Out of the Straitjacket. Michael Weinstein Thomas Jefferson University, [email protected]

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Out of the Straitjacket. Michael Weinstein Thomas Jefferson University, Michael.Weinstein@Jefferson.Edu Thomas Jefferson University Jefferson Digital Commons Department of Surgery Faculty Papers Department of Surgery 3-1-2018 Out of the Straitjacket. Michael Weinstein Thomas Jefferson University, [email protected] Let us know how access to this document benefits ouy Follow this and additional works at: https://jdc.jefferson.edu/surgeryfp Part of the Mental and Social Health Commons, and the Surgery Commons Recommended Citation Weinstein, Michael, "Out of the Straitjacket." (2018). Department of Surgery Faculty Papers. Paper 154. https://jdc.jefferson.edu/surgeryfp/154 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Jefferson Digital Commons. The effeJ rson Digital Commons is a service of Thomas Jefferson University's Center for Teaching and Learning (CTL). The ommonC s is a showcase for Jefferson books and journals, peer-reviewed scholarly publications, unique historical collections from the University archives, and teaching tools. The effeJ rson Digital Commons allows researchers and interested readers anywhere in the world to learn about and keep up to date with Jefferson scholarship. This article has been accepted for inclusion in Department of Surgery Faculty Papers by an authorized administrator of the Jefferson Digital Commons. For more information, please contact: [email protected]. PERSPECTIVE Friction in the Path to Use of Biosimilar Drugs 2016, and growth in spending has From the Department of Health Care Policy, comments on its guidance for industry on Harvard Medical School, Boston. the “nonproprietary naming of biological been averaging 10% per year re- products; draft guidance for industry; avail- cently. Thus, competition creates 1 . IQVIA Institute for Human Data Science. ability.” October 27, 2015. the potential for considerable sav- Medicines use and spending in the U.S.: a re- 4 . Baumgärtel C. Australian medicines view of 2016 and outlook to 2021. May 2017. authority positive towards biosimilar inter- ings — but if the impediments 2 . Cohen H, Beydoun D, Chien D, et al. changeability. GaBi J 2017; 6: 41. continue, important savings will Awareness, knowledge and perceptions of 5 . Price WN II, Rai AK. Manufacturing probably be left on the table. biosimilars among specialty physicians. Adv barriers to biologics competition and inno- Ther 2017; 33: 2160-72. vation. Iowa Law Rev 2016; 101: 1023-63. Disclosure forms provided by the author 3 . Federal Trade Commission Staff. Com- DOI: 10.1056/NEJMp1714908 are available at NEJM.org. ment to the FDA in response to a request for CopyrightFriction in the Path to Use of Biosimilar Drugs © 2018 Massachusetts Medical Society. Out of the Straitjacket Out of the Straitjacket Michael S. Weinstein, M.D., M.B.E. see him, maybe not so clearly. differently from some of his edu- ternating with 48 hours off, to I He is in isolation, in a strait- cators and emulate the many maximize the consecutive hours jacket. He’s just been committed, who inspired him. we could spend with family or given a shot of haloperidol after I know all these intimate de- friends. They call it “residency” he resisted going to the locked tails because I am this surgeon- for a reason, we were told. ward. He kicked, screamed, patient. I became an acute care sur- yelled, threatened . and geon, commonly known as a now he cries. trauma surgeon. We are the In the middle of elective ones who respond on a mo- inpatient electroconvulsive ment’s notice to care for the therapy for treatment-resis- seriously injured. We remove tant depression, he had be- unwanted appendices as well come profoundly depressed, as desired limbs. I remem- delirious, and hopeless. He’d ber the pain, early in resi- lost faith in treatment and dency, of witnessing a young in reasons to live. He with- man who had lost both his drew to bed and would not arms in an electrical inci- get up or eat. He had to be dent, but my recollection of committed for his own safe- the countless limbs I subse- ty. Several security guards quently removed is vague or had to forcefully remove him nonexistent. from his bed. We attend to critical ill- He happened to be a 48- ness and have tools that save year-old surgeon who worked people’s lives, but sometimes in an academic medical cen- I know I have used them to ter. He had gone to medical My training occurred before extend life too long. We face and school intending to become a work-hour regulations were creat- witness death on a daily basis. family doctor like his father. He ed. Every-third-night call was the We care tremendously about the never imagined becoming a sur- norm; every-other-night was com- welfare of our patients, their geon; he thought surgeons were mon. On one rotation, we were families, our trainees, our col- pompous, and that’s being kind. “rewarded” with being the opera- leagues and coworkers, though I But he fell in love with surgery tive resident on post-call days, haven’t always shown that care — the decisiveness, the immedi- which extended our shift to near- as well as I could. We often make ate “cure,” the bravado. He prom- ly 36 hours. On my trauma rota- decisions in the face of uncer- ised himself he would behave tion, we took 48-hour shifts al- tainty that deeply affect our pa- n engl j med 378;9 nejm.org March 1, 2018 793 The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org at THOMAS JEFFERSON UNIVERSITY on March 20, 2018. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright © 2018 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved. PERSPECTIVE Out of the Straitjacket tients’ lives. When things went knew how to listen and under- I wanted out, out of work and wrong, I frequently blamed my- stood my world. I endured. I com- out of life. I wished I would get self. I learned that doubt, igno- pleted residency and fellowship hit by a car, and sometimes took rance, and lack of confidence and continued to endure for 16 steps to increase my risk. I felt were my own failings. years. Outside observers might trapped in my work and worried As attending staff, I still take have perceived me as “having it that I would expose my short- 24- to 36-hour “shifts” of in-house all”: a surgeon with leadership comings if I sought a leave or call. A third to half of my week- promise, with an amazing wife disclosed my feelings. I’ve sub- ends may be spent in the hospi- and two great kids, who’s paid sequently learned that my col- tal. Early in my career, I even more than I ever expected to earn. leagues were quite concerned covered full weekends in the hos- But enduring is not thriving. about me but found me unrecep- pital, a 72-hour shift, in order to I had heard of burnout but didn’t tive to attempts to help. I was have more whole weekends with really comprehend it. And though trying to get help in many ways, my family — and probably to I had mental illness, I still saw but nothing seemed to work. demonstrate my machismo. it as a weakness, a personal fault. My functioning continued to One might have predicted my I remember early in my career decline until I could barely inter- act with others. My wife forced me to see my family doctor, who My work lost meaning; I was just going insisted I take a medical leave. through the motions. I thought everything I went electively to a psychiatric hospital. It was humiliating. I was I tried to accomplish was a failure. scared, and I was certain my ca- reer was over. I had trouble relating to patients I went through a full course and felt the urge to avoid encounters of electroconvulsive therapy and other treatments and felt better altogether. I cared less and less for a while. I even returned to work, prematurely. My depression about anything I was doing. came back with a vengeance. My severe psychological pain was fall. I have had depression and hearing of a colleague who took unrelenting. I was suicidal and dysthymia since my teen years. a leave of absence for a “nervous developing a plan to take all the When I was a third-year resident breakdown.” I joked about it, said pills I had. Even as I held onto with increasing operative inde- he was weak. Now it was my turn. the love of my children and wife, pendence, a couple of surgical My work lost meaning; I was my brain told me they would be complications threw me into a just going through the motions. better off without me. I contem- funk. I convinced myself that I I thought everything I tried to plated death, though I feared the shouldn’t be a surgeon. I wasn’t accomplish was a failure. I had finality — perhaps death would good enough, technically or cog- trouble relating to patients and be even worse than what I was nitively. I didn’t have the forti- felt the urge to avoid encounters experiencing. tude. I was a fake. altogether. I cared less and less You would not be reading this I didn’t know what to do with about anything I was doing. I today were it not for the love of these feelings. I didn’t believe didn’t know it then, but I had my wife, my children, my mother anyone around me had similar long experienced classic signs of and sister, and so many others, thoughts. I didn’t know how to burnout: emotional exhaustion, including the guards and doctors talk to my coresidents or faculty depersonalization, and low per- who “locked me up” against my about medical mistakes and the ceived personal achievement.
Recommended publications
  • The Effect of Contact Precautions on Healthcare Worker Activity in Acute Care Hospitals Author(S): Daniel J
    The Effect of Contact Precautions on Healthcare Worker Activity in Acute Care Hospitals Author(s): Daniel J. Morgan, MD, MS; Lisa Pineles, MA; Michelle Shardell, PhD; Margaret M. Graham, MPH; Shahrzad Mohammadi, BS, MPH; Graeme N. Forrest, MBBS; Heather S. Reisinger, PhD; Marin L. Schweizer, PhD; Eli N. Perencevich, MD, MS Reviewed work(s): Source: Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology, Vol. 34, No. 1 (January 2013), pp. 69-73 Published by: The University of Chicago Press on behalf of The Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/668775 . Accessed: 17/12/2012 01:25 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. The University of Chicago Press and The Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded on Mon, 17 Dec 2012 01:25:08 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions infection control and hospital epidemiology january 2013, vol. 34, no. 1 original article The Effect of Contact Precautions on Healthcare Worker Activity in Acute Care Hospitals Daniel J.
