Debates of the Senate
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DEBATES OF THE SENATE 2nd SESSION • 43rd PARLIAMENT • VOLUME 152 • NUMBER 40 OFFICIAL REPORT (HANSARD) Tuesday, May 25, 2021 The Honourable GEORGE J. FUREY, Speaker CONTENTS (Daily index of proceedings appears at back of this issue). Debates Services: Josée Boisvert, National Press Building, Room 831, Tel. 613-219-3775 Publications Centre: Kim Laughren, National Press Building, Room 926, Tel. 343-550-5002 Published by the Senate Available on the Internet: http://www.parl.gc.ca 1459 THE SENATE Tuesday, May 25, 2021 The Senate met at 2 p.m., the Speaker in the chair. [English] Prayers. SENATORS’ STATEMENTS [Translation] THE HONOURABLE MARY JANE MCCALLUM SPEAKER’S STATEMENT THE HONOURABLE MURRAY SINCLAIR The Hon. the Speaker: Honourable senators, on May 5, 2021, CONGRATULATIONS ON INSTALLATION AS I made a statement in the Senate outlining the process to be UNIVERSITY CHANCELLORS followed for the election of the Speaker pro tempore for the rest of the session. This was done pursuant to a decision of the Senate made on February 8, 2021, when it adopted the fourth report of Hon. Yuen Pau Woo: Honourable colleagues, as senators, we the Committee of the Selection. are involved in many activities outside of the Red Chamber. From time to time, some of us may be given awards and recognition for accomplishments and other good deeds. It would The deadline for senators to indicate a wish to run for the be impossible to recite them every time an award or recognition position of Speaker pro tempore was noon on May 10, 2021. is given. However, on this occasion, I want to take a minute to Only one senator expressed an interest, so an election is not recognize a current colleague and a former colleague who have required, and the post can be filled by acclamation. truly achieved something quite extraordinary. Honourable senators, I am therefore pleased to advise you that Senator Mary Jane McCallum, as some of you know, has been the Honourable Senator Ringuette will be Speaker pro tempore appointed as chancellor of Brandon University, the first for the remainder of the session. Pursuant to the process Indigenous person and woman to serve as chancellor of that established on May 5, the following motion is deemed moved, university. Our former colleague Senator Murray Sinclair was seconded and adopted: “That the Honourable Senator Ringuette appointed as chancellor of Queen’s University. be named Speaker pro tempore for the remainder of the session”. Former Senator Sinclair is fond of saying words to the effect Colleagues, I know that, like me, you will wish to congratulate of, “It was education that got us into this mess,” referring, of Senator Ringuette on her new responsibilities. She brings course, to residential schools. He has always said in the follow- extensive parliamentary experience — both in the Senate and in up to that comment that it is education that will get us out of this the House of Commons — to her role, and we will benefit from mess. her good sense, quick wit and acumen. I have appreciated her dedication and support since she took on her role on an interim He and Senator Mary Jane McCallum are at the pinnacle of basis. responsibility at two prestigious universities in our country. We look to them to help us get out of this mess. Thank you, Senator Ringuette, for all your diligent work for the Senate, and my very heartfelt congratulations and best Congratulations, Senator Sinclair and Senator Mary Jane wishes. McCallum. [English] Hon. Senators: Hear, hear! Hon. Pierrette Ringuette: I would like to say a particular thank you to all honourable senators. ASIAN HERITAGE MONTH [Translation] Hon. Wanda Elaine Thomas Bernard: Honourable senators, I rise today, during Asian Heritage Month, to recognize the I am really blessed to have the support of my colleagues in this important work of the Filipino-Canadian Social and Community task, which I see as very important to the proper functioning of Worker Network. our institution, and to have your support, Mr. Speaker. Many, many thanks to all of you, dear colleagues. I hope to be able to This year has brought an influx of anti-Asian discrimination continue to serve you in this role. Thank you. and an increased awareness of the racism and violence faced by Asian Canadians. It is important that we work together to address Hon. Senators: Hear, hear! anti-Asian racism. I also want to bring attention to positive things that are happening in Asian-Canadian communities by acknowledging a grassroots organization that is supporting their community through this difficult time. 1460 SENATE DEBATES May 25, 2021 I have had the pleasure of meeting the executive members of She wants to tell a story of a sinister Jewish conspiracy. The the Filipino-Canadian Social and Community Worker Network: conspiracy does not exist, but photographs can be placed side by Monica Batac, Dr. Ilyan