(19) TZZ ¥_T

(11) EP 2 782 893 B1

(12) EUROPEAN PATENT SPECIFICATION

(45) Date of publication and mention (51) Int Cl.: of the grant of the patent: C07C 67/303 (2006.01) C07D 307/20 (2006.01) 23.08.2017 Bulletin 2017/34 C07D 307/33 (2006.01) C07C 29/149 (2006.01) C07D 307/08 (2006.01) C07C 29/17 (2006.01) (21) Application number: 11810696.2 (86) International application number: (22) Date of filing: 25.11.2011 PCT/IT2011/000387

(87) International publication number: WO 2013/076747 (30.05.2013 Gazette 2013/22)

(54) PROCESS FOR PRODUCING 1,4-BUTANEDIOL, GAMMA-BUTYROLACTONE AND TETRAHYDROFURAN BY HYDROGENATING DIALKYL MALEATE IN MIXED LIQUID/VAPOR PHASE VERFAHREN ZUR HERSTELLUNG VON 1,4-BUTANDIOL, GAMMA-BUTYROLACTON UND TETRAHYDROFURAN DURCH HYDRIERUNG VON DIALKYLMALEAT IN EINER GEMISCHTEN FLÜSSIGKEITS-/DAMPFPHASE PROCÉDÉ DE PRODUCTION DE 1,4-BUTANEDIOL, GAMMA-BUTYROLACTONE ET TETRAHYDROFURANE PAR HYDROGÉNATION DE MALÉATE DE DIALKYLE DANS UNE PHASE MIXTE LIQUIDE/VAPEUR

(84) Designated Contracting States: • SCARSELLA, Marco AL AT BE BG CH CY CZ DE DK EE ES FI FR GB I-00137 Roma (IT) GR HR HU IE IS IT LI LT LU LV MC MK MT NL NO • DE FILIPPIS, Paolo PL PT RO RS SE SI SK SM TR I-00162 Roma (IT)

(43) Date of publication of application: (74) Representative: Sarpi, Maurizio et al 01.10.2014 Bulletin 2014/40 Studio Ferrario S.r.l. Via Collina, 36 (73) Proprietor: Conser SPA 00187 Roma (IT) 00144 Roma (IT) (56) References cited: (72) Inventors: WO-A1-99/35114 US-A- 4 751 334 • SIMOLA, Flavio US-A- 5 872 276 US-B1- 6 350 924 I-00015 Monterotondo (RM) (IT)

Note: Within nine months of the publication of the mention of the grant of the European patent in the European Patent Bulletin, any person may give notice to the European Patent Office of opposition to that patent, in accordance with the Implementing Regulations. Notice of opposition shall not be deemed to have been filed until the opposition fee has been paid. (Art. 99(1) European Patent Convention). EP 2 782 893 B1

Printed by Jouve, 75001 PARIS (FR) EP 2 782 893 B1

Description

SUMMARY OF INVENTION

5 [0001] A process is described for the production of 1,4-butanediol, gamma-butyrolactone and tetrahydrofuran by catalytic hydrogenation of dialkyl maleates. The process consists essentially in the following steps:

a) hydrogenating a stream of dialkyl maleate in a first stage of reaction over suitable catalysts to produce dialkyl succinate; 10 b) further hydrogenating the dialkyl succinate in a second stage of reaction, by using a different suitable catalyst, for producing mainly 1,4-butanediol, together with gamma-butyrolactone and tetrahydrofuran as co-products.

[0002] In both stages of reaction the conditions, as hydrogen/ organic feed ratio, pressure and temperature, are such to maintain the reactors in mixed liquid/vapor phase. 15 FIELD OF DISCLOSURE

[0003] Embodiments disclosed herein relate generally to processes and equipment to produce 1,4-butanediol, together with gamma-butyrolactone and tetrahydrofuran as co-products, by reacting a feed, consisting of alkyl maleates, with 20 hydrogen gas in a two stages reaction over suitable catalysts.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

[0004] 1,4-butanediol (BDO) is a versatile chemical intermediate, thanks to its terminal, primary hydroxyl groups and 25 to its chemical resistant nature. [0005] BDO is an important raw material in the synthesis of technically relevant polymers such as thermoplastic urethanes and polyesters, mainly polybutylene terephthalate (PBT), polyester plasticizers, paints, coatings and adhe- sives. [0006] In the recent years the largest consumer of BDO is tetrahydrofuran (THF), used to produce polytetramethylene 30 ether glycol (PTMEG) a key raw material for spandex fibers. Substantial quantities of BDO go into the manufacture of gamma-butyrolactone (GBL) which is in turn used to manufacture N-methyl-pyrrolidone (NMP) and other pyrrolidones. [0007] There are a number of routes to manufacture BDO: the first commercial route was the Reppe process from acetylene and formaldehyde. Other technologies include the production from butadiene, from propylene oxide, from allyl alcohol and more recently through biotransformation process. 35 [0008] Thanks to the availability and low cost of the raw material, in the last twenty years and in the next future the processes based on butane/maleic anhydride tend to dominate the market. [0009] The processes based on butane/maleic anhydride comprise two main groups. [0010] The first group includes all the processes based on the esterification of the maleic anhydride by methanol, ethanol or other alcohols and the following hydrogenation of the dialkyl ester, usually as dimethyl maleate (DMM), to 40 butanediol and/or, depending on the conditions of pressure and temperature and on the catalyst, to tetrahydrofuran and gamma-butyrolactone. [0011] The second group on the contrary includes the processes based on the direct hydrogenation of the maleic anhydride or maleic acid to BDO and/or THF and GBL. Even if theoretically these processes appear to be simpler, with fewer processing steps (both the maleic anhydride purification and the esterification are not necessary), in the industrial 45 application they met with poor success, probably due to the high cost of the catalyst and of the sophisticated materials of construction necessary in presence of maleic acid at high temperature . [0012] Considering again the processes of the first group based on the esterification of the maleic anhydride, another distinction can be made between the processes based on the hydrogenation in vapor phase and the processes based on the hydrogenation in mixed liquid/vapor phase. 50 [0013] The new process introduced in the present invention belongs to the hydrogenation processes of diesters of the maleic anhydride in mixed phase. [0014] Irrespective of the vapor or mixed phase, it is believed that the reaction of dimethyl maleate to 1,4-butanediol proceeds through at least two intermediates, as follows:

55

2 EP 2 782 893 B1

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

[0015] In conclusion, 1,4-butanediol, tetraydrofuran and gamma-butyrolactone are products of reaction which are converted one to another by addition/subtraction of hydrogen and/or water. The products distribution may be changed 45 by adjusting the operating parameters of the hydrogenolysis reaction or the type of catalysts. [0016] In the prior art several inventions have been applied on the hydrogenation of maleic anhydride esters to produce 1,4-butanediol. [0017] US patent 2,110,488 can be considered the first application concerning the hydrogenation of an ester of aliphatic carboxylic acids to produce aliphatic alcohols using a catalyst consisting of copper oxide and chromium oxide, within a 50 temperature range from 250 to 300 °C and within a pressure range from 150 to 300 atmospheres. [0018] On the other hand US patent 4,032,458 is the first application on the production of 1,4-butanediol, where a solution containing maleic acid is first subject to esterification by a monohydric alcohol and the dialkyl ester of maleic acid is hydrogenated in a two reaction steps, the first step to saturate the double bond present in the maleic acid and the second step to produce 1,4-butanediol and the monohydric alcohol. Both reaction steps uses a copper-chromite 55 catalyst. Reaction temperatures are in the range from 100 to 300 °C, reaction pressures from 172 to 241 barg, being the catalyst dissolved in slurry. [0019] US patent 4,172,961 is another application of copper chromite catalyst in slurry, to hydrogenate dibutyl butoxy succinate to 1,4-butanediol.

3 EP 2 782 893 B1

[0020] WO patent 82/03854 is a generic process to hydrogenate a carboxylic acid ester in vapor phase with a catalyst comprising a mixture of copper oxide and zinc oxide. One of the several possible applications concerns the production of 1,4-butanediol from an ester of maleic, fumaric or succinic acid. [0021] US patent 4,584,419 consists in a process to hydrogenate an ester of maleic anhydride to 1,4 butanediol in 5 vapor phase in the presence of a copper chromite catalyst. [0022] US patent 4,656,297 is another process to produce 1,4 butanediol by the hydrogenation in vapor phase of dimethylsuccinate with copper chromite catalyst, by adding methanol to the ester feed. [0023] US patent 4,751,334 is also an hydrogenation process in vapor phase with Cu-Cr or Cu-Zn oxide catalyst, to produce 1,4-butanediol from diethyl maleate in two or three adiabatic hydrogenolysis zones in series. 10 [0024] US patent 5,872,276 refers to a process to hydrogenate dialkyl maleate to dialkyl succinate in liquid phase at a pressure of from 50 to 400 bar, at temperature of from 30 to 160 °C and at hydrogen/feed molar ratio from 20 to 40. The catalyst consists of pressed powders of the elements of the iron subgroup with addition of elements of transition groups IV or V, having particular compressive strength and internal surface area. [0025] WO patent 99/52845 represents a process for producing BDO by vapor phase hydrogenation of different types 15 of feed, including dimethyl maleate, characterized by the addition of carbon monoxide to the reaction. [0026] US patents 6,100,410, 6,239,292, 6,274,743, 6,350,924 and 6,433,192 describe different special integrations between a maleic anhydride plant and a BDO production plant, wherein the maleic anhydride absorbed in an organic solvent is first esterified and the resulting maleic ester is stripped by a stream of hydrogen and then subject to an hydrogenation in vapor phase. US patent 6,350,924 belongs to the same group, but it is the only one considering the 20 hydrogenation in liquid phase, by preference operated at very high pressure to obtain, after distillation, very high purity butanediol. US patents 6,137,016 and 2007/0260073 provide a process for the purification of BDO containing minor amount of cyclic acetal, by hydrogenating the butanediol in presence of minor amount of water and under conditions of temperature and pressure typical of the liquid/vapor reactions. [0027] US patent 6,191,322 is a process for the production of BDO by mixed phase catalytic hydrogenation of gamma- 25 butyrolactone or succinic anhydride esters or their mixtures in two catalytic steps in series with injection of cold hydrogen between the reaction stages, at pressure of from 75 to 90 bar and temperature between 160 and 250°C. The catalyst can be selected between copper and zinc oxide or copper chromite. [0028] US patent 6,248,906 is a process where the maleic anhydride ester is subject to two subsequent hydrogenation steps, where the primary hydrogenation produces mainly GBL and THF and the secondary hydrogenation converts a 30 fraction of GBL to BDO. [0029] US patent 6,288,245 teaches a process to convert the BDO produced by vapor phase hydrogenation of maleic ester to THF through a second stage reactor containing silica-alumina catalyst. [0030] US patent 6,433,193 refers to an integration between maleic anhydride and butanediol productions, where the maleic anhydride is recovered by absorption in gamma-butyrolactone and the resulting mixture of maleic anhydride and 35 GBL is subjected to an hydrogenation step under conditions favoring the formation of THF and GBL. [0031] US patent 6,620,949 is another process of integration where the maleic anhydride used to produce BDO, GBL and THF is produced by partial condensation of the vapor effluent from a maleic anhydride catalytic oxidation reactor. [0032] US patent 6,844,452 is a hydrogenation process in vapor phase for production of BDO and THF from dimethyl or diethyl maleate, characterized by three hydrogenation zones in series using different catalysts, such arrangement 40 permitting to accept minor amounts of acidic material in the feed, to enhance the yields of THF and to reduce the formation of cyclic acetals. [0033] US patent 6,936,727 refers to a particular scheme of vapor phase hydrogenation, using catalyst and conditions favorable to the formation of tetrahydrofuran, characterized by the liquid feed which is divided in two parts fed separately to two subsequent vaporizer/reactor systems, allowing in this way an overall lower circulation of hydrogen to maintain 45 the reactor feed above its dew point temperature. [0034] CN patent 101307042 relates to a method for producing BDO together with THF and GBL, by using two catalyst bed layers, the first containing copper oxide and copper chromite or zinc oxide with one among Ba, Mg, Ti, Ce, Si, Zr and Mn oxide additive, the second containing copper oxide, alumina and one of the above described additive. [0035] The aim of the US patent 7,598,404 is the same of the above mentioned US patent 6,936,727: in a process 50 targeted to producing mainly tetrahydrofuran, the feed is first hydrogenated in a pre-reactor zone comprising catalyst which favors the carbon double bond saturation, i.e. the production of dimethyl succinate from dimethyl maleate. In this way the heat of reaction may be utilized in the evaporation of some of the liquid feed. Accordingly to the patent, in the second reaction zone, where THF and optionally diol and/or lactone are produced, the reaction occurs strictly under conditions of complete vaporization. 55 [0036] CN patent 101747149 discloses a method for preparing BDO by two stages hydrogenation in series by using maleic acid dialkyl ester, where the effluent from the first reaction step is cooled and separated in two phases and the resulting liquid product is contacted again with hydrogen in the second hydrogenation section. [0037] Most of the above mentioned and other patents on the production of butanediol by hydrogenation of a dialkyl