    [Show full text]
  • ELECTRICAL GUIDE for HEALTH FACILITIES REVIEW
    ELECTRICAL GUIDE for HEALTH FACILITIES REVIEW HOSPITALS SKILLED NURSING FACILITIES AND CLINICS 2016 Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development Facilities Development Division Revised 3/1/2017 OSHPD 2016 Electrical Guide for Health Facilities Review Forward The Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD) is responsible for enforcing all building standards, codes, and regulations pertaining to hospitals, skilled nursing facilities, and under specific circumstances, clinics in the State of California. The following document was compiled by the OSHPD electrical engineering staff as a guide for plan review to verify compliance and is intended for OSHPD use. All others who use this information for any other purpose do so with the full knowledge that it may not contain every requirement or change in policy and that the requirements are as interpreted by OSHPD. Title 24, Part 3, California Electrical Code, as well as other parts of Title 24, apply in the design and construction of health care facilities. This guide highlights and summarizes the most common requirements encountered in the review of hospitals, skilled nursing facilities, and clinics. This document may not contain every requirement or change in policy and the requirements are as interpreted by OSHPD. All projects submitted on or after January 1, 2016, are subject to the 2016 California Electrical Code (CEC) which is based on the 2014 National Electrical Code (NEC) with the 2016 California amendments. Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development Facilities Development Division www.oshpd.ca.gov 2 | Page Revised 3/1/17 OSHPD 2016 Electrical Guide for Health Facilities Review Table of Contents Plan Submittal Check List ................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Guidance: Discontinuing Additional Precautions Related to COVID- 19 for Admitted Patients in Acute Care and in High-Risk Outpatient Areas
    Interim Guidance: Discontinuing Additional Precautions Related to COVID- 19 for Admitted Patients in Acute Care and in High-Risk Outpatient Areas May 21, 2021 This guidance is intended for health-care providers working in acute care settings including infection prevention and control; workplace health and safety and public health teams; direct care providers (e.g., physicians, nurse practitioners, nurses); patient access and flow teams; and unit and site leadership. Contents Scope ..............................................................................................................................................................2 Purpose ...........................................................................................................................................................2 How to Use This Document ................................................................................................................................2 Considerations for Determining Duration of Additional Precautions ..................................................................3 Use of a Test-Based Strategy........................................................................................................................4 Definitions of Key Concepts ................................................................................................................................5 General ....................................................................................................................................................5
    [Show full text]
  • United States Ex Rel. Integra Med Analytics, LLC V
    Case 5:17-cv-00886-DAE Document 29 Filed 08/05/19 Page 1 of 17 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS SAN ANTONIO DIVISION UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ex § No. 5:17-CV-886-DAE rel. INTEGRA MED ANALYTICS, § LLC, § § Plaintiff, § § vs. § § BAYLOR SCOTT & WHITE § HEALTH, BAYLOR UNIVERSITY § MEDICAL CENTER-DALLAS, § HILLCREST BAPTIST MEDICAL § CENTER, SCOTT & WHITE § HOSPITAL-ROUND ROCK, § SCOTT & WHITE HOSPITAL § TEMPLE, § § Defendants. § ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS (DKT. # 21) Before the Court is a Motion to Dismiss filed by Defendants Baylor Scott & White Health, Baylor University Medical Center-Dallas, Hillcrest Baptist Medical Center, Scott & White Hospital-Round Rock, and Scott & White Hospital Temple (collectively “Defendants”). (Dkt. # 21.) Pursuant to Local Rule CV-7(h), the Court finds these matters suitable for disposition without a hearing. After careful consideration of the memoranda filed in support of and in opposition to the 1 Case 5:17-cv-00886-DAE Document 29 Filed 08/05/19 Page 2 of 17 motion, the Court—for the reasons that follow—GRANTS Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss. (Id.) BACKGROUND I. Factual Background Defendants in this qui tam action are the operator of a network of inpatient short-term acute care hospitals and four of its affiliated hospitals. (Dkt. # 151 at 3.) Part of the services Defendants perform are for patients covered by Medicare, and therefore Defendants regularly submit requests to Medicare for reimbursement for these services. (Id.) As such, these request for reimbursement are subject to the False Claims Act (“FCA”), and knowingly presenting false or fraudulent claims to the Government for reimbursement is illegal and incurs civil liability.2 31 U.S.C.