Ferrer, Veronica Javier and Dr. Fritz side under a suggestive headline to create a false impression. Pino. These change leaders have mobilized Filipino, Filipina and Then the headline and the photos can be posted to social media to Filipinx social workers across Canada by hosting events and weaponize the false impression on thousands of minds that will through their Facebook group. This group is a hub for never click to the underlying report to read how baseless it all is. connections, mentorship and resource sharing. They bring attention to issues faced by Filipino people in Canada, including issues related to racism and colonialism, immigration, labour, I was one of those side-swiped by this campaign. I was singled solidarity with Black and Indigenous communities and assessing out as a member of the conspiracy, illustrated by a photo of me COVID-related community needs. standing beside an Israeli flag. Just in case anyone missed the point: Jew plot, Jew danger, Jew enemy. The network fills a need for Filipino scholarship and representation in social work and community activism as social Parliamentary rules discourage me from identifying the workers, community workers, social work educators or reporter in question. On reflection anyway, the issue is not one academics. As a founder of the Association of Black Social reporter. Reporters do not write their own headlines, select their Workers established 42 years ago, I am familiar with the courage own photographs or make the placement of those photographs, and persistence needed to spearhead such an initiative off the and many of the most inflammatory social media posts about this side of your desk. I hope that 42 years from now, the network can were issued from the accounts of the reporter’s colleagues and look back on these early years as a pivotal point for Filipino friends, not the reporter herself. So this is not about a single social workers and community workers in Canada. individual. This is a story about a habit of mind. Professional news organizations usually have standards to • (1410) prevent this kind of sly defamation. Public broadcasters might be expected to be more professional than most, but when the topic is Jews, Radio-Canada is less professional than any. It’s not a new Honourable colleagues, in honour of Asian Heritage Month, problem, and it’s not one person’s failure. It is a deep cultural please join me in recognizing and supporting the important work malformation that starts with ancient paranoid fantasies and of the Filipino-Canadian Social and Community Worker culminates in violence on the streets of Montreal. Network. Thank you. FEDERAL GREENHOUSE GAS OFFSET SYSTEM ANTI-SEMITISM Hon. Robert Black: Honourable senators, I rise today to Hon. Linda Frum: Honourable senators, in the past days, highlight the important steps that many Canadian farmers have Canadian cities have seen an unprecedented surge of assaults and taken to make their operations more environmentally sustainable. attacks upon Jewish Canadians. Our elected leaders may say there is no place for hate of any kind in Canada, but, of course, that’s not true. This government has made it clear that the fight against climate change remains one of its key focuses. While I wholeheartedly support the important goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions, I am wary of the impacts that For people who hate Jews, there’s most certainly a place in initiatives such as the Federal Greenhouse Gas Offset System Canada. It’s a large place, a growing place and an increasingly will have on our agricultural industry. comfortable and respectable place. Those who inhabit that comfortable and respectable place might not deface a synagogue themselves or throw a brick at a school, but they create Earlier this year, the Minister of Environment and Climate permission for those who do commit those overt acts of hatred. Change Canada announced this new system. Unfortunately, draft They teach our fellow citizens to think it is perhaps excessive to regulations for Canada’s carbon offset market indicate that throw a brick, but those Jews, they brought it on themselves. farmers won’t receive credit for removing any greenhouse gas They deserve it. The real victim is the brick thrower. emissions before 2017. I want to talk today about one of those teachers. It is, While the government established its plan to put a national unfortunately, a taxpayer-funded broadcaster, Radio-Canada. In cost on carbon that same year, many farmers had already taken recent weeks, one reporter at Radio-Canada has embarked on a steps over previous years to make their land a zero-till campaign against a former ambassador of this country to Israel. operation — this technique increases the retention of organic The trouble is, the reporter has got no facts to support the sequestration, organic matter and nutrient cycling, which in turn campaign, so the campaign has to proceed by insinuation.