4 EP 2 782 893 B1

maleate, refers to a reaction in vapor phase. The operation in vapor phase at high pressure needs a large amount of recirculating hydrogen rich gas. [0038] Moreover the conversion of DMM in a single reactor, where both the hydrogenation (double bond saturation) and the hydrogenolysis reactions occur at the same time, being the hydrogenation reaction the more exothermic step 5 and also the quicker as rate of reaction, causes localized high temperatures (hot spot) in the first part of the catalytic bed difficult to control and producing unwelcome by-products, butanol and other, and risk of catalyst decay. [0039] The already mentioned US patent 7,598,404 refers at page 3:In conventional vapour phase reactions with hydrogen the capital and operating costs, particularly energy and other utilities requirements, are largely determined by the flow rate of the gas feed to the vaporiser..... The size of the compressors, heat exchangers and interconnecting 10 pipework is dictated by the cycle gas flow rate as is the power required for compression and the heat required to be added to the reactor feed and removed from the reactor product. There is therefore a strong incentive to minimize the cycle gas flow rate within a particular process. [0040] It is clear the reduction of the cycle gas below a certain limit, causes the reaction to be any more in vapor phase and to enter in the mixed liquid/vapor conditions. This operation with a reduced gas circulation, even if of course it is 15 advantageous both as capital and operating cost, owing to the high exothermic effect of the hydrogenation reaction, results in a more difficult control of the reaction temperature. In fact, as already mentioned, excessive temperature of the reaction involves both an higher formation of undesired by-products and a reduced life of the catalyst. The by- products are certainly cause of reduced efficiency (higher consumption of raw materials and utilities) and, in some cases, are detrimental for the quality of the product. 20 [0041] The above mentioned US patent 6,191,322 is one of the very few patent for the production of BDO in mixed phase. The patent solves the problem connected to the temperature control, first by using as feedstock an already partially hydrogenated product, i.e. gamma-butyrolactone or dimethyl succinate or a mixture of both compounds, second by using a multistage reactor and by cooling down the mixture between the reaction stages by injecting cold hydrogen. [0042] It is clear that the main limitation of this patent is related to the type of feedstock, which needs a further separate 25 hydrogenation plant to transform dimethylmaleate into dimethylsuccinate or gamma-butyrolactone. [0043] It is object of the present invention a method to produce 1,4-butanediol from dialkyl maleates in a single hydrogenation plant, by avoiding the expensive process in vapor phase.

SUMMARY OF THE DISCLOSURE 30 [0044] Aim of the present invention is to propose a process for the production of 1,4-butanediol gamma-butyrolactone and tetrahydrofuran by catalytic hydrogenation of dialkyl maleates, according to claim 1. [0045] The process consists essentially in the following steps:

35 a) hydrogenating a stream of dialkyl maleate in a first stage of reaction over a suitable catalyst to produce dialkyl succinate; b) further hydrogenating the dialkyl succinate in a second stage of reaction, by using a different suitable catalyst, for producing mainly 1,4-butanediol, together with gamma-butyrolactone and tetrahydrofuran as co-products.

40 [0046] In both stages of reaction the conditions, as hydrogen/ organic feed ratio, pressure and temperature, are such to maintain the reactors in mixed liquid/vapor phase. [0047] In the preferred embodiment of the present invention the catalyst used in the first step of hydrogenation shall have to following characteristics:

45 i) high selectivity to the saturation of the carbon double bond and very low selectivity to the hydrogenolysis; ii) high activity to the saturation of the carbon double bond even at moderate temperature.

[0048] By using a catalyst having the above described characteristic, besides the other economic advantages already described due to the reaction in mixed liquid/vapor phase rather than in vapor phase, the following further advantages 50 are achieved:

a) the heat released during the first step of reaction is only limited to the saturation of the carbon double bond; by using a controlled amount of recycle hydrogen, the increase of temperature in a fixed bed reactor is also easily maintained under control. 55 b) by properly controlling the inlet temperature of the reaction mixture, dialkyl maleate and recycling hydrogen rich gas, the outlet temperature from first reaction step may match the inlet temperature of the second stage of the reaction, where most or all the hydrogenolysis reactions take place. c) all the heat of reaction of the first hydrogenation step is used for pre-heating at the proper temperature the reactive

5 EP 2 782 893 B1

mixture entering the second stage. d) the heat content of the liquid-gas mixture from the second stage of reaction, at a temperature between 180 to 230 °C, is first used to generate low pressure steam, which may be used in other sections of the plant, for instance for the distillation of DMM or for the purification of the products, BDO, THF and, if required, GBL. Then the effluent 5 heat is used to preheat of the mixed phase feedstock, DMM plus hydrogen, up to the inlet temperature of the first stage of reaction, which, as above mentioned, may be moderate (between 80 to 130 °C). No external heat source is needed.

