DOCSLIB.ORG

UNIVERSITY of HULL a Case Study of Death and Bereavement Arising

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
UNIVERSITY of HULL a Case Study of Death and Bereavement Arising UNIVERSITY OF HULL A Case Study of Death and Bereavement arising from Political Violence in Nepal being a Thesis submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in The University of Hull by Sujeet K. Karn MA, MSW October 2012 Contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................ vi ABSTRACT ...............................................................................................................viii CHAPTER 1 ................................................................................................................ 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................. 1 Introduction .......................................................................................................... 1 The Nepali State: a Historical Overview ................................................................. 6 Nepal before 1950 ............................................................................................. 7 Nepal during 1950 to 1990 ................................................................................ 7 Maoist in the Making........................................................................................... 11 Death during Maoist Conflict ............................................................................... 16 Deliberate and unlawful killings ....................................................................... 20 Meaning of Death in Maoist Revolution in Nepal ................................................. 21 Death - a sacrifice ............................................................................................ 21 Martyrdom ...................................................................................................... 22 Death bestows meaning on life ........................................................................ 26 Aims and Objectives ............................................................................................ 27 Research Questions ............................................................................................. 29 CHAPTER 2 .............................................................................................................. 32 Death: Meanings and Perceptions .......................................................................... 32 Introduction ........................................................................................................ 32 Death – ‘Immortality’ in Hindu Religion and the East ........................................... 35 Death – a spiritual experience ......................................................................... 38 Death Rituals in the Hindu and the Buddhist Traditions ....................................... 43 Notions of purity and pollution in death ‘sansakar’ .......................................... 49 Death ‘sanskar’ – a cosmogony ........................................................................ 52 Death rituals among Himalayan Buddhists ....................................................... 54 Death studies and the Anthropological Imagination ............................................ 61 CHAPTER 3 .............................................................................................................. 69 Researching Politically Implicated Violent Death: Methodological Issues .............. 69 Introduction ........................................................................................................ 69 Qualitative Design: Mindfulness and Beyond ....................................................... 70 Ethnography and the study of Death and Bereavement ....................................... 73 Multi-sited Ethnography in Death and Bereavement studies ............................... 81 The ‘Sites’ in Ethnography ................................................................................... 89 Fieldwork sites ................................................................................................ 90 Engaging in field-Sites.......................................................................................... 91 Field Notes - Journal ............................................................................................ 94 Bara: a Field Site .................................................................................................. 98 Security a Major Concern .................................................................................. 100 Ethical Dilemmas ............................................................................................... 109 Being in the Field and Being Doubtful ................................................................ 111 Rukum: another Field-Site ................................................................................. 113 Interacting with Family Members ...................................................................... 117 Managing Emotions in the Field......................................................................... 120 Interviewing Children ........................................................................................ 121 CHAPTER 4 ............................................................................................................ 128 Understanding Death in Post-Conflict Nepali Society ........................................... 128 Introduction ...................................................................................................... 128 Conceptualising Death in Nepal ......................................................................... 129 Understanding of Death in Nepali Context – a Typology: ................................... 132 Acceptance of Death ......................................................................................... 136 ‘Mrytu’ (death): ‘sarbabhut yathartha’ (ultimate reality) – the truth .............. 137 Timely death and untimely death .................................................................. 142 Death: a hope for a bereaved ........................................................................ 144 ‘Mrytu’ is ‘kaala’ – defined fate ..................................................................... 146 Rejection of Death ............................................................................................. 151 Akaala mrytu (untimely death) ...................................................................... 