A Rhetorical History of the Politics of Respectability in Black Chicago, 1919 - 1939
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
WOMEN SPEAKING IN AND FOR INSTITUTIONS: A RHETORICAL HISTORY OF THE POLITICS OF RESPECTABILITY IN BLACK CHICAGO, 1919 - 1939 BY ANITA J. MIXON DISSERTATION Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Communication in the Graduate College of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2017 Urbana, Illinois Doctoral Committee: Professor Cara A. Finnegan, Chair Associate Professor John M. Murphy Associate Professor J. David Cisneros Professor Ronald W. Bailey ii Abstract Institutions have been vital to the survival and uplift of Black communities. To that end, this dissertation analyzes how Black women -- as economic agents and women of faith -- used rhetoric within institutions to advocate and uplift their enclaved communities. Specifically, my dissertation explores how Black women used the discourse of labor unions and the Black Church to promote their enclaved communities in Black Chicago from 1919 to 1939. Black women often shouldered the work to help a community thrive and, while they may not be the public face of Black communities, their productivity in Black churches and labor unions challenges the male- centric narrative that Black men are more harmed by oppressive and discriminatory practices and, therefore, are in greater need of community initiatives, legislation, and protection. Through a rhetorical analysis of institutional documents from two labor unions and two Black churches that span across 20 years - including the boiling over of racial tensions, height of Black entrepreneurship, and the Great Depression - I demonstrate how Black women, both constrained and enabled by politics of respectability, worked as economic agents in defense of their labor/in advocating for greater economic equity for Black folk. My focus on the lived experiences of Black, urban Midwestern women thickens our understanding of concepts like institutions, community, identity-formation, civil rights, and citizenship. iii Acknowledgments First, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my dissertation director, Dr. Cara Finnegan, and committee members Dr. John Murphy, Dr. J. David Cisneros, and Dr. Ronald Bailey for their generous feedback, mentorship, and encouragement as I navigated through the dissertation process and my academic career at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Each member of my dissertation committee has taught me a great deal about research and life in the academy and I can never give enough credit to the examples that they provided as professors and mentors. Second, this work would not have been possible without the financial support of the Black Metropolis Research Consortium at the University of Chicago, the Illinois Programming for Research in the Humanities Fellowship, and the University of Illinois at Urbana- Champaign’s Department of Communication summer dissertation completion fellowship. Special thanks to the former Executive Director of the Black Metropolis, Camille Brewer, and project manager and archivist Anita Mechler for their enthusiastic support of my project and guidance in establishing networks with archival repositories that became central to my study. Thanks to Dr. Antoinette Burton and Dr. Nancy Castro also for providing a collaborative and collegial space at IPRH to share early drafts. I am grateful to the archivists who spent countless hours helping me to sort through and find documents: Beverly Cook at the Vivian G. Harsh Research Collection at the Woodson Regional Library, Ellen Keith at the Chicago History Museum Research Center, Janet Harper at the Center for Black Music Research at Columbia College Chicago, and Kristen Chinery at the Walter P. Reuther Library: Archives of Labor and Urban Affairs. Their patience and expertise made my experience in the archives a rewarding one. iv To my colleagues and friends, I will cherish the memories that we shared at the university and surrounding cities. Their friendship sustained me through the rigors of the program and the solitude of the dissertating year. Additionally, thanks to the friends scattered across the United States and abroad who have taught me to not take life so seriously and to enjoy the ride. Last, and most importantly, I would like to thank my parents, brother, and twin sister. Their love and guidance has been with me in whatever I pursued. They believed in my goals and sacrificed so that I could chase my dreams. They are the very best parts of who I am and my greatest inspiration. v Table of Contents List of Figures ........................................................................................................................ vi Chapter 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 1 Chapter 2 History of Chicago and Bronzeville, 1919-1939.................................................. 29 Chapter 3 Domestics, Musicians, and Black Labor .............................................................. 54 Chapter 4 Respectability and Restraint in the Church .......................................................... 92 Chapter 5 Conclusion and Implications .............................................................................. 139 Notes ................................................................................................................................... 152 Selected Bibliography ......................................................................................................... 168 Archival Resources ............................................................................................................. 170 vi List of Figures 1. Chicago History Museum, Historic City: The Settlement of Chicago1920, Chicago, IL. Photographed March 23, 2016. In the Settlement Map of 1920, the grey areas with light stippling are the areas that Blacks lived. ...................................................................................................... 33 2. Newberry Library, Census Tracts of Chicago 1934: Per Cent of Total Population Negro, Digital collection: http://dcc.newberry.org/system/artifacts/588/medium/Map-Census-tracts-of- Chicago-1934.jpg .......................................................................................................................... 33 3. “Racial and Nationality Map of Chicago,” Chicago Daily Tribune, March 8, 1951. The map was generated by University of Chicago students based on the 1940 census tracts. .................... 33 4. Cosmopolitan Community Church. Original Structure. Marjorie Stewart Joyner Papers, Chicago Public Library, Woodson Regional Library, Vivian G. Harsh Research Collection of Afro-American History and Literature. ........................................................................................ 95 5. Cosmopolitan Community Church. Pastor Evans. Marjorie Stewart Joyner Papers, Chicago Public Library, Woodson Regional Library, Vivian G. Harsh Research Collection of Afro- American History and Literature. ................................................................................................. 96 6. Olivet Baptist Church, “Greetings Celebrating the Seventy-Second Anniversary of the Church and Six Years Pastorate of Dr. L.K. Williams,” [1922], Olivet Baptist Church Collection, Chicago History Museum, Chicago. ............................................................................................. 98 7. Pastor L.K. Williams, Olivet Baptist Church, “Greetings Celebrating the Seventy-Second Anniversary of the Church and Six Years Pastorate of Dr. L.K. Williams,” [1922], Olivet Baptist Church Collection, Chicago History Museum, Chicago. ............................................................. 99 8. Sermon. Marjorie Stewart Joyner Papers, [Box 17, Folder 7], Chicago Public Library, Woodson Regional Library, Vivian G. Harsh Research Collection of Afro-American History and Literature. .................................................................................................................................... 101 9. Sermon. Reverend J. H. Jackson papers [manuscript], Box 32, Folder 1936 June – December, “The New Age” Chicago History Museum Research Collection. .............................................. 113 10. New Front of Cosmopolitan Community Church. Marjorie Stewart Joyner Papers, Chicago Public Library, Woodson Regional Library, Vivian G. Harsh Research Collection of Afro- American History and Literature. ............................................................................................... 120 11. Inside the Sanctuary: Marjorie Stewart Joyner Papers, Chicago Public Library, Woodson Regional Library, Vivian G. Harsh Research Collection of Afro-American History and Literature. .................................................................................................................................... 122 vii 12. Reverend Mary Evans, 1932. Marjorie Stewart Joyner Papers, Chicago Public Library, Woodson Regional Library, Vivian G. Harsh Research Collection of Afro-American History and Literature. .................................................................................................................................... 123 13. Director of Music. Marjorie Stewart Joyner Papers, Chicago Public Library, Woodson Regional Library, Vivian G. Harsh Research Collection of Afro-American History and Literature. .................................................................................................................................... 124 14. Left image - original