 &"/ % " 6 % ' % '2" ( ' && ! "+ ! + % /8 {( %+ ' ( 2 " %/ "( ( 6 % '/ +/ $8 Ç% &"& )

° /%) ! t % / ! ?h "' D3.@ .!$ 5$ t%& ° /% ) ! {!/ /+ 5! í L !" Ia {h D3E ° /% /+" Ç 5$ {( ) Ç, "& !/ ! Ü ' 5$ / % % /% , % % // í h + . 6 ! W E ° /% h // t . ! t( / w"( ( ! w& Dë!6 wIí [6 !"( 6 ! /í !/ W/ ° /% // / ! !&&"%6 /%" {!/ ?5 w&@ Ç/ ò$ C'

Ç%/ +/ !6 ! % !&% % /8 {!/ %( -" + ( "% ' % "%$$ $ ! !+&( ! "+ + % /8 ! $ 0( & % / "%& % L !/ %!! :í % +F;6 $$$ % % , ( ! &!& ""8 L $' % % &!( % , , $ "( &/ % && 0( 8

Ç% "" ? % F@ "%" % ' ! ! 9$% I$ % &!"! ( ' &"" $! "!$ :Ü !!$ t"6 I" ! !( ) t"& ! t""; ?9I W @8 í % /+ ! $/ % &" & / ! "( ( !8 ! / !"( $/ %+ $ % &"/ !"( 6 &"/ %" % $/ ( ! ! "%$8

w"( ( !6 $! a $( t ! %+ % ! " ' !&! '/ % "" {/ t$ D!"8

Ç% ( ! !/ '/ Ç/ ò$ % 0&! % "%" ! ' % "/ "!' ! ! G '/ G '8 Ü ( /6 % + % % / &" ! ' "! 8 I, + %& % &" !/ ( % "/

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants 7

* ! ++, % &" - /%

, ! "%"" , %"% $% " % " /%; - -/ "/8 Ç% , $ !" , % '+! ' % "%""6 % , / , %"% %/ "/ &"+! ' ! %6 ' %, %/ %! ' ( , !+&( , %"% " && % "%" % "/8

/% "% &( & %" /8 h !'! && % , %"% ( ( % w( &! ' % "% +! ( ( / '- &!8 !- '$ % E% "/6 % !+&! "6 ! " !+& ( $$ ""8 í % % !+&( % + " % ( 5, !$ , %"% " ' !+! ( !/ ', $! /8 Ç% "%$" " % / ( "% + ' /%; & ! $ ! $""8

! &"& % ( ' ! % % "%$" + / ( ' &"! ! "'! &&& , /8

" Ü $

Ç% "/ % +!" ' w( , % &"& $% $ ! % ( " ?&/$ "! %&@ "8 Ç% " , 0!! %, ! % + % {0 &!6 ! % , % & , % ( !+ &!8

C ( / " % , %& " ', % "!6 &"/ % $ w( ! % !$ "/! , % ! '!$ !+&( / !! '/ +/ & "/! ! ( ?/@ '' !+&(

Ç% " % ' '! , % % !+&( 0+ ë" '' % "/ 0&6 %, + % !" !/ ! " ', % ( ! 0 ( &" " $" "%"" % "/ ! %! ' !!6 ' %"! , % &'8

{

! ! &+/ % & " /% &!"! % "#$ ! % "#$ C % ( % w( 8 Ç%6 $% , % % , ! 0 0

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants E

* ! ++, % &" - /%

C!%( { ! % %, ! 0 [, .!$ { %+ ( ! % &"& % "/ % & !/8 5+&( % !! " % ! % 6 , % $ %( "( ( !$ &( ( +8 L& % +' $ % ( !6 ' % "! + ( !( ( &" % $% $ ! & % ( %$% !$ % :'"5!; 8 90( & % Y$ {6 I {6 /( ( % {6 b , $ { ! { í '$%8

Ç% %! "$/ " % , 5$ / ! &$, / C 8$8 D! [8

L % ( !+ &! ! 6 % &( ( & !$ , % &"& 8 ! ( ! % , % %$% ! + ! % , % $ & !+&( 8 { , % % 0"& "+" """ '!$6 % '!$ % $ , % ! ( &$8 .!$ % $ !! ' ! % $ & "%$ !$ &"" ++! ! 0&!!8 Ç% $ ( % '!$ , %"% %, +!" % $ ( ' 6 , % !+&( 8

D/6 % % "/ % %"%/ " ! -/ "( ( " '!$ , ! % %"%/ 8

Ç% % $ " '!$ , """ C % "%!6 { t6 { a /; ! I/ Ç/ "%"%6 ! !( + $ C % Ç, I6 % "6 % ( 5 ! ( &+ !"8

L ( & % , !+&( , % % 0$ '" , % % , $/ + % - "6 %, $ !" ', "+" ! "( ( " ! $! " ""!$ " %$% ! ""8

% {

Ç% ( 5$ "%"" % &"& !$ /% % w, 8 Ç% & !+&( % & % 9& " ' , % " ! "8

Ç% $ %/ % 0" % , % % % "/ % / ( !+ &! % "( ( " & % ( , "% % ( "% , !& " $ ! !$ &"8 Ü ' ? , $@ + '/! % , 6 ! ' " ( $ %/ !&! % , '!$

