Identification of networking quantum teleportation on 14-qubit IBM universal quantum computer Ni-Ni Huang,1, 2 Wei-Hao Huang,1, 2 and Che-Ming Li1, 2, 3, ∗ 1Department of Engineering Science, National Cheng Kung University, Tainan 701, Taiwan 2Center for Quantum Frontiers of Research & Technology, NCKU, Tainan 701, Taiwan 3Center for Quantum Technology, Hsinchu 30013, Taiwan (Dated: February 21, 2020) Quantum teleportation enables networking participants to move an unknown quantum state be- tween the nodes of a quantum network, and hence constitutes an essential element in constructing large-sale quantum processors with a quantum modular architecture. Herein, we propose two pro- tocols for teleporting qubits through an N-node quantum network in a highly-entangled box-cluster state or chain-type cluster state. The proposed protocols are systematically scalable to an arbitrary finite number N and applicable to arbitrary size of modules. The protocol based on a box-cluster state is implemented on a 14-qubit IBM quantum computer for N up to 12. To identify faithful networking teleportation, namely that the elements on real devices required for the networking tele- portation process are all qualified for achieving teleportation task, we quantify quantum-mechanical processes using a generic classical-process model through which any classical strategies of mimicry of teleportation can be ruled out. From the viewpoint of achieving a genuinely quantum-mechanical process, the present work provides a novel toolbox consisting of the networking teleportation pro- tocols and the criteria for identifying faithful teleportation for universal quantum computers with modular architectures and facilitates further improvements in the reliability of quantum-information processing. I. INTRODUCTION Accordingly, we present herein a toolbox for examining the performance of IBM quantum computers, where the Quantum teleportation provides a method for trans- networking teleportation protocol is executed. We firstly porting unknown quantum states between remote sys- propose two systematically extensible networking tele- tems based on shared entanglement and quantum mea- portation protocols for a network consisting of N parties surements [1]. Teleportation constitutes the fundamen- based on either a box-cluster state or a chain-type cluster tal element required to perform a wide range of quan- state [30, 31]. The proposed protocols possess applica- tum computation and quantum information tasks in a bility to arbitrary finite size of modules and the adapt- quantum network [2{9]. In particular, to construct large- ability to the benchmark provided by a generic classical scale quantum computing processors with a modular ar- process model [32]. We then implement the proposed chitecture [4,7, 10{16] (Fig.1a), ideal teleportation is protocol based on the N-qubit box-cluster state on a 14- required to connect the various modules within the net- qubit quantum processor named ibmq 16 melbourne for work [4,7, 10, 13{16] (Figs.1b, c). Notably, such an ideal N up to 12. quantum process is also essential for the modularization A generic classical-process model providing the of quantum networks in which spatially-separated quan- strictest criteria in order to rule out any classical strate- tum nodes communicate across different modules [6]. gies of mimicry of teleportation [32] is utilized for as- Recently, IBM launched the IBM Q Experience, which sessing the performance of the real quantum device, on makes universal quantum computers accessible to the which the proposed networking teleportation protocol is general public through cloud service [18]. IBM has also conducted. Through the generic classical-process model, developed Qiskit [19] to provide users with the tools one can identify whether the experimental networking required to run their quantum programs on prototype arXiv:2002.08671v1 [quant-ph] 20 Feb 2020 teleportation process is faithful. In the case that the quantum devices and simulators. IBM Q Experience pro- experimental process is identified as faithful, all the ele- vides an online platform for the experimental testing of ments on real quantum devices required in the network- the fundamentals of quantum physics [20{24] and a wide ing teleportation process are identified as all qualified variety of applications in quantum information theory for use. The model is defined as input states satisfying [25{29]. However, while IBM has built both 20-qubit the assumption of realism and their evolutions to out- and 50-qubit quantum processors [18], a comprehensive put states that can be reconstructed as a density opera- characterization of the networking teleportation process tor, where this evolution conforms to classical stochastic for future modular use on IBM quantum devices is still theory. Existing identification methods utilize the state