The Judiciary

March 2018

CCJA Bureau Meets in Durban

Enhancing Judicial Accountability

The State Capture Commission CONTENTS Editorial Staff and Contributors.

2 CCJA Bureau Meeting Editors Judge President & 4 Justice receives Biko-Fanon Award Judge President Dunstan Mlambo.

Writers Lindo Nkomonde; Pfunzo 5 Justice Nkabinde retires Mafenya, and Yvonne van Niekerk.

6 State of the Nation 2018 Photographers Cornelius Silaule, Pfunzo Mafeny and Murendeni Mugivhi. 7 State Capture Commission Thanks To Judicial Contributors 10 Enhancing Judicial Accountability

10 SAJEI Workshop

13 Seminar on organised crime

16 The Gentleman Judge remembered

NATIONAL OFFICE

188 14th ROAD NOORDWYK MIDRAND 1685

010 493 2500

[email protected]

www.judiciary.org.za From the Editor

Dear colleagues, Cooperation between African Jurisdictions for the advancement of constitutionalism and the rule of law Welcome to 2018 and to our first Issue for the year! was also the theme when the South African We trust that you have had a good start to the year Judiciary met with Judges from neighbouring states and that, so far, you are on track with all the goals to share experiences on the adjudication of you have set yourselves for the current twelve organised crimes, specifically relating to human month period. trafficking, wildlife trafficking and money laundering. We expand more on this event on pages 11 and 12. A lot has happened within the Judiciary space since the last time we published this newsletter. Notable Lastly, but certainly not least; we are all aware that among these was the retirement of our esteemed the Honourable Deputy Chief Justice of the Republic colleague, Justice , whose twelve of , Judge , was appointed year term at the Constitutional Court ended in by the former President of the Republic of South December 2017. A moving farewell ceremony was Africa, President , to chair the held in her honour – read about it on page 4. We Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of State of take this opportunity to wish her an enjoyable Capture, Corruption and Fraud in the Public Sector retirement. including Organs of State in January this year. This is a momentous task that has been given to the As we all know, His Excellency the Chief Justice of Deputy Chief Justice and the work of the the Republic of South Africa, the Honourable Commission will be watched closely not only within , has since April 2017 been our borders, but also beyond by the global serving the Judiciaries of the Continent of Africa as community. In March, the Deputy Chief Justice the President of the Conference of Constitutional announced a high-level team that will assist him in Jurisdictions of Africa (CCJA). undertaking this work. The details are page 7. We assure the Deputy Chief Justice of our full support The CCJA is an organisation which brings together as he undertakes this important assignment. the African constitutional jurisdictions (Constitutional Council, Court, Tribunal, Supreme Court, and We trust that you will enjoy this Issue as much as Constitutional Chambers) and aims to support and you enjoyed our first one! deepen democracy in the African continent by upholding constitutionalism and the rule of law in Judge President John Hlophe the member states. The CCJA Executive Bureau, Chairperson: Judicial Communications led by His Excellency Chief Justice Mogoeng Committee Mogoeng, held its 9th Annual Session in January to discuss its programme of action for the year as well The South African Judiciary as constitutional developments in its various member countries. You can read more about the @OCJ_RSA great work the CCJA is doing on pages 2 and 3. @OCJ_RSA

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 1 T H E C C J A C O N C E R N E D A B O U T T H R E A T S T O J U D G E S

Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng issued by the CCJA raising concern lauded by other jurisdictions of the says the Conference of about negative remarks allegedly world as ‘trend-setting’. Constitutional Jurisdictions of made by President Uhuru Kenyatta Africa (CCJA) is concerned about following a decision of the Supreme “During the course of elections [in threats to Judges in the African Court of Kenya that nullified his re- Kenya], when [Judges] were continent by ‘powerful forces’ who election as President last year. reportedly subjected to want to erode the independence of unprecedented insults – and what the Judiciary. In a media statement on behalf of could have been understood to be the CCJA, Chief Justice Mogoeng utterances of intimidation by very He was speaking during a media Mogoeng said “The CCJA and the powerful forces in their country – briefing in his capacity as the South African Judiciary, are deeply caught not only the eyes of major President of the CCJA at the concerned about the remarks players in the continent, but also conclusion of its 9th Annual reportedly made by His Excellency major players in the global stage. Session of the Executive Bureau President Uhuru Kenyatta about So much so that, when we held in Durban on 24 January 2018. Chief Justice Maraga and other the Congress of the World colleagues in the Kenyan Judiciary… Conference of Constitutional Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng His Excellency the President is Jurisdictions in Lithuania, our said the Session of the Executive reported to have said that Kenya has intervention was so trend-setting Bureau had spent some time a ‘problem’ with its Judiciary that that it became a subject matter of deliberating on this matter so that must be fixed, asked ‘who even extended deliberations by the the CCJA could intervene elected you’, and said ‘six people world body,” said Chief Justice decisively in instances where the have decided that they will go Mogoeng Mogoeng during the independence of the Judiciary was against the will of the people’. He media briefing. threatened. allegedly went so far as to label the Chief Justice and his colleagues as Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng The CCJA has intervened in a ‘wakora’ or ‘crooks’.” attended the 30th African Union number of such cases in the (AU) summit in Addis Ababa and African continent. One of these Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng used the opportunity to raise these interventions was the statement said that this intervention was issues with the political leadership

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 2 CCJA Sets Agenda for 2018

of the continent. He was invited in understand better the challenges The CCJA’s 9th Annual Session of his capacity as President of the facing the AU in enforcing the AU the Executive Bureau was held to CCJA as a special guest to the Charter on Human and People’s discuss its programme of action for summit by AU Commission Rights and the strengthening of the year as well as constitutional chairperson Moussa Faki judiciaries in constitutional developments in its various Mahamat. democracies, but he was also there member countries. to advise the politicians about the It was meant to help him worries of Judges on the continent.

Chief Justice Mogoeng with Mr. Medelci Mourad (President of the Constitutional Court of Algeria and Madam Justice Guilhermina Contreiras Prata (Vice President of the Constitutional Tribunal of Angola). Deputy Chief Justice Zondo addressing delegates at the Gala Dinner.

From L-R: Mr. Aboudou Salami Maman Sani (Secretary-General of the CCJA; Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng (President of the CCJA); Mr. Laraba Moussa (Deputy Secretary General of the CCJA) and Mr. Tabbech Abdelmadjid (Treasurer General of the CCJA).

Delegates visited cultural and tourist sites in Durban Chief Justice Mogoeng addressing delegates at the Gala Dinner following the Executive Bureau meeting. T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 3 C H I E F J U S T I C E M O G O E N G R E C I E V E S B I K O - F A N O N A W A R D

Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng received the Biko of Chief Justice Mogoeng’s contributions to public Fanon Award for Psychological Liberation. The awareness, creating a singular source of hope for award - jointly made by the Steve Biko Foundation, morality in the South African and continental the Psychological Society of South Africa (PsySSA), citizenry. He was honoured during an evening event the Pan-African Psychology Union (PAPU) and the held at Zoo Lake Bowling Club in on Fondation Frantz Fanon - was made in recognition March 12.

Chief Justice Mogoeng received the Biko-Fanon Award for Psychological Liberation, and was presented with a blanket depicting Steve Biko the father of Black Consciousness. Well known musician Sipho ' Hotstix' Mabuse performed at the event, held at Zoo Lake.

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 4 J U S T I C E B E S S N K A B I N D E R E T I R E S

December 2017 marked On December 7, a ceremonial Constitutional Court Judge Bess sitting of the Constitutional Court Nkabinde’s end of her twelve was held in which Judge year term as a Justice of the Nkabinde handed down her last Constitutional Court of the judgment. The judgment on her Republic of South Africa. She final day was on a labour matter was bade farewell in a two-part where she found Section 38(2) ceremony during 6 and 7 (b)(i) of the Public Service Act December 2017. unconstitutional.