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants D

* ! ++, % &" - /%

!' % $ '/ %+$ ! !$ &" , +8 í %% % !+$ % /( ( % $, $"/ , !'/ &! "6 %, + % "" % /( % ( % % ++! % & !/8 Ç% ( !+&( % ( ! & % ( + %&&$ (

Ç% & &&/ +""/ +!" % "/ % w, ! & ! ( & % % "( "6 $ ! ( $( ( , 5 ! , %"% & !2! , % !$ ( +'8

L 5/ % % ( "" , ! ' &"! % % "/ , % ! "( " 2"6 ' , % &&& % ( / ' "!!8

& Ç

L &! , %+ % "( ( " ! " & , "% % '!$ , ""! , % ( / 6 ! % $/ , !6 % '/ ( "% ( / ?, % % ! @ ' % ( "( ( " 8 í % % +'/ "%& ' % ( "/$ $! , % % ! & ! !, , ""&! ! , % ( 8 Ç% %$% && !/ ! ( &"/ , % '!$ , ""&! & ' +$ ! !$8

a "/6 % "%$ ! + "( '! , % % $ "5 " %$% !/ ! ( 0! %+ ! "$/ % +" && 8 !%$% % w, !+&( !! % + "( ( " ?' ! & ( &@ % ( "!' ( ! && $/8 Ç%/ $/ , + "( ( "/ '" ( ! ""6 !$ "&'/ "8 ' %/ " &+! ! " &( 8 I, + ( 0! " ' &'( " $/ ! ( $( 8

L ( & % , % 0$ !+&( % + 0&! '/ &+/ "$$ % 6 '% , / &( $ % % '!$ &" !/ +' ! ( +$ % "/ " ! "$ % $ !/I+$ " "8

1 ?8 .wh í b 6 !!, ?!@ ) Ç% w, /%6 9$% I$ DDD &83@

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants

* ! ++, % &" - /%

' ù

! /&" ' " &! % &&/ ! ( $!6 & ( ""& $& $%8 Ç% % ( ' !+$ C , $ "( & %6 %$ "( ( " "6 %$ 0& ! ( &+$ && " &"%8 Ç% ! ! " ( ! +( , % % ! G % "/6 "$ % + +/ ! "%8

! /% 0( &/ % ! - $/ C % $ - ! % "6 % % & 6 % '"% % "5 ( 56 %( 5 $&! $% ! 8

{( % ! %+ % "/ $% ?8$8 $ !6 '6 @ '+ +( $" 8 I, + ( / ( 6 ! ( 8 L , ! ' !' % G$ &$6 % " !+&6 ! & &&&8

) h

/% , ' $ "5 & &" , % % " % , 6 &"/ , % % $ w( 8 Ç% !' "-" % &0$ & ! % "( ( " & !/ ! 8 !$ % /&" ( !+ " , % ! + %$% ! " ' 5& '!$ % $ " !$ 8 Ç% ( & &" / " , ( 5 &'" ( '/ C / "" , % $ "+" "8 9, % & &" " ( , % %/ " & '! "% ( 8 {( & &" ( / ( $( 6 , % % , ( % ! 6 ' % ! ' "! %, ! ' '"8 /% %! , / %8

Ç% ( & /%; %" " &+!! '/ % $ +, ! '/ '$ +, ( % "$ , 8 Ç% $ &" % "%! - "- &"" " C % ( " " ! % $" % "" - % E% "/8

L ( ' ! %, + % % $% ' +( % ' ( &/ %$% % "" '!$ && !+&( 8 Ç% $+ ( & % ' +( 6 ! '" % 0!! !+&( &! % &

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants

* ! ++, % &" - /%

&"/ !( % %" ! "( ( " +( % "/8

L ! &+ % ' I '' !" ! % %"%/ &" , %"% % ++! ( & % % &+ & &" &" % "%"" !"'! ! !$! &" "8

h && %! ' 5 , %+ &' % '( ! "6 + ( &/6 &!$ ( !+&( "+/8

í % % & % &+ & "( '! , % % + !" &'" & ? "/@6 & &" " " &5$ , % % "/ "( ( ! &( ( 8 5" ! + &5$ &+ $! ! /!8 Ç% % " % "/ %+ '"( !( ! '/ " " &5$ % !( % $ +( 8

Ç% "$ +( " " &5$ &+ %! ' ! & , % % % !+&( &'" & "8

) ë+

! ! % ( ' & &" % % %$% , % /% "/ " ( 6 ! , % % 0"& % &"& % %$% %( + - , 8 Ç5 $% % " ( % $ +, $! + - "!6 ( / '$ ( ! + & ! !, % 5/ 8

./ , / "! %, + % :&; +, % , ! ! /8 D( & !''/ D ( b%$6 D! [ ( { í '$% ! / { ( [, .!$ { 0( &8

! +! + % $! +, !, % ( % w, 6 ! % , 5 ! % , &+! "% +/ +, , % ! ! % "/8 ?w! /% // í ) /+ a $( t '/ 5! L !"6 a / E@8

L ( " /6 ! "" && !+&( " &5$ &&6 % $% " $! + + + % ' , 5!8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants

* ! ++, % &" - /%

L $ && , !+&( ( & 5/ +, ! % " $! $ &"& +, , % !! :&; ! +, %! ' ( ! ! %"!8 .! &$ , %"% $+ $! +$ ! +, %! ' !8

, .

