Farmers' Guide to MN Lending

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Farmers' Guide to MN Lending Farmers’ Guide to Minnesota Lending Law Third Edition, March 2019 Farmers’ Legal Action Group, Inc. Farmers’ Guide to Minnesota Lending Law Third Edition, March 2019 Written by Stephen Carpenter Edited by Lindsay Kuehn This publication was made possible with the generous support of: Legal Services Advisory Committee Otto Bremer Trust Farm Aid Individual contributions from FLAG supporters To support FLAG’s work and publications like this one, please click here to make a tax-deductible donation. PUBLISHED BY Farmers’ Legal Action Group, Inc. 6 West Fifth Street, Suite 650 St. Paul, Minnesota 55102-1404 www.flaginc.org [email protected] Text © Copyright 1996, 2003, 2019 Farmers’ Legal Action Group, Inc. This Guide may be reprinted for educational purposes as long as Farmers’ Legal Action Group, Inc., is credited when reprinting. Cover photo © Debby Juarez. Acknowledgements Stephen Carpenter wrote the first edition of this Guide, published in 1996. David Moeller updated and revised the Guide for its second edition in 2003. Stephen Carpenter again wrote this third edition. Lindsay Kuehn provided significant research and edited the entire Guide. Lynn Hayes provided helpful thoughts and insights. Excellent research and editing assistance came from Ellie Bastian, Taylor Gess, Jessica Irwin, Sloan Kessler, and Karen Krub. Wendy Reid managed the production of the Guide. Her work included the copyediting, layout, and oversight of the publication process. The team of people here, along with the funders listed on the title page, have contributed to a product that is intended to help thousands of Minnesota farmers understand their legal rights and, hopefully, despite challenging economic times, help keep their families on the land and preserve their farms. Scott W. Carlson Executive Director Farmers’ Legal Action Group March 2019 Dedicated to the memory of Lou Anne Kling. A member of FLAG’s first Board of Directors, Lou Anne was a strong farm activist, and a tireless advocate for Minnesota farm families. TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Chapter One - Introduction ..................................................................................................... 1 I. Credit and farming ................................................................................................................ 1 II. Keeping a written record of credit arrangements .................................................................. 1 A. Keep copies of documents ................................................................................................ 2 B. Put important contacts with creditors in writing ........................................................... 2 C. Verify what is sent and received ....................................................................................... 2 D. Document telephone calls and conversations in writing ................................................. 2 E. Keep E-mails .................................................................................................................... 2 III. Getting help — attorneys and advocates ............................................................................. 3 A. Minnesota Farm Advocates .............................................................................................. 3 B. Attorneys .......................................................................................................................... 3 1. Looking for an attorney ....................................................................................................... 3 a. Experience in helping farmers .................................................................................. 4 b. Willing to sometimes say they don’t know ............................................................... 4 c. Trustworthiness ........................................................................................................ 4 d. Reliability .................................................................................................................. 4 2. Be clear about the work to be done and the cost .................................................................. 4 C. Legal referrals .................................................................................................................. 4 IV. What this Guide covers ......................................................................................................... 4 A. Some agreements must be in writing .............................................................................. 5 B. Real estate debt ................................................................................................................ 5 C. Secured credit ................................................................................................................... 5 D. Unsecured credit ............................................................................................................... 5 E. Leases ............................................................................................................................... 6 F. Mediation ......................................................................................................................... 6 G. Bankruptcy ....................................................................................................................... 6 H. Taxes................................................................................................................................. 6 I. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) ............................................................................ 6 J. Usury ................................................................................................................................ 6 K. Scam artists targeting farmers ......................................................................................... 6 L. Glossary ............................................................................................................................ 6 V. Current through November 30, 2018................................................................................... 6 Farmers’ Guide to Minnesota Lending Law Table of Contents Farmers’ Legal Action Group, Inc. i Chapter Two - The Statute of Frauds ....................................................................................7 I. Introduction ..........................................................................................................................7 II. What agreements must be in writing ....................................................................................7 A. Agreements that cannot be completed within one year must be in writing .....................7 B. Agreements to transfer land must be in writing .............................................................. 