    [Show full text]
  • An Alternative Payment Model for Delivering Acute Care in the Home
    Personalized Recovery Care Program Home Hospitalization: An Alternative Payment Model for Delivering Acute Care in the Home A Proposal to the Physician-Focused Payment Model Technical Advisory Committee From Personalized Recovery Care, LLC October 27, 2017 Personalized Recovery Care, LLC Contact: Narayana S. Murali President/Chief Executive Officer, Marshfield Clinic Health System Hospitals, Inc. Chief Clinical Strategy Officer, Marshfield Clinic Health System 1000 North Oak Avenue Marshfield, Wisconsin 54449 Phone: 715-387-5253 Email: [email protected] Personalized Recovery Care, LLC 1000 North Oak Avenue Marshfield, Wisconsin 54449 October 27, 2017 Physician-Focused Payment Model Technical Advisory Committee C/o U.S. DHHS Asst. Secretary for Planning and Evaluation Office of Health Policy 200 Independence Avenue S.W. Washington, D.C. 20201 [email protected] Cover Letter– Personalized Recovery Care, LLC, Home Hospitalization: An Alternative Model for Delivering Acute Care in the Home Dear Committee Members, On behalf of Personalized Recovery Care, LLC (“PRC”), a joint venture between Marshfield Clinic and Contessa Health, I respectfully submit this proposal for a Physician-Focused Payment Model entitled “Home Hospitalization: An Alternative Model for Delivering Acute Care in the Home” for PTAC review. PRC proposes to launch this model for Medicare Fee-For-Service patients at Marshfield Clinic, with the goal of expanding it to physicians and settings across the country. PRC welcomes the opportunity to engage with PTAC Advisory Committee to test this model where physicians could provide hospital level care delivery to Medicare fee-for-service beneficiaries in their homes for a meaningful number of medical and surgical conditions. PRC is committed to and has demonstrated high quality of care focused on superior outcomes, excellence in patient experience and lower health care costs.
    [Show full text]
  • Interim Guidance for Discharge to Home Or New/Re-Admission to Congregate Living Settings and Discontinuing Transmission-Based Precautions
    MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH Interim Guidance for Discharge to Home or New/Re-Admission to Congregate Living Settings and Discontinuing Transmission-Based Precautions 6/4/2021 Community transmission of SARS-CoV-2 in Minnesota continues to lead to COVID-19 illness and hospitalizations. Ensuring hospital bed capacity for individuals who require acute care is directly related to the ability to discharge COVID-19 patients to settings equipped to provide appropriate care while maintaining the safety of other vulnerable residents. Minnesota Department of Health (MDH) recommends that patients with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 be discharged when clinically indicated. Discontinuation of Transmission-Based Precautions nor negative COVID-19 test results are not required prior to hospital discharge.1 This guidance addresses discharging hospital inpatients or congregate living settings residents to home or congregate living settings. This guidance also addresses discontinuation of Transmission-Based Precautions in hospitals and congregate living settings. Congregate living settings include assisted living and skilled nursing facilities, or other congregate living settings that provide direct care. All facilities providing health care should address source control,2 eye protection, and staff monitoring and exclusion policies.3 Discharge of an inpatient or resident to home Patients or residents with confirmed or suspected COVID-19 can be discharged to home when it is clinically indicated. These recommendations are relevant when no additional health services are needed and when ongoing home health care (e.g., skilled nursing, physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, social work) is appropriate. Home isolation can be discontinued following a symptom-based strategy.1 . Caregivers should be educated on care procedures and visitation restrictions in the home for confirmed or suspected COVID-19 patients.4 .
