VENTURING to AFRICA Overcoming Obstacles for Finnish VC Firms to Invest in Africa

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

VENTURING to AFRICA Overcoming Obstacles for Finnish VC Firms to Invest in Africa VENTURING TO AFRICA Overcoming Obstacles for Finnish VC Firms to Invest in Africa University of Helsinki, Faculty of Law Master’s Thesis International Business Law April 2021 Jacob Pichna Supervisor: Ville Pönkä Tiedekunta - Fakultet - Faculty Koulutusohjelma - Utbildningsprogram – Degree Programme Faculty of Law Master in International and Comparative Law Tekijä - Författare - Author Jacob Pichna Työn nimi - Arbetets titel Venturing to Africa: Overcoming Obstacles for Finnish VC Firms to Invest in Africa Oppiaine - Läroämne - Subject Law and Economics Työn laji/ Ohjaaja - Arbetets art/Handledare - Level/Instructor Aika - Datum - Month and year Sivumäärä - Sidoantal - Number of Master’s Thesis/ Ville Pönkä April 2021 pages 78 p. + XXVIII Tiivistelmä - Referat - Abstract The African start-up scene has been rapidly developing in recent years and respected Silicon Valley VC firms and large tech companies are moving in on the market which could be regarded as a signal of opportunity. Yet a single investment is to be made by a Finnish VC firm into an African start-up. The democratizing effect of technology and internet accessibility has led to the growth of innovation and disruption on the continent with the three selected jurisdictions for the thesis South Africa, Nigeria and Kenya leading the charge. Focusing on the three countries enables more a pragmatic analysis and thus applicable solutions. Analysing three different ecosystems also showcases the heterogeneity of the continent’s opportunities for VC firms. The objective of the thesis is to establish the main blockers for Finnish VC firms when weighing the option of investing in Africa and then provide solutions to overcome the obstacles whilst taking a form of a roadmap to also show the process of investing in Africa and its peculiarities. Because of the specificity and novelty of the subject matter, there is very little research specific to the objective to build on. To paint a picture of the different ecosystems’ comparative legal analysis and market analysis was utilized. The obstacles were identified through thematically analysed qualitative interviews with Finnish VC firms. The solutions to these obstacles were built on qualitative interviews with individuals that have experience from the African start-up scene. Four obstacles rose above the rest in prevalence: mandates, being geographically far from founders, local expertise & networks and corporate governance & unknown risks. Based on the four obstacles a prescription of four actions that enable a Finnish VC firm to invest in Africa was developed: 1. Cannot be focused on early stage start-ups. 2. Needs to find a local co-investor. 3. Cannot have a mandate blocking Africa as an investment option. 4. Is a specialized fund. By adhering to these four “rules” a Finnish VC firm can venture to Africa with confidence. Avainsanat - Nyckelord Pääomasijoitus, Afrikka, Nigeria, Etelä-Afrikka, Kenia, Startup, kehittyvät markkinat Keywords Venture Capital, Africa, Nigeria, South Africa, Kenya, Start-up, emerging markets Säilytyspaikka - Förvaringsställe - Where deposited Library of the University of Helsinki Muita tietoja - Övriga uppgifter - Additional information TABLE OF CONTENTS ABBREVIATIONS ........................................................................................................ V 1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Background and Objectives .............................................................................. 1 1.2 Methodology and Scope ................................................................................... 2 1.3 Approach With Sources .................................................................................... 4 1.4 Outline .............................................................................................................. 6 2 VENTURE CAPITAL ............................................................................................ 7 2.1 Introduction ....................................................................................................... 7 2.2 History ............................................................................................................ 10 2.3 Finnish Venture Capital .................................................................................. 13 2.3.1 History ................................................................................................... 13 2.3.2 The Current State .................................................................................. 14 2.3.3 Legal Framework Along the Lifecycle of a Finnish VC firm ................ 18 3 VENTURE CAPITAL IN AFRICA .................................................................... 26 3.1 Current Level of Investment ........................................................................... 26 3.2 Geographic Division of VC Investors in Africa ............................................. 28 3.2.1 African Firms ........................................................................................ 28 3.2.2 Global Firms ......................................................................................... 30 3.2.3 Finnish Firms ........................................................................................ 31 3.3 The Investment Process in Africa for a Finnish Firm ..................................... 33 4 THE READINESS OF THE CHOSEN COUNTRIES FOR VC INVESTMENT...................................................................................................... 40 4.1 Nigeria ............................................................................................................ 