oecuVCut
JANUARY 1952
GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL. WASHINGTON. I). ('.
VOL. 4, No. 2
KRONSTEIN HONORED BY UNIV. OF FRANKFURT
STUDENTS ELECTED TO HOUSE OF DELEGATES SBA Organization Now Completed
Georgetown Reaches Final Round In National Moot Court Competion
Doctor Heinrich Kronstein has been honored with the distinction of an
Honorarprofessor appointment to the
Faculty of Law of the University of Frankfurt. The fields included under his appointment are Trade Regulation and Comparative Law. By virtue of his position as an honorary professor, he may teach these subjects, if he so chooses, at the famous German university. He also enjoys all the rights of a full professor of the university, such as participation in faculty meetings and decisions.
Doctor Curt Staff, President of the
Court of Appeals (Criminal Division) for Hesse, received a similar appointment at the same time as Doctor Kronstein.
As a result of Doctor Kronstein’s appointment, all the doctorate theses on Comparative Law submitted to the University of Frankfurt will be sent to him for examination and criticism. The appointment also makes it possible for students at Georgetown University School pf Law to have ready access, with the assistance of Doctor Kronstein, to German resources for the study of Comparative Law.
Swinging into action shortly after the election of class representatives and the nomination of delegates from the law clubs, the House of Delegates of the Student Bar Association convened and set into motion several committees which will function throughout the year to provide activities of an intellectual, social, and recreational nature for students here at Georgetown Law School.
As provided for by the SBA Constitution, ratified early in the school vear by the student bodv, the House of Delegates is the legislative body of the organization and is composed of the Board of Governors, that is, the officers of the SBA and the Governorat-Large; the class delegates; delegates from the law clubs; the chairman of each standing committee and section of the SBA ; and the delegatesat-large.
D. C. Cup Retained By School As Result of District Victory
bj/ Richard J . Zanurd %A. \ . 52
On Friday night, December 14, Georgetown's Moot Court team entered the final round of the Second Annual National Competition. The adversaries represented the University of Arizona. 1he bench consisted oi the following: Mr. Justice Harold H. Burton, Supreme Court of the United States; Judge John J. Parker, U. S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit; Judge Herbert F. Goodrich, U. S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit; Judge Edmund H. Lewis, New York Court of Appeals; and Hon. Whitney N. Seymour, President of the Bar of the City of New York. Georgetown’s advocates, Rev. Joseph M. Snee, S.J., I). C. ’52, and George J. Meiburger, Mo. ’52, presented the argument for the petitioner. The court rendered a divided decision in favor of the resnondent. the University of Arizona.
Ti mely Problem
Elected by the students to be class representatives are the following: Peter Franco, N. Y. ’54, and Walter
Organized by the Junior Bar Committee of the New Aork City Bar Association, the annual National Moot Court Competition is rapidly moving toward the center stage of law school activities. The finalists are chosen as a result of nation-wide eliminations from more than sixty schools. The interest in the Competition was greatly enhanced this year by the timeliness of the problem presented. The facts of the case, in brief, are as follows: John Doe, State’s Attorney from Movieland County was duly subpoenaed to testify and produce papers before the Senate Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce which was authorized to conduct an investigation into the existence and extent of criminal, immoral, subversive and corrupting elements and influences upon the motion picture industry.
{Continued on page 3)
FR. LUCEY GIVEN HONORARY DEGREE BY THE UNIVERSITY OF FRANKFURT
The Reverend Francis E. Lucey, S.J., became on November 20, 1951, the first Jesuit in modern times to receive an honorary degree from a German university. The Faculty of Law of the University of Frankfurt conferred the degree, honoris causa, of Doctor of Civil and Canon Law upon Father Lucey for his oustanding work in legal philosophy, particularly in the field of natural law.
The degree particularly praised Father Lucey for the excellence of his knowledge and research in social philosophy, for his fusion of the truths of classical philosophy with the principles of our own time, for his brilliant contributions to modern jurisprudence, for his unceasing mindfulness of the
-----------
While on the witness stand before
the committee, Doe was subjected to Kleig lights, microphones, constant snapping of flashbulbs by press photographers, and an overcrowded committee room. He refused to testify on the ground that such subjection was a violation of his Constitutional rights, erffo he could not he convicted under the contempt statute.