8 C. Lease of land for more than one year must be in writing ................................................ 8 D. Lease of goods with total payments of $1,000 or more must be in writing..................... 8 E. Agreements to lend money must be in writing ................................................................ 8 F. Sale of goods for $500 or more must be in writing ......................................................... 9 G. Most security agreements must be in writing .................................................................. 9 H. Others ............................................................................................................................... 9 III. If the agreement is not in writing ....................................................................................... 9 Chapter Three - Mortgages and Contracts for Deed ....................................................... 11 I. Mortgages and contracts for deed — a basic introduction .................................................. 11 A. Mortgages ........................................................................................................................ 11 1. There are typically two documents in a mortgage transaction .................................. 12 a. Promissory note ....................................................................................................... 12 b. Mortgage .................................................................................................................. 12 2. Satisfaction of mortgage ............................................................................................. 12 B. Contracts for deed ........................................................................................................... 13 C. Differences between mortgages and contracts for deed ................................................. 14 1. Buyers can lose money already paid if a contract for deed is canceled ...................... 14 2. Contracts for deed can allow sellers to act more quickly after default ...................... 14 3. Income tax differences ............................................................................................... 15 4. Mortgages can give sellers finality ............................................................................. 15 5. A contract for deed may be cheaper for the buyer ..................................................... 15 II. Mortgages and contracts for deed — basic terms................................................................ 15 A. Real Property, personal property, and fixtures ............................................................... 15 1. Real property vs. personal property ..........................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Quarterly Report June 30, 2017
    Quarterly Report June 30, 2017 MANAGEMENT'S DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS The following commentary reviews the consolidated financial condition and consolidated results of operations of AgStar Financial Services, ACA and its subsidiaries AgStar Financial Services, FLCA and AgStar Financial Services, PCA. This discussion should be read in conjunction with both the unaudited consolidated financial information and related notes included in this Quarterly Report as well as Management’s Discussion and Analysis included in our Annual Report for the year ended December 31, 2016 (2016 Annual Report). Due to the nature of our financial relationship with AgriBank, FCB (AgriBank), the financial condition and results of operations of AgriBank materially impact our stockholders' investment. To request free copies of the AgriBank or the AgriBank District financial reports or additional copies of our report, contact us at: Compeer Financial, ACA AgriBank, FCB 2600 Jenny Wren Trail 30 East 7th Street, Suite 1600 Sun Prairie, WI 53590 St. Paul, MN 55101 (844) 426-6733 (651) 282-8800 www.compeer.com www.agribank.com [email protected] MERGER ACTIVITY We are committed to the success of agriculture, rural communities and most importantly, our client-owners. Every day, we partner with our clients to deliver the insights and expert guidance they have come to expect and count on from their financial services provider. To be that trusted advisor, we are consistently looking for ways to better serve our clients and return value to our stockholders. It’s a business objective we’ve been committed to for the long haul and one we believe matches the strides of our clients – constantly evolving and growing to better our operation.
    [Show full text]
  • Consolidation in the Farm Credit System: the Case of Agcountry and United Erik D Hanson North Dakota State University
    Case Study Consolidation in the Farm Credit System: The Case of AgCountry and United Erik D Hanson North Dakota State University JEL Codes: Q13, Q14 Keywords: Agricultural finance, agricultural lending, consolidation, Farm Credit System, merger Abstract Agricultural lenders provide an important service in America’s agricultural economy. In recent years, consolidation has occurred in many aspects of agriculture, including agricultural lending. This educational case study examines consolidation in the Farm Credit System (FCS), which is a system of cooperatively owned agricultural lending associations. The merger between AgCountry Farm Credit Services and United FCS illustrates some drivers of consolidation in the Farm Credit System and provides opportunities to consider the advantages and disadvantages of a merger. The perspectives of the associations’ leaders, member-owners, and employees are explored, allowing students to offer tactical and strategic advice to these stakeholders. This case study is intended for undergraduate students taking courses in agricultural finance, agricultural lending, or cooperatives. 1 Introduction In fall 2016, farmers across the upper Midwest were busy harvesting their crops and preparing for the next growing season. At the same time, leaders at AgCountry Farm Credit Services and United FCS were also reflecting on past efforts and planning for the future. Bob Bahl, the chief executive officer (CEO) of AgCountry, and Marc Knisely, the CEO of United, had identified and evaluated strategic opportunities throughout their careers in the Farm Credit System (FCS). Now they were considering another key question: whether AgCountry and United should become a single association. If a merger were to occur, the new association would conduct business with approximately 18,000 borrowers in 65 counties in eastern North Dakota, western Minnesota, and north central Wisconsin (Vinje 2017).