Ç% '/ " "! &" $+! '/ % ( % &$ ( ! 6 , % ( " % E% "/ % & $+! '/ % "%$ ( / ! ( ' ""8 Ç% "%$ &%! % ( / '/ , %/ " , % +!$ ! " $ &"8 Ç% % $ & "! , % """ ( / '!$8

Ç% !+&( 6 , ! '/ ! "" ""6 % '! !$ " + $ +( 6 ' / % &' , / 5 & , % % , &"" ! ! , % "/ $ , +'6 , % ( "! ' $$$!8

Ü % D% "/ % $+( '!$ "! ' "! , % "%"% "+" '!$ C % ( 56 % "6 % , % ! % D + ( ( 0( &8

! "%"" !$ &"& !' % % $ +( ?! %" $ &@ '!$ +! &" , % &'" "+" "8 5( " " '!$ %!6 % "& " % +( 6 ( / % &"& %! ' , ! '!$8

. D $

Ç% &+ " !" " ! +( 8 I, + %! ! ! "%"" % :$; !+&( 8 D ! ' " & G8 /%; ( !+ 6 ( / ( !+ ( , '!! '/ , ' !& '$$ & $% $ % 8 Ç% ( % &/ '!/ , $% $ % ! %6 %/ !! ' !+&! !+!/ % & ( &/ , &/ , 6 &$ $' ! % ! % +8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants *

* ! ++, % &" - /%

Ç% ( !+&( &!" % %/%( " ! '/ "! , %"% , , ! , %"% "%"" % "/ "8

! ! + ! & !" , / ( % "6 ! ! $( ! % $ '"( ( !8 I, + , % $ &"&' $ +! %! ' "$! / !+&( 8

0 . [

t !+&( ! !/ %+ ( % +6 &"/ % &"& , %$% ( ! &+/8 h "-" % % % , !+&! ! % ( && , % % " % %" "/6 '% "( ( " ! ! ' % '"5 % &+( 8

Ç ( "/ ! ' "%" !+&( %! ( / ' ' % '"5 % &+( 8

L !" 5 ' % '!$ ( , % $ %( &" '!$ / 8 /%; % ( & % "/ "" ( C ! '$ ( /6 ( ' ( $ ! ! '$ '"5, 58 ! +!" &" 6 /% %/ & ""+/ w( %$% / ( !+6 ( !+ &! 7% "/ ! '"5, 56 7% "/ ( ! % "/8 I, + % +( &" % ( / 0( & % ++ % &" / ! ( 8

!%$% , / '+6 % ( ! "" ( -/ "" "( '8 Ç% " ' '/ ""+ %$% ! %" &! 6 -/ ""! ( % D% "/ /%6 % !' ( 0! ( &&/8

h % ++ % &" ( /6 , !! " ' & ! "+"$8 I, + /% , &"/ %+$ , %/ "6 "!$ % 55 í ( ! ( , ( ! "%" "!$ % ! W% 5$8 5$ %! &! 5, !$ +" ( 6 " ! ( ! % , ' % +/$ & '! ! "+"$

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants .

* ! ++, % &" - /%

, /8 I "! - %&&/ "! $! ( /6 '"5 ! " , 5 ! ( ' ( $ " 5$ ! "+"$ "8

Ç% $ ( 0! ( &" "%"" /% ! !! % + 8 L "! , &+! !$ " !+&( 6 ' % ( &% ( ' '! && !!$ % && ! ( 8

" 5

D/ % '! ! ( "" !$ % , %"% "/ 0& % % % &! , %"% %/ 6 ! ! % $$ &!8 Ç% % ' /% , %"% % ' ' ( '"$ % & ""+ $6 &"/ !$ &! "!" ! &&/8 {""+ " ( % w( &! %$% % , / %+ "'! "% ! +! &/8

/% %! ( + , ! , % "!" $ !$ $$ , %"% % ' !/ ! , %"% , !! , / +! " % %" '" % "/8

Ç% + % % , ! :!$; % $ "! /%; "%"" +!" % " % ( % !( % "/; &%/" ( ! ( +/ %" "!8 C( % E% "/ , ! %, + % %! % !$ % " % "/ '"( "$/ $"8

9/ !$! &" , Ç%( I; " "( &0 ! % '/ D+ .!$8 I , , ! $ % "/ , , $" "%$ % , / % "/ , !6 &$ & $ , %! +%" ! "'$ ( $%! ! + ! "( ( "8

L % E% ! D% "6 ! "! $6 % & ( ! "( ( " &( " ! ( " % % , ! % $ ( / % w, "( ( " &( 6 ! % "( & '! ( 8 Ç% $ %, """ ( 0 D$ ! D%" "! $ ( 6 ( / 0%'$ %$% !! !$ ! , 5( %&8 L ( " $ , "!

