Arxiv:2101.09203V1 [Gr-Qc] 22 Jan 2021 a Powerful Selection Principle Can Be Implemented by Mation Behavior (Sec.III)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Coordinate conditions and field equations for pure composite gravity Hans Christian Ottinger¨ ∗ ETH Z¨urich,Department of Materials, CH-8093 Z¨urich,Switzerland (Dated: January 25, 2021) Whenever an alternative theory of gravity is formulated in a background Minkowski space, the conditions characterizing admissible coordinate systems, in which the alternative theory of gravity may be applied, play an important role. We here propose Lorentz covariant coordinate condi- tions for the composite theory of pure gravity developed from the Yang-Mills theory based on the Lorentz group, thereby completing this previously proposed higher derivative theory of gravity. The physically relevant static isotropic solutions are determined by various methods, the high-precision predictions of general relativity are reproduced, and an exact black-hole solution with mildly singular behavior is found. I. INTRODUCTION As the composite theory of gravity [9], just like the underlying Yang-Mills theory, is formulated in a back- Only two years after the discovery of Yang-Mills theo- ground Minkowski space, the question arises how to char- ries [1], it has been recognized that that there is a strik- acterize the \good" coordinate systems in which the the- ing formal relationship between the Riemann curvature ory may be applied. This characterization should be tensor of general relativity and the field tensor of the Lorentz invariant, but not invariant under more general Yang-Mills theory based on the Lorentz group [2]. How- coordinate transformations, that is, it shares the formal ever, developing this particular Yang-Mills theory into a properties of coordinate conditions in general relativity. consistent and convincing theory of gravity is not at all However, the unique solutions obtained from Einstein's straightforward. The ideas of [2] have been found to be field equations only after specifying coordinate condi- \unnatural" by Yang (see footnote 5 of [3]), whose work tions are all physically equivalent, whereas the coordi- has later been criticized massively in Chap. 19 of [4]. nate conditions in composite gravity characterize phys- Nevertheless, the pioneering work [2] may be considered ically preferred systems. From a historical perspective, as the origin of what is now known as gauge gravitation it is remarkable that Einstein in 1914 still believed that theory [5,6]. the metric should be completely determined by the field An obvious problem with the Yang-Mills theory based equations and, therefore, a generally covariant theory of on the Lorentz group is that it has the large number of 48 gravity was not desirable (see [10] for a detailed discus- degrees of freedom, half of which are physically relevant. sion). The important task of characterizing the preferred One is faced with six four-vector fields satisfying second- systems in composite gravity is addressed in the present order evolution equations. For the pure field theories, paper. Once it is solved, we can provide a canonical the physical degrees of freedom are essentially given by Hamiltonian formulation of composite theory of gravity the two transverse components of the four-vector fields, beyond the weak-field approximation [11] and we obtain like in electrodynamics with its single vector potential. the static isotropic black-hole solution in a proper coor- In view of this enormous number of degrees of freedom dinate system. we need an almost equally large number of constraints to keep only a few degrees of freedom in a theory of grav- ity. In other words, we need a structured principle for The structure of the paper is as follows. As a prepara- selecting just a few ones among all the solutions of the tory step, we present the various variables and relations Yang-Mills theory based on the Lorentz group. between them (Sec.II) and discuss their gauge transfor- arXiv:2101.09203v1 [gr-qc] 22 Jan 2021 A powerful selection principle can be implemented by mation behavior (Sec. III). A cornerstone of the devel- means of the tool of composite theories [7,8]. The basic opment is the close relationship between the covariant idea is to write the gauge vector fields of the Yang-Mills derivatives associated (i) with a connection with torsion theory in terms of fewer, more fundamental variables and and (ii) with the Yang-Mills theory based on the Lorentz their derivatives. The admission of derivatives in this so- group. The core of the composite theory of gravity con- called composition rule implies that the composite theory sists of the field equations presented for several sets of involves higher than second derivatives. The power of the variables (Sec.IV) and the coordinate conditions charac- tool of composite theories results from the fact that, in terizing the admissible coordinate systems (Sec.V). As their Hamiltonian formulations [7,8], the structure of an application, we determine the static isotropic solutions the constraints providing the selection principle is highly and provide the results for the high-precision tests of transparent. gravity as well as an exact black-hole solution (Sec.VI). We finally offer a detailed summary of our results and draw a number of conclusions (Sec. VII). A number of detailed results and arguments are provided in six ap- ∗ [email protected]; www.polyphys.mat.ethz.ch pendices. 