Comptroller's Handbook for Asset Management

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Comptroller's Handbook for Asset Management AM-OC As of January 6, 2012, this guidance applies to federal savings associations in addition to national banks.* Comptroller of the Currency Administrator of National Banks Asset Management Operations and Controls Comptroller’s Handbook January 2011 AM Asset Management As of January 6, 2012, this guidance applies to federal savings associations in addition to national banks.* Asset Management UOperations and Controls Table of Contents Asset Management Operations and Controls: Overview................................ 1 Background............................................................................................... 1 Risks Associated With Asset Management Operations ............................... 3 Operational Risk.................................................................................... 4 Reputation Risk ..................................................................................... 5 Strategic Risk......................................................................................... 5 Compliance Risk ................................................................................... 6 Credit Risk............................................................................................. 7 Board and Management Supervision ......................................................... 7 Risk Management.................................................................................. 8 Compliance Management...................................................................... 9 Staffing ................................................................................................ 11 Oversight of IT and Third-Party Service Providers ................................ 11 Operational Controls............................................................................... 15 Separation of Trust and Bank Assets..................................................... 16 Segregation of Duties .......................................................................... 17 Joint Custody or Control ...................................................................... 18 System Administration......................................................................... 19 Internal Accounting Controls ............................................................... 20 Operations Core Functions...................................................................... 20 Safeguarding of Assets ......................................................................... 20 Securities Servicing ............................................................................. 28 Securities Transaction Processing......................................................... 38 Cash Transaction Processing................................................................ 44 Asset Management Accounting and Internal Accounting Controls........ 51 Record Keeping and Reporting ............................................................ 58 Other Processes, Controls, or Regulatory Requirements....................... 61 Operations and Controls: Examination Procedures...................................... 72 Planning Activities .................................................................................. 72 Operations and Controls: Quantity of Risk.................................................. 77 Comptroller’s Handbook i Asset Management Operations and Controls As of January 6, 2012, this guidance applies to federal savings associations in addition to national banks.* Operations and Controls: Quality of Risk Management............................... 79 Board and Management Supervision ....................................................... 79 Audit and Internal Controls ..................................................................... 84 Core Asset Management Operations Functions........................................ 90 Operations and Controls: Examination Conclusions .................................... 97 Operations and Controls: Appendix A......................................................... 99 Sample Request Letter............................................................................. 99 Examination Request Letter Attachment................................................. 100 General Information .......................................................................... 100 Control Functions.............................................................................. 101 Systems and Processes....................................................................... 102 Operations and Controls: References ........................................................ 105 Laws ..................................................................................................... 105 Regulations ........................................................................................... 105 Comptroller’s Handbook Booklets......................................................... 107 OCC Issuances...................................................................................... 107 U.S. Department of Labor Issuances...................................................... 108 Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council Issuances ................ 108 Comptroller’s Handbook ii Asset Management Operations and Controls As of January 6, 2012, this guidance applies to federal savings associations in addition to national banks.