[0049] In conclusion the two stages reaction system, as proposed in this invention, not only cuts to nil the external 10 energy consumption, normally not negligible in the conventional processes in vapor phase, but also permits the production and the export of steam from the reaction system, by making the best of the intrinsic exothermic heat of the hydrogenation reactions. Moreover the proposed solution permits a better control of hot spot temperatures and a more selective process, with reduced amount of by-products. [0050] In another embodiment of this invention, the temperature profile of the second stage of reaction can be improved 15 and flattened, by injecting moderate amounts of cold hydrogen, withdrawn from the discharge of the recycle compressor, and sent, without any heat recovery, in intermediate points of the fixed bed second stage of reaction. [0051] Examples of suitable catalysts to be used in the first stage include low content palladium catalysts supported on carbon or on alumina. [0052] Examples of suitable catalysts to be used for hydrogenolysis in the second stage include copper containing 20 catalysts, such as copper-chromite catalysts or copper-zinc oxide catalysts. [0053] To an extent surprisingly more favourable than expected, the tests produced using the above described reaction in mixed phase and in two steps showed that the formation of the by-product cyclic acetal, the 2-(hydroxybutoxy)-tet- rahydrofuran, which represents a particularly undesired impurity due to its boiling point very close to that of BDO, is considerably reduced compared to other similar processes in vapor phase. This represents a further and not negligible 25 advantage of the present invention. On the other hand the already mentioned US patent 2007/0260073 by Davy Process Technology Ltd. teaches that the reduction of acetal may be achieved by contacting in liquid phase with a stream of hydrogen and in presence of catalysts of the same type described in the present invention the butanediol produced, normally in vapor phase, in another hydrogenolysis reactor. The present invention reaches a still better result, in terms of acetal contamination, simply by operating the hydrogenolysis reaction in mixed liquid-gas phase, without any need 30 of additional purification step in liquid phase. [0054] Another aspect of this invention became manifest during the execution of the laboratory tests. In an industrial plant the total reaction gas, used in large excess respect the stoichiometric amount, is mainly made by recycle gas, originated in the low temperature (30 to 60 °C) liquid-gas separator located after the cooling of the second stage reaction effluent. In the second stage of reaction some tetrahydrofuran is produced together with a stoichiometric amount of 35 water. Being such water much lighter, as boiling point, than the main product (BDO), most of the water remain in vapor phase and, therefore, the recycle gas, circulated back to the first stage of reaction by a compressor, is saturated with vapor water. [0055] In the laboratory tests, where the equipment arrangement is simpler than in the industrial plant, all the reaction gas is formed by high purity gas from hydrogen cylinder. In order to reproduce the industrial plant performances, some 40 tests have been repeated by adding to the hydrogen stream a calculated amount of steam. Surprisingly, in the tests with addition of steam the THF/BDO ratio was much lower, around half, compared to the tests with anhydrous hydrogen. This feature may be used when the desired final product from the plant is mainly or only THF rather than BDO: by removing water from the recycle gas, the yield in THF may be in some extent increased. The water removal from the recycle gas may be accomplished by contact with a solid adsorbent of several types. A possible adsorbing agent is a 45 standard zeolite used for the dehydration of gases. [0056] Alternatively the water removal from the hydrogen rich gas can take place by contacting it in a absorption column with an organic solvent having high boiling point and hygroscopic tendency, as for instance triethylene glycol. The preferred type of liquid absorbent is however one of the products from the plant, including butanediol or gamma- butyrolactone, recycled back from the product purification system of the plant. The tetrahydrofuran on the contrary in 50 not considered a right absorbent, both since it is a volatile product (the boiling point is only 65 °C) and since it is quite difficult to separate from water by distillation, by forming the two components an azeotropic mixture. Beside the increased yields in THF, the water removal from the recycle gas may also contribute to reduce the deterioration of the catalysts and to increase their life time. [0057] The process of this invention allows to modify the relative ratios of butanediol, tetrahydrofuran and gamma- 55 butyrolactone . [0058] The THF/BDO ratio may be modified, besides by means of the above described moisture removal from the recycle gas, even by subjecting either the crude or the refined butanediol and either in presence or without hydrogen to a process of dehydration at moderate temperature, 120 to 250 °C, which may occur by contact with an acidic catalyst

6 EP 2 782 893 B1

of the silica-alumina type or , if applied to the purified butanediol, of the polymer-based resin with sulfonic acid group. [0059] Moreover the THF+GBL/BDO ratio may be also increased by lowering the pressure of the hydrogenation reaction. [0060] A right combination of moisture removal, reduced operating pressure and acid catalyst bed may contribute to 5 reach the desired ratio THF/BDO. Moreover, also the production of gamma-butyro-lactone may be controlled from zero to a certain amount, by adjusting its recycle rate, between full recycle to zero recycle, from the purification to the hydrogenation section. [0061] The overall Hydrogenation reaction conditions and performances relevant to the this invention are summarized in the attached Table 1. 10 Table 1 - Reactors conditions and performances Pressure 30 to 80 bar Temperatures 1st stage inlet 80 to 130 °C 15 2nd stage inlet 160 to 190 °C Ratio Hydrogen/organic feed (molar) 30 to 60 Liquid Hourly Space velocity (LHSV) 1st stage 0.5 to 2.0 20 2nd stage 0.1 to 0.3 DMM conversion higher than 99.9% Selectivity (BDO/THF/GBL) higher than 95%

25 BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS

[0062]

Figure 1 is a simplified process flow diagram of the hydrogenation system, as described in the summary of the 30 disclosure points (a), (b), (c) and (d), to produce 1,4-butanediol and, optionally, gamma-butyrolactone and/or tet- rahydrofuran by catalytic hydrogenation of dialkyl maleates. Figure 2 is a more complete arrangement of the hydrogenation system, where besides the two stages of reaction, the following additional features are included:

35 (i) the temperature profile of the second stage of reaction is flattened by injection of cold recycle gas rich in hydrogen (ii) the recycle gas is washed in an absorption column to reduce its moisture content, for increasing the tetrahy- drofuran formation

40 [0063] The present invention will be described with reference to these drawings.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

[0064] Figure 1 illustrates a plant for the production of BDO and, optionally GBL and THF, by catalytic reaction of a 45 dialkyl maleate, typically dimethyl maleate, with hydrogen in mixed liquid-vapor phase. [0065] The dimethyl maleate, produced by catalytic esterification of maleic anhydride, is fed as stream 1 in liquid phase. Stream 1 may also contain, beside DMM, a minor amount of unconverted DMS recycled back from the purification section of the plant, normally in mixture with some amount of GBL. Stream 1 is mixed with stream 13, which represents the mixture of the fresh hydrogen stream 2 with the reaction recycle gas stream 12. 50 [0066] The resulting stream 3 is therefore a mixed liquid/vapor fluid. It is first preheated in the heat exchanger 24, by recovering heat from the effluent stream 8 of the second stage hydrogenation reactor 22, and then in the heat exchanger 27, using condensing low pressure steam as heating medium. This heat exchanger 27 is used for temperature control reason particularly during the start-up of the plant; during the normal steady operation of the plant, it could be disconnected or by-passed. By using peculiar start-up procedures, the heat exchanger 27 could be even eliminated. The outlet stream 55 5 from the exchanger enters the first stage of reaction 21. It is a downflow fixed bed adiabatic reactor, containing a specific catalyst highly selective for the saturation of the carbon double bond contained in the dialkyl-maleate. [0067] In the catalyst bed of reactor 21 the dimethyl maleate is transformed in dimethyl succinate with very high conversion and selectivity. This reaction is highly exothermic and therefore the outlet temperature of the effluent stream