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants 1

* ! ++, % &" - /%

" + % '$$ & !"$ ! "-6 ' % ( 2/ ( ! $ & ! % +/ ( !8

Ç% &+! !$ " "( &/ +6 , % % %/%( & , !% %! ' ( ! ' , $ !( !$ , % % %/%( 8

Ç% , 5 W% 5$ +! " % "/6 , % + $ " !+&( , !+! w, $8 9+/, % % !$ -/ %$% ! "( %& % !8 ."5 !$ "" ! %$%/ , 5! 6 ( ' ( $ ' ! , ( '!8 h +/$ % $ ( , 5 % / "( %& ! !$ , %"% , ! " !/8

h " / % %$% !$ ! &"/ % ! ! & %+ '"( %'8 I, + /% / &" , % % &&/ " ! !+&( 8 Ç% ! , &''/ ' ! ( 6 ' ( $+ ! "( ' "( &/ ( , %"% %+ % , "% " ! "8

! ! ' , !+&( /% %! ' ""! % %$% !!6 , % " "! ! !$ ! &8

% .

! , % " /% " "$/ "( &0 , ' +"$ " C , 6 &&6 !"6 "" , /6 "" '06 ( '0 "8 Ç%/ $&! ! % %!$ :;6 , ! , %"% , ( & % '" + !$8 L % ë" 6 &"/6 , % % ( $! +"$ '!$ % ( " "! , % % , !$! , % ' ! "!"8 L!! " / "( & , , '!$ ! $% % % +" "6 , % +' "! % % % "( & ! , "( &' , % % "8

í % % $$$ % ( " !"+ % !&&!6 ! % $ + !$ +" " ?( %6 ( '06 %/! ( 56 2" '06 @ $/ ( "% , ! ( !!!6 ' , % " ( 5! 0"&8

a "% % " $$ ! !/ '$ &"! ! &"( 8 Ç% !" ! +"$ $6 , ! !$

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants 3

* ! ++, % &" - /%

&&, 5 " %+ ( &" %" " ! "%$" /8

!$6 % '!$6 % ""&" !! ! , %"% "( &( % %" +( %! ' ""&! , % "/ "% $""8 [" /%&"" !$ +' " ( %! ' "$!8

& {$

I"/6 /% % ' 0" 0( & "/ , %"% ( '! $! '/ &"&)

° Ü "/ "! "" ( ° 5 ' !+&( !"$ & ! " " ° Ü ! , '! & ( ' ° w ! ( !" %" " % % 0"+ ,

Ç% &"& %$%/ & % - '/6 ! /% %! " '/ "'$ ! ! '/ ( &/$ % ! % ( $$ &"& & ( , !$8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants 7

. /%$ % !+/ 0""

. /

I+$ ! !$ !!6 ! !! /%; 0$ - %& !! % , %"% ( $ $ % &!" %$% -/ '!$8

Ç% " , %"% ( / "' & "( " 5 " %$% % , % !+&( &"6 ( '$ %$% % "( & ""6 ! ( / ++ % , % $ & % !+&( &"8

Ç% , $ % 5/ &"+! :"%$;= % ( / % $ 6 &"/ &%& % ! "( &"6 ! " ( / % C &"" "%$8 L , % $ %, + % % /!.9 / " ! !" % &&! !" ( &! '/ " " ' % & !$ 0""8

% t 4 +

Ç% ( &&"% % '( ( && &$ ( &&"8 í %% !'/6 '/ ! &&" &&/ / % $ ( ( ( ( ( ! "% , / % ( / ' !" & ! " - &! - ""8 Ç( " " % ( &" % &"8

a ( ' % !+&( ( $( ( !" % %/ &! , % ( , %"% "6 ( "6 %, % +$ "%" "% % &&+ '! % ( ! " ' :, $%; % !'8

Ç% '"% &$ "! &! "$ " "/ "( 8

% " 5

Ç% ( &! '!$ !+&( !+&( " 0! / + !"!8 5$ % ( % & % &" ( / "%$ "!'/8 t&/ ( / ' ! 6 "( " ""( " ( / "%$6 "" ! % " ( / "%$ ! &$ &"/ ( / "%$8 L &$ % % % '2"+ % &2" !+/ ( ( / ! "!'/ ( % % && , % &! % !+&( 8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants E

. /%$ % !+/ 0""

í % % 0!! &" ( / , ( &+( "( '/ $+$ % &&/ % !$ %, !!6 -/ &+! && , !! ! !$ 8

! &" 0( & % &" "" , % % "%$ !$ ( 6 + , % % ( ++! !+&$ % $ '!$ !$ ( &/! ( % "" $8 Ç% ( & % &%!$ &&+! !$ ! !+&$ , !$! ! '-/ !$ % "" &" " % ' 8