Constitutional Court Judges Representatives from the serve for a term of twelve years. National Association of Democratic Lawyers (NADEL), Justice Nkabinde during her formative years. An elegant gala dinner was Black Lawyers Association hosted in Judge Nkabinde’s (BLA), the General Council of honour on December 6. This the Bar of South Africa, as well was attended by members of as Parliament of South Africa, her family as well as other among others, all took turns dignitaries from the legal during the ceremonial sitting fraternity. Speakers at the lauding Judge Nkabinde for her dinner included Justice stellar career. Froneman, Former Deputy Chief Justice Moseneke, and the We wish her well in her Acting Chief Justice Zondo, with retirement! Justices Cameron and Khampepe being programme Justice Nkabinde with some of her former law directors. clerks.

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 5 S T A T E O F T H E N A T I O N A D D R E S S I N P I C T U R E S

The leadership of the Judiciary annually takes part in the opening of Parliament. The Justices are joined here by the Secretary-General of the OCJ, Ms Memme Sejosengwe.

CJ Mogoeng leads the Judicial procession on the red carpet The spouses of the Judiciary leadership were also there.

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 6 D E P U T Y C H I E F J U S T I C E Z O N D O A S S E M B L E S S T A T E C A P T U R E C O M M I S S I O N T E A M

The Chairperson of the Commission who are multi-disciplined in order to Director of the Ahmed Kathrada of Inquiry into Allegations of State of cope with the type of investigations Foundation, Neeshan Balton, said Capture, Corruption and Fraud in that will be required,” said the they were ‘thrilled’ to learn the Public Sector including Organs Commission Chairperson. Nombembe would be leading the of State, Deputy Chief Justice investigation. “He is a man of Raymond Zondo, has announced Senior Counsel, Paul Pretorius, will incredible integrity and has a full the high-level team that will assist lead the Commission’s legal team. understanding of the public sector. him in the work of the Commission. He will be joined by three other If there is anyone who will be able senior counsel, namely, Vincent to pick up the flaws, it`s him,” He made the announcement during Maleka, Leah Gcabashe and Thandi Balton said. – The Mercury, March a press briefing held at the Office of Norman. Pretorius, as leader of the 8. the Chief Justice building in legal team, would at times lead Midrand, Gauteng, on 7 March evidence in the hearings. Council for the Advancement of the 2018. South African Constitution Deputy Chief Justice Zondo said the (CASAC) director Lawson Naidoo Speaking during the press briefing, Commission had effectively begun told Daily Maverick: “This is an Deputy Chief Justice Zondo said he its work on March 1, and “some impressive team of able and had appointed Dr Khotso De Wee, investigators would begin to go out experienced professionals whose Vincent Maleka SC, Terence into the field and conduct integrity is beyond reproach. Nombembe, Leah Gcabashe SC, investigations”. He said some Justice Zondo is to be commended Paul Pretorius SC and Thandi investigations would need more time for assembling such a strong Norman to help him spearhead the and there might be a need to wait team.” – Daily Maverick, March 9. work of the Commission. before those hearings begin. The team was … described as Dr Khotso De Wee has been The announcement of the team “very impressive” by Accountability appointed as the Secretary of the generated a sentiment of approval Now’s Paul Hoffman, who added Commission. He was the Executive from the media with headlines such that its composition “engenders Director of Fort Hare Solutions and as “Zondo puts together his own confidence that a serious effort will previously served as the Chief justice league” (Mail & Guardian be made to get to the bottom of Operations Officer at the online, March 7) “Zondo selects a State Capture, its causes, effects Department of Justice and crack team” (Business Day, March and the means of preventing it Constitutional Development. De 8), “State capture inquiry team from happening again”. – Daily Wee was also previously the Acting inspires confidence, hope” (The Maverick, March 9. Secretary General of the Office of Mercury, March 8), and “High- the Chief Justice. powered team on board for Zondo An announcement is expected inquiry” (The Herald, March 8). soon on the premises from which Terence Nombembe, former Auditor the Commission will operate. General of SA will be head of Civil society organisations also investigations for the Commission. welcomed the team announced “He will lead a team of investigators by the Deputy Chief Justice: T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 7 State of Capture Commission