7 EP 2 782 893 B1

6 is somewhat higher than the temperature of the inlet stream 5. In a preferred embodiment of this invention, the reaction system is designed in a way that the outlet temperature of the first reactor stage matches the inlet temperature of the second reaction stage and, therefore, no heat exchanger is included in the design of the system. [0068] The effluent from the reactor first stage 6 under controlled temperature enters the second stage reactor 22. It 5 is also a downflow fixed bed adiabatic reactor, containing a catalyst different from the first stage and, more specifically, a catalyst suitable for the hydrogenolysis of the dimethyl succinate to 1,4-butanediol; depending from the conditions of pressure and temperature, together with BDO, variable amounts of gamma-butyrolactone and/or tetrahydrofuran can be produced. [0069] Product stream 7 from the reactor is first cooled in the heat exchanger 23. The heat exchanger 23 is a steam 10 generator, preferably of the kettle type with the production of steam inside the shell of the exchanger. It could be, as alternate case, a natural circulation exchanger, where the boiler feed water used to produce steam is fed to an external vessel and a natural thermosiphon circulation is generated between the vessel and the boiler. [0070] The outlet stream 8 from the heat exchanger 23 is passed to the already described interexchanger 24. The outlet stream 9 is further cooled in the heat exchanger 25, which is without distinction a water cooler or an air cooler. 15 [0071] The cooled stream 10 enters the separator vessel 26, where the crude liquid product 14, containing mostly BDO with lower percentages of gamma-butyrolactone, tetrahydrofuran, methanol, water, unreacted dimethyl succinate and impurities, is separated from the vapor phase stream 11, consisting essentially in hydrogen, with lower amounts of methanol, tetrahydrofuran and water. The gaseous stream 11 is then recycled back via the compressor 28, which differential pressure corresponds to the total pressure drop, including reactors, heat exchangers, separators, piping and 20 control valves, of the plant. [0072] The discharge stream 12 from the compressor, together with the fresh hydrogen stream 2, constitutes the overall reaction gas 13 used in the hydrogenation reactors. [0073] Figure 2 illustrates a plant for the production of BDO and, optionally GBL and THF, by catalytic reaction of a dialkyl maleate, where (i) the temperature profile of the second stage of reaction is flattened by injection of cold recycle 25 gas rich in hydrogen and (ii) the recycle gas is washed in an absorption column to reduce its moisture content, by increasing the tetrahydrofuran formation. [0074] The dimethyl maleate, produced by catalytic esterification of maleic anhydride, is fed as stream 1 in liquid phase. Stream 1 may also contain, beside DMM, a minor amount of unconverted DMS recycled back from the purification section of the plant, normally in mixture with some amount of GBL. Stream 1 is mixed with stream 16, which represents 30 part of the mixture 13 of the fresh hydrogen stream 2 with the reaction recycle gas stream 12. Another minor portion of the recycle gas, as stream 15, is directly recycled at cold temperature to the second stage of reaction to control its temperature increase. Fig. 2 shows two different injection points: depending on reactor conditions, the points of injection could be more than two or even a single injection. [0075] The stream 3, resulting from the mixture of fresh feed and recycle gas, is therefore a mixed liquid/vapor fluid. 35 It is first preheated in the heat exchanger 24, by recovering heat from the effluent stream 8 of the second stage hydro- genation reactor 22 , and then in the heat exchanger 27, using condensing low pressure steam as heating medium. This heat exchanger 27 is used for temperature control reason particularly during the start-up of the plant; during the normal steady operation of the plant, it could be disconnected or by-passed. By using peculiar start-up procedures, the heat exchanger 27 could be even eliminated. The outlet stream 5 from the exchanger enters the first stage of reaction 21. It 40 is a downflow fixed bed adiabatic reactor, containing a specific catalyst highly selective for the saturation of the carbon double bond contained in the dialkyl maleate. [0076] In the catalyst bed of reactor 21 the dimethylmaleate is transformed in dimethyl-succinate with very high con- version and selectivity. This reaction is highly exothermic and therefore the outlet temperature of the effluent stream 6 is somewhat higher than the temperature of the inlet stream 5. In a preferred embodiment of this invention, the reaction 45 system is designed in a way that the outlet temperature of the first reactor stage matches the inlet temperature of the second reaction stage and, therefore, no heat exchanger is included in the design of the system. [0077] The effluent from the reactor first stage 6 under controlled temperature enters the second stage reactor 22. It is also a downflow fixed bed adiabatic reactor, containing a catalyst different from the first stage and, more specifically, a catalyst suitable for the hydrogenolysis of the dimethyl succinate to 1,4-butanediol; depending from the conditions of 50 pressure and temperature, together with BDO, variable amounts of gamma-butyrolactone and/or tetrahydrofuran can be produced. [0078] Product stream 7 from the reactor is first cooled in the heat exchanger 23. The heat exchanger 23 is a steam generator, preferably of the kettle type with the production of steam inside the shell of the exchanger. It could be, as alternate case, a natural circulation exchanger, where the boiler feed water used to produce steam is fed to an external 55 vessel and a natural thermosiphon circulation is generated between the vessel and the boiler. [0079] The outlet stream 8 from the heat exchanger 23 is passed to the already described interexchanger 24. The outlet stream 9 is further cooled in the heat exchanger 25, which is without distinction a water cooler or an air cooler. [0080] The cooled stream 10 enters the separator vessel 26, where the crude liquid product 14, containing mostly

8 EP 2 782 893 B1

BDO with lower percentages of gamma-butyrolactone, tetrahydrofuran, methanol, water, unreacted dimethyl succinate and impurities, is separated from the vapor phase stream 11, consisting essentially in hydrogen, with lower amounts of methanol, tetrahydrofuran and water. [0081] The gaseous stream 11, containing some percentages of moisture produced in the second stage of reaction, 5 enters an absorption column 29, including trays or packing of different types, where the moisture is removed by contacting with a cold liquid stream 18, preferably consisting in purified GBL or BDO, fed to the top of the column. The resulting liquid stream 19 from the column bottom, consisting in wet GBL or BDO, joins the stream 14, to be sent together to the distillation section of the plant. [0082] The dry gaseous stream 17 from the column overhead is then recycled back via the compressor 28, which 10 differential pressure corresponds to the total pressure drop, including reactors, heat exchangers, columns, separators, piping and control valves, of the plant. [0083] The discharge stream 12 from the compressor, together with the fresh hydrogen stream 2, constitutes the overall reaction gas 13 used in the hydrogenation reactors.

