Biochemical Investigations in the Rare Disease Alkaptonuria: Studies on the Metabolome and the Nature of Ochronotic Pigment
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Biochemical Investigations in the Rare Disease Alkaptonuria: Studies on the Metabolome and the Nature of Ochronotic Pigment Thesis submitted in accordance with the requirements of the University of Liverpool for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Brendan Paul Norman September 2019 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS It is hard to describe the journey this PhD has taken me on without reverting to well-worn clichés. There has been plenty of challenges along the way, but ultimately I can look back on the past four years with a great sense of pride, both in the work presented here and the skills I have developed. Equally important though are the relationships I have established. I have lots of people to thank for playing a part in this thesis. First, I would like to thank my supervisors, Jim Gallagher, Lakshminarayan Ranganath and Norman Roberts for giving me this fantastic opportunity. Your dedication to research into alkaptonuria (AKU) is inspiring and our discussions together have always been thoughtful and often offered fresh perspective on my work. It has been a pleasure to work under your supervision and your ongoing support and encouragement continues to drive me on. It has truly been a pleasure to be part of the AKU research group. Andrew Davison deserves a special mention - much of the highs and lows of our PhD projects have been experienced together. Learning LC-QTOF-MS was exciting (and continues to be) but equally daunting at the start of our projects (admittedly more so for me as a Psychology graduate turned mass spectrometrist!). I am very proud of what we have achieved together, largely starting from scratch on the instrument, and we are continuing to learn all the time. Thank you to the AKU research group more widely, including the AKU Society: to Peter Wilson, Hazel Sutherland, Anna Milan, Juliette Hughes, Jane Dillon, Leah Taylor, George Bou-Gharios, Jonathan Jarvis, Andy Hughes, Milad Khedr and Eman Alawadhi. Thanks to Agilent Technologies for contributing to the funding for this PhD. Special thanks go to Gordon Ross - I have learned so much working under your guidance and expertise throughout this project. Through you and everyone else at Agilent I have always been made to feel very welcome as part of the wider Agilent community. This thesis would not have been possible without the specialist training provided by Gordon and others within the company. I look forward to continuing our collaboration going forward. Thanks also to Hania Khouri and Richard Blankley at Agilent for your kind assistance with technical aspects of the project. I am grateful for the funding from Agilent to attend the 2018 Metabolomics Society conference in Seattle. I must not forget to mention the NMR folks. Thanks to Wing Ying Chow and Marie Phelan for lending their expertise in NMR. I feel the NMR data has added considerable value to the project and I have enjoyed learning about this technique besides MS. I have made friendships that I will never forget during my time in Liverpool. Eddie, Sahem, Pete, Leah, Fran, Mikele and Juliette to name but a few. Not forgetting the Bullring Irish coffee club ft. Dr Craig. We have had some great times together. Thanks to Jaini for putting a roof over my head. Finally, I would like to thank my family and especially mum and dad for your unconditional love and support in everything I do. I hope I can keep on making you proud. i ABSTRACT Alkaptonuria (AKU) is a rare inherited disorder of tyrosine metabolism caused by lack of the enzyme homogentisate 1,2-dioxygenase (HGD). The primary biochemical consequence of HGD deficiency is increased circulating concentration of homogentisic acid (HGA); this is the central cause of the devastating multi-systemic damage observed in AKU. One of the most striking pathophysiological features of AKU is accumulation of ochronotic pigment derived from HGA in tissues throughout the body. HGA has an affinity for cartilaginous tissue. Presence of ochronotic pigment in cartilage of load- bearing joints causes severe early-onset osteoarthropathy; the greatest cause of morbidity in AKU. This thesis addresses two major unanswered questions in AKU. First is the wider metabolic consequences both of HGD deficiency and those observed following treatment with the promising HGA-lowering agent nitisinone. A metabolomics approach was employed to address these questions, with the aim of discovering biomarkers with potential clinical value in monitoring disease in AKU and in assessing the wider metabolic consequences of nitisinone treatment. Second, this thesis explores the nature of ochronotic pigment derived from HGA. The chemical structure of ochronotic pigment is not known, nor are the mechanisms by which HGA interacts with and binds into the cartilage extracellular