40 4.1.1 Overview ............................................................................................... 40 4.1.2 Legal Landscape for VC Investments ................................................... 41 4.1.3 Start-up Scene ....................................................................................... 45 4.2 South Africa .................................................................................................... 47 4.2.1 Overview ............................................................................................... 47 4.2.2 Legal Landscape for VC Investments ................................................... 48 4.2.3 Start-up Scene ....................................................................................... 51 4.3 Kenya .............................................................................................................. 52 iii 4.3.1 Overview ............................................................................................... 52 4.3.2 Legal Landscape for VC Investments ................................................... 54 4.3.3 Start-up Scene ....................................................................................... 57 5 OBSTACLES ........................................................................................................ 59 5.1 Methodology ................................................................................................... 59 5.2 The Results ..................................................................................................... 62 5.2.1 Question I .............................................................................................. 62 5.2.2 Question II ............................................................................................ 63 5.2.3 Question III ........................................................................................... 63 5.2.4 The Obstacles for Analysis .................................................................... 63 6 ANALYSIS AND POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS TO OBSTACLES .................. 65 6.1 Methodology ................................................................................................... 65 6.2 The Obstacles .................................................................................................. 67 6.2.1 Mandates ............................................................................................... 67 6.2.2 Being Geographically Far From Founders .......................................... 69 6.2.3 Lack of Local Expertise & Networks .................................................... 71 6.2.4 Corporate Governance & Unknown Risks ........................................... 74 7 CONCLUSION ..................................................................................................... 78 BIBLIOGRAPHY ......................................................................................................... 79 Literature ................................................................................................................. 79 Legislature and Cases ............................................................................................. 87 Online Sources ........................................................................................................ 88 APPENDIXES ............................................................................................................... 99 LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Venture capital investment by industry and region. .......................................... 9 Figure 2. Investments made and funds raised by public and private Finnish VC funds 15 Figure 3. Structure of a VC fund .................................................................................... 19 iv Abbreviations AGDI African Governance and Development Institute
Recommended publications
  • P4 Prime Minister Launches the Aberdare Trust - P8
    THE NEWSLETTER OF THE RHINO ARK CHARITABLE TRUST NO. 41 NOVEMBER 2012 RHINO CHARGE 2012 REsults - p4 PRImE mINIstER lAuNCHEs tHE AbERdARE tRust - P8 FINANCE mINIstER lAuNCHEs tHE mt KENyA FENCE - P9 2012 AbERdARE FENCE RuN GEts ROyAl NOd - P24 The Winning Team BRAEBURN’SEBURN’S CAR 49, CAPTAINED BY PATRICK GARNER AND TERRY CHILDS,CHILDS WONWON THE 2012 RHINO CHARGE. Winning is a goal we all strive for, but howw wewe achieve that goal is perhaps even more important. Those that make it to the totopp need real determination to keep going when things getet tough;tough; they need a “can-do” sort of attitude and a desire to deal with diffi culties head-on and not try to skirt around them or take the easy wayway out. Determination, a positive mindset, an ability to work with others as a team to support, encourage and be encouraged are the characteracter traits that success in all walks of life are built on. We all face challenges at different stages of our life; it is how we deal with these challengeslenges that will gauge how successful we will go on to be. The Braeburn Group of International Schools boasts an ethos of nurturing personal growthth byby providing a friendly and supportive environment in all our schools in East Africa. Early years, primary and secondary students develop thehe skills,skills, attitudes andan awareness necessary to become successful learners, confi dent individuals and responsible citizens. We congratulate the whole team! Rhino Ark Objectives Rhino Ark seeks solutions in the mountain range ecosystems of Executive Director’s view Kenya and for the benefit of Eastern s ht Africa generally to: rec At the crossroad… Christian Lamb • Conserve such ecologically precious indigenous forests and their provision of vital During the last 24 years, rarely have so many changes have taken place environmental services; in only a few months.