15 EXAMPLES

[0084] Experimental apparatus. The laboratory scale experiments highlight the nature of the invention, but are not intended to limit its scope. [0085] In these laboratory experiments, the hydrogenation of dimethyl maleate (DMM) to butanediol (BDO) has been 20 produced by using two reactors in series: the first to convert DMM to dimethyl succinate (DMS), the second to convert DMS to BDO. [0086] The first reactor consists of a stainless steel tube (1000 mm length, 20 mm internal diameter) externally thermo- controlled by heating bands. The reactor has been designed to contain a single catalytic bed for the hydrogenation of dimethyl maleate (DMM) to dimethyl succinate (DMS), with height of 60 mm and consisting of Pd supported by carbon. 25 [0087] The second reactor consists of a stainless steel tube (1800 mm length, 20 mm internal diameter) externally thermo-controlled by heating bands. For the tests described in this patent, it has been used with a single catalytic bed for the hydrogenolysis of the DMS to butanediol (BDO) with height of 600 mm. The catalysts used in the tests are based on copper, such us copper-chromite catalysts or copper-zinc oxide catalysts. [0088] Both catalytic beds are preceded by a bed of glass cylinders (5 x 10 mm) with height of around 500 mm, used 30 to preheat the feedstock to the reaction starting temperature. [0089] The preheating of the liquid feed is performed by means of the crossing of the feedstock capillary tube through the heating bands of the first reactor. [0090] The continuous monitoring of the temperature is performed by means of four thermocouples located respectively at the inlet and outlet of each catalytic bed. 35 [0091] The reaction products are recovered in two separated vessels, the first for the heavier product, directly located at the bottom of the second reactor, the second, mainly for the lighter products, located downstream of a double pipe heat exchanger for the cooling of the outlet mixture. [0092] The samples were analyzed using a gas chromatograph equipped with a mass spectrometer detector (Agilent 5893N). 40 Comparative Example 1

[0093] In this example 1 only the first reactor was used. [0094] A stream of liquid DMM was fed to the first reactor with Palladium on carbon catalyst, under the following 45 conditions:

Pressure: 60 barg Temperature: 100 to 165 °C

Molar ratio H2/DMM: 50 50 Liquid hourly Space Velocity: about 2

[0095] The main results of tests at different temperatures are shown in Table 2

55 Table 2 - DMM Hydrogenation to DMS Temperature °C Conversion % Selectivity to DMS % 100 100 99.0

9 EP 2 782 893 B1

(continued)

Temperature °C Conversion % Selectivity to DMS % 120 100 98.9 5 165 100 99.0

[0096] This example 1 shows the catalyst for the first step of reaction has both the necessary characteristics: i) high selectivity to the saturation of the carbon double bond and very low selectivity to the hydrogenolysis, ii) high activity to 10 the saturation of the carbon double bond even at moderate temperature. [0097] Even if, due to the small size of the laboratory equipment, the fully adiabatic conditions were not reproduced, a computer simulation of the conditions used during the test showed the increment of temperature from the inlet to the outlet of an adiabatic fixed bed reactor is around 60 °C.

15 Comparative Example 2

[0098] In this example 2 both reactor stages, as described in the Experimental apparatus, were used. [0099] A stream of liquid DMM was fed to the first reactor with palladium on carbon catalyst, under the following conditions: 20 Pressure: 70 barg Temperatures: First stage outlet 130 to 135 °C Second stage outlet 178 to 182 °C 25 Molar ratio H2/DMM: 50 Liquid hourly Space Velocity: First stage 2.0 hr -1 Second stage 0.2 hr -1 30 [0100] The main results of the analytical test are shown in Table 3

Table 3 - DMM Hydrogenation and Hydrogenolysis -Dry conditions

35 DMM conversion 100% Selectivity to BDO/GBL/THF 95 Composition (*) % THF 13.09 40 BuOH 1.61 2Me THF less than 0.01 Me-butyrate 0.47

45 2-Metoxy-THF less than 0.01 4-Metoxy-BuOH 0.44 GBL 4.86 1,4 BDO 77.00 50 DMS 2.36 Unknown 1 0.17 Other unknown less than 0.01

55 (*) net of water and methanol

10 EP 2 782 893 B1

Comparative Example 3

[0101] In this example 3 the conditions of example 2 have been repeated, with the only difference of a small addition of water to the feed to simulate the conditions of an industrial plant, where the recycle gas is saturated by water. 5 The main results of the analytical test are shown in Table 4

Table 4 - DMM Hydrogenation and Hydrogenolysis - Wet conditions DMM conversion 100%

10 Selectivity to BDO/GBL/THF 95.6 Composition (*) % THF 6.34 BuOH 0.69 15 2Me THF less than 0.01 Me-butyrate 0.22 2-Metoxy-THF less than 0.01

20 4-Metoxy-BuOH 0.31 GBL 5.33 1,4 BDO 83.96 DMS 2.20 25 Unknown 1 0.95 Other unknown less than 0.01 (*) net of water and methanol

30 [0102] This example 3 shows that in wet conditions the overall results are very similar to the dry conditions ones, with the main difference in the yields in THF which drops from 13% to around 6%, being this difference compensated by an equivalent increased yield in BDO. [0103] The overall yield in the three valuable products, BDO,GBL and THF, is 95.6%. Considering that the unreacted 35 DMS may be separated by distillation, alone or in mixture with GBL, and recycled back to the reaction system, the actual overall yield is around 97.8%.

Claims 40 1. A process for manufacturing, from dialkyl maleates and hydrogen, 1,4-butanediol, gamma-butyrolactone and tet- rahydrofuran, said process comprising the following steps:

a) hydrogenating a stream of dialkyl maleate in a first stage of reaction over suitable catalyst to produce dialkyl 45 succinate; b) further hydrogenating the dialkyl succinate in a second stage of reaction, by using a different suitable catalyst, for producing mainly 1,4-butanediol (BDO), together with gamma-butyrolactone (GBL) and tetrahydrofuran (THF) as co-products;

50 wherein,

the catalyst used in the first stage of reaction is a low content palladium catalyst supported on carbon or on alumina, the catalyst used for hydrogenolysis in the second stage is a copper containing catalyst, such as copper-chromite 55 catalyst or copper-zinc oxide catalyst, the first stage of reaction operates from 80 to 130 °C as inlet temperature and from 160 to 190 °C as outlet temperature, from 30 to 80 bar as pressure and with a liquid hourly space velocity from 0.5 to 2.0;

11 EP 2 782 893 B1

the second stage of reaction operates from 160 to 190 °C as inlet temperature, from 30 to 80 bar as pressure and with a liquid hourly space velocity from 0.1 to 0.3, and the hydrogen/organic feed molar ratio is from 30 to 60, in order to obtain that: 5 (i) in both stages of reaction the conditions, as hydrogen/ organic feed ratio, pressure and temperature, are such to maintain the reactors in mixed liquid/vapor phase, (ii) the outlet temperature from first reaction step matches the inlet temperature of the second stage of the reaction, being all the heat of reaction of the first hydrogenation step used for pre-heating at the proper 10 temperature the reactive mixture entering the second stage, (iii) the heat content of the liquid-gas mixture from the second stage of reaction, is first used to generate low pressure steam and then to preheat the mixed feed to the inlet temperature of the first reaction stage, and (iv) no external heat source is needed in the reaction system.