M E E T T H E T E A M

Dr Khotso De Wee Isaac Vincent Maleka, SC

Terence MncedisiNombembe Leah Gcabashe, SC

Paul Joseph Pretorius, SC Thandi Victoria Norman

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 8 Polokwane Bar Council honours Judge President Makgoba

The Polokwane Bar Council hosted an annual dinner on November 25 to honour the Judge President of Limpopo Division of High Court, Judge Ephraim Makgoba for his leadership. The event was held at Fumani Lodge in the Waterberg District.

Judge President Makgoba with Adv Lindiwe Vilakazi of the Polokwane Society of Advocates

Colleagues, stakeholders and OCJ staff came together to honour JP Makgoba T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 9 J U D G E S T H R A S H O U T J U D I C I A L A C C O U N T A B I L I T Y M E C H A N I S M

By Yvonne van Niekerk

The Judiciary owes its relevance, significance A workshop was held on 11 – 12 December and support not just to the Constitution of the 2018, where 45 Judges from all the Superior country, its laws and institutions. It also owes its Courts met to discuss and finalise the Judicial credibility and admiration in the eyes of the Accountability report. The purpose was to public to the Judgments it delivers and the identify challenges that undermine the strategic priorities it is able to set for itself. The efficiency and effectiveness of the Judiciary. starting point is identifying key challenges that inhibit the Judiciary from meeting its The identification and exchange of best constitutional mandate to ensure access to practices and the setting of measurable targets Justice for all, efficiently and effectively. for court performance bears the ultimate aim of ensuring that the Judiciary regain control of Throughout the world the Judiciary remains litigation and court processes. It seeks to deal accountable to the people for the power and with the developing situation in which, thanks to authority bestowed upon it. Chief Justice a heightened understanding of constitutionally Mogoeng Mogoeng has emphasised that the mandated judicial independence, it is no longer Judiciary should be responsible for setting its appropriate for any other institution to report on own performance indicators and targets for the the state of the Judiciary. Instead, Judges must purpose of accountability, evaluation of its now speak for themselves about their progress performance and identifying areas that require and problems. improvement. This was a truly momentous moment for the The Heads of Court established a sub- Judiciary. Historically there were no committee, chaired by Judge President Hlophe, accountability mechanisms to allow the on Judicial Accountability to address the Judiciary to report on court performance and following issues: other matters related to the exercise of its constitutional mandate. Traditionally Judges a) What should Judges do to improve accounted through their judgments, with the court performance; Executive reporting on court performance and b) What is the most effective way of related budget matters. gathering statistics; c) How should the Judiciary communicate Deputy Chief Justice Zondo delivered the effectively its work to the public keynote address at the workshop. He drew (progress made; the challenges and from his experience as a Judge President and the required resources); and addressed the Judges on matters relating to d) How best the Judiciary can ensure that proper management of judicial performance. it reviews its targets on an on-going basis.

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 1 0 Judicial Accountability

He said that “as our democracy matures and develops and the principle of judicial independence becomes more crystallised, it becomes necessary for the Judiciary to develop its own way of being accountable to the people it serves.”

The Judges spent the two days deliberating and discussing what criteria should be used when Deputy Chief Justice Zondo delivered a Judge President Hlophe is the Chair of the reporting on Court keynote address at the workshop. Committee on Judicial Accountability. Performance and how best to indicate and measure whether the Judiciary is improving or not? Critical indicators were discussed and the lively debates ensured the fine-tuning of targets the Judiciary have set for themselves.

The workshop also endorsed the idea of a Legal Week where the Judiciary would report on its performance to the public at large and in so Judge President Shongwe addressing the Deputy Judge President Musi addressing workshop. the workshop during a presentation. doing be transparent and accountable on its Constitutional Mandate.

During his closing address, Judge President Hlophe said that “The time has now come for the Judiciary to take the lead on accounting to the public for its work, and for the power and authority the state has endowed on them.”