matrix. Various analytical chemistry techniques were employed to study the chemical properties of ochronotic pigment and pigmented cartilage in patients and mice with AKU. The data from chemical analyses presented in this thesis provide new insights into the nature of ochronotic pigment. The chemical structure of ochronotic pigment remains unknown, but the pigment had long been widely cited as a polymer in the literature. First, these data fundamentally challenge the idea that ochronotic pigment is a polymeric species. Through study of ochronotic tissue samples, the data also indicate for the first time a specific alteration to the cartilage matrix that enables binding of HGA-derived species. An LC-QTOF-MS metabolic phenotyping strategy was developed, enabling identification of hundreds of metabolites simultaneously, based on chemical properties of accurate mass and chromatographic retention time. Application of this technique to AKU showed that the biochemical alterations following a) targeted deletion of the HGD gene in mice to cause AKU, and b) nitisinone treatment, reflect a complex, interconnected network of metabolite changes. The data not only stimulate myriad further lines of research into AKU pathophysiology but also reveal previously uncharacterised association between metabolites at a network level. These studies provide a prime example of how rare diseases such as inborn errors of metabolism can offer unique windows into metabolism and human physiology more generally. ii ABBREVIATIONS 18F-NaF PET 18F-NaF positron emission tomography 3-MT 3-methoxytyramine 5-HIAA 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid AKU Alkaptonuria AM Accurate mass AMRT Accurate mass - retention time APCI Atmospheric-pressure chemical ionisation BDI-II Beck’s Depression Inventory-II BQA Benzoquinone acetic acid CEF Compound exchange file CID Collision-induced dissociation CNS Central nervous system CP Cross polarisation CSF Cerebrospinal fluid DHMA 3,4-Dihydroxymandelaldehyde DNP Dynamic nuclear polarisation ENU N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea ESI Electrospray ionisation FC Fold change FDA U.S. Food and Drug Administration FSLG Frequency-switched Lee-Goldburg (NMR pulse seq.) FTICR Fourier-transform ion cyclon resonance GAG Glycosaminoglycan GC Gas chromatography HETCOR HETeronuclear CORrelation spectroscopy HGA Homogentisic acid HGD Homogentisate 1,2-dioxygenase HPLA 3-(4-hydroxyphenyl)lactic acid HPPD 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvic acid dioxygenase HSQC Heteronuclear Single Quantum Coherence spectroscopy HT-I Hereditary tyrosinaemia type-I HVA Homovanillic acid INEPT Insensitive Nuclei Enhanced by Polarisation Transfer LC Liquid chromatography LC-QTOF-MS Liquid chromatography quadrupole time-of flight mass spectrometry MA Metadrenaline MALDI Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionisation MAS Magic angle spinning MHPG 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylglycol MPP Mass Profiler Professional MS Mass spectrometry iii NAC National Alkaptonuria Centre NIH National Institutes of Health NMA Normetadrenaline NMDA N-methyl-D-aspartate NMR Nuclear magnetic resonance NTFA 2-Nitro-4-trifluoromethylbenzoic acid OA Osteoarthritis PBS Phosphate buffered saline PCA Principal components analysis PG Proteoglycan PLS Partial least squares ppm Parts per million QA Quality assurance QC Quality control RA Rheumatoid arthritis RF Radiofrequency RT Retention time ssNMR Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance TIC Total ion chromatogram TOCSY TOtal Correlation SpectroscopY TOF Time-of-flight iv TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 GENERAL INTRODUCTION ........................................................................ 1 1.1.1 AKU is an historic disease .................................................................. 2 1.1.2 The genetic basis of AKU ................................................................... 3 1.1.3 AKU is a disease of tyrosine metabolism ............................................ 4 1.1.4 Clinical presentation of AKU ............................................................... 6 1.1.5 Distribution of ochronosis is not uniform ........................................... 10 1.1.6 Effect of ochronosis .......................................................................... 12 1.1.7 Treatment of AKU ................................................................................ 14 1.1.8 Model systems of AKU .................................................................... 17 1.2 Metabolomics ......................................................................................... 20 1.2.1 The metabolome and metabolomics ................................................. 20 1.2.2 Non-targeted metabolomics: opportunities and challenges ............... 21 1.2.3 LC-QTOF-MS: application to metabolomics ...................................... 27 1.2.4 Metabolomics in the clinical laboratory and its potential