* Asset Management UOperations and Controls Overview This booklet provides guidance applicable to core Asset Management operations functions and to internal controls and processes used by national banks to manage risks associated with Asset Management activities. One of a series of specialized booklets in the Comptroller’s Handbook, this booklet supplements the overall guidance provided in the “Large Bank Supervision,” “Community Bank Supervision,“ and “Asset Management” booklets of the Comptroller’s Handbook. This booklet provides expanded examination procedures when specific products or risks warrant review beyond the core assessment. Related booklets in the Comptroller’s Handbook include “Personal Fiduciary Services,” “Retirement Plan Services,” “Custody Services,” “Investment Management Services,” “Internal and External Audits,” and “Internal Control.” Background Asset Management consists of an array of bank services, such as custody, investment management, trust and estate administration, retirement plan administration and participant record keeping, and corporate trust administration. The types of Asset Management customers serviced by a bank are diverse (e.g., individuals, retirement plans, corporations, mutual funds, investment managers, insurance companies, endowments, and foundations), as are the capacities in which a bank acts on behalf of these customers (e.g., trustee, agent, or custodian). Many of these customer and account types have specialized legal, processing, accounting, and reporting requirements. This booklet focuses on core processes applicable to most account types. Asset Management operations serves as the “back office” for a bank’s Asset Management activities and plays an important role in fulfilling a bank’s strategic goals. Asset Management operations should implement efficient processes and systems capable of supporting the types of Asset Management accounts, clients, and assets that the bank services. These processes and systems should be capable of providing timely and detailed account information to management, customers, regulatory agencies, and other authorized parties, such as accountants or co-fiduciaries. Asset Management operations moves and controls cash balances, marketable securities, and tangible assets. This results in a heightened risk of loss due to Comptroller’s Handbook 1 Asset Management Operations and Controls As of January 6, 2012, this guidance applies to federal savings associations in addition to national banks.* error or theft. The market volatility of assets being processed may increase the impact of such losses. As a result, a strong system of internal controls is required. In addition, Asset Management operations often supports systems and processes integral to overall risk management and compliance processes for Asset Management services. This booklet provides guidance related to core Asset Management operations functions and core Asset Management accounting systems. These core functions include safeguarding assets, servicing securities, processing cash and securities transactions, maintaining internal controls, record keeping and reporting, and record retention. This booklet addresses these functions in detail. Core Asset Management accounting systems support these core functions by maintaining account and asset master files, account level asset and cash positions, department-level asset and cash positions, and securities movement and control (SMAC) capabilities. These systems process such transactions as interest and dividend payments, cash receipts, disbursements, and fees. They can track key events and produce client statements and regulatory and management reports. Banks may also rely on specialized systems for specific lines of business, services, asset types, or functions. Examples include retirement plan participant recordkeeping, document custody, natural resource accounting, tax preparation, performance measurement, performance attribution, or fund accounting. Many of these systems have automated data feeds or interfaces with the core Asset Management accounting system and therefore affect core functions. While this booklet does not specifically
Recommended publications
  • Ten Reasons Why Commodities
    10 Reasons Why Commodities LAZARD GLOBAL COMMODITIES 1. Build a bridge to the new economy Commodity trading is indispensable in the production and delivery of the fossil fuels that power today’s economy, and it will be equally indispensable as energy markets evolve. Global futures markets are developing for the trading of carbon allotments as well as wind and solar power. And even now many of the components of tomorrow’s transport—such as the rare metals used in batteries for electric vehicles—trade on futures exchanges. 2. Invest in the global recovery Commodity returns rise fastest when business confidence returns and the pace of economic growth begins to quicken. Base commodity demand does not vary—people have to heat and eat regardless of economic conditions. As the business cycle revives, as it has recently, incremental demand should surge. 3. Profit from inflation Rising Inflation Just as rising commodity prices drive Average Month-on-Month Change (1990–Present) consumer price inflation, they also drive (%) Commodities Equities Bonds commodity returns. No other asset class 2 responds more or more consistently 1 to heightened inflation and inflation 0 expectations. At low inflation levels like those -1 currently, commodities have historically -2 -3 delivered positive returns in contrast to 1%–2% Inflation 2%–3% Inflation 3%–5% Inflation 5%+ Inflation equity and fixed income markets, and these (25 Months) (53 Months) (73 Months) (11 Months) returns have remained positive when inflation As of 30 November 2017 Inflation was rising in 167 months and not rising in 167 months. Months of rising has become extreme.
