The Reflexive Realism of Richard Yates

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Reflexive Realism of Richard Yates A Thing Made of Words: The Reflexive Realism of Richard Yates By Leif Bull Student no. 33073581 Goldsmiths College PhD English 1 DECLARATION I hereby declare that the work presented in this thesis is my own. Leif Bull 2 Abstract This thesis is a study of the work of American novelist and short story writer Richard Yates. Taking as its starting point the consensus view of Richard Yates as a realist operating during a period of strong anti-realist currents in American literature, the thesis seeks to complicate this notion, arguing instead for a reading of Richard Yates' work as a mode of realism that could only have emerged after modernism, a realism that focussed on a number of concerns and problems regarding representation and interpretation shared with literary postmodernism, and which anticipates recent and current trends within American literary fiction. Its main areas of investigation are Yates' take on everyday language as a site of entropy; his use of intertextuality, in particular in relation to the short story; tensions between realism's claim to cognitive/visual authority and epistemological uncertainty; concerns and anxieties around masculinity within American realism; his use of autobiographical material in relation to the psychoanalytic theories of Melanie Klein and D. W. Winnicott; the impact of media saturation on subjectivity, with particular focus on cliché. 3 A THING MADE OF WORDS: THE REFLEXIVE REALISM OF RICHARD YATES ........................................................................................ 1 ABSTRACT ..................................................................................................... 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................... 7 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................. 8 Realism: Definitions, accusations, and defenses during postmodernity ............................................ 9 The influence of Flaubert, and its significance ................................................................................... 15 Some aesthetic strategies of the realist novel, and their relevance to a study of Richard Yates .... 18 An American and a realist, but an American realist? ....................................................................... 21 Technological innovation and the realist/modernist/postmodernist continuum ............................. 26 McHale, Cohen, Hassan: Some definitions of postmodernist poetics .............................................. 29 Chapters ................................................................................................................................................ 31 Survey of Yates Criticism .................................................................................................................... 35 CHAPTER ONE: REVOLUTIONARY ROAD, OR, SAND IN THE REALIST MACHINERY ................................................................................................. 50 Lilian Furst: Realism, the visual, and fictionality .............................................................................. 51 Cecelia Tichi: Modernism and the machine ....................................................................................... 53 The professional-managerial classes, real and fictional .................................................................... 55 Emma and April ................................................................................................................................... 77 The exhausted engine of capitalist desire ........................................................................................... 81 Philip Roth: ‘Writing American Fiction’ ........................................................................................... 86 CHAPTER TWO: ELEVEN KINDS OF LONELINESS, ELEVEN KINDS OF WRITER’S BLOCK ........................................................................................ 88 Frank O’Connor: On the margins ...................................................................................................... 89 Debunking rhythms .............................................................................................................................. 94 4 ‘It’s just something to do’ .................................................................................................................... 98 Generic difference and intertextual play .......................................................................................... 101 Writer’s block, writerly impotence ................................................................................................... 107 Narration and irony ........................................................................................................................... 108 Nick Adams and Robert Prentice ...................................................................................................... 114 CHAPTER THREE: WAR, WORK, MASCULINITY .................................... 123 Writing as labour ................................................................................................................................ 124 Men at war .......................................................................................................................................... 126 Prelude to war: A Good School, homosocial desire and spectacular masculinity......................... 130 At war with the domestic: ‘A Compassionate Leave’ and A Special Providence ......................... 140 After the war: Toy soldiers ................................................................................................................ 160 CHAPTER FOUR: AUTOBIOGRAPHY, PSYCHOANALYSIS AND PLAY 163 Issues of genre ..................................................................................................................................... 164 Melanie Klein, splitting and storytelling .......................................................................................... 167 D. W. Winnicott and Vladimir Nabokov: Between internal and external ..................................... 168 Nabokov: Further notes on play, and on the role of detail ............................................................. 169 Life and/as literature .......................................................................................................................... 