152 Death as an inflicted sorrow .......................................................................... 157 Death as ‘an accident’ ................................................................................... 159 Transcendental approach to Death .................................................................... 163 Body is ‘chetana’ ........................................................................................... 166 Death is a balancing act ................................................................................. 168 Death as Self-actualisation ................................................................................ 169 ‘Mrytu’, ‘mukti’ and martyrdom .................................................................... 172 Power to choose and sacrifice life .................................................................. 175 Death as revenge ........................................................................................... 179 Death as power to kill .................................................................................... 182 Conclusions ....................................................................................................... 185 CHAPTER 5 ............................................................................................................ 189 Commemorating Violent Death: Ritual Perspectives and Practices ..................... 189 Introduction ...................................................................................................... 189 Rituals for death and dying ................................................................................ 192 Cremation rites.............................................................................................. 193 ‘Dasa-kriya’ karma ......................................................................................... 195 Barkhi and masik sraddha as regular rituals of remembrances ....................... 199 Variations in Death Rituals ................................................................................ 204 Contradictory rituals in troubled times: the case of a little know................... 205 Pranami sect.................................................................................................. 205 Death rituals of Magars: flexibility to choose ................................................. 209 Buddhist Tamang death rituals after a violent death ...................................... 212 Muslims’ way of mourning ............................................................................ 215 ‘Durgati’ of the Dead Body and Hasty Cremation ............................................... 217 Effects of ‘Dosa’ in ‘Sarddha Karma’ (Death rituals) ........................................... 222 Ritual Power and Local Politics .......................................................................... 226 Rituals amidst Fear ............................................................................................ 229 ‘Soka - Surta’ led to Ritual Confiscation ............................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Switching Over to Identity Politics Nepali Left Political Parties Have
    1 1. Introduction: Switching over to Identity Politics Nepali left political parties have come to regard caste and ethnicity equivalent to class disseminating new ethnic-based identity that demonstrates how the very foundation of communist ideology has been shifting from class into identity politics. The politics of identity that emerged and spread from 1990 received prominence in Nepali politics especially after 2006 April Uprising which ultimately popped up as an apple of discord when political parties failed to deliver new constitution through the Constituent Assembly (CA) bickering over it. Ultimately, the CA got dissolved on May 27, 2012 after parties apparently failed to make consensus on identity-based federalism. Though a number of identity-based organizations emerged before 2006 as well, the trends of forming identity-based organizations and focusing on identity groups rather than class soared after the second people's movement. Moreover, polarization due to the identity politics has heightened in Nepali politics after the CA dissolution. Left political parties of Nepal who are guided by the Marxist slogan as 'Worker's of all countries, unite' gradually gave way to identity politics that was diluted from 'class struggle' itself. As the time changes, everything changes with it except the 'change' itself. Same is the case with ideology. It shifts from one to the other as Daniel Bell in his book " The End of Ideology: on the Exhaustion of Political Ideas in the Fifties" claims that the older humanistic ideologies developed during the nineteenth and early twentieth century is ebbing gradually (1960). During 1960s and 70s, in contrast to the logic of Marxist and Neo-Marxist theory, social movements were focused on culture and identity such as civil rights and women's movements challenging the class structure (Bernstein 49).
    [Show full text]
  • European Bulletin of Himalayan Research (EBHR)
    Nine Years On: The 1999 eLection and Nepalese politics since the 1990 janandoLan' John Whelpton Introduction In May 1999 Nepal held its th ird general election since the re-establishment of parliamentary democracy through the 'People's Movement' (janandolan) of spring 1990. it was in one way a return to the start ing point si nce, as in the first (1991) electio n, the Nepali Congress achieved an absolute majority, whilst the party's choice in 1999 for Prime Minister, Krishna Prasad Bhat­ tami, had led the \990-9\ interim government and would have conti nued in otTi ce had it not been for his personal defeat in Kathmandu-i constituency. Whilst the leading figu re was the same, the circumstances and expectations we re, of course, ve ry different. Set against the high hopes of 1990, the nine years of democracy in praclice had been a disill us ioning ex perience for mosl Ne palese, as cynical manoeuvring for power seemed to have replaced any attempt 10 solve the deep economic and social problems bequeathed by the Panchayat regime. This essay is an allempt to summarize developments up to the recent election, looking at wha t has apparently go ne wrong but also trying to identify some positive ac hievements.l The political kaleidoscope The interim government, which presided over the drafting of the 1990 I I am grateful 10 Krishna Hachhelhu for comments on an earlier draft oflhis paper and for help in collecting materials. 1 The main political developments up to late 1995 are covered in Brown (1996) and Hoftun et al.