    [Show full text]
  • Corporate Methodology
    Criteria | Corporates | General: Corporate Methodology Global Criteria Officer, Corporate Ratings: Mark Puccia, New York (1) 212-438-7233; [email protected] Chief Credit Officer, Americas: Lucy A Collett, New York (1) 212-438-6627; [email protected] European Corporate Ratings Criteria Officer: Peter Kernan, London (44) 20-7176-3618; [email protected] Criteria Officer, Asia Pacific: Andrew D Palmer, Melbourne (61) 3-9631-2052; [email protected] Criteria Officer, Corporate Ratings: Gregoire Buet, New York (1) 212-438-4122; [email protected] Primary Credit Analysts: Mark S Mettrick, CFA, Toronto (1) 416-507-2584; [email protected] Guy Deslondes, Milan (39) 02-72111-213; [email protected] Secondary Contacts: Michael P Altberg, New York (1) 212-438-3950; [email protected] David C Lundberg, CFA, New York (1) 212-438-7551; [email protected] Anthony J Flintoff, Melbourne (61) 3-9631-2038; [email protected] Pablo F Lutereau, Buenos Aires (54) 114-891-2125; [email protected] Table Of Contents SUMMARY OF THE CRITERIA SCOPE OF THE CRITERIA IMPACT ON OUTSTANDING RATINGS EFFECTIVE DATE AND TRANSITION METHODOLOGY WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT NOVEMBER 19, 2013 1 1218904 | 300023050 Table Of Contents (cont.) A. Corporate Ratings Framework B. Industry Risk C. Country Risk D. Competitive Position E. Cash Flow/Leverage F. Diversification/Portfolio Effect G. Capital Structure H. Financial Policy I. Liquidity J. Management And Governance K. Comparable Ratings Analysis SUPERSEDED CRITERIA FOR ISSUERS WITHIN THE SCOPE OF THESE CRITERIA RELATED CRITERIA APPENDIXES A. Country Risk B. Competitive Position C. Cash Flow/Leverage Analysis D.
    [Show full text]
  • Budgeting, Planning and Forecasting for Asset Management
    BUDGETING, PLANNING AND FORECASTING FOR ASSET MANAGEMENT YOU MANAGE ASSETS, LET US MANAGE YOUR PERFORMANCE Just about everything in investment management is uncertain: you’ve got volatile markets, shifting investor profiles, fluctuating portfolios, demanding clients, an uncertain political climate and increased regulation to deal with - your performance shouldn’t be a mystery. CCH Tagetik enables you to keep a finger to the pulse of your corporate performance, while equipping you with the tools to create budgets, plans, models and forecasts faster and more efficiently to drive illuminating insights and better business decisions. CCH TAGETIK PLANNING FOR ASSET MANAGEMENT Align Finance & Operations Reduce Planning Cycle Plan True Revenue and with Unified Planning Time Automate Fees Increase accuracy and confidence in As a single unified source for all your Build a comprehensive view of your numbers when budgets, plans, planning data, CCH Tagetik shaves customers, plan across different asset forecasts and models across your days, weeks, or in some cases months types, and automate fee processes with company are created using a single off the planning cycle. With dynamic highly customized accounting rules. version of the truth in a single system. dashboards, workflow and controls, View real-time assets under With automated real-time and historical Managers can address bottlenecks management, revenues and expenses data, CCH Tagetik aligns strategic, before they happen. Planners work with automated calculations, whether financial and operational planning smarter and more efficiently with that’s bank deposits, mutual funds, enterprise-wide, so the cycle is personalized work papers, task lists and cash or other funds under discretionary completed faster and with a 360* view self-service analysis.
    [Show full text]
  • Lazard Commodities Fund Monthly
    Lazard Commodities Fund APR Commentary 2019 Market Overview OPEC discipline continued to drive performance in oil and related products for the BCOMTR during April, and the top performers were gasoline, crude oil and heating oil. Elsewhere, non-OPEC capital discipline proved helpful, even for US shale, and the Baker Hughes US Crude Oil Rotary Rig Count fell by 26 rigs during the month. is occurred despite the renewal of economic sanctions prohibiting the sale of Iran oil, and the continued decline in Venezuela oil production resulting from the country’s political crisis, and the recently imposed oil sanctions. e iron ore sector continued to wrestle with the consequences of the Brumadinho mine collapse in Brazil. It has been estimated that 10% of iron ore supply has been immediately suspended, and additional tailings dams are under review. In agriculture, there was concern about oods in the US Midwest delaying crop plantings, especially for corn, which require a much longer planting cycle than soy. Some of this appears to have been offset by healthy grain inventories, and the trade dispute with China. e number of African swine fever (ASF) outbreaks continued to rise during the month. e top three performers in the BCOMTR were: • RBOB Gasoline +11.0% • Brent Crude +7.4% • WTI Crude +6.6% e bottom three detractors in the BCOMTR were: • Kansas Wheat -9.7% • Wheat -6.9% • Aluminum -6.6% April Performance of Commodities, Stocks and Bonds Currency (US$) 4/2019 Bloomberg Commodity Total Return Index -0.42% S&P 500 Index 4.05% MSCI World 3.60% Bloomberg Barclays US Aggregate Total Return Bond Index 0.03% Bloomberg Barclays Global-Aggregate Total Return Bond Index -0.30% Portfolio Review We deploy a blended approach to commodity investing by investing in commodities and commodity related equities.