He was indicted and sentenced to five years imprisonment hy a District Court under R.S. 102. The Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed without opinion. Retit ion for certiorari was granted and the case was argued before the Moot Court in the same manner as if it had been before the Supreme Court of the United States.
USED BOOK EXCHANGE TO BE OPENED BY SBA
The S.B.A. has undertaken to satisfy a long-desired need of the student body by setting up a Student Book Exchange. The Exchange is designed to enable the student to remain pocket-book happy while* purchasing used case books and text books. The creation of such a facility also obviates the time-consuming practice of searching the bulletin boards.
The plan tentatively adopted is this: any student wishing to sell his books will deposit them in the office of the Book Exchange and stipulate the price desired for the same. After the hooks have been stamped with the seller’s price, they will be ottered for sale hy the Exchange Office, and upon sale' of the same the money will be promptly turned over to the owner of such books.
(Continued on page 4)
Finals and I). C . ( u p
In the opening round of the finals,
Georgetown bested the advocates from the* University of Miami (Fla.). The next victory was at the expense of the* team from Cornell University. In the semi-finals, Georgetown’s representatives won out over the University of North Carolina. All three decisions were rendered in Georgetown’s favor by a unanimous bench.
Prior to their appearance in New
York, our team had succeeded in retaining the 1). C. Cup —symbol of the winner in the D. C. Circuit of the N ational Moot Court Competition. Columbus Law School and Catholic University School of Law provided the actual opposition in the District. George Washington University Law School, Howard University Law School, National Law School, and Washington College of Law (Ameri-
Under such a plan each student will have a “bargain-basement” opportunity to browse, examine, and select the book or books which suit his purse and taste.
The Exchange Office has set a fee of ten cents for each book sold through its office. This fee will be used to defray operating costs, and any profit from this organization will be used to purchase subscriptions to magazines and newspapers which will be placed in the social room of the school. If, after this, any profits still remain, they will be deposited in the S.B.A. fund. Samuel R. DeSimone, Mass. ’53, will supervise the Exchange.
Pictured with Fr. Lucey are the two other recipients of honorary degrees at the November 20, 1951, ceremony at the University of Frankfurt in Germany. Immediately right of FT. Lucey is Dr. Lorenzo Mossa, Professor of Law at the University of Pisa, Italy; and on the right, Dr. Hermann Meinert, Chief Archivist for the City of Frankfurt.
(Continued on page 3)
January 1952
I’age 2
r f :s i p s a l o q u i t u r
With the curtain down on the 1951
Competition, Georgetown can look forward with pride and confidence to 1952. It owes and gives sincere thanks to its team. During the last two years, Georgetown is the only school to get past the quarter finals twice. Furthermore, prior to the final round in New York, our teams had been successful on various levels of the competition for twelve consecutive times. Our record is the finest. It represents the able work of our students and of Professor Paul R. Dean '46, faculty moderator to these successful teams during the last two years.
MOOT COURT
(Continued from page 1)
uRES IPSA LOQUITUR”
GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL
WASHINGTON 1, D. C. can University) were eliminated in earlier competitions and did not meet Georgetown Law School in actual competition. A Georgetown victory next year will retire the D. C. Cup, while the Samuel Seabury Cup—emblematic of the national victory—can be similarly retired, because of Georgetown’s victory last year.
Editor
Ric h a r d P. Br o u il l a r d , .V. II., ’53
A ssocia tc Editor
Ri c h a r d J. Za n a r d , .V. Y., ’52
Associ a ta Editor
Do n a l d M. Wa l s h , .V.
Participants
’52
Born in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania,
Rev. Joseph M. Snee, S.J., received his A.B. from Gonzaga University in Spokane in 1941. In 1942 the Gregorian University in Rome bestowed the degree of Ph.L. upon him. Since that time he has added an M.A. from Catholic University, 1946, and the degree of S.T.L.—granted by Woodstock College in 1949. Father Snee was chosen the second best advocate in the final rounds, and was awarded several
EDITORIAL BOARD
Wa l t e r E. We bs t e r , Jr ., Wash. ’53
Do n a l d C. Ma c h a d o , Hawaii ’53
Re v . Jo s e ph M. Sn e e , S.J., D. ’52
Ne l s o n De c k e l ba u m , I). C. ’53
Ja m e s He n r io t , Wash. ’54
\e w 8 Editor
- Anniston!