    [Show full text]
  • Restructuring Bowmans
    RESTRUCTURING BOWMANS 2 Restructuring Contents 04 Our Firm 05 Our Footprint in Africa 06 Our Restructuring Practice 07 Our Specialist Services 07 Our Signature Matters 11 Key Contacts 3 BOWMANS Our Firm We help our clients overcome legal complexity and unlock opportunity in Africa. ur track record of providing specialist Our expertise is frequently recognised by Olegal services in the fields of corporate independent research organisations. Most law, banking and finance law and dispute recently, at the inaugural IFLR1000 Awards resolution, spans over a century. for Sub-Saharan Africa (2020), we received 10 awards across four jurisdictions confirming With eight offices in seven African countries our leadership when it comes to advising on and over 400 specialist lawyers, we draw on multijurisdictional mergers and acquisitions in our unique knowledge of the business and Africa. At the African Legal Awards (2020), socio-political environment to advise clients we won awards in three categories and were on a wide range of legal issues. highly commended in a further four categories including African Law Firm of the Year – Large Everywhere we work, we offer clients a Practice. We received awards in three out of service that uniquely blends expertise in the four categories at the DealMakers East Africa law, knowledge of the local market, and an Awards (2019): top legal adviser in the M&A understanding of their businesses. Our aim Category for both deal flow and deal value is to assist them to achieve their objectives and advised on the Deal of the Year. In the as smoothly and efficiently as possible while DealMakers South Africa Awards (2019), we minimising the legal and regulatory risks.
    [Show full text]
  • 2014 Emissions Inventory Report
    Calendar Year 2014 Greenhouse Gas Emissions Inventory Report Prepared for: The U.S. Overseas Private Investment Corporation Prepared by: FINAL REPORT July 2016 SC&A, Inc. 1608 Spring Hill Rd., Suite 400 Vienna, VA 22182 (703) 893-6600 www.scainc.com i TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS ................................................................................................................................. ii TABLES ......................................................................................................................................................... iii FIGURES ...................................................................................................................................................... iv INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................................... 1 Baseline Inventory Development .............................................................................................................. 1 2008-2012 Inventories .............................................................................................................................. 2 2013 Inventory Summary.......................................................................................................................... 3 2014 Inventory Summary.......................................................................................................................... 3 METHODOLOGY .........................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Swedfund's Investments Through Funds
    Contents 1. Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 3 2. Overview of Swedfund’s investments through funds ....................................................... 4 3. Developments effects of Swedfund's investments through funds ................................... 6 3.1 A framework for monitoring and evaluating development effects ........................... 6 3.2 Financial performance .................................................................................................. 8 3.3 Economic performance ............................................................................................... 10 3.4 Environmental, social and governance performance ................................................... 13 3.5 Private sector development ........................................................................................ 17 4. Regional reviews ................................................................................................................ 21 4.1 Africa ............................................................................................................................. 21 4.2 Asia ................................................................................................................................ 23 4.3 Eastern Europe ............................................................................................................ 25 4.4 Latin America ..............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Development Finance As Agro-Colonialism