    [Show full text]
  • Asset Management Risk 101 Where to Start Triage Have You Ever Wondered Why…
    Asset Management Risk 101 Where to start Triage Have you ever wondered why… • How would you prioritize all transportation asset related investments across the country? • Where would you start? “The objective of this performance and outcome-based program is for States to invest resources in projects that collectively will make progress toward the achievement of the national goals.” FTA MAP-21 Fact Sheet Federal perspective “MAP–21 fundamentally shifted the focus of Federal investment in transit to emphasize the need to maintain, rehabilitate, and replace existing transit investments.” (Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 143 / Tuesday, July 26, 2016 / Rules and Regulations, P. 48912) “In these financially constrained times, transit agencies will need to be more strategic in the use of all available funds.” (Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 143 / Tuesday, July 26, 2016 / Rules and Regulations, P. 48946) MAP-21 Goal area National goal Safety To achieve a significant reduction in traffic fatalities and serious injuries on all public roads Infrastructure condition To maintain the highway infrastructure asset system in a state of good repair Congestion reduction To achieve a significant reduction in congestion on the National Highway System System reliability To improve the efficiency of the surface transportation system Freight movement and economic vitality To improve the national freight network, strengthen the ability of rural communities to access national and international trade markets, and support regional economic development Environmental sustainability To enhance the performance of the transportation system while protecting and enhancing the natural environment Reduced project delivery delays To reduce project costs, promote jobs and the economy, and expedite the movement of people and goods by accelerating project completion through eliminating delays in the project development and delivery process, including reducing regulatory burdens and improving agencies’ work practices MAP 21: FTA requirements for TAMP elements No.
    [Show full text]
  • Asset Management Tax Update: a New Limited Partnership Fund
    Asset Management – Tax update A new Limited Partnership Fund regime for Hong Kong The introduction of the Limited Partnership Fund Bill is one of the Hong Kong Summary Government’s flagship initiatives and a major development in continuing to promote The Limited Partnership Hong Kong as Asia’s leading Private Equity hub. This follows extensive consultation Fund Bill is an important by the Government with the asset management industry in Hong Kong with the development for the funds objective of introducing an LPF regime that is on par with the more established industry in Hong Kong as domicile jurisdictions. the Hong Kong Asian focused funds have always looked to Hong Kong as a regional hub in which to Government looks to situate their investment teams. However, these funds have typically established or encourage funds to domiciled their collective investment vehicles in jurisdictions such as the Cayman domicile here. The Islands because such jurisdictions provide a regulatory framework with which proposed Limited investors are familiar, and a tax neutral investment platform which allows investors to Partnership Fund (LPF) be taxed on investment returns in their home jurisdictions. regime will provide a We anticipate that the LPF regime will prove beneficial to asset managers looking for comparable regulatory an alternative jurisdiction to establish their offshore funds. framework to other jurisdictions commonly used by Asian focused Key features of the regime funds and should cement Establishing an LPF The fund must be constituted by a limited partnership Hong Kong’s position as agreement with one general partner and at least one limited partner.