    [Show full text]
  • The Biography of a Magar Communist Anne De Sales
    The Biography of a Magar Communist Anne de Sales To cite this version: Anne de Sales. The Biography of a Magar Communist. David Gellner. Varieties of Activist Ex- periences in South Asia, Sage, pp.18-45, 2010, Governance, Conflict, and Civic Action Series. hal- 00794601 HAL Id: hal-00794601 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00794601 Submitted on 10 Mar 2013 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. Chapter 2 The Biography of a Magar Communist Anne de Sales Let us begin with the end of the story: Barman Budha Magar was elected a Member of Parliament in 1991, one year after the People’s Movement (jan andolan) that put an end to thirty years of the Partyless Panchayat ‘democracy’ in Nepal. He had stood for the Samyukta Jana Morcha or United People’s Front (UPF), the political wing of the revolutionary faction of the Communist Party of Nepal, or CPN (Unity Centre).1 To the surprise of the nation, the UPF won 9 seats and the status of third-largest party with more than 3 per cent of the national vote. However, following the directives of his party,2 Barman, despite being an MP, soon went underground until he retired from political life at the time of the People’s War in 1996.
    [Show full text]
  • The Double Life of Development: Peasants, Agrarian Livelihoods, and the Prehistory of Nepal's Maoist Revolution a DISSERTATION
    The Double Life of Development: Peasants, Agrarian Livelihoods, and the Prehistory of Nepal’s Maoist Revolution A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA BY Dinesh Paudel IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Vinay Gidwani and Abdi Samatar October 2012 © Dinesh Paudel 2012 Acknowledgements This dissertation is the cumulative outcome of the efforts of many individuals, institutions and communities. Any attempt to list them all — let alone offer sufficient appreciation and acknowledgment — will remain incomplete. I am forever indebted to them for their constant and transformative inspiration and intellectual and moral support, which made this work possible. The formality of “Acknowledgements” does not really capture and leaves far too understated my appreciation to my advisors Vinay Gidwani and Abdi Samatar for their tireless intellectual guidance, inspiration, patience, critical insights and unconditional support over the last five years. I have been privileged to learn from their academic acumen and commitment to change. Their incisive comments and thorough engagements in various stages of my research have taught me nuanced ways of approaching political praxis, geography and development. My sincere gratitude to them for their help in shaping my academic path and ways of thinking about the world that I hope to carry with me into my future endeavors. Likewise, I am indebted and grateful to Eric Sheppard and Dean Current, who served on my committee and also remained a special source of intellectual inspiration and academic support in my research. Their ideas are imprinted in this dissertation. I feel particularly fortunate to have worked with many scholars at the University of Minnesota.
    [Show full text]
  • The Maoist Insurgency in Nepal and the Political Economy of Violence∗
    The Maoist Insurgency in Nepal and the Political Economy of Violence∗ Avidit Acharyay October 2009 Abstract This paper studies the incidence of political violence associated with the Maoist insurgency in Nepal. I take a cross-sectional approach where the unit of analy- sis is the district, and dependent variable is total killings by state and Maoists normalized by district population. I find no evidence that political and economic grievances are linked to the incidence of political violence. There is also very lit- tle evidence that district prosperity or political ideology are associated with the incidence of violence. On the other hand, I find that the intensity of violence was greatest in the Midwestern districts and in districts with low road density. His- torical evidence suggests that the dummy variable for Midwestern districts that appears significant and robust reflects the political entrepreneurship of leftist lead- ers more than half a century ago. The results support a theory of conflict that treats an insurgency as analogous to a profit maximizing firm. JEL Classification Codes: D74 Key words: conflict, insurgency, political violence, greed, grievance ∗I would like to thank Jayaraj Acharya, Jose Azar, Nicholas Sambanis, Swarnim Wagle, an anony- mous referee, and the editors of this volume for valuable comments and discussions. All errors and shortcomings are my own. yWoodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs, Robertson Hall, Princeton University, Princeton NJ 08544-1013 (e-mail: [email protected]). 1 1 Introduction What were the causes of insurgency in Nepal? There have been two approaches to an- swering this question. In one line of research, studies such as Murshed and Gates (2005) and Bohara, Mitchell and Nepal (2006) have used cross-sectional regression techniques to predict the effect of poverty, inequality, rough terrain, and ethno-linguistic divisions on the intensity of political violence.