Forty-five Judges from all the Superior Courts attended the workshop.

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 1 1 Enhancing Judicial Excellence

The South African Judicial Education Institute The South African Judicial Education (SAJEI) kicked off 2018 by hosting their first Institute (SAJEI) was established in terms of workshop for Judicial Educators and Guest the South African Judicial Institute Act 14 of Facilitators. 2008 in order to:

The three-day workshop focused on facilitation (a) provide proper, appropriate and skills, developing effective curriculum programmes, transformational judicial education as well as on how to employ systematic methods and training, having due regard to for planning and conducting judicial programmes. both our inherited legacy and our new constitutional dispensation; and The workshop was held from 8 to 10 January 2018 at SAJEI training centre at the OCJ National Office (b) offer judicial education and training to in Midrand. aspiring and newly appointed Judicial Officers as well as continuing training The main objectives of the workshop were to equip for Judicial Officers. judicial facilitators with judicial skills required to develop learner-centred educational programmes, and also to recognise the difference between adults SAJEI is led by a Council consisting of 24 and children’s curriculum. members who are largely from the Judiciary. Other stakeholders such as The workshop was conducted by Mr John Meeks of Advocates, Attorneys, Academics as well as the National Centre for State Courts in the United Traditional Leaders form part of the Council. States of America. Meeks is a frequent presenter at judicial branch education programmes on the topics of adult education, faculty development, curriculum development and leadership.

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 1 2 SA Judiciary meets with Judges from neighbouring states to share experiences on the adjudication of organised crimes

Human trafficking, wildlife signalled that the Judiciary is The following topics were covered trafficking and money laundering acknowledging that it is faced with during the seminar: cases have become constant in challenges. Nature and extent of wildlife the court rolls of the Judiciary. trafficking in Africa: Issues and Combating human trafficking, “In a seminar like this one it is where Challenge, by Dr Joseph Okori, wildlife trafficking and money we learn from one another and also Regional Director IFAW Southern laundering has become a global share experiences with other Judges Africa. concern, with different structures from our neighbouring countries”, Complexities in adjudicating identifying gaps in legislation and said Deputy Chief Justice Zondo. Human Trafficking cases in the criminal justice system on the South Africa, by Justice C complexities of adjudicating cases The Deputy Chief Justice also Mocumie (Supreme Court of of this nature. mentioned that, of the three topics, Appeal), Judge R. Henney money laundering was the most (Western Cape Division of High During 17-19 January 2018, challenging. “Money laundering is a Court, Judge N. Ranchod (North members of the South African global phenomenon, with the United of High Court), Judiciary and Judges from Kenya, States, Italy and Russia being the Judge M. Mabesele (South Mozambique and Tanzania top three countries faced with this Gauteng Division of High Court) attended a Seminar hosted by the illegal activity… The International and Deputy Judge President P. South African Judicial Education Monetary Fund estimated that Goliath. Institute (SAJEI) in the Limpopo between 2% to 5% of the global Adjudicating transnational Province to exchange knowledge economy involves laundered Human Trafficking cases, by in dealing with these matters. money,” said the Deputy Chief Justice (Dr) P. Kihwelo Justice. (Mozambique) and Deputy Judge The Deputy Chief Justice of the President C. Mu. Republic of South Africa, Justice He also expressed serious concerns International Adoptions and Child Raymond Zondo, gave the regarding wildlife trafficking, stating Trafficking, by Justice Z. Tshiqi keynote address. In his address, that the Judiciary and the law (Supreme Court of Appeal). Deputy Chief Justice Zondo enforcement agencies are faced with Unpacking complex instruments thanked the organisers of the a number of challenges when of proceeds from Money seminar for focusing on the investigating and adjudicating wildlife Laundering (e.g. Trusts, chosen topics, stating that it cases. Corporations and Companies), demonstrated commitment and by Mr Pedro Gomes Pereira.

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 1 3 Deputy Chief Justice Ray Zondo gave a keynote address at Deputy Judge President of the Limpopo Division of the High the opening of the workshop. Court, Judge Fikile Mokgohloa

Judges from South African and neighbouring Judicial jurisdictions with Deputy Chief Justice Zondo.