172 All about mother ................................................................................................................................. 174 Disturbing the Peace: Banishing the scapegoat ............................................................................... 188 CHAPTER FIVE: YATES AFTER POSTMODERNISM ............................... 195 Robert Rebein: The revitalisation of realism ................................................................................... 196 After postmodernism .......................................................................................................................... 201 A. M Homes: Suburban surrealism .................................................................................................. 204 David Foster Wallace: Postmodernism as the cultural logic of late capitalism indeed ................ 207 Richard Yates on Hollywood ............................................................................................................. 219 Disturbing the Peace: The nervous breakdown as tired lot device ................................................ 226 Frank Wheeler: Sitcom dad............................................................................................................... 230 5 CONCLUSION ............................................................................................. 233 BIBLIOGRAPHY ......................................................................................... 245 6 Acknowledgements The following have all enabled this project in various ways, and so I wish to extend my sincerest gratitude to: my supervisors, Dr Josh Cohen and Dr Rick Crownshaw, for all their advice, clarity of vision, and always constructive criticism; Dr Jacqueline Rattray, Dr Michael Simpson, and the Goldsmiths Literature Seminar (GLITS), for a highly valued testing ground; the organisers of the 2007 Real Things conference, the International Society for the Study of Narrative, and the Centre for Studies in Literature at the University of Portsmouth for inviting me to present my work; Dr Ben Parsons and Dr Chris Louttit, editors current and former of Peer English: The Journal for New Critical Thinking; Dr Eva Aldea and Dr Geoff Baker, for the forthcoming anthology; the Department of English and Comparative Literature at Goldsmiths College, University of London, for providing funding, as well as gainful employment; Kevin O'Neill and Catherine Humble, for fruitful discussions; my parents, Aaslaug and Jens Bull, for their continued support; and finally, my wife, Sara Clarke, whose love, understanding, and patience are a constant source of amazement to me. I dedicate this thesis to her. 7 Introduction In an introductory essay, Richard Ford writes of the standing Richard Yates‟ debut novel enjoys among fellow writers: We marvel at its consummate writerliness, its almost simple durability as a purely made thing of words that defeats all attempts at classification. Realism, naturalism, social satire – the standard critical bracketry – all go begging before this splendid book. Revolutionary
Recommended publications
  • Reading Group Guide Spotlight
    Spotlight on: Reading Group Guide Revolutionary Road Author: Richard Yates Born February 3, 926, in Yonkers, NY; died of Name: Richard Yates emphysema and complications from minor Born: 926 surgery, November 7, 992, in Birmingham, AL; son of Vincent M. (a sales executive) and Ruth (Maurer) Yates; married Sheila Bryant, 948 (divorced, 959); married Martha Speer, 968 (divorced, 974); children: Sharon, Monica, Gina. Military/Wartime Service: U.S. Army, 944-46. Career: United Press Association, New York City, financial reporter, 946- 48; Remington Rand, Inc., New York City, publicity writer, 948-50; freelance public relations writer, 953-60; New School for Social Research, New York City, teacher of creative writing, 959-62; Columbia University, New York City, teacher of creative writing, 960-62; United Artists, Hollywood, screenwriter, 962; U.S. Attorney General Robert Kennedy, Washington, DC, speech writer, 963; University of Iowa, Iowa City, lecturer, 964-65, assistant professor of English, 966- 92; Columbia Pictures, Hollywood, screenwriter, 965-66; Wichita State University, writer in residence, 97-72; taught at Harvard Extension, Columbia University, and Boston University. Awards: Atlantic Firsts award, 953; National Book Award nomination for Revolutionary Road; Guggenheim fellowship, 962, 98; American Academy Grant, 963; National Institute of Arts and Letters grant, 963 and 975; Creative Arts Award, Brandeis University, 964; National Endowment for the Arts grant, 966, and award, 984; Rockefeller grant, 967; Rosenthal Foundation award, 976; National Magazine Award for Fiction, 978, for “Oh, Joseph, I’m So Tired.” Writings: Novels: Revolutionary Road, Atlantic-Little, Brown, 96. A Special Providence, Knopf, 969. Disturbing the Peace, Delacorte, 975.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION A. Background of the Study
    1 CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION A. Background of The Study Revolutionary Road is an American romance drama movie. This movie has duration 119 minutes and it was released on 23 January 2009 in USA. The screenplay of this movie is adapted from the novel that has the same title by Richard Yates. This movie is directed by Sam Mendes and Screenplay is written by Justin Hythe. This movie is being launched on DVD and in movie. Revolutionary Road has professionals’ actor and actress like Leonardo Dicaprio as Frank Wheller and Kate Winslet (April). This movie also has another actor, like Kathy Bates as Hellen Givings, Kathy Hahn as Milly Campell, David Harbour as Shep Cambell, Michael Shannon as Jhon Givings, Richard Easton as Howard givings, Zoe Kazan as Maureen Givbe and the last is Jay O. Sanders as Bart Pollock. The music score is done by Thomas Newman, produced by Dream work picture. In 2 June 2009 DVD of the movie was released. The director of Revolutionary Road is Sam Mendes (Samuel Alexander Mendes) who was born on 1 August 1965. He lives in Berkshire (England). He was graduated from University of Cambridge. Then he lives in New York. Sam Mendes career began in 1993, started as a theatre director. Some movies which are directed by Sam Mendes are American Beauty in 1999, Road Perdition in 2002, Jarhead in 2005, Starter for Ten movie in 1 2 2006, The Kite Runner, in 2007 and the last in 2008 Mendes directed Revolutionary Road. The story of this movie is begun from New York at 1948, on cocktail party, Frank Wheller and April Jonshon met.