- XeEditor
DELTA THETAS INITIATE NEW FRAT BROTHERS
Copy Editor AIooi m Editor Secretary Adccrtising Manager Circa Ia t i on Mo v age r
The White Senate of Delta Theta
Phi welcomed the Christmas season with an informal dance held on December 7 at the Hotel 2400. Thomas A. Sweeney, Mo. '52, Chairman of the Social Committee, was in charge of the dance and was assisted by Richard
Henkel, Ohio ’52.
The event had the advantage of a double celebration because it was the fraternity’s first opportunity to introduce its thirty-five new initiates to its friends and alumni.
Eu g e n e J. Hy n e s , .Jr .,
Y . ’53
Jo h n F. Kin g , Pa. ’52
STAFF
. a l F5’4; James R. Bates, ml. ’54; Thomas R. Behan,
E. Ramon Arango, volumes of books dealing with various
subjects in the field of law. While at the Law School, he has been an active member of Phi Delta Phi F raternity, a member of the Pierce Butler Law Club, and a candidate for the Law Journal.
.V. Y. ’52; Armand CinR'olani, Pa. 54; Walter C. Ford, Conn. ’54; W. Paul Flynn,
. n o C5’4; Andrew S. O. Lee, T. II. ’52; Carmen Iodice, X .
’54;
Ar t ios Neill. D. C. ’54; John J. O’Dowd, Pa. ’53; Louis J. Perez, R. I. ’53;
- John B. Walsh, .V.
- . Y5’3; James B. Vander Kelen, Mich. ’53; Charles
M. Whelan, I). C. ’54
FACULTY ADVISOR
George J. Meiburger, a native of St.
Louis, Missouri, was Georgetown’s second advocate. An afternoon student at the Law School, he is employed in the law office of Attorney Charles S. Rhyne here in Washington.
Jo s e ph F. Ga g h a n
Initiated into membership, a week prior to the dance, were: Louis Brence, Pa. ’53; Richard Brouillard, A\ II. ’53; Joseph Czerniakowski, Ohio ’53; John Egan, A\ Y. ’52; Benjamin Gilleas,
I). C. ’52; James Gillespie, Ohio ’53;
Call Hall, Okla. ’53; Harry Haddock, Colo. ’52 ; Norbert Halloran, I). C. ’55; William Harrison, A\ M. ’53; David Hodge, Pa. ’54; James W. Kelley, Mass. ’53; Leo Lesieur, A7. II. ’52; Joseph Loonan, Wash. ’52; Donald Machado, T. H . ’53; Edward Manley, Pa. ’53; John Maxwell, A\ ./. ’5o; George Mayrash, Pa. ’53; Matthew Naughton, Md. ’53; Frank Paz, Pa. ’53; Louis Perez, R. /. ’53; William Pfalzgraf, IB. Va. ’53; John Pickett, Conn. ’53; Joseph Pickle, Pa. ’52; John Rafter, Mo. '52; Peter Roots, Md. ’52; Martin Salas, A\ M. '53; Russell Shamansky, Pa. ’52; Charles Stuart, I). C. ’54; Edward Sullivan, Mass. '53; Natale Urso, R. I. ’53; Richard Whittenburger, Va. ’53; and Alexis Zer-
vanos, Pa. ’53.
St. Louis University conferred an A.B.
•
OUR TEAM TO THE MOOT COURT
degree on Mr. Meiburger in 1945. His Law School activities have been centered about law club arguments, Student Bar activities, and Phi Alpha Delta Fraternity.
The success of Georgetown Law School’s team in gaining second honors at the Second National Moot Court Competition affords a splendid opportunity to the Ren: Ipsa tending a “well done” to students of the Law School again. Such a remarkable record in this field—first honors last year and second this year—is indeed a reason why we should be proud of this achievement. The time and effort which has gone into the preparation for this competition has yielded and will continue to yield valuable experience to members of the team—experience of which few law students can boast.
The speakers from schools throughout the country that have met the representatives from Georgetown Law School in these last two competitions have become convinced of our high regard for oral argument. They can be sure that through the continued work of our law clubs, we shall be able to send to the National Moot Court Competitions the same type of accomplished participants which we have s e n t and f or which the national event has become known. for ex-
The first alternate on Georgetown’s team was Charles J. Pilzer, D. C. ’52. Mr. Pilzer is a native of the District and obtained his B.S. degree from George Washington University in 1949. An active member of Pierce Butler Law Club, he is also a member of Phi Delta Phi Fraternity, and Administrative Law Editor of the Law Journal.