    REPORT Development Finance as Agro-Colonialism: European Development Bank funding of Feronia-PHC oil palm plantations in the Democratic Republic of Congo 2 Development Finance as Agro-Colonialism: European Development Bank funding of Feronia- PHC oil palm plantations in the Democratic Republic of Congo Redistribution of the material presented in this work is encouraged provided that the original text is not altered, that the original source is properly and fully acknowledged, and the objective of the redistribution is not commercial gain. This report is co-published by the following organisations: RIAO-RDC (DR Congo), FIAN Belgium, Entraide et Fraternité (Belgium), CCFD-Terre Solidaire (France), FIAN Germany, urgewald (Germany), Milieudefensie (The Netherlands), The Corner House (UK), Global Justice Now (UK), World Rainforest Movement (International), GRAIN (International) Date of Publication: January 2021 Design and Layout: Ruben Stelli (www.rubenstelli.nl), Tyra van Mossevelde (www.mosgroen.nl) Acknowledgments: Research for this report was part of an ESRC IIA University of Bristol-funded project entitled “Communities, land rights and development banks’ complaint mechanism: co-constructing a strategy and a toolkit for future meaningful participation.” Financial support for the research behind this report has also been received from CCFD-Terre Solidaire (France), FIAN Belgium, grassroots Foundation (Germany), Misereor (Germany) and the World Rainforest Movement (Uruguay). This publication has been produced with the financial support of
    [Show full text]
  • Effect of Chinese Firms on Local Firms in Nairobi, Kenya by Farhiya Yussuf
    EFFECT OF CHINESE FIRMS ON LOCAL FIRMS IN NAIROBI, KENYA BY FARHIYA YUSSUF IBRAHIM UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL UNVERSITY - AFRICA SPRING 2019 EFFECT OF CHINESE FIRMS ON LOCAL FIRMS IN NAIROBI, KENYA BY FARHIYA YUSSUF IBRAHIM A Research Project Submitted to the Chandaria School of Business in Partial Fulfillments of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Organizational Development (MOD) UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL UNVERSITY - AFRICA SPRING 2019 ii STUDENT’S DECLARATION I,theundersigned,declarethatthisis myoriginalworkandhasnotbeensubmittedtoanyothercollege,institution,oruniversityothertha ntheUnitedStatesInternationalUniversityin Nairobi foracademiccredit. Signature……………………………………Date……………………………………. FarhiyaYussuf Ibrahim (640003) Thisresearchissubmittedforexaminationwithmyapproval asuniversity supervisor. Signature………………………………… Date……………………………………. PROF. TIMOTHY OKECH Signature………………………………… Date……………………………………. Dean, Chandaria School of Business iii COPYRIGHT Alltherightsreserved.Nopartofthisreportmaybephotocopied,recordedorotherwisereproduced, storedinaretrievalsystemortransmittedinanyelectronicormechanicalmeans without prior permission ofthe copyrightowner. FarhiyaYussuf IbrahimCopyright © 2019 iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Iwouldliketobegin by giving thankstoAllahfor thestrength,courage,andguidancehehasofferedtomeduringtheprocessofpreparingmyprojectf ormygraduatestudies.Ialsogiveappreciateandacknowledgemygreatfamilyfortheuncondition alsupporttheyofferedme,andtoProf. Timothy Okechforherpatience,directionandmotivationthatsheaccordedmeinwritingupthisresearchMa
    [Show full text]
  • Thomas B. Trimble Partner, Washington, D.C
    Thomas B. Trimble Partner, Washington, D.C. +1 202-282-5155 [email protected] Tom is a leading international transactions, private equity and project finance lawyer with over 30 years of experience in cross-border and emerging markets transactions, representing clients in over 60 countries across five continents—primarily in the infrastructure, energy, mining and telecommunications industries. Tom Trimble advises clients on matters involving project finance and development, private equity investors, mergers and acquisitions, and structured finance. He advises U.S., European and emerging markets companies, private equity funds and foreign governments in connection with equity and asset acquisitions and sales, project finance, infrastructure development and renewable energy transactions. Tom is one of the industry’s leading lawyers representing investors in transactions across a broad range of emerging markets, with core concentration in the markets of Africa and Latin America. Geographic coverage in the emerging markets includes: 20 Countries in Africa: Nigeria, Kenya, Ghana, Tanzania, Ivory Coast, Zambia, Zimbabwe, Algeria, DRC, Mozambique, Morocco, South Africa, Angola, Cameroon, Uganda, Rwanda Senegal, Mauritius, Central African Republic and Liberia. 15 countries in Latin America: Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Ecuador, Colombia, Costa Rica, Dominica, Dominican Republic, Guatemala, Haiti, Jamaica, Mexico, Nicaragua, Peru and St. Lucia. 15 countries in Europe and the Middle East: Russia, Belarus, Moldova, Ukraine, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Poland, Romania, Hungary, Czech Republic, Macedonia, Turkey, Oman, Saudi Arabia, UAE. 11 countries in Asia: Pakistan, Indonesia, Vietnam, Thailand, Myanmar, Singapore, Malaysia, China, South Korea, Mongolia and Japan. Industry experience includes: Power, Telecommunications, Oil and Gas, Broadcasting and Media, Chemicals, Mining, Financial Services, Gas Trading, Port Facilities and Logistics, Cell Tower Infrastructure, Agribusiness, Insurance, Education, Food Services, Retail and Construction.