15 2. The process according to claim 1, wherein the operation is performed on a continuous basis.

3. The process according to claim 1, wherein the dialkyl maleate is dimethyl maleate.

4. The process according to claim 1, wherein both reaction stages are fixed bed adiabatic reactors. 20 5. The process according to claim 1 wherein the catalyst of the second stage, in addition to copper-chromite or copper- zinc oxides, contains 2 to 15 % of barium or manganese oxide.

6. The process according to claim 1, wherein the required hydrogen/organic feed molar ratio is achieved by cooling 25 the effluent from the second stage of reaction at a temperature between 20 to 60 °C, by separating the resulting liquid and gaseous phases in a dedicated vessel, by recirculating the gaseous phase through a recycle compressor and by removing the water from said recycle gas by contact with a solid adsorbent or by contact in a absorption column with an organic solvent having high boiling point and hygroscopic tendency.

30 7. The process according to claim 6, wherein the organic solvent is gamma-butyrolactone or butanediol.

8. The process according to claim 1, wherein the tetrahydrofuran/1,4-butanediol (THF/BDO) ratio may be modified by subjecting either the crude or the refined butanediol to a process of dehydration at moderate temperature, 120 to 250 °C, which may occur by contact with an acidic catalyst of the silica-alumina type. 35 9. The process according to claim 1, wherein the tetrahydrofuran + gamma-butyrolactone / 1,4-butanediol (THF+GBL/BDO) ratio may be increased by operating the process at a pressure of the hydrogenation reaction in the range between 30 to 40 bar.

40 Patentansprüche

1. Verfahren zur Herstellung von 1,4-Butandiol, Gamma-butyrolacton und Tetrahydrofuran aus Dialkylmaleaten und Wasserstoff, wobei das Verfahren die folgenden Schritte umfasst: 45 a)Hydrieren eines Stroms Dialkylmaleat in einer ersten Reaktionsstufe über einem geeignetem Katalysator, um Dialkylsuccinat zu bilden; b)weiteres Hydrieren des Dialkylsuccinats in einer zweiten Reaktionsstufe, um hauptsächlich 1,4-Butandiol (BDO) herzustellen, zusammen mit Gamma-butyrolacton und Tetrahydrofuran als Nebenprodukte; 50 wobei

der in der ersten Reaktionsstufe verwendete Katalysator ein Katalysator mit geringem Palladiumgehalt auf Kohlenstoff oder auf Aluminium ist, 55 der in der zweiten Reaktionsstufe zur Hydrierung verwendete Katalysator ein Kupfer enthaltender Katalysator, wie ein Kupferchromit-Katalysator oder ein Kupfer-Zink-Oxid-Katalysator, ist, die erste Reaktionsstufe bei einer Einlasstemperatur von 80 bis 130°C und einer Auslasstemperatur von 160 bis 190°C, mit einem Druck von 30 bis 80 bar und einer stündlichen Flüssigkeitsraumgeschwindigkeit von 0,5

12 EP 2 782 893 B1

bis 2,0 betrieben wird; die zweite Reaktionsstufe bei einer Einlasstemperatur von 160 bis 190°C, mit einem Druck von 30 bis 80 bar und einer stündlichen Flüssigkeitsraumgeschwindigkeit von 0,1 bis 0,3 betrieben wird, und das molare Verhältnis des Wasserstoff/organischen-Stroms von 30 bis 60 ist, 5 um zu erreichen, dass:

(i)die Bedingungen in beiden Reaktionsstufen, wie das Verhältnis des Wasserstoff/organischen-Stroms, Druck und Temperatur, so sind, dass die Reaktoren in einer gemischten flüssigen/dampfförmigen Phase sind, 10 (ii) die Auslasstemperatur der ersten Reaktionsstufe der Einlasstemperatur der zweiten Reaktionsstufe entspricht, also die gesamte Wärme der Reaktion des ersten Hydrierungsschrittes zum Vorheizen auf die richtige Temperatur der in die zweite Stufe eintretenden reaktiven Mischung verwendet wird, (iii) der Wärmegehalt der Flüssigkeit-Gasmischung der zweiten Reaktionsstufe als erstes verwendet wird, um einen Dampf mit niedrigem Druck zu erzeugen und dann um den gemischten Strom auf die Einlass- 15 temperatur der ersten Reaktionsstufe vorzuheizen, und (iv) keine externe Wärmequelle im Reaktionssystem benötigt wird.

2. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei der Betrieb auf einer kontinuierlichen Basis durchgeführt wird.

20 3. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei das Dialkylmaleat Dimethylmaleat ist.

4. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei beide Reaktionsstufen adiabatische Festbettreaktoren sind.

5. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei der Katalysator der zweiten Stufe zusätzlich zu Kupferchromit oder zu Kupfer- 25 Zink-Oxiden 2 bis 15% Barium- oder Manganoxid enthält.

6. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei das benötigte molare Verhältnis im Wasserstoff/organischen-Strom erreicht wird indem der Ablauf von der zweiten Reaktionsstufe bei einer Temperatur zwischen 20 und 60°C gekühlt wird, indem die resultierenden flüssigen und gasförmigen Phasen in entsprechenden Behältern getrennt werden, indem die 30 gasförmige Phase durch einen Recyclekompressor rezirkuliert wird und indem Wasser vom rezirkulierten Gas entfernt wird, durch Kontakt mit einem festen Adsorber oder durch Kontakt mit einer Absorptionssäule mit einem organischen Lösungsmittel mit hohem Siedepunkt und hygroskopischer Tendenz.