    [Show full text]
  • 2019 Annual Report
    POSITIONED FOR PROGRESS 2019 Annual Report CONTENTS About Us 4 Leadership 6 Year in Review 9 Patronage 10 Voice of the Clients 12 Legislative Affairs 14 Contact Center 16 Leadership Message 18 Financial Report 19 2 POSITIONED FOR PROGRESS When times are volatile, it’s natural to put more energy toward what we know – trying to do things better just to maintain the status quo. Making progress or growing when times are tough could be considered unrealistic. Yet, progress is possible even when volatility abounds. Making progress takes thoughtful planning, calculated risks and a commitment to growth. It also requires a willingness to adapt and innovate. When we’re open to change and ready to act on it, we’re positioned for opportunity that can move us forward. Compeer Financial is focused on positioning our cooperative for progress, and we’re proud to partner with our member-owners so they can do the same for their operations. We’re optimistic about the future and committed to being ready for whatever it holds. When positioned for it, progress is always possible. 3 MAKING PROGRESS WITH INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS Products and Services Compeer Financial is dedicated to helping farmers and rural America by offering a diverse product and service portfolio, including: • Agriculture Financing • Leasing • Rural Financing • Agribusiness Financing • Appraisals • Tax & Accounting • Crop Insurance • Title • Home Loans LifeWorks Resource Program Compeer launched the LifeWorks Resource Program in 2019. This program confidentially connects clients and their families with tools and resources to help navigate challenges related to work, family, life and health. We know farming and life in rural America aren’t always easy, and factors out of one’s control can be frustrating and stressful.
    [Show full text]
  • COMMUNITYCONNECTED 2013 Agribank Giving Report ROOTED in OUR COMMUNITIES Agribank Is on a Mission to Serve Rural America
    COMMUNITYCONNECTED 2013 AgriBank Giving Report ROOTED IN OUR COMMUNITIES AgriBank is on a mission to serve rural America. As Inside part of the Farm Credit System, a borrower-owned 4……………………………….…..To Our Stakeholders financial cooperative, supporting American agriculture 6………………………………..…….New Sponsorships is at the core of our business operations and extends to everything we do. Community involvement is an 10……………………..…..Focus: Urban Agriculture important way for us to further this mission. In 12…………………...Rural Community Grant Fund partnership with 17 affiliated Farm Credit 14.…....Minneapolis-St. Paul Charitable Giving Associations, we support all agriculture – traditional and non-traditional – in the hopes of creating a 16………………………………………...About AgriBank balanced approach for America's ag future. On the Cover NEARLY AgriBank sponsors Windy City Harvest, an $500,000 urban agriculture training program in Chicago. See page 10. in new sponsorships in 2013 Education Community Agriculture Support $2.1 MILLION Advocates Young, in total giving in 2013, Beginning, including: Disaster Relief Small Farmers $1.2 million to sponsor traditional and non-traditional agricultural programs $700,000 to support projects in western North Dakota communities affected by oil and mineral exploration and production Land/Water Conservation $150,000 to support Minneapolis-St. Paul charities Food Security and Local Foods $27,000 to match employee Urban Agriculture contributions 2 COMMUNITYCONNECTED 15 $1.1 MILLION awarded since 2012 through the Rural Community Grant Fund, a partnership with Farm Credit Services of Mandan and Farm Credit Services of North Dakota, to support projects in western North Dakota communities affected by oil and mineral exploration and production AgriBank joined United FCS in sponsoring this tractor for a student garden.