    [Show full text]
  • Shiva.MST Job 1
    Chapter 3 Evolution of Communist Movement in Nepal till 1990 Early Years, Development after 1960, Splits within the Movement 1. Formation of Communist Party of Nepal: Its Initial Documents As described (See p.43), disillusioned by Regmi’s activities Pushpalal left for Calcutta. On reaching there, he says, “His contact with Nripen Chakraborty and Ratanlal Brahmin and … his belief that the International Communists would instantaneously support the launch of a Communist Party in Nepal encouraged him to open Nepal Communist Party” (Pushpalal, Itihas 32). Further, he notes, “Revolutionary friends from Kathmandu Valley and from Eastern and Western Nepal were also conferring with me on the issue” (35). From then onwards, describing the formation of Nepal Communist Party, he writes: On 22nd of April 1949 a meeting was held among Pushpalal, Niranjan Govind Vaid, Narayanvilas Joshi and Narbahadur at Shyambazar, 28, Naveen Sarkar Lane, Calcutta. Meanwhile, Durgadevi had also arrived from Kathmandu so she was also included as the founding member in the organisational committee of the Party. This committee appointed Pushpalal as the general secretary of the Party and gave him the responsibility of organising the Party at the Central level. The responsibility of organising the Party in Bara, Parsa and Rautahat was given to Niranjan Govind Vaid, because he had played an active role in Birganj area during the 1947 Satyagraha movement. Narayanvilas and Durgadevi were asked to look after Kathmandu Valley and Narbahadur was given the responsibility of working among the workers of Biratnagar and Jogbani (35). However, there exists a controversy regarding the exact date when the Party was formed and regarding the number of founding members.
    [Show full text]
  • Dilemma and Factionalism in the Maoist Politics of Nepal
    A Peer-Reviewed Article Dilemma and Factionalism in the Maoist Politics of Nepal Arjun Bahadur Ayadi Abstract The history of the Communist movement of Nepal has passed almost 70-years since the formation of the Communist Party of Nepal (CPN) in 1949. During this period, the Communist movement of Nepal passes through so many ups and downs, twists and turns, and defeats and victories. It has taken different paths in course of its development. It has experienced series of split and merger, which still continues. The Maoist, a radical faction of the communist movement, led the armed struggle for ten-years between 1996-2006 to seizes political power and establish a “New People’s Democracy”. However, the deadly armed struggle concluded in negotiation after 10-year and Maoists re-entered in the competitive politics. As it entered in the competitive politics, the CPN (Maoist), revised its ideological goal from “New People’s Democracy” to “Democracy in the Twenty First Century”. After these ideological change, it has entered in the vicious circle of split and merger. In this context, this paper aims to understand the relations between political dilemma and fraction taken place in the history of Communist movement of Nepal in general and Maoist politics in particular. On the basis of documentary analyses, this paper argues, the whole Communist movement of Nepal including Maoists politics suffered from ideological dilemma (between liberal and radical line) that resulted internal contradiction within the movement leading toward the series of split and generated the serious crisis to radical politics in Nepal. Keywords: CPN (Maoist), Maoism, Marxism, Leninism, ideology Introduction … it will appear that sometimes we are going to the Left and - 1 - Journal of Political Science, Volume XVIII, 2018 sometimes to the Right.