    [Show full text]
  • Jennifer Daly Trinity College Dublin [email protected] Remembering Who
    Jennifer Daly Trinity College Dublin [email protected] Remembering Who You Are: Memory and Deception in Revolutionary Road This paper is part of a wider project which seeks to challenge the accepted narrative of a crisis in American masculine identity through the prism of fiction since the 1950s. The increased influence of psychoanalysis and a general move toward a therapeutic culture began in the 1950s. Since then the dominant theory has been to position the men of the United States in a state of crisis borne out of increased freedom for women, the modernisation of society, technological advancements, and the promotion of a consumer driven culture. As a result, the crisis narrative has assumed a position as an accepted memory for masculinity studies. This paper will question the validity of the “masculinity in crisis” theory through an analysis of the Richard Yates novel Revolutionary Road. Yates regularly allows his characters to indulge in fantasies of how a particular situation will play out, but reality rarely matches what they imagine. They consistently dream about better, more exciting lives for themselves, spurred on by the pressures of a society that celebrates the individual while at the same time demanding that individual conform to the national stereotype of the American dream. Frank Wheeler, the protagonist, is particularly guilty of this to the point that his memories of events are subject to the same fantastic qualities until tragedy strikes and he is forced to embrace the reality of his situation. This paper will thus seek to interrogate the collective memory that has grown up around the theory of a crisis in masculinity in the United States.
    [Show full text]
  • CONFERENCE 2016 RICHMOND MARRIOTT 500 EAST BROAD STREET RICHMOND, VA the 2015 Plutarch Award
    BIOGRAPHERS INTERNATIONAL SEVENTH JUNE 35 ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2016 RICHMOND MARRIOTT 500 EAST BROAD STREET RICHMOND, VA The 2015 Plutarch Award Biographers International Organization is proud to present the Plutarch Award for the best biography of 2015, as chosen by you. Congratulations to the ten nominees for the Best Biography of 2015: The 2016 BIO Award Recipient: Claire Tomalin Claire Tomalin, née Delavenay, was born in London in 1933 to a French father and English mother, studied at Cambridge, and worked in pub- lishing and journalism, becoming literary editor of the New Statesman, then of the (British) Sunday Times, while bringing up her children. In 1974, she published The Life and Death of Mary Wollstonecraft, which won the Whitbread First Book Prize. Since then she has written Shelley and His World, 1980; Katherine Mansfield: A Secret Life, 1987; The Invisible Woman: The Story of Nelly Ternan and Charles Dickens, 1991 (which won the NCR, Hawthornden, and James Tait Black prizes, and is now a film);Mrs. Jordan’s Profession, 1994; Jane Austen: A Life, 1997; Samuel Pepys: The Unequalled Self, 2002 (winner of the Whitbread Biography and Book of the Year prizes, Pepys Society Prize, and Rose Crawshay Prize from the Royal Academy). Thomas Hardy: The Time-Torn Man, 2006, and Charles Dickens: A Life, 2011, followed. She has honorary doctorates from Cambridge and many other universities, has served on the Committee of the London Library, is a trustee of the National Portrait Gallery, and is a vice-president of the Royal Literary Fund, the Royal Society of Literature, and English PEN.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter I Introduction
    CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION A. Background of the Study One of interesting literary theories is Psychology. Psychoanalysis is a branch of psychology that methodology of studying mental process and mental behavior. Psychoanalysis related to structural, process and developmental change. Basically, Psychology has the relation between people behavior and the other human. It comprises everything related to the feeling, thought, behavior, ideas, etc. related to the psychology, every person are created with different personalities. The quality of personality is being a person. Personality is deeper than character. It does not confine itself to an organized expression as character does. In a movie, the personality of the main character is interesting object for the researcher to analyze. Personality in a movie is closely related to personal psychological behavior, because it is shown many ways, like actions, dialogues, attitudes, and characteristics that influence the personality. It means that character can influence personality, but personality is unchanging. Wellek and Werren (1956: 31) in theory of literature state that literature has function as the duce and the utile. They said that the work of literature is successful, the two “notes” of pleasure and utility should not coexist but coalesce. The pleasure of literature need to maintain is not one of 1 2 preferences among along list of possible pleasure but also a “higher-pleasure” because pleasure is higher kind of activity, i.e. non-acquisitive contemplation. Personality is defined by the particular concepts a theorist uses to describe or understand human behavior. According to Pervin (1984: 2) the field of personality is concerned with the total individual and with individual differences.
    [Show full text]
  • Richard Yates’ “Builders” and Questions of the Autobiographical Content of His Work
    .........................................................................................CROSSROADS. A Journal of English Studies 32 (2021) (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) KARL WOOD1 DOI: 10.15290/CR.2021.32.1.04 Kazimierz Wielki University in Bydgoszcz, Poland ORCID: 0000-0002-4042-1307 A window into short- -story construction: Richard Yates’ “Builders” and questions of the autobiographical content of his work Abstract. Richard Yates, most remembered for his Revolutionary Road (1961), was also the author of two fine and exceptionally well-crafted collections of short stories, Eleven Kinds of Loneliness (1963) and Liars in Love (1981). Yates was a writer of exceptional perception and unflinching clarity, yet some have criti- cized his work as drawing too heavily on autobiographical content. This article seeks to examine Yates’ 1963 story “Builders” to gain insight into this extraordinary author’s understanding of the writing pro- cess, his use of autobiographical or semi-autobiographical content, and to suggest new approaches for work on this still under-appreciated twentieth century author. Keywords: Richard Yates, autofiction, self-narrative, short stories Richard Yates, an author whose name often evokes a vague sense of familiarity, is most often remembered for his 1961 first novel Revolutionary Road, accompanied by a sense that this was an important and fine author, yet one who remains on many bucket lists of works to be read, someday, when time permits. This is an improvement over the situa- tion at the turn of the century, when Richard Ford commented that Yates was a kind of “cultural-literary secret handshake” (2000: 16), with his work largely out of print, leading Stewart O’Nan (1999) to remark that “to write so well and be forgotten is a terrifying legacy.” Over the past twenty years or so, however, prompted by the advocacy of several of his students, there has been a small renaissance in the appreciation of Yates.
