Saskatchewan Mid-Year Update
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Saskatchewan 2020 Budget – Update Economics and Strategy November 27, 2020 At mid-year, planned return to balance in 2024-25 remains unchanged By Marc Pinsonneault . Economic outlook: As a consequence of virus containment measures and the fall in oil process, an unprecedented disruption in economic activity occurred in March and April in Saskatchewan. An impressive total of 73,800 jobs were lost over these two months (-12.7%). Employment has since rebounded sharply and 56,000 jobs have been recovered as of October. The unemployment rate climbed from 6.2% in February to 12.5% in May before gradually retreating to 6.4% in October, when it was the lowest among the Canadian provinces. Still, the employment recovery has been uneven across industries. In accommodation and food services and in information, culture and leisure, employment in October was respectively 22% and 34% below pre-pandemic levels. The oil sector was impacted particularly hard. Year-to-date, drilling is down 43% while oil production dropped 9.5%. Crop production is estimated to have declined by roughly 3.5%. But there is also good news. So far in 2020, retail sales, housing starts and international goods exports have exceeded expectations. Potash production is expected to increase 5.4%. This allowed the Ministry of Finance to upwardly revise its real GDP forecast for 2020 from a 5.5% decline in the Q1 update to a 5.0% decrease. This is somewhat more optimistic than the private sector average forecast of 5.4% (including only forecasts issued since September). However, the growth forecast for next year has been revised down from Q1 due to lower expectations for oil production and investment. The 2021 rebound is now projected at 3.6% (4.4% as of Q1 update) while the 2022 growth rate is about the same at 2.7%. Nominal GDP is expected to decline 9.3% in 2020 and to rebound 6.0% in 2021 and 5.3% in 2022. The uncertainty surrounding the forecast for the whole fiscal year has increased lately with more stringent measures adopted in order to curb the second wave of Covid-19 infections. Updated 2020-21 fiscal picture: A deficit of $2.0 billion is now forecast, an $86 million improvement from Q1 and a total improvement of $382 million from the Budget. The mid-year update includes the impact of Government’s election platform commitments, estimated at $133 million, and $260 million of contingencies (1.8% of total revenue; $100 million booked in revenue, $160 million booked in expenses) to cushion against potential pandemic-related revenue and spending shocks over the remainder of the fiscal year. Revenue for the whole fiscal year is projected at $14.2 billion at mid-year, a $504 million increase from the Budget. The increase is largely due to higher federal transfers and GBE’s net income. Tax revenue is $41 million lower than the budget estimate and reflects Government’s commitment to reduce the small business Corporate Income Tax rate, effective October 1, 2020. Expenses are now projected to be $16.2 billion. This is $122 million higher than the Budget and includes increases for the health, education, municipal and tourism sectors. Government’s election commitments related to SaskPower utility bill relief, lower seniors’ ambulance fees and funding for community rinks are also included. These increases are partially offset by lower-than- budgeted crop insurance claims expense and pension expense. Beyond this year, there is no material change to the medium-term outlook presented in the August Q1 update. This year’s improvement is largely due to one-time gains, specifically federal safe restart funding and lower-than-budgeted crop insurance indemnities. Saskatchewan’s planned return to balance in 2024-25 remains unchanged. Commodity revenue and prices assumptions: Non-renewable resources revenue is forecast to increase $56.4 million from the Budget. At mid-year, oil and natural gas revenue is forecast to be $165.0 million higher than budget. The increase is primarily due to an increase in WTI oil prices, a narrower light-heavy oil price differential and a forecast increase in production, partially offset by a higher average exchange rate forecast. At mid-year, WTI oil price is assumed to average US$38.70 in 2020-21, a US$8.70 increase over budget. The budget assumption of a light-heavy differential at $US40 has almost been cut by half at mid-year (US$20.50), reflecting Western Canadian heavy crude shut-ins and increased demand from U.S. refineries. The value of the Canadian dollar is now expected to average 74.7 U.S. cents in 2020-21, up 3.7 U.S. cents from the budget assumption of 71.0 