REPORT of the ARBITERS' COMMISSION (ARB) for the 3 Quarter FIDE PB 2019
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REPORT OF THE ARBITERS’ COMMISSION (ARB) For the 3rd quarter FIDE PB 2019 (Budapest, HUNGARY, September 7-8, 2019) The present report covers the commission’s activity in the period between June and August 2019. It was prepared in collaboration with Nebojsa Baralic, Secretary of the Commission. The main focus during the summer period was on ensuring daily activities and preparation of the commission’s councilors meeting planned in August in Minsk. 1. MEETINGS AND REPRESENTATION a) EUROPEAN YOUTH CHAMPIONSHIP IN BRATISLAVA Following the invitation by the FIDE Women commission’s (WOM) Chairman, Eva Repkova, to attend their meeting in Bratislava, the ARB Chairman, Laurent Freyd, attended the session dedicated to arbiters on August 5th 2019 in Bratislava. The ECU Arbiters Council (AC) was represented as well by their Chairman, Tomasz Delega. Discussions mainly covered the positioning of Women Arbiters and the support that both commissions can jointly bring to help developing the sector. A first action was launched to support women attending FIDE Arbiter Seminars around the world, under the leadership of the WOM. Followed an exchange of ideas with the ECU AC’s Chairman, which covered subjects such as the synergy between both commissions, especially in the area of arbiters evaluation and assignment in top level events. Another meeting was held with the Chairman of the FIDE Events Commission (EVE), Ozgur Solakoglu, with a main focus on appointment processes, quotas (25% women, local arbiters vs FIDE nominated arbiters, etc.) in a view of managed human resources for the overall arbiter sector. On August 6th, one of the few FIDE Arbiter Seminars animated by 2 women, lecturer Jirina Prokopova, and assistant lecturer Ilaha Kadimova, was launched in presence of our chairman. This trip was also an opportunity to discuss with the arbiters of the championship, following the invitation by the Chief Arbiter Ivan Syrovy, and share warm encouragements to them for their assignment in the championship which grouped more than 1300 players. b) ARBITERS COMMISSION MEETING IN MINSK The new FIDE Arbiters Commission held their first Councillors Meeting at the Belarus Hotel in Minsk, August 14th to 17th, during the World Cadet Rapid and Blitz Championship 2019. The ARB members present were Laurent Freyd (Chairman), Nebojsa Baralic (Secretary), Panagiotis Nikolopoulos (Honorary Chairman), Shohreh Bayat (Councillor), Irina Gevorgyan (Councillor), Jirina Prokopova (Member) and Natalija Popova (Member). While several members of the commission were on duty at the championship, the meeting was structured to foster ideation phases with the whole team, alternating with structuring phases in a smaller group. The team started by reviewing the activities covered in the first 7 months of the year, foundational actions on the way to a next level of maturity: arbiters and seminars database, upcoming KPI's, licensing and title application processes, assessment of FIDE arbiter exams, update of the FIDE Arbiter Manual ... They also discussed proposals and requests, with a key focus on the appointment of arbiters in FIDE events and arbiters curriculum and classification. 1 To emphasise the synergy with other commissions and the FIDE management, which is a key factor of success, the 3rd day's session was dedicated to exchanges with other commissions, with special guests and open to visitors. As an introduction, the chairman summarised the previous 2 days and shared his view about future developments for the commission to the audience. We had the honour to welcome a few distinguished guests: Anastasia Sorokina (FIDE Vice President) expressed her satisfaction in front of the dynamic shared and to see her family of arbiters working in the beautiful Minsk. Lukasz Turlej (FIDE Vice President) showed interest in the quality of the topics covered and shared encouragements to provide some visibility to the Presidential Board about the commission's achievements. Ozgur Solakoglu (EVE Chairman) congratulated for the great collaboration so far between both commissions. Geert Bailleul (ECU Arbiters Council Secretary) shared about evaluation of arbiters to be implemented in Europe. Marco Biagioli (FIDE GDPR) was consulted about data protection matters. Maciej Cybulski (SPP Chairman) and Aleksandra Dimitrijevic (OLC Secretary) also took part in the discussions. Other key commissions for ARB couldn't be represented this time, GSC, PDC, WOM, FPL and RC, however collaboration on a regular basis is effective with them. Priorities for the short term are: - Finalising the appointment and evaluation process for FIDE events - Reinforcing the training structure (including refreshment seminars) - Clarifying regulations - Connecting with federations and national arbiters councils Also attended the open session : IA Olexandr Prohorov (SPP Councilor), IA Rafal Faron, IA Artur Vashurin, IA Igor Vereshchagin The complete minutes of the meeting still need to be finalized as this report is being written. A presentation is planned during the PB in Budapest to cover key elements. 