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 Letter CONT Committee Spencon
    TO EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, BUDGETARY CONTROL COMMITTEE (CONT) CHAIR Monika Hohlmeier VICE-CHAIRS Isabel Garcia Munoz Caterina Chinnici Martina Dlabajova Tamas Deutsch April 7, 2020 Dear Chair and Vice-chairs of the CONT Committee, Flagship BBC programme reports allegations of bribes, fraud and mismanagement in Kenya company owned by European Investment Bank (EIB)-financed private equity fund: concerns that the EIB has signed away powers to protect billions of pounds of EU aid money. A recent report1 by Counter Balance raised concerns that the European Investment Bank (EIB)’s use of financial intermediaries, such as private equity funds2, is putting EU aid money and development finance at financial or reputational risk through alleged or actual mismanagement, corruption, fraud or other abuses by the companies in which the intermediary funds are invested. Given these concerns, we are writing to draw the CONT Committee’s urgent attention to shocking allegations, reported on last night by the award-winning BBC documentary programme African Eye. The programme reported on serious concerns of alleged fraud, bribery and other highly questionable business practices by two British managers appointed by a European Investment Bank (EIB)-backed private equity fund to run its investee Kenyan firm Spencon3. The allegations are vehemently denied by the managers.4 A transcript of the programme is attached. 1 https://www.counter-balance.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Report_OnlineVersion_EIB_Corruption_Oct2019.pdf 2 As at the end of June 2019, the EIB has invested in 47 active private equity funds in the Africa, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) regions, to which it has committed a total of €705.9m.
    [Show full text]
  • PIDG Annual Report 2010 Contents
    PIDG members PIDG Annual Report 2010 Contents Acronyms and abbreviations 3 Development impact 26 Foreword 4 The results framework 27 2010 in review 8 Managing expectations 27 What actually happened 34 The Infrastructure Challenge 12 Vital services needed 12 Project financing and development facilities 36 Investment overstretched 12 The Emerging Africa Infrastructure Fund Ltd. 37 Obstacles to private sector involvement 14 GuarantCo Ltd. 43 What we do 14 Infrastructure Crisis Facility – Debt Pool 47 DevCo 50 Our distinctive approach 16 Technical Assistance Facility 54 Beyond ‘business as usual’ 17 InfraCo Ltd. 56 The creative tension 19 InfraCo Asia Development Pte. Ltd. 60 The project portfolio 20 In conclusion 61 Overall portfolio 21 Portfolio by facility 21 Annex 1: PIDG structure and governance 65 Portfolio by sector 22 Annex 2: DAC list of ODA recipients 66 Portfolio by region 25 Annex 3: Contributions by the PIDG members 68 Annex 4: PIDG project portfolio 70 Annex 5: Contacts and links 85 Acronyms and abbreviations ACL Ackruti City Ltd. IPP Independent Power Producer ADA Austrian Development Agency ISSIF InfraCo Sub-Saharan Infrastructure Fund AECID Agencia Española de Cooperación Internacional para el Desarrollo (Spanish JDA Joint Development Agreement Agency for international development cooperation) JICA Japanese International Cooperation Agency AfDB African Development Bank KEK Korporata Energjetike e Kosovës (Energy Corporation of Kosovo) AFL Africa Foundries Limited KfW KfW development bank (the German Development Bank) AICD
    [Show full text]
  • CHAPTER 2: Global Challenges and Impact
    global challenges 2 and impact where challenges The global crisis changed the economic order, deepening the challenges developing countries will face in the decades ahead. Joblessness is making it harder for families to improve their living standards. Growing energy needs are exacerbating the threat of climate change. Rapid population growth is overwhelming urban infrastructures. Water scarcity and inadequate food security are endangering the lives of millions. Such strains also heighten the potential for confl ict. solutions meet Promoting sustainable development inthis era of they also will be critical forglobal prosperity. and more accessible, give communities access to advisory projects ease on services focused that are and innovation — and the ability mobilize to — resourcesand innovation conditions inareas ravaged byconfl fosterclean sustainable water, cities, and improve countries will not only havethe most— urgent needs IFC is playing aleading roleinhelping the private interconnected and multipolar world, developing developing world, multipolar interconnected and wherever they can be found. Inan increasingly unemployment and climate change, food make safer uncertainty will depend more than ever on partnerships sector address these challenges. Our investments and ict. p9 global challenges p10: results p16: strategy/scorecard p18: unemployment (gender program, extractive industries) p28: climate change (renewable energy, Lighting Africa) and impact p38: food security (food production, insurance) p46: confl ict (Haiti, Africa) p56: water & urbanization (water security, south-south investment) p66: lessons learned GLOBAL CHALLENGES AND IMPACT IFC’s global impact RESULTS FOSTERING SUSTAINABLE PRIVATE SECTOR GROWTH BY REGION IFC works with private sector clients across a swath of industries to improve www.ifc.org/results_region lives in the world’s most impoverished regions.