Louis Scolnik, Me. ’52, filled the position of second alternate. Born in Lewiston, Maine, Mr. Scolnik received his A.B. from Bates College in 1947. Also a member of Pierce Butler Law Club, he has been active in oral arguments at the Law School during the past two years.
James Anton, A\ H. ’52 succeeded
Charles F. Crimi, A\ Y. '52, who resigned as Dean late in November.
THE GENTLEMEN FROM ARIZONA
To the two advocates who represented the University of
Arizona College of Law and their school, go our sincere congratulations.
HOLTZOFF SPEAKS AT BUTLER CLUB LUNCHEON
WELCH ADDRESSES PAD AT INITIATION EVENT
Judge Alexander Holtzoff of the
United States District Court for the District of Columbia was guest speaker at the annual luncheon of the Bierce Butler Law Club, held at 11ammel’s Restaurant on December 11th. The luncheon was arranged under the chairmanship of John Dohony, Md. ’54. lie was assisted by Jordan Tanenbaum, K. /. ’54. Chancellor Richard Gordon, D. C. '53, introduced the speaker whose topic was education and the law. Stressing the cultural riches of literature as one of the most vital contributions to a great lawyer. Judge Holtzoff indicated that the extent to which modern college curriculae have shifted from the classics to the exact sciences has resulted in a younger generation which is almost inarticulate. To the credit of the Jesuit Order, he added, it should be said that their universities are the last bulwark of this type of learning.
(icorgetown’s Taft Chapter and
George Washington's Jay Chapter of the Phi Alpha Delta Law Fraternity joined forces for their initiation ceremonies and banquet on December 8, 1951. The joint initiation was decided upon in furtherance of one of the purposes of the fraternity: to form a strong link between the students of the two schools. The two chapters also held a joint pledging ceremony last year.
The principal speaker at the initiation was J. Harry Welch, ’21, prominent member of the D. C. Bar and former Justice of the Taft Chapter. Mr. Welch spoke convincingly on trial techniques, problems in interviewing and examining witnesses, and general problems confronting a young lawyer. The initiation ceremonies were conducted by William Zhiel and Louis Fernandez, Fla. ’52, present Justices of Jay and Taft Chapters, respectively.
Three Alumni, pictured as they heard the public argument in Carroll
Auditorium at which Georgetown’s speakers to the National Moot Court were chosen, are from left to right, Andrew M. Hood ’24, Judge, Municipal Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia; E. Barrett Prettyman ’15, Judge United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, presiding; and Walter M. Bastian ’13, Judge, United States District Court for the District of Columbia.
Page 3
- January 1952
- RES IPSA LOQUITUR
Chairman of the Fourth Regional
KILEY DIRECTS SBA ATHLETIC PROGRAM
JUDGE McGUIRE SPEAKS AT GAMMA ETA MEETING
Loyalty Board, a quasi-judicial organization which carries out the President's Executive Order regarding the loyalty of federal employees. Doubtful cases are referred to this board which inspects the employee or the prospective employee's record and. if necessary, conducts a hearing to determine his eligibility for employment.
The Faculty—
The successful athletic program inaugurated last year bv the Student Bar Association is being continued this year, and plans for expanding its scope to include more activities and to bring more students together in active out-of-class companionship are being formulated.
The Georgetown and George Washington Chapters of Gamma Eta Gamma Fraternity held a joint initiation program on November 17th, 1951 at the Congressional Hotel. The District Alumni Chapter of the Fraternity also joined in the event.
Georgetown Law School students initiated into the legal brotherhood were: Joel Cohen, Jr., I). ( ’. '53; Eli W.
Fleming, I). C. '53; Ralf Hellmer, Va.
'54; Howard Levine, I). C. *53; Frank M. Miga, R. L '53; Walter R. Sceery, D. C. '53; and llarrv E. Stowers, Jr.,
N. M. ’53.
Speaking at the banquet which followed the initiation was Judge Matthew F. McGuire of the U. S. District Court for the District of Columbia, an alumni member of the Fraternity. Robert Ludwig, president of the Alumni Chapter, was toastmaster.
Judge McGuire spoke of the lowering of standards in Judaeo-Christian morality in public and private life. He observed that when we consider the news today, we see an almost complete lack of faith, hope and charity, and love of neighbor; and a manifest departure even from the rudiments of due process. He urged those present, as lawvers and future law vers, to revive these weakened ideals.