Justice tshiqi, Deputy Judge Pressident Mokgohloa and Judge President Frans Legodi, Mpumalanga Division of the Judge President Legodi. High Court.

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 1 4 Upskilling for Aspirant District Magistrates

A total of 160 Magistrates from different provinces a range of critical issues faced by the Judiciary on a converged in Kempton Park, Gauteng, to attend the daily basis. Aspirant District Magistrate Training programme, conducted by the South African Judicial Education During the opening ceremony, Chief Magistrate J. Institute (SAJEI). The workshops took place between 4 Ikaneng from North West addressed the magistrates February and 2 March 2018. on “The Role of the Magistrate, Integrity of the Profession, the do’s and don’ts of the profession”. The programme was aimed at advancing the Aspirant The keynote address was delivered by Judge T.P. Magistrates’ skills in children’s court, child justice, Mudau of the Gauteng Division of the High Court. In criminal court, family court, civil court, and judgment his address, he talked about the role of the writing. During this period, the Magistrates engaged Magistrates in a constitutional dispensation. on

The Aspirant District Magistrate Training programme began in earnest on 4 February 2018. Minister of Justice and Correctional Services, Adv TM Masutha, MP addressed the Aspirant Magistrates words of encouragment.

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 1 5 T H E “ G E N T L E M A N J U D G E ” R E M E M B E R E D By Pfunzo Mafenya

As has been a long standing practice of the SA In his tribute, former Judge President of the Judiciary to honour late Judges for their Gauteng Division of the High Court, Bernard contributions to the bench, the Judiciary came Ngoepe, said he learnt from Judge Eloff that when together to remember the late Transvaal Judge difficult matters arose at the Court, as the head he President, Frikkie Eloff, who passed away in must avail himself. He also remembered the late December 2017 at the age of 92. Judge’s work ethic by telling a story of how Judge Eloff once denied long leave to another Judge in On February 27, members of the Judiciary, Eloff the Johannesburg High Court, demanding that he family members and the legal fraternity, gathered at deliver judgments for all his cases before leave the Pretoria High Court for a ceremonial sitting, held could be granted. in remembrance of the “Gentleman Judge”, as he was popularly known. “Who on earth could be Judge Eloff, except the man himself? I aspired to be him, but I could not Judge President Eloff was well-known for presiding be him,” said former Judge President Ngoepe. over the Chris Hani case and his sentencing of the South African Communist Party (SACP) leader's Speaking on behalf of Law Society of the Northern killers to death. He was also the Judge who swore- Province, Mr Gule said Judge President Eloff was in to office the late former President Nelson an eminent jurist who mentored many others. Mandela’s cabinet after the 1994 democratic “Former Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Mosekene elections. ascended to the bench through the late Judge [Eloff],” he said. Speaking during the ceremonial sitting, Judge President of the Gauteng Division of High Court, On behalf of the NPA, Adv Andrew Chauke Judge Dunstan Mlambo, spoke about Judge Eloff’s remembered the late Judge as a remarkable family history and their role during the apartheid era. Judge who was fair on all his decisions. Advocate Green from the Johannesburg Society of Judge Mlambo described Judge President Eloff as Advocates described him as an officer of the law, someone who struggled to come to terms with the who enjoyed his law career regardless of the changes of 1994, especially with the transformation challenges that comes with the job. “He received of the Judiciary. But he commended him for many honorary awards for his work”, he added. later embracing the transformative imperative ushered in by the Constitution. He also described The former Judge was buried on December 12, him as a jurist who held on to legal principles. “We 2017, in a private ceremony. A formal funeral was know of his Judgments in the Chris Hani murder trial held on January 15, 2018, in Pretoria where his and the Mandela vs Mandela divorce matter”, he former colleagues and peers paid their last said. respects.