    [Show full text]
  • Supporting Farm Credit Associations That Serve Rural Communities and Agriculture
    MISSION POSSIBLE Supporting Farm Credit Associations that serve rural communities and agriculture. AGRIBANK DISTRICT 2016 ANNUAL REPORT AGRIBANK, FCB AND DISTRICT ASSOCIATIONS FARM CREDIT BANK1 TABLE OF CONTENTS AgriBank, FCB and District Associations Combined Five-Year Summary of Selected Financial Data ............................................................. 1 Management's Discussion and Analysis .......................................................................................... 2 Report of Managment .................................................................................................................. 40 Report of Independent Auditors ................................................................................................... 41 Combined Financial Statements ................................................................................................... 42 Notes to Combined Financial Statements ..................................................................................... 46 Additional Regulatory Information ............................................................................................. 112 Young, Beginning and Small Farmers and Ranchers ................................................................... 112 Risk Factors ................................................................................................................................. 114 Combined Five-Year Summary of Selected Financial Data AgriBank, FCB and District Associations (Dollars in thousands) 2016 2015 2014
    [Show full text]
  • Farm Credit Services of America's Deal to Leave the Farm Credit System
    Order Code RS21919 Updated September 24, 2004 CRS Report for Congress Received through the CRS Web Farm Credit Services of America’s Deal to Leave the Farm Credit System Jim Monke Analyst in Agricultural Policy Resources, Science, and Industry Division Summary In an unprecedented move, an institution of the Farm Credit System (FCS or System) — a government-sponsored enterprise (GSE) — has initiated procedures to terminate its status in the System and be purchased by a private company. On July 30, 2004, the board of directors of Farm Credit Services of America (FCSA) accepted an offer to be purchased by Rabobank for $600 million in borrower-owned stock, and a projected $800 million “exit fee” payable to the Farm Credit System Insurance Corporation. FCSA is the System lending association that serves farmers in Iowa, Nebraska, South Dakota, and Wyoming. Rabobank is a private banking company from the Netherlands with extensive lending experience in agriculture. The option to leave the System is allowed by statute under the Farm Credit Act of 1971, as amended, but has been exercised only once, and did not involve an outside purchaser. The acquisition needs to be approved by the Farm Credit Administration, the federal regulator of the Farm Credit System, and by the farmer-borrower shareholders in the four-state region. If approved, the loans, facilities, and employees of FCSA would become part of Rabobank. New charters would need to be issued to allow new or existing FCS associations to begin lending in the four-state region. The approval process could be completed as early as the spring of 2005.
    [Show full text]
  • AGSTAR FINANCIAL SERVICES, ACA Agstar.Com
    AGSTAR FINANCIAL SERVICES, ACA agstar.com April 29, 2011 Ms. Jennifer J. Johnson Secretary, Board of Governors Federal Reserve System 20th Street and Constitution Avenue Washington, D C 2 0 5 5 1 Re: Proposed regulations related to escrows (Docket Number R - 1 4 0 6 and R I N Number 7 1 0 0 - A D 6 5) Dear Ms. Johnson: AgStar Financial Services, ACA ("AgStar") appreciates the opportunity to comment on the Federal Reserve's proposed amendments to Regulation Z related to mandatory escrows for high- priced mortgage loans and related to additional disclosures regarding escrows that was published in the March 2, 2011 Federal Register. AgStar, one of the nation's largest Farm Credit associations, is a member-owned cooperative and a part of the Farm Credit System. One of AgStar's primary missions, and indeed the primary mission of the entire Farm Credit System is to support agriculture and rural America. One of the ways associations like AgStar fulfill this mission is by offering home mortgage loans to farmers and residents of rural communities. AgStar is concerned that the proposed regulations fail to adequately consider the unique nature of home mortgage lending to farmers and other rural residents. AgStar recognizes that amendments to the Truth in Lending Act were included in the Dodd Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act ("Dodd Frank Act") passed by Congress in 2010, and appreciates the need for the Federal Reserve to promulgate regulations to implement those amendments. That said, it appears that the proposed regulations provide for a narrower exemption than required by the Dodd Frank Act.