U.S. cents. As a result, the well-head oil price in Cdn$ has been revised from $21 at budget time to $36 at mid-year. Potash royalties are forecast to decrease $87.4 million from budget, primarily due to lower average realized prices in U.S. dollars and an increase in the average exchange rate forecast. Prices are now forecast to average US$178 per KCl tonne (C$389 per K2O tonne), down from the budget assumption of US$188 (C$434). The sensitivity of revenue to a US$1/bbl change in WTI oil price is estimated at $13 million, while a US$10 change in KCI tonne in average potash price has a $51 million impact on revenue. Public debt and net debt: Public debt (gross debt minus sinking funds) at March 31, 2021 is forecast to be $540.8 million lower than budgeted, primarily due to the improvement in the deficit forecast and reduced GBE debt. The decline in GBE debt is mainly attributable to lower than expected uptake of the Crown utility payment deferral program and deferrals and reductions of capital expenditures. Net debt as of March 31, 2021 is forecast to be $14.8 billion. This is $359.3 million lower than budgeted, primarily due to the anticipated reduction in the 2020-21 deficit. The net debt to GDP ratio is now projected at 19.6% as of March 31, 2021, compared to 20.8% at budget time. It is one of the lowest ratios among provinces, if not the lowest. Borrowing requirement: There is no change in total borrowing requirement from Budget, which still amounts to $4.5 billion. There are slight changes to the types of financing. Cdn$ long-term financing of $139.6 million and short-term financing of $40.2 million are expected to be replaced by a foreign-currency financing of $179.8 million ($0 at budget time). Saskatchewan 2020 Budget – Update Economics and Strategy . Long-term credit ratings: S&P: AA | Moody’s: Aaa, Negative | DBRS: AA(low) | Fitch: AA Conclusion Saskatchewan’s planned return to balance in 2024-25 remains unchanged. The COVID-19 pandemic continues to weigh heavily on the economic and fiscal outlook for governments around the world. Like in most jurisdictions in Canada, Saskatchewan adopted stricter measures in the hope of curbing the second wave of infections currently underway. Indeed, the recent resurgence of the virus and stricter public health measures threaten the current pace of recovery around the World, not only in Saskatchewan and Canada. The longer-term impacts of the pandemic – social, health and economic – are still unfolding. Nevertheless, Saskatchewan remains well positioned to respond to the challenge given its strong fiscal foundation. Saskatchewan 2020-21 mid-year update First Millions of dollars Budget Quarter Mid-year Total Revenue 13,648.7 14,046.9 14,152.2 Taxation 7,202.8 7,202.8 7,161.6 Non-renewable resources 997.4 1,053.8 1,053.8 Net income from GBEs 728.8 705.6 874.4 Other own-source revenue 1,933.1 1,933.1 1,933.1 Transfers from the federal government 2,786.6 3,151.6 3,229.3 Revenue risk allowance - - (100.0) Total expenses 16,074.7 16,177.3 16,196.7 Program expenses 15,356.5 15,452.7 15,472.1 as of Health 6,176.3 6,248.3 6,351.1 Education 3,361.9 3,364.5 3,397.3 Health and public safety contingency 200.0 160.0 160.0 Others 5,618.3 5,679.9 5,563.7 Financing charges 718.2 724.6 724.6 Deficit (2,426.0) (2,130.4) (2,044.5) As a % of GDP -3.3% -2.9% -2.7% Public Debt at the end of fiscal year 2020-21 Government Service Organization Debt 14,336.6 14,036.2 14,035.7 Government Business Enterprise Debt 10,032.6 9,878.2 9,792.7 Total Public debt 24,369.2 23,914.4 23,828.4 Net debt 15,122.0 14,827.0 14,763.0 Net debt as a % of GDP 20.8% 19.7% 19.6% Actual Budget Mid-year Borrowing requirements by type 2019-2020 2020-21 2020-21 Foreign currencies - - 179.8 Canadian Dollar 1,970.0 4,339.6 4,200.0 Short Term 117.5 117.9 77.7 Total 2,087.5 4,457.5 4,457.5 Source: Saskatchewan 2020-21 Mid-Year report and 2020-21 Mid-Year Green Sheets. 2 Saskatchewan 2020 Budget – Update Economics and Strategy Economics and Strategy Montreal Office Toronto Office 514-879-2529 416-869-8598 Stéfane Marion Matthieu Arseneau Warren Lovely Chief Economist and Strategist Deputy Chief Economist Chief Rate Strategist, Economics and Strategy [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Paul-André Pinsonnault Marc Pinsonneault Angelo Katsoras Taylor Schleich Senior Economist Senior Economist Geopolitical Analyst Associate, Rates Strategist, Economics and Strategy [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Kyle Dahms Jocelyn Paquet Alexandra Ducharme Economist Economist Intern Economist [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] General This Report was prepared by National Bank Financial, Inc.