    [Show full text]
  • Ambiguous Bikās: History of the Concept of Development in Nepal 1900–2006
    Department of Political and Economic Studies University of Helsinki Finland Ambiguous Bikās: History of the Concept of Development in Nepal 1900–2006 Bandana Gyawali ACADEMIC DISSERTATION To be publicly discussed, by due permission of the Faculty of Social Sciences of the University of Helsinki, in lecture room PIII, Porthania (Yliopistonkatu 3) at 11:00 on Thursday, 23 August 2018 Publication of the Faculty of Social Sciences 82/2018 Development Studies Opponent Professor Mark Liechty, Departments of Anthropology and History, University of Illinois at Chicago Pre-examiners Professor Stacy Leigh Pigg, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Simon Fraser University Professor Tatsuro Fujikura, Department of South Asia and Indian Ocean Studies, Kyoto University Supervisors Professor emeritus Juhani Koponen Department of Political and Economic Studies, Development Studies, University of Helsinki Docent Sudhindra Sharma, Interdisciplinary Analysts, Kathmandu, Nepal © Bandana Gyawali Distribution and Sales Unigrafia Bookstore http://shop.unigrafia.fi ISSN 2343-273X (Print) ISSN 2343-2748 (Online publication) ISBN 978-951-51-3319-9 (Paperback) ISBN 978-951-51-3320-5 (PDF File) Unigrafia, Helsinki 2018 ABSTRACT Development, an ambiguous sociopolitical concept, has become entrenched in the imaginations and vocabulary of the people of Nepal for decades. Its Nepali translation, bikās, is commonly believed to have come into existence with the American Point Four assistance in 1951, followed by a plethora of technical and financial assistance offered by various countries. That development is to be achieved mainly through foreign-aided interventions that will ultimately propel the country to economic prosperity and social wellbeing akin to the West is the dominant view in Nepal. Such a view makes development a fairly recent phenomenon.
    [Show full text]
  • Nepali Times for Giving So Much Charnawati Khola Disaster Due to Friends and This Does Not Equate Them to Because He Failed in English
    #255 8 - 14 July 2005 20 pages Rs 30 Weekly Internet Poll # 255 Q. How do you evaluate the security situation since 1 February? Poorer and poorer Total votes:541 Weekly Internet Poll # 256. To vote go to: www.nepalitimes.com Q... How confident are you that the new budget will help Nepal make an economic turnaround? KUMAR SHRESTHA KIRAN NEPAL the drop in investment, fall in even though the number of WALKING THE PLANK: A woman tourism, plummeting agricultural workers went up and money crosses a dilaptidated bridge t is simple arithmetic: if a and industrial production and it transfer became more streamlined. linking Libang to the rest opf country’s GDP growth is less is clear that Nepal is getting Nepalis aren’t sending their Rolpa last week, the bridge I than its population growth poorer by the day. money home and political symbolises the state of Nepal's economy--ravaged by conflict and rate then its citizens are getting Finance Minister Madhukar instability has spurred starved of budget. poorer. Nepal’s population is Rana, who is preparing the budget capital flight. growing at 2.24 percent a year, for presentation next week, has an Tourism revenue is down 33 GDP growth this year will fall to unenviable task of paying for percent this year, third country from Bombay that it traded for US 2.1 percent. more with less. exports have fallen by 20 percent dollars. Private banks are awash If the inflation rate, which Remittances from Nepali and there is a severe shortage of in cash, but they have Rs 3 billion has climbed from 1.7 percent last workers abroad, which served as a Indian currency to pay for invested in unproductive sectors year to nearly 6 percent this year, parachute for Nepal’s economy, imports.