    [Show full text]
  • Compeer Financial Farmer Cooperative Conference Mark Cade
    COMPEER FINANCIAL FARMER COOPERATIVE CONFERENCE MARK CADE November 1-3 FARM CREDIT SYSTEM • Part of the cooperative Farm Credit System . Approximately 75 associations nationwide • Farm Credit is the largest lender to U.S. agriculture . Provides more than 1/3 of the credit needed . Assets in excess of $217 billion . Nearly 500,000 member-borrowers . More than 13,000 employees 2 A RESULT OF SUCCESSFUL MERGERS • In the late 1990s PCAs & FLBAs began to combine • 1995: East Central Wisconsin Farm Credit, based in Fond du Lac, combined with Madison Farm Credit Association to form the original Badgerland Farm Credit Services. • 1998: Heartland Farm Credit, based in Baraboo, joined Badgerland Farm Credit Services to create the cooperative’s territory across 33 southern Wisconsin counties. • 2008: Badgerland Farm Credit Services rebranded to Badgerland Financial • 2017: Badgerland Financial merged with AgStar Financial Services and 1st Farm Credit Services to become Compeer Financial 3 MERGER OF THREE ORGANIZATIONS • On July 1, 1st Farm Credit Services, AgStar Financial Services and Badgerland Financial joined together as Compeer Financial, strengthening our commitment to the agricultural community. 4 ABOUT COMPEER FINANCIAL • Compeer Financial is a member-owned Farm Credit cooperative supporting agriculture and rural communities. The $19+ billion organization provides loans, leases, risk management and other financial services throughout 144 counties in Illinois, Minnesota and Wisconsin. • Based in the Upper Midwest, Compeer Financial exists to
    [Show full text]
  • Agstar-2012-Annual-Report.Pdf
    BY YOUR S IDE Life in rural America is extraordinary. There’s no place we’d rather be. We help one another, because the life we’ve chosen isn’t always easy. We work together. We walk together. We stand together. At AgStar, we’re your friends, neighbors and partners. Our place is right here. By your side. OUR MISSION STATEMENT Enhancing Life in Agriculture and Rural America AgStar Financial Services is a cooperative owned For more than 95 years, we’ve been here, by by client-stockholders. As part of the Farm Credit your side, providing opportunities and improving System, we serve 69 counties in Minnesota and lives. By offering high quality financial products northwest Wisconsin. and services, along with financial and business education programs, we strengthen the economy of the region we serve. SUCCEEDING WITH YOU When AgStar succeeds, you succeed. As a financial services cooperative, AgStar distributes patronage dividends to our 15,300 stockholders. We base allocations on company earnings and the amount of products or services stockholders purchase from AgStar during the year. 2012 was a landmark year for AgStar and our clients. We retired the remaining patronage allocations for 2002 and 2003, totaling over $40 million to eligible stockholders. Since the inception of the program in 1998, AgStar has allocated $392 million in patronage dividends and retired more than $80 million to qualified stockholders. We’re helping you succeed by returning wealth to our region and communities. GROWING WITH YOU At AgStar, we understand you are looking for insights and information to help give you an edge.