% Ç

í % $ % & "( & "%( , $/ "( ( " 6 !! % , ( ' %!! & , % % !+&( &" , %"% " %+ !+ ( &" "$! ! "!8

Ç% $+( % %! &"/6 & 0 &6 &! & % &$ /( 8 b '/6 ( " !" ( 5$ %+ ' ( &!8 I, + % ( ( % !" ( 5$ &" % '"( ( "( &0 %$% % & &"/6 % "$ "( ( ( " ! ( , !/ " &'" &8

Ç% % ' & &$ &$ !&( " 0& "!$ "+ "8

h "( % % && "! + &$ &&" " ' "! ( ! ( !" '/ % ! !% ( '8

L $' % % &" " % $ &/ % ! % ! ( &% !" ! "$ "( % % , $ " $!8 h % % ( &% !+/ !+&( &$ "( $ % ! % "- , "% ! , $ "%$ &" !%&8

Ç% & &" ! 6 , % % $ $% $+ &" "%( % & !+ , % % &" +( +' C , %"% " & !$ ! "" ( ! & "( 8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants D

. /%$ % !+/ 0""

% % a $5 6 {

Ç% $ "( " ! " "( % & , %"% "& ( "% ( !/ , % % !+/ ( ' -' "( % % , %"% / -+ " ( ""8 Ç% +( &! % ! ', '2"+ ! '2"+ "8

L % , ! &$ ! !+&( %6 % , %"% &%/"/ ( '6 &!" -' "( " ! %+ &"!" + %" 2!$( ?, %"% ! ' $!! ( / & &@8 ! 0( & % % !"/ % & ( !!! %$%, / &+ ! !( $ % % % ( ( $+ , %"% " &!" ( + ! +%" !( ! "%( 8

L"/ % 5, !$ , % :""&'; %"/ ! !+ 8 Ç% "5 "/ ""&! "%" $$ ( / ' /( &( "/ "%$ , % "/6 ( / ' +!" $( &( "$/ , ! !+$" ' ( -! C % " ( / ! , ! % "& % !/8

! % % ( & / , %"%6 ! , " &!" +/ /$ ' ( "% ( -/ &"% , %"% ( / % 8

Ç% &"%6 !! , %"% ! ( % &"" % ' ! % %! ' ""&' , % /%8

L " "( " +( 6 ! , % $ "5 "!" !$ % &&/ !+& !++ &'/ !$ ( &6 &$ !+ :% /( ; $/8 Ç% : , % / , ; &&"% &6 ! :, "( ( !( ; "( 8

Ç% ! ' +! %$% &$6 && !$ '6 ( &" " ! , $ ""& ( " 8

5$ ! "" ( %! ' -! '"5 &"" &$ $!" "% !+&( I&$ ' !$ '8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants

. /%$ % !+/ 0""

% & Ç $

[" % $ &&" ++$ ! '!$ % $6 "+ ! &" !$! " -! '/ , 6 '/ " &"/ '/ $! &"" " $ !+/ '!8 Ç% &" $ , % /% %" "/ &&" % /+" Ç6 % /+ ! !!+/ /( ( 6 9$% I$6 {"/ % t" !" .!$ ?{t!.@6 % ë" {"/6 D$ {"/ ! !" a ( "/8 !"%$ ! % , % % "" ""! , % % %" +( ( / !+8

Ç% !+" ""$ % %" ' % "/ % 0!/ , &!8 I, + '/ " % ""! , % &( !$6 &"/ "( &/ !$ % ' +( ! &!8

Ç% % % % , %"% , ! !+ % && , % % !+/ '! ! % % &&" % &+ "%( & % " "% !+&( "( &8

% ' t$ 3

! $ , % % Ü Y6 ! &%& &"/ ( && !+&( && ! ! /% ( , / $ +/ ! &'" "( ( 8 í % ( % &" &&& % &&! "6 % ( "% !" % &" !$8

Ç% & 5 " %$% $ , && "( ( 6 !" ! !" " "! "" &% ! "/ +6 ! !" & &$ !&( 8

í % % , / - /% % &&!" & ! &'" "( ( ! %+ $+ 8 Ç% ( / ' , !+! ( " ' % !"/ $+/ % !( $ " % &( $ ! &!"$ , !+&( 6 !"$ 5 5$ ! "$ % !"/ & , % % ' %, ' &'"/ ""&' % &8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants

. /%$ % !+/ 0""

/% % $ & ( % "!( " "( ( /6 ! '" &" +( $ %" ''/8 í % %" !!$ ' "( ( !!6 % &&" %" &&"% !+&( ! "! % " && !$ "( ( /8

% ) L

!/ &% % !$ ! !+&( &" / "/ ! "$ % "( & :, 5 &$;8 ! "/ !/( " "" "%$$ " ! "( " +6 "%$$ " ! "%$$ &8 h + ( / / % "" +! ' ( , %"% % , "/" ! '"( &&& 8 { "%$ % '!$ "! %$% ( ( 2 6 !+&( 8 !/ +, % &" , "/ , % "$( '!$ ! +/$ $ % "/"8 h +! % % 0 ( , 5 $6 &$ $!" ! &"/8