    [Show full text]
  • Asset Management and Financial Stability
    OFROFFICE OF FINANCIAL RESEARCH Asset Management and Financial Stability September 2013 Contents Introduction 1 Industry Activities 3 Vulnerabilities 9 Transmission Channels 21 Data Gaps 24 Appendix: Asset Management Firms and Activities 27 References 29 Introduction This report provides a brief overview of the asset management industry and an analysis of how asset management firms and the activities in which they engage can introduce vulnerabilities that could pose, amplify, or transmit threats to financial stability. The Financial Stability Oversight Council (the Council) decided to study the activities of asset management firms to better inform its analysis of whether—and how—to consider such firms for enhanced pruden- tial standards and supervision under Section 113 of the Dodd-Frank Act.1 The Council asked the Office of Financial Research (OFR), in collaboration with Council members, to provide data and analysis to inform this consideration. This study responds to that request by analyzing industry activities, describing the factors that make the industry and individual firms vulnerable to financial shocks, and considering the channels through which the industry could transmit risks across financial markets. The U.S. asset management industry oversees the allocation of approximately $53 trillion in financial assets (see Figure 1). The industry is central to the allocation of financial assets on behalf of investors. By facilitating investment for a broad cross-section of individuals and institutions, discretionary asset management plays a key role in capital formation and credit intermediation, while spreading any gains or losses across a diverse population of market participants. The industry is marked by a high degree of innovation, with new prod- ucts and technologies frequently reshaping the competitive landscape and changing the way that financial services are provided.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Commodities in Asset Allocation
    COMMODITY INVESTMENTS: THE MISSING PIECE OF THE PORTFOLIO PUZZLE? The Role of Commodities in Asset Allocation Investors often look to commodities as a way to potentially gain enhanced Contributor: portfolio diversification, protection against inflation, and equity-like returns. As such, commodities have gained traction among institutional and retail Xiaowei Kang, CFA investors in recent years, either as a separate asset class or as part of a real Director assets allocation. Index Research & Design [email protected] Generally, commodities have low or negative correlation with traditional asset classes over the long-term, and can act as a portfolio diversifier. For ® example, from December 1972 to June 2012, the S&P GSCI had a correlation of -0.02 and -0.08 with global equities and fixed income, Want more? Sign up to receive respectively. However, during periods of global economic downturn such as complimentary updates on a broad in the early 1980s, early 1990s and late 2000s, commodities’ correlation with range of index-related topics and other asset classes–especially equities–tended to sharply increase before events brought to you by S&P Dow reverting to relatively low levels (see Exhibit 1). Jones Indices. Exhibit 1: Rolling 36-Month Correlation with Equities and Fixed Income www.spindices.com/registration 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -0.2 -0.4 -0.6 Jul-91 Jul-08 Apr-87 Apr-04 Oct-78 Oct-95 Jan-83 Jan-00 Feb-90 Feb-07 Jun-84 Jun-01 Nov-85 Nov-02 Dec-75 Dec-92 Dec-09 Aug-81 Aug-98 Mar-80 Mar-97 Sep-88 Sep-05 May-77 May-94 May-11 Correlation with Equities Correlation with Fixed Income Source: S&P DOW JONES INDICES, MSCI, Barclays.
    [Show full text]
  • The Path Ahead Asset Management Operating Model
    Financial Services POINT OF VIEW THE PATH AHEAD REDEFINING THE ASSET MANAGEMENT OPERATING MODEL AUTHORS Matthias Hüebner, Partner Samir Misra, Partner Gökhan ÖztÜrk, Partner Robert Urtheil, Partner INTRODUCTION Asset management firms have recovered well since the financial crisis, Assets under management (AuM) stand at record levels, net revenues have risen and costs (as a percentage of AuM) have been stable (see Exhibit 1). During the recovery from the global financial crisis, we have seen global AuM growth of 8% per annum. Current conditions, on the surface at least, would appear to indicate that asset management firms are entering calm waters. EXHIBIT 1: GLOBAL ASSET MANAGEMENT INDUSTRY EVOLUTION + 7% 200 +5% 197 Revenues ($ BN) 185 Costs ($ BN) 175 156 150 139 141 141 125 119 113 98 100 95 90 91 Revenues and costs ($ BN) costs and Revenues 75 50 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Source: Oliver Wyman analysis However, despite a slight decrease in cost margin (from 16 to 15 basis points (bps)), overall cost has increased by US$29 BN (approximately one third), now reaching a total of US$119 BN. Therefore, while the current average cost-to-income ratios of a little more than 60% look acceptable, any external shock may well hit asset management profitability hard if companies do not adjust their cost base. Indeed, even with the recovery since the crisis, asset managers are uneasy. Increasing regulatory costs, the sustained challenge to the asset manager value proposition due to the inconsistent delivery of alpha performance, and the secular shift to passive products will all influence profit margins in the coming years.
