SUCCESSFUL APPEAL dkb/br, 1996 height 16.1 Dosage (9-2-9-0-0); DI: 3.44; CD: 1.00 See gray pages—Matchem RACE AND (BLACK TYPE) RECORD Intentionally, 1956 Intent, by War Relic Age Starts 1st 2nd 3rd Earned 34s, BTW, $652,258 2 6 3(1) 2(1) 0 $148,580 In Reality, 1964 187 f, 20 BTW, 3.58 AEI My Recipe, by Discovery 27s, BTW, $795,824 3 11 3(3) 0 3(3) $316,601 555 f, 83 BTW, 3.16 AEI My Dear Girl, 1957 Rough'n Tumble, by Free For All 4 5 2(1) 0 1(1) $189,500 Valid Appeal, b, 1972 20s, BTW, $209,739 War Relic Totals 22 8(5) 2(1) 4(4) $654,681 36s, BTW, $201,733 15 f, 14 r, 13 w, 7 BTW Iltis, by Won A.G. Vanderbilt H Withers S 791 f, 85 BTW, 2.20 AEI Moslem Chief, 1957 Alibhai, by Hyperion (G2, 6f), (G2, 8f), 6.47 AWD Kentucky Cup Sprint S (G2, 6f), Cowdin S (G2, 6.5f), 30s, BTW, $39,027 Desert Trial, 1963 8 f, 1 BTW, 1.78 AEI Up the Hill, by Jacopo Amsterdam S (G3, 6f), 2nd S (G3, 8f), 3rd 31s, BTW, $106,385 King’s Bishop S (G1, 7f), Forego H (G2, 6.5f), Dwyer S 13 f, 11 r, 8 w, 4 BTW Scotch Verdict, 1960 Alsab, by Good Goods (G2, 8.5f), Leonard Richards S (8.5f). Unraced 10 f, 7 r, 7 w, 3 BTW Glen Arvis, by Attention SIRE LINE Northern Prospect, 1976 Mr. Prospector, by Raise a Native SUCCESSFUL APPEAL is by VALID APPEAL, black- 15s, BTW, $89,941 type stakes winner of 8 races, $201,733, Dwyer H Fortunate Prospect, 1981 579 f, 34 BTW, 1.33 AEI Sleek Dancer, by (G2), etc., and sire of 85 black-type stakes winners, 39s, BTW, $439,875 including K. J.’S APPEAL (G1), STORMY BUT VALID 739 f, 27 BTW, 1.44 AEI Fortunate Bid, 1971 Lucky Debonair, by Vertex Successful Dancer, dkb/br, 1989 20s, wnr, $22,448 STUD ANALYSIS 42s, wnr, $96,817 13 f, 12 r, 9 w, 4 BTW Biddy Big, by Palestinian 7 f, 5 r, 4 w, 2 BTW Staff Writer, 1968 Northern Dancer, by Nearctic Northern Hemisphere 6.23 AWD Unraced By Foal Crop (14 crops) Debonair Dancer, 1978 496 f, 37 BTW, 1.23 AEI Twill, by 31s, BTW, $173,856 Named Run- Win- 2yo 2yo BT 8 f, 6 r, 6 w, 3 BTW In the Bag, 1971 Lucky Debonair, by Vertex Year Foals ners ners Wnrs BTW Winners 22s, wnr, $14,199 2002 43 36 (84%) 30 (70%) 15 6 9 (21%) 7 f, 7 r, 4 w, 1 BTW Equiria, by Olympia 2003 36 32 (89%) 28 (78%) 10 0 1 (3%) 2004 41 32 (78%) 29 (71%) 13 3 6 (15%) 2005 62 49 (79%) 37 (60%) 12 1 4 (6%) (G1), MIGHTY APPEALING (G1), PROUD APPEAL (G1), SUCCESSFUL SONG, 07, f (Sultry Song, Inverness 2006 52 42 (81%) 36 (69%) 9 1 3 (6%) SOUTHERN APPEAL (G1), NANNERL (G2), WORLD Drive): $632,538, Lighthouse S, Ocala S, etc. 2007 58 52 (90%) 47 (81%) 20 1 3 (5%) APPEAL (G2), ISAYSO (G2T), VALID WAGER (G2), ISABELLE, 11, f (A++, Gold Fever, Northern Jove): 2008 71 54 (76%) 46 (65%) 15 1 5 (7%) Sportsmaster (champion 3yo colt in Dom), etc. $508,102, Heavenly Prize Invitational S, etc., to 6, 2017. 2009 49 38 (78%) 33 (67%) 11 1 5 (10%) VALID APPEAL’S other sons as stallions include SUCCESSFUL AFFAIR, 02, g (A++, Private Terms, 2010 62 51 (82%) 41 (66%) 17 1 3 (5%) PROUD APPEAL (166 foals, 11 BTW, 2.15 AEI), Storm Bird): $478,115, H, etc. 2011 55 44 (80%) 35 (64%) 6 0 4 (7%) MIGHTY APPEALING (70 foals, 4 BTW, 1.47 AEI), VALID SUCCESSFUL NATIVE 2012 60 48 (80%) 39 (65%) 11 2 5 (8%) , 11, c (Street Cry, Iron 2013 36 27 (75%) 22 (61%) 4 0 2 (6%) EXPECTATIONS (667 foals, 41 BTW, 1.20 AEI), etc. Constitution): $465,270, Kentucky Downs Turf Sprint 2014 44 41 (93%) 30 (68%) 7 0 3 (7%) SUCCESSFUL APPEAL Has Sired: S, Bob Umphrey Turf Sprint S, etc., to 6, 2017. 