2. ADMINISTRATION a) DATABASE REVIEW, LICENSING & SEMINARS PROCESS Day-to-day activities like licensing of arbiters or seminar registration and reporting processes were covered and improved as needs for data were raised. The commission collaborated with the newly appointed GDPR team to identify needs and ensure that we are aligned with the law. Licensing process is quite demanding, with more than 830 requests for new National Arbiters since the beginning of the year (see graph below),while upgrades related to backlog activity or PB title activity represented approximately 500 cases so far. 2 Table 1: Number of new National Arbiter Licenses (February – August 2019) FIDE IT provided some statistics about tournaments and rated players, to help us better understand the context and start projects (our own, with PDC or WOM) knowing some key data. Below is an illustration, at the continental level to keep readability, of indicators which can be interesting to follow. So far, this requests a lot of manual processing, but as soon as we have better tool, we expect to industrialize the production of KPIs. Table 2: Representativity of arbiters in various contexts (August 2019) - In charge for the commission: Nebojsa Baralic, Laurent Freyd. b) TITLE APPLICATIONS PROCESS No changes in the process during the reported period. In charge for the commission: Nebojsa Baralic, Laurent Freyd, Takis Nikolopoulos, Irina Prokopova. 3 3. REGULATIONS AND PUBLICATIONS a) ARBITERS` MANUAL The Arbiters Manual 2019 Preparation Team formed by Arbiters` Commission has completed a new digital edition and it has been posted on website arbiter.fide.com. The new version uses texts that came into force on July 1, 2019. Collaboration with another commission and FIDE office has been helpful in advancing this task. Thank them! In the next period, a printed edition should also be done. It was decided to contact the FIDE Office for a printing procedure. This project is led by Shohreh Bayat, with collaboration of several commission members. b) REGULATIONS FOR ARBITERS An initial work was started during the commission meeting in Minsk to list gaps, inconsistencies in the writing of our regulations, so that new proposals can be proposed to the FIDE Congress. In charge for the commission: Irina Gevorgyan, Shohreh Bayat with collaboration of other collaboration members . 4. TRAINING OF ARBITERS a) FIDE ARBITERS SEMINARS In the period from the April 23rd, 2019 till the August 22nd, 2019 twenty (20) FIDE ARBITERS’ SEMINARS were organized in the following places and dates, under the auspices of FIDE. For each of them, report and results have been published on the FIDE website: 1. 65th Internet Based Seminar, 11-18 June 2019 30 participants from 12 Federations, 2. Mandalay, MYANMAR, 12-16 June 2019 11 participants from 4 Federations, 3. Uddingston, SCOTLAND, 14-16 June 2019 5 participants from 3 Federations, 4. Saint Quentin, FRANCE, 14-16 June 2019 13 participants from 3 Federations, 5. Baku, AZERBAIJAN, 23-27 June 2019 29 participants from 2 Federations, 6. Gold Coast, AUSTRALIA, 02-03 July 2019 11 participants from 2 Federations, 7. Maseru, LESOTHO, 04-07 July 2019 5 participants from 2 Federations, 8. Magglingen, SWITZERLAND, 05-07 July 2019 16 participants from 4 Federations, 9. Sao Paulo, BRASIL, 06-12 July 2019 5 participants from 1 Federation, 10. Kaohsiung, CHINESE TAIPEI, 13-17 July 2019 5 participants from 1 Federation, 11. Gaborone, BOTSWANA, 17-19 July 2019 18 participants from 3 Federations, 12. Tehran, IRAN, 25-29 July 2019 46 participants from 1 Federation, 13. Dakha, BANGLADESH, 01-03 August 2019 14 participants from 2 Federations, 4 14. Lusaka, ZAMBIA, 01-04 August 2019 13 participants from 2 Federations, 15. Paris, FRANCE, 04-10 August 2019 7 participants from 6 Federations, 16. Bratislava, SLOVAKIA, 06-09 August 2019 7 participants from 5 Federations, 17. Orlando, USA, 07-09 August 2019 21 participants from 3 Federations, 18. Rosenheim, GERMANY, 15-18 August 2019 23 participants from 3 Federations, 19. Panama City, PANAMA, 17-19 August 2019 20 participants from 3 Federations, 20. Kabul, AFGANISTAN, 16-19 August 2019 33 participants from 1 Federations, *Two Seminars were canceled Macau, MACAU, 28-30 June 2019 and Ramat Hasharon, ISRAEL, 13-15 August 2019 * From the previous period: rd - 63 Internet Based Seminar, 23-30 April 2019 4 participants from 4 Federations Map 1 – Seminars reported for 3rd PB 2019 A few statistics (based on received reports to date): 332 arbiters from 52 Federations took part in 20 seminars. 308 arbiters took part in the exam. 230 arbiters passed the exam and achieved an FA Norm (see Appendix A for the full list). 23 direct titles were submitted for validation from this period. The following FIDE Arbiters’ Seminars have been approved to be organized in the next period and published on the FIDE website by August 18th: 1. Saint Lucia, SAINT LUCIA, 22-24 August 2019 Organized by SAINT LUCIA CHESS FEDERATION, 2. Izmir, TURKEY, 22-25 August 2019 Organized by TURKISH CHESS FEDERATION, 5 3.