    [Show full text]
  • Philip Roth Biography Appeared Before the Book Came Out, with Major Stories in Magazines and Literary Publications
    Sexual Assault Allegations Against Biographer Halt Shipping of His Roth Book W.W. Norton, citing the accusations that the author, Blake Bailey, faces, said it would stop shipping and promoting his new best-selling book. “Philip Roth: The Biography” went on sale earlier this month.Credit...W.W. Norton, via Associated Press By Alexandra Alter and Rachel Abrams Published April 21, 2021Updated May 17, 2021 Earlier this month, the biographer Blake Bailey was approaching what seemed like the apex of his literary career. Reviews of his highly anticipated Philip Roth biography appeared before the book came out, with major stories in magazines and literary publications. It landed on the New York Times best-seller list this week. Now, allegations against Mr. Bailey, 57, have emerged, including claims that he sexually assaulted two women, one as recently as 2015, and that he behaved inappropriately toward middle school students when he was a teacher in the 1990s. His publisher, W.W. Norton, took swift and unusual action: It said on Wednesday that it had stopped shipments and promotion of his book. “These allegations are serious,” it said in a statement. “In light of them, we have decided to pause the shipping and promotion of ‘Philip Roth: The Biography’ pending any further information that may emerge.” Norton, which initially printed 50,000 copies of the title, has stopped a 10,000-copy second printing that was scheduled to arrive in early May. It has also halted advertising and media outreach, and events that Norton arranged to promote the book are being canceled. The pullback from the publisher came just days after Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • Clotel 184) with the Speed of a Bird, Having Passed the Avenue, She Began to Gain, and Presently She Was Upon the Long Bridge
    European journal of American studies 15-2 | 2020 Summer 2020 Édition électronique URL : https://journals.openedition.org/ejas/15701 DOI : 10.4000/ejas.15701 ISSN : 1991-9336 Éditeur European Association for American Studies Référence électronique European journal of American studies, 15-2 | 2020, « Summer 2020 » [En ligne], mis en ligne le 23 juin 2020, consulté le 08 juillet 2021. URL : https://journals.openedition.org/ejas/15701 ; DOI : https:// doi.org/10.4000/ejas.15701 Ce document a été généré automatiquement le 8 juillet 2021. European Journal of American studies 1 SOMMAIRE What on Earth! Slated Globes, School Geography and Imperial Pedagogy Mahshid Mayar Homecomings: Black Women’s Mobility in Early African American Fiction Anna Pochmara Hollywood’s Depiction of Italian American Servicemen During the Italian Campaign of World War II Matteo Pretelli “Being an Instance of the Norm”: Women, Surveillance and Guilt in Richard Yates’s Revolutionary Road Vavotici Francesca Complicating American Manhood: Marge Piercy’s Woman on the Edge of Time and the Feminist Utopia as a Site for Transforming Masculinities Michael Pitts Beyond Determinism: Geography of Jewishness in Nathan Englander’s “Sister Hills” and Michael Chabon’s The Yiddish Policemen’s Union Filip Boratyn Rummaging Through the Ashes: 9/11 American Poetry and the Transcultural Counterwitness Matthew Moran “Challenging Borders: Susanna Kaysen’s Girl, Interrupted as a Subversive Disability Memoir” Pascale Antolin Un/Seeing Campus Carry: Experiencing Gun Culture in Texas Benita Heiskanen
    [Show full text]
  • Avatars of the Anti-Heroic Couple
    University of Bucharest Review Vol. III/2013, no. 1 (new series) Cultures of Memory, Memories of Culture Anca Peiu* THE AMERICAN DREAM OF SELF-RELIANCE: AVATARS OF THE ANTI-HEROIC COUPLE Keywords: self-reliance/achievement; the perfect couple; partnership; love; family; culture; memory. Abstract: Self-Reliance is perhaps the most powerful American myth. It precedes Ralph Waldo Emerson himself in a vision that Benjamin Franklin called The American Dream: the availability of success to anyone who is ready to surpass one’s own limits. This classic American heritage of thought has been questioned again and again by writers who put their national culture icons and their (sense of) history on the map of world literature. And further on, high up there, on the screen of really memorable movies. My case in point here is Richard Yates’s 1961 novel, Revolutionary Road. Its outstanding 2008 film version, achieved by Sam Mendes, who directed a cast of actors starring Kate Winslet and Leonardo DiCaprio, is much more than a fortunate coincidence. Ironic distortion and doom interweave as echoes of one of the few books which William Faulkner wrote out of Yoknapatwpha County: The Wild Palms (1939). Whether modern or post-modern, the two realistic novels share a focus on the anti-heroic couple. Their main delusions stem from the deepest memory of American culture: the (revolutionary) myth of self-reliance. For Kate Winslet, the year 2008 meant the international acknowledgement of a double triumph of her artistic maturity: first as the best actress in the film The Reader – which also brought her the Oscar – and second as the leading lady of the movie Revolutionary Road.