7. Verfahren nach Anspruch 6, wobei das organische Lösungsmittel Gamma-butyrolacton oder Butandiol ist. 35 8. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei das Verhältnis von Tetrahydrofuran/1,4-Butandiol (THF/BDO) verändert werden kann indem unaufbereitetes oder aufbereitetes Butandiol einem Verfahren zur Dehydrierung bei gemäßigter Tem- peratur, 120 bis 250°C, unterzogen wird, welches durch Kontakt mit einem sauren Katalysator vom Siliciumoxid- Aluminumoxid-Typ erfolgen kann. 40 9. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei das Verhältnis von Tetrahydrofuran + Gamma-butyrolacton / 1,4-Butandiol (THF+GBL/BDO) erhöht werden kann, indem die Hydrierungsreaktion des Verfahrens mit einem Druck im Bereich zwischen 30 und 40 bar betrieben wird.

45 Revendications

1. Procédé de fabrication de 1,4-butanediol, de gamma-butyrolactone et de tétrahydrofuranne, à partir de maléates de dialkyle et d’hydrogène, ledit procédé comprenant les étapes suivantes : 50 a) l’hydrogénation d’un flux de maléate de dialkyle dans une première étape de réaction sur un catalyseur approprié pour produire du succinate de dialkyle ; b) l’hydrogénation ultérieure du succinate de dialkyle dans une deuxième étape de réaction, en utilisant un catalyseur approprié différent, pour produire principalement du 1,4-butanediol (BDO), conjointement à de la 55 gamma-butyrolactone (GBL) et du tétrahydrofuranne (THF) comme coproduits ;

dans lequel, le catalyseur utilisé dans la première étape de réaction est un catalyseur à faible teneur en palladium supporté sur

13 EP 2 782 893 B1

carbone ou sur alumine, le catalyseur utilisé pour l’hydrogénolyse dans la deuxième étape est un catalyseur contenant du cuivre, tel qu’un catalyseur cuivre-chromite ou un catalyseur cuivre oxyde de zinc, la première étape de réaction s’opère à une température d’entrée de 80 à 130°C et à une température de sortie de 5 160 à 190°C, à une pression de 30 à 80 bars et avec une vitesse spatiale horaire de liquide de 0,5 à 2,0 ; la deuxième étape de réaction s’opère à une température d’entrée de 160 à 190°C, à une pression de 30 à 80 bars et avec une vitesse spatiale horaire de liquide de 0,1 à 0,3, et le rapport molaire d’alimentation hydrogène/organique est de 30 à 60, de manière à obtenir que : 10 (i) dans les deux étapes de réaction, les conditions, telle que le rapport d’alimentation hydrogène/organique, lapression et latempérature, soientsusceptibles de maintenir les réacteursdans unephase mixteliquide/vapeur, (ii) la température de sortie de la première étape de réaction corresponde à la température d’entrée de la deuxième étape de réaction, toute la chaleur de réaction de la première étape d’hydrogénation étant utilisée 15 pour le préchauffage à la température appropriée du mélange réactif entrant dans la deuxième étape, (iii) le contenu calorifique du mélange liquide-gaz provenant de la deuxième étape de réaction soit utilisé d’abord pour générer de la vapeur à basse pression et ensuite pour préchauffer l’alimentation mixte à la température d’entrée de la première étape de réaction, et (iv) aucune source de chaleur externe ne soit nécessaire dans le système de réaction. 20 2. Procédé selon la revendication 1, dans lequel le fonctionnement est effectué sur une base continue.

3. Procédé selon la revendication 1, dans lequel le maléate de dialkyle est un maléate diméthyle.

25 4. Procédé selon la revendication 1, dans lequel les deux étapes de réaction sont des réacteurs adiabatiques à lit fixe.

5. Procédé selon la revendication 1, dans lequel le catalyseur de la deuxième étape, en plus du cuivre-chromite ou du cuivre-oxydes de zinc, contient 2 à 15% d’oxyde de baryum ou de manganèse.

30 6. Procédé selon la revendication 1, dans lequel le rapport molaire d’alimentation hydrogène/organique nécessaire est obtenu par refroidissement de l’effluent provenant de la deuxième étape de réaction à une température entre 20 et 60°C, par séparation des phases liquide et gazeuse résultantes dans un récipient dédié, par recirculation de la phase gazeuse par le biais d’un compresseur de recyclage et par élimination de l’eau dudit gaz de recyclage par contact avec un absorbant solide ou par contact dans une colonne d’absorption avec un solvant organique ayant 35 un point d’ébullition élevé et une tendance hygroscopique.

7. Procédé selon la revendication 6, dans lequel le solvant organique est de la gamma-butyrolactone ou du butanediol.

8. Procédé selon la revendication 1, dans lequel le rapport tétrahydrofuranne/1,4-butanediol (THF/BDO) peut être 40 modifié en soumettant le butanediol soit brut soit raffiné à un processus de déshydratation à température modérée, 120 à 250°C, qui peut s’effectuer par contact avec un catalyseur acide du type silice-alumine.

9. Procédé selon la revendication 1, dans lequel le rapport tétrahydrofuranne + gamma-butyrolactone / 1,4-butanediol (THF+GBL/BDO) peut être augmenté en faisant fonctionner le processus à une pression de la réaction d’hydrogé- 45 nation dans la plage entre 30 et 40 bars.

50

55

14 EP 2 782 893 B1

15 EP 2 782 893 B1

16 EP 2 782 893 B1

REFERENCES CITED IN THE DESCRIPTION

This list of references cited by the applicant is for the reader’s convenience only. It does not form part of the European patent document. Even though great care has been taken in compiling the references, errors or omissions cannot be excluded and the EPO disclaims all liability in this regard.

Patent documents cited in the description

• US 2110488 A [0017] • US 6433192 B [0026] • US 4032458 A [0018] • US 6137016 A [0026] • US 4172961 A [0019] • US 20070260073 A [0026] [0053] • WO 8203854 A [0020] • US 6191322 B [0027] [0041] • US 4584419 A [0021] • US 6248906 B [0028] • US 4656297 A [0022] • US 6288245 B [0029] • US 4751334 A [0023] • US 6433193 B [0030] • US 5872276 A [0024] • US 6620949 B [0031] • WO 9952845 A [0025] • US 6844452 B [0032] • US 6100410 A [0026] • US 6936727 B [0033] [0035] • US 6239292 B [0026] • CN 101307042 [0034] • US 6274743 B [0026] • US 7598404 B [0035] [0039] • US 6350924 B [0026] • CN 101747149 [0036]

17