!/ ( & "%$ !" &"/ ! ""( ( ! % " % / ( % $"/ 0$ &$ $( 6 h !6 &( ! ++$ &" , %"%6 %$% &%& % %!! ( +, " %+ $ " !+&( / "( 8 í % % "( & $ % ! "%$ &"/6 !! % " %!$ ! $ -!8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants

1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

% %" +( 1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

Ç% , % ( 6 $ ! $!" ! % ++! % !+&( &" !/ +' % &'" ( 8 Ç% &" "+! $ ( "%" !$ &" % %" +( ( $$ % !+&( &"8 a "% ( % , %"% / -! ( ! ' % , %"% % !+&( -/ !$8 I, + % / % [' $+( % - -/ ! + "$ $! &" + ! ! '6 , ( , !/ "$!8

Ç% , $ 0" ( &'%! !"( % - &( $ 0"" !$)

Ia D í / t ! t 5/a { /[D / [ D !

%í / t () a )**+ D -

Ç í / t D L - "L í / t ! t$

Ç !$ % , % % !" t + % &" '$ "!!8 Ç% !"( "! ( ' $ , %"% %+ +" ( &+$ !$ -/ , % % "0 % !/ ! %$% $! $+( + !" ( 5 %+ ( &" $ $"6 " %6 !+& ! "( ( 8

h &" +" )

"{ # $% & 9 -

!" &( ! ! % '2"+ "! C ° !+&$ ' , / $ -/ &"6

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants *

1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

° $+( , 5$ , % [! "%+ %$% -/ !+&( 6 ° ( &+$ && ! $ -/ &" "+" !6

%{ # $% ' 9 -

Ç% " "!6 ( &/6 '2"+ !+&$ , &$ &"/ % %" +( , %"% % , ' ! , % % &'" tt{ 1 ! &&$ $!" ? ', @8

%{ # $% ( t -

! ( & '2"+ , % % " % :9"$$ &'" ++( %&$ % + % ! % !$ !+! "%( ;8 Ç !$ % ! %$% % , "( $! " &$ &"/8

%{ # $% ) 9 # -

!" , % % '2"+ "! "$$ " % :" -/ &" ( '; % " &$ ( , 56 "$ 2 , 5$ ! % t$ t( " !$( 6 ! !+& ! &( % ' " +$ "%+$ -/ &" &"/ , % &+ " !+&8

%{ # $% * { -

Ç% " && $%$ !$ && " %6 % &'" " ! !+&6 "$$ %/ %$ 0& ! $ % "" &$ "( ( %+ % 5 ! && %/ !8

t$ &"/ $ % %" +( % ' "! $ $8 Ü a "% % 5/ + $ , "! t$ ! t"/ $!" !"( ttD 1 ! ttD 38 t/ % $ % í ! / t" !" t % $!" ! &"/ % ' &!! ! ! t$ t"/ {( 1) t$ % I" 9+( ?!& @6 &&! '/ % D !" !"( &!"! % ( ( 8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants .

1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

Y/ " , % % !"( , %"% ( !$ %" , )

& t # t+ { , t # - . I 9 ! &00! Comment [a1]: National Planning Policy Framework has replaced PPS5 – need to review sections 5.2 & 5.3 as a th [L/ò I9', w9D Lh b ![ !b 5 [h /![ t[!b b Lb D !ttwh !/I9{ result.

I9 ' w 3 4

"$ - "$ "$

I9 '( ! I 6

th [L/ò I9), Lb Ch wa !ÇLh b w9v Ü Lw9a 9b Ç{ Ch w !tt[L/!ÇLh b { Ch w /h b {9b Ç !CC9/ÇLb D I9wLÇ!D 9 !{{9Ç{

I9) [ 6

th [L/ò I9*, th [L/ò twLb /Lt[9{ D Ü L5 Lb D ÇI9 5 9Ç9wa Lb !ÇLh b h C !tt[L/!ÇLh b { Ch w /h b {9b Ç w9[!ÇLb D Çh ![[ I 9wLÇ!D 9 !{{9Ç{

I989 [ Ç

Ç ""( &/6 ! ( &/$ % t$ t"/ {( % , $ $!"6 ?$/ &&! '/ 9$% I$@ , !)

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants 1

1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

' tt{ , t # - . I 9 , I 9 t # t D ! &00!

w+ " "!)

%t+ I9', w # # .