2 II. VARIOUS VARIABLES AND RELATIONS a 1 2 3 4 5 6 BETWEEN THEM (κ, λ) (0; 1) (0; 2) (0; 3) (2; 3) (3; 1) (1; 2) For the understanding of composite theories, it is im- TABLE I. Correspondence between the label a for the base vectors of the six-dimensional Lie algebra so(1; 3) and ordered portant to introduce different kinds of variables and to pairs (κ, λ) of space-time indices. clarify the relations between them. On the one hand, we have the metric tensors, tetrad variables, connections and curvature tensors familiar from general relativity and six vector fields associated with six pairs (κ, λ), or with other theories of gravity. On the other hand, we have the a label a taking the values from 1 to 6 according to Ta- gauge vectors and field tensors of the Yang-Mills theory bleI. The pairs (0 ; 1), (0; 2), (0; 3) correspond to Lorentz based on the Lorentz group. boosts in the respective directions (involving also time) An important step is the decomposition of metric ten- and the pairs (2; 3), (3; 1), (1; 2) correspond to rotations sors in terms of tetrad or vierbein variables, in the respective planes, as can be recognized by analyz- ing the gauge transformation behavior of the fields A g = η bκ bλ = bκ b ; (1) (κλ)ρ µν κλ µ ν µ κν resulting from the freedom of acting with Lorentz trans- κ κλ formations on b µ (see Sec. III for details). where ηκλ = η is the Minkowski metric with signa- ture (−; +; +; +). Throughout this paper, the Minkowski Following standard procedures for Yang-Mills theories metric is used for raising or lowering space-time indices. (see, e.g., Sect. 15.2 of [12], Chap. 15 of [13], or [14]), we For the inverses of the metric and the tetrad variables we can introduce a field tensor in terms of the vector fields, µν ¯µ introduce the componentsg ¯ and b κ. Note that they @Aaν @Aaµ bc are not obtained by raising or lowering indices of gµν and Faµν = µ − ν +gf ~ a AbµAcν ; (3) κ @x @x b µ, respectively. bc Equation (1) may be regarded as the characterization where fa are the structure constants of the Lorentz of metric tensors by symmetry and definiteness proper- group. A Lie algebra label, say a, can be raised or lowered ties. A general metric tensor may also be regarded as the by raising or lowering the indices in the pairs associated result of transforming the Minkowski metric. The decom- with a according to TableI. The structure constants can κ abc position of a metric gµν into tetrad variables b µ is not then be specified as follows: f is 1 (−1) if (a; b; c) is κ unique. If we multiply b µ from the left with any Lorentz an even (odd) permutation of (4; 5; 6), (1; 3; 5), (1; 6; 2) transformation, the invariance of the Minkowski metric or (2; 4; 3) and 0 otherwise (see also Eq. (A3)). under Lorentz transformations implies that we obtain an- The definition (2) suggests the following general pas- other valid decomposition. This observation reveals the sage from quantities labeled by a Lie algebra index to a origin of the underlying gauge symmetry of the composite quantity with space-time indices, theory of gravity. ~ κ λ The key role of the metric tensor in the present the- Xµν = b µb ν X(κλ): (4) ory is the characterization of the momentum-velocity re- lation, so that it can be interpreted as an indication of One then gets a deep relation between covariant deriva- tensorial properties of mass. While this is also the case in tives associated with metrics and connections on the one general relativity, Einstein's theory of gravity goes much hand and covariant derivatives associated with a Yang- further in the geometric interpretation of the metric by Mills theory based on the Lorentz group on the other assuming that it characterizes the underlying space-time. hand (for a proof of this fundamental relation based on In contrast, the present theory is developed in an under- the structure of the Lorentz group, see AppendixA), lying Minkowski space, which is the standard situation @X~µν for Yang-Mills theories. − Γσ X~ − Γσ X~ = @xρ ρµ σν ρν µσ As a next step, we introduce the vector fields A (κλ)ρ @X in terms of the tetrad variables (the pair (κ, λ) of space- κ λ (κλ) bc b µb ν ρ +g ~ f(κλ)AbρXc ; (5) time indices should be considered as a label associated @x with the Lorentz group, ρ as a four-vector index), ρ where the connection Γµν is given by κ λ 1 @gνρ @gµρ b µb ν A(κλ)ρ = − ρ 1 ρσ @gσν @gµσ @gµν ρσ 2 @xµ @xν Γ = g¯ +g ~ − =g ¯ Γ¯σµν : µν 2 @xµ @xν @xσ κ 1 κ @bκν @b µ (6) + b µ ρ − ρ bκν : (2) ρ 2~g @x @x Unlike the Christoffel symbols obtained forg ~ = 1, Γµν is not symmetric in µ and ν forg ~ 6= 1.