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 1 6 The Gentleman Judge

The Judges of the Gauteng Division of the High Court paid homage to former Judge President Eloff, together with members of his family and those form the legal fraternity

The Eloff Family Mr T Joubert from the Gauteng Attorneys Association

William Moadi from the Black Lawyers Association Adv C Eloff, son of the late Judge Eloff

T H E J U D I C I A R Y | 1 7 Superior Courts Contact Information

Constitutional Court Supreme Court of Appeal Gauteng Division, Pretoria

Tel: +27 11 359 7400 Tel: +27 51 412 7400 Tel: 012 315 7711 Fax: +27 11 339 5098 Fax: +27 51 412 7449 Fax: 012 326 1995 Private Bag x 1 Constitutional Hill Braamfontein PO Box 258, Bloemfontein, Free State, 9300 2017 Cnr President Brand & Elizabeth Streets, Private Bag x 67, Pretoria, 0001 1 Hospital Road, Braamfontein, Johannesburg, Bloemfontein, 9300 Cnr Paul Kruger & Madiba Streets, Pretoria, 0002 2017 GPS: E 26.21675; S -29.11563 GPS: E 28.18784; S -25.7449 GPS: E 28.04336; S -26.1882 Registrar: Ms CH Van der Merwe Pretoria High Court Palace of Justice Registrar: Mr K Makgakga E-mail: [email protected] Tel: 012 314 9000 E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.justice.gov.za/ Website: www.constitutionalcourt.org.za Chief Registrar: Mr.S.D.Mniki E-mail: [email protected] Free State Division, Bloemfontein Northern Cape Division, Kimberly Western Cape Division, Cape Town Tel: 051 406 8100 Tel: 053 833 1441 Fax: 051 430 7041 Tel: 021 480 2411/2636 Fax: 053 831 1320 Fax: 021 423 0412 Private Bag x 20612, Bloemfontein, 9300 Private Bag x 5043, Kimberley, 8300 cnr Fountain & Pres Brand Street, Private Bag x 9020, Cape Town, 8000 Sol Plaatje Drive, Kimberley, 8301 Bloemfontein, 9300 35 Keerom Street, Cape Town, 8001 GPS: E 24.76783; S -28.74564 GPS: E 26.21739; S -29.11858 GPS: E 18.41752; S -33.925

Registrar: Mr C Conradie Chief Registrar: Mr S Mapossa Chief Registrar: Ms Ruanne David E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected]

Limpopo Division, Polokwane KwaZulu-Natal Division, Durban Mpumalanga Division, Nelspruit Polokwane Circuit Court Tel: 031 362 5800 Tel: 013 345 8211 Tel: 015 230 4000 Fax: 031 305 4550 Fax: 033 345 3815 Fax: 015 230 4200 Private Bag x 54314, Durban, 4000 Private Bag x 9014, Pietermartizburg, 3200 Private Bag x9696, Polokwane, 0700 12 Dullah Omar (Masonic) Grove, Durban, 301 Church Street, Pietermarizburg, 3200 36 Biccard and Bodenstein Street, 4001 GPS: E 30.3805; S -29.599 Polokwane, 0700 GPS: E 31.01921; S -29.86172 Chief Registrar: Mr M Seloana Chief Registrar: Ms M Phaswane Acting Chief Registrar: E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected] Ms Tanisa Mahomed-Hanif E-mail: [email protected] Labour and Labour Appeal Court Johannesburg Land Claims Court National Office address: Tel: 011 359 5700 Fax: 011 403 9328 Tel: 011 781 2291 188 14th ROAD Email: [email protected] Fax: 011 781 2217 / 2218 Noordwyk Private Bag X10060, Randburg 2125 Midrand Private Bag x52, Braamfontein, 2017 Trust Bank Centre, Randburg Mall, Corner of 1685 Arbour Square Building, 6th and 7th Floor Hill Street and Kent Avenue, Randburg, 2194 c/o Juta & Melle Street GPS: E 28.00083; S -26.09232 Switchboard number Braamfontein, 2001 010 493 2500 Registrar: Mr Stephen Cindi Registrar: Ms F.N Ntuli Email: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.justice.gov.za Website: www.justice.gov.za/labourcourt