    [Show full text]
  • Not for Distribution
    14 THE STRAITJACKET, THE BED, AND THE PILL Material culture and madness Benoît Majerus The seat [. .] consists of a sinkhole (a), a pot (b), discharge pipes (c) ventilation tubes (d). The whole device is covered up to the mouth of the sinkhole and the pot with wood; the pot is closed with a screwable tight lid. Sinkhole and pot are constructed like faïence tubes and have a wall thickness of 0.1’. [. .] The inside diameter of the upper sinkhole measures 1.0’, the lower only 0:27’.1 The proliferation of asylums in the nineteenth century2 resulted in an exhaustive and prescriptive literature, which went beyond discussion on the cardinal architectural principles to elaborate upon spaces for the insane. Any self-respecting psychiatrist had to take Taylorinto account the materiality and of these newFrancis places. If this aspect was gradu- ally abandoned during the second half of the nineteenth century – Emile Kraepelin and GeorgeNot Beard, for instance, for were distribution more interested in nosological issues – the first half of the nineteenth century saw many psychiatrists, such as the likes of Joseph Guislain3 or Etienne Esquirol,4 debating the (future) materiality of institutions for the insane. These treatises offer easy access for anyone interested in the material culture of asylums.5 The excerpt quoted above is taken from this corpus. In 1869, the German physician Emil Fries published a booklet devoted to the construction of toilets in asylums. Without wishing to declare a toilet an objet social total that might unravel the entire history of psychiatry, the object such as imagined by Fries nevertheless allows us to address several facets of psychiatric history and to uncover the potential of a nar- rative that is mindful of material culture: the importance attached to drilling patients through hygiene education, a history of odours inside asylums, the difficulty in man- aging persons suspected of misusing even such mundane objects as toilets.
    [Show full text]
  • Nordic Health Care Systems Pb:Nordic Health Care Systems Pb 11/8/09 14:04 Page 1
    Nordic Health Care Systems pb:Nordic Health Care Systems pb 11/8/09 14:04 Page 1 Nordic Health Care Systems Recent Reforms and Current Policy Challenges European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies Series “The book is very valuable as actual information about the health systems in the Nordic countries and the changes that have been made during the last two decades. It informs well both about the similarities within the ‘Nordic Health Model’ and the important differences that exist between the countries.” Bo Könberg, County Governor, Former Minister of Health and Social Insurance in Sweden (1991-1994) “The publishing of this book about the Nordic health care systems is a major Nordic Health Care Systems event for those interested not only in Nordic health policy and health systems but also for everybody interested in comparative health policy and health systems. It is the first book in its kind. It covers the four “large” Nordic countries, Denmark, Norway, Sweden and Finland, and does so in a very systematically comparative way. The book is well organized, covers “everything” and is analytically sophisticated.” Ole Berg, Professor of Health Management, University of Oslo This book examines recent patterns of health reform in Nordic health care systems, and the balance between stability and change in how these systems have developed. Nordic Health Care Systems The health systems in Norway, Denmark, Sweden and Finland are investigated through detailed comparisons along a variety of policy-driven parameters. The following themes are explored: Recent Reforms and Current Policy Challenges • Politicians, patients, and professions Financing, production, and distribution • &Saltman Magnussen,Vrangbaek • The role of the primary health sector • The role of public health • Internal management mechanisms • Impact of the European Union The book probes the impact of these topics and then contrasts the development across all four coumntries, allowing the reader to gain a sense of perspective both on the individual systems as well as on the region as a whole.
    [Show full text]
  • The Importance of Home and Community-Based Settings in Population Health Management
    The importance of home and community-based settings in population health management Nathan Cohen Dieter van de Craen Andrija Stamenovic Charles Lagor Philips Home Monitoring March 2013 Philips Healthcare 2 Furthermore, the new strategies require Executive Summary technologies to support health care providers in delivering population health. This paper is the first of a series of white papers that Philips has published on population health management. It provides a summary of the The Cost, Quality and Access implications of the health care reform on the financial risks being placed on healthcare Conundrum providers in the United States. It emphasizes Managing Chronic Disease the importance of the home and community- based settings in population health The growth in health expenditures is driven by management. In doing so, it sets the stage for multiple factors. One critical factor is the rising other white papers that describe actual incidence of chronic diseases, which the approaches to leverage remote health Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has management offerings for population health estimated now account for 75% of the cost of management. medical care. Patients with Chronic disease make up only 20% of Medicare patients yet account for 80% of expenditures. These Introduction patients have higher rates of unnecessary hospital admissions and take many Health care expenditures have been rising medications to manage their conditions. unsustainably across the globe. Alone in the Traditional fee-for-service payment models United States, for example, health care that pay for treatment transactions are ill- expenditures in 2010 reached $2.6 trillion, over suited for serving patients that require close ten times the $250 billion expended in 1980.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 7—Acute Care Inpatient/Outpatient Hospital Services Chapter 7: Acute Care Inpatient/ Outpatient Hospital Services