2015 43 10 (23%) 6 (14%) 6 0 0 (0%) SWEET ON SMOKEY, 12, f (A++, Devil’s Bag, Mr. SOLID APPEAL, 09, f (A+, dam by Woodman, 2nd *Totals 712 556 (78%) 459 (64%) 156 17 53 (7%) Prospector): $465,037, What A Summer S twice, dam by Soviet Star): $583,721, champion turf By Racing Year Dashing Beauty S, etc., to 5, 2017. female in Can, Nassau S (G2T) twice, etc. CAPTAIN SERIOUS, 11, g (A, Mr. Greeley, Wavering BT GS J P’S GUSTO , 08, c (A++, Caller I. D., Encino): Monarch): $415,815, Mike Lee S, etc. Year Wins Wins Wins Earned $811,760, Del Mar Futurity (G1A), Best Pal S (G2A), 2004 31 12 2 $1,727,557 Hollywood Juvenile Championship S (G3A), etc., sire. Successful Appeal also has sired the winners 2005 39 4 1 $1,802,840 2006 90 8 3 $2,461,887 HER EMMYNENCY, 12, f (Joyeux Danseur, Beau’s Eagle): PUNCH APPEAL ($413,340), SAX APPEAL ($320,704), 2007 71 5 1 $2,287,286 $560,595, Queen Elizabeth II Challenge Cup S (G1T), WIND CHILL FACTOR ($309,959, to 5, 2017), SUCCESS 2008 107 6 1 $2,866,608 Surfer Girl S, 2nd Del Mar Debutante S (G1A), etc. SUCCESS ($303,694), QUIET SUCCESS ($292,414), 2009 142 7 1 $3,774,495 APPEALING ZOPHIE, 04, f (A, Hawkster, ): POLAR PLUNGE ($287,174), REAL APPEAL 2010 165 10 5 $4,298,230 $497,898, Spinaway S (G1), Silverbulletday S (G3), ($277,151), APPEALING CAT ($266,453), HONEY’S 2011 174 10 3 $4,926,289 2nd Boyd Gaming’s Delta Princess S, etc. SOX APPEAL ($251,170, to 4, 2017), RAPID RHYTHM 2012 157 6 1 $4,429,868 SUCCESFUL AFFAIR, 05, c (Storm Bird, Key to the MS VANENZZA 2013 148 6 3 $4,188,951 ($248,237, to 5, 2017), ($244,365), 2014 181 13 2 $5,426,858 Mint): $100,272, General San Martin (G1 in Arg), COAX LIBERTY ($234,700), SHE’S A JEWEL 2015 139 8 2 $4,148,206 Coronel Miguel F. Martinez (G2 in Arg), etc. ($207,585), AUNT ELLIPSIS ($204,386), SALAMERA 2016 130 8 0 $3,508,901 SUCCESSFUL DAN, 06, g (A++, Wolf Power, ($202,663), TRUSTY TEMPER ($188,374), 2017 134 11 2 $3,518,561 ): $998,154, S (G2), etc. BEANWAH’SMACHINE ($177,152), HOSTILE WITNESS *Totals 1,708 114 27 $49,366,537 LIMOUSINE LIBERAL, 12, g (A++, In Excess, His ($170,568), SARATOGA TANGO ($159,735), Southern Hemisphere Majesty): $934,687, Churchill Downs S Presented by APPEALING MAGGIE ($159,270, to 4, 2017), By Foal Crop (5 crops) Twinspires.com (G2), S (G3), etc., to 5, 2017. BARBAZILLA ($139,080), FREETOLEAVE ($138,192), DAWN AFTER DAWN, 04, f (Sword Dance, Black GARY D ($135,690), APPEALING SPRING ($123,136), Named Run- Win- 2yo 2yo BT Sulphur): $635,494, La Canada S (G2A), etc. OUR ELEANOR ($120,608), LADY BANKS ($107,600), Year Foals ners ners Wnrs BTW Winners GALAN DE CINE, 08, c (Gone West, Danzig): 2005-06 2 2 (100%) 2 (100%) 1 0 2 (100%) SUCCESSFULLY SWEET ($104,650), etc., and 2017 2008-09 3 3 (100%) 1 (33%) 0 0 1 (33%) $168,226, Otono (G2 in Arg), etc. 2-year-old winners Emma Kate, Pearl of Laredo, Miss 2010-11 4 2 (50%) 2 (50%) 0 0 0 (0%) CLOSING ARGUMENT, 02, c (A, Mr. Greeley, Groovy): Alva, Simuladora, Luckynsuccessful, Fortunate Cookie. 