    [Show full text]
  • Operational Risk White Paper: Tailoring the Right Model for Asset
    Operational Risk Tailoring the right model for asset management firms OPERATIONAL RISK: TAILORING THE RIGHT MODEL FOR ASSET MANAGEMENT FIRMS Introduction The past decade has flooded asset managers with investment management firms or investment challenges and complications—from escalating managers of larger integrated financial cyber-attacks, service provider and exchange institutions. outages, and devastating natural disasters to insider trading allegations against certain hedge While banks and insurance companies have fairly fund companies, unprecedented regulatory prescriptive guidance from regulators for an changes with complex operational impacts, effective ORM program, the requirements and information security threats and controls expectations for stand-alone asset managers may required to protect that data, and the need for be less prescriptive. Some additional challenges more complex investment solutions to satisfy faced in particular by smaller asset management client needs. All of which are challenging to not firms may include: only understand but manage effectively. • Small number of support staff relative to assets Asset managers continue to look for solutions under management where there are limited that enables them to excel in the face of internal resources to cover operational risks; unexpected challenges. Many asset managers • Potential for inadequately established find that Operational Risk Management (ORM) independent lines of defense due to commonly could be the path to manage challenges and flat organizational structure of the industry complications. There is no single universal approach to Operational risk is defined as the ‘risk of loss developing an effective operational risk program. resulting from inadequate or failed processes, Each firm’s operational risk strategy will vary people and systems or from external events depending on a number of factors including: (BASEL II)’.
    [Show full text]
  • Where Do Asset Management Ceos Come From?
    WHERE DO ASSET MANAGEMENT CEOs COME FROM? KEY FINDINGS FROM AN ANALYSIS OF CEO CAREER DYNAMICS METHODOLOGY This study presents key findings from an analysis of the profiles and career paths of CEOs in the asset management industry Our analysis included 96 CEOs across 46 large firms and 46 boutique asset management firms. Summary of key findings CEOs of large asset management firms: Of the 48 CEOs profiled1, 37 (77%) have been appointed since 2006. Spikes in CEO appointments occurred in North America during the financial crisis and in 2012 in Europe, possibly due to profits failing to recover to pre-financial crisis levels. Approximately 29% were externally appointed, roughly in line with other industries. While buy-side experience is prevalent among these CEOs, over half have never held an investment role in their career. There are differences in profiles between CEOs of independent, bank-linked and insurance- linked firms. Bank-linked CEOs often come from buy-side and other non-asset management- related parts of financial services. In contrast, CEOs at both independent and insurance-linked firms tend to come from within the asset management industry, most commonly serving as the CEO with a smaller firm prior to assuming their current role. Only one in five CEOs have international experience, which is notably lower than in other parts of financial services. For comparison, in insurance three in five CEOs have international experience. CEOs of boutique asset management firms: While the CEOs of boutique firms on multi-manager platforms are primarily promoted internally (similar to large firms), the majority of CEOs of independent asset managers are founders.
    [Show full text]
  • Pwc AWM Insights IFRS for Asset Management
    PwC AWM Insights IFRS for Asset Management Asset managers and fund companies are now playing on a field marked by turbulent markets and complex regulatory reform. In this kind of environment, a trusted advisor with a balanced, comprehensive and international perspective can be an invaluable resource. In depth – A look at current financial reporting issues The IASB and FASB issued their converged standard on revenue recognition. This ‘in depth’ focuses on the accounting for transactions that are not insurance contracts or financial instruments. This includes any service components required to be separated (or optionally separated under IFRS 4) from those contracts and accounted for under the new revenue standard. http://pwc.to/2lRQxer In depth – A look at current financial reporting issues IFRS 10 for asset managers and other related issues IFRS 10, ‘Consolidated Financial Statements’, sets out principles for the presentation and preparation of consolidated financial statements where an entity controls one or more other entities. The assessment of whether an investor or any other party controls a fund can be complex and depends heavily on facts and circumstances. This publication provides guidance on how to apply the requirements of IFRS 10 in different scenarios. http://pwc.to/2kBeFQn IFRS 13 Disclosure requirements – Questions & Answers IFRS 13 expanded the guidance on assessing fair value measurements within the three levels of the fair value hierarchy which was originally introduced in IFRS 7. As a result, the classification as Level 1, Level 2 or Level 3 became required for nonfinancial assets and liabilities measured at fair value and disclosures of fair values in the notes to the financial statements.
    [Show full text]