    Chapter 7—Acute Care Inpatient/Outpatient Hospital Services Chapter 7: Acute Care Inpatient/ Outpatient Hospital Services Executive Summary Description Acute care hospitals are the largest group of enrolled hospital providers. Kansas Medicaid has 144 acute care hospitals, 5 state institutions, 5 rehabilitation hospitals, and 3 psychiatric hospitals en- rolled within the state. Over 540 similar out-of-state hospitals are also enrolled. All but nine of Kansas 105 counties have an acute care hospital: two-thirds of those (68) have just one. Most in- patient hospitals are reimbursed based on diagnosis related groups (DRG) with rates that vary as a proportion of Medicare. Outpatient hospitals are reimbursed as fee-for-service. Key Points In 2005, legislation funded a DRG rate increase through a hospital provider assessment. Overall spending on inpatient services has increased each year. The majority of top DRGs by reimbursement are related to births and the majority of reim- bursements based on procedure codes are related to the emergency room visits. KHPA updates the DRGs and realigns (but does not increase overall) payment rates each year with the annual Medicare DRG updates. However, KHPA frequently receives the DRG updates late in the year making it difficult to implement them by January 1, resulting in administrative challenges. In 2007, Medicare’s payment update included a significant adjustment in many DRG rates, along with the addition of many new DRGs, to better reflect the true costs of care in general versus specialty hospitals. KHPA was not able to make these changes in 2007, but is planning to incorporate these more significant changes in January 2009.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction of a Psychiatric Acute Care Clinic Into a Metropolitan Jail
    Introduction of a Psychiatric Acute Care Clinic into a Metropolitan Jail JOHN PETRICH. M.D.- Introduction Mentally ill individuals continue to be housed in metropolitan .jails to await trial or to serve short sentences'! Such patients frequently present seriom in-.jail management prob­ lems because of suicidal. assaultive and disruptive beha\"ior.~ A recent study estimated psychiatric morbidity in a metropolitan .jail to be 4.fi%.~ The majority of those patients suffered from psychotic psychiatric syndromes. Facilities for in-jail psychiatric treatment are seldom available.4 Out-of-jail facilities are resistant to providing services to prisoners.1i The literature on treatment of mentally disordered offenders describes prison.6-11 hospital!:! and outpatient program~!3. H which offer forensic. long-term care or rehabili­ tative therapy. No descriptions of programs designed to provide acute psychiatric care to jailed patients. except in the context of forensic programs.la could be identified. Community-oriented short-term hospitalization and crisis service\ are gaining wide acceptance in general psychiatric practice.1fl. 17 These techniques are considered to pro­ vide effectivelH• 19 and ecollomical21l treatment for most acute psychiatric disorders. They can be adapted to serve highly mobile and severely disturbed patients.!!1 Such approaches could be utilized to meet the psychiatric aCllte care needs of a metropolitan jail population. This paper describes the developmcnt and operation of a jail-based aCllte care psychi­ atric clinic which provides short-term and crisis-oriented psychiatric treatment and referral services fOT inmates suffering from psychotic iIlnc\\es and severe situational reactions. Method . The combined Seattle City and King County Jail facilitie~ prmide detention for indi­ VIduals arrested on felony and misdemeanor charges in King COUllty, 'Vashington, which has a population of I.
    [Show full text]
  • The Case for Interim Mental Health Legislation
    HHr Health and Human Rights Journal A Key, Not a Straitjacket: The Case for InterimHHR_final_logo_alone.indd Mental 1 10/19/15 10:53 AM Health Legislation Pending Complete Prohibition of Psychiatric Coercion in Accordance with the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities laura davidson Abstract The practice of coercion on the basis of psychosocial disability is plainly discriminatory. This has resulted in a demand from the Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (the CRPD Committee) for a paradigm shift away from the traditional biomedical model and a global ban on compulsion in the psychiatric context. However, that has not occurred. This paper considers conflicting pronouncements of the CRPD Committee and other United Nations bodies. Assuming the former’s interpretations of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disability (CRPD) are accurate, involuntary psychiatric detention and enforced treatment on the basis of psychosocial disability are prima facie discriminatory and unlawful practices. However, dedicated mental health legislation both permits discrimination and protects and enhances rights. This paper proposes a practical way out of the present impasse: the global introduction of interim “holding” legislation lacking full compliance with the CRPD. While imperfect, such a framework would facilitate a move toward a complete ban on psychiatric coercion. The paper outlines four essential ingredients that any interim legislation ought to contain, including clear timebound targets for full CRPD implementation. It concludes by urging the CRPD Committee to take the unprecedented step of issuing a general comment providing reluctant “permission” for the progressive realization of respect for articles 12 and 14 of the CRPD.
    [Show full text]