:: 6

v + -

:; Ç D - í / t /[D ")**+$ I w

:96

:< I I Ç -

t+ I9*, t+ # # . - - # . #

"b : , # ;

=* t I989 +9 I9(* ! 4

( Ç ) Ç : [

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants 3

1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

; Ç 9 Ç < ë 8 D = Ç

{

=( 5 9 I /!.9 C 4 . / 4 b 5 I ! ")**($B D Ç . ")**8$B . / Ç ")**<$-

Ç% $!" ! &"/ !"( -!6 '$ $/ "& ! ' % %$% +8 Ç%/ ! , % '2"+ ! -( $ ! " % !+/ ( "%( -! "%+ %( 8 Ç% !+/ '!/ /!.9 , & &/ & % - "!$ % & % &" ! % &'" +/ ( + % !+&( 6 % !!$ -/ ! '!$ %" 8

& % b ". # / ; , b : . = . % 9 #. I # > /!.9 $ - &00

t$ . ! 1

Ç. b - ! %í -

Ç 6 %L Ç -

5 %L " $ Ç

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants 7

1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

h % - Ç -

h Ç

Ç Ç " $ 3

t -

Ç. w#. ! . Ç Ç h 3 % - % - 6

/ 3

Ç -

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants E

1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

C :< :8

/ 6 %Ç 9

Ç -6

%Ç

° Ç B #

° Ç

° 5

° í

° I

° {

° D

° I

° {

° L -

%! # Ç !

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants D

1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

5 3 L 3 3 C . 3 Ç Ç 4

° I D L D I D ! D / D

° I D ! D ! D í D

° I D L D

° I D L D 5 D

° í D I D L D ! D I D

° L D L D

° I D L E 5 D

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants *

1 D+( '2"+ ! $!"

° í D L D

° L D 5 D 5 D 5 D

Ç% " && && %& ( 5 % &" ( '2"+ ! "&' & 8 {"%( " ! %! ' 2!$! $ % , "! " % &"8 L % && $+ &+ & % " % 5/ % % 5/ ' , , ! ""8 w % ! % "; "% & '/ , %+ $ ( &" % %" "%"" % '!$ ! $'/ %+ $ + % ( / 6 !' %/ 8

181 /!.9 % %& !$ ( ! !$$ , % % "0 % " ! % %" +( 8 !( $ % % . / Ç 8 , %"% &&"% "0 !$ &'/ & /" &"8

183 ! % + /!.9 % &( ! % 5 w+ &" , / $ !$ -/ , % ( $$ &&8 Ç% !+&6 "%" ! % ( , % % & &&& % $$ & !" ' % !+&( % !$8 Ç% /( & ! % ( &$ &" ! /8 I, + &+ +' ( !$ ( 6 ""( ! & +, 8

187 Ç% !"( :{ + 3 3 :/!.9 "00.;< ?{ !&&!0 @ +, % "+$ !$ +, &8 L && % % "+$ % % , 9$! - $%8 :t" a ; % & , %"% "+ % , % % $+( " $6 ' , % , " % %+ ( " & %/ % % % $! "( &! , % , %8 Ç% &" /% % /í !/ %/8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants *

3 a t&

3 a !b LC9{Çh twh th {![{

Ç% !"( % % + & 6 !!6 % &" "%"" /% ! ( % &'( "! ( $ % &8 L % $ $+( '2"+ , %"% !"! , ! -/ % ' +( $ , % $!" ( + - %, "%+ %( 8

Ç% & % &" , / , ! /%6 , %"% +"! "% , / % & " !! ! !/ , % % ( ! ' "( ( &"8

L ! !!$ % $ % &&6 , %+ ! % ( :( ;8 Ç% , ! % ' !! )

% -

Ç% " % '$ , % ( + ( , ! '/ ( ( / % 5/ 6 "% , %"% , ! '/ ( &&! &"/8 Ç% !"( , ( & / &"/ / &$ &" ' !! ' ! ( "! & % &$ !" ( 5$ &"8

{ =

"L $ - + - ? + ? $ @ ? /. ° $ . # A ° . : . $ -$ # . .#. $ + =

! Ç 4 $ $ $

! t'" , % - ! -( $! "( &/ !$ ! ' "!6 "% % % '"( ( 0&"8

! .!$ , 6 !+& ! " ! ' ( ! , % &( ( , %"% $! !$ ! 5 , %& !$ , % % '!$ '8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants *

3 a t&

!* !"%" ! !$ %! ' "$! %$% % $!" ! % &( 0( & & % %$% + !$ ! &"( 5$8

!. Ç% , % ( 5 &$ !" ! ' %&! !! ! + $! !$ "% % " ' !/ &( !8

!1 C, $ % ! &$ &"/6 % '2" -/ %! ' ( / ( '!!! $" &$ !"( 6 [" 5+&( C( , 5 ! % {&&( / t$ D!"8

!3 t'"/ ( !6 &"/ % " &6 ! ' "$! $+ &+ ( $ ' !$ & ! !+&( &&8 Ç% ( "%( !$ ! ' / "!!8