    [Show full text]
  • Prachanda the Mastermind Behind the Maoist Insurgency in Nepal
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Calhoun, Institutional Archive of the Naval Postgraduate School Calhoun: The NPS Institutional Archive Theses and Dissertations Thesis Collection 2010-12 Prachanda the mastermind behind the Maoist Insurgency in Nepal Shahi, Prem. Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School http://hdl.handle.net/10945/5055 NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL MONTEREY, CALIFORNIA THESIS PRACHANDA: THE MASTERMIND BEHIND THE MAOIST INSURGENCY IN NEPAL by Prem Shahi December 2010 Thesis Advisor: Gordon McCormick Second Reader: Michael Freeman Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE Form Approved OMB No. 0704-0188 Public reporting burden for this collection of information is estimated to average 1 hour per response, including the time for reviewing instruction, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. Send comments regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of information, including suggestions for reducing this burden, to Washington headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and Reports, 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, Arlington, VA 22202-4302, and to the Office of Management and Budget, Paperwork Reduction Project (0704-0188) Washington DC 20503. 1. AGENCY USE ONLY (Leave blank) 2. REPORT DATE 3. REPORT TYPE AND DATES COVERED December 2010 Master’s Thesis 4. TITLE AND SUBTITLE 5. FUNDING NUMBERS Prachanda: The Mastermind Behind the Maoist Insurgency in Nepal 6. AUTHOR(S) Prem Shahi 7. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) 8. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION Naval Postgraduate School REPORT NUMBER Monterey, CA 93943-5000 9.
    [Show full text]
  • Shiva.MST Job 1
    Chapter 1 Introduction Framework, Review of Literature and Methodology 1. Introduction In the beginning of the 20th century, when modernisation and nationalist politics had initiated major transformation in the social and political life of South Asia, Nepal was still limping under a traditional social structure and religious order. Though the King remained the de jure ruler of the country the Ranas monopolised all political authority and military power. Nepal at that time was not really a theocracy, yet religion and Brahamanical order dominated every walk of her life. The social structure and values were traditional without any traces of modern education, ideas and values. The country did not have a system of modern education: first College was established in 1918, and there was an absence of modern administration and legal system. The level of industrialisation was insignificant. Though the rulers of Nepal maintained close political and military links with neighbouring British India, yet they successfully insulated Nepalese society from the influences of modernisation. The ruling elites were able to confine new ideas and aspirations sweeping other parts of South Asia, to certain pockets, if not only to certain families. As a result, the ideas equality, freedom, right of self-determination, popular government as well as democracy, socialism, communism, which were rapidly spreading in neighbouring countries, took time to enter Nepal. As a consequence, the Communist movement in Nepal has been a late starter. The first attempt at forming a Communist Party of Nepal was made in April 1949, when Pushpalal Shrestha with the help of Nripen Chakravarty and Ratanlal Brahmin initiated the process of forming the NCP (Nepal Communist Party) in Kolkata.
    [Show full text]
  • The Great Leap Forward: an Inevitable Need of History
    The Great Leap Forward: An Inevitable Need of History [This document is undated, but from internal evidence it appears to be from 2001.] “Correctness or otherwise of the ideological and political line decides everything. If it is correct, everything is gained, but if it wrong, everything is lost.” —Mao Tse-tung i. International Communist Movement and its Historical Lessons ii. Some Fundamental Characteristics of the International Situation iii. On the Situation in South Asia iv. On National Situation v. On the Synthesis of the Nepalese Communist Movement vi. Additional Points on the Party History and the Process of Ideological Synthesis vii. On Three Instruments of Revolution viii. A Great Achievement ix. Great Leap Forward and Sketch of Future Plan With its originality and grandeur, the People‟s War has completed its five memorable years and is entering the sixth. Through its rapid development process, it is entering an entirely new and higher stage of achievements and challenges during this period. The ideological synthesis of the experiences of those five years on the basis of universal principles of invincible Marxism- Leninism-Maoism has been necessary for the continuation and further development of the Nepalese revolution and to serve the world revolution as well. Needless to say, this synthesis shall be based on lofty objectives of furthering the world revolution in the 21st century, learning lessons from both world communist movement and Nepalese communist movement. Moreover, it shall be the synthesis of achievements gained through initiatives and active participation of millions of Masses in the historical and great process of People‟s War.
    [Show full text]