    [Show full text]
  • Pulitzer Prize Winners and Finalists
    WINNERS AND FINALISTS 1917 TO PRESENT TABLE OF CONTENTS Excerpts from the Plan of Award ..............................................................2 PULITZER PRIZES IN JOURNALISM Public Service ...........................................................................................6 Reporting ...............................................................................................24 Local Reporting .....................................................................................27 Local Reporting, Edition Time ..............................................................32 Local General or Spot News Reporting ..................................................33 General News Reporting ........................................................................36 Spot News Reporting ............................................................................38 Breaking News Reporting .....................................................................39 Local Reporting, No Edition Time .......................................................45 Local Investigative or Specialized Reporting .........................................47 Investigative Reporting ..........................................................................50 Explanatory Journalism .........................................................................61 Explanatory Reporting ...........................................................................64 Specialized Reporting .............................................................................70
    [Show full text]
  • Schedule of Courses for Fall 2018
    Old Dominion University Old Dominion University Institute for Learning in Retirement VIRGINIA BEACH HIGHER EDUCATION CENTER 1881 University Drive, Virginia Beach, VA 23453 (757) 368-4160 website: www.oduilr.org email: [email protected] SCHEDULE OF COURSES FOR FALL 2018 ILR does not discriminate with respect to race, color, sex, religion or national origin. The opinions expressed by our speakers are not necessarily the opinion of ILR or Old Dominion University. The Clash Between the U.S. and China Date and Time: Monday, October 1, 10:00-12:00 Cost: $14 Location: VBHEC Speaker: Shaomin Li, Ph.D. Course Description: Last year Dr. Li gave a lecture at the ILR with a title of "The Coming Clash between U.S. and China." Now, unfortunately, the clash has come, multidimensionally, ranging from culture, politics, the economy, to the military. Two major changes have occurred since last year’s lecture: first, the Chinese Communist Party is taking a more offensive position; second, a consensus is emerging in the U.S. against the expansion of the Chinese Communist Party. In this lecture, we will analyze the clash from the political, economic and cultural perspectives, with a focus on what the U.S. should do facing the clash. Credentials/Background: Dr. Shaomin Li is Eminent Scholar and Professor of International Business. He received his Ph.D. in Sociology from Princeton University. His research focuses on international political economy. His articles have appeared in The Wall Street Journal, The Financial Times, The New York Times, and Harvard Business Review. The Economist magazine featured his research twice.
    [Show full text]
  • Richard Yates, Novelist, 66, Dies - Chronicler of Disappointed
    Richard Yates, Novelist, 66, Dies - Chronicler of Disappointed ... http://www.nytimes.com/1992/11/09/obituaries/richard-yates-no... HOME PAGE TODAY'S PAPER VIDEO MOST POPULAR U.S. Edition dennis... Help Search All NYTimes.com Obituaries WORLD U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION ARTS STYLE TRAVEL JOBS REAL ESTATE AUTOS Richard Yates, Novelist, 66, Dies; Chronicler of Disappointed Lives By ERIC PACE Published: November 9, 1992 Richard Yates, who wrote "Revolutionary Road" and other novels FACEBOOK about self-deception, disappointment and grief, died on Saturday at TWITTER the Birmingham (Ala.) Veterans Administration hospital. He was 66 GOOGLE+ years old and had lived in Tuscaloosa, Ala., for two years. EMAIL He died of emphysema, which he had had for 10 years, and of SHARE complications from minor surgery, said his daughter Monica Yates. PRINT She said he smoked heavily until a year ago. REPRINTS "Revolutionary Road," Mr. Yates's first novel, published by Atlantic- MOST EMAILED RECOMMENDED FOR YOU Little, Brown in 1961, was what the New York Times critic Orville Prescott called a "brilliantly dismal" account of an unhappy articles viewed dennis recently All Recommendations 30-year-old couple, Frank and April Wheeler, who "lived in one of 112 those new little houses on Revolutionary Road not very far from 1. STATE OF THE ART Debunking the Latest Predictions of Stamford, Conn." Facebook’s Demise When it was reissued by Delta-Seymour Lawrence in 1983, Michiko Kakutani, reviewing it 2. MACHINE LEARNING in The New York Times, wrote, "It remains a remarkable and deeply troubling book -- a Messaging Apps Offer Do-It-All Services in Bid for Higher Profits book that creates an indelible portrait of lost promises and mortgaged hopes in the suburbs of America." 3.
    [Show full text]