lacking. characteristics to verify the teleportation of IBM Q [25{ 27], solid-state systems [33{35], trapped atoms [36, 37], photonic qubits [38{42], atomic ensembles [43, 44] and satellite-based systems [45, 46]. By contrast, the present ∗ [email protected] study provides a novel toolbox consisting of the two scal- 2 a b c Flying qubit 1 0 1 3 5 Alice Bob 1 Participant 0 2 4 6 Arbitrary state Specific measurement 2 Bell-state measurement 0 1 3 5 2 (iii) P 1 3 5 (i) Recover 2 4 6 2 4 6 Qubit (ii) Physical interaction j mi FIG. 1. Networking teleportation in a modular architecture. (a) Modular architecture of the quantum network. Each module is regarded as a node of the quantum network and consists of qubits [4,7, 10, 12, 13, 16]. The modules transmit quantum states to one another by performing intra- and inter-module operations [4,7, 10, 11, 13{16]. The architecture can be extended to realize a universal quantum computer by teleporting a controlled-Z (CZ) gate [7]. (b) Transmission of quantum information among different modules. Due to the isolation between modules, quantum teleportation [4,7, 10, 13{16] is utilized to transport an arbitrary quantum state of qubit 0 (purple) from module 1 to module 2 consisting of qubits 1{6. In particular, qubit 0 is entangled with a flying photon qubit [7, 11, 12, 14] (gradient purple) via a CNOT-like operation on Alice's side [14]. Alice then measures qubit 0 on a specific basis to enable the flying qubit to carry the information regarding the quantum state of qubit 0 to be transported via remote state preparation [17]. (c) Networking teleportation protocol based on a 6-qubit box-cluster state jCb;6i. The protocol aims to teleport the arbitrary state of qubit 0 from Alice to Bob using a shared entangled state jCb;6i among Alice, the participants and Bob. The main steps of the protocol are as follows: (i) Bell-state measurement (red) on Alice's flying photon qubit which carries the information of the quantum state of qubit 0 and qubit 1; (ii) specific local measurements (orange) on participants' qubits 2{5; (iii) appropriate unitary transformations P on Bob's qubit N to recover the initial input state (purple) in accordance with the measurement results informed by Alice and the participants. (See text for detailed procedures.) able N-qubit networking teleportation protocols and the and Z = (j0i h0j − j1i h1j) and X = (j+i h+j − |−i h−|) criteria for identifying faithful teleportation. are the Pauli-Z matrix andp Pauli-X matrix, respectively, where |−i = (j0i − j1i)= 2. The proposed networking teleportation protocol utilizes two different types of phys- II. CLUSTER STATES ical interaction of the cluster states, namely an N-qubit box-cluster state jCb;N i (shown in Fig.2a, top) and a To implement the proposed networking teleportation chain-type cluster state jCc;N i (shown in Fig.2a, bot- protocol, it is first necessary to generate highly-entangled tom). multipartite states (so-called cluster states) [30, 31]. Notably, the advantages are twofold for the teleporta- Cluster states with multipartite quantum correlations are tion protocols to use either chain-type cluster states or considered to be the significant source: basic building box-cluster states. First, according to the connectivity block when constructing general modular architectures map of 14-qubit ibmq 16 melbourne device and the other for quantum networks [6]. quantum devices on IBMQ [18], chain-type cluster states An N-qubit cluster state jCi can be generated by ap- and box-cluster states are the most feasible and applica- plying the controlled-Z (CZ) gates with a specified con- ble types of entangled states to be generated. Second, figuration to the initial states, i.e., these two types of cluster states are natural resources to be integrated into different and complex networking j+i⊗N = H⊗N j0i⊗N ; (1) protocols, such as universal measurement-based quantum p computation [31, 47{49], error correction [50{53], blind where j+i = (j0pi + j1i)= 2 and H = (j0i h0j + j0i h1j + quantum computation [54{57], as well as quantum cryp- j1i h0j−j1i h1j)= 2 is the Hadamard transformation (H). tography like quantum secret sharing [58, 59]. The state vector jCi can then be written in the form Y ⊗N jCi = CZ 0 j+i ; (2) (a;a ) III. NETWORKING TELEPORTATION 0 (a )2I(a) PROTOCOLS where I(a) is the set of qubits that physically interact with qubit a, and CZa;a0 = j0i h0ja ⊗ Ia0 + j1i h1ja ⊗ Za0 This section presents a general description of the pro- denotes the CZ gate acting on the control qubit a and tar- posed networking teleportation protocol, wherein either 0 get qubit a . Here, I is a 2-dimensional identity matrix, an N-qubit box-cluster state jCb;N i (Fig.2a, top) with 3 positive even integer N up to 12 or an N-qubit chain-type a N-3 N-1 cluster state jCc;N i (Fig.2a, bottom) with arbitrary pos- 0 1 3 itive even integer N (Fig.2a), is employed.