. t + + 8 / 4

. ! & ( " "+ /%; %$ ""!" , % % &+ "% ! !!8

. ! &6 ' &"/ "%" ! '!$ !$ ( %+ &" , % &"" "%"" /%; ' +( 8 ?b ) ( / % !! {" *@

.* ! & ( % % &"" - ! -( % "! !+&( &&6 ( ! '/ % + /%" ! !( ! % , &"" /8

.. t& !+&( / $" G ( %+ & ( ' !$ % % , ! "0 ! % &'" ( &&&/ !!!8

.1 ! *!( + ( ! % "/ %! ' "! , ( $$ "%( ' %( ' ! ( $6 $% 6 $ "8

.3 { &"" -( &( ! '/ 9$% I$ ! % / " %! ' '%! % % !$ &"6 0( & %$% % 5+&( Ç( &&"% & &&" !"8 +! ( !" 8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants **

3 a t&

/ Ç + 3 8 / $ 4

/ 5$ ' %! " &"" " -/ ! &"" -/ ( 58 I$% !$ -/ %! ' ( Comment [A2]: Para 63 and 64 of NPPF &$ "!8

/ ! !$ +, & /% %! ' '%!6 , % & ( " % !$ !"& ! %" ! ( &! " &"8 !+/ % +" % 0$ !$ & :t" a ; %! ' ( &/!8 Comment [A3]: Para 62 of NPPF encourages this. /* 5$ +, %! % ?$/@ '2"+ ( !+&! '/ /!.9 ! ! &$ D % !"( 8

/. L %! ' -! % !+&( , %"% , %+ $" ( &" % "/ ! / $ % !$ &8 Ç% , ' / '%( $! !$ &"& , %"% " % ' &$! , % "!"8 /( / , % % !$ &; &&"% %! " $ $( $ &$ &( 8 Comment [A4]: Para 62 of NPPF

/1 t& !+&( , % % "/ %! ' '! &"! %$% !$ ! &$ $ $" ( 6 , %'/ % ( &( !$ '6 &$ &"/ ! $!"6 ! " % !$ & , ' $!! +, %( $ +!" '/ &&+8

/3 Ç% "/ %! && !&! !$ "%( & , % % &"" &( $ $! !$ %$% % ' +( C " % , '!$6 &'" & &"6 ! $$8 Ç% "! ' "%" % &6 , % & , % ' & % " !$ /% % &'" ( " ! +8 Ç% & , , 5 "/ , % % ""; , !$ "%( &8

/7 Ç% , 5$ , % % !+&( ( $( /( %! ' &&/ '!6 &&! ! -&&! - -/ ! %+ "/ ' && ' "! 2"$ "%( !- -/8& !$6 + , % % ""$ '8

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants *.

3 a t&

/E Ç% &&" ( ! & -/ " %! ' ( ! '/ $ % "/ -( ! " & &&" +, 8

/D !"%" ! !$ %! % && %+ !$ $/6 ! &"/ % 0 0& ! ! ( &/ &"%8 Comment [A5]: See para 65 of NPPF

/ Ç% ( " !$ -/ %$% % !+&( &" %! ' ! '/ -$ !+& % +" "%" ! !$ %$% % % &2" % !$ -/ ( ! %$% "( &8

5 9 $ $

5 Ç% " %/ ! % 5/ 5%! , % /% %! 5 % ! !&$ % %$% !$ !! % "%( , %"% "( ( ++! "+/ &( $8

5 {"" ! , !$! "%( %! ' "'! ! &( ! %$% , ! ! &+ &'"/8

5* ./ " & "( %! ' :( ! ! %( !8;

Ç L { ! $4 8 3 $ + $ Comment [A6]: By whom

Ç $ $ $ $ Ç + / $

Ç a $ $

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants *1

3 a t&

{ + $ > L + $ + +

Donald Insall Associates • Chartered Architects Historic Building & Planning Consultants *3

!&&!0 L w" ! "

5h /Ü a9b Ç{ " t" a , h "' '$ I$ /

! ( $G ?wL.! b % í @ L !( ?/% C"@ t$ t"/ {( 1 ) t$ % I" 9+( Ç{h [! a "% t$ t"/ {( 1 ) t$ % I" 9+( ) I" +( t$ t"" D! 5/[D6 5/a {6 9I a "%

.!$ /06 b , !+&( I" ! 9I /!.9 w 5+&( I" ! I9[a 9I 1

/%) ! t % / ! ?h "' D3.@ .!$ 5$ t%&

/% ) ! {!/ /+ 5! í L !" Ia {h D3E

/% /+" Ç 5$ {( ) Ç, "& !/ ! Ü ' 5$ / % % /% , % % // í h + . 6 ! W E

/% h // t . ! t( / w"( ( ! w& Dë! ! %6 /í !/ W/

/% // / ! !&&"%6 /%" {!/ ?5 w&@ Ç/ ò$ C'

í 9.{LÇ9{ /+" ë" , , , 8"+"+"8$85 Ü ' 5$ /( &!( , , , 8'!$"( &!( 8"85 t" a , , , 8&"( 8"85 /!.9 , , , 8"'8$85

/h b {Ü [Ç99{ a ( ' /% w" ( a ( ' 5! L !" a ( ' /í !/ &$6 "+6 %$%, / ! +( (

!&&!0 LL 90" ( /!.9 +/ 5$ t "+$