    [Show full text]
  • Generations of Success
    Generations of Success ANNUAL REPORT 2015 You are the heart of agriculture; part of the generations of hardworking men and women committed to feeding the world and building a better future. You are the grandparents, parents, sons and daughters; the client-stockholders, businesses and communities we Generations of Success serve. You are the families that provide for all families. At AgStar Financial Services, our business is rooted in the tradition of helping you achieve success. For decades we have committed our financial services to the stability, security and growth of families in rural America. Now and forever, you can count on AgStar for generations of success. 2 Generations of Farm Credit 100 YEARS OF SERVING RURAL AMERICA Freedom, diversity, ingenuity, work ethic and entrepreneurship have made America a country of constant change and innovation. Nowhere is that more evident than on farms and rural communities. ROGER AND BEVERLY PETERSON Working with Farm Credit from Day One American farmers today produce yields that would have seemed For Roger and Bev Peterson, The Farm Credit impossible just a generation ago. Farmers have developed System has been a trusted business partner since new techniques and technologies to advance both productivity their first day in operation. Roger’s first loan was and sustainability. Thanks to generations of advances and with their local Production Credit Association, a innovations, today rural America provides the most abundant, predecessor of what AgStar is today. Later they safe and affordable food supply on earth. together obtained loans with Federal Land Bank Association and Farm Credit Services, and today they are with AgStar.
    [Show full text]
  • Farm Credit Services of America Ends Attempt to Leave the Farm Credit System
    Order Code RS21919 Updated October 22, 2004 CRS Report for Congress Received through the CRS Web Farm Credit Services of America Ends Attempt to Leave the Farm Credit System Jim Monke Analyst in Agricultural Policy Resources, Science, and Industry Division Summary In an unprecedented move, an institution of the Farm Credit System (FCS) — a government-sponsored enterprise — initiated procedures on July 30, 2004, to leave the FCS and be purchased by a private company. But after much controversy, including congressional hearings, the board of directors of Farm Credit Services of America (FCSA) voted on October 19, 2004, to terminate its agreement with Rabobank before seeking approval from the Farm Credit Administration, the System’s federal regulator. FCSA is the FCS lending association serving Iowa, Nebraska, South Dakota, and Wyoming. Rabobank is a private Dutch banking company with extensive experience in agriculture and a growing global network. Under the plan, the loans, facilities, and employees of FCSA would have become part of Rabobank, and new FCS charters would have been issued to reestablish a System presence in the four-state region. The option to leave the System is allowed by statute under the Farm Credit Act of 1971, as amended, but has been exercised only once, and did not involve an outside purchaser. Although Congress had no direct statutory role in the approval process, the House held hearings on the implications of the deal, and Senators Daschle and Johnson introduced S. 2851 to require public hearings and a longer approval process. This report will not be updated. Background on the Farm Credit System The Farm Credit System (FCS or System) is a national network of cooperatively owned lending institutions that provide credit and other services to farmers and ranchers.
    [Show full text]
  • Leaving the Farm Credit System: the Future of Farm Credit Services of America
    Order Code RS21919 August 23, 2004 CRS Report for Congress Received through the CRS Web Leaving the Farm Credit System: The Future of Farm Credit Services of America Jim Monke Analyst in Agricultural Policy Resources, Science, and Industry Division Summary In an unprecedented move, an institution of the Farm Credit System (FCS or System) — a government-sponsored enterprise (GSE) — has initiated procedures to terminate its status in the System and be purchased by a private company. On July 30, 2004, the board of directors of Farm Credit Services of America (FCSA) accepted an offer to be purchased by Rabobank for $600 million in borrower-owned stock, and a projected $800 million “exit fee” payable to the Farm Credit System Insurance Corporation. FCSA is the System lending association that serves farmers in Iowa, Nebraska, South Dakota, and Wyoming. Rabobank is a private banking company from the Netherlands with extensive lending experience in agriculture. The option to leave the System is allowed by statute under the Farm Credit Act of 1971, as amended, but has been exercised only once, and did not involve an outside purchaser. The acquisition needs to be approved by the Farm Credit Administration, the federal regulator of the Farm Credit System, and by the farmer-borrower shareholders in the four-state region. If approved, the loans, facilities, and employees of FCSA would become part of Rabobank. New charters would need to be issued to allow new or existing FCS associations to begin lending in the four-state region. The approval process is expected to proceed through the fall of 2004 and possibly be completed in the spring of 2005.
    [Show full text]