2011-12 4 3 (75%) 3 (75%) 1 0 0 (0%) $986,984, Holy Bull S (G3), NATC Futurity, 2nd 2013-14 12 9 (75%) 3 (25%) 1 0 0 (0%) (G1), etc., sire, 1.22 AEI. Sales Analysis* *Totals 25 19 (76%) 11 (44%) 3 0 3 (12%) AGELESS, 09, f (A++, , Full Pocket): Weanlings Yearlings Cover Sire # sold—Avg # sold—Avg # sold—Avg By Racing Year $737,130, Royal North S (G3T) twice, etc. ACCOUNTFORTHEGOLD, 02, g (A++, Private Account, 2017 — 7—$17,571 1—$7,000 BT GS 2016 1—$6,000 10—$17,720 6—$14,950 Year Wins Wins Wins Earned Key to the Mint): $538,467, Stuyvesant H (G3), etc. Lifetime 85—$39,318 365—$48,223 117—$67,785 2007-08 1 0 0 $9,516 TWICE THE APPEAL, 08, c (A++, Cormorant, Slady *to November 5, 2017 2008-09 3 1 1 $84,478 Castle): $476,060, Sunland Derby (G3), 2nd Fifth 2009-10 3 2 2 $43,725 Season S, 3rd Essex H, sire, 2.23 AEI. LIFETIME AS BROODMARE SIRE 2010-11 1 0 0 $7,666 SCOTUS, 08, c (A+, Seattle Slew, Alydar): $449,892, SUCCESSFUL APPEAL is the sire of 130 dams of 2011-12 8 1 1 $105,576 Matt Winn S (G3), 3rd Hanshin Cup S (G3A), etc. 366 foals, 228 rnrs(62%), 153 wnrs(42%), 48 2yo 2012-13 3 1 0 $33,613 SUCCESSFUL MISSION, 06, g (A++, Cryptoclearance, wnrs(13%), 1.22 AEI, 1.40 CI; 7 BTW here and abroad. 2013-14 14 0 0 $128,363 2014-15 11 0 0 $56,680 Avatar): $353,043, Miami Mile H (G3T), etc. FAMILY 2015-16 13 0 0 $67,052 LUNARPAL, 02, c (A++, Quiet American, Hold Your 2016-17 13 0 0 $94,894 Peace): $284,677, Bashford Manor S (G3), 1st dam 2017-18 2 0 0 $12,494 Kentucky Breeders’ Cup S (G3), etc., sire. SUCCESSFUL DANCER. 7 wins at 2 and 3, $96,817. *Totals 72 5 4 $644,057 GOLDSVILLE, 05, c (A++, Housebuster, Ruckus): Dam of 7 foals, including— 1.69 AEI; 1.48 CI; 6.67 AWD $276,940, Excelsior S (G3). TRUE TO TRADITION (by Rahy). 17 wins, 5 to 10, In 2017: 130 rnrs, 79 wnrs, 8 BTWnrs RICHWOMAN, 04, f (A++, Richman, Saratoga Six): $901,039, Nearctic S (G2T), etc. Lifetime On Turf: 157 wins, $6,477,685 $169,920, Debutante S (G3), Cinderella S, etc. SUCCESSFUL APPEAL (Subject stallion). Avg Earnings Per Starter: $85,941 GOLDEN SUCCESS, 05, c (Storm Cat, Mr. Prospector): ALEX’S PAL (Valid Expectations). 6 wins, 3 to 5, *to November 5, 2017 $46,481, Vicente L. Casares (G3 in Arg). $163,680. Sire, 1.19 AEI. check daily updates on stallionregister.com

SUCCESSFUL APPEAL Valid Appeal – Successful Dancer, by Fortunate Prospect IN 2017 SIRE OF MGSW LIMOUSINE LIBERAL-G2 ($934,687) Broodmare Sire of Belmont S.-G1 wnr TAPWRIT ($1,228,902)

2016ÕS 2ND LEADING SIRE IN AMERICA BY LIFETIME MEDIAN EARNINGS INDEX 2.59 Sire of 8 Black Type Stakes Winners in 2017, more than leading sires DISTORTED HUMOR, EXCHANGE RATE, HARD SPUN, HARLANÕS , MINESHAFT, PIONEEROF THE NILE, SKY MESA, SMART STRIKE, STREET BOSS, TWIRLING CANDY, UNION RAGS, etc. G1 Winner HER EMMYNENCY sold at KeeNov $1.5-Million to Katsumi Yoshida

Nominated to: 2018 FEE: $6,500 Live Foal Nominated to: (due when foal stands and nurses) KTDF Owner: A Syndicate WALMAC FARM, LLC Lexington, Kentucky 3395 Paris Pike, Lexington, KY 40511 (859) 299-0473 / Fax (859) 299-1259 / Web Site: www.walmac.com