    [Show full text]
  • Celtel Kenya
    CELTEL KENYA KES 725 million partial credit guarantee to credit enhance a local bond issue as part of a larger financing package for the second mobile telecommunications provider in Kenya. Transaction Overview Date: December 2005 Country: Kenya Developmental Benefit GuarantCo Guaranteed Amount: Kenya Shillings (KES) 725 million (USD 12 million) Celtel Kenya needed to restructure its balance sheet by exchanging costly Total Transaction size: KES 3.5 billion foreign currency shareholder loans with local currency debt. This allowed the Financing Partners: FMO, DEG company to run a more capital-efficient and competitive business and expand its GuarantCo Additionality: network. This helped to reduce tariffs, thus making mobile services affordable to As part of its initiative to maximise local currency financing, Celtel Kenya sought to raise Kenyan Shilling a greater proportion of the population. debt from the local capital market. However, in order to place debt in the local capital market, Celtel Kenya needed to obtain credit enhancement from an AAA-rated institution. GuarantCo’s involvement enabled FMO to arrange and underwrite the required credit enhancement for the debt issuance. The facility provided a major boost to the Kenyan capital market due to the demonstration effect of a private sector non-financial institution’s successful bond listing. ALAF LIMITED TZS 6.5 billion partial credit guarantee made available to provide credit enhancement for a bond issue to finance the expansion of a steel plant in Tanzania Transaction Overview Date: June 2007 Country: Tanzania Developmental Benefit GuarantCo Guaranteed Amount: Tanzania Shillings (TZS) 6.5 billion (USD 5.1 million) The Safal group is one of the biggest producers of steel roofing in Africa, widely Total Project Cost: TZS 37.3 billion used in affordable housing.
    [Show full text]
  • Spencon International Limited Information Summary for the Public
    Spencon International Limited Information Summary for the Public Host Country(ies): Kenya, Tanzania, Uganda Name of Borrower: Spencon International Limited U.S. Sponsor: ECP Manager LP Foreign Sponsor: ECP Africa Fund II PCC, ECP Africa FII Investments LLC, Jitendra Chhotabhai Patel, Naveen Parkash Sharma and Lokendra Ramanbhai Patel Project Description: Expansion of capacity for infrastructure contracts in road building, water supply and sewage systems Total Project Cost: $33,300,000 Loan Provided Under OPIC- $10,000,000 WorldBusiness Capital Framework Agreement: Developmental Effects: This project will have a positive development impact on the host countries through the construction of infrastructure projects such as roads, water supply and sanitation systems. The project will utilize new water sanitation technology in rural parts of East Africa. There will also be new jobs with training and benefits associated with this investment. Furthermore, the project company will provide strong social benefits to both its employees as well as the surrounding local communities. Environment: Screening: The investment has been reviewed against OPIC’s environmental and social policies and has been determined to be categorically eligible. The investment is screened as Category B because impacts are readily mitigated if appropriate management procedures are in place. The key environmental and social issue related to this investment is the need to establish strong corporate governance and management controls to limit environmental and social risks. Social issues include management of labor relations, occupational health and safety and protection of community health, safety and security. Conservation of resources, including water and energy, hazardous materials management and adequate solid waste management are among the principal environmental issues.
    [Show full text]